![陳淑樺记忆的门 Sarah Chen Memory Gate](/img/default-banner.jpg)
- Видео 48
- Просмотров 147 991
陳淑樺记忆的门 Sarah Chen Memory Gate
Добавлен 29 мар 2024
Bilingual music and educational channel focusing on the careers and music of Taiwanese singer Sarah Chen (陳淑樺) and her peers Teresa Teng, Julie Sue, Chyi Yu, and Mai Meng. We provide narratives that place their music within a broader societal and cultural context, highlighting the singers' character, determination, and intellectual contributions. We correct the 30-year narrative of male dominance over Sarah Chen's career and counter the unjust societal punishment of independently-minded female artists. All rights to the songs belong to the original rights holders. We follow RUclips's copyright policies and guidelines. The channel does not monetize its content.
致力于台湾歌手陈淑桦及其同行邓丽君、苏芮、齐豫和孟庭苇的双语音乐和教育频道。通过对歌手的叙述,我们将她们的音乐置于社会和文化背景中,突出歌手的品格、毅力和智慧。我们纠正30年来对陈淑桦职业叙述的男性主导偏见,并反击社会对独立自主女人的不公正待遇。所有歌曲的版权归原版权所有者。我们遵循RUclips的版权政策和指南。频道不从内容中盈利。
致力于台湾歌手陈淑桦及其同行邓丽君、苏芮、齐豫和孟庭苇的双语音乐和教育频道。通过对歌手的叙述,我们将她们的音乐置于社会和文化背景中,突出歌手的品格、毅力和智慧。我们纠正30年来对陈淑桦职业叙述的男性主导偏见,并反击社会对独立自主女人的不公正待遇。所有歌曲的版权归原版权所有者。我们遵循RUclips的版权政策和指南。频道不从内容中盈利。
AI驳倒转型论 | 夕阳伴我归 陈淑桦 Sarah Chen | Sunset Follows Me Home 1982 | AI refutes Mandopop Mistake
(Lyrics in CC). 【综述】《夕阳伴我归》是陈淑桦职业的第一个突破,但关于她转型的说法出在好几年后。我们用大型语言模型人工智能分析了陈淑桦的中文歌曲,确定她歌唱转型的时间,是否符合陈淑桦被制作人成功转型成华语天后的说法。惊讶的是,客观数据完全驳斥了转型论,表明她的作品只有逐渐演变而没有突然转型。LLM4将她逐渐演变的开端定在1983-1986EMI期间,而不是后来滚石的时候。这一发现推翻了30多年来对陈淑桦不公的职业叙述。
----------------------------------------------
一个广为接受的陈淑桦职业叙述是“转型理论”,在2003年《给淑桦的一封信》中有总结,认为陈淑桦成功的关键是滚石制作人将她从一个悲情歌手转型为华语流行天后。这个叙述是没有证据的主观看法,但却被广泛接受。对陈淑桦的在线叙述总把男词曲作者和制作人放在首位,她反倒成了一个嗓音好、被转型的歌手。但陈淑桦的作品真的经历了转型吗?如果有,转型与历来认可的1987-1989年相符吗?
在2024年,先进的人工智能,如在ChatGPT 4.0中实施的大型语言模型(LLM4),为转型理论提供了一个客观测试。LLM4在识别类比和分析文本(包括中文)方面非常出色。惊讶的是,它的分析彻底驳斥了转型理论:陈淑桦的音乐只是逐步演变,没有明确的变化点。它识别出的逐步演变开始的时间段是1983-1986年,即陈淑桦在EMI的时期。这一客观的、数据驱动的分析完全推翻了转型理论。数据分析详情在文末。
这一发现提出两个问题。首先,为什么转型理论如此广泛地被接受,尽管它没有证据,只是主观论调?我们...
----------------------------------------------
一个广为接受的陈淑桦职业叙述是“转型理论”,在2003年《给淑桦的一封信》中有总结,认为陈淑桦成功的关键是滚石制作人将她从一个悲情歌手转型为华语流行天后。这个叙述是没有证据的主观看法,但却被广泛接受。对陈淑桦的在线叙述总把男词曲作者和制作人放在首位,她反倒成了一个嗓音好、被转型的歌手。但陈淑桦的作品真的经历了转型吗?如果有,转型与历来认可的1987-1989年相符吗?
