FAT GENES vs PLANT BASED DIET w/ Dr. Giles Yeo & Dr. T. Colin Campbell
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 сен 2024
- Please support the campaign: wholistnutritio...
Featuring an exclusive commentary by Dr. T Colin Campbell
This video sees an interesting debate between BBC's plant-based critic Dr Giles Yeo who presented the documentary Clean Eating - The Dirty Truth & China Study author Dr. T. Colin Campbell from: nutritionstudie...
Produced & Edited by: Klaus Mitchell
Interview Videography: Robbie Lockie
Thank you so much Gordon Mackenzie. | Thank you Juan Lube for filming Dr. Campbell
---
★ SUPPORT OUR WORK BY MAKING A DONATION: www.plantbased...
★ HELP TRANSLATE OUR VIDEOS: bit.ly/translat...
★ SIGN UP TO RECEIVE OUR WEEKLY HEADLINES IN YOUR INBOX: www.plantbasedn...
★ GOT A NEWS STORY WE SHOULD KNOW ABOUT? Please email press@plantbasednews.org or leave a message on our hotline UK landline: +44 207 0960 175, US landline: +1 818 963 5411
★ CHECK OUT OUR WEBSITE: www.plantbasedn...
SOCIAL MEDIA
★ TWITTER: / plantbasednews
★ FACEBOOK: / plantbasednews
★ RUclips: / plantbasednews
★ INSTAGRAM: / plantbasednews
LEARN ABOUT VEGANISM
★ Cowspiracy ➞ • COWSPIRACY - Official ...
★ NutritionFacts.Org ➞ goo.gl/BdNbiU
★ Veganuary ➞ www.veganuary.com/
Please support the campaign: wholistnutrition.com/bbc-campaign
PLANT BASED NEWS petition signed...the public need to be given a fair chance to hear all sides. Blatant deceit is just shocking
PLANT BASED NEWS typical bbc.... BBC thinks it’s special, with their old draconian tv licence bullshit. BBC isn’t anything worthy of a draconian tax.
Please check the petition link - it redirects to another website selling supplements.
13:54 easy statement to refuse, he says the reason heart disease has been reversed with a plant based diet is because the patients lost weight, if that’s true then why hasn’t any other diet that can achieve weight loss reverse heart disease.
I thought the tragic case of Jim Fixx (google him if you're a youngster) had put a permanent end to that idea.
@@michaels4255should have
money is corrupting science
It's hard to get a man to understand something when his salary depends on him not understanding
well said.
eric jones
I remember that quote from somewhere. Good quote
@@mildreddavis1684 Upton Sinclair said that quote in the documentary "The Inconvenient Truth".. "It is hard to get a man to understand something when his salary depends upon him not understanding it " (not exact words)
Deep and true
Dr. Yeo lost all credibility when he said he was a dedicated carnivore. Thanks for calling out his defamatory claims.
Alexander Jeans Exactly, carcass crunchers carry no credibility.
"As long as men massacre animals, they will kill each other " ~ Leonardo Da Vinci
The Cambridge Declaration of Consciousness
[ fcmconference.org/img/CambridgeDeclarationOnConsciousness.pdf ]
Klaus that must've been a difficult interview for you, but you did it so much justice, hats off to you mate, well done ✌️
Yeo doesn't look healthy.
Ajit Varsani better call the doctor!
James 1984 he needs a plant based doctor. Will help him to lose excess weight clear his arteries and improve his complexion.
+James....haha! ;)
He's ugly!
@@likesarah7119 Ugly inside and out.
Dr. Campbell is so awesome. He cares so much and it shows.
Incredible Klaus! So glad he got a taste of his own medicine!
Why is it so hard for people to understand the difference between veganism and WFPB? Being one does not imply the other.
People just haven't been taught. Most people know at most only that vegans do not eat animal flesh, eggs, or milk (other than human mother's milk in infancy), so they assume that to be the definition of veganism and have no way of knowing that it is the result of veganism. The word veganism was coined and officially defined by the original Vegan Society as "the doctrine that man should live without exploiting animals." The other problem is that there is no simple, memorable, one word term for "whole foods plant-based diet," so it is easy to slip into using the term vegan has as "shorthand" even though it is not accurate.
Personally, I prefer the term "practicing herbivore."
