Jewish Chaplain Explains Need for Religious Beard Exemptions in Military

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 окт 2024
  • Rabbi Jacob Goldstein is the longest serving Jewish chaplain in the military -- and he wore a beard every step of the way. To learn more about how his situation applied to Sikhs, watch this video:
    Click on the link to subscribe to our videos: bit.ly/2iBn8Wv

Комментарии • 61

  • @ba9737
    @ba9737 4 года назад +19

    Jews Sikhs
    Beards🤜🏻🤛🏽

  • @Eris_Strife
    @Eris_Strife Год назад +2

    I retired in 2011. I was an ETC (SW/CC) in the Navy. I am also a Jew with Israeli heritage. The biggest problem I had with the military was shaving. Shaving every day gave me very bad razor bumps and ingrown hairs, mostly on my neck similar to a lot of my African American shipmates but it took years and a copious amount of pain before I could convince medical to give me a no shave chit waiver. Even when I had it I was still required to shave every 3 days and for inspections. I most definitely grew a beard and have had once since retirement. My wife loves it and says it suits me and she always thought I would l would look better with one.

  • @anzolaigor
    @anzolaigor 6 лет назад +17

    Our Creator made us this way. How men dare to oppose Him ?

    • @joeygibbs4775
      @joeygibbs4775 4 года назад

      Jesus loves you trust and repent in him and you will be saved !

    • @Wheyooo
      @Wheyooo 3 года назад +2

      @@joeygibbs4775 yeshua is yoshua in english, jesus is not his name. early bibles even write Iesus first because the j did not even exist and *sus came from greek and roman gods like sus/zeus for example

  • @RiverRockRecords
    @RiverRockRecords 5 месяцев назад +2

    I'm a Pagan.. and I'm trying to get Accommodations for my Religious belief's .. i cannot loose my faith. i need my hair so the gods know i am able to love and protect..
    So i feel my courage.. so i feel the connection to my gods.. I'm genuinely scared because they may try to cut my hair and if they do that.. i might as well be dead.
    It is ME.. and i cannot see why they would treat my religious belief's as a "Maybe" when women can just do it. It's my right as a Pagan to worship my gods.
    If anyone can help me.. please.. please help me stay true to my belief's.

  • @johnrodriguez3870
    @johnrodriguez3870 2 года назад +1

    Colonel ( Rabbi) Jacob Goldstein, U.S. Army Jewish Chaplain: Thank You for Your Military Service to GOD and Country as an Orthodox Jewish Rabbi, and, an Officer and a Gentleman, Sir. Shalom Aleichem, from this Prior Service USMC and US Army Enlisted Man. 🇺🇸🦅🗽📜🇮🇱🕍✡️🕎🛡️🗡️

    • @bigdog4166
      @bigdog4166 Год назад

      Thank you for your service 🇺🇲

  • @july1962
    @july1962 7 лет назад +15

    It shouldn't be an "exemption" either. There should be no rules about beards period. What a person grows on their face has nothing to do with being in the military. It's just a way for the military to control people.

    • @haseebahmed9664
      @haseebahmed9664 7 лет назад

      I myself want to join army and keep beard but they argue that soldiers and officers can't have beards because enemy might hold their beard in man to man battle or it is hard to wear gas mask as seen in ww1 and hard to wear oxygen mask in aircraft

    • @TheSealOfTheRose
      @TheSealOfTheRose 6 лет назад +1

      The Navy are allowed beards though.

    • @SupremeBapeTV
      @SupremeBapeTV 6 лет назад +1

      Haseeb Ahmed you can get a shaving waver if you get razor bumps

    • @josephasbury8738
      @josephasbury8738 5 лет назад +1

      Why wouldnt they? They're job is to keep our people safe and a beard like the one he's wearing would provide a handhold in combat, make first aid more difficult, trap possibly lifesaving food/water in an emergency, and provide a surface for chemical agents to get trapped near his face. I am in favor in allowing beards that are neatly kept and no longer than a 1/4 inch, but they're are absolutely downsides to longer ones

    • @TheSealOfTheRose
      @TheSealOfTheRose 4 года назад

      I’m not sure what you mean by how so they just are.

  • @jazsm5385
    @jazsm5385 4 года назад +3

    There is literally an entire regiment back in India that has all bearded men, it's called the Sikh Regiment and it is pretty tough to mess with those men I'm not exaggerating those guys have received hell lot of decorations

    • @harmanjotsingh4230
      @harmanjotsingh4230 4 года назад

      Yeh it's due to the religious obligation to not alter any hair from the body.

  • @iljay7669
    @iljay7669 6 лет назад +7

    I salute this dude - same should be the case of long hair for men in the army

    • @superniger4822
      @superniger4822 3 года назад +1

      I hope you never serve.

    • @mynameis......23
      @mynameis......23 3 года назад

      @@superniger4822 I hope God remove the stupidness from you

  • @ohiofisherofmen2194
    @ohiofisherofmen2194 4 года назад +7

    I am in the navy I am a Christian but I believe we should have beards as part of my beliefs and the navy wont let me😡
    Edit;
    Also the nazis kept people from growing beards there I said it!

    • @libertyordeath9936
      @libertyordeath9936 4 года назад

      There’s no religious requirement of Christian to have beards. You can have one if you’re a sikh, a pagan, a Muslim, or if you say that razors irritate your face.

