Diversity in World War 2
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 май 2024
- Thanks for watching!
=Support me via=
► Patreon: / danarrows
► TipJar: ko-fi.com/threearrows
► Merch: www.teepublic.com/stores/dan-...
=Other Stuff=
► Twitter: / dan_arrows
► Instagram: / dan.arrows
► Twitch: / dan_arrows
Additional info:
I'm aware that there are several articles critiquing Dunkirk more heavily for its cast and other stuff but non of them are featured in Brooks' video. Although I might disagree with some of those articles, what they have to say is still 100 times more interesting than anything NoDumbass has to say.
=SOURCES=
www.breitbart.com/big-hollywoo...
www.pambazuka.org/governance/...
www.spectator.co.uk/2015/07/b...
history.army.mil/documents/WW...
www.cwgc.org/foreverindia/cont...
www.usatoday.com/story/life/m...
www.slate.com/blogs/browbeat/2...
www.pri.org/stories/2017-08-0...
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manstei...
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/East_Af...)
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mediter...
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_...
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operati...
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Auxilia...
www.nytimes.com/2017/08/02/op...
news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/798...
www.open.ac.uk/researchproject...
Brooks: WW2 was a white man’s war
The entire pacific theater: Am I a joke to you?
Entirety of oceania, most of asia, all of africa: *Are we a fucking joke to you*
Weston Meyer, what point are you trying to make?
@Weston Meyer Russia wasn't at war with Germany, the ussr was. The ussr covered a massive area, (even larger than modern Russia) most of it in Asia, where there are now numerous countries. As such the ethnic make up of the ussr was actually quite diverse, and many "Russian" soldiers in ww2 would have been Asian in ethnicity.
@Weston Meyer " There were a lot more white people in those areas than you think."
Err.... You mean that in a theater where the main fighters were Japan, China and the USA, there were a lot of white people? Because, apart the part black US soldiers, I do not see ^^
"And the 22 million Russians killed alone dwarfs the entire war’s causalities from the rest of the world, much less the non-European battle fronts. "
Well, it does not dwarfs the 10 to 20 millions dead chineses ^^
@Weston Meyer "There were a crapload of white military guys in Asia."
Well, a crapload but a lot less than asian soldiers as they are, you know, in Asia XD
In 1945, Japan have 7 millions soldiers. China had engaged around 5 millions soldiers during the war. The US army had 11 millions soldiers, but most of them are in Europe in the "Germany First" plan.
As for the 90% white (I checked the statistics, it's not 90%+, it"s 89.8% in 1940), yes it's totally true. But I said "partially black", not "entirely black" ^^
Partially because a part of the US army was black. Yes it maybe was only 5 or 10%, as there was 11 million US soldiers, 5% mean more than 500 000 black soldiers, it's not nothing ^^
Oh god, people are actually starting to copy Sargon’s formula. They’re skimming an article and twisting words around to make them look bad because reading comprehension is hard.
@Roy McBatty True, we all know Sargon can't read, and that he will instantly evaporate if he watches more than 5 minutes of video.
He doesn't have time for that, he is busy looking for more ways to make himself look like a deranged fool xD
thinking Sargon pioneered this shit, lol
Every. Single. Time. Why is is that these reactionaries can never make anything with legitimate origins? It's always so fake - and people fall for it! Urgh!
Dear Bigots,
👋🏾 Hi!
Friendly, neighborhood black girl here to say that my grandfather fought in WWII, participated in the D-Day operation and lived in Paris for several years afterwards.
We were definitely there.
We have always been there.
With you.
Every time.
Yes. Even that time.
Stop pretending we just “appeared” during the Civil Rights Movement.
K. Bye.
Honestly, I would argue the rights afforded to many African Anerican soldiers during the war and the subsequent rollback of said rights postwar was a major cause of the civil rights movement. Of all the wars, ww2 was the MOST multicultural, it’s such a bad example for these guys to use. Really shows how lazy they are.
Muad Dib how am I race baiting? I am black. My grandfather fought in WWII. These are facts about my life 🤔🙄
1. Noone cares that u black
2. DDay is 1944 with the Americans, Dunkirk is 1940 without the Americans, the evacuated british troops were almost exclusively white, some french were black,
Stop appropriating my cultural history black girl xd
Stannis the Mannis did you watch the video where he specifically mentions Indian troops?
@@Kaanfight did you notice that i said almost exclusively
Say what you will, but I would love to watch Ice T and Snoop Dogg parachute into the middle of a battle to 'administer' weed to the troops.
Not Biased Historian I think any sane person would immediately watch that movie
That would be so fucking awesome lol. I'd pay to see that on opening night
Has to be a comedy though
That would be awsome
"It's da motherfuckn' D-O-DOUBLE G"
Ok, one nitpick:
British officers were legendary for their refusal to wear helmets or duck for cover. They considered it more valorous and inspiring to the men if they stood upright in caps.
Yes, really...
2manynegativewaves yeah, but they didnt even cgi fake troops in the background
Interesting didnt know that
Davesknd That's right! I saw a lindybeige video on that ;)
"There's no use in ducking, the bullets have already passed you."
Davesknd
Early in the war this was common practice amongst the German troops as well. Later in the war, the casualty rates amongst officers were so dire that the practice was formally banned.
(Eventually, Germany widely adopted modern methods of camouflage to try to reduce the casualty rate. The Waffen SS were the first adopters as they had horrific combat losses, starting in Poland where they got severely hammered due to organisational and training shortcomings.)
