How was Russia defeated in 11 days? ⚔️ Operation Faustschlag
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 июл 2022
- Install Hero Wars for FREE here ✅ : clik.cc/PROdQ and get a super chest with a secret hero! 🔥 Available for the next 30 days only!
🚩 Time for some World War I action! I'm happy to share with you the Operation Faustschlag, 1917, a strategic overview of the rapid German advance in the East that overwhelmed Russia. This video was made in collaboration with History Experience
🚩 Consider supporting our work on Patreon and enjoy early access ad-free videos for as little as $1: / historymarche
🚩 This video was made in collaboration with History Experience / channel Check out their channel and give them the credit that they deserve.
📢 Narrated by David McCallion
🎵 Music:
EpidemicSound
#ww1 #russia #germany
Install Hero Wars for FREE here ✅ : clik.cc/PROdQ and get a super chest with a secret hero! 🔥 Available for the next 30 days only!
When will you post Hannibal part19 sir
Can you do something for Bosnia in 92?
@zটি MDNR You are reported for misinformation.
Please do the wars following 1918 and the German Freikorps involvement in the Baltic states.
Russia: Implodes politically
Germany: It's marching time
Soon it will be time again ;)
@@MrNebelschatten для ядерных ракет 😈😈😈
@@user-hw2yo8vo5t Welche nuklearen Raketen, mein unterbelichteter Freund? Das nukleare Arsenal wird in Russland durch die selben korrupten Mittel wie die Armee bezahlt. Und siehe an, wie russische Panzer hinwegrosten. Ja, bitte feuert euer Nukleararsenal ab. Ich kann es kaum erwarten, wie eure Raketen in den Silos hochgehen und das russische Umland nuklear verseucht wird! Wäre genauso schlau wie die Aktion eurer Streitkräfte Schützengräben in Chernobyls verseuchtem Untergrund zu graben. Aber was kann man anderes auch von Russen erwarten?
@@user-hw2yo8vo5t your alien alphabet alone is enough to trigger my inner German marching songs 😆
@@MrNebelschatten Yes, when Germany collapses under this puppet government, Russians will have the free way. But fortunately for Germans, Russians are not nearly as brutal, and are not hungry for the land that is not theirs.. ;)
It's crazy how fast the Germans and there allies advanced into the Russian empire. Even faster then in WWII.
Russian imperial army was desintegrated due to the revolution and lack of morale. troops left army and go home by foot. Ukraine
Even crazier that Poland being 2 years old, after 123 years of slavery, remade from 3 different parts, won with Russia in 1921 and stopped their march to West Europe. XD
Germany should’ve dig themselves in defense on the west and finished russia and the bolsheviks once and for all. Dismember the country into at least 5 different kingdoms and be done with it.
No, these are political events, not military ones. After the Bolsheviks came to power, they practically disbanded the army. There were many reasons for this, including the creation of a new army subordinate to the revolution.
@@quandmeme9970 Nothing that in Russia there was still a civil war? It is ridiculous to talk about great merits.
This video is so fascinating.
1918 was the craziest year in human history.
Not as insane as 2020 when the world believed that covid were real, so they lock people up like animals, and punish them for wanting to eat.
It provided a blueprint for Operation Barbarossa in ww2. A good one really. Except they met a unifies Russia with different national attitudes.
It was going to be repeated in Ukraine actually, but the Germans decided to treat them as subhumans too. When they realized this, Ukrainians joined the effort.@@SuperChuckRaney
1945: Am i a joke to you?
wait a few years, it seems our generation ill break all records of lunacy
I believe the armies were stripping the grain and food because of the famine in Germany caused by the blockades of England during the war.
Yes, the Germans were trying to free the countries enslaved by Russia shown in this video but England and the US fought against the Germans which lead to those countries coming under Bolshevik enslavement which continues to this day.
Yes, wars have practically always started out fighting another country, but only a few of those didn't end with fighting starvation. Soldiers tend to forget about their nationalistic pride and perceived superior norms and values when having to resort to eating bugs.
@zটি MDNR Good info!
Wow you don't say I! And here I thought they just wanted to make the biggest loaf of bread in the world
@@Jaiyro That was actually their main mission on the eastern front.
What an amazing video. I love WW1 and the eastern front in this time period is largely forgotten or ignored. An excellent analysis of the conflict
I think HistoryMarche bring up a lot of unusual and overlooked topics with very interesting videos. I think this channel deserves more attention.
The humiliating defeat of the Russian army during the First World War was brilliantly portrayed in the film "Nicholas and Alexandra". At the end of the first part of the film, the soldiers in Saint Petersburg salute the Tsar and march to the front in a very epic scene full of patriotism and pride, which ends with the patriotic music slowly fading out and the screen going dark, but the sound of military footsepts is still heard for a while in a concerning haunting way. After the intermission, we only watch from this point military commanders taking their own lives, teenagers and old men on the front lines, and soldiers killing their superiors just to eat a rabbit in peace instead of fighting the germans.
