Superb and beautiful video! I've saved this to my large Arizona playlist, for the Saguaro National Park West section of the playlist. Thanks for posting this beautiful video. :)
Why do you say it was a forest-sound overlay? The Sonoran Desert is rich with birds; it is a life-filled environment. I don't know where you're from, but those are our bird-songs. We hear them all day long and some of them at night as well. Here are the songs of our Sonoran Desert birds; we have many, many kinds. And yes, we also have woodpeckers. ruclips.net/video/bHAop_HlO-I/видео.html Do you live in the Sonoran Desert to know our birds? Do you know how sound carries in the desert? I sure do. Perhaps you'd like to see my two Arizona playlists, one being a large video tour, and the other being "Beautiful Arizona, Scenery for the Soul." (You do hear the bees and the footsteps in this video, yes?)
@@cacatr4495 я живу в Украине . и именно в той части страны где много лесов. и я люблю лес! здесь же четкое наложение звука на видеоряд . посмотрите внимательно . и еще. я обладаю музыкальным слухом и четко различаю звук своего леса от других. у вас я слышу пение горлицы,это лесная птица. звук дятла слышен раскатисто ,с эхом. такой эффект может быть только в лесу!!! и пение птиц идентично пению наших птиц на Полесье, Украина. а в присланом вами звучании птиц нет даже намека на идентичность вставленного видеоряда пустыни Сонора. П.С. я очень обожаню звуки леса , пустыни , степи . каждый звук, вздох , крик живой природы прекрасен . я ими наслаждаюсь. если есть возможность поменяйте звуковую дорожку. и вставте уникальные пения птиц именно вашей пустыни Сонора. и я буду с удовольствием смотретьи и слушать те места где еще не был. Удачи Вам.
@@СергейГраф-й4е First, I have no control over this video; it is not mine. Second, Arizona has many great Ponderosa (Yellow Pine) forests, to almost a third of the State's land mass, and many of those birds are also down here in the desert, and in neighboring States. I understand what you've shared, but I recognize many of these bird voices from daily life. We do have the Mourning Dove, and the White-winged Dove, both of which are throughout the West, including in the great Ponderosa Pine forests. Sound carries in the desert in a mighty way; it's astounding, and in canyons and basins/bowls between hills, there are echos. The Gila Woodpecker pecks holes in Saguaros, and the sound can be heard. Assuming the poster did use a sound-overlay, what would be the possibility that the recording came from a Ukrainian forest? There are many forests here in the U.S. from which recordings could have been made, or Canada. As to the audio-video I linked of Sonoran Desert bird-songs, the recording engineer overlaid one morning's recordings upon another morning's recordings, and from another spot in the desert a few miles away. There is not a "sequence" that is heard in the desert: the birds vocalize as they are motivated, and besides the Saguaro, there are trees that the woodpecker pecks. I understand being a purist and appreciating native sounds of the desert. Thank you for sharing your input.
@@СергейГраф-й4е This may interest you. I just read that what we call Mourning Doves (very common birds here), are also called Turtle Doves. I also saw a video of the bird called the Northern Cardinal living in Hawaii. The Pacific is a huge ocean, far, far away from Arizona, where one of our most common birds is the Northern Cardinal. And yet, it is also resident to Hawaii. Birds are known for far-flung migrations, flying from Alaska to Mexico every year, even the tiny Hummingbirds, and back again! Not only the great whales, but butterflies too! We shouldn't assume that all birds are specific to a certain region; their species might just be resident to several places.
Krieger There has been some discussion about the audio. If you do overlay audio recordings on your desert videos, keep in mind that bird-songs and sound effects do differ from a forest sound, and that our desert birds should be heard. Here is a local recording that is excellent: ruclips.net/video/bHAop_HlO-I/видео.html
Thank you for the feedback. I liked that recording you've recommended. In the Sonoran desert around Tucson the main bird sounds are the dove, cactus wren, raven, red tail hawk, flicker, woodpecker rattle and the lovely cardinals. I've found some of those online except the cactus wren, flicker and cardinal. Most of the bird sounds in this video are what is present here. But there is one that doesn't belong although it's close enough.
