TARJA VS FLOOR! | Nightwish Phantom Of The Opera Official Live Video - REACTION

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 дек 2018
  • TWITTER: / preston_ktf I DO NOT OWN ANY COPYRIGHTS TO THIS VIDEO / preston_ktf paypal.me/preston207 Nightwish Phantom Of The Opera Official Live Video HD
  • РазвлеченияРазвлечения

Комментарии • 2,1 тыс.

  • @alelandaeta8299
    @alelandaeta8299 5 лет назад +775

    The bassist and vocalist name is Marco Hietala! The metal viking \o/

    • @aleksanderdomanski222
      @aleksanderdomanski222 5 лет назад +20

      ruclips.net/video/pqNSECREXoQ/видео.html
      Marco was a singer on Ayreon's album recently. And took part in "Ayreon Universe" shows. Search for it if you are interested. And whole Ayreon's discography is avesome.

    • @mikewalter1111
      @mikewalter1111 5 лет назад +1

      \m/ 0 \m/

    • @ortti8397
      @ortti8397 5 лет назад +23

      Marco has been involved in the Finnish Heavy Metal scene since the 80's

    • @PeeVee1979
      @PeeVee1979 5 лет назад +28

      The Official Metal Voice of Finland.

    • @Ta2dlam
      @Ta2dlam 5 лет назад +19

      He also has a band with his brother called Tarot.

  • @andrewkeyser8428
    @andrewkeyser8428 5 лет назад +244

    Marco really doesn't get enough credit, he's bloody amazing and to be able to keep up with Tarja just shows how good he is.

    • @jemakrol
      @jemakrol 5 лет назад +7

      **while** playing bass.... damn that dude... I am so impressed.

    • @terriewatson8828
      @terriewatson8828 4 года назад +1

      Marco needs more love.

    • @Julio-Ces4r
      @Julio-Ces4r 4 года назад

      @mickor can you confirm it was vodka though? Kappa

    • @lorenas.centellag.3556
      @lorenas.centellag.3556 2 года назад +1

      Totally, the both of them have a good chemistry and complement each other very well. Definitely Marko and Tarja took their roles very seriously to perform and with the support of a great band members like all of they are. And Tarja is Tarja, regardless Floor is also a great singer and both of them are good friends and also have the same operatical training and education in music.

  • @wayneelyard3863
    @wayneelyard3863 5 лет назад +364

    Dude! Three things you never do:
    1. Yell "Fire" in a theatre.
    2. Yell "Bomb" on a plane.
    3. Ask Nightwish fans who the best singer is.
    No, make #3 the top one. Never, ever, do that ....

    • @yksvaan1690
      @yksvaan1690 5 лет назад +17

      Come on, it's okay to ask!
      3. Marco Hietala (feat. Tarja, Anette, Floor, Muammar Gaddafi, Hosni Mubarak and his rubber band)

    • @hazelangus
      @hazelangus 5 лет назад +27

      @@yksvaan1690 It's ok to ask, you just need to be able to run really really fast. XD

    • @otacon1024
      @otacon1024 5 лет назад +10

      Problem is, they'll tell you even if you don't ask xD

    • @savageinnecromancy3175
      @savageinnecromancy3175 5 лет назад +1

      I think I will yell there's a bomb in the vehicle just for a good laugh 😂😅

    • @ILoveGrilledCheese
      @ILoveGrilledCheese 4 года назад +11

      Tarja is the best. Don’t @ me

  • @Songfugel
    @Songfugel 5 лет назад +286

    Don't even try to compare Floor and Tarja, perfection can have many faces

    • @odddity
      @odddity 5 лет назад +16

      Floor is great, but Tarja is just magical.

    • @Aldarion69
      @Aldarion69 5 лет назад +14

      Exactly , Floor and tarja are perfect, you cant compare perfection

    • @joelvog82
      @joelvog82 5 лет назад +6

      oh my, the perfect coment about a "tarja vs. floor" theme, both are perfect

    • @emanuelebruzzese1117
      @emanuelebruzzese1117 5 лет назад +2

      Perfection has no face

    • @LeanEre
      @LeanEre 4 года назад +8

      I agree. Everybody knows that Tarja is better

  • @ezekielrosales2020
    @ezekielrosales2020 5 лет назад +85

    "He knew it was about to happen. He braced himself." Hahahaha

  • @ioanniskostoulas4448
    @ioanniskostoulas4448 5 лет назад +121

    The answer is easy. I like both singers.

  • @ren.batista
    @ren.batista 5 лет назад +97

    I absolutely love Tarja. She doesn't only sing well, but her entire performance is beautiful.

    • @brent4770
      @brent4770 4 года назад +1

      She's a little to opera for me.

  • @KalElvis
    @KalElvis 5 лет назад +5

    Your reaction to Tarja was spot on. She's the best!

  • @sergiocarrillo3935
    @sergiocarrillo3935 3 года назад +10

    Simplemente decir que Nightwish hoy es lo que es gracias a Tarja 😍😌😎 unica e irremplazable!!

  • @TheComicBookJoker
    @TheComicBookJoker 5 лет назад +215

    Tarja, the original singer, is who drew me into Nightwish. Their second singer, Annette (who you have not reacted to), I felt did not match the band’s style well, so I stopped listening to them for a long time. A few years ago, I listened to them again after they gained Floor, and I’m back on them. Floor is my favorite of the three.

