There is nothing to "predict" for Ukraine. They get all their money from the United States taxpayer; they are not an independent country, they are a protectorate.
Russias central bank says that Russia will start having big problems soon due to war costs and sanctions. Ukraine is being aided. Do you want her to predict how long Ukraine will be aided?
The cold war formula sanction against Soviet Union failed. Unlike Soviet Union, Russia is outsourcing from multipolar world including China, India, Turkey, South America, ASEAN and Africa. It hurts Russia economy but it hurts both ways, especially the EU.
They buy because it s cheaper. Everyone has a set of needs. If you don't get it from a then u get it from b. Put up barrier means you would get your needs at a premium prices. If Germany wants to pay more, I bet everyone else would happy to comply.
What products? Russia has almost no products of its own. And countries in Africa and Asia have always been cheated and exploited by Russia. Countries in Africa could develop on their own, but they are robbed by Russia and China.
@@shawners198shawn4 diversification market,, that is russia do now and the future,, russia resource, oil,gas, will penetrate asia, south america, africa, market,, far away from europe,, for russia if europe choose expensive usa oil n gas, its up to them,, for russia have realize, russia future not in europe,, anyway sun rise in the east,, and set in the west,, bon apetit from your policy eu.
As an Indian our people will support more than 90% for Russia and no one can dictate terms and conditions by Europe or USA and sooner Germany will be overtaken bu india...
USA/Europe are even harrasing some Global South countries who are doing normal trade with Russia. This move has backfired as many countries who were neutral at the start of Ukraine war are now openly supporting Russia and want to join BRICS to get rid of Western unilateral sanctions
No guys we 90% of Indian doesn't know where is Russia & Ukrain in map We have tons of our problems like extreme Poverty, Unemployment, Corruption,Broken infrastructure, cleanliness we have to deal with thse things. Ya some lunatic from ruling party BJP definitely support Russia & but not everyone we're on the side of peace.
In a global economy, a country the size of Russia, with the resources it has, is impossible to isolate. It has an abundance of food and energy, two of the most critical needs in human life. No amount of Western finger wagging will stop people who are cold and hungry....
Well,THAT resources are exactly the real reason for this war. Anything else are lies and smoke and mirrors. I mean the US is desparate. They overplayed their hand for decades and the time window they can do anything is closing before the S... hits the fan.
@@karlvonbahnhof6594 ya know, not everyone who lives in Africa leaves Africa, right? Some folks actually love where they live. Africa is a beautiful country, but I'm sure your hatred towards the brown folk have you blinded by that... "Immigrate to Russia"... LOL.. so petty
Far from being crippled, Russia's economy is growing in 2024 as well. The International Monetary Fund predicts that Russia will record economic growth of 3.2% this year and that is still more than in any of the world's advanced economies. “Debilitating” the mother of all sanctions imposed on Russia have not produced shortages in the shops
GDP includes government spending. Buying expensive scrap metal to place in a field is not a good economic strategy, but that is what Russia is doing. How do you think that will work out for them?
@@lifestapestry2968 this is what I'm trying to explain to people. I am in Russia for the past 10 years. Interest rate is at 19 percent. Inflation at 9 percent. 1 dollar was 29 rubles now it's 95 rubles. How is this a sign of heskthy economy? These news channels are spreading lies.
The Russian economy is based on raw materials, not on a healthy economy in which all people can be entrepreneurs. Russia has nothing and will now be dependent on China, and China will take advantage of them and may even take over Russia's land that it considers its own. They will probably wait until Russia weakens enough. Already, most of the cars on the streets of Russia are Chinese and most of the products come from china. If Russian companies start to go bankrupt, the market will be taken over more and more by the Chinese. Russia will become China's puppet.
but here in the US we are quite happy and also stupefied... the europeans are buying our liquified natural gas that has to be shipped over the atlantic ... i think more and more that the EU is the one that will get seriously shafted when this conflict is over
For the fact they still ask these questions on media That’s showns that the Economy is strong It’s a clear Example, if they economy have failed we would have seen the western leaders making mockery of Russia Federation live on TV Russian Economy is vast and strong
#1 Economy in Europe? Not for a long time. Besides, basing it on fictitious GDP (war production) is not wise. Russia's economy is collapsing. It will take time, but it is inevitable.
The Russian economy might be nr1, in Russia, but in Europe? No! The IMF has forecasted a GDP of 4,591,100 MUSD for Germany, 3,495,261 MUSD for the United Kingdom, 3,130,014 MUSD for France, 2,328,028 MUSD for Italy and 2,056,844 MUSD for Russia, for 2024. So, I don’t know where you get your numbers from?
who cares about gdp especially when india has 11x more population than germany. Per capita is what matters. And by the way India in its majority is incredibly poor.
@@23Amadeus92 who tell you that ur gutter media? Uk have more poverty % than India.🤣🤣India is one of least expensive country in world. We can buy 2000$ which you can't in 10,000 $.
@@Nehas949 Be honest with yourself don't be so proud. It's ok to be proud of your country but come on you cannot be seriously comparing UK living standards to India. And by the way who has 2k dollars to spend in India? what percentage of the population?
@@23Amadeus92 lol you can't compare India with tiny country like uk that's make uk situation even worst. I have seen many Britisher living way worst than average India. New Delhi is way safe than London. Pickpocketing and shoplifting is not rampant crime in india. Even it's not normal even being 1.4 billions people like uk. Stop being delusional about own country and others. I can clearly see poverty is decreasing rapidly only 3% India live below poverty Line unlike many in west.
