Very good voices, tho sometimes Ned's a bit wonky. Anyway big fan of theories in which Cersei's plan of "let's get Robert drunker than usual and see what happens" fails as it should
This is perfect but the only thing I’d change is instead of Robert saying “you’re on my seat, boy” I’d change it to “you’re on my seat, bastard” seems more fitting with got and the knowledge that he’s now a bastard
From what I can tell, Tywin's actions were faithful to the original books. He takes a massive gamble to say the least, but alternative would be to let his entire life's work fall to ruin. Even the very survival of his lineage is at stake (while omitted from the TV show, there's a separate "House Lannister of Lannisport" - still makes sense that Crown would seize Casterly Rock and only return it once sufficient loyalty is demonstrated, either to one of the Cersei's spawn or a Lannisport scion.) Also his plan somewhat mirrors "Battle on the Green Fork" in the original books: Roose Bolton realizes his army is the underdog, and decides to execute a bold night attack, hoping to throw the enemy into a disarray. Ironically the stronger army is led by Tywin.
I'd like to see "what if Daenerys had been born earlier". Viserys blamed her for the targaryen downfall because she'd been born "too late" and couldn't marry Rhaegar, so what if he got his wish?
What if Queen Mother Cersei's Great Sept of Baelor plot accidentally caused all of the wildfire under the city to explode, destroying the city and everyone inside of it that day?
@@King_Steffon_II All the kingdoms would declare their own independence (no throne= no symbol of a unified realm) and maybe even go to war for control of the crownlands
@@evan-bunch-of-numbers It would be an interesting what if to be honest...but pretty sure, Daenerys would need a new total conquest in that case, except for the Iron Islands (Yara) maybe, for sure the North, Dorne, the Reach, the Iron Islands and the Vale will declared independence, as they did in the show. Maybe Jaime will be the new head of House Lannister in that case, other options are his aunt Genna or his cousin Janei.
@@IceAlvaro13 Dany would be the second Conqueror, with dragons and all. I doubt she wants to spare Jaime, but if Tyrion is still her hand he'd convince her to let him take the black. Yara and the iron islands would get their independence, but everyone else would be subjugated again
I have a rough script for a story 'what if ned named jon snow a stark'? In it i also thought of robert training to become a warrior again. Love the stories where robert survives.
Poor Margaery, although I think Robert has changed, but still, there is a marriage similar to Viserys-Alicent in terms of age, but he needs a new Queen so it makes sense.
There would be only four seasons of game of thrones at best if Robert would have survived and stayed alive because that means Ned will survive too and told him the truth about „his“ children. Cersei and Her twin would be executed, the children too, the war of the 5 Kings would never happen and Robert has to fight house Lannister which will cause a lot of trouble for Robert because he financed his rule with a big part of Lannister money. But in the end he and his best friend Ned would obliterate them, Daenerys would have been assassinated, Jon would alert them of the threat beyond the wall, no dragons means no wallbreak for the nightking and his undead army. They would know of dragonglass and stannis would have delivered, in this case Jon would have killed the Nightking somehow because he has the biggest plot armor, arya lacks her training from jaqhen. That’s how game of thrones would look like with Robert alive and staying alive.
25:40 I haven’t double checked yet but Garlands already married at this point, & given how close the Tyrells are with the faith they COULD possibly get an annulment but would they want to risk it? I think not a large portion of their power comes from their ties to the faith and the maesters and risking it is worth more trouble then it’s worth
@ have you ever considered making part 2’s to some of you videos. I know with Star Wars the would be difficult because there are so many outside factors that could come into play but GOT has a sort of set sequence of events. Would love to see how Daenerys’ storyline or Jon’s story plays out in this what if
Okay I got to ask why did Kevin get executed? Like everybody else made sense but Kevin was just doing his duty and Stannis would likely see it that way as well
There is one part of this theory that doesn't make sense. Tywin tells his men not to carry any banners or sigils that can connect them to the Lannisters. But he still sends the mountain even though he's a known servant of Tywin and is one of the most recognizable people in Westeros.
What if Robb stark joind Stannis What if Robb married frey what if Stannis won battle of ice. What if Stannis won battle of blackwater. What if Edmure tully killed Mountain. What if Aemond killed Dameond. What if Greens won dance of dragons. What if Joffrey survied. What if Tommen survied
"Robert would've sooner named you Heir than me" .. Definitely bro really knows his brother. 🤣🤣🤣
😂😂
Very good voices, tho sometimes Ned's a bit wonky. Anyway big fan of theories in which Cersei's plan of "let's get Robert drunker than usual and see what happens" fails as it should
@@evan-bunch-of-numbers glad you enjoyed it !! Yeah haha working on the voice over time, a constant work in process. It’ll get better 😃
Seriously, bro’s blood is 75% ethanol at this point.
