Battle of the 5.7 Pistols: Ruger-57 vs PSA 57 Rock

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 11 сен 2022
  • We compare the Ruger-57 pistol with the Palmetto State Armory 57 Rock head to head. While these two looks similar, there are some major difference. Thanks to my Patreon Members for helping with the Ruger and for PSA for supplying the Rock. #PSArock #Ruger57 #57x28
    Big thanks to Fiocchi USA for Supplying our ammunition!
    Robbie Wheaton's RUclips Channel: / robbiewheaton
    Sportsman's Guide $20 off $100 or more purchase using SOOTCH
    USCCA Affiliate Link: uscca.com/Sootch
    Rubber Dummies 10% off "Sootch00" Code. Click Affiliate Link: www.rubberdummies.com/
    Check out Getzone.com for the SootchZone to see exclusive content www.getzone.com/
    Be a Team Sootch Minuteman: / sootch00
    Hit the Like Button & Subscribe for more Fun Gun Reviews.
    Thanks for watching~ Sootch00
    Instagram: Sootch_00
    Music is from Jingle Punks and Epidemic Sounds Royalty Free Music through the Fullscreen Network. Used with permission.
  • СпортСпорт

Комментарии • 1 тыс.

  • @sootch00
    @sootch00  Год назад +240

    ☠ Warning: There is a Giveaway Scam posting in the comments using my thumbnail. I am not on Telegram. I've been blocking and reporting them but it helps when you guys report them too. Thanks.

    • @ArmamentAxes
      @ArmamentAxes Год назад +6

      good review of both!

    • @VonGoth
      @VonGoth Год назад +6

      They keep hitting Honest Outlaw too! Funny how RUclips makes no effort to find these Douchenozzles and prosecute them.... when theyre on Guntuber Channels. Weird, that.

    • @davidpyle7333
      @davidpyle7333 Год назад +5

      Wait, what. I didn’t win ten gazillion dollars ?

    • @randerson4124
      @randerson4124 Год назад +1

      they have been popping up in other youtube channels i follow both large and small using the channels profile pic, all posting links for whatsapp and telegram. the weirdest are the ones that post some random statement about how much money they are making with no context and then are followed by two equally fake accounts thanking them for the info.

    • @arequina
      @arequina Год назад +1

      @@randerson4124 I seen them on the TGC and MAC as well.

  • @jim78
    @jim78 Год назад +465

    5.7 is an amazing cartridge, just need more ammo manufacturers to make cheaper options for the range.

    • @chrisgrace1489
      @chrisgrace1489 Год назад +51

      Supposedly psa is going to start making it

    • @fredeschen3783
      @fredeschen3783 Год назад +32

      And more hot defense loads cheaper.

    • @joaopedrobaggio4475
      @joaopedrobaggio4475 Год назад +9

      Is it true that this caliber can pierce armours?

    • @fredeschen3783
      @fredeschen3783 Год назад +16

      @@joaopedrobaggio4475 yes but only the high power loads. There’s even steel core penatrators.

    • @joaopedrobaggio4475
      @joaopedrobaggio4475 Год назад +4

      @@fredeschen3783 thanks for the information buddy.

  • @Gun_Talk
    @Gun_Talk Год назад +130

    Just ordered a PSA Rock on sale for Christmas. Came with Holosun 407k optic, supressor height sights, threaded barrel and with a sniper green frame all for 600 bucks. So I'm happy with that purchase.

    • @jakenieten
      @jakenieten Год назад +4

      I just ordered the same thing on the same day!

    • @Gun_Talk
      @Gun_Talk Год назад +7

      @Jake Nieten Ayo!! 5.7 bros right here lol 😆

    • @NCFXSTI
      @NCFXSTI Год назад +4

      mine came in Monday. I got the FDE frame , ran 300 rounds through it today - so glad I picked one up - enjoy yours when it arrives !

    • @Gun_Talk
      @Gun_Talk Год назад +4

      @NCFXSTI damn. 300 rounds of 5.7, what a baller G 😅.
      But that's awesome to know that they work. I'm sure to enjoy it. Thanks mate 😀

    • @NCFXSTI
      @NCFXSTI Год назад +3

      @@Gun_Talk if I hadn't ordered another 500 on Tuesday , I may have stopped sooner lol

  • @texas66
    @texas66 Год назад +79

    PSA needs a carbine that uses the same mag as their pistol to keep up with Ruger!

    • @jackjohnson291
      @jackjohnson291 Год назад +4

      I’m sure it’s just a matter of time. They’ll hopefully take what they’re hearing about what people wish Ruger did with theirs and apply it to the PSA offering.

    • @mrarivv0007
      @mrarivv0007 Год назад

      PSA is a retailer not a gun manufacturer. In fact all of their guns are just trademarked clones. Trust me PSA is already winning, that's why they invested into private labeling firearms to compete with the "name brand" firearms. Simple business 101. If you know you know.

    • @brianfischer5609
      @brianfischer5609 Год назад +3

      Technically they do. You can get an AR9 which takes the same Glock mags.

