@@Stiegelzeine Someone but be an apple d rider. This test was flawed cause my Bixby and Google can do quite a lot of what they marked off on them. Maybe setting, maybe hearing, ect. Google is best for asking Google questions as Google I'd the best browser, and Bixby is best for internal since it does better internal then siri and google
@@axollivierre8658 Siri was also able to do a lot of those things he said they couldn’t so yes that test is trash but Siri is still better than Bixby and I use a iPad and (currently) a Samsung phone so I have access to all 3 assistants so I know what I’m talking about
@@Stiegelzeine same exact shit for me too. Siri can't do research like Google or internal like Bixby. But she does the other better then both. That's why Bixby and Google is better then siri, but just siri is better then each by themselves
I’m an iOS user, and I love my 13 Pro, but in terms of capability, Siri is still significantly behind Google’s Assistant. It can make reservations, you can order stuff through the voice assistant, it can take your place if you’re put on hold during a call, it’s better with contextual questions, and it is better with smart home tasks. That said, I don’t think Siri is as bad as people make it out to be. It’s still the second best voice assistant, ahead of Bixby and Alexa. But Google’s Voice Assistant, at least in terms of what it can do, is still better. But Siri, by no means, is trash. It’s still, on average, quicker than Google, Bixby, and Alexa, with requests and with tasks in regards to settings, messages, and searches, is on par with Google’s.
Great stuff! I tested on my Pixel 6 Pro with the same results except for the "take a screenshot" and "close Spotify". These commands work great for me every time. Mine is on the November 5th update for the OS and December 3rd for Google app.
I don't think it was really fair to say "Google something something" in the "controlling apps" section. What Google Assistant is really good at compared to the other assistant is answering questions - what you ended up actually testing here is Siri's and Bixby's ability to open Google and put in a search term, and not if they are actually able to answer the question
"google something' is actually the most common thing to ask assistants...there is no point of saying 'it's not fair'. We are testing the ability of assistant to get the result "as soon as possible" with accuracy....irrespective of the fact that how integrated it is. It doesn't mean that if apple and Samsung are not integrated (with google stuff) we will not test the most basic thing (which is searching something using assistant).
@@d.k.2418 If I want to know the answer to a question, I ask Siri. I don't tell Siri to google it because most of the time it will tell me the answer anyway, the rest off the time it will show me search results from sites like Google (Or google itself). Asking Siri to 'Google' something is dumb, and I have never in my life heard a single person add the extra step of asking Siri to use google. I understand and appreciate your input, but in terms of everyday usage, asking a phone to google something is an almost completely inconsequential testing parameter. And while we're at it (and this is irrelevant to this particular point) I was definitely annoyed when assistants weren't awarded points for accomplishing the task just because they did it in a different way from the other phones. Case and point, Siri not being awarded a point for 'Take a selfie' even though it opened up the front camera to take a selfie. No one would ever (if they even used that command) be disappointed by the phone not taking it upon itself to take the actual picture. By that definition, none of the phones should have been awarded a point for 'Download a game' because none of them actually downloaded any games. But yeah, rant over
@@harrymontgomery4585 I totally get your point, but I just have to say one thing. I am a student and i use iphone 12 mini. And trust me I say siri to search for something "on google" cause I just don't want the most popular results, I sometimes have to look for something different which is not in the top search results. To be honest i don't even care if it takes 1 sec more or even if i have to type for it but still just saying.
@@harrymontgomery4585 he also tended to ask the same question multiple times (turn on/off darkmode) as if that would change the outcome. Also, the speed points don't make sense, since that depends on the phone. Not only that he didn't really touch on context awareness, which I think is the most important. You should be able to ask: "What is RUclips?" and thereafter "Who founded it?"
So, in conclusion, Google Assistant is great at looking up things and random fun. Bixby is great at device control (my personal favorite), she can even open apps in split screen, wild control over device. Siri is average of both, she has some device control and she's good at looking up sometimes, average. Both Siri and Bixby have evolved so much over the years and I really didn't except both of them to do so good, that's nice!
Strange. Because my Google assistant can decrease and increase the brightness, increase or decrease volume and it can also take screenshots. There's something wrong with the pixel.
Like in previous videos there is a strange disadvantage to apples contestors, especially Samsung. They always seem to perform worse than they should. Draw your own conclusions
Wanna mention most of the commands you asked from Bixby that got failed works perfectly fine. I can prove that. Maybe regional issues but I think it deserves the best according to my testing ( Yes every command you mentioned was tested by myself after this vid). Anyway great content as always!
@@charles-davidberube1174 i found mine not to work when i switched Bixby to UK english. I think you have to adjust it to your language/ accent so it understand you better
@@sanukadeteka7953 No it doens't, i am not a native english speaker, my native one is portuguese, and Siri can't recognise when we ask her to play some international music like "Chained to the rythym".
The fact that Siri and Bixby kept up with Google is impressive for me considering they don’t have huge data search engine called google installed in their core
It would be interesting to know how each phone performed broken down by the type of questions you asked. It seems Google Assistant did really well with Internet questions due to Google search optmization.
