Why is Monorail a Failed Project in India
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 сен 2024
- #ad #monorail #powertrain
Toh Banayein ye Diwali Kamyabi wali 🪔 with KukuFM -
Download link - kukufm.sng.lin...
(Buy annual subscription now and get a chance to win a car 🚘, goldcoins 🟡 and 10L worth of gifts 🎁along with 50% off on yearly subscription i.e. Rs 199 only)
Coupon code - DIWALI50
Limited period offer ⏳till 25th October only
T&C applied and not applicable for residents of TN and Pondicherry users*
MMRDA Mumbai Monorail is a monorail system in the city of Mumbai, Maharashtra, India, built as part of a major expansion of public transport in the city. The project was implemented and is currently operated by the Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority (MMRDA). It is the first monorail in India since the Kundala Valley Railway and Patiala State Monorail Trainways were closed in the 1920s.[4][5] The system started commercial operation after partially opening its Phase 1 to the public in 2014.Monorail is running in 2 routes in Mumbai. Its cost of construction is lower than that of an elevated metro line but few companies in the world have this technology. That together with political uncertainty in 2015-18 period caused Chennai to give up (only one party took part in the bid as per reports) on this otherwise by now in two routes, this service would have been available by now
_____________________________________________________________________
INTRO MUSIC IF PRESENT - LEMMiNO - A THOUSAND YEARS
• LEMMiNO - A Thousand W...
CC BY-SA 4.0
_____________________________________________________________________
Copyright Related Issue Please Contact
aakashbhavsar88059@gmail.com
OR
DM on Twitter - / powertrain_yt
_____________________________________________________________________
INSTAGRAM- / aakash_rb
TWITTER- / powertrain_yt
Toh Banayein ye Diwali Kamyabi wali 🪔 with KukuFM -
Download link - kukufm.sng.link/Apksi/4ugo/zzk4
(Buy annual subscription now and get a chance to win a car 🚘, goldcoins 🟡 and 10L worth of gifts 🎁along with 50% off on yearly subscription i.e. Rs 199 only)
Coupon code - DIWALI50
Limited period offer ⏳till 25th October only
T&C applied and not applicable for residents of TN and Pondicherry users*
I think the new Mumbai Metro is also failing because of many reasons such as the locations for the stations is areorly planned and Hardly 2-10 commuters per train being seen. Can u make a video on it as well
Bullet trains will also end up like the monorail in india
Mono rail is not a failure in Mumbai. Now it's frequency is about 22 to 30 minutes. This is too much slow as per Mumbai standards. If it can be brought down to 3 to 6 minutes it will attract more travelers.
It is a shame to see authorities are irresponsible in this matter.
Introducing ifs and buts implies that Mumbai Monorail is a faiure
@@Abhi-nb1xo exactly. I mean that will require almost 3-4x the no of coaches that is too much of an investment not to mention this is non-standardized rail lines and coaches that requires special maintenance staff, special training for such a small subsection of trains, entire staff that is trained with this system needs to be on duty, all in all drawbacks are just too much. Normal standard guaze and broad guaze is much much better
Its constructed on route barely used😑
Also it doesn't connect Chembur Station to mahalaxmi Station... Its about a km away from both these stations.
accept it: dilli metro is by far the best metro & will remain that way till eternity.
few factors that r important for metro success:
* mid income working population size (shopkeepers generally live in shops or at walking distance, rich dont use public transport, poor people avoid hi tech things like metros, they live at walking distance or use traditional buses & tempos)
* visitor population size (official work, job search, sex work, tourism, shopping, business shopping)
* urban planning of existing city, poor plan affects all add up projects, dilli was well designed by edward lutyens...
* correct time of implementing, too late for all cities, bcoz all people hav buyed homes & vehicles already as per needs when even metro plan was not there plus, urban plans were simply made without metro in thought, now the current plans r totally incompatible with metro plans...
* size of urban sprawl, all cities r small compared to dilli-NCR, mumbai mmr is half the size of NCR core...NCR core population is 3 crore plus & daily outside visitors r in 2-3 million range...daily inner movement is above 10 million...which allows metro to share about 2-3 million passengers daily to keep head above break even point...
* necessary evil factor, dilli ncr will just collapse without rapid transit system, so dilli metro will b kept alive & gud no matter what r the losses & headache involved...
no one can handle 10 million vehicles on roads, 10 million plus inner movement, 3 million outside movemnt, VVIP traffic, foreign traffic...all at once and on daily basis...