    • @homelessman3483
      @homelessman3483 Год назад +2

      @@brianfischer5609 not in 5.7 though

    • @honkhonk1555
      @honkhonk1555 Год назад

      The problem with the ruger carbine is the barrel is way too long IMHO for the round. The whole point of the 5.7 is it’s great with great velocity out of a short barrel. I’d ruger comes out with one in a shorter barrel, I’d buy it and use it as a cheek pistol.

  • @edwardoalvarez3705
    @edwardoalvarez3705 Год назад +16

    Astronomical demonstration on both gun. Thank you. Greatly appreciated.

  • @ILLUMINATED-1
    @ILLUMINATED-1 Год назад +221

    I got a rock. Runs insanely well and just well built. They’re doing good things.

    • @VonGoth
      @VonGoth Год назад +28

      PSA has become my Second Favorite Gun Manufacturer. They and Taurus are in a Race to see who can get the most Guns into the hands of more new people in the shortest amount of time! Not a bad thing.
      Btw... Just bought a New PSA AR-15 during their Labor Day Sale....

    • @buttpirate57
      @buttpirate57 Год назад +3

      What ammo you running. American eagle seems to choke in mine

    • @ILLUMINATED-1
      @ILLUMINATED-1 Год назад +6

      @@buttpirate57 I’ve run american through it, but mostly FN stuff

    • @hkw8477
      @hkw8477 Год назад +12

      Just picked this up, I also own a FN5.7….I must say that the Rock feels and shoots better.
      Mine has been 100% out of box, tested mostly with federal ammo.
      This might be my new nightstand pistol!

    • @rontronimous
      @rontronimous Год назад +7

      Just got a 20" .308 from them really high quality and a good price. Wish I had known about them when they were selling stuff for $200-350

  • @A1doz
    @A1doz Год назад +50

    The PSA rocks threaded barrel and optics ready slide for the low $599 can’t be beat

    • @mixedmarksman5873
      @mixedmarksman5873 Год назад +1

      got my ruger 57 for $560 plus tax n shipping 🤣👍

    • @jax2158
      @jax2158 Год назад +8

      @@mixedmarksman5873 cool holler when you buy the threaded barrel and optic cut for it and check back

    • @ballinonabudget1130
      @ballinonabudget1130 Год назад

      @@jax2158 and the PSA is better. Size 15 clown shoes

    • @mixedmarksman5873
      @mixedmarksman5873 Год назад

      @@jax2158 ruger comes optic ready and with better sights 🤣👌and seen a threaded barrel for under $200 too actually so I'll take my ruger any day best customer service in the country too👍 nothin against psa though

    • @khysor1832
      @khysor1832 Год назад +3

      They have the Blem for $599 with 10 mags. The optic cut, threaded barrel, and suppressor height sights for $550. Really tempted on their bundle, the rock plus their ar for $850.

  • @TurfSurf
    @TurfSurf Год назад +24

    I like PSA better, it just looks so much cleaner and streamlined.

  • @ChrisG1392
    @ChrisG1392 Год назад +38

    I love how PSA puts a grip pad above the trigger guard where you rest your index finger and thumb. I tried that with some extra Talon grip I had and it feels great.

  • @jeffreylocke8808
    @jeffreylocke8808 Год назад +83

    I think the PSA Rock is a better design with the heavier barrel and much more robust chamber support. I like the look of the Ruger and the hammer fired action.

    • @brianfischer5609
      @brianfischer5609 Год назад +8

      I think the PSA looks better. I don't like the look of the new Ruger pistols. The grip just looks weird.

    • @tomtemple69
      @tomtemple69 8 месяцев назад

      the trigger difference is very small, i'd rather have a more durable barrel, thicker slide, helps reduce recoil slightly and its cheaper
      i love PSA

  • @mikereese15
    @mikereese15 Год назад +17

    One of your best comparison videos in my opinion.

  • @KerryFairbanks
    @KerryFairbanks Год назад +18

    Given me the PSA simply because I hate the trend of large bubble letters on the slide. PSA sleeper with that fluted barrel. Throw on an after market trigger, night sights and call it good. Maybe a light if it's home defense

    • @rhoshod7419
      @rhoshod7419 Год назад +7

      Literally perfect …it’s like they made a 5.7 Glock

  • @randyberetta6277
    @randyberetta6277 Год назад +18

    Absolutely love my 5.7 Ruger.!!!⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

  • @bobbyricigliano2799
    @bobbyricigliano2799 Год назад +27

    I own a Ruger 57 and I like everything about it except the magazines. After about the 10th round, the follower doesn't move freely and the rounds tilt forward and backward. Every magazine (about 10) behaved this way. This results in a lot of cartridge movement, including bullet tips nosediving into the front wall of the magazine. This problem got worse as spring tension increased closer to capacity.
    Normally I would put several hundred rounds through the gun before even contacting the MFG. But the 5.7 rounds are more than $1 each so I sent the mags to Ruger before firing a single shot. They were great about accepting and inspecting the magazines. I believe they replaced the followers and springs, and returned them to me quickly. A++ customer service. But the magazines behaved the same way when I got them back.
    I took the pistol along with a mix of FN blue tip, American Eagle FMJ, and some frangible rounds to the range. Out of about 120 rounds, I had exactly zero malfunctions. I mixed the ammo types, topped some mags off, loaded only a few in others, and the gun cycled perfectly. At 25 yards, it was very easy to keep everything in the 9-10 rings, but the holes were so small that I couldn't tell without retracting the targets back to me. Other than being loud, the pistol has barely any recoil and is a pleasure to shoot. I still don't like the magazines, and I think they could have been designed better, but the pistol is a champ.
    Now if we could get 5.7 ammo prices down a bit.......