Eu yes but us planned this for them it is all good as long as they "help" with usd, which nobody can pay back(without selling ones state) usd(paper) is gonna be just fine. For them its an investment
In retrospect - America's proxy war was a blessing in disguise for Russia. Their economy is focused primarily eastwards towards China now and is healthier than ever. Great leadership from Vladimir Vladimirovich 🇷🇺🐻💪
It's not a blessing.. I am in Russia for the past 10 years 1 dollar was = 28 rubles Now it's 95 rubles Inflation is 9 percent Interest rate is 19 percent. That's not a sign of a health economy. Things are rough here. Don't belive everything the news says.
This is nonsense. Averagecrussians are defaulting on loans at an accelerating rate. Remember the scenes of collapsing dams and flooded villages? Russia is a mess.
Sanctions will never ever hurt Russian federation because they have the resources that China and everyone are looking for, so if you think that sanctions could hurt Russia that means you're leaving in the past
Sanctions are working But europe is selling stuff that Kremlin needs to Georgia, Armenia , Kazahstan etc... when sells are going up 500% in these states and nobody asks why... we are to blame why sanctions aren't going that efficient
it's a method of cooking a frog - if you introduced everything at once, it would probably be bad for everyone in the world. So everyone, step by step, turns back from Russia and its economy. Moreover, Putin himself has also caused the poor condition of the Russian economy with his actions - now it will only be more visible to everyone and will continue to progress.
There is no better pasta than Asian pasta. The Italians can only learn from the Asians, if they had not already done so in Marco Polo's time. Italy probably permanently lost a large market with these boomerang sanctions. And the Russians will enjoy even more luxurious goods.🤣
The average russian does not even have a toilet at home or connected water. What are you writing about? Luxury goods? Only Moscow and St. Petersburg are cities that look like a normal civilized world, and the rest of russia still lives in the Middle Ages. 14 million russians living on the equivalent of USD 180 a month at least. Inflation is about 30% now there. According to Rosstat (which presents a false reality anyway - it provides data convenient for the authorities so the information about poverty in Russia probably looks even worse in reality) in the year 2023 over 11.2 percent russian families said they had difficulty buying clothes and paying housing and utility bills. Another 48.7 percent it is not possible to purchase durable goods. Only 36.6 percent families have enough money for this, but they cannot afford a car, an apartment or a summer house. The percentage of families that are able to buy everything they need, including real estate, is, according to official statistics, 3.4%. If Putler spends nearly 50% of the state budget on the war and not on its citizens, it will only get worse and worse.
The sanctions that have been imposed on Russia, it has been said only in the western media that Russia has become weak due to the sanctions, but in reality the sanctions have made no difference to Russia and nothing can harm Russia in the future too. But in spite of all this Russia is winning and is also standing and is stronger than before. All this is a slap on the face of NATO and America because the sanctions imposed with wrong intentions to cause harm to a country and its people are never successful when imposed by any country.
I'm favoured only God knows how much I praise Him, $230k every 4weeks! I now have a big mansion and can now afford anything and also support God’s work and the church.
Only God knows how much grateful i am. After so much struggles I now own a new house and my family is happy once again everything is finally falling into place!!
I think the men and women in charge of the Russian economy deserves a noble peace price..just imagine, Russia is the heavily sanctioned country on earth....and still thriving
Russia exports for 2022 was $631.55B, a 15.01% increase from 2021. Russia exports for 2021 was $549.14B, a 44.11% increase from 2020. Russia exports for 2020 was $381.07B, a 20.84% decline from 2019. Russia exports for 2019 was $481.41B, a 5.67% decline from 2018. Russia's exports in 2023 only with Asian countries, amounted to 306.6 billion U.S. dollars.
china has problems and india is a poor country. No country ruled by dictators will ever be rich and sooner or later their economies will collapse, because in a dictatorship there is no truth, only lies, manipulation, and pretense.
@@Polans-gd it has very little to do with democracy it is about education ,industrialisation & resource management. US is biggest supporter of dictator around the world in pakistan, Saudi Arabia, egypt, UAE, Qatar even their forces are present there to protect them so kindly do not sell this lollypop here with your own double standards. since world is becoming more & more Independent unilateral sanction will not work any more . US canada norway are biggest beneficiary of this oil & gas sanction they are producing more & more from where India purchase oil 🛢. iran is already under sanction Venezuela is sanctioned too than from where middle east region controlled & ruled by dictators backed by US?
Will sanctions ever hurt any other country is a more relevant question. The war in Ukraine has just accelerated multipolarity, thus negating the threat posed by sanctions.
Are they now allowed to mention the word Geopolitics? If they had called this war geopolitical, then the Russian concerns could have come to light and a solution could have been found. But no, it was about 'Democracy' and 'Our Way of Life'.
Biggest issue with EU and USA is you guys think a Stock exchange Market and GDP amounts to raw materials and good living. Money is paper, it cannot replace a tangible resource like gas , oil , farming , and other minerals that Russia has and 80% of the world needs. Energy is more important than an over inflated GDP
Once, after the Great Depression Kaynesian war economy made America great again. it came out of WWII as the by far biggest economy of the world. So why shouldn't this work to some extent also in Russia? And why, on the other hand, would we believe an economist who has been consistently wrong for more than two years?
The American economy was not based solely on war production, and the Russian economy is based on this. Germany during World War II also had a high GDP during the war, because it mainly produced weapons, and when the war ended, everything collapsed. The Russians rely on their oil deposits, but they do not have the appropriate technology, they misuse their sources, so they will not last long, and the quality of their oil is not high. And Russia without its resources and with a collapsing economy is a Russia of little importance in the world.
