PA Supreme Court Will Hear Appeal on Ellen Greenberg Case

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 21 окт 2024

Комментарии • 124

  • @etery-terrymayzlin8738
    @etery-terrymayzlin8738 2 месяца назад +53

    This case is a major cover up. I really hope her parents get justice 🙏🏻

  • @butterflygirl3359
    @butterflygirl3359 2 месяца назад +47

    Thank God! This was a terrible injustice to the Greenbergs.

  • @teresalong3821
    @teresalong3821 2 месяца назад +39

    Great news! The ME was correct in his first report. Power, pressure and possible financial gain or threat caused him to change it. It doesn’t take a Dr to determine her death was caused by someone else. This case has bothered me since I first heard about it years ago. Dirty politicians and people in power need to be removed from office and or criminally charged. Thanks for covering

  • @TraceD007
    @TraceD007 2 месяца назад +46

    Josh Shapiro should NEVER be Vice President or President of the US!!!! EVER!

    • @YellowB70
      @YellowB70 2 месяца назад +3

      💯 And let Kamala do the Shapiro cross-examination!! Wishful thinking

    • @debbiemartin2026
      @debbiemartin2026 2 месяца назад

      Theres a worse one now.
      Anti-Semite, Hamas supporter, socialist.

  • @e.c.c.s7040
    @e.c.c.s7040 2 месяца назад +32

    I am positive Ellen's case is not the only case Shapiro has handled unethiclly. He needs to be investigating.

    • @DrTiwade
      @DrTiwade 2 месяца назад +6

      Investigated

  • @lorisutherland7728
    @lorisutherland7728 2 месяца назад +21

    Plus the guy called his lawyer and the lawyer was there before cops.

    • @DrTiwade
      @DrTiwade 2 месяца назад +5

      And the DA was Josh Shapiro who is running for VP!

    • @aprilvilliar7907
      @aprilvilliar7907 2 месяца назад +2

      He called his cousin and uncle both lawyers who showed up before EMTs. Then he called his other family member a judge. They came over and grabbed all of ELLENS electronics and turned them over to the cops 2days later. Wow just mind blowing the level of coverup

    • @lorisutherland7728
      @lorisutherland7728 2 месяца назад +1

      @@aprilvilliar7907 stop this guy for not getting in trouble . He is corrupt like the others who helped him.

  • @zoehorn2551
    @zoehorn2551 2 месяца назад +13

    Gavin, I found your channel because of this case. Thank you so much for being an advocate for the Greenberg family.

  • @carolinetrig
    @carolinetrig 2 месяца назад +24

    I’m so glad for her parents, this always bothered me, I’m praying.

  • @cheryl4811
    @cheryl4811 2 месяца назад +23

    Thank you Gavin for covering Ellen Greenberg's case I first saw you a long time ago on Surviving the Survivor talking about the Ellen Greenberg case. I have followed you and this case ever since. Ellen so deserves her day of Justice!

  • @Kas-d5b
    @Kas-d5b 2 месяца назад +6

    Yours is by far the most comprehensive reporting of this case I've seen. Thank you for representing victims

  • @marygoff3332
    @marygoff3332 2 месяца назад +15

    Regarding Ellen's fiance Sam - a man who has such rage that he stabs Ellen 20 times certainly has shown such rage to his current wife. I'd love to get the truth about the state of their marriage and how much anger he has displayed over the years.

  • @marygoff3332
    @marygoff3332 2 месяца назад +13

    Your column was excellent regarding this case.

  • @VivianMonroe-gt7ny
    @VivianMonroe-gt7ny 2 месяца назад +4

    I have been following Ellen's case since 2011. This case will give you a brain bleed from all the corruption and how her fiancé got away with murder (hopefully about to change). I am so happy Ellen & her parents to finally got a life line because they have and many others have been fighting so hard for Ellen to get justice.

  • @JeannePursellBICHONPAWZ
    @JeannePursellBICHONPAWZ 2 месяца назад +14

    I am SO happy for Ellen’s parents! I absolutely agree with her parents and I commend them for standing behind her all this time. I sure hope that justice is served! Thanks for covering this!