    • @ohiofisherofmen2194
      @ohiofisherofmen2194 4 года назад

      @@libertyordeath9936 there isn't in norse either yet I guy was able to for it that being said shaving irritated my face so I could have

    • @ohiofisherofmen2194
      @ohiofisherofmen2194 4 года назад +1

      @@libertyordeath9936 you do know there are verses in the bible that mention keeping beards right. I'd say not

    • @libertyordeath9936
      @libertyordeath9936 4 года назад

      Alabama Fisher Of men there’s not a religious requirement for Christians to keep beards. Anyway, if you were that devout that you wanted to keep a beard, surely you wouldn’t lie and break the commandment not to lie, as that’s a worse sin than not having a beard.

    • @joshuabeaumont1219
      @joshuabeaumont1219 3 года назад +1

      @@libertyordeath9936 There are very few "religious requirements" in Christianity, but that doesn't mean we don't have spiritual practices we should be allowed to indulge in. As a Jewish Christian, I should be allowed to grow a beard, but so long as people hold to the ignorant view that you have expressed, I will keep on having to suppress my religious expression, simply because "there is no requirement"

  • @MondoBeno
    @MondoBeno 4 года назад +3

    Having beards didn't stop the Sikh troops from slaughtering Pakistan's forces in 1973.

    • @eliyahuohiyon7461
      @eliyahuohiyon7461 4 года назад

      Or from fighting in the somme in ww1

    • @TheSealOfTheRose
      @TheSealOfTheRose 4 года назад +1

      Sikh soldiers have special permission

    • @harmanjotsingh4230
      @harmanjotsingh4230 4 года назад

      You mean 1971?
      If so didnt the bulk of the army surrender without combat due to lack of ammunition?

  • @tedmitten8832
    @tedmitten8832 4 года назад +5

    Religious exemptions are stupid. If you can make exemptions for some, then the stipulation isn't mandatory for all

    • @mynameis......23
      @mynameis......23 3 года назад +1

      For you every religious thing is stupid. Why? Why not religious people have their own rights?

    • @tedmitten8832
      @tedmitten8832 3 года назад +2

      @@mynameis......23 of course, but if military makes exemptions based on your faith, then the stipulation doesn't need to be there in the first place

  • @MondoBeno
    @MondoBeno 4 года назад +1

    I don't see how the troops could've kept themselves clean shaven before the safety razor was invented. Shaving with a straight razor takes longer.

  • @British_loyalist
    @British_loyalist Год назад

    I am orthodox Jew. I wouldn’t mind trimming my beard with a trimmer

  • @harmanjotsingh4230
    @harmanjotsingh4230 4 года назад +2

    What if we tie our beards like in the Indian army (Sikh regime t)?

  • @irishtino1595
    @irishtino1595 5 лет назад +4

    This is a moot argument. American Jews are not joining the military for a variety of reasons. Two of my neighbors joined the IDF instead of the American military.

    • @crimsonseraph3543
      @crimsonseraph3543 4 года назад +1

      Irish Tino they are the same thing, and as we should. We fight for Israel

    • @chaimlevin125
      @chaimlevin125 2 года назад

      TOTALLY UNTRUE! I’M AN ORTHODOX JEW FROM NYC AND I WOULD REALLY LIKE TO JOIN THE US MILITARY IT’S JUST VERY HARD TO KEEP ORTHODOX JUDAISM IN THE MILITARY. I’M STILL LOOKING INTO IT

  • @ellenbalgley9985
    @ellenbalgley9985 4 года назад

    Can somebody keep Kosher in the military easily

    • @eliyahuohiyon7461
      @eliyahuohiyon7461 4 года назад

      Yes

    • @joeygibbs4775
      @joeygibbs4775 4 года назад +1

      Jesus loves you trust and repent in him and you will be saved !

    • @JudeanLibertarian
      @JudeanLibertarian 3 года назад

      While stationed anywhere in Europe or stateside it’s not too difficult. Deployments are a lot harder if not impossible. You could eat Kosher MREs everyday but they’re actually bad for you if you don’t break that up with real food. The chow halls aren’t kosher and serve pork in the same trays / kitchens. It’s possible but would be a very strenuous time. Speaking from experience.

  • @jazsm5385
    @jazsm5385 4 года назад +1

    O7!

  • @dhiggins5744
    @dhiggins5744 4 года назад

    Beards and long hair can be detrimental in combat situations - they can be grabbed - better off to have it shaved off for military service

  • @MFUNK-xp9um
    @MFUNK-xp9um 5 лет назад +3

    I love beards and everything but you cant properly wear a gas mask with a beard and long hair. Thats why the militaries of the world clean shave and cut hair short. Perhaps with advancements in gas mask technology it will allow for long hair and beards.

    • @frankcastle5285
      @frankcastle5285 5 лет назад +7

      That’s a lie I got a beard waiver the mask fit just fine

    • @ohiofisherofmen2194
      @ohiofisherofmen2194 4 года назад +3

      You do realize other militaries allow beards right

    • @danielaramburo7648
      @danielaramburo7648 4 года назад +1

      If you get exposed to nerves gas, you are dead anyway, mask or not.

    • @joshuabeaumont1219
      @joshuabeaumont1219 3 года назад +3

      1975 called, they want their dumb argument back