That moment when your 2 grand fathers and 2 great grand fathers fought in WWI and WWII. All 4 of them Algerian.
Same. Except we're Lakota.
My grandfather was a paratrooper, and participated in D-Day
My great grandfather, was also a part of the later days of WWII as a teenager, then the II as a Marine
Why did they fight for the allies? In WW1 germany did nithing to you not even really in WW2. On the other side they occupied your nation for a really long time. Also some africa divisions commited war crimes in germany. Actually it was really stupid to fight against germany because algeria had nothing to do with germany and his war.
@Easter Worshipper still this doesnt explain why his family fought us. Germany had nothing to do with algeria or prealgeria. His family members fought for nothing. They probably even got killed later from france in the war between algeria and france... his family just fought the enemys of his enemey to help his enemy. What a stupid nation... dyed for nothing.
@Easter Worshipper still it doesnt. Why should they fight us and not france? We occupied them only second. We werent the ones who let them suffer for about 100 years... also germany only did the north africa war because of italy. They started the war there and were to stupid wo fight there...
@Easter Worshipper Why the fuck are you even on this channel you little fascist troll.
I swear ppl will make fun of liberals for being snowflakes and then immediately get triggered over the smallest things.
@@JohnSmith-mc2zz … how?🤨
@@JohnSmith-mc2zz Idk how you did it but you managed to completely miss the point
I'm french and I'm always amazed that people from the US seem to think brown people and women weren't invented in Europe before 1950. :p
Leto Anor people of other colour and women *exists*
Much of the americans who believed in the far right: "reeeeeeeee"
"By the time of the XVI century 10% of lisbon's population was black." It makes sense as that was near Africa and a trade port, but where did you find this info? Genuinely curious.
@@Rogerio Lopes
Yeah, I would very much like to see the source for that.
I travelled on the Iberian, I know Lisboa - It might have 10-15% people of african heritage NOW.
As darkwing says - it could geographically be possible. But sounds made-up.
We Americans are full of small minded idiots.
@@nilesbutler8638 Darkwing never said it sounds made up.
"World War 2 is not a White Man's war, it is a World War..."
Nailed it!
Michael Oquendo That took place in Europe it's called a World war because the only countries worth a dam in the world were fighting
Isaiah D
It also took place in the Pacific Theater where Japan sought to dominate most, if not, all of Asia. While only the powerful nations around the World were at War, it is clear that white men weren't the only ones fighting that war.
Michael Oquendo Japan and China kinda had there own thing going on China is barely even mentioned in the west and Japan is because they were fighting the U.S. a majority white country especially then. Saying the world wars were not a White or western war is like saying grass isn't green because of the few dead yellow patches in the field.
Isaiah D
Yeah, it was the Second Sino-Japanese War that began in 1937 but it escalated into World War II when the U.S. finally supported China who has been fighting Japan through guerilla warfare all the way till 1945 when World War II ended (so World War II was pretty much China's war seeing as how they depended on the victory of the Allied Forces -- they were part of the Allies). Truthfully, no one is really saying World War II is not a White Man's war, so much as it isn't *only* their war. And the U.S. did have minorities serving in the U.S. Armed Forces during the war ranging from Japanese-Americans, Indian-Americans, African-Americans, and even Latinos (particulalrly Puerto Ricans and Mexicans), etc.
Isaiah D what about the Pacific, Africa, China, and there was even an allied invasion of Iran. Not because of then being Nazis or anything, but it still happened.
If there were more women and POC in the movie No BS would’ve complained about forced diversity to pander to the SJWs.
TheLaxLex Diversity just means running out the last white person.
Legitimately can't tell if you're being sarcastic or not . . .
Diversity means white being minority in their own country. Visit the sjw cestpitt sweden for an example
Whites are still a majority in sweden fam
Also thats racist
I've got a propaganda poster from the second world war on my wall, and it's a British one. The caption reads "Together". It has white British soldiers, Canadian RCAF troops, Indian troops, and African troops.
Not to mention the French, who apparently saw it as a point of pride that they had colonial troops in their armed forces, hosting many parades featuring them.
It was the US that was against integrated forces, and even forbade the French from allowing any colonial troops into 2nd Armoured Division, as the US didn't want any coloured folks in their propaganda photos/were just racist in general.
Three Arrows more or less mentions this, but I figured I'd drop my two cents.
That's interesting
Nik Nelson
Yep, the Muricans didn’t want “Any colonials to capture Paris”… even though De Gaule really wanted to have a mixed army because then “the whole of the French took back their capital”
He got rebuffed though… It’s extremely sad and crazy… But really, everyone silently laughs at all the dumb things the US have done in history…
@@Swat_Dennis well, the Americans began reforming their military during the war, especially the latter years, where they start integrating African-Americans into the US Army.
Nik Nelson Wtf I love France now.
6:27 shows the "together" poster you're referring to.
Actually, the "SJW whining" from the USA Today review sounds more like a mild whining ABOUT SJWs.
LarsCT interesting
I thought so too.
I thought the same thing... "/some/ people might not like it *wink wink*"
Agree.
hmm yes the floor here is made of floor.
It's funny how even a movie being popular and critically well-received _without_ featuring (what Brooks imagines leftists would consider) "politically correct" casting...is an occasion to complain about how everything is so damn politically correct these days.