Siemens faced significant financial losses due to its exit from the Russian market. The company reported a total hit of approximately €600 million directly related to its decision to wind down operations in Russia following the war in Ukraine. This included a non-cash charge for writing down assets and terminating its industrial activities, which impacted their quarterly earnings. Despite having been active in Russia for nearly 170 years, Siemens prioritized sanctions compliance and withdrew from key sectors such as energy and transportation
If you believe the hype that comes of Russia . But if you know anything about economics you realise that Russia is heading for serious Stagflation. You only have to look at the collapse of the Ruble as a currency . The lack of inward investment. The inability to raise capital . The rapid rise of the countries deficit . And worst still the lack of workers,a shortfall of over 2 million and rising as more and more are killed on the battlefield.
So basically, Putin is burning through foreign currency reserves in order to pour billions of rubles into the Russian economy and has already burnt through half of those reserves. Meanwhile, massive tax hikes on Russia's oil and gas industry, while they may be bringing in more tax in the same way hyper-inflation at around 20% is bringing in more tax, is also taking away money that is needed to reinvest in further expansion in the industry. While the military industries are booming, they are also paying better wages than the civilian manufacturers can afford meaning a shortage of workers and hence increased prices for consumer goods which further feeds inflation.Sure, Russian government figure can point at the money nicely squirreled away in Chinese banks but at the same time they appear to fail to realise this is playing right into Chinese hands and swinging the balance of power between the two allies even further in China's direction. Even if the war stops today it will take years for the Russian economy to recover and meanwhile Russia's supporters desperately try to tell us it's fine, nothing to see here. It's my Russian friends I feel sorry for, this is not their war and yet they are the ones paying for it.
What I am not understanding is that the same is happening in western countries. They are also producing a lot of weapons. Why isn't there an economic progress like the one in Russia?
@@ViciousSorina really, lol, the rubbles crashing, loss of revenue, loss of gas supply, loss of Russians that fled the country, should i go on ? Or maybe you just don’t understand what crashes an economy. Putin has and continues to destroy Russia because his ego won’t allow him to see what he did to his people.
According to the IMF, the GDP/capita is 54 291 USD in Germany (position 18 in the world) and the Russian GDP/capita is 14 391 USD (position 66 in the world). So, by definition the Germans, on average, are almost 4 times wealthier than the Russians. The pensions in Russia are about 15 000 to 30 000 rubles, per month, which is approximately 166 to 332 USD. If you would like to buy a used Japanese car in Russia, you have to pay twice as much as you have to pay in USA.
Russia is too big, too resourceful and too proud to collapse. They also have the legacy of Soviet Union, so they have a certain degree of sympathy within the developing world. Plus they have already faced the evil of secessionism. Economies will always rise and fall, but Russia will always remain a decent power.
Russia is a food and energy exporter. It is tough to collapse an industrialized country that export these two commodities. While their quality of life may suffer somehwhat their society will not collapse, especially if they can continue to export these two commodities. However, the sanctions can slowly (very slowly) restrict Russia's ability to continue the war. At some point, Russia must decide whether to continue the war or face actually see their economy collapse.
this war will not continue after 2026 why ? ukraine will run out of men in army which no amount of aid will stop. west will not(cannot) send their own population to fight against russia (in large no.s) so the war stops automatically
Hopefully during our life time. As things are moving, I guess Russia wants more sanctions to grow it's economy. When BRICS alternative payment system comes to play, then the euro and dollar dominance can say bye bye and the world shall celebrate the freedom
I was in the Russian army it’s corrupt to the core. Strong economy lol. The average Russian earns less than a average Filipino Its a mafia run state thats going to collapse the population is now living under needless and pins the Ruble is 92,3 against the dollar despite 19% interest rates. Its only a matter of time. Now the military is using sailors from a destroyed aircraft carrier to fight on the front in trenches despite paying big money for military personnel they are short in man power.
LMAO the economy is still hot? so hot the Russian people are complaining they can't complain LOL I mean when a father of 17 kids signs up to Ukraine for money, you do know they are short of cash.
The average father of 17 kids in europe would be already bankrupt or work as a drug dealer. Having 17 kids and properly taking care of them is not an easy task. Plus, he might work in logistics, not as a frontline soldier, so he actually might return.
They did not mention the growing shortage of Chinese Yuan in Russia (where the Chinese refuse to deal in the Ruble). Russian has a pending Yuan liquidity crisis where Chinese firms are worried about buying things from Russia due secondary sanctions. I think things are now starting to bite
Just checked online. Everyday Essentials Spaghetti 500g in Aldi Supermarket UK is currently £0.28. That's 56p per kilo. 34.89 rubles in case you are Russian. Don't know about average Russian wages, but that's not even a luxury price for a homeless hobo here in the UK.
It already hurts them massively, you're just measuring the wrong things. Russia is in a deep economic crisis but can cover it up by government spending on the military which heats up the economy but living standards are deteriorating and they were very low to begin with. Moscow and St Petersburg are the only relatively rich places in Russia.
Wow! Anyone here understandiing anything about economics? High GDP consisting of government orders of military equipment is not great! High employment rate because 1200 men die in Ukraine everyday is not a positive sign. Gradually losing your main source of income, oil production is devastating. 20% interest rate is not a sign of a healthy economy. Not being able to pay abroad with your own currency anywhere is the worst sign of economic weakness. Russia do no longer produce anything which can be sold abroad since the dysfunction of military equipment was demonstarted in Ukraine. Tell me any brand of manufactured brand from russia beyond alcohol which isn't laughable.
Germany was living on borrowed time thinking cheap Russian nat gas could save their chemicals and energy grids. They looked the other way when Russia invaded Crimea etc. So the reckoning is happening. Now Germany needs to wean themselves off of sending BMW's to China. The government listens to business more than it should and makes bad decisions as a result.
How Russia can live without luxury pasta? O my god...
😂😂😂😂 they don't have sense at all but full of egos.
We have any kind of european food for those who like it, the price is a bit higher because of the more complicated supply chains.
