Worse Than I Expected - MSI Claw In-Depth Review
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 3 июл 2024
- Links to my Social Media
▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰
Patreon 🅿️ / phawx
Twitter:🐦⬛ / carygolomb
Instagram: 📸 / thephawx
TikTok: 🎵 / thephawx
▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰▰
Chapters:
00:00 - The MSI Claw is really bad
01:16 - BIOS and Specs
02:45 - How To Unlock Advanced BIOS Menu
06:57 - WARNING Be CAREFUL in the unlocked BIOS
07:37 - MSI Claw Bugs and Intel Driver Problems
08:24 - Fixing Intel Driver Problems - Batman Arkham Knight
11:26 - Extremely High Idle Power, just unreal
15:26 - Comparing Intel to AMD is Difficult. You Can't Just Compare TDP to TDP
16:54 - Something Positive to say about INTEL!!
17:50 - Battery Life
19:01 - Per TDP GPU-Bound Synthetic Benchmark Comparisons
20:07 - Per TDP ADJUSTED FOR TOTAL SYSTEM POWER
20:47 - Cyberpunk 2077 10w / 15w / 20w / 25w Benchmarks
23:14 - Deus Ex Mankind Divided 10w / 15w / 20w / 25w Benchmarks
25:06 - Horizon Zero Dawn 10w / 15w / 20w / 25w Benchmarks
26:42 - Red Dead Redemption 2 10w / 15w / 20w / 25w Benchmarks
28:12 - Returnal 10w / 15w / 20w / 25w Benchmarks
30:36 - Remember When I Said It Was Impossible To Recommend?
31:14 - What If I Disable E-Cores?!
31:33 - DOOM Eternal P and E Cores Enabled
32:31 - DOOM Eternal E Cores Disabled
33:13 - DOOM Eternal Steam Deck OLED
34:03 - DOOM Eternal Asus ROG ALLY
34:27 - SteamDeck OLED Still Champ
35:20 - MSI Center Needs A Bunch of Work
41:45 - MSI Build Quality Review
47:33 - Standby Modes / VRR Panel / Fan Loudness
48:25 - How Can I Recommend This?
#MSI #MSICLAW #PCGAMING 
Игры
That transition from thumbnail to video was truly amazing
Thanks!
Fr i was like sike that's so sick!!
On God
Honestly true
@@ThePhawx hopefully you continue this style - it's so perfect
Oh boy! Those first 5 seconds alone got me mentally prepared for what is about to unfold!
''Hello everyone I am the Phawx and today I am dissapointed''
He does the same intro when he looks in the 🪞
@@Asfanboy1 hahaha gat damn
My man
@@ThePhawx So Intel Technology in Early-2024 is almost performing as good as AMD Technology from Early-2020. As expected.
The Valve SteamDeck, ASUS ROG Ally, and GPD Win Max. That are the devices to consider. Forget the rest. They may have their charms, or tiny niche, but this trifecta has been it for the past 2 years and will remain for 2 years more.
@@ekintekoWeird that Intel's first generation real attempt at a GPU architecture doesn't hold up to a company with almost 30 years of experience in the field.
As i've said before, this should have been called "MSI Flaw".
Just like when the steam deck was first out. Lol
msi CLAWN 🤡
I blame Intel, not msi.
@@coolhawk2003 Heh VERY different. This is not fixable.
@@X862go Yep, true.
this guy is way more thorough than eta prime he should have more subs
ETA should honestly be loosing more subs with how much of payed shill he became.
ETA is just a glorified commercial channel. I unsubbed from him over a year ago. He's no longer a trustworthy review channel.
Eta prime is one of the worst tech youtubers ever, if you can even call him a tech youtuber
It's expected. The Phawk's videos are very technical. ETA stuffs are more "bite-sized" and "for the mass". Easy, short video will get more views (hence subs) than technical, long video. It's been working like that for every type of media consumption ever.
@@tuanld91ETA doesn’t criticize.