  • @normajeandoyle
    @normajeandoyle 2 месяца назад +13

    Gavin! Oh happy day! You deserve credit where credit is due for supporting the Greenbergs unflinching and determined. I hope someone is shaking in his boots tonight!❤

  • @Esh486
    @Esh486 2 месяца назад +3

    Finally! I can't believe it took so long. All the corrupt people who were involved in this cover up need to be sent to prison.
    No one in their right mind can think it was self inflicted... Shame on this corrupted people.

  • @caterandolph3440
    @caterandolph3440 2 месяца назад +13

    You have to feel good about all your hard work. Congratulations!!

  • @cyrillyons1531
    @cyrillyons1531 2 месяца назад +2

    I only found out about this case today. I saw some of your videos from 2 years ago today. Thank you very much for doing an update. The amount of intentional wrongdoing and incompetence is horrific! This family deserves justice & closure! Also, there needs to be accountability for everyone involved in this disaster!!!! I hope most PDs, ME's & DA's are operating with honesty. However, for this case, in every area, there was absolute, acute incompetence. Along with conflicts of interest & intentional covering up. I want to be much stronger 💪 with my terminology. However, I'm trying to stay within the apps comment guidelines. At least this recent news is a step in the right direction.😢 It's just sad that it's taken 13+ years to move forward!

  • @RambleOn.
    @RambleOn. 2 месяца назад +10

    I just saw this!!! I AM SO HAPPY!!!

  • @kellystuard-will2826
    @kellystuard-will2826 2 месяца назад +1

    I don't know why the medical examiner gave that determination of cause of death. It seems obvious that something dodgy happened in this case. Her wounds simply don't support it. My heart goes out to these grieving parents.

  • @sleuthinsandals1230
    @sleuthinsandals1230 2 месяца назад +12

    Well done Gavin, I've seen your work on this case all along and it's fantastic that there is FINALLY some movement on Ellen's murder. Now more people will learn the awful truth about this case, and Ellen's parents may get closer to some sort of accountability for their daughter's brutal death. ❤

  • @thomasadrian9854
    @thomasadrian9854 2 месяца назад +18

    Hey Sam- justice is coming…….

    • @DrTiwade
      @DrTiwade 2 месяца назад

      Is that why Josh Shapiro is running for VP!!

  • @nikkienova129
    @nikkienova129 2 месяца назад +1

    THIS IS 💯% A MURDER...SHE DID NOT KILL HERSELF..

  • @cosmicshy637
    @cosmicshy637 2 месяца назад +1

    Love your passion for this case, Gavin! I'm so excited for Ellens' parents! Praying for Justice! ❤

  • @robbinslanding356
    @robbinslanding356 2 месяца назад +1

    Hey Gavin! I heard about this lady on X the other day bc of the possible VP pick. So I figured I needed to educated. I'm so impressed with your Playlist. I love your passion as well. You're Ellen Playlist will be keeping me company all day today to get caught up. Keep up the great work Gavin.

  • @starflower703
    @starflower703 2 месяца назад +9

    Finally some movement in the correct direction for Ellen and her family!

  • @sgreen0000
    @sgreen0000 2 месяца назад +8

    Thank God! She didn’t kill herself! I feel so bad for her parents. 💔😢😢❤️

  • @PA_PRISON_NURSE
    @PA_PRISON_NURSE 2 месяца назад +6

    It's about time!!!!!

  • @Kas-d5b
    @Kas-d5b 2 месяца назад +4

    Spent 2 days binge watching all your videos through the years..I only became aware of it as it connected to Josh Shapiro.. It disgusts me that he is being under consideration as VP. This and other things he's participated in including siding with polluters against citizens harmed by fracking, sexual and other claims of harassment tied to his office, and what I consider conflicts of interest in backing school vouches make him a terrible choice.

    • @yankeecitygirl
      @yankeecitygirl 2 месяца назад

      After the Little Sisters of the Poor won their Supreme Court case, Josh Shapiro and another AG took the religious order back to court.