The majority of people with disabilities use Voice Assistant probably more than the average consumer, especially when it comes to things like voiceover on iOS and Talkback on Android. The majority of my friends have some level of disability and if they can afford it will have two devices and iOS and and Android device. So far as which Voice Assistant is used most, Google Assistant would be used probably about 60%to 70% of the time, then IOS mainly because of the rotor and built in braiiie keyboard. Among my friends. Bixby is not used at all.
Some commands and questions did not rank the same as the others. When Bixby was losing at the end to those less important tasks, I did not saw that as fair.
The screen brightness on the pixel actually changed, seems like the version of the Google app you were running just has a bug that makes the slider appear in the wrong place
The main thing I miss in these videos is more real world use performance, than as shown in this controlled environment. I would like to see more contrast between the real world performance and the curated performance. The biggest thing I'm missing from this comparison, as with all voice assistant comparison, is multilingual testing, as in my experience many other language supporting as far from good as English, and using a voice assistant in non English speaking country is counterproductive and dysfunctional.
There is no assistant that can handle my language (Polish) in a usable way so... 😆 But Bixby is much more accurate understanding my non-native speaker's English than Google Assistant.
I think you should've asked more related questions like how far is Mc Donald's pudong then next one should've been navigate me to there or show me it's menu.
7:26 and 7:44 Here you wrong! Acutully bixby didn't played the song as you havent set up your Spotify account with it, I use bixby on my S9+ and i had to set up Spotify so when i ask to play a song it plays on Spotify also on 9:30 its weird that it doesn't answer on mine it tells ghe joke and also the same with 9:42 I think there's something wrong with. your bixby There should be a tie between the 3, 42-42-42
Sorry to say this. But this video is not the proper answer for the best assistant. -->siri is way faster. -->Bixby is way ahead when controlling the device with voice --> Google assistant works way faster and better in Samsung phones more than in pixel phones. Try the same test in s21 ultra and you will be surprised that Bixby and siri will eat dust.
For every question that Bixby got wrong, I asked Bixby the same question on my Galaxy Note10+ running OneUI 3.1. Bixby got every question correct except for the Wikipedia question.
@@charlesxavier1904 Google Assistant was a thing in 2016 and it was already leapfrogging over everything else that was out. Meanwhile Bixby started in 2017 which no one wanted, it was completely unusable and four years later it went from completely unusable, to borderline unusable. Compared to Google assistant, it will need another 10 years of work before it could even be on the level of Siri.
@@Saphman4 obviously some people wanted it. Second Samsung makes lots of products which is why they are making a push for it. Thirdly Bixby routines have been fantastic out of the gate which Google is just starting to adopt. Lastly they had a year head start of course it's going to look better. Some of the features that Google added happened because of the competition from Bixby as well as other virtual assistants.
Hi Nick. Bro plz make camera comparison of pixel 6 pro, iphone 13 pro,vivo x70 pro plus.... By the way your reviewing style of Smart phones are awesome.
I've rarely seen tests like this before. Siri has been maligned for years, but it pretty much dominated here, plus you said it won last time too. Pretty funny it couldn't produce the founders of Apple though. 🤦🏿♂️
This test is fundamentally flawed. The same questions are asked multiple times but worded differently, as if that will change the outcome (turn on/off darkmode). Context awareness is not tested at all, and speed is irrelevant as it depends on the phone (and the difference is so small it doesn't matter). I've seen some much better executed tests and the result tends to be: - Google Assistant - Siri - Bixby
The iphone is faster in opening apps with or without using the voice assistant so I think this comparison was heavily influenced by that. Doing the same comparisons with different phone models/os versions would produce different results, but the assistants are still the same so I don't think the "speed" part of the video is any accurate. Nonetheless nice video!
Same exact thought. Also it's clearly that Google Assistant is the king with more advanced and "real life talking" sentences rather than a robot who automates some actions At least to me, Google is trying to model a "smart" assistant rather than a "virtual assistant" like Siri (which ofc works just fine it does the job, but in a different way)
@@pucciox40 Yh, I actually use Google assistant quite often, as it's as far as i know the only good tool to recognise songs by you humming/singing them.
Instead of "Google what is Elon Musk's net worth". You should have asked "What is his net worth?". This was a decent test, but there should have been more questions based around context. For example; "When did [movie] release?", "Who acted in it?", "How did it perform in the box office?", etc.
@@mikey187lfc I agree, Google would have, and should have, won this comparison. Google Assistant is the better assistant. Being able to recognize and understand natural language and context is important for voice assistants.
Would be interesting to see the voice assistants compared on watches. A couple years ago when I tried Bixby it seriously struggled with simple tasks like starting workouts or making calls.
I don't think this is a good comparison at all, because I feel that you played specifically to Siri's strengths here. Specifically, you didn't ask back-to-back questions to test conversational skills and overall didn't go that in-depth on many categories. Plus, the speed category is a little misleading, and while I am impressed with Siri's speed I believe it should only be used to settle ties (unless it's not even close). It looks like you used Google Assistant through a VPN as well, which can definitely impact speeds. That said, I still appreciate the work put into this video, and am not trying to hate on anyone here. Just giving some feedback!