Manufactured outrage. Shaun made a video on it. Can't find anything to complain about, then just make something up. It's amazing how easy the anti-sjw crowd is
Heads Full of Eyeballs -- Right? The outrage is just mindbending. Like, even *not* acting like (Brooks's perception of) SJWs means the SJWs are taking over?
Actually, the Indians (as a collective) probably had one of the most interesting stories of WWII. And after provodibg the biggest volunteer army Churchill basically called them subhuman.
I’m not exactly sure it was a surprise when they discovered that in fact the British Empire lied seeing their previous colonial record
Nothing like volunteering to fight as a matter of honor and being devalued to get an independence movement going
Another reason to hate the British.
@@andymancan_ yes, let’s hate an entire country and its people for something they did 75 years ago. I wonder if people will be hating America 75 years from now
@@jamaphy8621 yes, i guarentee they will, because i guarentee the middle east will still be struggling economically from the war on terror, not to mention the other nations the US will no doubt invade in order to flex it's military dick and attempt to maintain geopolitical influence.
Also when ppl say "indian" in that era it includes what's now Pakistani and Bangladeshi....
and Indians and Nepalis.
Sikhs, Rajputs, Gurkhas, Muslims... all fought in the great war.
Hououin Kyoma you forgot to say ‘with distinction’
Looking through this guys channel.
Holy hell, how can he complain about people being sensitive when he literally finds anything to be offended about.
Alt-right anti-sjw's are the biggest and thinnest skinned snowflakes out there.
@@KingBobXVI Constantly triggered, 24 fking seven about *everything,* crying and moaning for a safe space where they won't be judged for their objectively disgusting views, hobbies, and habits that society is repulsed by. They think getting fired for telling hard-core racist jokes is censorship. It's not. It's called living in civil f***ing society.
I'm so tired of the bullshit of the far right.
Sanaralerx He’s trying to save western civilization bro. You gotsta be thorough in today’s crazy times...
Yes especially that tweet from Burger King after the milkshake incident.
Because lunatics like this have little understanding of irony or hypocrisy.
There were some amazing feats by French black colonial troops called the Tirailleurs Sénégalais during WW1. Various observers of these troops mentioned their extraordinarily high morale for the conditions they were in.
There was also the 369th Infantry Regiment of the US army during WW1 more commonly known as the Harlem Hellfighters. Young and old black men from the United States fought with the French army who would accept black troops because of their manpower shortages. Here's a quote on one of their accomplishments.
On 25 September 1918 the Fourth French Army went on the offensive in conjunction with the American drive in the Meuse-Argonne. The 369th turned in a good account in heavy fighting, though they sustained severe losses. The unit captured the important village of Séchault. At one point the 369th advanced faster than French troops on their right and left flanks, and risked being cut off. By the time the regiment pulled back for reorganization, it had advanced 14 kilometres (8.7 mi) through severe German resistance.
I'd say that's some pretty significant accomplishment for a "inferior" people as many beloved athletes the time. Men are men and women are women no matter their skin tone. Just because their different doesn't mean that they are less than others.
I went into WW1 specifically because of my interest in it but i'm sure with some research anyone could find more cases of black armies being equal to or superior to others.
Okay.What about the 332nd Fighter Squadron -aka-The Tuskeegee Airmen.
They were the subject of the 2012 movie "Red Tails".
The 92nd I.D.fought very bravely in France and Italy.
Finally Pearl Harbot hero Doris Miller.
Although untrained In how to an AAA Gun he still managed to shoot down several Japanese planes.
Cuba Gooding,Jr.played hi. In the 2001 movie "Pearl Harbor".
Also the Navy's latest carrier is named the U.S.S.Doris Miller.
Shaquille O'Neal can't act?
Somehow has never seen the masterpiece theater classic Kazam.
There's also Steel.
I'm sorry, you must be thinking of the classic 90's film, Shazam; starring Sinbad.
We would all be doing ourselves a disservice by not mentioning blue chips.
The range...
McDeus I wept when he didn’t take home that oscar... WTF is happening to The West??
Oh boy yeah
So Nobullshit is fullofshit? Who knew?
NoBullshit gets triggered whenever he sees a woman or brown person in a movie lok
yea sick I liked him
At first but he went on a racist tangent
Facts XD
Nah, it's clear he thinks women are ok as long as they're in bikinis.
I like calling him Mr. Bullshit
He is easily offended. Period. Snowflake par excellence.
> nothing would ruin my immersion more than a woman or a black guy in WWII
> both fiction and nonfiction should be free to cast whatever race or gender
Neanis Why do I feel like this is 30% genuine question and 70% vain desire to state your superiority to ancaps?
Neanis Good job I'm not one anymore.
Neania Generally when you search out people to feel superior towards you're lacking something in real life. No matter how many people you find and abuse who you feel are less than you, it will not improve your personal life. You'll just push more and more people away from you until you're alone.
Sneaky Turtle lmao, chill, my dude.
@Neanis *Radical Centrism Intensifies*
As a certain skull said, manufactured outrage
Salokin I love that skull
Robert Walpole
I didn't get the reference.
skull is love skull is life
Salokin hail to the professor
Salokin Sorry I meant Comrade professor
A very annoying, minor point, I didn't like about Dunkirk was it made it seem bloodless. Bodies dying in romantic poses and stuff like that.
That's because of the PG13 rating so that the film could reach a wider audience and make more money.