Russia lost because of inner betrayal and outside infiltration, it's obvious to me now that in late 1916 Russia was considering to make a separate peace with Germany, so to avoid that British instigated February "democratic" revolution, which was nothing else but a coup with many generals and government ministers at the head of it. Rasputin wasn't a monster like they like to portray him, far from it...keep watching CNN and base your "knowledge" on Hollywood so to make sure you stay in darkness
Hey man, thanks for that recommendation, saw it's on prime. I sure do miss the grand period epics like the ones they did back then, the ones that were 3+hrs long with intermission and all practical effects and well done costume designs
The Russians were ill-prepared for the war, much less against the strongest army in Europe.
Sorry to say but Tzar and his family was killedby bolshevics (communists) so Tzar didnt have anything wit Red army loss.
@@nikolamatic8684 The war was already lost when the communists took the power. In fact, the Bolsheviks wanted a peace treaty with the Germans while the Mensheviks wanted to win no matter what. Interestingly, the Germans helped Lenin to return to Russia because the latter promised them to sign a peace agreement.
This is why Hitler thought Barbarossa would be a walk in the park.
Barbarossa was a walk in the park in the beginning. The Soviets held out long enough until winter and the American supplies came.... blizzards saved the Soviet capital... let's not forget.
@@BrandonTimmons-km4hi its funny down there in uncany valey, isnt it 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@hastalavictoriasiempre2730 What do you mean?
@@BrandonTimmons-km4hiThe most of the american lend lease arrived after the most crucial battles in the eastern front. Sure american trucks carried the soviet logistics in Bagatrion, but them what? Soviets held 80% of the Germany army, the western allies merely 20%.
@@BrandonTimmons-km4hithe winter didn’t save Russia
Terrific video! There's such a rich and complex history in that region.
Great video. This is a part of Modern history I know pretty little about so this helped me alot in building a clearer picture
A Wonderful Historical Coverage ...always History Marche channel sharing Informative history Episodes
Didn't expect a WW1 video! A great surprise
Thanks KHK, lovely to see you here!
I like to use this major turning point in world war 1 to remind my friends how dynamic and fluid the political landscape was towards the end of the war. Things changed a lot for some groups and those changes set the stage for the hostility that would rise in WW2. We often all of the sudden realIe there’s a Soviet Russia, and Germany has become nazis and that’s the story of the eastern conflict. American education am I right? Well thank you guys for you hard work and beautiful story telling!
Our education is everything they said soviet and oppressive regimes educations would be lol. I’m finding out alot of things are this way.
I never even know about the war between Russia and Poland, 1919-21. I was taught that there was peace after the armistice. American children and young adults are taught history very poorly, in my experience.
@@unionsquaregrassman there was also the north Siberian intervention! American troops fought Russians on Russian soil!
@@ianfitzpatrick2230
They wanted the 40% Russian gold reserves the Czechs managed to get their hands on .
Our High Shcool education system was all about the civil war but onlt a few chapters the rest was all about slavery and a few unheard of blacks,,,,, Teacher (Black and dumb as a rock) tried to tell me some Black general led a Hatian Army against the French Grand Army and was the first general to defeat Napoleon....... I know all about Haiti ( not a good black roll modle for a country) and I never new Naploeon left the Continent nor that a Hatian Army landed in Europe.... Revisionist BS history.................
It was not defeated in 11 days. The operation was successful in 11 days. This title is a bit over simplified.
they were defeated. russia has never won a war on its own
L TO THE SOVIETS, L TO COMMUNISM
@@Blox117 copium level in this comment
@@anil2584 enjoy your success in ukraine
@@Blox117 balkhmuth
As I recall, a large part of the reason the Germans advanced so quickly because they encountered very little resistance since Russian troops had just stopped fighting for the most part. They still manned the front line but when the Germans would move forward, they would just retreat without a fight.
Because the army had been disbanded by the Bolsheviks, so there were virtually no resistance
@@andrewbarton8034 it was disbanded due February revolution. Bolsheviks did nothing for that, as in October 1917 there was no army to disband.
@@danielkirpichnikov2007 thaf's false. The mass of the soldiers stayed on the front lines (and some even fought) in 1917. It was not until the Bolsheviks' coming to power the army was disbanded
Nonsense propaganda. Russians manned more troops on the front than the Germans, but still they lost.
Love the content, please keep up the work.
Amazing video as always i hope u could do some WW2 videos as well !!!
@HistoryMarche awesome, great intro for 1919/1920-1921 polish - bolshevik war, wuld love to see you cover that
This is arguably the most underdiscussed cause of WWII, that many in German Army felt they had finally reconquered the Baltic “Wild East” (where the Baltic German settlers had remained the nobility for 700 years even under the Swedish and Russian Empires), along with establishing a presence in the breadbasket of Ukraine and the fought-over-for-millennia Crimea, and that it had all been taken away from their victorious army by the surrender of the republican government in 1918.