  • @karenkeiper1278
    @karenkeiper1278 2 месяца назад +5

    So glad this is being looked into properly.🥰

  • @robrosser8831
    @robrosser8831 2 месяца назад +1

    Same situation happened To my son Daniel Evan Rosser. I experienced a threat from the Coroner’s office, the state police and the FBI. He was shot in the back of his head at his mother’s house, and the coroner donated Daniel’s body parts to the gift of life, and close Daniel’s case as suicide. All of the doors were close to me. I will never get justice for my son, but I hope that this young woman gets justice.

  • @cherylcolston9620
    @cherylcolston9620 2 месяца назад

    Excellent work Gavin. We need more laypersons like you to keep us informed of such nonsensical events and failure of the justice system. It is sad that we have to spend our life savings to fight the obvious wrong doings and mistakes of the system which we put our trust in, only to see the misdeeds of payoffs and favor to criminals while families suffer injustice. Someone needs to be held accountable for this tragedy of Ellen Greenberg. it appears that she didn't have defense wounds perhaps she was attached from behind (head, neck, back)by the time she turn around he body was lifeless and the intruder continued to stab her in the chest and else where until his rage subsided. I'm glad to see the Greenberg family fight till the better end for her case to be reopened, maybe someday the truth will prevail.

  • @leslievasquez2645
    @leslievasquez2645 2 месяца назад +2

    God is good!! I’ve been praying about this case for years!

  • @AWanderingEye
    @AWanderingEye 2 месяца назад +4

    Thank you for the political overlap. Michael Moore also recommends Kamala to not choose Josh, for what it's worth. Thanks for pursuing this case.

  • @janeg8274
    @janeg8274 2 месяца назад

    This is so Amazing!!! It is the most outrageous case out there!! Bless her parents ❤️

  • @jlf6614
    @jlf6614 2 месяца назад +1

    I found your channel due to your reporting in this case. I am praying truth wins

  • @aterryadg
    @aterryadg 2 месяца назад +5

    This is wonderful news!!

  • @AlexDeChristian6323
    @AlexDeChristian6323 Месяц назад

    If the door was latched from the inside, case closed.

  • @hlowrylong
    @hlowrylong 2 месяца назад

    You should be proud of yourself, GF. You kept this alive via great reporting for those of us who love true crime & real justice.
    Well done.

  • @EigthFeathersofHope
    @EigthFeathersofHope 2 месяца назад +3

    Hope this is the beginning of some justice for Ellen Greenberg.

  • @MysticalLibra
    @MysticalLibra 2 месяца назад +1

    I think your channel will be blowing up here really soon. Thanks for the great coverage!

  • @jennyobrien849
    @jennyobrien849 2 месяца назад +11

    Ellen is stunning glad she might finally getting justice

  • @Peaceb111
    @Peaceb111 2 месяца назад +1

    Prayers for these parents 🙏 i could not imagine their grief with what they have to go through 😢

  • @mn9120
    @mn9120 2 месяца назад

    He couldn't control her as much as he wanted and he lost control and killed her.
    I admire your efforts, Gavin!!

  • @CHutch-w2u
    @CHutch-w2u 2 месяца назад

    Wow great work.

  • @junebuchholtz287
    @junebuchholtz287 2 месяца назад

    Sometimes you wonder how do these people get keep their jobs????
    No way is this anything but murder...

  • @AlexDeChristian6323
    @AlexDeChristian6323 Месяц назад

    You are forcing the justice system to blame her boyfriend without any evidence.

  • @abacus749
    @abacus749 2 месяца назад

    Does the Autopsy report say whether or not the HYOID BONE was damaged?
    Damage to the HYOID BONE indicates strangulation and occurs in one third of all homicides.
    (The Hyoid Bone was damaged in the neck of Shannen Gilbert-one of the girls found at Gilgo beach)

  • @rachelrae860
    @rachelrae860 2 месяца назад +7

    Gavin I love what you do and I think you are truly incredibly amazing ❤. I'm so happy your still working on Ellen's case along with her parents. I'm sorry I missed this live 😢

  • @barbarabrooks4747
    @barbarabrooks4747 2 месяца назад +1

    The police and medical examiner need to be sanctioned or disciplined in some way for not doing a proper investigation. A ruling of undetermined at least allows for a search for witnesses and similar crimes in the region, but deciding a case like this is suicide without a very thorough investigation reeks of laziness and a cover-up.

