Edifier R1280TS vs Edifier MR4 - What to choose?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 21 янв 2025

Комментарии • 78

  • @KnowledgeSharingTech
    @KnowledgeSharingTech  Год назад +2

    Edifier R1280TS on Amazon: amzn.to/3Xf5Crh
    Edifier R1280TS on Edifier: edifier-usa.myshopify.com/products/edifier-r1280ts-brown?sca_ref=2950905.Bg8N4HhErK
    Edifier MR4 on Amazon: amzn.to/3ZnYdHP
    Edifier MR4 on Edifier: edifier-usa.myshopify.com/products/edifier-mr4-ref?sca_ref=2950905.Bg8N4HhErK
    Links are affiliate links. I gain a small percentage at no cost to you if you make a purchase. This will help my channel. Thank you.

  • @nmelnechuk
    @nmelnechuk 2 месяца назад +11

    Thanks for the video. I'm a filmmaker. I purchased both to test during a recent edit. The MR4 is cleaner and a superior monitor (with discrete monitor mode) for that purpose. I'm returning the R1280TS.

  • @CasualSome1
    @CasualSome1 10 месяцев назад +11

    My exploration and research into Edifier started with 1280T, and then it led into another level up, another level up, and I ended up getting S2000MKIII speakers.
    After about a year, Optical input died, and after contacting Edifier, I was shipped brand new set which works great on my gaming setup

    • @NilanjanMal-c7n
      @NilanjanMal-c7n 9 месяцев назад +1

      1280t, Mr4 or 1700bt which is good for music listening experience? Can you help me please.

    • @maivercamachomartinez3657
      @maivercamachomartinez3657 8 месяцев назад

      ​@@NilanjanMal-c7n what do you choose?

    • @matereo
      @matereo Месяц назад

      @@NilanjanMal-c7n mR4 probably sounds best, but id never go for them because they have no bluetooth

  • @andreabriganti5113
    @andreabriganti5113 Год назад +7

    The R1280Ts, paired with the T5 Sub from Edifier, sound good for the price. I use those with the Topping E30. I spent 330€ for everything and I'm really happy with this choose.

    • @andikardian9014
      @andikardian9014 Год назад +6

      Unfortunately for Us or other people from 3rd countries, 300 something $ or € is what most of us made in a month.
      Yes food price, gas price, or real estate price here is lower. but sometimes I feel jealous to 1st countries with extremely cheap electronics and vehicles so you can have better lifestyle.

    • @kloszard13
      @kloszard13 11 месяцев назад +3

      @@andikardian9014who gives a fuck? that's life

  • @CJDilag
    @CJDilag 8 месяцев назад +6

    Using the MR4 with a Topping E50 (balanced) and WiiM Mini. I'm a happy guy.

  • @UmbrellaSound
    @UmbrellaSound 6 месяцев назад +2

    Went for Edifier MR4 since my soundcard has got TSR outputs for monitors. Very decent for the price. Had a chance to compare them with Fluid Audio F4, Fluid are flatter and has got better separation but Edifier is pretty close, especially if placed correctly.

  • @taigalaar
    @taigalaar Год назад +3

    Thank you for great comparison!

    • @marek23456
      @marek23456 5 месяцев назад

      @@taigalaar tak identycznie

  • @mohamadkasem6509
    @mohamadkasem6509 Год назад +2

    Thank you, this helped a lot

  • @walterg74
    @walterg74 11 месяцев назад +9

    Did we listen to the same sounds..? Completely opposite opinion...

  • @rayzarlbeng8338
    @rayzarlbeng8338 Год назад +3

    I have a rt1700 model n its blown a week ago.. do u suggest this mr4 or 1280

    • @KnowledgeSharingTech
      @KnowledgeSharingTech  Год назад +2

      1280

    • @palomania2414
      @palomania2414 Год назад +1

      MR4

    • @rayzarlbeng8338
      @rayzarlbeng8338 Год назад +3

      I have buy the mr4 now.. and i know how the 1280 sound.. the mr4 clarity is real good for its price but its lack of bass.. if u r more to bass.. go for the 1280..

  • @JonathanFerrer-g2g
    @JonathanFerrer-g2g Год назад +1

    Into your set up sound test i think the speaker will not sound as good to produce its full potential use other source

  • @theodin1913
    @theodin1913 Год назад +5

    👍for the comparison demonstration of the speakers. MP4 sound more voluminous and cleaner, very close to the original, just what you need for your computer. I did not like the sound of the R1280TS at all, they sound deaf and muddy, there is no channel separation, as if the speakers were bolted to the trash can. The fact that they have a bit more bass doesn't make them any better, they are bass heavy, so they have a dull and muddy sound.🪣🔉🎶