Then to add insult to injury, in 1919 when the Bolsheviks threatened the Baltic Germans in the newly independent Baltic states, including a Soviet takeover over of Latvia and Riga, the old Germanic Order and Hanseatic city, Germany recaptured Courland and Livonia with the promise of settlement for a volunteer force which was joined by Baltic German forces, and installed a Baltic German government in Latvia. However they were then defeated by the Classicalist Estonians and Latvians, who had already ejected the Soviets from Estonia, at the Battle of Cesis and Latvians regained power in Riga, although the Baltic German nobility remained significant under the new government, but they were stripped of a large portions of their landholdings which was given to Latvians.
This all was seen as a revitalization of the old “East Settling”, the original German settlement of Prussia, Riga and the Baltic, and was later characterized as the beginning of a new “Drive to the East", with the Baltics, Ukraine and Crimea forming the heart of the German “Living Space” idea.
Show me a signed document by Hitler stating that he has any intention of colonising Eastern Europe.
This excuses mass genocide in the ussr by Germany?
This is conveniently ignored in history because it would make Germany seem rational, which they were. Just as the Soviet imperialist expansions west aren’t even covered in our history books while Germany invaded Poland was the end of the world.
@@blitzy3244 polish imperialist expansions are not covered either
From military point this was a waste of time, men and resources. Victory was achieved too late to really use Ukranian grain and right moment for decisive attack in the West was missed. If Spring offensive came early and with more manpower, USA wont save Europe...
"No War, No Peace."
Then the Trotskists ask why Stalin was more popular...
@@omarbradley6807 Well he got to pick who got the jobs.
I was completely floored when I learnt Trotsky did this for the first time and to this day don't see how he wasn't laughed out of every room after he came up with this
@@throneandaltar7557 They asked him to come up with an alternative because without allied backing they couldn't afford to stay in the war. They assumed Germany would switch focus to the Western front and them alone because they knew the Allies had been using the Provisional Government to tie down German troops. When they realized Germany *wanted* to keep fighting, they agreed to the terms, but by then it was too late.
@@brainflash1 Lenin and the Soviets gave Trotsky a clear instruction to conclude peace along the front line. And if it failed, Lenin was ready to fight further, using it already in agitation for the defense of the Fatherland. We are ready for a world without conditions, but the Kaiser wants to capture everyone.
Trotsky somehow thought that the dissolution of the army would immediately cause a revolution in Germany. By the way, Lenin tried with all his might to cancel the order to disband the army.
a good video. Keep them coming
I love your videos for relating the hard facts in an accurate manner also being entertaining. True history lesson at its finest. I do not miss any of your videos, I am an addict to perfection😄
Thanks for this!
I think adding the year/time-line of the event in the title would help a lot. I didn't know this was a video on WW1 until I started playing it. Same with the videos on say the Scottish clan system or Egyptian fatimid video. It also piques my interest more.
Same
+1
Correct
Perhaps because HistoryMarche bring up lesser known subjects? I think this channel is overlooked and deserve more attention, hvye have a broad and very interesting selection. I.M.H.O.
There is a video description, like on almost any historical video on youtube, i get that you want to watch videos here but it can't be that hard to read literally sentence because that is exactly where it explains the timeline and the year
General Max Hoffman finally getting some love. Nice
I love to see you covering WW1. As of now, I am writing an essay on the topic, so it's great to see someone like you make a video on it.
these vids are really informative and entertaining!!!
This is cool I've always love history especially told in such a way as this 🇫🇮 is of particular interest to me. A country forged by fire and steel.
Lol, I remember the Russian plan we don't make peace and we stall, and hopefully, the Germans stop fighting. "Germany I'm about to do a pro gamer move".
To be honest its misleading. Bolsheviks were hoping for a communist revolution in Germany after Russia, and then in the whole world. Yup, they seriously believed in their fairy tales and that's why they didn't prepared
This is Trotsky's decision. Lenin wanted peace, along the front line, and after that, demobilization.
But Germany was also overwhelmed by unprecedented greed. Instead of capturing Poland and Lithuania and buying food from Russia with money. They wanted everything for nothing, as a result, they continued the war on two fronts. And in the occupied lands, instead of free food, guerrilla warfare and Bolshevik agitation of their soldiers.
Interesting topic would very much like to hear more about this. Thank you.
Amazing video
The Germans know their way around this region .
This clip greatly helps my understanding of the Weltkrieg Mod for Hearts of Iron 4. Kind makes sense how the landscape could've went if Germany had won WWI
>if Germany had won WWI
And then socialist revolution strike down Kaiser. What a mess that would be.
Nicely informative video
great video, thanks
Top notch vie on an undercovered bit of the first world war
thats crazy so the reason finland, baltics and poland are independant is because of the desicions of imperial germany?
and the bolsheviks refusal to surrender
And the Poles refusal to surrender. Poland forever.