    • @madhatter6708
      @madhatter6708 5 лет назад +15

      Floor is also my favorite,,, Anette did some really good album work- not great live on Tarja songs.. Floor is the total package.

    • @danihu03
      @danihu03 5 лет назад +7

      I just found them a week ago. I've been obsessed. The second singer sucks.

    • @TheComicBookJoker
      @TheComicBookJoker 5 лет назад +3

      Danielle Hudson Annette doesn’t suck. She just doesn’t fit Nightwish’s sound at all. In a less operatic band, she would have been great.

    • @TheBemontsOfficial
      @TheBemontsOfficial 5 лет назад +1

      Same experience 100%

    • @TheBemontsOfficial
      @TheBemontsOfficial 5 лет назад +1

      Actually...I agree 99%...I think that Annette indeed does suck 😂

  • @SithLordReven
    @SithLordReven 5 лет назад +8

    This song just proves metal and opera can work together and take it to the next level

    • @Mal_Messiah
      @Mal_Messiah 5 лет назад

      Candlemass proves that also

  • @dianamistera2424
    @dianamistera2424 5 лет назад +6

    I was a fan of Nightwish just when Tarja was there. Flor is good and have a nice voice, good stage presence, but Tarja is unbelievable. And her voice with Marko's voice, hit straight to the core, especially in this song :)

  • @dgn4369
    @dgn4369 5 лет назад +34

    I discovered Nightwish in 1999 so I am a Tarja fanboy. When the band decided to dismiss Tarja, the first name and only name for me to pop in my mind as a worthy of taking her spot was Floor. And I can fully understand why they didn't pursue Floor at the time because she was having her own success in After Forever. The bass player Marco Hietala has been in the music scene for over 30 years, releasing 9 albums with his first band Tarot. The first replacement singer Annette was an ok singer but CANNOT do what Tarja or Floor can do.

    • @elyeliza8287
      @elyeliza8287 5 лет назад +6

      I discovered Nightwish in 2013 and i'm a Tarja fangirl too 💖💖 she's my idol
      Floor is the whole package, she was made for Tuomas's compositions !!
      I loved Anette's albums too. I guess i'm more of a Tuomas fan 😂

    • @nguyenvincent708
      @nguyenvincent708 5 лет назад +1

      ​@@elyeliza8287 yesss me too, I personally think that Nightwish would be fine unless Toumas still there

    • @natashas.1566
      @natashas.1566 5 лет назад +2

      @@elyeliza8287 I 'hated' Tuomas after the saga with Tarja's leaving. I am also a fan of the band since the late 1990s, so it hit me hard the way that Tarja was let go. However, after hearing The poet and the pendulum, Tuomas was forgiven by me, as the song tells that he seriously suffered tons for what happened.

    • @gamerkef
      @gamerkef 5 лет назад

      @@natashas.1566 I am with you! I was really upset with him too because of their complaints with her in that letter, I was convinced that to Tuomas, Tarja was his secret Christine, and was really just hurt and jealous that she married someone else. I remember when I watched their old documentary, he was always falling down drunk all the time and they had to take care of him. I wondered why with all that beautiful music flowing out through him, and that gorgeous festive Disney-inspired stuff too, is he so unhappy? I figured maybe he's like one of those really smart prodigal people who almost can't function here around most people if not for booze. I conjured my own drama about it. XD But anyway, he makes life so much more beautiful with his amazing talent. Even though I hadn't heard them in a long time now since Tarja left, I fell in love with Tuomas' epic composing within the first few measures as per usu!! XD I hadn't heard the poet and the pendulum yet!! I will go listen!!

  • @praxis7997
    @praxis7997 5 лет назад +107

    Dear God Preston do you know what you have done with the question you just asked all your viewers? "Let me know who your favorite singer is." Let the fighting begin! Lmao

    • @nemo6666
      @nemo6666 5 лет назад +1

      Praxis 79 IM in the war 😂

    • @nemo6666
      @nemo6666 5 лет назад +5

      And yeah he has open that door😱😂

    • @praxis7997
      @praxis7997 5 лет назад +5

      They are both amazing singers.

    • @jackskellington9570
      @jackskellington9570 5 лет назад +1

      Right😅☠

    • @TerranigmaQuintet
      @TerranigmaQuintet 5 лет назад +10

      He opened Pandora's box that's what he did lol. :P

  • @sugarjo9
    @sugarjo9 5 лет назад +8

    from the moment they created I used to be a fan.I love Tarja. Her voice, her profile, her performance. I was disbelieved about Floor, even though I was a fan to her previous band 'after forever' cause she was going to perform after legend Tarja, But , there she was and proofed us wrong.I love the way she performs with Nightwish and I kinda think she is better in general..

  • @shivannah772
    @shivannah772 5 лет назад +33

    Floor is my fav for Nightwish, but Tarjas voice is incredibly beautiful!!

  • @PeeVee1979
    @PeeVee1979 5 лет назад +21

    It's impossible to choose between them. Tarja's voice fits better in songs like Phantom but then again it was Floor who made Ghost Love Score a masterpiece. Sure it was always a masterpiece but Floor really put final touches to it.
    Even though I never had any problem with Anette, she never was on the par with Tarja and Floor. Anette has a clear and powerful voice but she leans more towards a pop singer. Nothing wrong with that but with Nightwish you need to have something extra.