    • @bigbinhous
      @bigbinhous Год назад +1

      Did you check your serial number vs the recall? There was a recall with certain serial numbers with issues

    • @jamesw7072
      @jamesw7072 Год назад

      I believe the Ruger 5.7 accepts the magazines from the Rock. You get an additional 3 rounds per mag to I believe.

    • @bobbyricigliano2799
      @bobbyricigliano2799 Год назад +3

      @@bigbinhous Yep, and mine is post-recall. I don’t think the recall had anything to do with the magazines though.

    • @kenhellegers9468
      @kenhellegers9468 Год назад

      my two mags that came with the gun were terrible-would't feed at all near capacity

    • @chelvismelton3570
      @chelvismelton3570 3 месяца назад

      You have to let the slide slam shut.. you can’t show feed it

  • @zendean5207
    @zendean5207 Год назад +2

    You really are the best gun reviewer. So methodical, organized and detailed. No fluff. Great job.

  • @FitzUrse
    @FitzUrse Год назад +56

    For the price and the direct mount optic option, I gotta go with PSA on this one. They also offer threaded barrels, which just adds to the party.

    • @LordFondleballs
      @LordFondleballs Год назад +2

      Ruger does threaded barrels for the 57 as well, I have one. You just have to buy it separate, is all.

    • @menegene4129
      @menegene4129 Год назад +3

      James Reeves (TFB TV) did a video a while ago where he tested .22 suppressors on 5.7 pistols....and it worked.

    • @JohnnyCirucci
      @JohnnyCirucci Год назад +3

      STUPIDEST thing I have ever seen is a BOBBED, SHROWDED HAMMER on a FULL-SIZED SIDEARM and this explains the HELLACIOUSLY bad trigger--it's about as stupid as a cut slide that doesn't correspond to compensator cuts in the barrel (which you wouldn't even need for such a light-recoiling round).

    • @calebnation6155
      @calebnation6155 Год назад +1

      Why would you want a can on a round that is designed to have very high velocity (meaning even with a can it’s very much not hearing safe due to the supersonic crack)

    • @LordFondleballs
      @LordFondleballs Год назад +3

      @@calebnation6155 because any assistance with hearing damage is better than no assistance

  • @timothywaterreus9618
    @timothywaterreus9618 Год назад +6

    Beautiful review, I really enjoyed your comparisons of the two pistols. Great work and a great watch! Thanks sootch!

  • @roggiewonkanobe
    @roggiewonkanobe Год назад +4

    At the time of this post, you had 5.7k likes on your video for the 5.7 round. Great video as well.

  • @jcramer20
    @jcramer20 Год назад +6

    I will stick with the Ruger 5.7 even though it's a little more $$

  • @yamxo17
    @yamxo17 Год назад +12

    Yaaa the PSA rock for sure i love the accuracy and the lighter trigger pull for faster shots.

  • @wpherigo1
    @wpherigo1 Год назад +19

    I’ve been a subscriber of yours for a long time. Consistently excellent videos, content and ideas. Keep up the great work.

    • @geronimo5537
      @geronimo5537 Год назад

      Ive been watching sootch since he first appeared on nutnfancy in like 2011. lol

  • @Jeremysmith747
    @Jeremysmith747 Год назад +8

    Great comparison of two newer 5.7 x 28 pistols !!! Keep up the good work, great video.

  • @bigmoe4712
    @bigmoe4712 Год назад +1

    Another great video brother! I REALLY was looking forward to this comparison and you did an EXCELLENT job as usual.

  • @armsdirectory
    @armsdirectory Год назад +2

    These really look like excellent offerings from both companies! This is a great and very informative review, and I've already sent people here to watch it so they can make an informed decision for themselves. Thanks!

  • @JordanJimmyDavison
    @JordanJimmyDavison Год назад +7

    I like this style of video! Competing firearms head to head!

  • @jboucaud1221
    @jboucaud1221 Год назад +6

    Best 5.7 Rock video I've seen yet. Thanks for this. Was curious about the takedown for it and now I'm clear on exactly how. Can't wait to take it to the range!

    • @jboucaud1221
      @jboucaud1221 Год назад

      Holy 💩 what a great weapon. I'm loving this!

  • @matterickson5993
    @matterickson5993 2 месяца назад +1

    The camera angle at 0:40 really shows the difference in how they eject - the Ruger looks MUCH more consistent than the PSA

  • @noahbrown6706
    @noahbrown6706 Год назад +7

    Can we all acknowledge that the Rock is about as aesthetic as a rock next to the Ruger though

  • @hopewilliams6705
    @hopewilliams6705 Год назад +11

    The PSA rock looks a lot like a Taurus TX22 !