在2024年,先进的人工智能,如在ChatGPT 4.0中实施的大型语言模型(LLM4),为转型理论提供了一个客观测试。LLM4在识别类比和分析文本(包括中文)方面非常出色。惊讶的是,它的分析彻底驳斥了转型理论:陈淑桦的音乐只是逐步演变,没有明确的变化点。它识别出的逐步演变开始的时间段是1983-1986年,即陈淑桦在EMI的时期。这一客观的、数据驱动的分析完全推翻了转型理论。数据分析详情在文末。
这一发现提出两个问题。首先,为什么转型理论如此广泛地被接受,尽管它没有证据,只是主观论调?我们...
Просмотров: 116
Видео
Bonus: Similarity between Languages 母语和外语相似性 | On Language and Music with Prof. Hartshorne 语言和音乐
Просмотров 1712 часов назад
(中英文字幕) Bonus Episode of "On Language and Music with Prof. Josh Hartshorne" Playlist: ruclips.net/video/Z_5dKCkHa4c/видео.html Do children learn a foreign language faster than adults, or is it the opposite? Does your first language interfere with learning a second language? This bonus episode delves into the complex relationship between the age of language learning and the similarity between on...
E5: Tips for Adult Language Learners 对成人外语学习的建议 | On Language and Music with Prof. Hartshorne 语言和音乐
Просмотров 1912 часов назад
(中英文字幕) Episode 5 of "On Language and Music with Prof. Josh Hartshorne" Playlist: ruclips.net/video/Z_5dKCkHa4c/видео.html What's the best way for adults to learn a foreign language? Should they even try? Prof. Hartshorne, a multilingual who has learned several languages throughout his life, offers encouraging advice and valuable tips for adult language learners in Episode 5. The conversation i...
E4: Age to Learn Music 音乐学习年龄 | On Language and Music with Prof. Josh Hartshorne 语言和音乐
Просмотров 1912 часов назад
(中英文字幕) Episode 4 of "On Language and Music with Prof. Josh Hartshorne" Playlist: ruclips.net/video/Z_5dKCkHa4c/видео.html How much does age affect music learning? Surprisingly, it’s difficult to find a definitive scientific answer, as music training isn’t universal. Episode 4 explores preliminary data suggesting that early music training is important. Channel Notes: The causality between early...
E3: Cutoff Age for Language 外语学习最晚年龄 | On Language and Music with Prof. Josh Hartshorne 语言和音乐
Просмотров 2212 часов назад
(中英文字幕) Episode 3 of "On Language and Music with Prof. Josh Hartshorne" Playlist: ruclips.net/video/Z_5dKCkHa4c/видео.html At what age is it too late to learn a foreign language? Is there a critical period? If so, what role do motivation and time spent on learning play? Episode 3 explores the explanations and the cutoff age for the critical period of language acquisition. The conversation is di...
E2:Critical Periods 语言关键期 | On Language and Music with Prof. Josh Hartshorne 语言和音乐
Просмотров 1512 часов назад
(中英文字幕) Episode 2 of "On Language and Music with Prof. Josh Hartshorne" Playlist: ruclips.net/video/Z_5dKCkHa4c/видео.html What is the "critical periods hypothesis" in language acquisition? Who proposed it, and who objects to it? Episode 2 explores the history and key concepts behind this hypothesis. The conversation is divided into multiple episodes, following the chronological order of the in...
E1: Is Language Special? 语言特殊吗? | On Language and Music with Prof. Josh Hartshorne 语言和音乐
Просмотров 2612 часов назад
(中英文字幕) Episode 1 of "On Language and Music with Prof. Josh Hartshorne" Playlist: ruclips.net/video/Z_5dKCkHa4c/видео.html When is the best time to learn a second language? Does age affect music learning? We spoke with Prof. Joshua Hartshorne, a world expert on language acquisition, about the latest scientific discoveries. The conversation is divided into multiple episodes, following the chrono...
陈淑桦身为几人 | 靠近我 Sarah Chen | Closer 1988 (歌曲评述) 1-million Sarahs in her English songs
Просмотров 67221 час назад
(歌词在字幕里)【综述】陈淑桦留给她同事的一个谜是:她到底是谁?她的音乐形象经历了如此多的变化,他们疑惑:她认识她自己吗?以她最亲密的歌曲 英文二重唱《Closer》为例,这段视频探讨了陈淑桦在歌中的多元性。在现实生活和工作里,她得很小心。而在音乐改换现实中,她必须,也可以自由地,进入天下 何Sarah的角色。 A puzzle Sarah Chen left for her closest colleagues was: Who is she? Her musical persona underwent such transformations-from an innocent and graceful young woman to an assertive urban woman-that they wondered, "Does she even know herself?"...