Intel must be paying a good chunk of money for handheld companies to partner with them despite already knowing how good the amd chips are
Or selling the chip at a HUGE discount
@@GodofGHz Which would be great is that got passed onto the consumer. I would consider buying an Intel handheld if it had a nice hook like being a clamshell and it was a good price. This is more expensive than the ROG ally besides the great value of the steam deck.
I completely agree and I think this statement can be extended to the entire laptop market. Idk if intel's throwing money at the right persons from every big brands or what but that's definitely weird.
It's not that, Intel offers long term contract, these companies like MSI and One X Player infact paying more to get these chips but they did because they believe Intel will beat AMD in coming generations.....
If that's Arm chips related or not I'm not sure, but I know that some companies if not majority believe Intel will beat AMD in terms of APUs soon
@@TRX25EX Nobody believes Intel will beat AMD in the long run handhelds because it's clear they're scaling down desktop cpu's. So with Intels desktop CPUs drawing insane amount of power just to keep up with AMD, scale that down and then do the math. Amd is making custom APUs for OEMs JUST for handhelds. Also Intel also historically gave rebates to OEM not to use AMD, which may or may not be illegal. So I'm guessing they're either giving rebates to MSI just to get some hold in the handheld market, or they forced MSI to use their chipset or they would withhold cpu's from them in the future for their laptops. People also forgot companies GPD used intel a few years ago and it sucked ass.
Curious how many other youtubers 'break down' this handheld but neglect to go this far into it.
Well done.
Most youtubers are just salesmen who sell off their reviews for getting devices for free and getting viewers!
Thanks!
Not to mention.. nobodys actually breaking it down. They dont even remove the back.
Warranty sticker.. Warranty is history if you swap ssd.
@@hornantuutti5157which is illegal in the US. You have a right to repair. They cannot void a warranty for simply opening up your device.
My personal oppinion is MSI had NO interest entering into the handheld market but intel probably gave them a ton of money to make a handheld with intel chips inside to take on the marketshare with AMD. That explains why the claw resembles the ROG Ally so much, Someone on Reddit was able to find purchase orders where it appears MSI bought parts from ASUS or the company that makes the components for ASUS.
If MSI took this serious they could of had a killer device on their hand, instead they just released a sub par product. And for the people that said the Steam Deck, ROG Ally and Legion go all had issues when they first launched, yes you are correct they did however MSI also had almost a year since the ROG Ally launched to be able to get things tweaked and working properly. One would expect the claw should at least be on par with the current handhelds not this far behind.
They basically rushed it out to get a quick buck and now it's gonna bite them in the as.
Finally something that i can skip! Tired of some RUclipsrs recomend every single gadget. Some be like : "i am a huge fan of ..."
thanks for the video!
That describes about 99% of the tech youtubers out there, stick to those who give an honest review, they are a reare species, thanks ThePhawx
Like the fraud ETA PRIME
I can smell the scent of ETA PRIME in that comment.... And I totally agree
Some tech channels are more like "influencers" (marketers) than reviewers.
I love the way it transitions from thumbnail to video
This is what RUclips needs more. Good informative high quality videos with a nice presentation. Thank you for your work, im always happy to see a video of yours.
Gulp GULP 🤤
Poor Russ took this thing on his trip to Japan
He must've had a boring flight after the battery died 😂
He undoubtedly has a smaller handheld as a backup lol
A handheld that basically needs to be plugged in at all times really sucks. What a bummer.
Lol hold my beer game gear 😂
Great intro from the thumbnail. I dont think ive ever seen anyone do that in all the years ive watched youtube. Well done and subbed
Wow, that 50 minutes FLEW by. That's a good thing! To me and my brain that means you didn't doddle or wafer too much on a single thing. You didn't beat any dead horses, you stuck to the point, and changed topics and talking points perfectly. This is what I would call a gold standard on a deep dive review; not too long, not too short, and never did I feel the need to CMD-Tab over to something else.
Nice profile pic
Late to game and not cheap enough... wtf is Intel thinking?