    • @bluepunk182
      @bluepunk182 Год назад +2

      Agreed. And that's a good thing, in my book...

  • @I_am_ENSanity
    @I_am_ENSanity Год назад +39

    Going to be honest, going to get a Rock purely for the price. Especially with how expensive .57 ammo is right now.

    • @natjonestower3035
      @natjonestower3035 Год назад +4

      It's coming down a bit, around .357 price now. Which, by the way, is pretty dang high yet. But the 5.7 has less than half the material cost, not sure how that works out.

    • @osazeaddae3597
      @osazeaddae3597 Год назад

      I went with the Rock, and I really enjoyed it ar the range.. only issue I personally have with the 57 is ammo price and availability of hot ammo

    • @HansBelphegor
      @HansBelphegor 9 месяцев назад +1

      I got 50 defensive rounds for 31$ a box

    • @tomtemple69
      @tomtemple69 8 месяцев назад

      @@natjonestower3035 supply and demand

    • @josecruz021
      @josecruz021 8 месяцев назад

      That's my dilemma rn although i just seem to like the look of the Ruger more bit the price of the psa is half the Ruger price.

  • @Fengshawn86
    @Fengshawn86 Год назад +1

    Awesome video! Thanks for the comparison. I have a Ruger 57, but my first AR is a PSA and I really like what they do, so when I saw them come out with a 57 pistol… I now want one!

  • @JasonLeeDeeCee
    @JasonLeeDeeCee Год назад +2

    Excellent video. Couldn’t have asked for a better comparison.

  • @bobcat409
    @bobcat409 Год назад +5

    Good review from the nicest guy on the internet. The Ruger has more travel in the trigger. That makes the Rock the winner. Great job.

  • @bobailanjian3700
    @bobailanjian3700 Год назад +54

    FN 57 was about $1400, pre Ruger, then dropped to about $1100. With PSA at $500, will be interesting to see where FN and Ruger prices end up. Started to get interested in 5.7 when Ruger dropped the new carbine. Now, even more so knowing the PSA mags will run it. Something to consider if 5.7 ammo continues to drop in price and get improvements through competition between manufacturers.

    • @SticksAndStoners007
      @SticksAndStoners007 Год назад +1

      My Ruger was 500

    • @ianjaskela5877
      @ianjaskela5877 Год назад +6

      Wen how where did u get the ruger for 500?

    • @22addict40
      @22addict40 Год назад

      Federal 5.7 just went up in price from $34 to $40 here in Mississippi

    • @stephonthompson3575
      @stephonthompson3575 Год назад +2

      Only place I seen a Ruger 5.7 for $1100 was a gun show I bought mine for $600 when it first released

    • @3PercentNeanderhal
      @3PercentNeanderhal Год назад +6

      I ran across a Ruger today at academy sports on some sort of sale . It was the display model in fde with the case and 2 magazines. I walked it out the door for $360, I couldn't pass it up. I can't wait to get it to the range. [edit] original price was $799 at an Academy here in Kentucky.

  • @tiamogonzalez3641
    @tiamogonzalez3641 Год назад

    The content is great but the best part is the ending bloopers. You can really see your fun personality come out. Wonderful video. I learned today about the rock because of you. Job well done!

  • @markyoung2981
    @markyoung2981 Год назад +1

    Thank you for your time posting this very helpful information.

  • @VonGoth
    @VonGoth Год назад +33

    Man! That Group you shot with the Rock was a thing of beauty. THAT... is an accurate Pistol, and youve had the Ruger for awhile and have more familiarity with it.
    Id get the 5.7 Rock. Even if I had Ruger Money. That barrel. That Accuracy.. because of that barrel. And the Ruger has too much going on with that safetey and take down. The Rock is just Cleeeeean... PSA knocked it outta the Park! And its Hundreds Cheaper??
    When I go 5.7.... I will Rock 5.7 !

    • @MisterBrewer
      @MisterBrewer Год назад +4

      That's what I was thinking too. I'm a Ruger fan but after watching this I'm leaning more towards The Rock.

  • @larryegilman1
    @larryegilman1 Год назад +6

    Fiber optic is great outdoors, but love the white dot indoors

  • @Swampytheroot
    @Swampytheroot Год назад +2

    Never shot 5.7
    My brother has been sending me videos. Bought the PSA optic ready version, an extra mag deal with ammo they have tonight, and a HoloSun for him. Merry Christmas, my Brother!
    Tonight PSA has 5 mags & 50rds for about a C note if anyone is interested.
    Nice video!

  • @kwamesha3477
    @kwamesha3477 Год назад +2

    Thanks sootch00. I appreciate the details you put into your gun reviews. The PSA is worth a look.

  • @ChrisGovert
    @ChrisGovert Год назад +21

    I want to see a carry version of one of these in 5.7!