When Bixby was first released in beta it was fast, accurate and had way more options plus could have answered all the ones it wasn't able to now; my guess is Samsung partnerships with microsoft made it less useful.
Really? Because I remember when Bixby was released, and it was a steaming pile of obsolete garbage. Looks like now it's just obsolete, so credit to Samsung I guess...
@@bensignor1476 lol , all the questions je asked to bixby , in Real life Bixby answer theses question . This kid IS just a Apple fanboy and he IS sad caus he know how much better IS Samsung
@Les Idées De Neo Absolutely and as siri is device based its obviously going to be faster. Did you see how slow it was when it had to do external tasks? He manipulated the test and yes Bixby answered them for me too.
I tested the same stuff, my Assistant on Oneplus Nord was way quicker and did some of the stuff that the pixel didn't do, like increasing brightness. Weird..
I feel as though speed only matters on certain things. For example, you already had Spotify open in the background with the Apple phone, so when you asked it to open it, it just switch tabs rather then opening it. Not to mention the fact the Pixel has the least powerful chip here meaning opening apps, the apple phone is clearly going to win in most cases.
Bixby is actually really good. I think bixby missed a lot of those questions because a lot of bixby capsules are only available in USA and south korea. Even spotify capsules is not available in europe? Come on. I,m in the USA and the only question bixby missed was the wikipedia question. Bixby has really improved. No joke. Samsung has improved bixby but the development is so uneven. It,s stupid. Why make most of the capsules only available in the USA and Korea?
Milliseconds speed doesn't matter to me, but I consider google assistant as best as it is the perfect allrounder for our questions to random conversation. Come on Apple didn't show it's founders (I love apple)
Asking the iPhone "Google " isn't being too fair since it isn't an Android that natively runs Google Search. I tried the same questions by just asking them directly and it was nigh instantaneous.
Siri does as much on device processing as possible, where Google sends everything to their servers which can cause slight delays due to latency and such. I know Google is trying to modify this going forward but Apple still has the upper hand with their neural engine.
@@pambinobequeno5062 I strongly disagree with you supporting that the information I shared is not useful. It shows that Siri is constantly getting updated or that there were some technical issues with that iPhone 13 Pro Max. I’m not sure how Siri didn’t respond to that question. Too bad your comment is useless. 😌
Either way Samsung is the true winner here Imagine having two smart-ass-istant on the same phone It's like one knows everything inside and the other knows everything on the outside
Personally because iOS is so privacy oriented, I don't think it could ever surpass Google assistant. It's just not going to be able to use certain core info to get as granular as Google can. Granted, Google downright gets alot more info that some users might not appreciate, but the up side is that it can answer super specific requests because of that. But who knows what'll happen in the future.
The commands will run faster on the iPhone due to the A15 and Nvme storage and wider system cache and that 5 core GPU, remember that the CPU itself has 4 AI accelerators that are there to accelerate such tasks quicker on the A15. However, on the other two, the limitation of the CPU architecture starts kicking in because of the lack of having their own CPU cores and a much more faster Nvme.
That is the problem with subjective analysis. Here we have a scientific test that shows Siri is faster by a good margin and as accurate with some good contextual responses. It is clear that accuracy levels are good on all devices but that, as usual, iOS is so much faster with its ML and AI. Hopefully the new 2022 chips will close that speed deficit. Bearing in mind Siri started many years behind Google Assistant it is impressive that it now leads the way.
@@andyH_England yes and no. The point is, how much do you ask to your assistant things, and what do you ask? As shown in the video siri is fast in turning on and off Bluetooth and stuffs BUT she cannot do things related to what you told her before EG "delete that thing" and since I use that function very often in my everyday life Siri sucks
@@justaguyfromreddit ...I would say that "delete that stuff" has a very specific user case. I do not think I have ever used that instruction! You are right, if that is what you mainly do then Google is better, but for the average consumer who rarely use that, opening apps and turning stuff on are far more relevant and Siri does that with speed and accuracy.
There's something wrong with Pixel 6 pro lol. I tried wrong answer of google on my OnePlus 9 pro and it got that fast and correct. My animation is on 0.5x so a bit cheat but i think google assistant is more reliable than bixby, more or bit less better than siri i think
I experienced both of Siri and Google Assistant, I feel that at term of AI and details in seeking information Siri is a bit behind Google Assistant, even in this video some information or commands are faster on Google Assistant talking about speed I rather say draw, AI Google is à bit better
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
I loved how Siri failed to answer "who are the founders of apple"
Right, that was hilarious 🤣🤣🤣
Just tried on my iphone and it worked
@@charles-davidberube1174 sheesh. I can't wait to get my hands on Iphone 13 pro max next year 😍
It worked for me lol
It works on my ip 7 :/
Love how Siri failed to find the founders of Apple
Yeah that was just sad
My Siri can find though.