  • @Christy-sf6vt
    @Christy-sf6vt 2 месяца назад +2

    This makes me so happy ❤

  • @daisywares1
    @daisywares1 2 месяца назад

    It's beyond belief that there has been no justice for the Greenbergs. Praying that that's about to change.

  • @marygoff3332
    @marygoff3332 2 месяца назад +1

    Gavin, Peter Hyatt did a breakdown on Sam's 911 call. It would be wonderful if you could get him on your channel to discuss it. He is brilliant.

  • @jacquelinejacobson6789
    @jacquelinejacobson6789 2 месяца назад

    This is just horrible. How could a competent medical examiner change the manner of death to suicide if no history of suicidal ideation or histrionic episodes?
    How could Sam assume she "stabbed " herself and "fell on a knife" in his 911 call? How can anyone fir that matter "fall in a knife"?? This screams of suspicion!!

  • @jennyobrien849
    @jennyobrien849 2 месяца назад +2

    @GF do u have a complete playlist on this on RUclips ? Or is its only on ur website

    • @marygoff3332
      @marygoff3332 2 месяца назад

      Jenny, hit the "playlist" tab and you will see all videos he's done regarding the Ellen G case.

  • @patricial641
    @patricial641 2 месяца назад +2

    This is fantastic news! I keep hoping there will be justice for Ellen. There is no way the facts lead to anything but murder.

  • @hollinaomi
    @hollinaomi 2 месяца назад +2

    watching now!

  • @coolcougar
    @coolcougar 2 месяца назад +3

    Excellent news!

  • @americaneagle697
    @americaneagle697 2 месяца назад

    So happy for this family.

  • @usakiwi1986
    @usakiwi1986 2 месяца назад

    This case is so messed up! There is NO way she did this to herself!

  • @TaraAnneRosie-hb9lq
    @TaraAnneRosie-hb9lq Месяц назад

    GF……………………A few solid creators are covering this now and I hope you also look into the Sandra Birchmore case GF

  • @gillianstapleton8566
    @gillianstapleton8566 23 дня назад

    It’s humanly impossible to stab yourself in the back of the head and neck 10 times one of which went through and severed her spinal cord which would have incapacitated her at that point .. she would not have been capable to go on and stab herself in the heart .. of course she would not have been able to stab herself in the back to begin with but once the cord was severed there is no way possible for her to have moved from the neck down .. never mind move herself from lying flat on the floor to where she was found. He did it moved her and also cleaned up lots of the blood .. he obviously knows people with lots of influence. I would say she was going to leave him and he found out or she told him. Didn’t her dad say she had phoned him at one point saying she wanted to move home but he told her to not leave in the middle of a school year. Sometimes you only realize how abusive someone is when you move in, get married or have a baby with them .. they let the mask slip as soon as they think they have you trapped and you’ve less options to leave. She was in a da relationship.
    Is that dude trying to run as vice for Kamala Harris .. not great choice for presidency but she will be a huge mistake.. where was she as vice the last 3.5 yrs and what exactly has she to show positive for it … 0 . She says a whole load of key words and virtue-signaling but never answers any question or takes responsibility for anything she failed doing in her 3.5yrs .. it’s always someone else’s fault.

  • @YellowB70
    @YellowB70 2 месяца назад +1

    Gavin, I commend you for all your work and in particular your bravery in calling out the political corruption in this case. Josh Shapiro should be stopped in his tracks and be held accountable for his actions, never mind be considered as a VP candidate of the United States 😮.What I would’nt give to see Kamala herself cross examine him on this issue.

  • @rhianevans7189
    @rhianevans7189 2 месяца назад +1

    Hi Gavin
    Now I am hearing this on here.. This case is a well known fact to be inaccurate by lay men and Ellen’s parents and injustice to them
    Much love and respect from across the pond in Uk x

  • @elf1845
    @elf1845 2 месяца назад

    Thank God Gavin.. I found your channel as a result of your dedication to this case. I always share your videos on Ellen. Gree ergs need justice. This is a ray of hope!

