Button: Joshua Roy Is Montreal’s Best Prospect | The Sick Podcast with Tony Marinaro May 16 2024

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 15 май 2024
  • On this episode of The Sick Podcast, Craig Button joins Tony Marinaro to discuss the idea of starting to trade prospects to improve the team now, which prospects should be considered untouchable, which blossoming NHL star Craig Button compares Joshua Roy to and much more!
  • РазвлеченияРазвлечения

Комментарии • 65

  • @essenegnostic8711
    @essenegnostic8711 25 дней назад +25

    I'd like to thank the Carolina Hurricanes for offer sheeting Jesperi Kotkaniemi.

    • @frenchycanopy1659
      @frenchycanopy1659 25 дней назад +6

      Yeah but also Bergevin wasted those picks on Dvorak that was bad

    • @mandan
      @mandan 21 день назад

      @@frenchycanopy1659 Bergevin low balled offer sheeted for Aho that started it... he offered $8.5M, but should've gone like $9.5M - 10M

  • @DrunkenBanker
    @DrunkenBanker 25 дней назад +10

    Craig Button is quickly becoming my favorite guest. No disrespect to Eric Engels and Grant but from a GM and Talent perspective, Button is as solid as they come

  • @user-bi6cl9rt9o
    @user-bi6cl9rt9o 26 дней назад +10

    I just LOVE listening to Craig. Very informative. 👍🏻

  • @matrixisreal2023
    @matrixisreal2023 26 дней назад +10

    I told yall during Montreal training camp, when Joshua Roy scored his first goal & he did it effortlessly with a perfect execution . At this moment , I knew he’s will be great.

    • @carycwilliams
      @carycwilliams 23 дня назад +1

      Great is a little extreme

    • @matrixisreal2023
      @matrixisreal2023 23 дня назад

      @@carycwilliams let’s say very good. Why ? Go watch his
      First presence first goal during the preseason game . That’s pure talent .

    • @carycwilliams
      @carycwilliams 22 дня назад

      @@matrixisreal2023 Very good is better, but, this is about opinions. The kid has talent, but he has a long ways to go. 4g and 9pts in 23 games isn't great, or very good yet. Very good would be a 55+ point season. Joshua has the talent, but does he have the same kind of drive to work on improving like Slafkovsky??

  • @jonsmith9518
    @jonsmith9518 26 дней назад +14

    You have an unlistenable theme song Tony. Love the show

    • @acidraindrops1
      @acidraindrops1 25 дней назад +2

      It need to go

    • @moviestoshare813
      @moviestoshare813 25 дней назад

      Well… I love it 🤷‍♂️

    • @novasahota3052
      @novasahota3052 24 дня назад +1

      new intro new layout is highly needed we love you tony

    • @birdythebird
      @birdythebird 23 дня назад

      You have to get a LIFE 🤷🏻‍♀️🤣🤣🤣

  • @humankirk9196
    @humankirk9196 25 дней назад +4

    About franchise vs generational talents, there's one important name missing: Patrick Roy. Also a generational talent, and picked in the 3rd round in the same year as Mario Lemieux.

  • @caseyr5554
    @caseyr5554 24 дня назад +2

    How is lane Hudson not our best prospect??

  • @user-ku8qw8bg8c
    @user-ku8qw8bg8c 26 дней назад +1

    Yeah you keep roy !

  • @marc-etiennemercier6584
    @marc-etiennemercier6584 23 дня назад

    There's a guy in the chat named ''Pierre Cloutier'' who mispelled ''Lapiere'' lmfao. That's something.

  • @user-bi6cl9rt9o
    @user-bi6cl9rt9o 26 дней назад +1

    Fans keep asking for a winger in the draft or in a trade. Well, they already have a top one in Joshua Roy. Mešár and Kapanen are close. 🙄

  • @acidraindrops1
    @acidraindrops1 25 дней назад

    Button is a star

  • @powers1500
    @powers1500 25 дней назад +1

    Mesar was sent back to the OHL to develop his game...He has basically shown in the last 2 years that he a basically a point per game player. Even Beck has better offensive numbers while being a more complete player. To this date...I still wonder what they saw in Mesar to draft him in the first round...ayoye !!!

    • @acidraindrops1
      @acidraindrops1 25 дней назад

      Check last years tournament highlights

    • @powers1500
      @powers1500 25 дней назад

      @@acidraindrops1 Pro scouts usually rely on what players do over the course of a whole season including tournaments. Based on what Mesar showed over the last 2 seasons in junior hockey at 19 and 20 yrs old..It is pretty obvious that he may not have a successful NHL career !!!

  • @CharlesPatrick61
    @CharlesPatrick61 25 дней назад +1

    Outside of Bob Cole that opening with Tony screaming is horrific.

    • @alexrock9898
      @alexrock9898 25 дней назад

      false. he found the dogs and finding the dogs was extremely important that post season.