  • @tonyfriesen
    @tonyfriesen 5 лет назад +4

    Ever dream end of an era by nightwish is a great performance. Team Tarja!

  • @Mad9977
    @Mad9977 5 лет назад +28

    Tarja's voice can make the hardest dude get emotional =)

  • @NatsNotHere
    @NatsNotHere 5 лет назад +13

    I love both Tarja and Floor. Tarja’s voice is what drew me in all those years ago and introduced me to symphonic metal. I’ve seen them perform in several countries spanning two decades and I’m grateful to have their discography as a bit of a soundtrack to my life since my teen years. All that said, Floor is my personal preference as lead vocalist. Marko is incredible too and deserves a mention. Looove when they sing together and harmonize to the point where their voices meld and sound almost like one... *happy sigh*
    That’s not to say either Tarja or Anette were in any way less accomplished as leads, I just prefer Floor’s range and diversity over Tarja’s more strictly classical approach and Anette’s more poppy sound. That she can go from a growl all the way up to operatic and back down in a single breath with a smile on her face is to me simply magical and I appreciate the goosebumps I get when she flips through the different “styles” with such ease. She feels like the perfect fit that can do it all. Angelic arias and growling headbangs and windmills... I mean... yeah... Love Tarja, but Floor ticks more boxes for me personally.

  • @sbhmetal3838
    @sbhmetal3838 5 лет назад +79

    Great reaction!Tarja is excellent at what she does. Floor is the whole package!!

    • @juny9445
      @juny9445 5 лет назад +5

      Facts

    • @ryanhalien8468
      @ryanhalien8468 5 лет назад +8

      My thoughts exactly, Tarja edges Floor out on the operatic stuff, but that’s all she does, she’s all head voice, and she’s great at it and sounds amazing, but Floor as a beautiful operatic soprano as well and can also do literally anything else you need her to vocally, she’s complete, perfect singer for Nightwish

    • @maryakin-ajayi5601
      @maryakin-ajayi5601 5 лет назад

      @@ryanhalien8468 when last did you listen to Tarja? No, dear, she's not all headvoice. Even in Nightwish she wasn't all headvoice. She was so consistent almost everyone thought she was all headvoice. Now more than ever she definitely isn't all headvoice.

    • @ryanhalien8468
      @ryanhalien8468 5 лет назад

      Mary Akin-Ajayi fair enough let me put it differently, I’ve never heard a Tarja song that wasn’t at least 95 percent headvoice, I’d love to hear one that showcases her full vocal range, if you could give me a link that’d be great, I mean that sincerely.

    • @maryakin-ajayi5601
      @maryakin-ajayi5601 5 лет назад

      @@ryanhalien8468 If you listen to her performances in December 2018 you'd realise she sings more in chest and mixed voice now unlike her Nightwish days.
      ruclips.net/video/1Zd7_MLtV1U/видео.html
      The above is a playful performance of White Christmas with Joe Lynn Turner

  • @SnakeM98
    @SnakeM98 5 лет назад +34

    You should explore the situation a bit deeper, her departure wasn't nice so you wont find her as a surprise act nowdays. But Tarja did start her solo career after she was kicked out of NW and she did invite Floor to sing with her on one song at her concert so luckily for us, there is a performance where both of them sing together!

    • @Scioneer
      @Scioneer 5 лет назад +5

      There's also recent performances where Tarja and Marco performed together again. Tarja also kept in touch with Emppu after the split and even talked to Jukka from time to time. However Toumas and Tarja still hasn't seemed to healed their wounds. So far, it is difficult to find Tarja's side of the story and requires use of the Internet Wayback Machine. Last I checked, Toumas still has that damn open letter on the Nightwish site.

    • @Tbone.357
      @Tbone.357 5 лет назад

      @@chrisbergsten1429 I may be mistaken but isn't she about half his age?

    • @Tbone.357
      @Tbone.357 5 лет назад +2

      Thanos shit....hahaha

    • @dorothymadara5589
      @dorothymadara5589 5 лет назад +1

      @@Tbone.357 They went to music school together. Tuomos was also dating Annette for a short period of time. Tuomos writes most of the songs so he was the one that made the executive decision.

  • @minakalsi4232
    @minakalsi4232 5 лет назад +6

    Madness as soon as she started singing I had tears 😭

  • @simmysims9209
    @simmysims9209 5 лет назад +46

    I have been listening Nightwish since '98 and I like all 3 singers, but my favorite is Floor 🤘

  • @SoyDovah
    @SoyDovah 5 лет назад +104

    React to Nightwish - While your lips are still red.. as Marco singer

    • @valikdorofei6129
      @valikdorofei6129 5 лет назад +1

      @@neleleit-teetlaus2703 yeah, live at Tampere

    • @amberday2475
      @amberday2475 5 лет назад +2

      @@neleleit-teetlaus2703 How about both??

    • @coffeebaesh4827
      @coffeebaesh4827 5 лет назад +1

      Absolutely both. Marco is amazing! I'd even say check out him and Floor singing Ave Maria. It was beautiful!

    • @gamerkef
      @gamerkef 5 лет назад

      Hail Dovahkiin!!!