@@bluedawn45 There is a woodpecker with an obvious forest-echo, that viewers have noticed. That's unfortunate, it's a give-away. A Ukrainian viewer in the comments and I had a discussion you can read here, where they say they heard birds in this video that are common to their forested area, naming them. Most of the birds in this video sound alright, but the woodpecker-echo (although we certainly do have the Gila Woodpecker) surely doesn't fit because of that echo. How wonderful it would be if you were to make a Springtime video from your archival footage that was filmed a little earlier, as in April, where the brittle bush and Palo Verdes are blooming more reliably and profusely than in this video, and where the audio is completely local. My 2 Arizona playlists (the large one being an organized video tour of much of the State > take a look) are getting a lot of views (they include a number of your videos), and it's appropriate and fitting to only use local audio, to honor the viewers' trust. I hope you consider making one like that; you make worthwhile videos and I appreciate and enjoy your videos. I've just subscribed to your channel; thank you for sharing your videos.
@@cacatr4495 Yes a spring blooming video with correct sound effects is on my to-do list. It's unfortunate that I have a Ukrainian woodpecker sound effect in there....I'll try harder next time. Thanks for your good input.
This place is Magical, so beautiful, heaven on earth. Thanks 🙏♥️
What a beautiful place.
Beautiful..im in Ct ...always wanted to see the desert
I love the sound of you walking so perfect along with the animal sounds.
Fabulous region - one of a kind
Superb and beautiful video! I've saved this to my large Arizona playlist, for the Saguaro National Park West section of the playlist. Thanks for posting this beautiful video. :)
Wow amazing place for hiking , Beautiful flowers . Thank You !! Great job .:)
thanks for sharing !!! all is beautiful.
I love it! thanks that was relaxing to watch listening to the wildlife.
Thank you. Those flowers are fascinating!
Beautiful, love love Tucson!!!
Türkiye den selamlar..🇹🇷 çiçekler kus sesleri harika..belki hicbir zaman gelme şansımız olmaz ama sayenizde gormus olduk🤗🤗😍😍😍
I have watched a few videos and have become somewhat fascinated with cactus trees and Saguaro National Park.
Beautiful ❤
Beautiful👏💞🌷
Спасибо!
So much life going on, I never expected this.
Beautiful! This is all from May? I live in the WA States desert and it blooms in the Fall. Thank you.
April and May mostly.
What trail was that Crested Saguaro on?
Somewhere between Loma Verde trailhead and Garwood trail via Squeeze Pen and Carrillo trails.
@@bluedawn45 wow that's a lot of trails. You cant pin point it any better?
@@Iseekoutthetruth That's a fairly short run really...it's somewhere in the middle.
@@bluedawn45 is it one of those parks you have to pay?
@@bluedawn45 so do you take squeeze pen trail towards Carrilo trail?
hay, thanks
✨❤️
😵😵😵😵
зачем было звуковую дорожку из леса накладывать на видеоряд из пустыни , не понимаю. бред какой-то.
Why do you say it was a forest-sound overlay? The Sonoran Desert is rich with birds; it is a life-filled environment. I don't know where you're from, but those are our bird-songs. We hear them all day long and some of them at night as well. Here are the songs of our Sonoran Desert birds; we have many, many kinds. And yes, we also have woodpeckers. ruclips.net/video/bHAop_HlO-I/видео.html Do you live in the Sonoran Desert to know our birds? Do you know how sound carries in the desert? I sure do. Perhaps you'd like to see my two Arizona playlists, one being a large video tour, and the other being "Beautiful Arizona, Scenery for the Soul." (You do hear the bees and the footsteps in this video, yes?)
@@cacatr4495 я живу в Украине . и именно в той части страны где много лесов. и я люблю лес! здесь же четкое наложение звука на видеоряд . посмотрите внимательно . и еще. я обладаю музыкальным слухом и четко различаю звук своего леса от других. у вас я слышу пение горлицы,это лесная птица. звук дятла слышен раскатисто ,с эхом. такой эффект может быть только в лесу!!! и пение птиц идентично пению наших птиц на Полесье, Украина. а в присланом вами звучании птиц нет даже намека на идентичность вставленного видеоряда пустыни Сонора.