Monorails are not successful even in Rollercoaster Tycoon games.. 🤣🤣
Old memories I played roller coaster tycoon games in 2016
But I make it successful in cities Skyline
Finnally someone plays games on a real computer not those tiny-miny handy ones
Lol 😂😂
Lmai
Mumbai monorail would have been successful if it would have connected with Ghatkopar railway station. In that case Ghatkopar railway station could become a big transit hub between local train, metro and mono
no station in vashi naka and shankar deol . frequency is 15 minutes
no connection to kurla or ghatkoper.
this is reason of failure.
Yes if it had connected chembur with Ghatkopar then it would have been super easy for someone from harbour to go to western
Thanks to Japan, Delhi Metro is simply the BEST public transport project in India currently.
@Krishna bro just check the delhi metro connectivity
Nope bro you can say it is best metro in India some tier 2 or 3 cities doesn't have metro but their bus transport is very good
Lol . Odisha public buses connectivity is top notch . They even got awarded this year in entire Asia .
@@debaprasad9379 bro have you ever been into delhi metro
@@harshsharmaw yup . I have travelled in Delhi metro twice . I went to Delhi in 2017 🙂
In Mumbai Mono Rail roots, there are many Stations located in non residential areas like Pratikshanagar and Wadala free way, most stations are located in isolated areas, Monorails are not failure, there plannings are
Bhai uska munafa Nahi horaha uske tyr BHI mahnge h
@@Technicalmaan jaha logo ko jarurat hi nahi hai waha mono rail banane ka kya fayda ? chembur to ghatkopar usako connection hi nahi hai.
Thankfully, Ecosystem of metro construction established in our country now...
It will be easy to construct more metros than any other light system
Monorails are perfect to connect Airport to main metro system or like in any entertainment zone or in any Business district because it's looks cool
i would really like if Jewar / NOIDA international airport have monorail to connect it to Main metro of Noida but i think the metro tender already floated on that section :(
Why bother with it
When you can get regular high capacity metro
@@KanishQQuotes well yeah !! i know but it looks fancier than conventional metro
@@Ishantyagiofficial
Tell me you're a mall rat, without telling me you're a mall rat
@@KanishQQuotes i only go for malls for only Pictures, Food court and if i had some little extra money i only purchase from fast fashion brands like Zara and H&M
i always buy clothes from local market
and i dont wanna spend my parent money on my fanciness
@@Ishantyagiofficial
Transportation system is form over function. No point in building it if after spending crores it fails to serve the main purpose, transporting people.
Especially in India where we have massive crowds, a high capacity metro makes more sense compared to a weak monorail.
Sydney removed their monorail after 30 years because of crowds and low capacity.
Monorail have only seen success in cities where the topography is mountainous, making regular railway tricky to build with the gradient and space constrains.
The 1st Monorail of India was proposed to be built in Kolkata.
1st corridor:- BUDGE BUDGE - TARATALA.
2nd corridor:- RUBY - RAJARHAT.
Ist monorail was in patiala Punjab.
@@paritoshdaurwal9484 bro you are somewhat wrong.... Kolkata monorail (modern monorail) was proposed in 2004...
@@chaitalisaha2263 it was thr in British era
@@paritoshdaurwal9484 no not that, what he means is modern monorail. Not that steam wheel supported one.
Metro System is more faster then Monorail. Especially if we consider Ruby-Rajarhat route.
That's why government of West Bengal gave more importance to the elevated metro lines.
But Mono rail will be effective in old city. Like Taratala and other congested routes where metro bridges are hard to build due to lack of Space.
I travelled in Mumbai monorail few months ago
It was really good experience
because barely any one uses it 😅
@@SshivamKhopkar it's not that empty
All seats were occupied so i had to stand 😅
*Saudi Arabia also Wants to Join BRICS for The De-Dolarization process*
Western Hegemony is Getting Over😂
Saudi arabia won't do , if they try there will coup and anothet puppet prince will installed
I think there should be a continental currency like asia should have its seperate and africa should have its seperate
And it would end dominance of dollar
Saudi will always sell oil in dollar
Because they are allies of usa its like as usa plays a game with them
Have travelled in Mumbai's monorail. It has potential. But sadly, its network is way sparser. Today, its more like a joyride for Mumbaikars
It can turn into successful project by connecting Wadala/Chembur Kurla BKC and Andheri. Next chembur/,wadala Kurla Kamani Sakinaka Andheri & Powai route.
At present less connectivity to BKC and from these area. Please study and submit your infra suggestion to govt
Yes i agree they are the most remote areas
We already got like 14 metro planned here in Mumbai. I don't see any reason to bankrupt our city just to have every single route have a train.
@@Atiq_s need based planning required instead of white elephant project. From the beginning I predicted how this project become unsuccessful considering duplication of routes. The above mentioned route is more demanding and need urgent attention
What the future of Monorail in Mumbai. This is waste of public money.