  • @matthewgaines9065
    @matthewgaines9065 5 лет назад +17

    Marco is a singing beast!!! He’s went through 3 different singers and changed his pitch and tone to fit perfectly with each one...To answer your question... FLOOR is the metal Queen!!! My backing statement is that Floor can sing all the older songs and newer in any style she feels like on a given night... she has it all!!! Most of all she’s Humble!! Can’t say that about the first two... lol!! Great reaction... Love Nightwish!!!!

  • @mkvision
    @mkvision 4 года назад +1

    I first experienced Nighwish with Tarja as the singer so she is special to me and obviously my favorite.

  • @allenhuling598
    @allenhuling598 5 лет назад

    So glad you found Nightwish and truly appreciate their music! Tarja was one of the pioneers of soprano voices over Metal music, creating a genre that so many of us love today, so props have to go to her! That said, I am definitely 'Team Floor' and always will be! Yes, Marco has a fantastic voice and I would love to see him featured even more! You have many, many more of their excellent songs to to discover....enjoy the journey!

  • @thegreatsagesun
    @thegreatsagesun 5 лет назад +8

    If you like Marco's voice, he is the lead singer on Nightwish's "The Islander", which you should definitely check out Live at Tampere. One of my favourite songs by the band as a whole.
    As for Tarja vs. Floor. I like all three of the Nightwish frontwomen, for different reasons, but Floor is my favourite, she brings a lot more versatility and can effectively execute the largest range of their musical catalogue.

  • @harleyquinn8011
    @harleyquinn8011 5 лет назад +11

    Yep, Tarja is quite brilliant singer too, I like many of her versions, but... there's no one like Floor's versatility and supremacy! This high note at the end was D6 by the way - the note that anyone doesn't dare to reach just like that at LIVE concert which goes to DVD. Bass player/second vocalist is Marco Hietala - super cool dude, brilliant musician and awesome singer.

  • @2dimitropolis370
    @2dimitropolis370 5 лет назад +77

    Team Tarja ❤️I love them both though. They are friends, so...

    • @ktvindicare
      @ktvindicare 5 лет назад +3

      The only real answer to this question.

    • @-_YouMayFind_-
      @-_YouMayFind_- 5 лет назад

      But Tarja left them so basically I am not sure if she deserved this

    • @ktvindicare
      @ktvindicare 5 лет назад +8

      @@-_YouMayFind_- Tarja was fired. She didn't leave on her own.

    • @cassiewinters331
      @cassiewinters331 5 лет назад

      Verrottesok she mentioned wanting to leave on her terms but they fired her instead

    • @IvoryElvenson
      @IvoryElvenson 4 года назад +2

      @@-_YouMayFind_-
      The band did not even had the balls to tell her face to face, that they gonna kick her out, so they wrote a letter and gave it to her after the last show!
      That's when I stopped following the band! I'm 100% a Tarja-Lover and I still love the band of her time, but I do not care, what they did since then - in my opinion they don't deserve to be cared of!

  • @georgerexford9768
    @georgerexford9768 5 лет назад +4

    Great reaction. You are right Markko is a fantastic singer, he complimented all the ladies voices. As to who I enjoy most would be The Beautiful Miss Floor Jansen. She can sing all genre. Her range is phenomenal. She is the perfect front women for Nightwish. Love her.

  • @seanmurphy637
    @seanmurphy637 5 лет назад +8

    As usual, a great reaction. As a fellow Nightwish fan i get it 100%. I would pick Floor as my favourite because she is just so much more versatile and brings a much warmer personality to her performance. Who can't help falling in love with her.

  • @thebluriam
    @thebluriam 5 лет назад +3

    YES!!! I've been waiting for this reaction so damn much! Favorite singer is the Floor even though I fell in love with Nightwish when Tarja was their singer. Floor adds a whole new dimension sonicalyl.

  • @roubenkhosrovian
    @roubenkhosrovian 5 лет назад +2

    She's actually the first singer. happy to see another person loving tarja :D

  • @Romulus980
    @Romulus980 Год назад +1

    Tarja chief strength was performing in Nightwish and this was one of her best performances perfect chemistry with Marco (man of hidden talents...!)

  • @aymane4417
    @aymane4417 5 лет назад +80

    Please react to Epica - Sancta Terra ( Featuring Floor Jansen)
    Also Epica - Kingdom of Heaven live (It's gonna blow your mind)
    Epica is nightwish but heavier.

    • @rafaell.atlanticforest603
      @rafaell.atlanticforest603 5 лет назад +3

      is funny, i think NW is more havier... at least the old NW

    • @codydrummer
      @codydrummer 5 лет назад +5

      Epica - The Essence of Silence

    • @javielabreu8619
      @javielabreu8619 5 лет назад +3

      Epica - cry for the moon

    • @bumbolee
      @bumbolee 5 лет назад

      I really like Epica, except for one thing....they to do much of those death vocals. Simone is a wonderful singer and the band is very good but for me it just ruins the song. Same with Amaranthe. Elize Ryd can sing her butt off and former singer Jake was soooo dang good. But those other vocals are just horrible.

    • @mordraug
      @mordraug 5 лет назад +2

      @@bumbolee you just have to get into them. Once you do, you will at least very appreciate them. They can add a ton to the music. Try to view them not as vocals, but instruments, as that is their main purpose.