Maybe WFPBers should start calling themselves "Edenites" in commemoration of Genesis 1:29
And God said, Behold, I have given you every herb bearing seed, which is upon the face of all the earth, and every tree, in the which is the fruit of a tree yielding seed; to you it shall be for meat.
Or: Then God said, “I give you every seed-bearing plant on the face of the whole earth and every tree that has fruit with seed in it. They will be yours for food.
www.biblegateway.com/verse/en/Genesis%201:29
Long live Colin Campbell, our plant-based Obi Wan!
I would say he's more like Yoda: 'Whole Food Plant Based, you must eat'
This was the best RUclips video I have watched - in my life. An absolute thrill to watch and I will probably watch it Again and again… Excellent work!
I'm from the Caribbean...and I just finished the book the China study , it was eye opening. 💚💚💚💚💚💚💚. I have no regrets...and it dose not matter what lies these people come up with ...WFPBD...is the way to go...
This was so politely savage.
Peter Rabitt agreed!
hobbitkicker
The best kind of savagery - words with science-based facts mixed with conviction
I am so impressed with the whole food/plant based diet movement out of the United Kingdom. Keep up the important work. As a nurse practitioner I see these medical problems from the foods people eat. Like Dr. Claper says in What The Health: "It's the food!"
I am glad that T. Colin Campbell had a chance to show how biased Dr. Yeo's opinions are. The whole foods plant based diet will always have to defend the the facts, and the truth until the animal foods industry dies from it own inefficiencies, cruelty, contribution to climate change, deforestation, pollution, and the huge amount of disease that it causes.
If flesh eating dies out, I think it will be a very slow process. First, the livestock industry is probably the most profitable branch of agriculture, so the supply side will not easily go away, and its profits will always give it political leverage. Second, humans are status-obsessed creatures. Third, because it consumes more resources, animal flesh will always be more costly than plants, and the greater inherent cost of animal foods make them high status foods by default. Paradoxically, some of the worst externalities of flesh-eating make it more likely, not less, to be perpetuated. Fourth, Plato and Aristotle already understood 23 centuries ago that plants were healthier and less resource intensive than animal foods, yet dead animal consumption has not died out. Even earlier, Pythagoras was the first "ethical" vegan, and vegetarians/vegans were known as Pythagoreans for many centuries, yet his example did not spread. The Bible presents plants as man's original diet, and pre-Enlightenment Christians held that animal flesh consumption excited man's carnal passions, and any animal with a spine was abstained from during Lent and similar periods, yet consistent abstinence from animal flesh remained rare even among very pious believers. So spread the word, but do not wait breathless with anticipation.
"any animal with a spine", more accurately, mammals, poultry, and any sea creature with a spine, however reptiles and amphibians could be consumed even during Lent, probably because these types of animals were likely to be consumed by the poor. Shellfish was also not considered a luxury food when these rules were adopted.
Thanks doctor Campbell for telling the truth and saving lives.
Absolutely smashed it mate, spot on to you!
That was brilliant! Sent him running.
You know, this nimrod sounds like my husband. I have lost over 150lbs so far and reversed pre-diabetes as well as getting rid of my cholesterol meds and reflux meds along with reducing my fibromyalgia medication from 8 pills per day down to 2. I attribute all of this to my plant-based lifestyle, whereas my husband says, like this yo-ho doctor that Klaus was interviewing, that my improving health came from the weight loss and not from my lifestyle. I thoroughly enjoyed watching you put this guy in his place Klaus!!! Well done!!
They always say that! I lost weight from a non plant based diet and still had health issues. It didn't get me off my pain meds, my BP meds, I still had high cholesterol which my Drs said they should get better. Then I slowly gained the weight back plus some. I watch McDougall and though we'll, it can't hurt! I lost 75lbs the first yr and within months I was off BP meds, pain meds, and 6 months later I was off cholesterol meds! My other health issues started to reverse! No other diet ever did this!!!! I lost a total of 100lbs and am finally at a healthy weight and feel great!