陈淑桦人生转折 | 聪明糊涂心 Sarah Chen | Be Wise, Be Easy 1991 (English lyrics) Mandopop Classics
Просмотров 260День назад
(Lyrics in CC). 【综述】陈淑桦的人生和职业在1991年《聪明糊涂心》时发生转折。她身心痛苦中制作的专辑是我们的最爱,其主题-聪明又糊涂-是陈淑桦和郑华娟给大家的人生哲学。 Sarah Chen's life and career made a turn in 1991 with the album 'Be Wise, Be Easy.' The album, produced during her physical and mental anguish, is dearest to us. Its theme- wise yet muddled minds -is life philosophy that Sarah Chen and Chieng Hua-Jiuan shared with us. 1991年的《聪明糊涂心》是陈淑桦职业生涯中的奇迹, 发行于她生命的...
陈淑桦女权磨难 | 她的名字是爱 Sarah Chen | Her Name Is Love 1982 (English lyrics) 1980s Mandopop for women
Просмотров 36221 день назад
(Lyrics in CC). 【综述】陈淑桦对性别平等的倡导给她带来三十年的社会抨击;她的勇气和不屈不挠的立场使她成为我们眼中的英雄。 这个视频是她早期赞扬女人的歌。 陈淑桦1982年专辑《她的名字是爱》的主打歌强调了女人在社会中的重要,她们经历的艰辛,以及她们对家庭和社会的贡献。陈淑桦在职业生涯中是性别平等的倡导者,却因此受到抨击。她退艺三十年后,网络帖子充满了对她人格的谣言和攻击,几乎全部源于她拒绝进入不平等的关系,保持单身。她的前唱片公司2003年的纪录片,意图将她重新吸引回来,却突显了男性主导的不公平。 我们钦佩陈淑桦的固执和勇气,佩服她面对不懈的社会攻击时不屈不挠的立场。这推动了我们所做的一切。陈淑桦的经历反映了独立女性的困境;而她不是唯一一个。但我们相信冥冥中总有人伴随着她:陈淑桦在争取平等的努力中从不孤单。 Sarah Chen's advocacy for gend...
陈淑桦职业谢幕 | 生生世世 Sarah Chen | Everlasting Love 1995 (English lyrics) Mandopop Golden Melody Award
Просмотров 86321 день назад
(Lyrics in CC). 【综述】“生生世世”是陈淑桦深思熟虑后的告别杰作。她将一生奉献给音乐,此时却决定退出。爱和悲伤交织在她歌声中,令人难以释怀。 《生生世世》是陈淑桦倒数第二张专辑中的主打歌,该专辑于1995年底发行。有一种说法是这可能是陈淑桦的最后录音,她1998年的专辑《失落园》在之前已基本完成。这与陈淑桦在1996年春节晚会现场演出中的讲话以及后来小虫与郑怡的谈话一致。 这一时间线表明《生生世世》可能是陈淑桦的告别专辑。经过深思熟虑的计划后,陈淑桦在1996年也许已经退出了音乐界, 有两年的宝贵时间陪伴母亲。而不是因1998年母亲去世而退出。这一更合理的时间线表明,陈淑桦一直完全掌控自己的职业生涯,包括何时以及如何结束。也没有比她选择的离场方式更绝妙:在结束辉煌的职业生涯时,她还赢得“最佳女歌手”奖并制作出她一生中最好的专辑! 在事业巅峰期,陈淑桦本可以继续。然而,...