Mr. Bungle is a pretty good band
A fair point, but drowning while on a ship is just as horrifying
@@MrPtrlix to be fair the whole point of the movie was to create tension around the whole evacuation thing which it did amazingly well. I can understand the lack of excessive blood or limbs being torn apart as a tactic to be more marketable but it doesn't take anything away from the movie's central plot. We've all seen people being blown apart in the multitude of war films that have come before anyways. Besides, what's wrong with wanting to make money from a movie you've put effort into if it just means sacrificing a little bit of gore?
It’s interesting how NB wanting of accuracy only extends to the casting of white actors
Even in my shitty highschool world history classes that focused way too much on ww2 battles rather than on other history taught us that yes, it wasn't just white men who fought on the battlefield, so how bad was his school that he didn't even learn THAT?
He likely didn't pay attention cuz the lessons were "SJW propaganda" or something
No BS always finds a way to be exceptionally dim in a sea of dim bulbs.
It's like he literally just smokes weed and gets information from 4chan
I don't say this lightly, but truly, No BS is one of the dumbest people on the platform.
His debates with Destiny are strangely fascinating, because he practically blacks out the whole bingo card of ego defenses, but because he's such a dim bulb, it's like watching a fumble in slow-mo.
Smarter people regularly employ the same defenses, distractions, and deflections, but they do so more skillfully, so it's easy to miss it if you blink.
I like it when he reads way to deep into south park episodes
Awayforthewin I saw one where he actually thought they were positive about Trump, also in the newest finale, they introduced the “White Family”, and he states how it’s great there’s finally a voice for the whites. I’m like “dude, nearly the entire character list is white people!” Lol
Look no BS may not be the brightest but the presumption that only racist white people have a problem isn't correct
A movie about the British Indian army in WWII would be pretty cool.
I would give everything I have to see a Band of Brothers type show about the British Indian Army
If it was the British Indian Army, it would be closer to The Pacific, since they mainly were fighting the japanese in Burma.
Meirstein I think there were Indian and Gurkha troops in North Africa too
There were, but in much smaller numbers. Burma and Indochina were the main places the Indians fought.
It would be! There are not enough British and commonwealth films.
Sorry, but the random shift in backdrop is so hilariously transparent.
"Hello, please stare at these boobs while you get angry about fictional SJWs. Welcome to your two minute hate"
(I hate myself for using two minutes hate like that. But its closer to being that than not being that)
I'm glad you pointed out how he said "if I look hard enough..." because that's honestly a large part of the fake outrage that anti-sjws sell. A lot of their material revolves around finding minor complaints and then overexaggerating them, blowing them out of proportion and getting outraged. Their fanbases eat this stuff up like candy because it's not really intellectual - it's just making fun of people. This happened with the new DOOM trailer, where over a dozen different channels harped on the exact same few minor complaints.
They're not interested in truth. That much is evident by the fact that they always send their kids over to response videos - like this one - to click the dislike button and move on. Childish, and they say that SJWs are overly sensitive.
I remember this happening way back with _Super Smash Bros. 4_ too (well, it's happening _all the fucking time,_ I've just since been tuning it out).
An image from the game was posted showing the character Zero Suit Samus' new costume, which basically amounted to booty-shorts and a sports bra. The anti-SJW crowd went bonkers - thousands of comments complaining about "the inevitable backlash" from "SJWs", people saying why "it's totally ok, guys" and how they "aren't misogynists for liking it" and if they _are_ then by golly so be it, blog posts and articles preemptively written to _defend_ the costume, pointing out "no no, it's totally practical wear for a fighting game" and "it has precedence! See, it's from this old game! It's not misogynistic!"
Literally no one ever actually complained about the outfit, outside of some saying the character's boots from the previous game had a better design.
They manufacture straw-SJWs to attack to keep their outrage mill going, and they have to invent them because there isn't enough of an _actual_ opposition for them to fight. Then when the rhetoric is established, they started latching it to every bit of media they conceivably could - a director cast a woman? SJWs. A game has a female character? SJWs. Girls at gaming or comic conventions? _PURE SJW INVASION!_
It's absurd.
"The anti-SJW crowd went bonkers - thousands of comments complaining about "the inevitable backlash" from "SJWs", people saying why "it's totally ok, guys" and how they "aren't misogynists for liking it" and if they are then by golly so be it, blog posts and articles preemptively written to defend the costume, pointing out "no no, it's totally practical wear for a fighting game" and "it has precedence! See, it's from this old game! It's not misogynistic!""
The irony of that one is that in SSB4 the character Shulk has a costume where he's literally just in shoes and a pair of trunks. (It's a reference to Xenoblade Chronicles where Dunban gets all sorts of buffs if he's fighting in just his trunks).
NBS was the guy who complained about Last Jedi being "too overly-diversed". The guy should be disqualified from being taken seriously.
motherly father I know right right? Rogue One has a more “overly-diversed” cast than The Last Jedi in its main characters; and that movie was great!
To the Thread: SJW is a straw man identity invented by people who politically lean towards the center or the right to dismiss legitimate critiques of power. For those who use it as a derogatory term, can you actually identify an Ideology behind “SJW-ism” or what kind of people believe in it (something concrete please. not just insults or vague descriptions of behaviors)
people who lean left politically aren’t perfect, and there certainly is an issue of activists with leftist ideology fetishizing oppression and struggle for social capital in leftist social circles (especially in the US).
but damn, you all can at least try to address the points they’re making, instead of making up caricatures to avoid actually engaging critique.