TwoSnakes OneSword That is REMARKABLE! Congratulations! 🎉 🎉 🎉 👏 👏 👏 👏
What a wonderful story. Thank you for sharing and well done Annette
Annette Fowler
You are remarkable!!! What a positive inspiration you are!!! We are all very proud of you! 🌹
mildred davis Awwwww, thank you so much! 💚💚💚
Yeo is a nobody in comparison to Campbell and Essy. They have nothing to lose form being honest - Yeo has a big pharma (and BBC) paycheck to gain from being dishonest
Yes. To argue with a character like Yeo is a total waste of time for a serious scientist like Dr. Campbell. Yeo's ignorance and dishonesty do not deserve a response.
@@realalsenor 🤣 serious scientist?
Beyond impressed with how you interviewed him. Love how you got him at the end. Well done!
So I was a new Vegan when this came out in the early part of last year. I had only spent 3 months studying (all sides) the WFPB diet. I am a lay person and I saw through Yeo immediately and sent off my first and only complaint to the BBC. This is easy, it's something all Vegans and supporters of a WFPB diet have a duty to do. It costs nothing, only 20 mins of your time but the stronger our voice the more positive impact for our planet, the animals and human health. Thank you Klaus for conducting (as usual) such a professional interview - it could not have been easy...
Wowsers mate, you’ve smoked that clown! Well handled, why isn’t there more guys like you on tv, you should have your own tv show on BBC, top journalism!👍
Brilliant work Klaus, really proud of how well you handled the interview.
Dr Campbell is a brilliant charming man..... the other other..... is a narrow arrogant ignorant well paid Pharma advocate... Mom told me two things, never argue with an ignorant person, never give your time to a crook....signing off, this is too hard to watch
Nice one! Keep turning up the heat!
Klaus is a fucking legend!!!.....excellent work 👍👍👍🌶🌶🌶
Some of your best work yet!
Klaus you're a king reporter!! :'-D .."mine's based on data & yours is based on an unchangeable meat eaters perspective"--that's how you do a mic drop young'ns!
Great job, Klaus! And my favorite part was 19:46 when you called him out....
Me tooooo so gd
I keep seeing that time stamp in comments as a great part and the desire to skip to there is HUGE 😊 I'm gonna watch it through though but I was always the person who skips to the back of the book to see how it works out ☺
Nice one Klaus- quality piece of film, well constructed, and extremely succinct. Ace
Great takedown from Klaus, well done. Oh, and TCC is an absolute legend.
hell ya! I loved that mic drop moment at the end!
Klaus you are my hero!
BALLZZZZZZZ OF STEEEEEEEEELLLLL! Klaus that was impressive...
7:21 - 7:40 savage! Love your attitude, and firmness.
Well bloody done. Big ups
The battle rages on, and we all have a duty to our fellow citizens to tell our stories of success in healing ourselves with food rather than masking our illnesses with bottle of pills, be it prescription or supplemental. A whole food plant based diet has changed my life almost immeasurably for the better, and as a result I live a life free of alcohol, drugs and disease. Thank you Dr. Campbell for fighting the powers that be and shooting turkeys like this one down.
You never disappoint Klaus. Aways great work from you.
I’ve never seen an interviewer fact check someone DURING an interview. Classic! It’s clear that he regretted granting the interview five minutes in. Well done, and stay after these guys!
Right?! I was so impressed how much work he put into his interview. Obviously came prepared as hell! Wish more interviewers did that....
Excellent questioning Klaus. I thought you were brilliant.
Great work, Klaus. I just have to say, though, that just because one calls themselves "vegan" doesn't mean they can't be just as concerned with health as someone who calls themselves "plant-based". I consider myself a (mainly) whole foods plant-based vegan. I started this journey for *both* health and ethics. One is no more important to me than the other. I love animals, and that is the motivator that allows me to "stay the course" and remain vegan. But I also am determined not to become a statistic (another cog in the BigPharma /BigMedicine wheel), so I eat as "clean" as I can (save for some minimally processed stuff). "Progress not perfection" is better for me on the way toward eventually becoming a 100% plant-based vegan (I hope!) And as I've said before, I love your accent. Don't ever lose it. 😊 xx
In my top 5 videos of all time.
Klaus, your patience and composition is an impenetrable barrier against deception. I admire how you managed not to lose your cool.