Home pasta was always the best
Rich Russians need to stop buying western luxury cars via central Asian countries. They should stop giving western companies money
Yeah russian economy may be growing and its people may have a better welfare but what about that luxury pasta? Checkmate russians 💅
😂 Are they back to making predictions for russian collapse next year again??
Lol it will collapse. It's just the market of running out Russian reserve
Yap😂😂
@@Marolesee where are you from?speaking about collapse. It happened in 1991 what makes you think it can't happen again?
@@luciferjohnson8495Unity and solidarity from the global South with Russia. Stay out west 😂😂
@@izajahmed8863 sure and you stay out of Europe and west deal?
Have you ever been to Russia? Or just acting like a bot is your Hobbie?.
She can make predictions for Russia but not for Ukraine? 😅
There is nothing to "predict" for Ukraine. They get all their money from the United States taxpayer; they are not an independent country, they are a protectorate.
Just how insane people can be!!
Russias central bank says that Russia will start having big problems soon due to war costs and sanctions.
Ukraine is being aided. Do you want her to predict how long Ukraine will be aided?
No Russian bank released any statement. And Ukraine is getting less aid @@WinterGK
@glintongordon6811 The dude just wants his baseless comment to be relevant
The cold war formula sanction against Soviet Union failed.
Unlike Soviet Union, Russia is outsourcing from multipolar world including China, India, Turkey, South America, ASEAN and Africa. It hurts Russia economy but it hurts both ways, especially the EU.
Becouse, if you stop buying Russia n Products, africa will buy, Asia will buy, Europe's problem is not ours😊😊😊
Unless Africa, Asia already have their original supplies. Economics are not so simple.
They buy because it s cheaper. Everyone has a set of needs. If you don't get it from a then u get it from b. Put up barrier means you would get your needs at a premium prices. If Germany wants to pay more, I bet everyone else would happy to comply.
What products? Russia has almost no products of its own. And countries in Africa and Asia have always been cheated and exploited by Russia. Countries in Africa could develop on their own, but they are robbed by Russia and China.
@@shawners198shawn4 diversification market,, that is russia do now and the future,, russia resource, oil,gas, will penetrate asia, south america, africa, market,, far away from europe,, for russia if europe choose expensive usa oil n gas, its up to them,, for russia have realize, russia future not in europe,, anyway sun rise in the east,, and set in the west,, bon apetit from your policy eu.
South America too
As an Indian our people will support more than 90% for Russia and no one can dictate terms and conditions by Europe or USA and sooner Germany will be overtaken bu india...
Except Europe and USA, World in on the side of Russia . because, it is not complex to understand the core reason of Ukraine/NATO-Russia conflict.
@@muluTam7471 TRUE 👍
USA/Europe are even harrasing some Global South countries who are doing normal trade with Russia. This move has backfired as many countries who were neutral at the start of Ukraine war are now openly supporting Russia and want to join BRICS to get rid of Western unilateral sanctions
No guys we 90% of Indian doesn't know where is Russia & Ukrain in map We have tons of our problems like extreme Poverty, Unemployment, Corruption,Broken infrastructure, cleanliness we have to deal with thse things. Ya some lunatic from ruling party BJP definitely support Russia & but not everyone we're on the side of peace.
@@himanshusingh0876OK Chinese bot😂😂 now go pay house dept and drink bat soup
In a global economy, a country the size of Russia, with the resources it has, is impossible to isolate. It has an abundance of food and energy, two of the most critical needs in human life. No amount of Western finger wagging will stop people who are cold and hungry....
Well,THAT resources are exactly the real reason for this war. Anything else are lies and smoke and mirrors.
I mean the US is desparate. They overplayed their hand for decades and the time window they can do anything
is closing before the S... hits the fan.
We shall see. I am currently in Russia inflation is high.
Interest rates are at 19 percent.
Rent is higher it's not easy as you say it is.
Russia is 1 century behind the usa
It is easily to destroy. Just close the Baltic and Mediterranean sea and Russia is done.
@@ernstschwaig4667 who gonna close it?
In Africa we stand with Russia
Immigrate to Russia, not to Europe then
@@karlvonbahnhof6594 ya know, not everyone who lives in Africa leaves Africa, right? Some folks actually love where they live. Africa is a beautiful country, but I'm sure your hatred towards the brown folk have you blinded by that... "Immigrate to Russia"... LOL.. so petty
@karlvonbahnhof6594 Even if a visa free is offered to me to move to eeurope, I can never. Broo Europee is broke 😂😂. Bunch of poor citizens
@@karlvonbahnhof6594Europeans once migrated to Africa...so, Africans are just paying back
Viva Russia
Yes it hurt Russia so badly. At the same time Germany enjoy import US LNG at low price. Congrat Germany you are succeeded.
And they are selling more expensive VW cars than the cheaper chinese cars too😂
What are you smoking 😂
Germany has succeeded to put sanction on Russia but it has destroyed its own economy
that is why German economy decline, huge inflation , are you OK? States of BRICS are growing...not our economy in EU
@@NoMan769 Reads like satire to me
wow… when DW saying russian is doing good in their economy…. mean actually russian are making much much more better then actually DW admitting… hahha
The sanctions on Russia worked… but on Germany 😂😂
@@pajodarwin3687 get educated on the subject before you write :)
ok_best, that's such a dumb comment 🤣
Far from being crippled, Russia's economy is growing in 2024 as well. The International Monetary Fund predicts that Russia will record economic growth of 3.2% this year and that is still more than in any of the world's advanced economies. “Debilitating” the mother of all sanctions imposed on Russia have not produced shortages in the shops
GDP includes government spending. Buying expensive scrap metal to place in a field is not a good economic strategy, but that is what Russia is doing. How do you think that will work out for them?