I couldn't stop laughing 😂
Its weird how my Siri managed to do it.
Mine got it right on my iPhone XR when I asked the question who the founder of apple and got the answer right
The best part in samsung phones... can use bixby for internal operations and Google for net operations
best of both worlds
@@axollivierre8658 the best of both worlds is Siri for everything and google assistant for google questions
@@Stiegelzeine Someone but be an apple d rider. This test was flawed cause my Bixby and Google can do quite a lot of what they marked off on them. Maybe setting, maybe hearing, ect. Google is best for asking Google questions as Google I'd the best browser, and Bixby is best for internal since it does better internal then siri and google
@@axollivierre8658 Siri was also able to do a lot of those things he said they couldn’t so yes that test is trash but Siri is still better than Bixby and I use a iPad and (currently) a Samsung phone so I have access to all 3 assistants so I know what I’m talking about
@@Stiegelzeine same exact shit for me too. Siri can't do research like Google or internal like Bixby. But she does the other better then both. That's why Bixby and Google is better then siri, but just siri is better then each by themselves
Only if google assistant and Bixby could be merged,they would make a great assistant. Love them all anyways!
I guess so many people agree with this 😀
I use the long press button for bixby especially with samsung settings,and google for the rest,that equals beast mode
I use the long press button for bixby especially with samsung settings,and google for the rest,that equals beast mode
Gooby or Bixle?
@@aaryaputra108 Both😄
I’m an iOS user, and I love my 13 Pro, but in terms of capability, Siri is still significantly behind Google’s Assistant. It can make reservations, you can order stuff through the voice assistant, it can take your place if you’re put on hold during a call, it’s better with contextual questions, and it is better with smart home tasks. That said, I don’t think Siri is as bad as people make it out to be. It’s still the second best voice assistant, ahead of Bixby and Alexa. But Google’s Voice Assistant, at least in terms of what it can do, is still better. But Siri, by no means, is trash. It’s still, on average, quicker than Google, Bixby, and Alexa, with requests and with tasks in regards to settings, messages, and searches, is on par with Google’s.
You're not iOS user 😂
I'm so sad to be living in a country where I can't use the full functionality of my Assistant xdd
@@maybesaad lol I have to be a isheep to be a iOS user.
Well said
@@maybesaad i also use ios and i agree with him, you don’t have to be obnoxious money flexing asshole to be using ios lol
Great stuff!
I tested on my Pixel 6 Pro with the same results except for the "take a screenshot" and "close Spotify". These commands work great for me every time. Mine is on the November 5th update for the OS and December 3rd for Google app.
Increasing brightness and decreasing brightness also works for me
these commands work fine on my pixel2 and pixel6
@@hunhunhun_ even my Redmi 4A with Pixel Experience A12 run these command haha
Same with bixby, there was 5 or 6 that worked for me but Google is clearly the best AI
I did the same on my galaxy s20 fe. It worked amazing. Don't know what happened here.
I don't think it was really fair to say "Google something something" in the "controlling apps" section. What Google Assistant is really good at compared to the other assistant is answering questions - what you ended up actually testing here is Siri's and Bixby's ability to open Google and put in a search term, and not if they are actually able to answer the question
Probably like 6 of the questions were googling
"google something' is actually the most common thing to ask assistants...there is no point of saying 'it's not fair'.
We are testing the ability of assistant to get the result "as soon as possible" with accuracy....irrespective of the fact that how integrated it is.
It doesn't mean that if apple and Samsung are not integrated (with google stuff) we will not test the most basic thing (which is searching something using assistant).
@@d.k.2418 If I want to know the answer to a question, I ask Siri. I don't tell Siri to google it because most of the time it will tell me the answer anyway, the rest off the time it will show me search results from sites like Google (Or google itself). Asking Siri to 'Google' something is dumb, and I have never in my life heard a single person add the extra step of asking Siri to use google. I understand and appreciate your input, but in terms of everyday usage, asking a phone to google something is an almost completely inconsequential testing parameter. And while we're at it (and this is irrelevant to this particular point) I was definitely annoyed when assistants weren't awarded points for accomplishing the task just because they did it in a different way from the other phones. Case and point, Siri not being awarded a point for 'Take a selfie' even though it opened up the front camera to take a selfie. No one would ever (if they even used that command) be disappointed by the phone not taking it upon itself to take the actual picture. By that definition, none of the phones should have been awarded a point for 'Download a game' because none of them actually downloaded any games. But yeah, rant over
@@harrymontgomery4585 I totally get your point, but I just have to say one thing. I am a student and i use iphone 12 mini. And trust me I say siri to search for something "on google" cause I just don't want the most popular results, I sometimes have to look for something different which is not in the top search results. To be honest i don't even care if it takes 1 sec more or even if i have to type for it but still just saying.
@@harrymontgomery4585 he also tended to ask the same question multiple times (turn on/off darkmode) as if that would change the outcome. Also, the speed points don't make sense, since that depends on the phone. Not only that he didn't really touch on context awareness, which I think is the most important. You should be able to ask: "What is RUclips?" and thereafter "Who founded it?"