  • @harjajarvi71
    @harjajarvi71 5 лет назад +85

    Tarja is my favorite. But Floor is great too. Marco Hietala is the singing basist. His former band is Tarot.

    • @SapiaNt0mata
      @SapiaNt0mata 5 лет назад

      he is still in Tarot. the drummer of Tarot had a serious illness so the band didn't record new album, and in 2016 that he passed away the band is on break.

    • @truellaksala
      @truellaksala 4 года назад

      harjajarvi71 No shit! ?

  • @debbiefulton1001
    @debbiefulton1001 5 лет назад +2

    Total enchantment! I've never heard this group before.

  • @XercesandAlexander
    @XercesandAlexander 5 лет назад +14

    I don't have a favorite, they're both great. I can't and won't choose. They're both different but talented. It's like choosing between Messi or Ronaldo you know your going to win with either one but they play different styles.

  • @freya4764
    @freya4764 5 лет назад +4

    Loved it!! I can't pick between the two. They are both amazing. Another good band , Within Temptation. A lot of great songs. The live Black Symphony performance of Our Solemn Hour is awesome. From Winston Churchill in the beginning to her designing costumes and her voice. Awesome. They also did a colab with Xzibit that's pretty dope. Love your channel. ✌&❤

  • @gustavodb20
    @gustavodb20 5 лет назад +29

    After Forever - My Pledge of Allegiance #1
    Floor Jansen was the singer. Check it out!!!!!

    • @FabianKinder
      @FabianKinder 5 лет назад +1

      Sins of Idealism is also a good song.

  • @SKSHCS
    @SKSHCS 5 лет назад

    Love it man..I like seeing you going through songs I like and just as much I like the fact you introduced me lots of song from the rap side of the music.. Thanks for being there for us. Keep it going. Greetings from Czech republic, Europe

  • @onlythtruth2938
    @onlythtruth2938 4 года назад

    Thank you so much, my friend, for giving that heavenly creation,Tarja a chancev to shine again.. i am a 6'3" former army ranger and has never shed a tear even after loosing my best friend in a mission, until i heard this
    magnificent voice do this song and another ballad called "swanheart" thats right she reduced me to a fountain of tears. by the way, i lovev the intro tyo your channel. the man speaking is soooo right. your most difficult impediment is the one you build for yourself looking forward to more Tarja and thanks

  • @Rossable666
    @Rossable666 5 лет назад +12

    Keep it up man, I'm lovin' your reaction vids. Tarja is amazing, and as an old school Nightwish fan, I will always love her vocals, however Floor Jansen is probably one of the best vocalists out there today with her range and versatility, so I have to give this one to Floor. If you're liking the symphonic metal, please check out some Epica.

  • @CavemanJesus4Life
    @CavemanJesus4Life 5 лет назад +55

    I love Floor Jansen, she my goddess. But for Nightwish, Tarja Turunen is and always will be the voice of Nightwish.
    The Bassist is a singer for his own band Tarot

  • @reisereise1123
    @reisereise1123 5 лет назад

    Glad you get to experience Tarja' s voice. Floor is an unbelievable singer and I love her. However we never forget Tarja and always will appreciate her.

  • @mnicolemortensen7
    @mnicolemortensen7 5 лет назад

    I love both singers. They are talented in their own ways but also amazing and enjoyable.

  • @ronniemendheim5564
    @ronniemendheim5564 5 лет назад +37

    Tarja is my fav. But Floor is freaking amazing!!

  • @ajnunya6649
    @ajnunya6649 5 лет назад +12

    I loved Tarja didn't think a lot of Annette and think Floor is brilliant. And Marco is totally underrated.

  • @dourden30
    @dourden30 5 лет назад +2

    Both Tarja and Floor are incredible, talented and gifted singers with lots of hours of hard work on their backs. No sense to compare. Enjoy both ;)

  • @leetmeathead
    @leetmeathead 5 лет назад +1

    I saw them in Denver last year. It was an awesome show.

  • @bangbray4224
    @bangbray4224 5 лет назад +5

    You right bro!!! She is Legend!!! I am glad finally NIGHTWISH have found a Best New Singer who fit with all their songs but Tarja she's still a Legend of NIGHTWISH. Tarja vs Floor? Nightwish win

  • @donaldcampbell9483
    @donaldcampbell9483 4 года назад +6

    You need to see Floor sing this omg.... speechless

    • @FriedToast
      @FriedToast 4 года назад

      Yes, her duet with Henk is incredible. However, I still prefer this version over that one (altho' Floor's ending is OVER THE TOP). Part of why I like Tarja's Phantom better is because Marco is almost perfect. Henk was great but seemed a bit overdone at points.

  • @raven_the_shamanmagus8252
    @raven_the_shamanmagus8252 5 лет назад

    This was the BEST reaction yet!! Preston, you have not ever failed to deliver!!

  • @VampyreVladimira
    @VampyreVladimira 5 лет назад

    Yeah. I saw The Phantom of the Opera on Broadway when they came to Birmingham. That start at 2:24 always startles people who are unfamiliar with The Phantom of the Opera. I love it. I took my dad to see it with me, and he had the same reaction as you. Lol. Love your reactions. Much love. ♥

  • @orion351us
    @orion351us 5 лет назад +7

    My favorite singer depends on the song that is being sung bro. Tarja is TOTALLY meant for the pure classical element, whereas Floor is meant for more metal elements.