  • @mohdzulhilmimohdzin
    @mohdzulhilmimohdzin 4 месяца назад

    I wondering whats the difference in choosing between:
    A) RCA to 3.5mm
    B) 3.5 mm To 3.5 mm AUX front input, if i want to connect to my device such as laptop/phone/tab
    Is any obvious difference or just personal preference? I recently bought mR4 for my laptop desk mainly to connect with my instrument using audio interface 🙏 Please someone give advice. Thansk

    • @KnowledgeSharingTech
      @KnowledgeSharingTech  4 месяца назад +1

      No difference in Sound quality

    • @mohdzulhilmimohdzin
      @mohdzulhilmimohdzin 4 месяца назад

      @@KnowledgeSharingTech Ok thank you for the answer.. now I am satisfied, This matter confuses me who is an starter😃

  • @Marian_Rusnak
    @Marian_Rusnak Год назад +2

    Do I even need external speakers ?
    I currently use my notebook's speakers. Plus can use my wired Koss The Plug earphones if I need higher quality (music, some movies).
    The notebook speakers are fine for speech (youtube, videoconferencing, ...).
    And they take zero taking care of.
    Should I buy EDIFIER R1280DB, to be put onto my desk ? How will they compare with Koss The Plug earphones sound quality? Will I be happy?

    • @Wgames1248
      @Wgames1248 17 дней назад

      U will want mr4 speakers, they r better, they will sound way better than ur koss headphones

  • @rootcanal7188
    @rootcanal7188 2 года назад +1

    Thanks for the video. If I may ask an off-topic question: could you do a tutorial on improving Wifi signal strength on Linux? For some reason, I watch the signal go from strong, to weak, to strong again, to disconnecting entirely, then reconnecting right away....very frustrating. I have noticed this issue on Parrot OS, Mint, Lubuntu, etc. Thank you again.

    • @KnowledgeSharingTech
      @KnowledgeSharingTech  2 года назад +2

      Is this only happening on Linux? Try to change the band from 5 to 2.4 or vis-versa

  • @palomania2414
    @palomania2414 Год назад +6

    el 1280 suena como si estuviera metido dentro de una lata

  • @ivegyattocomment
    @ivegyattocomment Год назад +2

    thank you for the comparison! is the R1280TS and the R1280DB are actually the same?

    • @KnowledgeSharingTech
      @KnowledgeSharingTech  Год назад +3

      Sound wise, yes, they are the same.

    • @Goodman12363
      @Goodman12363 Год назад +1

      DB has no sub out

    • @turczynskii4741
      @turczynskii4741 Год назад +1

      @@Goodman12363 but DBS has, so the best option is R1280DBS

    • @beverpix
      @beverpix Месяц назад

      The 1280T, Ts, DB and DBs all have a slightly different sound, though the differences are tiny. The DB is imho the best 1280.

  • @memos5205
    @memos5205 Год назад +3

    I wanna got me some 1280DBS !!!
    I need them for Music (Listing) and PC Games...
    I Heard a lot about "Bringing the trebble to 100% will improve the sound quality alot" is that true ?
    And Thank you soooo much for this Compare 🥰
    btw sorry for my English, its not the best i know... :D

    • @KnowledgeSharingTech
      @KnowledgeSharingTech  Год назад +2

      For the treble, it's a matter of taste, I adjust mine at +3 only

    • @memos5205
      @memos5205 Год назад

      @@KnowledgeSharingTech wich one would you recommend for mostly listing to music and watching Videos ?
      R1280DBS or MR4 ?
      Btw i can get the R1280dbs for the same price (100€) as the MR4.
      I have a small (like 15m²) room to cover, wich one would you prefer ?

    • @KnowledgeSharingTech
      @KnowledgeSharingTech  Год назад +2

      @@memos5205 R1280DBS

    • @chaij5621
      @chaij5621 Год назад +2

      @@KnowledgeSharingTech Which one is better ? between R1280DBS + T5 or MR44 + T5

    • @palomania2414
      @palomania2414 Год назад

      @@chaij5621 MR4 + T5

  • @ciuyr2510
    @ciuyr2510 Год назад

    Hello. Thank you for demo. I guess it wont be an issue if i RcA them to a DAC, and not straight to the PC?

  • @y.z.6493
    @y.z.6493 10 месяцев назад +4

    Speakers produce different sound. I like MR4.

  • @Yoshi92
    @Yoshi92 Год назад

    Wow that comparison is exactly what I searched for, unbelievable lol. 1 question tho 😅
    I'm looking into these two options to replace my Logitech Z-2300 2.1. Is it possible to use the Subwoofer of the Z-2300 with the R1280T or MR4? (I read somewhere that it would work safely if I split the audio signal with a Y-adapter connected to my PC or sth like that?)