Finnish reds were already losing by the time germans landed
Also poland killed a lot of germans and took German land after 1919
Thanks for making this video, now i know how operation where my great great grandfather was look liked.
Great video!
If you ever wondered why the Nazis were so convinced they’d crush the Soviets in a year here’s your answer
The Kaiser’s army was ground to a bloody halt in France but crushed Russia and then the Bolsheviks with ease
An army that had routed France and Britain in weeks would surely crush the bolsheviks again
Also many men fighting in WW1 would be the German generals of WW2. Hitler included.
I was going to say this, thanks. "We have only to kick in the front door and the whole rotten structure will collapse!"
@@terraflow__bryanburdo4547 yeah, they kicked, and then rebuilt Berlin from the ground
And remembered winters from Russia much milder what they endured in the 1940s
@@pawelnowak9440 IMHO, the winter gets somewhat overplayed as a factor.
The whole Nazi race theory told them that Slavs were incapable of sophisticated warfare and they were communists so they'd never manage to build 10s of thousands of tanks etc
No mention of the Makhnovists and anarchists in Ukraine fighting both Austro-Hungrian troops and Soviets at the same time?
Problal;y cause they were not much to them in the big picture...
Somewhat happy to see this video. Speaking finnish, german etc and knowing local history I would have been happy to help with pronouciation and so on, but anyway, quite great video done. anyway. Great to see things in somewhat different views... And good to remember this part of history....
great stuff
Treaty of Brest-Litovsk - Russia lost 34% of its population, 54% of its industrial land, 89% of its coalfields, and 26% of its railways. Russia was also fined 300 million gold marks.[37]
This happened before the Treaty of Versailles and even after that the Germans cried that the Treaty of Versailles was unfair! While they themselves, when they won, literally tore off the last shoes from the losing sides 🤣
the Russians had their final revenge in 1945 i guess lol
@@therearenoshortcuts9868 Even after German unconditional surrender, they did not lose nearly as much as Russians did in this treaty..
They basicly freed the nation from russian Grips
The germans comitted the same mistake with this treaty which could have been just as costly in the long run, like the treaty of Versailles.
No, ivan , you (Muscovy ) lost nothing
Just keep in mind:
Russian Civil War 1917 - 1923
Operation Faustschlag 1918
Same with the sailor revolts in germany (1918), which sparked into a full blown revolution.
That's why the Kaiser had to flee the country and the Weimar Republic was found and doomed in the next year after signing the treaty of Versailles.
Fun fact, the Weimar republic and the Soviet Union were both very isolated after the 1. WW.
That's why both met in Rapallo and the Weimar Republic was the first country, which recognized the Soviet Union as a state.
The Germans made a deal that they could test their tanks there (disregarding the Treaty of Versailles) and the Soviets got technology and engineers from the germans.
Both wanted to end the isolation.
Excuses the russians where getting thrashed on the battlefield so it wouldn't make a difference.
@@ninjaa6952 trashed you don't no shit about eastern front
@@jackhardy3905battle of tannenberg alone is proof enough
@@mmaedits2002 It doesnt proof anything
Well done video.
7:15
Wrangell: I can see where this is going...
I wonder how many German soldiers in this campaign would later be senior officers or generals in operation barbarossa? You can see why they might think it would be successful after their experience here
Many, Including Hitler who was also a soldier in this time.
@@itzikashemtov6045, Hitler was in the Western Front, not the Eastern Front.
@@nathanpangilinan4397 I know he was on front when they attacked my country Serbia, we're not western front tho.
@@goxyeagle8446 He was serving in the Army at that time, yes, but he was not anywhere near Serbia.
@@randomlyentertaining8287 Might be, I have other informations. Anyways he was Austrian and Austrians lost on their first attempt to conquer Serbia. It was first Allies victory so he must remembered that for sure
Russia has always been overestimated because of how big the country is. For the largest part of history it was nothing more than a rural backwater, severely underdeveloped in comparison to its neighbours save for some urban centers. Even today Russia "only" has about the same population as Germany and France combined.
But then again, Russia has also been severely underestimated because of how big the country is. Napoleon and Hitler weren't intimidated by the massive blob on their maps, and we all know how that went down. You have to sacrifice your manpower, Russia only has to sacrifice ground. And you can bet that you run out of manpower before Russia runs out of ground.
This is to beautifull I cannot describe with words that map, victory of this size magneficient
there are only countable youtube channels, i think 4 or 5 who make detailed videos on war i mean explaining the war itself and not only the overall history and you are one of them, just wanted to say that please also make videos on more modern wars such as the war going on right now, after it ends, and also arab Israel war, as well as the indo pak war, these wars need to be covered by someone like you
And of those channels, the one with the worst viewers is Knowledgia. The amount of idiots there....