This was Beautifully Set Up.
You Truly Have a Knack for Tech Entertainment,
love the color separations, the demonstration!
So, in conclusion, Google Assistant is great at looking up things and random fun.
Bixby is great at device control (my personal favorite), she can even open apps in split screen, wild control over device.
Siri is average of both, she has some device control and she's good at looking up sometimes, average.
Both Siri and Bixby have evolved so much over the years and I really didn't except both of them to do so good, that's nice!
Strange. Because my Google assistant can decrease and increase the brightness, increase or decrease volume and it can also take screenshots. There's something wrong with the pixel.
Same. Something's wrong here. My Google assistant does that too
@@carlosgarciasanchez I have a pixel 6 pro, and it can do all that as well I think it's something wrong with his
Like in previous videos there is a strange disadvantage to apples contestors, especially Samsung. They always seem to perform worse than they should. Draw your own conclusions
Pixel and Bixby in the video had VPN symbols that would definitely affect the latency. Seems like my man was paid by Apple.
Same
So getting a S21U might be the best option. You can get the best of both worlds ; Bixby and Google Assistant. 😌
Bixby is the worst and you can also get google assistant on iOS so no getting an iPhone is the best option
@@Stiegelzeine no its not the same
Isheep 🤡 @@Stiegelzeine
When he say "ok google" my assistant is ready to respond... 🤣
Wanna mention most of the commands you asked from Bixby that got failed works perfectly fine. I can prove that. Maybe regional issues but I think it deserves the best according to my testing ( Yes every command you mentioned was tested by myself after this vid). Anyway great content as always!
Well the fact it worked with you and not him proves it’s not as accurate
@@charles-davidberube1174 exactly
@@charles-davidberube1174 it is not a question of precision, it is a question of access granted to Bixby.
@@charles-davidberube1174 i found mine not to work when i switched Bixby to UK english. I think you have to adjust it to your language/ accent so it understand you better
Bixby is shit
It's so impressive that Siri won, even that she doens't collect that same amount of data Google Assistent does.
Actually it does more 😉
@@sanukadeteka7953 No it doens't, i am not a native english speaker, my native one is portuguese, and Siri can't recognise when we ask her to play some international music like "Chained to the rythym".
Except Siri definitely doesn't win in real life. Fact is that nothing can match Google or Google Assistant. 🤷🏻♂️
@@dvht1108 I have no idea about that but as they say I can confirm they collect data as same as Google. 🤷
@@sanukadeteka7953 No
Bixby was winning the whole way and bottled it at the end 😂😂😂
That was somthing to do with his phone lmao asking if you're a real person works, tell me a joke works, saying goodbye works
All final commands worked on my Bixby... 🤔
@@noads8175 on mine too
Good job Nick👍
Loved the overall video and mainly the way you've categoriesed the points and Timing. Great one
The fact that Siri and Bixby kept up with Google is impressive for me considering they don’t have huge data search engine called google installed in their core
Did you see how many of the search results relied on Google search engine? Lol
Then where tf they search? Bing?
It would be interesting to know how each phone performed broken down by the type of questions you asked. It seems Google Assistant did really well with Internet questions due to Google search optmization.
Thanks for including me in your video. It was so much fun to record ☺️ hope to be in upcoming videos!
The majority of people with disabilities use Voice Assistant probably more than the average consumer, especially when it comes to things like voiceover on iOS and Talkback on Android.
The majority of my friends have some level of disability and if they can afford it will have two devices and iOS and and Android device.
So far as which Voice Assistant is used most, Google Assistant would be used probably about 60%to 70% of the time, then IOS mainly because of the rotor and built in braiiie keyboard.
Among my friends. Bixby is not used at all.
I'm actually surprised of how well Bixby did
Some commands and questions did not rank the same as the others. When Bixby was losing at the end to those less important tasks, I did not saw that as fair.
Siri was more accurate than I thought. It’s always been a hit or miss for me.
Siri is soooo fast😁
Siri is getting better every year and it blows me away
And Bixby still improving
Google can make reservations using its AI, that's mind blowing
Good thing about Samsung you can use both Bixby and Google Assistant
Love your new type of content😍
The screen brightness on the pixel actually changed, seems like the version of the Google app you were running just has a bug that makes the slider appear in the wrong place
Great test! Lekker!
Those last few commands worked on my Bixby, it's so weird how the response for you was just "i didn't understand that"
The main thing I miss in these videos is more real world use performance, than as shown in this controlled environment. I would like to see more contrast between the real world performance and the curated performance. The biggest thing I'm missing from this comparison, as with all voice assistant comparison, is multilingual testing, as in my experience many other language supporting as far from good as English, and using a voice assistant in non English speaking country is counterproductive and dysfunctional.
There is no assistant that can handle my language (Polish) in a usable way so... 😆 But Bixby is much more accurate understanding my non-native speaker's English than Google Assistant.