This key combo was known back on the old MSIbooks on notebookreview, back in 2016! Amazing that it's still there.
It's basically the AMI menus that are locked out. But some options don't do anything.
Also, the VRM "trip" current limit (hard shutdown), sometimes linked to SKU ICCMAX, can't be controlled by hidden advanced menus, as this is hardware specific and has to be enabled as an option by MSI directly.
I love that transition from thumbnail to video you're doing. You're probably the first one I watched who did that. Keep that up!
Appreciate it!
The king talked.
That means a lot to me! Thank you so much
@ThePhaw, you've been my only one recommendation since I had the first GPD WIN.
That intro trick still gets me everytime. Excellent job!
Im soo glad you did this video! Cause I know you don't mess around and tells it how it really is! Great job on the video!
Really wonder why they went with intel for a "Gaming handheld" there game driver is still not on par with amd or nvidia.
intel probably begged a few companies and MSI is a good little doggy.
They probably gave the chips basically for free.
You know it’s bad when the phawx hates it. Just get a deck or an ally (sale)
EDIT: Oops forgot the legion go
or legion go
Legion Go is the best in my opinion and I will hope a refresh on Ally
Good thing I found the ally on sale @best buy for $399.
A legion Go is more appropriate, Either that or the steam Deck oled
Either way I'd maybe go with a deck than Legion Go, Steam Deck I previously owned. Rog Ally is not shady at all. I dimmed down most of all settings I had no reason for use including bloatware. I got the adrenalin driver up and going. Also as far as playtime with the battery on Cyberpunk and Call Of Duty MW2 it's acceptable for me. On the Steam Deck CyberPunk drains more rapidly and I'm only playing on the z1 processor model. I really don't even get my games above the 80°F heat mark.
I had backed the OneXPlayer X1 Ultra (same chip as the claw) and dropped support for many of the reasons this video showed.
First clue was OneX would stall when asked for true numbers showing frame rates between AMD and Intel - and the made handhelds that used both chips. Got worse stalling when asking for lower wattage data between the chips.
Was waiting for this review. Not sure drivers can fix a lot of this….
I guarantee they’ll be launching an AMD version sooner or later, you know it. They should have stuck to what they know with their previous models and used AMD.
Intel and good drivers don't match. Like ever since. Just take a look at the Arc GPU users asking for updates.
Was so waiting for @ThePhawx 's review on this. Got to make some time for watching it
Lol, i love ur thumbnail to video transitions Carey.
Now i see why u werent in the nerdnest podcast yesterday lol.😂
Been waiting for this! I've seen so many other reviews and I could tell the reviewer was trying their hardest to not totally say it was garbage. I've been waiting for yours because you tell the brutal truths we need! Keep up the good work!
Thanks! Truthfully I tend to want to be positive myself, but I couldn't find anything redeeming here.
@@ThePhawx Does the APU use Arc tech? Because I bought ARC and one of their issues is consumption while idle.
Maybe is a flaw in the XE cores of Arc tech that continues even in an APU form.
Extremely informative and very well presented. This same Claw chassis would be great with an AMD APU.
Amazing in-depth review, subbed
wait the way the thumbnail transitions into the video was amazing i wish more channels do that
I'm happy that intel is in the scene to compete. Unfortunate that this device has so many shortcomings
First handheld flop of 2024. Glad I didn’t pre-order this garbage. Will wait on ROG Ally 2 and hopefully they won’t use Intel iGPU.
My bet is strix point......
Just get a steam deck
That is a sick transition from the thumbnail.
Yea I liked it too. Was a different approach
Thanks!
Very nice video review the best I’ve seen so far. I see the high idle wattage on this is very much like the issues on the arc graphics cards. I’d say this is hardware related issues and won’t be fixed and again the drivers took a year to improve but a lot needed again to fix games. I agree it’s not recommended to buy this device as the next gen Amd will be around the corner and are power efficient. I want a competitive market maybe intel down the line can improve
The best review by far the tear down the breakdown of power consumption shutting things off going into the BIOS this is all the s*** I want to know first time finding the channel best review by far looking forward to many more videos awesome keep up the good work I subscribed👊
It’ll be interesting to see how this develops as the firmware etc matures.