@@nigelgarrett7970Lmao our western Economies can't even register 1% growth, Stop coping and let's face the facts.
Brics Economy is the future
Which BRIC economy? Some will do well some won’t.
@@shawners198shawn4 Tell me about sanctions on Russian, NAFO
In your dream 😂😂😂
@@ragnarandersson2866 wake up nord, you dont have what BRICS have.
Strong economy, lands, natural resources, good people, political stability and powerfull army this is the "secret of success" of great Russia.
This is why Germany wanted that Russian lands and replace them with Germans in the 1930-40s
Thank China and India.
Wodka and outhouses.
LOL, not one thing you say is true.
@@lifestapestry2968 this is what I'm trying to explain to people. I am in Russia for the past 10 years.
Interest rate is at 19 percent.
Inflation at 9 percent.
1 dollar was 29 rubles now it's 95 rubles.
How is this a sign of heskthy economy?
These news channels are spreading lies.
😂 Russia produces everything on its own 😅
The Russian economy is based on raw materials, not on a healthy economy in which all people can be entrepreneurs. Russia has nothing and will now be dependent on China, and China will take advantage of them and may even take over Russia's land that it considers its own. They will probably wait until Russia weakens enough. Already, most of the cars on the streets of Russia are Chinese and most of the products come from china. If Russian companies start to go bankrupt, the market will be taken over more and more by the Chinese. Russia will become China's puppet.
no it doesn't, russia only produces oil, gas and weapons,nothing more.
🇨🇳: Comrade, please hold our Dumplings and Noodles 🥟🍜
North Koreans: Slava SOJU🍶 Heroyam Kimchin😮
@@KamBar2020 Ok bot... we know how much you guys hate facts... lmao
Europe's ability to shoot their own foot is remarkable... 😂😂😂😂😂
And Germany sucking up to Usa still struggling
but here in the US we are quite happy and also stupefied... the europeans are buying our liquified natural gas that has to be shipped over the atlantic ... i think more and more that the EU is the one that will get seriously shafted when this conflict is over
For the fact they still ask these questions on media
That’s showns that the Economy is strong
It’s a clear Example, if they economy have failed we would have seen the western leaders making mockery of Russia Federation live on TV
Russian Economy is vast and strong
IMF and WB:
🇷🇺 #1 Economy in Europe
🇷🇺 #4 Economy in the World.
#1 Economy in Europe? Not for a long time.
Besides, basing it on fictitious GDP (war production) is not wise. Russia's economy is collapsing.
It will take time, but it is inevitable.
@@Polans-gd Cope harder.🤣🤣🤣
Go tell that to the IMF and WB, they need a genius like you.
🤣🤣🤣wishfull Ruzzian thinking,
The Russian economy might be nr1, in Russia, but in Europe? No! The IMF has forecasted a GDP of 4,591,100 MUSD for Germany, 3,495,261 MUSD for the United Kingdom, 3,130,014 MUSD for France, 2,328,028 MUSD for Italy and 2,056,844 MUSD for Russia, for 2024. So, I don’t know where you get your numbers from?
@@PeterHärma In terms of PPP, Germany and Russia very close. By 2025, Russia will overtake Germany.
Stabilized because still buying from Russia 😂😂 Russia is a big economical player
not any more
IMF and WB:
🇷🇺 #1 Economy in Europe
🇷🇺 #4 Economy in the World.
@@Polans-gd LMAO... you believe everything you see on CNN? Russia is thriving my dude. Learn economics.
Keep crying german soon taken over by India in economy in gdp. We already in PPP😂😂
who cares about gdp especially when india has 11x more population than germany. Per capita is what matters. And by the way India in its majority is incredibly poor.
@@23Amadeus92 who tell you that ur gutter media? Uk have more poverty % than India.🤣🤣India is one of least expensive country in world. We can buy 2000$ which you can't in 10,000 $.
@@Nehas949 Be honest with yourself don't be so proud. It's ok to be proud of your country but come on you cannot be seriously comparing UK living standards to India. And by the way who has 2k dollars to spend in India? what percentage of the population?
@@23Amadeus92 lol you can't compare India with tiny country like uk that's make uk situation even worst. I have seen many Britisher living way worst than average India. New Delhi is way safe than London. Pickpocketing and shoplifting is not rampant crime in india. Even it's not normal even being 1.4 billions people like uk. Stop being delusional about own country and others. I can clearly see poverty is decreasing rapidly only 3% India live below poverty Line unlike many in west.
dont watch this western rating, you are in BRICS
Putin:My heart is cold, my moves are Bold! 😂😂😂
EU n US digging their own graves lul
Eu yes but us planned this for them it is all good as long as they "help" with usd, which nobody can pay back(without selling ones state) usd(paper) is gonna be just fine. For them its an investment
We are great and we will be great. Russia has just collapsed.
,,,,,, RUSSIA COLLAPSING? 😅
Whos Russia?
😂😂😂😂@@Polans-gd
Oh no!!!! in europe the US LNG is 10X cheaper than ruasian gas!!!! 😂😂😂😂😂😂
which is produces from Russian gas
😂
Long answer: No
😂😂😂
In retrospect - America's proxy war was a blessing in disguise for Russia. Their economy is focused primarily eastwards towards China now and is healthier than ever. Great leadership from Vladimir Vladimirovich 🇷🇺🐻💪
Please send your thank you cards to the White House.
It's not a blessing..
I am in Russia for the past 10 years
1 dollar was = 28 rubles
Now it's 95 rubles
Inflation is 9 percent
Interest rate is 19 percent.
That's not a sign of a health economy.
Things are rough here. Don't belive everything the news says.
This is nonsense. Averagecrussians are defaulting on loans at an accelerating rate. Remember the scenes of collapsing dams and flooded villages? Russia is a mess.