  • @SunOfTheSun
    @SunOfTheSun 5 лет назад +6

    Tarja is my fave. I loved her when I first started listening. But, I really love Floor.
    PLEASE react to NIGHTWISH- THE SIREN live @ END OF AN ERA - Another Tarja 🔥

  • @PhoenixxxOberon
    @PhoenixxxOberon 4 года назад +1

    Nightwish isn't about singers. It's about musicians pushing their limits and become the best. Every member of the band is simply an exceptional musician, and Tuomas is a musical genious. Tarja is still an absolute legend, an amazing singer and I adore her in this version of the song. On the other hand, the years Floor Jansen spent side by side with these super talented guys and the hard work she has put on her art, has propelled her into becoming one of the most versatile and best technical singers in the world... She can now sing absolutely everything, and the emotion in her voice can make you cry, every time. She is trully a siren. Just goggle her...

  • @Marcus7469
    @Marcus7469 5 лет назад

    I love all 3 singers of this band. Just absolutely love the band itself

  • @Mimzzis
    @Mimzzis 5 лет назад +6

    Tarja is good. I was at her concert and nightwish too. Floor and Tarja are both great singer but Floor is the one who stole my heart!
    and because of the title I thought you would do a comparison between floor and tarja because floor sang the phantom of the opera too :D
    and here is few position to react:
    Tarja and Floor - over the hills and far away
    Floor and Epica - sancta terra
    Tarja and Within Temptation - Paradise
    im sure you will like it!!!!

  • @chrismg1980
    @chrismg1980 5 лет назад +31

    I am new to Nightwish, but so far I'm a fan of the new singer Floor. I've listened to Tarja's original version of Ghost Love Score and Floor's (new singer) live version to compare. And Floor adds what the song was missing, an epic climactic ending. The original song just seems to fade away but the new singer (Floor) belts out some emotionally charged high notes at the end that leave the listener satisfied and in awe. Plus I think she just fits the band better than Tarja did. Her stage presence and style meld very well with Nightwish

    • @SCraig-Handsome
      @SCraig-Handsome 5 лет назад +4

      I saw Floor live in concert but Marco was actually the best vocalist, Floor was great, just not the main act. Tarja was Nightwish would have loved to see her live...

    • @legendofold101
      @legendofold101 4 года назад +2

      For me Tarja was like Darksied on Apocalyspe Thanos on planet Titan everytime you saw Tarja it was like an Archangel going to do the lords work she had that presence about her Floor doesnt have. Since your newer to the band you'll always favour Floor, Floor is doing amazing things with the band but I cant forget Tarja greatness.

    • @TinaMUFC10
      @TinaMUFC10 4 года назад

      @@legendofold101 amen to that 👍

    • @legendofold101
      @legendofold101 4 года назад

      @@TinaMUFC10 Just speaking fact.

  • @joseguidos1385
    @joseguidos1385 5 лет назад

    I can´t believe u are reacting to nightwish!!! that´s freaking awesome!

  • @SapiaNt0mata
    @SapiaNt0mata 5 лет назад

    Marco Hietala(bassist) is a singer since the 80's. even when he joined Nightwish he was a lead singer in a band called Tarot. he released a solo album a few weeks ago in Finish language. he said the English version will come out on fall 2019.

  • @Samantha2209
    @Samantha2209 5 лет назад +238

    Well tarja is an operatic singer, so she is naturally fitted for this song. She has a warm dark voice which matches the tone of the Phantom of the Opera... Floor on the other hand has more range in her style, meaning she can go classic or contemporary... so she may not do THIS particular vocal as dramatically as Tarja, but across the board I think Floor is a better fit for the “metal” band that Nightwish is.

    • @nicosimioni7363
      @nicosimioni7363 5 лет назад +21

      Both can do things that the other can't, that's for sure. I love both of them and if someone had to become the new singer of Nightwish, then Floor was the best option by far.

    • @FarazOloumi
      @FarazOloumi 5 лет назад +8

      @Samantha Khan while a valid argument, your conclusion of which vocal style is a better fit for a metal band, is purely subjective and based on your preference.

    • @Samantha2209
      @Samantha2209 5 лет назад +3

      jon more I don’t know how much training is required to be considered “operatic”... I’ll have to google that... but I know she definitely was classically trained (no google for that, you only need your ears lol), but she’s got that range too man, she can belt like a beast when she wants to, and I love that about her.

    • @Samantha2209
      @Samantha2209 5 лет назад +4

      Faraz Oloumi absolutely dude. Absolutely. Don’t you just love that about music? 😉

    • @InconSteveHable
      @InconSteveHable 5 лет назад +6

      @@Samantha2209 she can belt like a beast... fair point, but she can't sustain it like Farja, her power lies in her warm broad mid range, and her low range, her vocals are much broader and warmer than Tarja's, but Tarja's were brighter and clearer (especially at high range) and were more in keeping with the bands musical etho's at the time, i'm old enough to have now seen them both live, and Tarja is in my experience by far the better all round performer.

  • @Curtes69
    @Curtes69 5 лет назад +9

    I like them both, but in my opinion, for the kind of music that nightwish make, Floor is perfect. The guy singer and bassist is Marco, he is pretty good too. You have to listen to their cover from pink Floyd's song high hope, with Marco doing all the singing. Also there's a performance with both singers Tarja and Floor, just don't remember which song is. And try Epica, song sancta Terra, feat Floor

    • @allenhuling598
      @allenhuling598 5 лет назад +1

      I believe it was 'Over the Hills and Far Away' - Great song, and displays their friendship!