I love how instant the Pixel was when you asked to see photos 😂 it knew before you even finished
I think you should've asked more related questions like how far is Mc Donald's pudong then next one should've been navigate me to there or show me it's menu.
And just asking them questions not asking them to google it. As I'll usually ask the question straight.
It's funny that all three were tied at 38.
Nice video :)
7:26 and 7:44 Here you wrong! Acutully bixby didn't played the song as you havent set up your Spotify account with it, I use bixby on my S9+ and i had to set up Spotify so when i ask to play a song it plays on Spotify
also on 9:30 its weird that it doesn't answer on mine it tells ghe joke and also the same with 9:42 I think there's something wrong with. your bixby
There should be a tie between the 3, 42-42-42
Sorry to say this. But this video is not the proper answer for the best assistant.
-->siri is way faster.
-->Bixby is way ahead when controlling the device with voice
--> Google assistant works way faster and better in Samsung phones more than in pixel phones. Try the same test in s21 ultra and you will be surprised that Bixby and siri will eat dust.
For every question that Bixby got wrong, I asked Bixby the same question on my Galaxy Note10+ running OneUI 3.1. Bixby got every question correct except for the Wikipedia question.
Well, i asked My IPhones with the same questions and it all worked considering i have a Filipino accent.
Hmm. The commenter talked about bixby, not iphone. I wonder why there are so many comments like this here^^
That was awesome bro
Google's assistant is known for continued conversations. Test that out, thanks.
Very true! Especially without context I think the test will go differently.
Google can take a screenshot! You have the "use screenshot context" off. It can also adjust your screen brightness.
i loved how bixby managed to do the most important, with improvements it'll be better than the others *in my opinion*
If you have a Samsung, bixby internal and Google AI external
It only took four and a half years.
@@Saphman4 how long has assistant been out? 4 years for starting a voice assistant from scratch is actually very good.
@@charlesxavier1904 Google Assistant was a thing in 2016 and it was already leapfrogging over everything else that was out. Meanwhile Bixby started in 2017 which no one wanted, it was completely unusable and four years later it went from completely unusable, to borderline unusable. Compared to Google assistant, it will need another 10 years of work before it could even be on the level of Siri.
@@Saphman4 obviously some people wanted it. Second Samsung makes lots of products which is why they are making a push for it. Thirdly Bixby routines have been fantastic out of the gate which Google is just starting to adopt. Lastly they had a year head start of course it's going to look better. Some of the features that Google added happened because of the competition from Bixby as well as other virtual assistants.
Most of the previously non working voice command are now working in bixby 😍
Google aswell
Hi Nick.
Bro plz make camera comparison of pixel 6 pro, iphone 13 pro,vivo x70 pro plus....
By the way your reviewing style of Smart phones are awesome.
Video quality is very good, buuuut the assistant capabilities of harder questions and tasks are the real game changer
interesting test. I've never seen such a comparison
Mrwhosetheboss did
@@Black-ef6xm Plenty did but not as calculated as Nick. For example he even tested their response time, it was quite a deep test.
@@nikunjkhangwal yea, that's how Apple won
I use Bixby a lot on my phone, and I tried all the commands that Bixby failed in this test, and they worked for me .
Same for me.
Samsung fan spotted😂😂😂😂
I've rarely seen tests like this before. Siri has been maligned for years, but it pretty much dominated here, plus you said it won last time too. Pretty funny it couldn't produce the founders of Apple though. 🤦🏿♂️
it can most of the time
@@amaanmohdd Samsung are better
@e93 Samsung is better
@@androidoneiu5206 ratioed
@e93 proof? Oh yeas you don’t have any proof, that same with the people that supports you
This test is fundamentally flawed. The same questions are asked multiple times but worded differently, as if that will change the outcome (turn on/off darkmode). Context awareness is not tested at all, and speed is irrelevant as it depends on the phone (and the difference is so small it doesn't matter). I've seen some much better executed tests and the result tends to be:
- Google Assistant
- Siri
- Bixby
The iphone is faster in opening apps with or without using the voice assistant so I think this comparison was heavily influenced by that.
Doing the same comparisons with different phone models/os versions would produce different results, but the assistants are still the same so I don't think the "speed" part of the video is any accurate.
Nonetheless nice video!
Same exact thought. Also it's clearly that Google Assistant is the king with more advanced and "real life talking" sentences rather than a robot who automates some actions
At least to me, Google is trying to model a "smart" assistant rather than a "virtual assistant" like Siri (which ofc works just fine it does the job, but in a different way)
@@pucciox40 Yh, I actually use Google assistant quite often, as it's as far as i know the only good tool to recognise songs by you humming/singing them.
Google is good at understanding second and third questions without telling anymore who are you talking about. That's the hardest thing to do !
Agreed
Instead of "Google what is Elon Musk's net worth". You should have asked "What is his net worth?".
This was a decent test, but there should have been more questions based around context. For example; "When did [movie] release?", "Who acted in it?", "How did it perform in the box office?", etc.