RE: Unchangeable Carnist bias:
“We often assume that only vegans and vegetarians bring their beliefs to the dinner table. But the only reason many of us eat cows but not dogs-for example, is because we do have a belief system when it comes to eating animals. When eating animals is not a necessity-which is the case for many people in the world today-then it is a choice. And choices always stem from beliefs. So what my research uncovered is that there is an invisible belief system that conditions us to eat certain animals. And I named that system carnism.” - Melanie Joy, The Secret Reason We Eat Meat
“There is a tendency-overall-to grossly underestimate the human potential for self-deception, even among critical thinkers and sceptics. We all want to view ourselves as rational beings, but that is just the greatest self-deception of all. If you think [that] you are not biased, and that you cannot rationalize a completely erroneous belief, then that is just the greatest bias of all, that’s the master bias-the one that can undo all of your critical thinking skills.” - Steven Novella, Your Deceptive Mind - Lecture 24: Critical Thinking and Science in Your Life (06:10)
=====
I support this campaign and have shared it on Facebook. Well done for confronting these deceitful people and not letting them get away with pulling the wool over the public's eyes.
This episode is fantastic. Thank you for your work on behalf of people that need to know the truth.
Meat vs disease
That ending of the interview was absolutely hilarious! :D
I also love the mental clarity of Colin Campbell. He emits an aura of wisdom and not dementia like many of his non-vegan peers... That is when they even survive that long.
Dr Yeo calls them ,"Diet related diseases" himself on this video.
👏🏼 brilliantly done ;)
Nice job!
I am so happy to see ethically responsible medical professionals challenge their opposition and clarify the facts. We need this so badly! I do wish I could understand more why the opposition exists...
"why the opposition exists?" MAMMON. WFPB diets are good for health, but bad for profits. No more complicated than that.
Neoteric Phoenix
For profit$
Klaus, this was a completely brilliant piece of work you did here.
In particular, it needs to be highlighted that you clearly managed to get him comfortable and confident speaking fluent BS for what in this edited clip is nearly a full first ten minutes, but right when you drop the "pharmaceuticals" question on him from about 9:29, he suddenly, for the first time, breaks his constant eye contact, looks up, swallows, looks up again to the right, then responds by hardly meeting your eyes for the next couple of minutes, and during that time offers several false starts to his sentences, verging on a sudden development of stammering, and all that on top of sudden inclusion of an "ahh" and an "umm."
And is that a blush, or a flush, his suddenly extra red face is sporting..?!
Gosh, what interesting body language.
Julian Warmington yes it was spot on...
Dr Campbell has so much clarity and conviction when expressing his views. Dr Yeo is extremely unimpressionable...
This is some next level investigative journalism. Wow! Amazing you got this interview on the fly. Great work.
thank you!!
"He discusses nutrition as would a student in elementary school." Pure savagery!
This is awesome! You are so cool, calm & collected. Wonderful to watch 🙌🙌🙌
Great work Klaus! Really great film.
Drs. Michael Klaper, Neal Bernard, Michael Greger, and others mentioned and featured in this video are a wealth of nutritional and health knowledge.
Great interview Klaus! Excellent questioning and a masterclass at exposing the truth!
Michael Billups
Agree. Give them the rope..and wait
lol 19:45 Thug life!
This doctor Yeo shows very suspicious composure, verbal and non-verbal communication. I think he doesn't even believe himself and his funded B.S. Shame on BBC and kudos for Klaus.
Just watched to the end of the video about the actions of the BBC Could we not make a complaint to Ofcom and ask Caroline Lucas MP to pursue the matter? One way to ramp up the pressure on these matters 😉🌶🌶
Wow! Klaus I'm so glad you stuck up for Dr Campbell and wiped the floor with him, Dr Yeo was speechless in the end! Savage. hahaha
Keep exposing the truth !!! Love Campbell’s books
I watched the BBC documentary when it came out. I was misled and now know better. Very disappointed in the BBC.
And you don’t have to be fat to have heart disease! Skinny people have it as well! Yeo’ve no idea mate.
"Yeo've" no idea! LOL!
All about money....such a shame. Well there's always opposing sides in everything. Sheesh....the answers are the closest to nature not whatever the man says. Don't listen to the man lol
It was a terrible documentary. The kind of crap that people ask you if you watched to try and undermine your efforts in moving to a healthier lifestyle. That program does more harm than good. I feel sorry for many involved who were somewhat tricked into taking part unaware of the bias agenda. 🤬
Well done on that interview!!!
Some of his best friends are vegan! ha
Paul J Kimberlee
I am going to find more vegan friends 👍☺
GREAT work, Klaus and Dr. C!