  • @JacobSmith-if2oj
    @JacobSmith-if2oj 4 года назад

    tarja for life she has such great crowd work her show in Argentina was amazing

  • @FutileGrief
    @FutileGrief 5 лет назад

    Also, yes, they have performed together (Over The Hills and Far Away) and After Forever and Nightwish toured in the early 2000s. Oh! And before that, After forever did use to cover some songs by Nightwish.

  • @alexhamilton4084
    @alexhamilton4084 5 лет назад +3

    I couldn’t get into Nightwish for years. Tarja voice sounded wrong to my ears but then through your reaction to Ghost Love Score I became a fan and I have you to thank for that. Floor is a perfect fit in Nightwish. I am
    In debt to you man.

  • @sirgallahad4
    @sirgallahad4 5 лет назад +27

    Tarja is and forever will be incredible.
    Floor just commands everything within her field of vision.
    We all win.

  • @menotyou4678
    @menotyou4678 5 лет назад

    Holy hell, I love Phantom and metal... but I’ve never heard this ‘til now! Love it!!!

  • @SK-nw4ig
    @SK-nw4ig 4 года назад

    Marco has had Nightwish as a side project for couple of decades now ( ;D ). His other band he founded and sings in, is Tarot, FOUNDED IN EARLY 80'S and still going strong. So yeah, this guy is seriously professional and a talented professional. Glad you made a point of it :) Shout out from Finland, the metal music wonderland!

  • @juliegogola4647
    @juliegogola4647 5 лет назад +3

    See Marco the bassist and singer singing "The Islander" Live on stage. very impressive.

  • @katalynagiovanni1001
    @katalynagiovanni1001 5 лет назад +7

    Tarja gives me chills I love this performance!

  • @perfectone5848
    @perfectone5848 4 года назад

    That is soooooo true! Before, during and after her performances people of all ages, backgrounds and genders were known to react this emotionally to her cadence. Tarja was one of original founders of nightwiish and upon hearing her rich , operatic vocals they realized that being a small time folk band would be wasted with her magnificent voice. so they opted for much greater heights and went with operatic/symphonic metal genre.ALWAYS keetos-thank you in Finnish....if you like this , you would love Simone of the band Epica

  • @angusgow1887
    @angusgow1887 5 лет назад

    Respect to both ladies and the music they have created

  • @marceloluischociay4854
    @marceloluischociay4854 5 лет назад +13

    The Greatest Show on Earth - Live Tamper - PLEASEEEEE!!!!!!

  • @sulrics
    @sulrics 5 лет назад +4

    Another great reaction from you. Most entertaining. Tarja for her operatic style. Floor for taking Nightwish to the next level.

  • @anabango7278
    @anabango7278 5 лет назад

    I love all of your reactions. Greetings from Argentina.

  • @waynewilliams8815
    @waynewilliams8815 4 года назад

    Just found your channel and like your reactions. Nightwish is an awesome symphonic metal band and I love Both Tarja and Floor.

  • @SOTriggered
    @SOTriggered 5 лет назад +8

    Alter Bridge - Words Darker Than Their Wings (live)
    Full orchestral backing! Amazing performance.

  • @GibrannAragon
    @GibrannAragon 5 лет назад +3

    Both, Tarja and Floor fit perfectly with nightwish, the original singer is Tarja and they make a lot of good things with her, they own a lot bc of her, but I think Floor is so damn good too, her voice is so powerful, pretty different but powerful, she can do rock and opera, that’s the diferente between floor and tarja

  • @Cayleona
    @Cayleona 5 лет назад +1

    Love your reactions, dude! 🖤

  • @ulfdanielsen6009
    @ulfdanielsen6009 5 лет назад +1

    What you just experienced was true mastery.
    Tarja in her time with Nightwish reigned supreme.
    She was training to become an actual opera singer when they recruited her for Nightwish when she was still very young and as their singer she forged out an international career spanning by now more than twenty years.
    Without her in Nightwish it´s quite possible there would have been no Nightwish to speak of and quite possibly no symphonic metal genre as she was the trailblazer more or less single handedly defining this entire style of operatic rock singing.
    She was, is and will remain an absolute icon and in the metal community she is untouchable,- even if you like Floor better.
    By now there may be other singers beside her but no one above her,- not even Floor.
    A true much loved Queen.
    Metal royalty.

  • @TheSpydyr
    @TheSpydyr 5 лет назад +5

    I've been a huge fan of NW since the beginning and have liked all 3 singers. They all have their strengths in certain areas. Tarja is a god and spoiled a bunch of fans early on. But I like Floor the best.

  • @Monkeyboypk
    @Monkeyboypk 5 лет назад +6

    Tarja is a fantastic singer but is more suited to operatic style singing. Whereas Floor has the range to compete with the operatic style but also then hit the deep growls of death metal vocalists.
    Absolutely need to check out Kiss While Your Lips Are Still Red from Wembley (same show as Poet and the Pendulum) if you like how Marko sings. He takes centre stage and Floor provides more of a complimentary backing vocals.