@@luciferjohnson8495an how do we should believe you when your name is Lucifer
But that's been the case long before the sanctions, particularly interest rates and inflation its not that high now, if its 9%. @@luciferjohnson8495
They always profesy doom for Russia but God is on their side.
tell daddy America to lower the price of their LNG
Power of China n India
And Africa.
And South America
Rather the power of lies
@@Polans-gd what lies?
@@Polans-gd so didn't west build their kingdom on slavery n other inhumane crimes
Sanctions will never ever hurt Russian federation because they have the resources that China and everyone are looking for, so if you think that sanctions could hurt Russia that means you're leaving in the past
Lol it's hurt them badly, why do you think they bleat about it? Anyone who thought it would be a silver bullet was a fool.
,,,,,, why do you put your head in the bag?
So why is Putin desperate to have the sanctions removed, if they don’t work? 🤔
Never Say NEVER 😎 Justin Bieber
I love the great motherland Russia
Slava Russie
SLAVA UKRAINE !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
The Whole World does! 🇷🇺
@@760HorsePower troll
What doesn't kill you makes you strong
Sanctions are working
But europe is selling stuff that Kremlin needs to Georgia, Armenia , Kazahstan etc... when sells are going up 500% in these states and nobody asks why... we are to blame why sanctions aren't going that efficient
it's a method of cooking a frog - if you introduced everything at once, it would probably be bad for everyone in the world. So everyone, step by step, turns back from Russia and its economy. Moreover, Putin himself has also caused the poor condition of the Russian economy with his actions - now it will only be more visible to everyone and will continue to progress.
There is no better pasta than Asian pasta. The Italians can only learn from the Asians, if they had not already done so in Marco Polo's time. Italy probably permanently lost a large market with these boomerang sanctions. And the Russians will enjoy even more luxurious goods.🤣
The average russian does not even have a toilet at home or connected water. What are you writing about? Luxury goods? Only Moscow and St. Petersburg are cities that look like a normal civilized world, and the rest of russia still lives in the Middle Ages.
14 million russians living on the equivalent of USD 180 a month at least. Inflation is about 30% now there.
According to Rosstat (which presents a false reality anyway - it provides data convenient for the authorities so the information about poverty in Russia probably looks even worse in reality) in the year 2023 over 11.2 percent russian families said they had difficulty buying clothes and paying housing and utility bills. Another 48.7 percent it is not possible to purchase durable goods. Only 36.6 percent families have enough money for this, but they cannot afford a car, an apartment or a summer house. The percentage of families that are able to buy everything they need, including real estate, is, according to official statistics, 3.4%.
If Putler spends nearly 50% of the state budget on the war and not on its citizens, it will only get worse and worse.
@@Polans-gd Don't ask me about luxury goods (such as pasta😂). Watch the expert in the video!
@@Polans-gd Have you confused Russia with America ???
Delusions with this one
The sanctions that have been imposed on Russia, it has been said only in the western media that Russia has become weak due to the sanctions, but in reality the sanctions have made no difference to Russia and nothing can harm Russia in the future too. But in spite of all this Russia is winning and is also standing and is stronger than before. All this is a slap on the face of NATO and America because the sanctions imposed with wrong intentions to cause harm to a country and its people are never successful when imposed by any country.
Van we talk about the EU economi downfall as a result of sanctions?
Or is that a no-no?
Because it's not happening, that's why.
@@nigelgarrett7970Keep Coping and while at it pray harder😂😂
@@BruceJ999 it's not me that's coping. Try looking at facts, they don't care about your feelings.
I'm favoured only God knows how much I praise Him, $230k every 4weeks! I now have a big mansion and can now afford anything and also support God’s work and the church.
Only God knows how much grateful i am. After so much struggles I now own a new house and my family is happy once again everything is finally falling into place!!
I'm 37 and have been looking for ways to be successful, please how??
After I raised up to 525k trading with her I bought a new House and a car here in the states🇺🇸🇺🇸 also paid for my son's surgery….Glory to God, shalom.
She's a licensed broker here in the states🇺🇸 and finance advisor.
Can I also do it??? My life is facing lots of challenges lately.
I think the men and women in charge of the Russian economy deserves a noble peace price..just imagine, Russia is the heavily sanctioned country on earth....and still thriving
Russia exports for 2022 was $631.55B, a 15.01% increase from 2021. Russia exports for 2021 was $549.14B, a 44.11% increase from 2020. Russia exports for 2020 was $381.07B, a 20.84% decline from 2019. Russia exports for 2019 was $481.41B, a 5.67% decline from 2018. Russia's exports in 2023 only with Asian countries, amounted to 306.6 billion U.S. dollars.
europe has no resources. High cost , low profit., END
@@aleserban9322 Singapore has no resources, are they ending too?
Sanctions are counter productive.
We are the most prosperous country in Europe 🌍 🇷🇺
I am convinced that DW is sponsored by Russia
Power india china😂
No one can stop russia until we huys stop buying Russian oil gas coal 😅
china has problems and india is a poor country. No country ruled by dictators will ever be rich and sooner or later their economies will collapse, because in a dictatorship there is no truth, only lies, manipulation, and pretense.
@@Polans-gd it has very little to do with democracy it is about education ,industrialisation & resource management. US is biggest supporter of dictator around the world in pakistan, Saudi Arabia, egypt, UAE, Qatar even their forces are present there to protect them so kindly do not sell this lollypop here with your own double standards.
since world is becoming more & more Independent unilateral sanction will not work any more .
US canada norway are biggest beneficiary of this oil & gas sanction they are producing more & more from where India purchase oil 🛢. iran is already under sanction Venezuela is sanctioned too than from where middle east region controlled & ruled by dictators backed by US?