Knowledgia is a jack of all trades, and therefore a master of none, so they get a lot wrong, but they are very interesting videos in general. Of course, not as top notch as these.
PS Concerning India, they should do a video on the Indianoccupation of Sikkim where the Mongooids of Sikkim supposedly wanted to be owned by India instead of being free. PFF! I'm sure the Indian soldiers wielding guns were not at all an influence in the voting procedures. "Votes don't count. What counts is who counts the votes." The US occupation of Hawaii may ahve been covered already. Dumb liberals bash China for occupying Tibet when they do similarly.
The most humiliating defeat in our history by far
I'm sure that defeat in 1905 war with Japan is more humiliating, imagine being the first European nation that lost the major war with so called "worst race"
The worst is yet to come.
@@rikkithinn7258
Lol you are funny lad
@@KIRILL-fl7cp Mozhet, no to ya skazal pravada ist, Bog nakazhet neblagodarynkh.
@@rikkithinn7258
Накажет тех кто 8 лет бомбил Донбасс, убивая мирных женщин и детей, а сейчас прикидывается невинной жертвой
I have never heard Tsar Nicholas II described by anybody as "ruthless." Incompetent and gullible perhaps. 10:26
Yeah, wtf was that
make a similar one on the western front as well please
👍thank you
This is new for me and I'm Russian so thank you for doing so much research
What oblast do you live in?
поколение егэ?
It should not be that new for you. Lenin was a tool in the hand of the central powers. He greed to the harsh terms of the Brest-Litovsk treaty because for him the main thing was succedding in fully taking the power against the other faction who wanted to control Russia. One of his main argument to convince people to be on his side was to get Russia out of the war. And as we know, during the years that follower the war, the soviets took back most of the territories they let go in the Brest-Litovsk treaty.
10:27
Tsar Nikki wasn't ruthless 😆, he was miserable
The Protocols of The Learned Elders of Zion explain that powerful Gentile kigns were the only visible threat to the Jewish plans for global domination.
I plan to do a video explaining how the Protocols were frame to look like a plagiarized hoax. It has to do with the fact that the... well... I'll wait for the video.
PS I worship Jesus, a Jew. His race isn't the problem. The racist Talmudic culture is the problem. It is so ironic that the dispersal of the Jews by Rome especially, has become their strength, for then they had agents in ALL countries, and that made collusion and conspiracy rather easy.
If he's Russian he's ruthless
Germans attacking in conquering war but they're not ruthless
Typical western propaganda
Is this the same narrator as the channel WildCiencias?
I like both channels!
I would like you to make videos of more recent wars
Great video. It’s impressive how after years of relative stagnation (far less than in the West but none the less still comparatively a lot ) Germany was so successful at almost overnight defeating the Soviet army and capturing vast swathes of territory. Of courses the total collapse of the Russian state, the arrival of a new radical regime and an ongoing civil war likely didn’t help. Still it’s an impressive feet. I wonder to what extent this did prolong the war, as the food from Ukraine ( although heavily impacted by partisans as the video showed) must have helped mitigate the Allied blockade.
Actually it was too late to mitigate the blockade. German people in 1917 already suffered from hunger, some starved to death...
@@alexzero3736 Yes...which is why capturing Ukraine's food production would help mitigate the ongoing impact of the blockade...
The most beautiful thing is that during the Second World War the Soviet Union simply destroyed Germany completely. Just Despite all her achievements, successes, And it shows the strength of the Soviet Union and the Russians in particular.
@@denchik6278 the Soviet Union was everything except beautiful.
No freedom, just a dysfunctional system where man tries to control everything. A huge big state controls everything including what people think. Communism isn't very different from Nazism.
@@denchik6278 the soviet union collapsed 40 years later. How is that strong. Weak state with poor people thats what russia is. The only thing going for them is the size and the weather
Germany almost soloed the whole world
Indeed masterrace
France soloed the world for 5 wars with napoleon. But i guess it is napoleon after all
what Rule did the KDM of Poland as shown on the map played during the war?
Poles were fighting on both sides of the conflict, ones forced to join the army by the Russians and other by the Germans. In the end there was a revolution in Poland and it took land both from Germany and Russia and formed Poland.
It would have been nice to mention operation Albion. Early German naval blitzkrieg
OK, You win. I will walk away.😆
But why would that happen? Also, how would that be interesting?
@@l.s.9095 Why? The outcome of the war in the west wasn't settled in 1917. It was a stalemate at that point. In the east, the Germans were winning. If they could have concentrated more effort on it, the Bolsheviks and the Communist revolution would have ended in a loss. The western powers were not big fans of the Communist revolution. They probably wouldn't have stopped Germany from going into Russia heavily. The Entente powers probably would have agreed to end the war at that point with an amicable peace. With pressure from the civil population, the Entente powers needed to end the war anyway. Germany wouldn't have had the humiliation of losing the war that they had in November 1918. The rise of National Socialism would never have happened. No WWII, at least the way it happened in reality. I find that interesting. If you don't, I understand.