SJW’s believe in cultural Marxism - the belief that there is an oppressor and oppressed classes of people in society. Men oppress women, whites oppress ethnic minorities, straights oppress LGBTQ+ etc. Intersectionality is the belief that these paradigms can overlap, so by this thinking straight white men oppress white women, all ethnic minorities and LGBTQ+ groups. Anti-SJW’s oppose this position.
@@jasankristo2383 well, they're not entirely wrong. Gays were and are still persecuted for their sexual orientation. Women used to be treated like property. All of the great colonial powers were white who enslaves other countries and people.
Not that I agreed with them, but they do have a just cause for grievances.
Exactly! im tired of people thinking SJWs are an actual thing. "Social Justice Warrior" what's that even suppose to mean? How is that even such a bad thing if it was an actual thing?
to add on, since I have a lot to say on this. there is no solid definition of "SJW" some conservative shit would be defining it by collage students having a liberal opinion, others defining it by someone getting too offended, or someone believing in "cultural Marxism". No one agrees on a definition of SJW.
Mikachi Chan look, the vast majority of people including myself don't have a problem with leftists, as long as your not infringing on my life then i don't care what people believe. What pisses me and a lot of other people off is when we are told what to think and what is deemed acceptable. An example if comedy. Political correctness which is heavily promoted by leftists has nearly strangled it to death. Most comedy is either pushing an agenda or political nowadays, both of which i hate no matter which side it is.
Never has a channel so flagrantly misrepresented itself by its title.
Nope.
The three arrows were a communist subculture that fought against the Nazis and had slightly more success than everyone else you uneducated ancaps
Supreme Snek no, fascism is much, much worse than communism. Sorry.
Supreme Snek communism is a theory or system of social organization in which all property is owned by the community and each person contributes and receives according to their ability and needs.
Fascism is a form of far-right, authoritarian ultranationalism characterized by dictatorial power, forcible suppression of opposition, and strong regimentation of society and of the economy.
Supreme Snek stop making excuses for fascism... just stop.
Brooks dressed his avatar in nazi uniform. (make sense)
Muhammed Nuri SEVGİLİ it reminds me of a quote from oversimplified “if you’re trying to not look like the bad guy than good job”
Nazi? Do you see a swastika on that shoulder?
@@archer5722 No but I can see a one in eagles hand and that's a ww2 german army officer uniform.
@@archer5722 are you fucking dumb?
@@archer5722
Thank you. As a visible minority, we are often reminded we don't belong in history. The Africans and Indians (American and Asian) get forgotten by those who cannot see themselves in the other people. They also don't tell this in our high school history books. Our blood is as red as yours.
This guy literally exposed himself when having a debate with Destiny as having AT MOST the maturity, ego, attention span and knowledge of an 11yo, Three Arrows, you should watch it man, it's pure gold, these "skeptics" literally melt down when they are not in their echo-chamber podcasts or their video-monologues. The guy literally couldn't make a sound argument against paedophilia and incest.
Thank you for pointing up the sacrifices of those Indian and African soldiers. This little white American girl never heard of these in grade school, back in the '70's!
@Celtic and Penobscot wanna talk about those groups?
Gamers explaining why getting 360 noscoped by a Kar98k with a weed skin is historically accurate but not women or black people
I love when people debunk the "history was white" fallacy. Thank you. This is important work.
Avadrea what
I don't know what you're confused about. The narrative that most of history, civilization, or achievements has been attributed to "white" people is common in some groups. You hear white supremacists bang on about it all the time, how people of color have made "no contributions" to history or culture when that is demonstrably not the case. I might have used the wrong word because it is not an official "fallacy" but it is faulty thought.
Avadrea tbf general it was white people
Avadrea this is literally something you just made up to be upset about. People like you seem to forget that because we are a western country, our history is white history. It has nothing to do with white supremacy
+Maria Unido "Lol, people don't do that, you just made it up! Now let me tell you how all of American history was only white people, barring Africans, Native Americans, Immigrants, etc.." The lack of self-awareness in this comment is astounding.
"My grandfather died in Dunkirk"
"Lol! How can he have fought there when Indians didn't live in England then? Stop revising white history!!!! I read an article online that was uncited, but agreed with my views!"
A comment section that doesn't make me wish for the meteor wipe out of humanity
Where have you been all this time? :I
Haha, same here bro 😂 the search is finally over!
I guess you haven’t seen the posts by Easter Worshipper yet.
That’s good, don’t look for them.
I was gonna say the sensible can be found somewhere but ya really dont look for easter worshipper
@@jaymiddleton1782 there’s a few people like if. It worse in this comment section
Thanks for mentioning the Indian army during world war 2!
@@valerierodger7700 Pajeets
BTW, on the topic of "almost everyone fighting in WW2 was white", I'd like to recommend the movie Indigènes (English title: Days of Glory, for whatever reason), which deals with French Algerian troops and their historical mistreatment.
InnerPartisan
>almost everyone fighting in ww2 was white.
Who the fuck bombed Pearl Harbor? The Irish?
InnerPartisan "mistreatment"
Arabs were treated better than other whites in Nazi occupied lands
xcalibrx I always knew it was those fucking irish man... fucking traitors
no Xcalibrx it was the Grenadier Guards
How are Algerians not white?
i like that the video isn't even about a movie with black people in it, he's outraged at the very idea of a movie with black people in it
6:28
I love the intent of the French poster, because that was super progressive for the day
...but those drawings wouldnt fly today
Why wouldn't it fly today?
kind of telling that his avatar is wearing a german wwii uniform lol
A bull dressed in a wehrmacht uniform accuses others to be wannabe nazis, seems legit
Let's just list some of the areas of combat in WW2 where white people weren't the majority population shall we?