Imagine trying to cripple Russia but in turn you cripple yourself
Will sanctions ever hurt any other country is a more relevant question. The war in Ukraine has just accelerated multipolarity, thus negating the threat posed by sanctions.
Are they now allowed to mention the word Geopolitics?
If they had called this war geopolitical, then the Russian concerns could have come to light and a solution could have been found. But no, it was about 'Democracy' and 'Our Way of Life'.
Biggest issue with EU and USA is you guys think a Stock exchange Market and GDP amounts to raw materials and good living. Money is paper, it cannot replace a tangible resource like gas , oil , farming , and other minerals that Russia has and 80% of the world needs. Energy is more important than an over inflated GDP
"Wartime economy" - that's the clue. It looks good in the short term but isn't sustainable.
West and europe choping their legs themselves 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Once, after the Great Depression Kaynesian war economy made America great again. it came out of WWII as the by far biggest economy of the world. So why shouldn't this work to some extent also in Russia? And why, on the other hand, would we believe an economist who has been consistently wrong for more than two years?
The American economy was not based solely on war production, and the Russian economy is based on this. Germany during World War II also had a high GDP during the war, because it mainly produced weapons, and when the war ended, everything collapsed. The Russians rely on their oil deposits, but they do not have the appropriate technology, they misuse their sources, so they will not last long, and the quality of their oil is not high. And Russia without its resources and with a collapsing economy is a Russia of little importance in the world.
"russia had woven energy depenencies" ..meaning : " russia made us buy cheap energy...😮😮😮" ....😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅 It is Russia's fault that we are greedy😅😅😅😅
Until today, Europeans have not realized what they got themselves into.
A lot of ruzzian trolling here
The lesson from the Ukraine-Russia conflict is that you can't out-sanction a resource-rich country like Russia. Period.
Siemens faced significant financial losses due to its exit from the Russian market. The company reported a total hit of approximately €600 million directly related to its decision to wind down operations in Russia following the war in Ukraine. This included a non-cash charge for writing down assets and terminating its industrial activities, which impacted their quarterly earnings. Despite having been active in Russia for nearly 170 years, Siemens prioritized sanctions compliance and withdrew from key sectors such as energy and transportation
Economy is hot because Russia is spending its Sovereign Wealth Fund. Started war with $210 billion in cash, now has $40 billion left.
I'm surprised she doesn't say that Ukraine economy is doing better than Russia
If you believe the hype that comes of Russia . But if you know anything about economics you realise that Russia is heading for serious Stagflation. You only have to look at the collapse of the Ruble as a currency . The lack of inward investment. The inability to raise capital . The rapid rise of the countries deficit . And worst still the lack of workers,a shortfall of over 2 million and rising as more and more are killed on the battlefield.
So basically, Putin is burning through foreign currency reserves in order to pour billions of rubles into the Russian economy and has already burnt through half of those reserves. Meanwhile, massive tax hikes on Russia's oil and gas industry, while they may be bringing in more tax in the same way hyper-inflation at around 20% is bringing in more tax, is also taking away money that is needed to reinvest in further expansion in the industry. While the military industries are booming, they are also paying better wages than the civilian manufacturers can afford meaning a shortage of workers and hence increased prices for consumer goods which further feeds inflation.Sure, Russian government figure can point at the money nicely squirreled away in Chinese banks but at the same time they appear to fail to realise this is playing right into Chinese hands and swinging the balance of power between the two allies even further in China's direction. Even if the war stops today it will take years for the Russian economy to recover and meanwhile Russia's supporters desperately try to tell us it's fine, nothing to see here. It's my Russian friends I feel sorry for, this is not their war and yet they are the ones paying for it.
Yeah energy prices stabilized at 3x times of what they were in Germany in 2021
The Russian economy is feverish, with a central bank rate of 19%…, mind blowing.
What I am not understanding is that the same is happening in western countries. They are also producing a lot of weapons. Why isn't there an economic progress like the one in Russia?
Well EU is actually in very bad situation. Their economies cant produce war machines combine with respect ro Russia
You move out , rest of the world move in
In reality, Russia's economy will accelerate even further next year as a bounce in oil prices seems inevitable at this point.
If you believe that Russia is not hurting, you have not been paying attention.
Sanctions are working but not the way you thinking,this isn't Soviet who had no friends behind them like india,china, Brazil, mexico etc
Attention to what exactly?😂😂
@@ViciousSorina really, lol, the rubbles crashing, loss of revenue, loss of gas supply, loss of Russians that fled the country, should i go on ? Or maybe you just don’t understand what crashes an economy. Putin has and continues to destroy Russia because his ego won’t allow him to see what he did to his people.
This is opposite to what others are saying. Maybe prooganda.
2:45 russia IS hurting right now economically.
What others? Definitely not world bank or imf or even America banks. Maybe the RUclips ukraine propagandist.
According to the IMF, the GDP/capita is 54 291 USD in Germany (position 18 in the world) and the Russian GDP/capita is 14 391 USD (position 66 in the world). So, by definition the Germans, on average, are almost 4 times wealthier than the Russians. The pensions in Russia are about 15 000 to 30 000 rubles, per month, which is approximately 166 to 332 USD. If you would like to buy a used Japanese car in Russia, you have to pay twice as much as you have to pay in USA.
Russia will be brought to its knees from a lack of Italian pasta. 🤡😂
Russia is the most sanctioned country on earth and Yet it's economy is growing and continue to thrive. Let's all clap👏👏👏 for Russia
Russia is too big, too resourceful and too proud to collapse. They also have the legacy of Soviet Union, so they have a certain degree of sympathy within the developing world. Plus they have already faced the evil of secessionism.
Economies will always rise and fall, but Russia will always remain a decent power.