    • @IronChefBklyn
      @IronChefBklyn Год назад +11

      The 5" is already debatably too short, any shorter negates the ballistics, the whole point is LOST.

    • @hansgruber9685
      @hansgruber9685 Год назад +7

      @@IronChefBklyn Exactly. These ARE the carry versions.

    • @tomtemple69
      @tomtemple69 8 месяцев назад

      these are the carry version, 5.7 isn't supposed to be shot with something this short, any shorter and you just lose too much velocity which is the biggest strength of the 5.7 round

  • @timshelley8635
    @timshelley8635 Год назад +7

    Great comparison video Sootch! I like both of them. Think I would lean toward the Rock. Am kinda waiting till 5.7 gets a little cheaper and more available.

  • @qx4n9e1xp
    @qx4n9e1xp Год назад +1

    Excellent review! Great camera work & lighting!
    On other tabletop videos, even though they're speaking with lots of useful information, you can barely see the gun due to it being so dark or blurry!
    Good job!
    I might be picking up a Ruger.

  • @66ECHO
    @66ECHO Год назад +1

    Great vid on these 2! Well done.

  • @robertsilveus3071
    @robertsilveus3071 Год назад +3

    Leaning towards the Rock. Awsome round. Ammo price still needs to get lower before I 'pull the trigger'.
    Great video. Love the head to head. Stay safe. GodBless.

  • @Brad-ic4bp
    @Brad-ic4bp Год назад +9

    I had no idea there was a Ruger 5.7 Carbine out there, so thanks for that mention. I recently bought the classic FN Five Seven. I chose it over the Ruger pistol, which is by most standards a much better value, but I'm a 90's gun guy. I'm definitely gonna check out the Ruger carbine though.

    • @DJPitBear
      @DJPitBear Год назад

      THERE is a Company out there that has the AR-15 Covestion Uper in the 5.7 Caliber with a mag " $$$ UNKNOWN "

  • @jacruti
    @jacruti Год назад

    Thank you very much for you time and the all information. Nice and easy for understand.

  • @voteholyk
    @voteholyk Год назад +22

    Good stuff, I was really looking at the Ruger 5.7 a while ago but the price and availability of the ammo made it a no go for me. The ammo is becoming cheaper and easier to find now that more companies are making guns for it so that's good. Stay safe buddy.

    • @FL-Kman
      @FL-Kman Год назад +1

      Go for a FN, you get what you pay for. Rust on my ruger 57 after it sat on my sink as i took a shower a few times.

    • @jackjohnson291
      @jackjohnson291 Год назад +1

      @@FL-Kman But the FN is so FN ugly…

    • @SecondGambit
      @SecondGambit Год назад +2

      @@FL-Kman why would you shower with a 5.7 nearby 😂you don’t have any other HD weapon that won’t go through all 7 nearby walls?

    • @youtubewatcher4792
      @youtubewatcher4792 Год назад

      I always have a firearm within arms reach even while in the shower (ruger under a fresh set of cloths). Even in Texas while I would mow the lawn in the middle of the day I would have a Ruger 57 in a waistband holster (crossbreed). During all that time when it was my go to gun I never had my Ruger 57 rust. It appears Ruger is inconsistent with the quality of their finishes.

    • @FL-Kman
      @FL-Kman Год назад +2

      @@SecondGambit you ever see the 007 films? Seems like every other movie he gets attacked while showering or in the bathroom. I know those are movies but still the threat is there.. I just happened to be ccw the ruger 57 at that time 😂

  • @roymercer441
    @roymercer441 Год назад +4

    I put 200rds through both of them today and I love them both. Off a rest the Ruger slightly nudged the PSA at 50yds both using holosun accs reticles. It was so close it could have just been me. I was shooting reloads, FN ammo.. I have an FN also and it may go on gun broker, the newer 57's are next level.

  • @jerroddooley374
    @jerroddooley374 Год назад +2

    Wouldn't be surprised to see PSA release a 57 carbine soon

  • @julianjmillner810
    @julianjmillner810 Год назад

    Awesome summarization of both! Very well explained. Thank you from me in England..👍

  • @Walkdogable
    @Walkdogable Год назад +25

    I love my Ruger 5.7 and was thinking about getting the PSA, but when Ruger came out with a 5.7 LC Carbine, plans have changed.

    • @__boo
      @__boo Год назад +3

      Its ugly to me. Wish the wouldve seperate the mag well from the grip

    • @davydwalker8554
      @davydwalker8554 Год назад +1

      Rumor has it that Rock magazines work with the Ruger 5.7 LC Carbine.

    • @mobilegamersunite
      @mobilegamersunite Год назад +1

      Rumors are correct 💯 %

    • @BB-1990
      @BB-1990 Год назад +1

      @@__boo Yeah that would have been great, make the gun that much longer. We prefer guns as long as possible when used for home defense.
      What kind of idiot wants a carbine as short as possible.