The beef Germans had was with the British Empire and France who were suffocating German expansion in Africa and German commerce generally. Imperial Russia was an incompetent menace at that point.
The Allies would have never allowed that
Wasn't going to happen, the whole reason they made peace in the east was because the Russians have been defeated, France and Britain were bloodied, but hardly beaten. IT's possible they could have tried to make peace with the west after making peace in the east, but I doubt the 2 sides could have come to an agreement.
to be honest, it is interesting that the Germans did so selfishly but they played a vital role in laying the groundwork for the independence of eastern european states. not their actual intention ofcourse but certainly true
Also prove that Putin is right about reclaiming those nations, as they were part of Russia.
Ruthless Tzar Nicholas. Stalin, hold my beer.
Eastern Front, Lithuania,
a video:
The Battle of Lake Narocz 1916 , a presentation by Frank Pleszak - Y T
Your a ww1 german in the Eastern front:😁
Your a ww1 german on the Western front:💀
Your a ww2 german on the western front:😁
Your a ww2 german on the eastern front:💀
Hitler remembered this and said "11 days? I can do that again."
4 years later: *Soviet Anthem intensifies*
In Soviet Russia, you don't invade. You in-wade.. in the blood of your fellows.
Incredible that even after this, the central powers were defeared
Great video. It’s crazy how few Americans know this happened.
Why? Why is it surprising that few people care to learn about a German offensive in Russia in 1917? It had no impact on the end result of the war nor really interfered with the rise of the Soviets.
In the end, the Soviet Union rose equally, whatever one may say, and this is all that Rostov was captured by others, it never happened at all.
And in the final days of ww1, German/Austrian army even conflicted with their Turkish Ally in caucus to control the oil cities. So it’s reasonable for the free corp to feel “stabbed in the back” when suddenly heard their government surrendered.
Downvote for "ruthless" Tsar Nicholas. Like... what?
Like shooting civilians in 1905
@@Spiderfisch yeah because he ordered them to do that -____- (he didn’t) he wasn’t even in the city at the time.
@@gwlevits the men who did it were under his responsibility
@@Spiderfisch I didn’t say he didn’t bear any responsibility, I said he wasn’t ruthless. He didn’t order them to shoot. It was a tragic accident caused by provocateurs.
Very interesting narrative.
Interesting the city of Hapsal is now Haapsalu and the city of Reval is now Rakvere
I never realized that the Germans were so successful on the Eastern front. Imagine if they would have treated the ukrainians well and conscripted them into their army in order to hurl them on the Western front.
As cannon fodder
Conscripting the people of the occupied eastern lands would have been the fastest way to get them to revolt at that point.
why should they have fought for them if they didnt even want to give them food?
It wasn't a matter of manpower for the Germans it was much more about resources and especially food due to the British blockade. Taking the food was a lot more useful
Why they wanted to win france anyway? Russia was always the bigger threat. Germany should’ve destroyed Russia once and for all when they got the chance.
Germany watching Russia slip into Civil War and unrest with its army in ruins: 👹👹👹
Their infection-injection of the human virus Vladimir Lenin worked perfectly!
When will the Solferini video with PMF Productions come out?
Working on it. Some key members of both teams were on vacation, but we're getting back on the horse.
wheres the update to hannibal series!!! I want that!
A Central Power victory in WWI would have not only saved Germany from radicalization, but also Russia, since Imperial Germany would never tolerate a bolshevik state on its borders and finished them off after the war (just like the Allies tried in our timeline, but failed). Which would ultimately mean a less toxic world than ours.
Well yes and we would be all speaking German 😀Greetings from Slovakia!
@@NerickovaNoha Germans didn't really do the Germanising thing, not like the french or other slavic countries did (atleast not during this time, later ... well)
The permanent continuation of European Colonialism is not preferable
@@Ghreinos The Germans were very much into the Germanising thing
Yes they did in Poland.
To be fair, the soviet requisitions were just as bad if not worse than the Germans' requisitions.
They did not take the food out of the country.
Exactly. Many peasants, who lived through WWI and soviet repressions, had good memories about german occupation. Much less amounts of food were taken, independent government was preserved(in some point, at least, it had borders and wasn`t a part of Germany), no etnic/class oppressions etc. Because of that, many people from Belarus, Ukraine, Baltics joined Wehrmacht in WWII as collaborationists.
@@julianshepherd2038 USSR did take food out of the country for sale. All Stalin`s industrialization was carried out by money got from grain and gold exports. Also, taking the food out of villages(and selling it afterwards) was quite common as punishment for "counter-revolutionary activity/sabotage of grain plan" in early 1920-s and 1930-s.
@@mitchell1489 what a joke, Germans took everything they could from there in order to win on western front and the situation there was very bad. Skoropadsky the one who ruled on UNR wasn't supported by Ukrainian people because he let to Germans to take everything that's why Skoropadsky government fell and he ran to Germany.