For me it’s not an option at the moment as there seems to be an exclusive seller in the UK and they aren’t a company I’d willingly buy from
im happily waiting for my VRR capable gpd win mini. so done with this controller setup on windows. trackpads are essential
Excellent work!
That thumbnail to video transition 🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶
I've never watched a video where you could hear disappointment in the reviewer's voice for the whole 50 minute video
Thanks for being so dedicated Phawx, I really appreciate the time and effort you put into your videos!
Thank you :)
Woah, that thumbnail to video transition is slick
In 2024 steam deck oled with its price tag, performance at low tdp, accessibility, software support, trackpads, steam input, and flexible and open source Linux base, has just NO competition. Raw power is nothing. Control, optimization and the good user experience on the software side is key. And the steam deck is just on another level.
Absolutely
Some games might be better suited to a laptop but having the ability to just game, without Windows. Windows is still the main issue. And sure most people go around it but I already have a laptop with Windows, that's more than enough Windows
It is, but some of us really need more of a handheld laptop rather than a mobile gaming console. That's why I ended up selling my Steam Deck after getting my lenovo legion go. The Deck is a fantastic device, and the new OLED one especially is amazing for gaming- but sometimes I a tablet to browse the web and I actually do need raw CPU grunt. Battery life isn't a concern for me
It has no competition at that price point. But if you're looking for a portable AAA machine the steam deck falls behind FAST
Steam Deck = best value
Legion Go = best overall
I literally only have a gpd for anything the deck can't play. It's so enjoyable playing on the deck though hands down
Love the honesty man!
It's amazing that in the last 5 years AMD went from having no products of any particular value to now creating and commanding the entire handheld PC market (Yes Valve helped a lot but AMD had to develop the architecture to use in that application in the first place).
Nvidia is too busy printing money with AI. Once Nvidia gets serious about the handheld PC market, I expect them to dominate like they do in the PC market in general.
@@xuimodIt's more a big if than a "once". NVIDIA has the Switch, and that's worth a lot more than the PC mobile gaming market.
@@xuimod Nvidia can't make an APU based on x86 because they don't have the rights so that will never happen.
@@SIPEROTH Nvidia can make an APU based on ARM, and with Microsoft looking to expand into the "high performance" ARM device market (as evidenced by the Surface Pro 9 that has a Microsoft spec SnapDragon), it's safe to bet that they'd back that horse the nanosecond Nvidia could produce something with the horse power to allow x86 emulation good enough to keep up with what current iGPUs can handle.
this is an upload you need . you got a like and sub dude
Great review!
How is it in emulators? Should be good, no? With all those cores
holly crap i just realize i watch this 50-minute long video.
Thanks!
Knowledge is like a vast ocean; the more we explore, the deeper it becomes, and the greater our understanding of its boundless depths. @@ThePhawx
Man i subscribed cause i like the depth of your reviews. Please make legion go next. See ya
Would have been interesting to see different core counts (4P+4e) and (4P) to see if it improves as should reduce power the cpu tile draws
Give it 3 or 4 months tops for the MSI Claw price to drop drastically, every outlet and channles have the consistency of being disappointed and turned off by the Claws performance overall, especially seeing a RUclips channel made a video saying why their returning their claw
Love that the first 8 minutes of the review is a deep-dive into advanced BIOS settings. Never change Phawx.
Hey this is porbably such a weird comment, but that thumbnail tranistion into the video was really cool, wasn't expecting to mouse over a video in my feed and see soemthing that smooth, it immediately drew me in!
Excellent depth. Great job.
Much appreciated!
First time watching and that transition from thumbnail to video was impressive
Thankyou!
That thumbnail transition caught me so off guard that I had to double take AND double check
It's sad but kinda hilarious that the MSI claw is already with 100€ (around 108 USD) discount here in Amazon Germany. It's still 100€ more expensive than the Ally Z1extreme (the lower end MSI Claw!). What was MSI thinking?!