If he didn't die, we would've had 1 of them most unintentionally hilarious bro game of Thrones characters for at least 1 more season
Ned: Cersei's kids are bastards
Robert: Get the breastplate stretcher.... and the hammer
This is perfect but the only thing I’d change is instead of Robert saying “you’re on my seat, boy” I’d change it to “you’re on my seat, bastard” seems more fitting with got and the knowledge that he’s now a bastard
thats a great point, i like that, shouldve done it haha
@ keep up the great work though man this has been my favourite what if so far! I would even love to hear a continuation of this one!
Robert yelling at joffrey was so satisfying
Yeah, I wasn’t sure at first, but this is actually pretty good.
Glad you enjoyed it :)
I don’t know if Robert would’ve executed Kevan it’s likely he would’ve forced him to swear an oath and exchanged some hostages
We could have got Alex Jones to play old Robert 😂😂😂
lolol
I like how it ends with briefly touching on a best case scenario Sansa ending.
He would have gladly left King's Landing to Ned while he runs on a rampage at the North of the Wall against the dead.
Any story that ends with The Lannisters dead is a good story. Especially with Joffery getting nowhere near the throne.
@@mujahudin 100% agree
From what I can tell, Tywin's actions were faithful to the original books. He takes a massive gamble to say the least, but alternative would be to let his entire life's work fall to ruin. Even the very survival of his lineage is at stake (while omitted from the TV show, there's a separate "House Lannister of Lannisport" - still makes sense that Crown would seize Casterly Rock and only return it once sufficient loyalty is demonstrated, either to one of the Cersei's spawn or a Lannisport scion.)
Also his plan somewhat mirrors "Battle on the Green Fork" in the original books: Roose Bolton realizes his army is the underdog, and decides to execute a bold night attack, hoping to throw the enemy into a disarray. Ironically the stronger army is led by Tywin.
@@ThreeEyedTheorist I loved Robert's response to seeing Joffery sitting on The Iron Throne " you're in my seat boy! " Is Sooo Robert Baratheon 💯
I love how Littlefinger sounds a bit like Dr. Evil. 😂😂
Sweet channel though, I definitely subbed!
hahaha
I'm glad I got recommended you! More than happy to be subscriber number 10!
Happy to have you here 😃
this ending is too good! GRRM would never allow this to happen!
Dude I just binged all of your videos they are absolutely amazing good shit my G I’m super keen on more videos
@@codyorman121 coming soon :)
This was so good but way too wholesome
Beautiful work
Thank you!!
This would have been fun to watch unfold on the screen
Great work. Crazy how different the whole series is if like one crazy event changes in the first book.
@@bubbajFool thank you! 100% , everything is so intertwined in GoT
One of the best what if’s
Will keep making you proud
I hope you do some continuations of your videos sometime. They leave a lot of interesting possibilities for the future.
Hope y’all enjoy the video! Feel free to post any ideas you want to see in the comments :)
Gonna be posting 3 times a week for now, soon 4-5.
I'd like to see "what if Daenerys had been born earlier". Viserys blamed her for the targaryen downfall because she'd been born "too late" and couldn't marry Rhaegar, so what if he got his wish?
What if Queen Mother Cersei's Great Sept of Baelor plot accidentally caused all of the wildfire under the city to explode, destroying the city and everyone inside of it that day?
@@King_Steffon_II All the kingdoms would declare their own independence (no throne= no symbol of a unified realm) and maybe even go to war for control of the crownlands
@@evan-bunch-of-numbers It would be an interesting what if to be honest...but pretty sure, Daenerys would need a new total conquest in that case, except for the Iron Islands (Yara) maybe, for sure the North, Dorne, the Reach, the Iron Islands and the Vale will declared independence, as they did in the show.
Maybe Jaime will be the new head of House Lannister in that case, other options are his aunt Genna or his cousin Janei.
@@IceAlvaro13 Dany would be the second Conqueror, with dragons and all. I doubt she wants to spare Jaime, but if Tyrion is still her hand he'd convince her to let him take the black. Yara and the iron islands would get their independence, but everyone else would be subjugated again
This is really great work, a realistic take on the "what if?" situation for sure.
@@erdnusse277 glad you liked it !!
I have a rough script for a story 'what if ned named jon snow a stark'? In it i also thought of robert training to become a warrior again.
Love the stories where robert survives.
Love it. Now we need to see how this affects Dany and Faegons invasion
Now this is hypothetical I can get behind
these voices are pretty good!
amazing work, keep it up!
@@jhonygoedert200 thanks!! Gotchu 🫡
Dude, the Yorkshire accent for Sean Bean is on point! Impressive!