You're talking about people who were nationalists during ww2 who were cheated by Germans one of them was Bandera who was imprisoned by Germans when he realized that Germans aren't going to give them freedom.
Germans lied very nice during ww2 that's why some Ukrainians believed in it but it's not the majority.
@@julianshepherd2038 yeah, they took everything they could because they were f*cked on western front, they sent the strongest troops (German and Austria Hungary) on eastern front that's why they lost on western front.
@11:50 Independence of the Baltic states, Finland, Poland, Ukraine only after the armistice in the west on November 9th, 1918?
NO!, most of them delared independece already in 1917. Recognition might have taken place later.
Estonia: 28. Novemebr 1917
Latvia: 18. November 1917
Lituania: 11. December 1917
Finland: 04. December 1917
Poland: 11. Nov 1918
Ukraine: 07./20.Novemebr 1917 as of 01. January 2018 within Russia, 25. January 1918 outside of Russia.
Belarus: December 1917 selection of a government / 25. March 1918 formation of a parliament.
Unternehman Fuastschlag was the template for the later invasion of Russia, Unternehman Barbarossa. Even allied commanders believed the USSR would roll over in 1941, just as it had in 1917.
Well, why was Tsar Nicolaus II. "ruthless" ? if so , he would have possibly retained hs throne.
Jews got rid of him. They prfer dumbocracies and commies bbecause atheists and liberals are mroe easy to manipulate than royal-loyals.
To summarize : the west allied victory over Germany in 1918 gave the russian USSR the opportunity to regain control thereafter over newly independant baltic states Poland Belarus and Ukraine. And if this 1918 victory occured it is mainly due to the 1917 arrival of US troops in France. Conclusion : if not for the USA intervention in WWI the USSR would have been in 1918 in the russia s 1990 borders. Russia should be thankful to the USA.
С чего быть благодарным ? В 1916 и 1917 весь немецкий кулак и значительный австро-венгерский кулак были направлен в Россию, а на западе шла траншейная война. (Австрия даже хотела пойти на уступки советской России, чтобы сохранить свое положение.) И надо учесть, что белая армия не воевала с немцами, так как хотела, чтобы немецкие войска захватили коммунистические города
И еще маленький момент: если бы страны, которые по брестскому миру остались независимыми, то никакого СССР бы не было, была бы просто российская советская федеративная социалистическая республика. СССР создали только для того, чтобы красная Украина, красная белорусь и красная ЗСФСР были равноправными членами одной страны.
There would be a Kaiserreich plot that is better for Russia than the USSR (the Union of States that sucked resources from Russia and Russians.)
US troops did not win World War I, only shortened it. The war was lost by logistics - Britain had solved its food problem and had ever growing munitions, Germany was starving and running out of raw materials. The end was inevitable. However, Britain was increasingly worried about revolution breaking out, both in Britain and all across Europe so they encouraged the US to commit to the war to hasten it as quickly as possible. Likewise, WW2 would have ended the same way regardless of US entering the war because the Axis ability to feed and rearm itself was steadily deteriorating.
Do you understand what nonsense you just wrote? What would happen if the Allies did not win the First World War? They would have lost this war! There are no other options. The tension of social and economic forces in Europe was such that in Britain, France and Germany there would be a cascade of Socialist revolutions, in fact, not only Lenin, but all the socialist forces in Europe counted on this. You simply cannot imagine the power of the proletarian Socialist associations at the end of the Great War. The result of a German victory could have been the Soviet Union from the Atlantic to the Pacific. The coming to power of the fascists and Nazis in Germany and Italy, the nationalist movements in Poland and Finland were vital in order to prevent socialist revolutions through the without judicial reprisals against the leaders and activists of the Socialist movements.
Just bingeing
Intressant som vanligt.
Why didn’t you deploy your endless manpower, your fierce winter, and your legion of bears balancing on unicycles?! You fools!
Yeah people still think this will happen even in the current war. People have been telling me that Russia will win by Christmas unironically. We are in a loop.
12:04 And yet people wonder why Poland was diplomatically isolated by 1941.