  • @lambhec
    @lambhec 5 лет назад

    Took a beautiful song, from an amazing play, made it their own...and just as enjoyable, with no actors.... surreal!!

  • @liveforlife2494
    @liveforlife2494 5 лет назад

    I've always loved Tarja for her incredibly rich and extremely strong voice and soprano range--there is something incredible in her singing that established Nightwish as one of the biggest bands in the world almost immediately after they started releasing music. The one thing is that she only has that one type of voice, essentially, and you never hear her doing much of anything else. Floor is a bit of a grab bag of everything because she's able to dip into a mix of different vocal approaches effortlessly. Her voice sounds somewhat thinner than Tarja's rich one, but she's absolutely capable of holding her own, and nobody does "Ghost Love Score" live like her. Love them both, and Anette, too.

  • @fernando-vd2cn
    @fernando-vd2cn 5 лет назад +3

    For this song Tarja, for all the other songs Floor.

  • @AndreRibeiro009
    @AndreRibeiro009 5 лет назад +25

    React to EPICA - CONSIGN TO OBLIVION or any other

  • @throgwarhammer7162
    @throgwarhammer7162 5 лет назад

    Your reactions are great. I love your enthusiasm.

  • @qaqalatif2830
    @qaqalatif2830 5 лет назад

    nightwish- bless the child floor&tarja duet...its so awsome!!😍

  • @nick74bul
    @nick74bul 5 лет назад +51

    Respect for Tarja, she is amazing vocalist but Floor is a tsunami. She just grabs you. Floor ever

  • @aragorn50th
    @aragorn50th 5 лет назад +7

    All three singers are great in their own way. I believe Floor has a more versatile voice and I love her stage presence.

  • @georgerexford9768
    @georgerexford9768 5 лет назад

    They are both beautiful & amazing singers. That being said, I absolutely love and adore Floor. Especially when Floor and Marko are singing together. It just doesn't get any better than that.
    The whole band seems a lot happier now. I feel Nightwish is going to bring even more epic music to us all, and I'm looking forward to it. NIGHTWISH!

  • @CanadianMetalHead73
    @CanadianMetalHead73 Год назад +1

    If there is anyone on the planet that can hang with Floor its Tarja!!! I love them both so hard for me to choose honestly! I started listening to Nightwish when it was Tarja's show!! you need to listen to Tarja doing Ghost Love Score as it was her song originally! Amazing! KTF

  • @BamaGrammy
    @BamaGrammy 5 лет назад +19

    I always love Tarja Turunen. You can't beat the original because she led the way. Annette stank her voice just rubbed me the wrong way. I used to listen to Floor Jensen when she was in Forever After. I also believe that Marco could have been a better choice after Tarja left the band. Since I was already a huge fan of Floors. Like others I stopped following NightWish when Tarja left. Now I believe that Floor is a Great singer and I was SO happy when she joined Nightwish! However, knowing that Nightwish was formed FOR Tarja I feel and believe she is the best singer from NightWish.

    • @jetfromholland9638
      @jetfromholland9638 4 года назад

      There must have been a reason why Tuomas wanted another front woman than Tarja.

    • @didido5245
      @didido5245 4 года назад +1

      Jet From Holland are you a new nightwish fan? Turnas never wanted another singar that tarja he said so múltiple times.

    • @jetfromholland9638
      @jetfromholland9638 4 года назад

      Didi Do Yes, I just discovered Nightwish a couple of months ago. I really tried to keep an open mind to all of their stuff. All three singers. I just have a hard time warming up to the thick operatc sound of Tarja. Just a personal preference. And I know she wanted to leave the band and the band just sped up the process. I think she caused a lot of stress in the time before her leaving. If I’m wrong, maybe you could fill me in. No disrespect.

    • @demoncleaner80
      @demoncleaner80 4 года назад

      You got it backwards. The band is After Forever ;)
      I used to listen to them too, though only their first two albums -- don't know why I didn't follow after that. A LOT of other bands formed from members of AF. Epica, MaYan, Floor to Nightwish eventually, etc.

  • @jackskellington9570
    @jackskellington9570 5 лет назад +4

    If you want to see Floor do a great operatic performance look up her old band After Forever. The life performance of Dreamflight. One of her best performances ever. Not the newer HD scaled one because while it improved the video quality it lost a little audio quality.
    Or for some awesome clean and harsh switching with opera her band revamp. The trial of monsters live at grasp 2010.

    • @DarkSeraphim1
      @DarkSeraphim1 5 лет назад +1

      I loved Disdain. She nailed both vocal parts flawlessly live.

    • @jackskellington9570
      @jackskellington9570 5 лет назад

      @@DarkSeraphim1 Ave it awesomely transitioned to trial of monsters

  • @jamesseiler5078
    @jamesseiler5078 5 лет назад

    There are videos with floor and tarja singing together I believe over the hills and far away is one such video . now with that being said each of the 3 singers have their place in the nightwish catalog. Annette was the first of their singers to draw me in with the superlative album imaginaerum, then I discovered tarja with the end of an Era album and it's diverse songs,but then I heard endless forms most beautiful and I fell deeply and hopelessly in love with floors vocals which have no peer as it is the voice from heaven an angels voice.

  • @SMBartwork
    @SMBartwork 5 лет назад

    His Name is Marco Hietala. He's also the singer of his band named Tarot since the 80's.