Pacific islands
Japan
China
Libya
Ethiopia
Algeria
Gabon
Madagascar
Somalia
Iraq
Burma
India
Siam
Indonesia
Vietnam
Iran
Mongolia
Korea
You just missed Eritrea in the list, but for the rest it's perfect
Optimist: The glass is half full
Pessimist: The glass is half empty
No Bullshit: The glass is problematic
Dude honestly compared the left to nazis while his avatar wears a nazi uniform.
Status Quo Warriors: "I'm not racist; I don't care; nobody should dictate the demographics of fictional characters."
Critic: "It would've been more believable, compelling, and/or accurate for X character(s) to have been _____."
Status Quo Warriors: "LOL I BET YOU WANT TO CAST A BUNCH OF DUMB RAPPERS, BECAUSE RAPPERS ARE DUMB AND CAN'T ACT. DID I MENTION I AM NOT RACIST?"
+Troj ZB Yeah, it isn't racist. What makes you think he is?
You don't see a problem with one person saying that more minority characters should've been included in a piece of fiction, and a second person scoffing at that, and suggesting that the first just wants some negative stereotype or negative representative of the group to be cast in the role?
Not to mention, the apparent assumption that rappers are dumb brutes who can't act. Uh, Ice Cube much, folks?
Troj ZB Maybe Brooks isn't right about what he said, but it isn't racist.
Troj ZB Brooks was just getting SJW vibes from that part of the article.
Well, and I'm not just calling out Brooks alone here. This is a conversation that happens *a lot.* You can practically set your watch by it.
Having watched his content and seen him in debates with other people, I can't just give him the benefit of the doubt. He's yet another Status Quo Warrior who just gets fundamentally twitchy whenever the comfortable status quo he enjoys and benefits from gets jostled or criticized. He's yet another person who sees anybody who challenges that status quo as an SJW, and who seeks out examples of wacky fringe SJWs to rationalize and justify not changing, growing, or questioning his assumptions about himself, other people, and the world.
But, this sort of thing is hardly limited just to him.
They forget the massive guerrilla war in Ethiopia against Italian fascist regime !
Rootin for Lenin Italy burned ancient Coptic monasteries and killed Christian monks as innocent people, this isn’t me being sarcastic I just wanted to give anyone who reads this some information on the atrocity, also they killed the princess of the empire.
Yeeeeaaaah, we kind of made a mess in Ethiopia, considering the size of the country and the zero tactical advantage the fascists obtained from its conquest... but everybody forgets about that LOL
Rootin for Lenin "gurilla warfare" the Italians literally stomped Africa and thete was about no resistance that actually did anything
Becauze that was a major front...
The abyssinian crisis wasn't part of ww2
I thought No BS was satirical with that video. Now you've changed my mind.
"And if you've grown to like Brooks"
No... No don't worry, I really haven't.
I literally unsubscribed from him, then subscribed to you in a space of 30 seconds, I thought I was the only one who didn’t like the things he was posting
Imagine being so gullible that you literally do a complete 180 of your opinions in 30 seconds. Whose video are you gonna watch next and conform your opinions to? A literal neo-nazi? A far left totalitarian commie? Who knows.
Here's an better idea. Try actually thinking for yourself for once and don't swallow everything people say in youtube videos without any critical thinking. That goes for both No Bullshit and Three Arrows.
VMohdude - PREACH
@@VMohdude- Lol. I agree that no bullshit is a complete moron. But if you like NBs vids then I think it's pretty safe to say you won't agree with Three Arrows and like his videos. Have you even watched NB?
So, yeah. All it took to convince him NB was shit was watching 30 seconds of another video. That's gullible in my book. Extremely gullible even. That's why you could probably convince the original poster of just about anything in 30 seconds if you make your argument convincing enough. That type of mentality is dangerous.
Helvegen I agree with everything in your first paragraph. And your right, that mentality is dangerous. But I think people only subscribe to channels after watching at least a few of their videos. And people can change their beliefs over long periods of time. And yes, I’ve watched nb on a few occasions and I found it predictable, childish, and less substantial.
I unsubcribed from Philosophy Tube because that was turning into leftist propaganda, yet I'm newly subscribed to Three Arrows and am enjoying his criticisms of people from the right.
Never watched a NB video, but maybe the dude was subscribed because he didn't fully understand what he was watching?
or maybe there was a "decent" NB video but then every other video wasn't as "decent"
I love that not only you expose the alt-right/alt-light, but I also get to learn so much cool shit from watching you doing it.
José Aguilar Wow. Thats one of the nicest compliments I ever got. Thanks! I hope to live up to your expectations.
Watch his other videos. He pretty much disintegrates all your masked talking points.
Not my job to educate the ignorant. And I was referring to your dog whistle lingo.
Pardon me, my response was rude.
ruclips.net/video/B1ed3HgHUZM/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/HOHthnsuhPw/видео.html
They really took no time to find at all, I'm just accustomed to inflammatory trolls.
ruclips.net/video/HOHthnsuhPw/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/B1ed3HgHUZM/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/c1rMLC87rJc/видео.html
Pardon me, my response was rude and finding the videos really took no time at all. I'm just accustomed to inflammatory trolls.
"Nobody's complaining about something I like! Oh, no! I better act as if someone is, otherwise I will have to start making actual content that means something!" - every alt-right / MRA ever.