But then Google would have won because siri is crap then and slow as it has to go external. The test was manipulated
@@mikey187lfc I agree, Google would have, and should have, won this comparison. Google Assistant is the better assistant.
Being able to recognize and understand natural language and context is important for voice assistants.
The visual prompts and sound effects were helpful.
Would be interesting to see the voice assistants compared on watches. A couple years ago when I tried Bixby it seriously struggled with simple tasks like starting workouts or making calls.
Because you were using Bixby, a voice assistant that struggles with functioning properly let alone actually doing it what you tell it to do.
@@Saphman4 Bixby is able to do way more than you think. I was able to edit photos and videos thanks with bixby without touching my phone.
@@chomp5558 on Bixby? ??
@@Saphman4 with* or on? I dont know. To was definitely wrong tho
@@chomp5558 ah ok. A grammar Nazi. We're online, not in college.
I don't think this is a good comparison at all, because I feel that you played specifically to Siri's strengths here. Specifically, you didn't ask back-to-back questions to test conversational skills and overall didn't go that in-depth on many categories. Plus, the speed category is a little misleading, and while I am impressed with Siri's speed I believe it should only be used to settle ties (unless it's not even close). It looks like you used Google Assistant through a VPN as well, which can definitely impact speeds. That said, I still appreciate the work put into this video, and am not trying to hate on anyone here. Just giving some feedback!
When Bixby was first released in beta it was fast, accurate and had way more options plus could have answered all the ones it wasn't able to now; my guess is Samsung partnerships with microsoft made it less useful.
Really? Because I remember when Bixby was released, and it was a steaming pile of obsolete garbage. Looks like now it's just obsolete, so credit to Samsung I guess...
Bixby wasn't that bad when it was released.It was completing internal tasks like a pro the only area where it lacks is online commands
@@bensignor1476 lol , all the questions je asked to bixby , in Real life Bixby answer theses question . This kid IS just a Apple fanboy and he IS sad caus he know how much better IS Samsung
Half the ones it failed on, worked on my S20 Ultra.
@Les Idées De Neo Absolutely and as siri is device based its obviously going to be faster. Did you see how slow it was when it had to do external tasks? He manipulated the test and yes Bixby answered them for me too.
I want this video to go viral, so much hard work has been put into it
I tested the same stuff, my Assistant on Oneplus Nord was way quicker and did some of the stuff that the pixel didn't do, like increasing brightness. Weird..
Yup.. definitely android 12 bugs
Hmm. I'm not sure what OS version you had running on the Samsung but as of now, it seems they fixed the things Bixby failed at in this video 🤔
Google assistant is on another level in the terms of talking to you as a person💪💪💪
❤️
Love your ideas of video making in differents topics.. 💐 keep it up. 👍
I feel as though speed only matters on certain things. For example, you already had Spotify open in the background with the Apple phone, so when you asked it to open it, it just switch tabs rather then opening it.
Not to mention the fact the Pixel has the least powerful chip here meaning opening apps, the apple phone is clearly going to win in most cases.
It's because siri is device based and not cloud based. Look how much slower siri was at googling stuff.
Samsung Bixby is best for device operations, Google is best for internet related assistance, Siri is a good medium for both.
Bixby is actually really good. I think bixby missed a lot of those questions because a lot of bixby capsules are only available in USA and south korea. Even spotify capsules is not available in europe? Come on.
I,m in the USA and the only question bixby missed was the wikipedia question. Bixby has really improved. No joke.
Samsung has improved bixby but the development is so uneven. It,s stupid. Why make most of the capsules only available in the USA and Korea?
Milliseconds speed doesn't matter to me, but I consider google assistant as best as it is the perfect allrounder for our questions to random conversation. Come on Apple didn't show it's founders (I love apple)
I don’t know, i asked mine and it worked, considering i have a Filipino accent.
nick: goodbye!
Bixby: I didn't understand that
Didn't expect samsung to do so well.
2:50 technick: ok google
My phone: activate google assistant
With all due respect, this test makes Siri look smarter than it actually is.
Ikr 😂😂it's so dumb
He did it like this to make Siri look the best. The fact he said siri had always dominated was a joke.
With all due respect, Siri is as smart as he made it look
Asking the iPhone "Google " isn't being too fair since it isn't an Android that natively runs Google Search. I tried the same questions by just asking them directly and it was nigh instantaneous.
I can't say I likes the formats of this comparison as I don't think it really showcase the power and accuracy of the voice assistants.
The test was manipulated
You did something to ur S21 at the end bc for me all the end questions worked
Siri does as much on device processing as possible, where Google sends everything to their servers which can cause slight delays due to latency and such. I know Google is trying to modify this going forward but Apple still has the upper hand with their neural engine.
Starting from the z flip 3 onwards, All bixby inquiries will be done on the device.
Samsung says it,s 35 percent faster
This man is so detailed , I LOVE IT
I just asked Siri “Who are the founders of Apple” and I got the correct response 🤔
she found 3. then she proceeds to pronounce their names.