Bhai mumbai k population bhot rapidly increase ho rhi hai ek time per ye bhi kaamki ho jayegi
well, age jake may be future m success ho jaye but abhi ke liye ye bas dikhane ke liye hai ha hmare pass monorail bhi
chaye iske lakh kamiya ho but ye dikhati mast hai
Mumbai Monorail 🚝 Only in India And Kolkata Tram 🚊 Only in India. But, Metro All Over India. 😄
Maybe in future their will be a great time for Monorail aswell!
Monorail is best for big tech parks, old market areas, townships
Monorail in Mumbai is built along the harbour railway line to east coast of Mumbai. Harbour railway line is already least crowded railway line, so there is no use of building another one. They should have built it between badlapur to dadar. Pura bharke jata 😅
Only cities where monorail are somewhat successful are mountainous cities with tricky geographies where building metros is difficult
Mumbai mono rail is not a total failure, the second phase is now getting popular by locals, specially from wadala to jacob circle. Peak hour monos get full of standing passengers. And moreover, mono has frequency of 18 minute's! If that is reduced to 10 min or less, this would be even more popular. Yes the initial phase is disaster. Mono runs almost empty but after wadala stn mono actually recives good number of passengers
It's not about the metro or mono rail , answer is the Route how useful it is and density of usage !!!! Simple
Such transformation mediums are good for mid size cities whose population is between 10-20 lakhs
Kya isse metro or lite/neo metro me convert kar sakte hai?kyoki pillar to khade hi hai bus upar ka change krna hai.
Chutiya kuch bhi bol raha hai
The government system and political party have worked very hard to make it a major flop.
No project will succeed if it is delayed extensively and poorly executed.
North East can have monorails
North east has very low population density
high density required which lacks in northeast, even ghuwati is big city but it lacks in dense population i thinks trams will be nice option
Aizwal(Capital of mizoram) corporation ney monorail propose kiye the 2011 mey still it's under proposal
Length 1 line of 5kms.
@@statman-techman isn't it small only 5 KM at all the best but northeast will look more beautiful with trams because of that area natural beauty
All Hill or Mountainous Capital Cities viz Dehradun, Shimla, Shillong, Aizawl, etc
Hi, i am a huge fan of your videos but somehow I feel that this video was made in a hurry just to post a video somehow. Waiting eagerly for your future videos. Lots of love, health and happiness to you and your team.
my experience in monorail was quite good..i used travel for college through monorail to avoid bus rush...i hope further in future there would be development of this transport
Monorail would have been successful if it extended from chembur to Bandra terminus via Kurla stn , bkc & Bandra stn
Main Failure Of Monorail In Mumbai Is The Route....It Would Still Work If They Connect Mumbai Central And Vashi!!!
After Frequent Failure & Loss They Are Running Short Of Coaches...Now Frequency Is Almost 30Mins Adding To More Loss!!!!
It'd make big difference if they just extend it to Vashi. Also it passes through mostly industrial areas and big efforts were probably made by lodhas to aid it's township planning in Wadala. They just started it between chembur and bhakti park in 1st stage like why lol.
For a city like Mumbai it should be hard to have transportation system that fails. The fact the management/planners achieved this makes them eligible for big time loser award😂.
Major problem was the route and a lot of accidents happened
Jai Hind Vande Mataram👏👏👏
Monorail was mostly used to transport people nonstop between two very populated regions. They have very few or no stops and many run non-stop and are a bit on the pricey side.
Monorail did not fail 'Management' did.
Yes, it is inferior to metro in many ways but Mumba's 'failed' monorail can easily be fixed by increasing FREQUENCY and ACCESSIBILITY
Metro is absolutely Fabulous 😍👌❤️
Monorail are unsafe and costly to maintain.
Metro is the best & for long distance Bullet train is the best 👌
Power train❤️lv u❤️❤️❤️Contents like this, deserves it's millions and even billions of subscription
fake acc hai@digubisht6722
not a fan of monorails in general TBH. regular trains are cheaper to make and you can connect them to the existing network.
Monorail was a terrible choice. It has high cost / passenger-km. Since number of passengers is low and have short runs, cost is high.
It's still saving car trips for people using it
KUKU FM ne sare Indian RUclipsrs ko sponsor kar diya he.
Same will happen with hyperloop😢😢😢
#AskPT Why states like Odisha & Bengal are not doing that well in building infrastructure even with increasing in FDI inflow and government investment ?
@@AllInOne-bv1ti in chennai some areas are posh while some are old. This is similar in all metros. Tamil nadu has high GDP and per capita not because of one city. If you look closely there are so Many industrial cities specialised in a specific industry. In india average 34 percentage live in urban area while in TN 55 percentage is in urban area. More people in urban means more urban activity and more GDP.