Every god damned anti-SJW rant is a preemptive defense against an attack that never comes.
These idiots need to shove their "identity politics" where they tell their imaginary SJWs to shove theirs.
FaithLehane you realize people who support Men’s right aren’t automatically a conservative republic. Also really? What’s wrong with wanting equal parenting rights and less death in the workplace and bodily autonomy?
cool user name that's quite an interpretation of FaithLehane's comment. With jumps like that you should go to the Olympics.
cool user name There’s nothing wrong with that. But if you weren’t so caught up in a right wing echo chamber, you’d realize feminism actually helps those things. You see, you want to fight the symptoms. “Men die more in the work place? We should fix that!” When the root cause is deep rooted misogyny. Because if women were in more dangerous jobs that wouldn’t happen. “But more men die from being homeless?” Ever considered that’s a result of men expected to be in the workforce while women stay at home. “But men get children less often in divorce cases!” Maybe because women are seen as caretakers and men as workers? Almost all sexism against men has its roots in misogyny.
This has been your ted talk from your friendly lefty crocodile.
"Every alt-right/ MRA ever"
No? Could we agree lumping everyone on the right together isnt the sollution here?
politics are like drugs
its so good
but makes you depressed.
Many people both left and right get their historical knowledge from Hollywood movies, unfortunately
There are many educational movies even by Hollywood, you just need to not take it all at face value.
Problem is people love to take things at face values and not analyze it with multiple sources
As someone who's fascinated by history, especially ancient and medieval history, it is always saddening when I see movies get things wrong, and always am glad when RUclips channels like Shadiversity and Metatron point out where they got stuff wrong.
When I point out the inaccuracies, people are always like, "It's just a movie; no one's expecting it to be accurate" and I then have to point out that many misconceptions are perpetuated by Hollywood to this day, and I point out that a movie has nothing to lose and a whole lot to gain by actually looking at history.
@@matthewmuir8884 a good reason why I'm not a fan of watching movies, one can watch movies no doubt because entertainment just don't believe everything in a movie
So you're telling me Forrest Gump wasn't a real documentary
Finally, a worthy rebuttal to all the far right propaganda that’s polluted the internet for so many years now. You are doing a great work.
inphanta Compared to what, exactly?
Propaganda😂😂😂 left started all this bullshit
+Stan Webb
That's the improper spelling of 'CNN'.
2 issues:
- The narrative that the left started anything is literally part of the propaganda. There's maybe a half-truth in it if you want to go into how political propaganda as a whole really kicked off in the 19th and 20th century, but if you want to talk about what has been happening in the last maybe 5 years it's mostly the alt-right and skeptospheres that do shit and they're pretty successfull if you look at stats.
- Pretending even if it were true that doesn't justify anything the right does and it's not a good idea to start whataboutism if you want to retain any credibility.
Nice Profile Image
Three Arrows, have you seen the film Camp De Thiaroye? It’s about the West African troops who fought for France in the aftermath of the war and I highly recommend it
No Bullshit is so cringe. He really got stuck in that 2016 anti-SJW trend and never got out
The film industry needs to recognise minorities for their historically accurate existence rather than ignore them.
The Nazis seem to be stuck in the early 2000s if they reference Fiddy, Snoop and Oprah.
Lmao they are so outdated.
Doyle Harken An actual Nazi wouldn't quote black ppl cuz Nazis didn't like blacks.
They're so left behind even recently they only started to gain interested in abstract painting.
To the alt-left: everyone's a Nazi.
To the alt-right: everyone's an SJW.
Questionable? "Alt-left" = "We have to project our failures on the left so we have anything we can critisize them for."
Has anyone noticed how No Bullshits appearance is with a Nazi uniform?
I'm more outraged by his pronunciation of Kenneth Branagh
I also hate when people say that WW2 was just a white people war and that they shouldn’t care, like you all forgot about Africa and Asia?
There is (or used to be) a whole room in the Art & History Museum in Birmingham that is dedicated to Sikh help in the war. I would invite that Brook to visit it but probably he won't be bothered. He can't let reality get in the way of a good rant.
@Shaheen Shad Yes. I don't know if the exposition is still there but I went there some years ago, and it was pretty big. And very interesting.
@Shaheen Shad They were volunteers, and the people I talked to they were very proud of their contribution. They didn't sound like slaves at all, assuming that was a thing during the WW2
He would probably call it "fake news" or "sjw propaganda"
I call bullshit on him using the name "No Bullshit".
"Nothing but bullshit" feels like a more accurate name for noBS
"no bullshit"; *wears a bull face*; *says shit*;
Failed miserably.
Khaler Jex,
You had one job, NOBS! One job!
You're producing some really good work and deserve many more subscribers.
i love how right wing youtubers are now making up theoretical people to be correct
He's really showing his colors with the German uniform
its funny because awhile back spike lee specifically got mad at world war 2 movies for downplaying black heroism just like they had in the war and made a great movie miracle at santa anna to counter it. so brooks fails at movies as well
blacktigerpaw1 wow so edgy😒
+Rightwinged Huey Freeman
It's a real event. You should look it up.
blacktigerpaw1 white soilders committed war crimes as well you idiot
Would they also show white soldiers doing that? Or white submariners machine gunning Japanese merchant marine survivors in the water? Those war crimes also happened.
Cherry pick at your own risk as cherry picking can be used to show whatever the cherrypicker wants.
I'm fascinated by the american wilful ignorance of historical events they otherwise constantly refer to. And yeah, it was a World War, and Africa itself was a significant theatre of operations even in the early years of the war.