Sarcasm?
Because that Yorkshire accent is cockney not Yorkshire lol😂😂
@ nah man I mean it.
I’m subscribing just for the cool dark voice bro sounds like Batman 😂
Gods I was strong
The voices are so good! Is it some sampling AI?
Actually all VO :D thank you!!
Poor Margaery, although I think Robert has changed, but still, there is a marriage similar to Viserys-Alicent in terms of age, but he needs a new Queen so it makes sense.
There would be only four seasons of game of thrones at best if Robert would have survived and stayed alive because that means Ned will survive too and told him the truth about „his“ children.
Cersei and Her twin would be executed, the children too, the war of the 5 Kings would never happen and Robert has to fight house Lannister which will cause a lot of trouble for Robert because he financed his rule with a big part of Lannister money. But in the end he and his best friend Ned would obliterate them, Daenerys would have been assassinated, Jon would alert them of the threat beyond the wall, no dragons means no wallbreak for
the nightking and his undead army. They would know of dragonglass and stannis would have delivered, in this case Jon would have killed the Nightking somehow because he has the biggest plot armor, arya lacks her training from jaqhen. That’s how game of thrones would look like with Robert alive and staying alive.
I'd take this so we don't have the dreadful season 8 Game of Thrones.
Excellent video
Thank you!!
This was a damn banger
That’s aim, gotta make them all bangers 🙌
By the quality of the video, I was sure that the viewcount said 1.1M and not 1.1k.
You certainly deserve the former.
Wow thank you bro. Really appreciate that. All in due time 🫡
"Sooner or later, Cersei always gets what she wants" - Tyrion
Great vid man.
Glad you liked it 😎
This is intriguing
@@yojon4905 glad you think so
Didnt even know you had a got channel, awesome.
@@redterrorproductions1373 just started it :)
Loved it!!! woulld have been an awesome story to read!!! .... the Whitewalkers could have been Book 2 than....
I was a bit sad when there wasn't more X3
Don’t worry, there will be more videos asap 🥹
The only problem with this is that Garland Tyrell is already married and has kids so there no possibility of divorce
I have a good one for you: What if Aerys died at Duskendale?
Joffrey should have been forced to take the black.
Hmmm that would’ve been crazy , have all the bastard kids and Jamie go to the wall, execute Cersei lol
Ive always wondered what would happen if egg brought back the dragons at summerhall
Have a video coming this weekend, what if Robert Baratheons rebellion failed. You might find that happening in the story 👀
@ThreeEyedTheorist can't wait
25:40 I haven’t double checked yet but Garlands already married at this point, & given how close the Tyrells are with the faith they COULD possibly get an annulment but would they want to risk it? I think not a large portion of their power comes from their ties to the faith and the maesters and risking it is worth more trouble then it’s worth
Well done
Thanks Dave !
Star Wars and now Game of Thrones
You sir have earned my follow if you expand into anime I’ll be the first there👏🏾
@@jdgreen1802 soon enough :D
@ have you ever considered making part 2’s to some of you videos. I know with Star Wars the would be difficult because there are so many outside factors that could come into play but GOT has a sort of set sequence of events. Would love to see how Daenerys’ storyline or Jon’s story plays out in this what if
@@jdgreen1802 I think if they get popular enough there’s a possibility !
What if... Ramsay Bolton didn't kill Roose Bolton?
Okay I got to ask why did Kevin get executed?
Like everybody else made sense but Kevin was just doing his duty and Stannis would likely see it that way as well
he's still Tywin's right-hand man so it's possible they were afraid of him trying to retaliate.
What if viserys didn’t defend Luke’s claim
This is FUCKING BRILLIANT!!!! Just subscribed!
Glad you liked it!! 😄
That was fun.
I wish robert had exiled Geoffrey to old valyria with the greyscale victims realizing his son was actually an inbred abomination.
There is one part of this theory that doesn't make sense. Tywin tells his men not to carry any banners or sigils that can connect them to the Lannisters. But he still sends the mountain even though he's a known servant of Tywin and is one of the most recognizable people in Westeros.
I mean he did that in Mummer's Ford.
Kevin Lannister was good man.
Important question who does Robert marry next?
0:11 the gods wood?!
Yeah, the Godswood
Garland was already married wasn't he?
If only 😔
Hope
There would be no story.....
15
😎🫡
What if Robb stark joind Stannis What if Robb married frey what if Stannis won battle of ice. What if Stannis won battle of blackwater. What if Edmure tully killed Mountain. What if Aemond killed Dameond. What if Greens won dance of dragons. What if Joffrey survied. What if Tommen survied
90% of these you recommended are on my list to be done :)