陈淑桦中期杰作 | 浪迹天涯 Sarah Chen | Wandering the World 1985 (歌曲介绍 English lyrics) Mandopop Classics
Просмотров 1,9 тыс.21 день назад
陈淑桦中期杰作 | 浪迹天涯 Sarah Chen | Wandering the World 1985 (歌曲介绍 English lyrics) Mandopop Classics
陈淑桦神奇作品 | 爱是唯一的理由 Sarah Chen | Love Is The Only Reason 1989 (English lyrics) Surreal Mandopop
Просмотров 90728 дней назад
陈淑桦神奇作品 | 爱是唯一的理由 Sarah Chen | Love Is The Only Reason 1989 (English lyrics) Surreal Mandopop
陈淑桦愤怒英文歌 | 谁甩了谁 Sarah Chen | Who's Leaving Who1988 (歌曲介绍) 短版 Angry Breakup English song
Просмотров 80628 дней назад
陈淑桦愤怒英文歌 | 谁甩了谁 Sarah Chen | Who's Leaving Who1988 (歌曲介绍) 短版 Angry Breakup English song
陈淑桦职业滑坡 | 柔弱女子 Sarah Chen | Strong Woman 1988 (职业评述; English lyrics) Mandopop Historical Mistake
Просмотров 361Месяц назад
陈淑桦职业滑坡 | 柔弱女子 Sarah Chen | Strong Woman 1988 (职业评述; English lyrics) Mandopop Historical Mistake
陈淑桦早期佳作 | 夜语 Sarah Chen | Night Whisper 1980 (English lyrics 歌曲和职业介绍) Early Career Best Ballad
Просмотров 1,7 тыс.Месяц назад
陈淑桦早期佳作 | 夜语 Sarah Chen | Night Whisper 1980 (English lyrics 歌曲和职业介绍) Early Career Best Ballad
陈淑桦心口不一 | 问 Sarah Chen | Questions 1994 (English lyrics) Controversial Mandopop Hit
Просмотров 634Месяц назад
陈淑桦心口不一 | 问 Sarah Chen | Questions 1994 (English lyrics) Controversial Mandopop Hit
陈淑桦哀伤杰作 | 诀 Sarah Chen | Final Good-Bye 1986 (歌曲和职业评述; English lyrics) For Grieving
Просмотров 493Месяц назад
陈淑桦哀伤杰作 | 诀 Sarah Chen | Final Good-Bye 1986 (歌曲和职业评述; English lyrics) For Grieving
邓丽君经典 | 叹十声 Teresa Teng | Ten Sighs (歌曲介绍;English lyrics) Best of Teresa Teng
Просмотров 534Месяц назад
邓丽君经典 | 叹十声 Teresa Teng | Ten Sighs (歌曲介绍;English lyrics) Best of Teresa Teng
陈淑桦古诗经典 | 如梦令 - 谁伴明窗独坐 Sarah Chen | Loneliness 1983 (歌曲介绍; English lyrics) Poetry Music Classics
Просмотров 1,6 тыс.Месяц назад
陈淑桦古诗经典 | 如梦令 - 谁伴明窗独坐 Sarah Chen | Loneliness 1983 (歌曲介绍; English lyrics) Poetry Music Classics
陈淑桦翻唱经典 | 梦里的呼唤 Sarah Chen | A Call in the Dream 1983 (歌曲介绍; English lyrics) Cover Classics
Просмотров 669Месяц назад
陈淑桦翻唱经典 | 梦里的呼唤 Sarah Chen | A Call in the Dream 1983 (歌曲介绍; English lyrics) Cover Classics
陈淑桦怨恨之歌 | 日安忧郁 Sarah Chen | Bonjour, Sadness 1988 CD版 (歌曲介绍; English lyrics) Resentment song
Просмотров 418Месяц назад
陈淑桦怨恨之歌 | 日安忧郁 Sarah Chen | Bonjour, Sadness 1988 CD版 (歌曲介绍; English lyrics) Resentment song
陈淑桦民谣经典 | 相思河畔 Sarah Chen | Lover's Riverside 1977 (歌曲介绍; English lyrics) Mandopop Classics
Просмотров 14 тыс.Месяц назад
陈淑桦民谣经典 | 相思河畔 Sarah Chen | Lover's Riverside 1977 (歌曲介绍; English lyrics) Mandopop Classics
陈淑桦爱台经典 | 你好, 台北 Sarah Chen | Hello, Taipei 1992(歌曲介绍; English lyrics) Buried Treasure with Lo Ta-Yu
Просмотров 597Месяц назад
陈淑桦爱台经典 | 你好, 台北 Sarah Chen | Hello, Taipei 1992(歌曲介绍; English lyrics) Buried Treasure with Lo Ta-Yu
陈淑桦大胆英文歌 | 爱已锁定你 Sarah Chen | Love's Got a Line On You 1983 (歌曲介绍) 1980s English Pop Classics
Просмотров 318Месяц назад
陈淑桦大胆英文歌 | 爱已锁定你 Sarah Chen | Love's Got a Line On You 1983 (歌曲介绍) 1980s English Pop Classics
陈淑桦抒情英文歌 | 大提琴 Sarah Chen | Cello 1988 (歌曲介绍)Best of Chen English Ballad
Просмотров 845Месяц назад
陈淑桦抒情英文歌 | 大提琴 Sarah Chen | Cello 1988 (歌曲介绍)Best of Chen English Ballad
陈淑桦 邓丽君 | 恭喜恭喜 Sarah Chen & Teresa Teng: Congratulations!