  • @lindseyh8898
    @lindseyh8898 2 месяца назад

    Poor Ellen! Praying she and her family can finally have some peace

  • @1ACL
    @1ACL 2 месяца назад +1

    You can be against Netanyahu and the Israeli government, and criticize our government, without being antisemitic. Many Jews in Isreal are against him.

  • @wendyshaw4335
    @wendyshaw4335 2 месяца назад +2

    Fantastic news

  • @Muffynbear-bs7fh
    @Muffynbear-bs7fh 2 месяца назад

    I asked Josh Shapiro via FB messenger about Ellen Greenberg and his relationship to the Goldburgs and he never responded.

  • @blastypowpow
    @blastypowpow 2 месяца назад +2

    YES!!! SWEET!! I’ve been following the case with you since day one, and I’ve been following this case since it happened. I live in South Jersey so I’m pretty close to Philly. I want to see justice for the Greenbergs!
    I wonder if this is partially so Shapiro can go on being Harris’ running mate if she picks him. I’ve been telling my parents about Shapiro’s participation in the cover up. I’m hoping she picks anyone but Shapiro. A lot of Dems don’t know anything about this. I’ve been posting about it on Twitter, but I don’t pay for a subscription so I dunno how many people are actually seeing my tweets. I’m a Dem and I don’t want him on the ticket AT ALL. *_(I POSTED THIS BEFORE YOU MENTIONED THIS TOPIC IN THE VIDEO. I’VE BEEN THINKING ABOUT THIS SINCE SHAPIRO’S NAME WAS THROWN OUT THERE AS A VP PICK.)_*
    Edit for grammar

  • @AnnaD25
    @AnnaD25 2 месяца назад

    Justice for Ellen

  • @annedouti4240
    @annedouti4240 2 месяца назад

    I guess a little pressure on Shapiro works. Finally, I'm glad it is going to the PA Supreme Court!

  • @barbarabrooks4747
    @barbarabrooks4747 2 месяца назад

    If police decide immediately that a case is self-inflicted, they won't gather forensic evidence from the site. If the door was locked from the inside, the perpetrator could have gone out the window or used a wire to make it look like it was locked from the inside. I can't imagine a person using this method of suicide unless she had a history of escalating self-harm. Usually women prefer the least gory modes of suicide.

  • @toeziegirl
    @toeziegirl 2 месяца назад

    Yesterday, I saw a lot of other media talking about Ellen Greenberg and the connection to Shapiro! I don't know if it is because of you but it did get picked up and maybe it was the final thing to make him not the pick.

  • @AgnesGoodwin
    @AgnesGoodwin 2 месяца назад

    Not murder omg the lady didn’t stab herself

  • @marie-claudepalassio7773
    @marie-claudepalassio7773 2 месяца назад +3

    This is wonderful news!
    @Gavin: What would it mean it the Supreme court rules in their favour, in terms of next steps?
    Would it mean the medical examiner's findings could potentially be reverted back to homicide? Hence needing a criminal investigation? Or would it open the door to something else (ex: civil)?
    Thanks in advance for your response :)

  • @TaraAnneRosie-hb9lq
    @TaraAnneRosie-hb9lq Месяц назад

    GF …IMO….I think MRS G @ The grizzled covered this case

  • @TraceD007
    @TraceD007 2 месяца назад +1

    Has Dr. Osborn ever been deposed????

    • @VivianMonroe-gt7ny
      @VivianMonroe-gt7ny 2 месяца назад

      If you go to Gavin's website he has tons and tons documents to through.

  • @RoadstrLa
    @RoadstrLa 2 месяца назад

    Obvious crime of passion. She told Sam she was leaving him and he lost it. Then covered up by Shapiro who is a family friend. Case solved! Good luck Sam!

  • @tiffknox6158
    @tiffknox6158 2 месяца назад +1

    What what what???? FINALLY!!!

  • @redsled7739
    @redsled7739 2 месяца назад +1

    FINALLY.!!!

  • @dmariej
    @dmariej 2 месяца назад

    Fantastic news! Hope this is a step in the right direction ❤

  • @aprilvilliar7907
    @aprilvilliar7907 2 месяца назад

    Ok just curious I believe Sam is guilty, but how did the door get locked? Was that a lie Sam told?