Yes, same
too bad this is not your video, so this information is useless 😌
@@pambinobequeno5062 I strongly disagree with you supporting that the information I shared is not useful. It shows that Siri is constantly getting updated or that there were some technical issues with that iPhone 13 Pro Max. I’m not sure how Siri didn’t respond to that question.
Too bad your comment is useless.
😌
Such a great video ^^
Either way Samsung is the true winner here
Imagine having two smart-ass-istant on the same phone
It's like one knows everything inside and the other knows everything on the outside
You can also install google assistant on iOS 🤦♂️
Dr. Strange: I saw 14000605 outcomes for assistant wars.
Siri: How many did I won?
Dr. Strange: 1.
And this is the video.
You didn't ask many questions that requires the assistant to refer to the previous question, that's where google assistant is far ahead
Personally because iOS is so privacy oriented, I don't think it could ever surpass Google assistant. It's just not going to be able to use certain core info to get as granular as Google can. Granted, Google downright gets alot more info that some users might not appreciate, but the up side is that it can answer super specific requests because of that. But who knows what'll happen in the future.
The commands will run faster on the iPhone due to the A15 and Nvme storage and wider system cache and that 5 core GPU, remember that the CPU itself has 4 AI accelerators that are there to accelerate such tasks quicker on the A15. However, on the other two, the limitation of the CPU architecture starts kicking in because of the lack of having their own CPU cores and a much more faster Nvme.
And the fact that siri is device based not cloud based, look how slow it was when asking her to Google questions.
Interestingly enough, my Bixby assistant is able to tell me a joke and when I say goodbye, Bixby says something like that, too.
Love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Same
Same same😅
Yeah
Love from 🔺A_A_AKIB 🔺
Great comparison mate!
Wouahhhh 🤔👀🤦🏽Siri 🔥🚀
There was a mistake with your Samsung at the end
Bixby tells jokes and responds if you say bye and also compliments
Wow i am really surprised by Samsung bixby...✌✌✌
Thumbnail is on fire 🔥
@WhatsApp ➕ 1 ②⑤⑥④⑦④③①①⑧ go to hell
Apple have been improving Siri 👏🏻🙏🏻
Have you seen Google duplex?
This is totally new concept 😃❤️
Apple really dominating in most areas with the iPhone 13 series this year!
Samsung still in the top 🔝
@@androidoneiu5206 I’m pretty sure the iPhone outsells the flagship galaxy. Better camera better performance and battery life. iPhone won.
@@RomanM803 Nope, Samsung won in sells, Samsung have better camera and better SO, the same support updates, Apple can’t beat Samsung
@@RomanM803 You only are thinking
@@androidoneiu5206 you must living under a rock the iPhone won all the speed test and camera test and battery test. Watch phone buff. 😂😂😂 Samsung lost
C'mon, Bixby can answer those last questions on my device!
I'm my user experience ( I have both an iPhone 11pro max and a OnePlus 9 pro ) Google Assistent is WAY better than Siri
That is the problem with subjective analysis. Here we have a scientific test that shows Siri is faster by a good margin and as accurate with some good contextual responses. It is clear that accuracy levels are good on all devices but that, as usual, iOS is so much faster with its ML and AI. Hopefully the new 2022 chips will close that speed deficit. Bearing in mind Siri started many years behind Google Assistant it is impressive that it now leads the way.
@@andyH_England yes and no. The point is, how much do you ask to your assistant things, and what do you ask?
As shown in the video siri is fast in turning on and off Bluetooth and stuffs BUT she cannot do things related to what you told her before EG "delete that thing" and since I use that function very often in my everyday life Siri sucks
@@justaguyfromreddit ...I would say that "delete that stuff" has a very specific user case. I do not think I have ever used that instruction! You are right, if that is what you mainly do then Google is better, but for the average consumer who rarely use that, opening apps and turning stuff on are far more relevant and Siri does that with speed and accuracy.
@@andyH_England idk, there are other comparisons where Google annihilated siri. Just depends on the usage I guess
@@justaguyfromreddit Yes for sure.
thanks Nick, i appreciate ur effort
There's something wrong with Pixel 6 pro lol. I tried wrong answer of google on my OnePlus 9 pro and it got that fast and correct. My animation is on 0.5x so a bit cheat but i think google assistant is more reliable than bixby, more or bit less better than siri i think
my assistant on Mi 11t pro ne does Take a screenshots
@@xulqarnaen maybe the tensor chip AI is messing with google assistant
@@johnwick5877 my p6p has no issues with doing things like volume, screenshots, brightness etc
we saw your location on the map. wait for us
Google assistant & Siri have done great so far and continue to do so 🙌🏿
You could literally design the set of question to make either of them win
This was a very interesting video, well done
I experienced both of Siri and Google Assistant, I feel that at term of AI and details in seeking information Siri is a bit behind Google Assistant, even in this video some information or commands are faster on Google Assistant talking about speed I rather say draw, AI Google is à bit better
Thanks for this video man. Keep it up 💪🏻
This was really interesting 🔥🤙