Просмотров 1,4 тыс.Месяц назад
陈淑桦 邓丽君 | 恭喜恭喜 Sarah Chen & Teresa Teng: Congratulations!
Fab 5 Age 40 邓丽君 陈淑桦 | 辉煌五星40岁 Teresa Teng,Sarah Chen, Chyi Yu, Julie Sue
Просмотров 426Месяц назад
Fab 5 Age 40 邓丽君 陈淑桦 | 辉煌五星40岁 Teresa Teng,Sarah Chen, Chyi Yu, Julie Sue
Fab 5 Age 35 邓丽君 陈淑桦 | 辉煌五星35岁 Teresa Teng,Sarah Chen, Chyi Yu, Julie Sue
Просмотров 422Месяц назад
Fab 5 Age 35 邓丽君 陈淑桦 | 辉煌五星35岁 Teresa Teng,Sarah Chen, Chyi Yu, Julie Sue
邓丽君 陈淑桦 | 闪舞 FlashDance by Teresa Teng (Live) & Sarah Chen (Mandarin)
Просмотров 2,6 тыс.Месяц назад
邓丽君 陈淑桦 | 闪舞 FlashDance by Teresa Teng (Live) & Sarah Chen (Mandarin)
陳淑樺 一直都是陳淑樺! 有人模仿鄧麗君、蘇芮等等的 就是沒有人有辦法模仿陳淑樺
Thank you for this song and the English lyrics. As a westerner, it is fairly difficult to know what Teresa Teng was singing about. She was a beautiful soul who will live in my heart for the rest of my life.
Thank you for the kind words. This song is particularly challenging to translate because some words in the verse are ambiguous and have historically received vastly different interpretations. But I am confident our translation is the most accurate. We hope to cover more of Teresa Teng's work in the future.
❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉#ให้น้องหมอหลิวคนดีของพี่นะ
印象里,陈淑桦没进滚石以前,台湾歌坛不乏描写女人怨愤的流行歌,但主要集中在闽南语歌曲,或老上海风格的国语歌中。这类歌曲的特征是相当俗气,风尘味特重,不是陈淑桦这类清新取向的歌手敢去碰的。
Do not complaint. Do your best to build a better future for yourself. Your life is your own. Do not seek dead but seek living. You have but one life on this planet. Work double hard. Put more afford in things you do. Productivity not laziness that will be the answer. Slothfulness doesn't bring you out of proverty. Amen
Thank you for sharing your thoughts. For an individual, working hard and helping others is what they can do. But systemic problems often place people in very unfavorable or hopeless situations. Do what we can to help, food, money, kind words, and forgiveness - a little bit can go a long way. Have a nice day.
博主,我跟你说个事,我从你这下载的成年海山歌曲全集里,追云彩和我愿常相守两首歌名要互相换一下,是另外个朋友告诉我的,其实我也没有听过不知道是不是,所以问下你!
Thank you so much for the information. We have added a note about the title mix-up of these songs in the description of the playlist. The playlist acts like a "Table of Content," providing index/pointer to videos maintained by other channels, which we have no control. These two songs are provided by the official Sarah Chen channel; We have not found other copies with the correct titles.
其实我也不确定是不是,所以我才问你,如果是的话,我就改下
@@玉琼邓-x3s Based on what she sang, the titles are reversed. Thanks for your input.
@玉琼邓: Thank you. We hope that our fresh perspective will draw out the cultural, societal, and psychological impact of Sarah Chen’s work. She’s so much more than a singer with good-looks and a good voice.
真心的谢谢你认真细心解析淑桦的歌曲,让更多的人知道淑桦并不只是声音好的原因,更让人爱的是她对音乐的情感表达和热爱!
博主好多宝藏视频啊,支持!!
這一輩子我都感謝,華娟老師與淑樺姐讓我們聽到這麼好的音樂作品
very nice
怀旧经典夜来香,是我喜爱的歌曲之一,非常震撼!陈淑桦歌声清亮相当优美,歌声唱出魅力,唱出我为你思念,令人无限陶醉!
淑桦姐确实是个非常聪明的女人,但人有时难免会糊涂!!
听到淑桦姐的声音真是让人心情愉悦!!