  • @Kas-d5b
    @Kas-d5b 2 месяца назад

    Shapiro does not really have a barrier of being considered as VP because he is Jewish. With him it's more being what some would consider too extreme in being against Palestinians going back to his college days. Harris's husband is Jewish.. Mark Kelly's wife is Jewish. It's not an issue for either one of them.

  • @galejordan4642
    @galejordan4642 2 месяца назад +3

    YAY! Election year.

  • @lorisutherland7728
    @lorisutherland7728 2 месяца назад +1

    That means if the stab wounds were at different times he could have killed her and did the stab wounds then and when he came back did more to confuse others.

    • @marygoff3332
      @marygoff3332 2 месяца назад +1

      Yes, the stab wounds either came at different times OR it was a prolonged attack and Ellen passed before he finished stabbing her.
      Just my opinion, but I think she had her head down and he stabbed her chest area and then went after the back of her head/neck which was exposed.

    • @lorisutherland7728
      @lorisutherland7728 2 месяца назад

      @@marygoff3332 why did anyone trust him if his lawyer was there before cops? No telling what they did. Were any of the stab wounds after death?

    • @lorisutherland7728
      @lorisutherland7728 2 месяца назад

      @@marygoff3332 how many killers like this guy do you think they bring them to the point of death know they will die and leave then come back to claim they and this is what happened.

  • @loladaise6432
    @loladaise6432 2 месяца назад

    How is Shitperio tied to all of this? Please give up the goods on him. He is about to be chosen as a VP runningmate. A video you did 2 yrs ago indicates that you had a lot of dirt on him.

  • @michaelkay3565
    @michaelkay3565 2 месяца назад

    Its not gonna change Shapiro is still the governor ive been following it since 2 days after it happened

  • @AshAshley-ni9fz
    @AshAshley-ni9fz 2 месяца назад

    Let's Make sure that Ellens murder wasn't in vain but instead Let's make ELLEN'S LAW Be the name øf supreme court the name that isn't up for discussion its GOING to be justice for Ellen by Ellens legacy and her parent's fight will be momentum in that change ELLEN'S LAW

  • @saneman751
    @saneman751 2 месяца назад

    Sam doesn't strike me as an athletic guy. How often had he been working out? who could waste away their entire careers for this Sam dude? Follow the money.

  • @lawadm1
    @lawadm1 2 месяца назад +2

    Shapiro the walls are closing in

  • @leipersgreen6763
    @leipersgreen6763 2 месяца назад

    2:07

  • @galfromphilly
    @galfromphilly 2 месяца назад

    Shapiro will be announced as Kamala Harris VP in Tuesday

  • @petrabethyname7142
    @petrabethyname7142 2 месяца назад +1

    Gavin what is the case from mn you were referencing
    I’m from mn I am curious if it’s a case I’m already following
    If you see this and get back to me thank you ❤

    • @GavinFish
      @GavinFish  2 месяца назад +3

      David Elmquist. gavinfish.com/cases/david-elmquist/

    • @bhrubes100
      @bhrubes100 2 месяца назад +2

      Hi Gavin. Has there been any movement with David’s case. His parents were very vocal on their FB pages and seemed to stop posting over the last year.

    • @petrabethyname7142
      @petrabethyname7142 2 месяца назад +1

      @@GavinFish omg that poor young man no I didn’t hear about his case. The little I just read from your link is another case of clear homicide like Ellen’s case. Thank you for giving them a voice and the parents support. Bless your heart and your mind while working on these heart breaking and maddening cases.

  • @amphetamean66X
    @amphetamean66X 2 месяца назад

    I'm on the far left and realize Shapiro has done good work and is a great speaker but good lord this doesn't look good for him. I'm glad Harris picked someone else. I truly hope that Ellen gets justice and her parents can truly find peace. I think her fiance murdered her but only with a real investigation will we know. Might even find a cover up.

  • @DJ-nk4dq
    @DJ-nk4dq 2 месяца назад

    This is the case of Jewish families battling each other in court. Goldberg family is better connected but Greenberg family has a chance now. Fingers crossed