    • @__boo
      @__boo Год назад +1

      @@BB-1990 Why do you have to result
      to immidiate insults? I have a 10.5 inch AR15 and you can get them even shorter. Even if the mag well is seperate. Its just what I prefer to look at. Theres plenty of home defense options I know I just gave my opinion sheesh

  • @MaximGhost
    @MaximGhost Год назад +4

    I like the thumb safety on the 1911 so it's Ruger-57 for me.

  • @ssoos7701
    @ssoos7701 Год назад +1

    Great comparison Sir, thank you

  • @denisewildfortune4058
    @denisewildfortune4058 Год назад

    Outstanding comparison! Thanks!

  • @BuffRANGE
    @BuffRANGE Год назад +4

    IMO the trigger I like the Rock the best as is from the factory. Then the FN FSN, and then the Ruger. The Ruger's trigger has that mushy DA like pull you show. Aftermarket shoe offerings for the FSN do add some better trigger options for the FSN, but that short reset on the Rock is hard to beat.

  • @christiandoeman4599
    @christiandoeman4599 Год назад +7

    Thank goodness ruger stayed true to themselves by keeping the hammer and that tigger is just nice!😌

    • @wafflestomper5206
      @wafflestomper5206 Год назад +1

      That trigger is trash

    • @PracticalReformation
      @PracticalReformation Год назад +2

      @@wafflestomper5206 the LGS had one, trigger was ok. They also had the FN 5.7 and its trigger was real TRASH. Felt like i was holding a drill.

    • @CL-ty6wp
      @CL-ty6wp Год назад +1

      @@wafflestomper5206 duh ruger is cheap gimmick garbage

  • @bobwampler3387
    @bobwampler3387 Год назад +1

    I really enjoyed this comparison. Well done.

  • @mattc1602
    @mattc1602 Год назад +1

    Great video. Love the info you provided.

  • @jermaineblalock5553
    @jermaineblalock5553 Год назад +14

    The rock has shorter barrel . Looks like it’s better balanced

  • @roberttalbot1658
    @roberttalbot1658 Год назад +4

    I do not like that overly clunky rear sight on the Ruger. A real plus for the PSA is the ability to take a much greater variety of sights, and magazines that won't break your bank account. I definitely plan on getting the PSA.

  • @klinec38
    @klinec38 Год назад +1

    Talk about a timely video. Awesome.

  • @bigbinhous
    @bigbinhous Год назад +1

    Great video as always!

  • @phillhuddleston9445
    @phillhuddleston9445 Год назад +5

    The cutout on the Ruger slide is just a lint trap, for people who plan on actually carrying this every day I would not want a cut out slide. The other thing to consider if you are a hand loader is that this cartridge requires a special coating on the case for it to feed and eject properly (I think more so for ejection purposes) and you have to wash them carefully and inspect the coating or you will get stuck cases, kind of a PITA to reload and expensive to buy all factory loads so this is a huge negative for any gun chambered in this round, that was the deal breaker for me.

    • @davidgoodnow269
      @davidgoodnow269 Год назад

      Not to mention the staked primers to handle the high pressure! Common in military ammunition for a century, you simply _cannot_ stake primers in reloaded cases. This is why the best handloads for 5.7 FN start with pulling the bullet from American Eagle budget factory loads, and replacing the powder.
      Actual military 5.7 FN is loaded optimized for a 10.5" barrel with an armor-piercing bullet--originally, a plastic-cored 28-grain with a copper-over-steel design getting 2,800 fps--designed to shoot flat and accurately, penetrate body armor or a helmet, and then dump all its energy quickly to maximize shock. Also, the low sectional density was advertised as reducing risk from stay bullets in an urban environment. Kills with body shots out to 200 meters, head shots through steel or kevlar helmets out to 300 meters, with the accuracy to do that; drops to the ground completely spent at 600 yards instead of (potentially) miles.
      Commercial civilian-sale 5.7 FN ammo is jinxed, since it cannot over-pressure the direct-blowback carbine action despite having an extra eleven inches of barrel to burn powder in versus the five-inch pistols; the pistols have to work with ammo loaded with gunpowder with a burn-rate suitable to a carbine!
      Get a heavier recoil-spring and some _very_ fast-burning powder, load with rifle bullets designed for .223 varminting (expands and mushrooms, rather than fragmenting, at the lower pistol velocity, where a 45-grain varmint bullet designed for .22 Bee or Hornet is likely to come fragment--same 2200-2400 velocity range), or make your own bullets with a swage for your loading press and some .22 LR cases.

    • @therealwewin
      @therealwewin Год назад

      Lint trap lol

  • @Sosa30032
    @Sosa30032 Год назад +5

    If you do just a bit of legwork, ammo prices arent that bad. In 10 mins, I found multiple sites selling 5.7 for 60 cents/rd

  • @bobou812
    @bobou812 Год назад

    Awesome video... been brainstorming on purchasing a 5.7...
    This video gave us great information.

  • @jays9211
    @jays9211 Год назад +1

    Nice video. I never heard of this caliber until ur video

  • @kevinkelley5438
    @kevinkelley5438 Год назад +3

    The Rock reminds me more of a Taurus TX22 in looks than the PSA Dagger.