Thank you Phawx
How do you not reach 100k? This quality is insane and the amount of work...
nintendo stuff
Most people aren't into the technical details and jargon, it's boring. I like this channel and even I had to skip like a third of the video
handheld PCs are finally mainstream but still dwarfed by Nintendo and regular PC gaming
It’s crazy because people said this wouldn’t be good before it even launched.. damn.
for a copycat of the Ally it's DoA, it's slow, it looks like those chinese no-brand generic pc controllers and in my country they charge it slightly above the Ally w/ Z1 Extreme, the nerve.
Perfect circularity should be the desirable and more logical result since the stick gate is circular thus should map into circle, but the main issue is mostly whether the app/game mapped to a more square result or circle result. Is a game accept 1,1 as the most bottom right corner or some value that correspond to the actual stick position in a circle (which definitely will be lower than on each axis). The difference can be that a stick that have more square shape in the circularity test can have more range of motion or the stick can have an outside dead zone which is not desirable when you want it to be precise. The reverse is also true, where a stick with perfect circularity can ended up have less range of motion or being more precise.
As for power consumption, this is basically the same problem that AMD encounter with their chiplet design which is higher idle power. There is really no way around it, something with chiplet or multiple chip glued together will have power consumption penalty. Intel trying to mitigate it with basically have the main SoC tile that contains pretty much everything to run the device (thus 2 low power E-cores) thus they can disable the compute/CPU tile, but probably still not enough to reach the same idle efficiency as non tile architecture. AMD Phoenix and Hawk Point are of course monolithic thus didn't have the glue penalty. Honestly I don't think this is something that can be solved entirely. Maybe with more optimization you can get the power consumption to be closer to a monolithic architecture but again, it will never be as efficient as a monolithic approach. Physics.
for msi first time doing handheld i think theres definitely improvements. with the recent software updates i see on their website i hope those help with performance!
This is the best analysis of Meteor Lake's performance in video games, I always hate that in these types of videos people use FSR or XeSS with like 50% internal resolution.
how does it compares on the emulation side of things? specially interested on rpcs3
I had this new generation mini pc .. .same story right 😅
looking to see the driver update that could make things better :)
I knew this (MSI Claw) would be hot garbage.
These chips are interesting. From what one can garner, them basically chopping up the chip and futzing more with Northbridge and segmenting it more, are we not just adding latency and inefficiency? There's a reason why old monolithic architectures feel snappy .
Your review was what I was waiting for. Now to wait also for Gamer's Nexus and Retro Game Corps reviews to see their thoughts
With the idle power draw, did you turn the E-cores back on? Would that make a difference?
What an excellent review! We need more honest reviews like this with people who know what they are talking about. Well done sir!
Great vid. Am thinking between the rog ally and this, but watching this video you convinced me not to buy it lol. Do you have a similar video about the rog ally? Am curious about undervolt if is posible. Thanks
every thing i own is amd, my laptop, my desktop, my original steam deck, my legion go heck even my ps5 has AMD chips it in.
sick transition
Ok this was the last and best video i needed,,i factory resetted my Claw I7 and its back in the box…refund it tommorow
This review really needed some indie game benchmarks to highlight even more the power struggles, we could see how 10w was performing in AAA games but how does 10w perform in indie games like dead cells etc because we know handhelds like steam deck can play those kinds of games set to 4w and get 60fps plus and the ally can play those games pretty comfortable set to its minimum 7w meaning on steam deck i can achieve 12 hours plus battery life in some cases and the ally i get around 4 hours still set to 7w so terrible but we all knew that... at least it still performs well... it seems like set to 10w the claw is barely able to function and this may crumble even indie game performance, so would have been good to see some indie testing, especially considering that these machines are perfect for indie typically, far more so than AAA gaming.
great in depth review as always though, cheers.
Shout out : Great work on equalizing the power consumption across these diverse chipsets, giving a much more reliable and useful perf/w comparison.