And in mainland Europe, battalions from the colonies were definitely stationed there. In fact, this practice was already in place WW1. A number of units indigenous of different parts of the world are integral parts of French history, from the trench warfare of WW1 to D-Day onwards, and are dutifully honoured with monuments to their bravery and all that you'd expect.
I think its telling what unifirm his fursona is wearing... and although I'm not gunna fault a bovine for it, but; I think he's confused the word "No" for the word "All".
Edit/Afterthought: Perhaps he misspelled "Moo" that kinda makes sense for a nonsense cow; "Moo Bullshit"
Three Arrows:
You truly make great videos, please keep up the good work.
6:28 I know this is unrelated, but that French poster is badass.
When I was in Paris in... I think it was 2014, I visited the Carnavalet Museum and they had a Liberation of Paris photography exhibition going on at the time which was apparently an exhibition they'd done decades ago before (maybe it was even as far back as the 40's? The details are escaping me rn) and some sections of it were dedicated to the things they'd neglected during the first run of the exhibition. Part of that was the women and the people of colour who had participated in the liberation. Photographs and even some film reels of them had been included to fix the earlier exclusion. I found it really refreshing, getting to see pictures of heroism in the war that weren't all just of white men.
Yes I'm sure Macron loves it too.
Syksy oh yea thank GOD there’s like 5 women who risked their life so fuck those white men who died by the hundred thousands
@Mapping Mapper Do you mean "refreshed"? coz that is what was said lol. Gotta be careful too, when you assert that white male persons constitute the bulk of agency, you are implying that they simultaneously take on the bulk of responsibility and accountability. Because, to have agency means to have responsibility and accountability. This paints white male persons as culpable for the actions of others who share their ethnicity and sex category. And that is exactly what you DON'T want. Don't posit that it was mostly white male persons who made choices....because then you leave us open to be held accountable for those choices. Use your brain.
That'sTerrorists, Bro! How in the fuck does pointing out that the majority of soldiers in Europe fighting ww2 were white in any way “paint white males as culpable for the actions of others who share their ethnicity and... “sex category(?)””???
@Ivan Ivanovich Ivanovosky : So you visited Paris... But then you dodged it by visiting Prague ? Was ?
Just discovered your channel.. Oh my, what an excellent work you're doing! Many thx!
"We don't hate black people. We just make condescending remarks about them. Why are you so obsessed with race?" They're so disingenuous about it too. Who are you people trying to kid?
Dude your channel is really fantastic, please do more videos and make them longer if possible!
My grandpa served with the 452nd Anti Aircraft Automatic Weapons Batt Colored. His brother served in the marine corp in WW2.
If they would have known to what allied voctory would lead they would have fought for Hitler.
u gay no
If dude just takes the ‘No’ out of the title to his you tube channel then everything is fixed. 😀
"No bullshit" is mostly bullshit. I watched the video's where he talked about South Park as if it is straight up conservative and making fun of liberals and etc, totally ingoring the parts where he made fun of conservatives and the right, too.
What was the point of his avatar wearing a Wehrmacht uniform?
It seems he hates subtlety.
The kids trying to be edgy
GEORGE RANGO go away with your nazi praises
Its funny
Other question : What about the damn cow head ?
The alt right cant exist without a revisionist interpretation of history
Their interpretation of 'revisionism' in truth is actually distorionism
Idk, i'd say they're more in the right than the left who in this game fucking EXCLUDED HALF THE PARTICIPANTS, say the Soviets and Japan.
4th Dimension Is NoBS actually alt-right? I hear so many people of the centre and right called alt-right that I am immediately sceptical of people called that.
Not to mention the soldiers from the Caribbean who fought for the British...
Love your take...
Yeah... I unsubscribed from No BS, The Quartering et al. a long time ago... best decision!
I'm glad I've found someone who battles the pure ignorance of the alt-right and alt-light. You got a new sub!!
"Alt right"
One of my favorite moments in Dunkirk was when they showed the French Africa troops. Towards the end of getting my history degree, I developed a focus on Colonial soldiers in European armies during the 1900's. Their stories are often forgotten and untold, and I think that's unfortunate considering the roles they played and the experiences they had.
He's talking about what he knows about the second world war, which is all from watching saving private ryan.
Dig! Dig!
Edward Coyle yup. That and black hawk down.
Watched a couple of your videos, I always learn something new.
New happy subscriber
Having the name Brooks currently is very disappointing considering No BS’s real name is Brooks.
What part of “*World* War” do some people not understand?
Brooks "sjws want all these minorities to be represented in the media fairly....and so did the Nazis....the Nazis loved cultural diversity and minorities...."
There's a monument in London that commemorates all the former colonies that aided in both World War, 5 million people from those regions volunteered. I can't imagine being so blinded by racism to just ignore so many people deserving of remembrance.
Where I used to live there's a graveyard dedicated to Muslim soldiers who died in the world wars. White man's war my ass.
No bullshit editing the video
- My avatar should be in a WW2 uniform! Which one should i use? American? No... too under the nose. British? Nah... i don't like tea. Soviet? Nope... that's SJW propaganda. WOW! That one with the eagles looks cool, sure it will give good vibes to the viewers.
4:35 they make that sound bad but that sounds kinda dope
One of my ancestors was involved in Operation Dynamo. To see someone like NBS bastardise a tribute to our brave men is infuriating beyond measure.
your channel is a breathe of fresh air