  • @Davoodoo69
    @Davoodoo69 Год назад +4

    I just bought the PSA in a combo deal from PSA ! I got the threaded barrel option & can't wait to suppress her. Glad I waited & didn't get the Ruger even though that's a nice pew pew as well 😊

    • @raulsanchez3670
      @raulsanchez3670 3 месяца назад

      Does supressor need a booster for 5.7?

  • @lazygamer9725
    @lazygamer9725 Год назад +2

    Psastepping up to the plate I love my tricked out dagger my gf3 and all my ar parts I've bought from them over the years... now just need the akv the micro dagger and the rock

  • @ritcheymt
    @ritcheymt Год назад +1

    Great review. Thanks!

  • @scottlawson9206
    @scottlawson9206 Год назад +9

    VERY nice comparison between the two pistols! Honestly it's worth getting both (although, I'm a bit perplexed why you didn't opt for the PSA version with the slide optics cut). For those considering attaching a suppressor, the PSA is available with the slide already cut for optics (it comes with two adapter plates for different footprints, the slide is cut for direct-mounting of Shield RMS/SMS footprint plus it comes with a blank-off plate) and a threaded barrel. At the time of this comment Ruger doesn't offer the pistol with a threaded barrel already installed but they do offer a threaded barrel on their website. Note: the threaded PSA barrel is 1/2x28 while the thinner Ruger barrel is threaded M10x1 and comes with an adapter for 1/2x28.
    There are a couple of suppressors which are specifically designed for the FN Five Seven pistol which also uses the M10x1 thread, so it's possible to purchase a suppressor in that thread without any additional adapters. Oh, and the striker-fired system has been proven well over 40 years- Heinrich Ortgies introduced a pistol in three different calibers around 1920, and the Baby Browning soon followed it (also striker-fired), among many others. Despite what many believe, Glock didn't come up with the idea (nor are they the first to use polymer frames- that milestone goes to HK).

  • @selfentertained1932
    @selfentertained1932 Год назад +10

    Great video! One thing I'd add about the price of the ruger is that you can also buy the LC carbine so you have a matching carbine for your pistol which makes the ruger a little more versatile imo and worth the extra cost.

  • @timsmith9645
    @timsmith9645 Год назад +1

    Really nice gun's there sootch00 thanks for sharing

  • @billmoyer3254
    @billmoyer3254 Год назад

    best gun reviews on RUclips! Thank you!

  • @cardboardkiller6883
    @cardboardkiller6883 Год назад +3

    The large flat recoil spring mitigates the recoil more than the fluted barrel does. Together, it makes it shoot a little softer than the Ruger.
    I have the Ruger and can't wait to get the Rock!

    • @salinsoulok3338
      @salinsoulok3338 5 месяцев назад

      I’m thinking about the rock to see what I like more but I feel like one would be home defense and the other a carry

  • @Turbogto_guy
    @Turbogto_guy Год назад +6

    If you shorten the follower in the ruger it will hold 23 rounds also. The tab on the follower is very long.

  • @mrf5347
    @mrf5347 Год назад +1

    Sweet tools!
    Great comparison, Thanks

  • @asdfasdf7199
    @asdfasdf7199 Год назад

    picked up my ruger last year and finally picked up decently priced ammo this year hehe, love it

  • @WildEvents522
    @WildEvents522 Год назад +4

    5. 7 PISTOLS... WOW!"SUPER SUPER AWESOME VIDEO!!! 🔥I love the way you put it together!! I think this is one of the best ones yet !! ❤ Looking forward to your next one! It's awesome!!

    • @sootch00
      @sootch00  Год назад +1

      Thanks for stopping by!

  • @wc7102
    @wc7102 Год назад +3

    I purchased the Rock frame separate from the optics ready slide and threaded barrel with 1 mag for $470. Ammo at .70 a round without additional shipping. While I am a Ruger fan, that deal is hard to beat. Whatever way you go, they are great pistols and the more people that get into 5.7, cheaper prices will get on ammo. Great review btw

    • @tomtemple69
      @tomtemple69 8 месяцев назад

      just got 5.7 last week for $0.47 for plain fmj 40 gr fiocchi 1700fps after shipping and tax, hopefully by next year, itll be closer to 30 cents a piece

  • @kjw882
    @kjw882 Год назад

    I didn't even know PSA had a 5.7 pistol until coming across this video. Learn something new everyday. I have a Ruger 57 and I like it a lot. It's a fun shooter.

  • @MeatShank
    @MeatShank Год назад +1

    Can't wait for the Hi Point 5.7×28!!!

  • @madacro5671
    @madacro5671 Год назад +3

    Tough choice, like both looks! Probably PSA though. I have a dagger and love the grip!

  • @timb8970
    @timb8970 Год назад +48

    Until the prices drop substantially on 5.7 ammo, it’s a pass for me. Just doesn’t have that much of an advantage over the 9mm to justify such a steep price. You literally find 5.56mm ammo for cheaper!

    • @swattimmy
      @swattimmy Год назад +10

      youve obviously never shot one or seen ballistics.