Actually mumbai main na karke cuttack Bhubaneswar jachate to super hit chata
Monorail should be used with toy train 😑 Darjeeling main hi thik rahega
Who says its fail last week i was Traveling i found its running in good form i ask specially to the staff security thy said now its good and running in full occupancy… kind check again ur facts
If implemented by planning where it is needed and if there are many companies that can supply monorail coaches then it can be a success.
Mono rail se accha metro train h humko journey se MATLAB Hai
Monorail will be popular is congested cities of UP AND BIHAR, like japan monorail
Paisa mangta hai dost.
Monorails are cute ☺️
Hehe😁
I thinnk metro se connect se monorail groth hoga
This mono rail is a right transport at wrong place this should have been from Thane Station via kalwa, mumbra ,shilphat towards kalamboli where it's needed the most with congested area and till today they are using maharashtra bus as their means of transport and this root will be the future extension of 2nd vashi
😊👍
Hi bhai
Dubai is the best example of monorail planning
monorails can be used in airports or in connecting lines of western central herbour or in places like csmt station to gateway marine drive etc near by places...its most advantage is it takes less space...in these places it will make easy also as from directly station to gateway or marine drive..like in these type of things we can use mono..in gateway it will give it a futuristic look also... u can make a metro bridge there so mono is best for conjusted places like these/...
Join it to Ghatkopar Metro. It will become successful.
It's not failure coz it's monorail. It's not a success coz the route passes through area which has hardly any population
Due to total absence of proper town planning mono rail project failed.
Make video on why india can't make bullet trains
Bullet train will come in existence from2026As I have seen on some video😊
When it,s fail then govt has choosen monorail for dholera smartcity
Dholera & gift city is just the combination of scam,fraud & corruption like sahara Ambey valley & lavasa city
monorail will work only if all the metros are made
Im par day using mono
rail
acharya atre nagr to niagon
Are there any other cities in India where monorail could be successful
Future hai bhai ye
I think it's too early to call it a failure.
Bhai background music name pls
Monorails are un efficient. Trains isse Kai jyada ache hai.
Video is informative. Your speech is too too fast, can you please look into this. Also it will be great if you add subtitles in English because due to your fast speech we can't understand few words
Speech was fast? I watch all his video in 1.5x-1.75x speed
Everyone building monorails wrong
Build monorail in Dehradun
Shimla, Shillong, Aizawl & maybe Guwahati.
But delhi metro >>>>>>>>>>>>
Monorail is a failed project
It was executed without any proper application of mind by the then MMRDA comissioner
Total loss of taxpayers money
Monorail crowded roads ke liye better hai
This was made to failed ,low construction cost ,low commission rate
This is not the problem, the main problem is the population of where the monorail travels which is very low, and no commercial Office's or no expensive highlited resturant or places.
Bbai voice kharab hai kya ya mic quilty
But using monorail isn't a need I mean they are giving anything special
But in that vid you said that phase 2 will be successful
Now you're cursing it only
Bombay waster their time by building monorail...it should have been metro...versova to wadala.
Eknum experience hai
The narrator needs to improve his enunciation. Good content thgh
Improved frequency and with routes in dense and frequently commuted routes, it can be fruitful
Local>>>>
Bus Rapid Transit syst
Bhai thoda dhire bolo
#askpt
Why there is no maglev train in india?
Bullet train will be the first MagLev in India
Mumbai me mono rail fail nahi hua
Great video man!
Congrats who see this early
Handover to B.E.S.T.
Kuku! Just waste! You can find more content on RUclips podcast videos! Free free! Avoid KuKu
इसी तरह बुलेट ट्रेन भी सफेद हांथी है। केवल ज़िद है।
It's not like this.
But it's save cost and time.
It's need of India.
It's 🗄️🗃️ files complete by Dr Manmohan Singh. it's study in multiple countries.
But project build by Modi.
If 2 pm support this project.
Because they study project in many different countries.
This train used by China for cheap transportation of goods, another reason Chinese books are cheaper than Indian goods. Chinese good extra tax compare than Indian goods if compare in percentage.
two words : POOR PLANNING.
1 line hai to mono rail to 2 line hai to kya stereo rail name hona nahi chahie ?
congress had no sense of people and nation
Har cheez mein congress ko blame kar do. Jab Monorail ka contruction start hua tha tab BJP aur Shiv Sena ki sarkaar thi
One Word: *Slow*
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Oooppp ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Bhai... Pehle apna pronunciation and bolne ke speed ko sudhaar.... Aadhi baat to samajh hi nai aa rai teri .. 🤣
👍👍👍
The ride is not smooth you will feel sick while riding it