With inflation at 10% and interest rates at 16% right now, it is a hot economy? Is that why it is struggling to bypass the sanctions?
EU is bypassing our own sanction to buy russian oil from India ,be on ground 😂
India is laughing at Western sanctions
There is always a next year if their prediction will not happen.
No more cheap Russian gas .
2022 : collapse in 2023
2023 : collapse in 2024
2024 : collapse in 2025.
Sactions just wasting time😂😂
Russia is a food and energy exporter. It is tough to collapse an industrialized country that export these two commodities. While their quality of life may suffer
somehwhat their society will not collapse, especially if they can continue to export these two commodities.
However, the sanctions can slowly (very slowly) restrict Russia's ability to continue the war. At some point, Russia must decide whether to continue the war or face actually see their economy collapse.
this war will not continue after 2026 why ? ukraine will run out of men in army which no amount of aid will stop. west will not(cannot) send their own population to fight against russia (in large no.s) so the war stops automatically
Hopefully during our life time. As things are moving, I guess Russia wants more sanctions to grow it's economy. When BRICS alternative payment system comes to play, then the euro and dollar dominance can say bye bye and the world shall celebrate the freedom
"EU and US have restricted import of luxury goods to Russia..." *** Talks about pasta *** 🤦♂
Paying 5x the price for gas is ridiculous. What manufacturer can compete in that environment. Damm
5x compared to what?
I was in the Russian army it’s corrupt to the core. Strong economy lol. The average Russian earns less than a average Filipino Its a mafia run state thats going to collapse the population is now living under needless and pins the Ruble is 92,3 against the dollar despite 19% interest rates. Its only a matter of time. Now the military is using sailors from a destroyed aircraft carrier to fight on the front in trenches despite paying big money for military personnel they are short in man power.
@@thegreatdane3627 The lady said in the interview: compared to the price in the United States. Did you watch the video?
@@kwektansAs this war began, the price of food doubled in Europe
If you are still asking this question after 2 years. Then the sanctions has failed woefully
Russia is like Deutschland!
She never dies👍😁
Importing oil from India❓❓ India is importing oil from Russia 😂😂
That’s very funny 🤣..Europe is indeed smart
Russia is booming system while Western in recession effect...
LMAO the economy is still hot? so hot the Russian people are complaining they can't complain LOL
I mean when a father of 17 kids signs up to Ukraine for money, you do know they are short of cash.
So do you think that only happens in Russia?? Why USA, UK and Europe have homeless people if they're are better???
@@Percival5 look at every single American city , full of homeless tents
The average father of 17 kids in europe would be already bankrupt or work as a drug dealer. Having 17 kids and properly taking care of them is not an easy task.
Plus, he might work in logistics, not as a frontline soldier, so he actually might return.
You can't father 17 kids and survive where I come from
Von der Layen said almost two years ago that the Russian economy is in taters
They did not mention the growing shortage of Chinese Yuan in Russia (where the Chinese refuse to deal in the Ruble). Russian has a pending Yuan liquidity crisis where Chinese firms are worried about buying things from Russia due secondary sanctions. I think things are now starting to bite
US and its EU dogs have been singing WE ARE THE WORLD way too much only to find out they are 10% of the world
Maybe you shouldn't use their language, media (DW), and platforms (YT); otherwise, your comment seems pretty silly.
Don’t dig a hole for someone else,
otherwise you’ll fall into it yourself
Wow, Russia can not import luxury pasta 😂😂😂😂 what a crime committed on Russia by the EU
Is Ukrain winning, sanctions backfired, Europe is suffering more than Russia
An overheating economy and already a interest rate of 19%
Pasta is considered a luxury product now? Man, EU is doing worse than I thought.
" Russia took our energy, we took her pasta!!"
@@samlatooni That might have worked if not for one thing: pasta is just processed wheat, and Russia is the largest exporter of wheat in the world.
Just checked online. Everyday Essentials Spaghetti 500g in Aldi Supermarket UK is currently £0.28. That's 56p per kilo. 34.89 rubles in case you are Russian. Don't know about average Russian wages, but that's not even a luxury price for a homeless hobo here in the UK.
@@Thomes-Maisling Well, let's just agree that this lady "expert" is talking out of her bottom.
@@Andre_Kummel Fair enough
She could tell the whole prediction about Russian Economy from A to Z but when it comes to Ukraine its hard to predict. Seriously??🤣🤣🤣
How I wish I had a pair of rosy glasses right now !
It already hurts them massively, you're just measuring the wrong things. Russia is in a deep economic crisis but can cover it up by government spending on the military which heats up the economy but living standards are deteriorating and they were very low to begin with. Moscow and St Petersburg are the only relatively rich places in Russia.
In latin america we side with Russia! 😂😂😂
Do you think that a 20 % interest rate is normal?
Wow! Anyone here understandiing anything about economics?
High GDP consisting of government orders of military equipment is not great!
High employment rate because 1200 men die in Ukraine everyday is not a positive sign.
Gradually losing your main source of income, oil production is devastating.
20% interest rate is not a sign of a healthy economy.
Not being able to pay abroad with your own currency anywhere is the worst sign of economic weakness.
Russia do no longer produce anything which can be sold abroad since the dysfunction of military equipment was demonstarted in Ukraine.
Tell me any brand of manufactured brand from russia beyond alcohol which isn't laughable.
This is so dull that she failed to answer most of the questions
😂😂after 21000+ sanctions Russia has become self reliant and eu fools lost big Russia market for thier agricutural products and auto export😂😂😂😃
Germany was living on borrowed time thinking cheap Russian nat gas could save their chemicals and energy grids. They looked the other way when Russia invaded Crimea etc. So the reckoning is happening. Now Germany needs to wean themselves off of sending BMW's to China. The government listens to business more than it should and makes bad decisions as a result.