П.С. я очень обожаню звуки леса , пустыни , степи . каждый звук, вздох , крик живой природы прекрасен . я ими наслаждаюсь. если есть возможность поменяйте звуковую дорожку. и вставте уникальные пения птиц именно вашей пустыни Сонора. и я буду с удовольствием смотретьи и слушать те места где еще не был.
Удачи Вам.
@@СергейГраф-й4е
First, I have no control over this video; it is not mine. Second, Arizona has many great Ponderosa (Yellow Pine) forests, to almost a third of the State's land mass, and many of those birds are also down here in the desert, and in neighboring States. I understand what you've shared, but I recognize many of these bird voices from daily life. We do have the Mourning Dove, and the White-winged Dove, both of which are throughout the West, including in the great Ponderosa Pine forests. Sound carries in the desert in a mighty way; it's astounding, and in canyons and basins/bowls between hills, there are echos. The Gila Woodpecker pecks holes in Saguaros, and the sound can be heard. Assuming the poster did use a sound-overlay, what would be the possibility that the recording came from a Ukrainian forest? There are many forests here in the U.S. from which recordings could have been made, or Canada. As to the audio-video I linked of Sonoran Desert bird-songs, the recording engineer overlaid one morning's recordings upon another morning's recordings, and from another spot in the desert a few miles away. There is not a "sequence" that is heard in the desert: the birds vocalize as they are motivated, and besides the Saguaro, there are trees that the woodpecker pecks. I understand being a purist and appreciating native sounds of the desert. Thank you for sharing your input.
@@СергейГраф-й4е
This may interest you. I just read that what we call Mourning Doves (very common birds here), are also called Turtle Doves. I also saw a video of the bird called the Northern Cardinal living in Hawaii. The Pacific is a huge ocean, far, far away from Arizona, where one of our most common birds is the Northern Cardinal. And yet, it is also resident to Hawaii. Birds are known for far-flung migrations, flying from Alaska to Mexico every year, even the tiny Hummingbirds, and back again! Not only the great whales, but butterflies too! We shouldn't assume that all birds are specific to a certain region; their species might just be resident to several places.
Krieger
There has been some discussion about the audio. If you do overlay audio recordings on your desert videos, keep in mind that bird-songs and sound effects do differ from a forest sound, and that our desert birds should be heard. Here is a local recording that is excellent: ruclips.net/video/bHAop_HlO-I/видео.html
Thank you for the feedback. I liked that recording you've recommended. In the Sonoran desert around Tucson the main bird sounds are the dove, cactus wren, raven, red tail hawk, flicker, woodpecker rattle and the lovely cardinals. I've found some of those online except the cactus wren, flicker and cardinal. Most of the bird sounds in this video are what is present here. But there is one that doesn't belong although it's close enough.
@@bluedawn45
There is a woodpecker with an obvious forest-echo, that viewers have noticed. That's unfortunate, it's a give-away. A Ukrainian viewer in the comments and I had a discussion you can read here, where they say they heard birds in this video that are common to their forested area, naming them. Most of the birds in this video sound alright, but the woodpecker-echo (although we certainly do have the Gila Woodpecker) surely doesn't fit because of that echo. How wonderful it would be if you were to make a Springtime video from your archival footage that was filmed a little earlier, as in April, where the brittle bush and Palo Verdes are blooming more reliably and profusely than in this video, and where the audio is completely local. My 2 Arizona playlists (the large one being an organized video tour of much of the State > take a look) are getting a lot of views (they include a number of your videos), and it's appropriate and fitting to only use local audio, to honor the viewers' trust. I hope you consider making one like that; you make worthwhile videos and I appreciate and enjoy your videos. I've just subscribed to your channel; thank you for sharing your videos.
@@cacatr4495 Yes a spring blooming video with correct sound effects is on my to-do list. It's unfortunate that I have a Ukrainian woodpecker sound effect in there....I'll try harder next time. Thanks for your good input.
Оооойййй😲👍😳🌍интересноооо🏞