    • @jstevo1349
      @jstevo1349 Год назад +2

      the r1280t has a sub out so you can go from speaker to sub. the mr4 doesnt so you will need a splitter from the source that goes to both

    • @Yoshi92
      @Yoshi92 Год назад +1

      @@jstevo1349 thanks! :)

    • @Wgames1248
      @Wgames1248 17 дней назад

      @@Yoshi92the mr4 is better sounding

  • @ThePandaGuitar
    @ThePandaGuitar 8 месяцев назад +9

    R1280 are muddy and bass sounds overdone I prefer MR4

    • @mhnoni
      @mhnoni 2 месяца назад

      Based on youtube demo? unless you hear them with your own ears or look at the speaker's freq graph, don't judge a speaker, especially not from youtube.

    • @Mario_Sky_521
      @Mario_Sky_521 8 дней назад +1

      @@mhnoni so true. Nothing like hearing them in person.

    • @mhnoni
      @mhnoni 8 дней назад

      @@Mario_Sky_521 btw, I bought a pair of R1280 just for testing, they are good for their price. they are clean for sure, one of the best I've heard for the price. no noise or any coloring of the sound, but don't expect to beat > $300 speakers.
      The only downside is the bass, but you aren't going to get a good speaker with a bass < 5" speaker and < $300. even if you get one, it will be hard to beat these ones when it comes to vocal frequency quality.
      I have an old pair of Wharfedale 9.1 (original not the newly released one which isn't good), these original are really good for me.
      I might use these R1280 as my rear speakers.
      In another words, I recommend them.

  • @stephinkoshyskj
    @stephinkoshyskj Месяц назад

    can i connect T5 sub with MR4??

  • @theouts1der
    @theouts1der 11 месяцев назад +3

    04:41 05:01

  • @jarreauetcobanez3447
    @jarreauetcobanez3447 Год назад +1

    hi, i have a question. what if adding t5 subwoofer to mr4, will it match the sound quality?

  • @GabrielPurziani
    @GabrielPurziani Год назад +1

    👏👏👏😎

  • @cleangoblin2021
    @cleangoblin2021 8 месяцев назад

    sold my Google Nest Audio.
    While the smart speaker was cool for a few months, it's not enough for a nerd.
    Plus my main goal here is for my guitar

    • @Wgames1248
      @Wgames1248 17 дней назад

      Sorry for late but the mr4 is better sounding especially for instruments

  • @THeCrEw-vg6le
    @THeCrEw-vg6le Год назад

    Please review Edifier Rt1700BT 🙏

  • @musicselecta5554
    @musicselecta5554 Год назад

    1280 without grills sound is much better!

  • @jeffreygleaves2931
    @jeffreygleaves2931 11 месяцев назад

    Yes, but what do they sound like when you play music through them?....lol

  • @matereo
    @matereo 7 месяцев назад

    the r1280ts would have sounded better with the grilles off

    • @KnowledgeSharingTech
      @KnowledgeSharingTech  7 месяцев назад +1

      I tried both with and without covers and the sound is the same.

    • @miscthings2559
      @miscthings2559 6 месяцев назад

      @@KnowledgeSharingTech nevermind, I thought it was the R1280T

    • @beverpix
      @beverpix Месяц назад +1

      The sound is NOT the same, I think your ears are getting tired

  • @illegalquantity
    @illegalquantity Год назад

    Now we know that R1280TS is worse than MR4

  • @badlilstang
    @badlilstang Год назад +1

    What's the source just your phone plugged into the speaker? that is a horrible source.. why aren't people testing with a proper DAC?

    • @Integroabysal
      @Integroabysal Год назад +17

      Because most of the people that buy speakers around 100-120$ don't use a 300$ DAC to power them up ? This is kind of stupid to do such tests , people buy budget speakers for a reason I'm laughing so hard from tests of 50-120$ speakers that are tested with DAC's that are at least 3times more expensive than the speakers itself , If I have a 120$ budget for speakers I'm sure I don't have a 300$ lying around for a good quality DAC to power them up , ill use them to connect to PC or mobile.

    • @waterfelon33
      @waterfelon33 Год назад +1

      @@Integroabysal Well he could've at least tested it with some budget audio interface such as Steinberg UR22 or Behringer UM2 which are about 50 euros, so it's not audiophile DAC but still better than phone or on-board PC audio sources just for a more complete comparison.

    • @jibrilxisreal8037
      @jibrilxisreal8037 10 месяцев назад

      @@waterfelon33 do you feel like a budget day will be worth it for a set of these or should I just invest in better speakers?

    • @UmbrellaSound
      @UmbrellaSound 6 месяцев назад

      ​​@@jibrilxisreal8037depends on your needs. If you just want to enjoy music MR4 are great for the buck. If you want studio monitors I'd recommend saving up and buying some entry level monitors from brand like Mackie. MR4 aren't really flat even in "monitor mode".

  • @v.l.4487
    @v.l.4487 4 месяца назад +3

    R1280TS is better by far

  • @markanthonypraico3099
    @markanthonypraico3099 Месяц назад

    sub out =