    • @digduck9463
      @digduck9463 Год назад +1

      indeed muh brudda

    • @hxgzeitg7985
      @hxgzeitg7985 Год назад +8

      50 cents a round brotha, same as 5.56

    • @catfishman1768
      @catfishman1768 Год назад +1

      @@swattimmy I can read

    • @KingCobra_45
      @KingCobra_45 Год назад +6

      Yep, I don't have the need to put a gun on the shelf due to no ammo. So it remains 45 acp & 9mm for me.

  • @raywilliams3530
    @raywilliams3530 2 месяца назад

    This comparison review is stellar!

  • @ray.d.oeaux1230
    @ray.d.oeaux1230 Год назад +1

    Great review.

  • @joshuar4470
    @joshuar4470 Год назад +9

    I’ve been looking at getting a Ruger 57 for awhile but the price and the availability of the ammo has kept me from getting it. Now with the Carbine being released, it’s become more intriguing

    • @brandtwebber5761
      @brandtwebber5761 Год назад

      A carbine, damn ruger just trying to break me. The did a good job with the 10/22 takedown.

    • @Truthloveliberty
      @Truthloveliberty Год назад

      Dont waste your money on the ruger. Trash

    • @brandtwebber5761
      @brandtwebber5761 Год назад

      @@Truthloveliberty the 10/22 got me already but I like them

  • @deet_boii
    @deet_boii Год назад +4

    Makes me want a 5.7 🤣 great video

  • @keyantwilliams
    @keyantwilliams 17 дней назад

    Great video as always. Thank you.

  • @williamplatt6859
    @williamplatt6859 9 месяцев назад

    Just bought a PSA Rock blem based upon your thorough review. Can't wait until range time!

  • @robertsimmons1653
    @robertsimmons1653 Год назад +11

    Either of these would make excellent home defense handguns.

  • @timtimtimmay4654
    @timtimtimmay4654 Год назад +5

    The PSA at the price during Christmas by buying the slide, mags, and frame separately along with the quality for what you get sold me on it. You get out the door with a threaded barrel, two mags and night sights for under $450 after shipping and taxes. It was just too good of a deal for me to pass up knowing I would get more interest in this round after having a blast with the .22 TCM.

    • @betweenthebars19
      @betweenthebars19 Год назад

      I bought my 5.7 for $525 after taxes and shipping but it came with 10 mags. Then the Xmas sale happened and I wanted to kick myself. I don’t think I need 10 mags but you know what, I got them!

    • @timtimtimmay4654
      @timtimtimmay4654 Год назад

      @@betweenthebars19 That was still a great deal. Not sure I'd need that many mags, either. At least you got the box, too. Mine came in cardboard.

  • @gregmcmurray9593
    @gregmcmurray9593 Год назад +1

    Excellent video with the comparison. I just bought the PSA on a early Black Friday special today. Threaded barrel, complete with Holosun HS407K-2, 2 magazines, range bad with free shipping for $599. Thats a smoking deal considering the Holosun is $230.😁

  • @Monkeydad1969
    @Monkeydad1969 5 месяцев назад

    I'm a little late to the show on this review, but I really appreciate your work. I've been looking at the Rock, and I think that will be my first 5.7. There are a lot of reviews and PSA seems to be holding their own. Thanks.

  • @CalvinJ82
    @CalvinJ82 Год назад +3

    Great comparisons. I want the precision, larger ammo capacity and better recoil of the PSA, but no thumb safety makes it a deal breaker for me. With my kids still at home, I like a visible thumb safety for peace of mind. Thanks for the detailed comparison, much appreciated. 17.99 a box would be awesome!!

    • @Akaban_94
      @Akaban_94 11 месяцев назад +2

      Keeping your gun in a holster when not in use and out of reach of your children is the best safety.

    • @aw4786
      @aw4786 8 месяцев назад

      If you’re relying on safety to keep your kid from doing something stupid you are too dumb to own a firearm.

  • @nicojuro
    @nicojuro Год назад +4

    I'd go with the rock over the FN and the Ruger specifically because they give you threaded barrel and rail options without an extra hundred bucks, when the gun is already at a base discount comparatively. If the Rock is anything like my Dagger, its solid design and build.

    • @Peakfreud
      @Peakfreud 8 месяцев назад

      Check out the S & W 5.7

  • @mikefromwv1010
    @mikefromwv1010 Год назад

    Thanks for the video

  • @troy9er
    @troy9er Год назад +2

    Looks like a winner!!! 😉 PSA all the way!!!

  • @ozrodmd
    @ozrodmd Год назад +3

    Just found the Ruger for $499 and at that price plus I like the looks of the Ruger, would go Ruger but both are good.

    • @cryengine_x
      @cryengine_x Год назад +1

      new? where'd you find it? And I agree the Ruger looks better. Call me shallow but that's a factor for me. Plus it seems more reliable than the PSA. Plus the optics cut PSA is the same price as the ruger anyway which is always optics cut. 23 round mag is nice for PSA though.

    • @rickgalla3377
      @rickgalla3377 Год назад

      I have the ruger over 1 yr, great flat shooter, 100% reliability, but need ammo prices to come down