Disable xmp or reduce xmp memory voltage to reduce power draw. And if available try real-time memory overclocking to regain xmp at load
This is the heat we've been waiting for. I got my coffee and danish ready.
The thumbnail transition hits extra hard today 😂
Just a crazy thought, possile to only use E cores?
what I take from this - - is just how awesome AMD did in making their mobile/game soc/platform. We are years into this now, and Intel really has no viable answer.
And the AMD chip is set to use LESS power while still having better performance.
sorry but the way the thumbnail blends into the video is just fantastic
The L1 and R1 trigger buttons on the Claw are too uncomfortable and just don't cut it for me, and I'm glad I've picked up the ROG Ally much earlier.
It's now my main computer too!
Regarding the power, especially idle power, I wouldn't put all the blame on Intel. I found out from Wolfgang's channel that different motherboards and the number of ports and if they're connected or not, can matter a lot, especially visible in power draw. Also, Windows itself is pinnacle of bloat. Seeing 216 !! processes at 6:37 makes me think that MSI did jack $#!t at debloating Windows. Also also MSI's own MSI Center, I wouldn't bet on it being made to be power efficient.
So, what I'm trying to say, I wouldn't be surprised AT ALL if it's all MSI's fault for the power management. If this is fixable through software, driver and firmware updates... that's another question. Hopefully it is, but it's not guaranteed.
Very solid review though! Is there a chance we can see more fiddling with cores active ? Like only running on E cores, or only running with 4 P cores. Checking with and without the 2 LP E cores. Checking if it can be undervolted. Things like that. Oh, and manually trying to debloat Windows, who knows, it might actually do wonders :))
It was particularly a long vid, but informative. He should test it out with the latest update Intel arc released. Since it imported games significantly
The review i was waiting for
I hope you can bring some insight of the new MSI Claw 8 AI+ and if that one will solve the many flaws of this one , also release date , price , etc , so we can know if it will be an alternative to the Ally X (if the price is around the 800)
Picked up the Rog ally recently so good in terms of performance. good it doesn't have intel.
Thanks, Phawx 👍
Question. Do u still testing the oled screen at the back there?
That intro was hilarious
Why don't the windows handhelds have TRACKPADS?
First: you misspelled trackpads
Second: there’s a thing called the legion go
For serious. After having used the Steamdeck a couple of years I cannot comprehend how anyone can even use one of these type of PCs without at least one track pad. Especially with windows, I cannot imagine using one of these things without access to a track pad or one of the optical sensor things that some devices use instead of a track pad.
@@PM-xc8ooIf you have a proper touch friendly desktop like gnome you don't really need it
@@PM-xc8ooTrack pads are a heavenly feature
GPD Win Mini and Win Max do have trackpads, and the Win 4 has one of those optical fiddly bits.
The unit has such high spikes even on idle. What are the causes of these spikes? They must be the same that cause it to freeze frequently while playing.
That’s sad, would’ve loved more competition and everyone having platform, Nvidia with Switch/2, AMD with Steam Deck(OLED and whatever is next), ROG Ally/2 and Legion Go and last but not least Intel with MSI Claw. 2 questions, what kind of panel does it use? 1080p 120Hz VRR LCD like Ally? And can you change color of each individual face button? So I can change them to lit up only in Xbox button colors? Thanks in advance for answering!
I don't understand why MSI decided to partner up with Intel on this.
It was basically DOA on launch. I know exactly 0 people who are interested in this product.
money, intel surely paid
Thanks man, appreciate all the hard work you do. Very informative and honest, keep the great work!
Any hope for this? I’m happy with the OLED Deck but more competition and choices is a good thing
Very interesting results!
Curious if you compare the MSI Claws idle power consumption to the One X Players Intel 155H device, if you will see the same high idle power consumptions, just to do (albeit low sample size) a like for like comparison from different hardware manufactures?
Just curious if the power consumption can be corrected with a different bios update or something.
TBH tho, I don't think it really matter, the drivers are terrible.