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
優美好聽、🥰🥰🥰👍👍👍👍
@deanlin: Thanks for your kind words. Watching/listening to Sarah's interviews, I actually think she was extremely smart (both IQ and EQ). She was just in a very tough spot, dealing with tricky problems/people, trying to keep her career going without compromising her moral principles. It's a miracle that she lasted so long. Truth and righteousness do eventually prevail, and such is the case for Sarah Chen's career, no matter how misunderstood or wronged she had been.
她是歌壇少有非常單純的歌手,不擅交際但唱功一極棒!希望她一切安好🙏🙏🙏💖!
真心希望她一切安好🙏🙏🙏💖!
. 🌹
淑樺姐的声音真是让人难以忘怀!!
好听,日常想念淑樺姐
敲碗,演唱會🎉
Thank you for your enthusiasm. We take it as support for Sarah rather than pressure. She has our highest respect for her decision to step out of public life. We wish her peace and hope you have a peaceful day as well.
👍👍👍👍👍👍🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
這首真的極少人知道。 只收錄在滾石一張合輯裡面。為了這首歌我買了四張來收藏。
感谢博主,每天都要听淑桦姐的歌,真的是太想念她了
@@玉琼邓-x3s It's great you still have 'new' songs to enjoy. Sarah's work was both high in quality and quantity, a treat for her fans! We discovered why there are more Chen/Xuan/Tan songs than often mentioned: some were originally performed by others like Tracy Huang, but Sarah also sang them. Have a nice day.
谢谢你博主,淑桦姐滚石之前的歌曲也有很多好听的,风格也不一样,唱法也不一样,冒昧问一下博主是中国人吗?
海山时期的“深情依旧”好像也是他们写的,不过网上有些是写 词:小轩,曲:谭健常,有些写作曲为叶佳修,希望您考证一下
@@tedchou8393 Wow, thank you so much! Yes, it was with Xuan/Tan, according to multiple sites and Spotify. I've added it to the list. You are a hero!
@@玉琼邓-x3s I'm your fellow Sarah Chen fan. Cheers!
好歌 耐聽 ! 👍👍👍👍👍👍
哈這首現在聽也很屌
I like both but Teresa Teng sang this song better with a more strong voice.
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
太想念淑樺姐了
You are so kind. Pray for her. Bless you, 玉琼邓.
谢谢你博主,想念淑桦姐
缩短版更好听了,谢谢频道
感恩, 讓我們再聽到 陳淑樺 !❤️❤️❤️
博主请继续多发点淑樺姐的歌,我真的非常爱她
Thank you for your loyalty. There's no better endorsement of a singer's work than from a fan, especially since Sarah Chen has been inactive for nearly 30 years. While we don't have many songs to cover after the initial blitz, our featured podcasts contain five collections of her nearly complete works, sourced from other channels. Please enjoy them. To quote Sarah, "wish you happiness every day" (Chen, 1985) and "bless you" (Chen, 2003).
作词:丁晓雯,作曲:童安格,都是非常专业杰出的,另外丁晓雯为淑桦写的爱的比较深真的很经典!
感谢您视频中的解说,夜语这个歌名让我联想到淑桦小姐聪明糊涂心专辑中的夜游,很好听的歌曲
Thanks! We have ‘Night Stroll’ in our top-10 cold playlist. That 1991 album is like aged wine, the more you listen to the better it gets. The circumstances of its recording may have contributed to its unique feel.
很多年前,我就是這樣失去了母親。這是想像中她留給我的歌。
每天都沉醉于淑桦姐的声音里
非常同意您的见解
Thank you. Times have changed, making some issues more noticeable. Despite this, we have struggled with this song for a long time.
感谢分享!
感谢您的分享,视频简介写的真好
Thank you. I appreciate it.
1:09
진숙화 넘 보고싶어요. -한국에서 진숙화의 오래된 팬-
@manchu-qu9mw Thank you for the comment. Making this video was heart-wrenching because her first sigh, the source of the later ones, resonated deeply. While many good people exist in this world, both men and women, relying on individual kindness is too random. We understand the problems poverty causes, but solutions remain elusive. Nonetheless, kindness, even when directed towards just one person, can make a significant difference.
well composed and delivered nicely. It is a reality of pathetic live of the poor. The rich usually arrogant and exploited the poor. There are of course bastardly heartless men taking advantage of beautiful woman.
聽說這場演唱会原本要連唱10首老歌組曲:但時間太長怕觀眾睡著、祇好濃縮成3首。
好聽。
Just heard Cara's rendition of this song at a coffee shop of a large airport, so exciting! Time does freeze for some things!