Well, this part of "Ukraine" that was "taken" was populated in some regions by 80% of Polish people, mostly city of Lwów, where Poles were 85-90%, there were mostly polish-speaking villages on Wołyń and Podole, as well as on Wileńszczyzna(Villinus and surroundings were birth places of most of Polish rulling Staff, mainly Piłsudski), on Belarus there were full-polish cities, like Grodno, and Brześć Litewski(today Brześć), and also countryside was populated by Poles, and adding a cherry on top, Belarus started existing in 1918, that was totally new creation, made by germans to keep their old enemies, Poles, in check, because many of Polish national uprisings(1831, 1863) had been taking places in teritories belonging today to Ukraine, and Belarus, actually, as much as 8 million Poles lived in polish eastern teritories, that demographic only changed after Mass murders from the hands of germans and Russians, and also Wołyń massacre, conducted by Stiepan Bandera facist wing of Ukrainian nationalists, and there are some horrific descriptions of killings right there, and also by Russian forcefull civilian relocations to the "given" western territories, and now only up to 300 000 polish people lives on Wołyń and Podole, so yes, we had a rough relationships with neighbours, because they took our territories away, and we had a good relationships only with Romania, Hungary, and Ukraine(Siemon Petlura government, whitch actually wanted to give polish territories back to Poland for help in fight with USSR, and we all know what happened in 1921)
PS.and let me just remind you that those "Belarussian", and "Western Ukraine" territories were polish for 600 years back then
Also Poland had to be isolated, because USSR was in war with Poland at that time, and UK chose USSR over Poland and betrayed it by doing so
And I don't know if you know about Chechoslowakia taking Polish territory by force in 1919, when they Poland was preocupied by soviet offensive
And to give you a glimpse of what were those teritories like, imagine when Scotland would sucede from UK and it would take city of York and northern Britain, or if Canada would take Northern America up to Boston, and Great Lakes region
does anyone told you before u sound like the guy who does the mission briefing in sniper elite
So Germany Basically did the Blitzkrieg in wwi and did not even realize and WON XD
The Treaty of Versailles is one of the great atrocities of all mankind.
Ok fascist sympathizer.
It's baffling how Germany surrender to allied forces while winning in the eastern front.
Not really. Morale was low after 4 years of war, supplies of food, weapons, ammunition and mostly everything else were running low as well. Confronting them was an enemy force rejuvenated by American soldiers and materiel. It was a war of attrition and Germany had been starved for 4 years, their soldiers and civilians had had enough. No amount of conquest in the east was going to make up for that.
@@NotOfWomanBorn Germany tried to win before America got there and used up the things you list.
And that was them done.
Is that a bad thing now? lmao
@@zakkart yeah
The next Hannibal Barca Punic wars video please
Turns out that 'Barbarossa' twenty tears later was just a "rerun"..
We will sometimes forget that Germany caused the Cold War too, they sent Lenin over.
Shut up. You couldn't even defeat Russia in six months!
Lenin was a rootless cosmopolitan
Can't help but notice you mispronounced "Kharkov", comrade...
My first reaction was: "Is this a fanfic about what would've happend" and later realized this was the east front in WW 1. Like what? If the government didn't surrender and pulled all troops back from the eastern front would anything have changed?
Historymarche! Please cover the battle of Al-Qudsia during the reign of Umar Farooq R.A against the sassanid empire.
The history channels nowadays are racing in portraying Russia's historic defeats, adhering to the Russophobic mania trend in the West. They lose therefore their neutrality, unbiasedness, and objectivity. I can't help and not see this video as well as a part of anti-Russian propaganda - it fails to describe the greater context and complex details of WWI and the Russian civil war. Even the title is very misleading, as there were two Russias fighting each other. The video only focuses to point out that Russia loses in the end. Please try not to take sides when reporting a historic event. You surely don't do that when you describe the Roman invasion of the Gaul, or Mongol invasion of China - you just report the facts, and explain the motives and the outcomes of the event.
Serbian talking about being one sided lol and also talking about propaganda, go write it on some ruSSian channel, they are masters of propaganda, everything in this video was described perfectly, ruSSians lost because they were weak as always and most of them didn't even know what they are fighting for, western propaganda is nothing when compared to ruSSian. Yes West should finally step up and stop 21st century Nazi ruSSians.
@@avtozastava6782 I am trying to make a sane point here.
You assumed my ethnicity, which is a very wrong thing. But you are wrong, I am not a Serb. My name is very unserbian. My nationality has nothing to do with a remark I said.
Again: I cannot take any of the information as unbiased, as it is being affected by the actual political situation. The Western world is not less affected by this propaganda.
History Marche is also affected by that, although I respect them as a very reliable source.
@@dubravkokovacevic3489 You sound same as any pro ruSSian guy, you just should snap out of your illusions about ruSSia, it is not powerful the best of the best country, quite the opposite, it is prison and global evil, and no western propaganda is nothing compared to russian, silly for you to even try to persuade someone about it.
@@avtozastava6782 please learn to discuss at the same level as me, then I'll be glad to answer your questions. The conflict of opinions lies in the very core of the modern Western Civilization and you are not communicating in that spirit.
If you are from Europe and have such stupid opinions then I can recommend you to get to your loved ruSSia and live there, also you can't even call russian invasion of Ukraine a war, cause you clearly are already brainwashed by ruso propaganda, also why the hell shouldn't west tell the true about ruSSia ? It is terrorist country which is terrorising whole Europe with nuclear weapons and threatening to destroy largest nuclear power plant, so yes it is only right to write in bad tone about ruSSia cause nothing good comes from that forsaken country.