Great interview
Instead of shaking his hand at the end you should have just stood up and dropped the mic, bang! Well done mate
Fantastic interview, Klaus. Love how you took that meat puppet Yeo down a few pegs with his own words.
SAW AND RECOMMEND THE MOVIE PLANT BASED NATION😇
You mean Plant Pure Nation(2015)? Yeah. great documentary :-D
Your amazing and this content is very much appreciated thankyou so very much!!!!! Plant based is the answer to the questions some don’t want us to ask 🍌🍒🍏🍉🥔🥦
Go Dr. Campbell!
I can't make any sense of what Dr Yeo is saying. It's babble!
"I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree" is the battle cry of the carnist physician...
Great interview as always, Klaus! So glad this has so many views.
This was so great, you have such a quick mind to catch his words and relate them to the 'facts' that we understand and ask him to answer. Please keep after people like this and keep us informed! I support Dr. Campbell and Dr. Esselstyn, their findings are so clear and exciting, keeps me focused on why plant based eating is so important!
GO ON THE KLAUS MEISTER
EM
More like Klaus the Master (interviewer)
I was grinning all the way through this.you’re joining the ranks of the rockstars in this movement!
What a great job you did there man! Glad to have soldiers like you on the frontline
Well done Klaus I'm so impressed with how you tackled this arrogant man. It's just what Colin Campbell deserved after being befriended then misrepresented by him. You made complete sense, and he made none!
Good job ❤❤❤❤🖒🖒🖒🖒
KLAUS!!!!! Man that was a brilliant interview!!! Yeo got served... hard!!! Good on ya mate!!! 🙌🏻
Well done. Great video.
Klaus is a badass!!
Keep doing what your doing. May God continue to bless you as you share the health message
To argue with a character like Yeo is a total waste of time for a serious scientist like Dr. Campbell. Yeo's ignorance and dishonesty does not deserve a response.
Excellent video...Disturbing to see Yeo's outright denial to suit his own agenda, but appreciate your detail catching presentation.
Shut him down. Well done.
Wow gamechanger!
I thinks it's good to challenge this kind of thing, especially if someone has been misrepresented. Though I don't like the trend of overly focusing on an rival researcher, dr or person's potential bias. I think it's best to stick to data and evidence as much as possible and use the principle of charity, attack a rival's best arguments. I don't think this over emphasis on bias is a very persuasive strategy. I think it'll only play well with committed vegans or plant based eaters.
I greatly appreciate Dr. Campbell's distinction that any diet, including veganism, is not inherently healthy. That his critically peer-reviewed published research findings led him to a whole-food plant-based diet.
The genetic aspect is interesting. What does it mean to have X percentage of heritability? That the outcome is fixed and can not change it or that it's a statistical representation of what we see usually turns out to be the case? If it's just the ladder and you can change for example obesity outcomes by diet, information, exercise then I would argue that it's not heritable at all, or that the concept of heritability in this context is misleading and counter-productive.
sajfen
It is as if the latest science of epigenetics is not talked about
Is it even about genetics though if you can circumvent the "genetic" outcomes by just doing the opposite?
Good work Klaus
And bravo to you Klass!
thanks a lot!
I've always been impressed with the work done by PBN and this is some of the best I've seen. Outstanding work!
thank you my friend!
Klaus do you have a link to the updated 2014 Esselstyn study cited, which has a larger sample size? how large was it? why are there so few studies of this nature? Seems to me it ought to be possible to prove whether or not weight loss alone is the cause of reversal of heart disease. i don'tget why science can'tput this question to rest definitively.
+Sunny, who has a financial incentive to fund this research? Not drug makers, not physicians, not the ag industry, they all have incentives *not* to fund it. Politicians get campaign donations and sometimes other perks from these industries, and saving the taxpayers' money has never been a high priority with them, so they have no incentive to fund the research. That leaves the private health insurance and life insurance industries. Maybe someone should bring these discoveries to their attention, or maybe they are owned by some of the same companies that own industries that want nutritional remedies suppressed. Conflicts of interest abound.
michael s Dr. G can fund it from profits from his new cookbook!
Weight loss is clearly not the cause for reversal of heart disease. You can be in "good shape" with artery blockages
Amazing information unfortunately money plays a big role in all this