  • @johnkondracki1559
    @johnkondracki1559 25 дней назад +1

    SICK

  • @oasisbeyond
    @oasisbeyond 26 дней назад +2

    Gavin is the next one, when you hear about a player at 14... you know he's special like Crosby and McDavid.... Mathews is the American Wayne Gretzky... come on dude. Bedard is no generational. Gavin is the next one.

  • @FrancoisCarbo
    @FrancoisCarbo 24 дня назад

    Tony i would like to hear Button about Farell. 2 years ago he was high in the prospect pool and now you guys dont even consider him in the top prospects. What happened ? Is injury made us forgot about him? I remember the comments Nicholas made after Farell had is first camp with him. He said was soooo Smart on the Ice and that he would be a magical player.

    • @Cacuna
      @Cacuna 23 дня назад

      He had good stats in ncaa but hes not strong enough for nhl

    • @FrancoisCarbo
      @FrancoisCarbo 23 дня назад

      @cacuna i didnt ask you thanks. I watch enough AHL hockey to make my own fan opinion but i wanted an expert on the subject

    • @Cacuna
      @Cacuna 23 дня назад

      Two years ago, habs had no prospects ... Of course they have to talk about someone

  • @robertlegault9226
    @robertlegault9226 25 дней назад

    Man this is going to be a long wait until the draft 😢

  • @Cacuna
    @Cacuna 23 дня назад

    Adam ebgstrom is not small anymore, hes 6 foot 2 195 according to elite prospect

  • @videopyc
    @videopyc 26 дней назад

    Habs needs talent: Roy and Reinbacher are top talent. Beck will be a strong NHL player.

  • @carycwilliams
    @carycwilliams 23 дня назад

    Roy needs to work on his lower body strength and skating explosiveness

  • @carycwilliams
    @carycwilliams 23 дня назад

    Way too early to move Engstrom, he's 6ft2 btw. Mesar won't play for Montreal, he's only an asset for them

  • @marc-etiennemercier6584
    @marc-etiennemercier6584 23 дня назад

    Ovechkin = franchise

  • @moviestoshare813
    @moviestoshare813 25 дней назад +1

    Sick Podcast…
    Adam Engstrom is
    NOT !
    6’0, 168lbs 😅
    He’s 6’2, 190lbs !!!

    • @moviestoshare813
      @moviestoshare813 25 дней назад

      Just realized you took that from
      hockeydb
      so I guess it’s their fault, not yours

  • @carycwilliams
    @carycwilliams 23 дня назад

    Dobes will surprise

  • @emmettebramble10
    @emmettebramble10 25 дней назад

    Engstrom is bigger than that. Figure your shit out

  • @MM-xg2td
    @MM-xg2td 25 дней назад

    Joshua Roy would be a 70-80 points player if he had better work ethics off the ice.

  • @claudelemay3912
    @claudelemay3912 23 дня назад

    *** Trade proposal ***
    Toronto & Montreal
    Toronto:
    Mitch Marner (27y - RW) to Mtl
    Montreal:
    Josh Anderson (30y - RW), Christian Dvorak (28y - C), Justin Barron (22y - RD) to Toronto

  • @idarthcadeus
    @idarthcadeus 24 дня назад

    Folks, let's be honest here. Roy on a cup contending team is a fourth liner and that's it. Tony and Button are way off dreaming he's gonna be a second line player. If Roy is on your second line, you ain't never winning the cup.

    • @Diminisherqc
      @Diminisherqc 24 дня назад +1

      yhea cause idarthcadeus on youtube knows whats up

  • @acidraindrops1
    @acidraindrops1 25 дней назад

    Please change the intro, whoever is in charge of that needs some lessons in music taste. Love the show otherwise

  • @rgood1204
    @rgood1204 25 дней назад +1

    I'm betting on Will Smith to have the superior career.

  • @andretrepanier8170
    @andretrepanier8170 23 дня назад

    Your franchise is in danger if joshua roy is your best prospect lol

  • @habs4life41
    @habs4life41 25 дней назад +2

    Mackinnon isn't a generational player? Lmfao I had to turn off the episode after he said this.. first episode I won't complete in MONTNS

    • @rgood1204
      @rgood1204 25 дней назад +3

      Don't you have to win multiple individual awards and be named 1st or 2nd team all star? Generational is thrown around way too much. He's what 28 or 29? He's no Crosby he's no McDavid. He's no Ovechkin.

    • @powers1500
      @powers1500 25 дней назад +3

      @@rgood1204 Indeed, Mackinnon is a special player but definitively not generational. The year he got drafted, Colorado was not even sure whether to take him or Seth Jones. It did turn out pretty good for them though !!! We can say just about the same about Makar, is he generational or just very good ???

    • @marcbabineau6001
      @marcbabineau6001 25 дней назад +4

      His production says otherwise, took him 10 years to start showing generational stats IMO.

    • @acidraindrops1
      @acidraindrops1 25 дней назад +1

      If you can’t handle different opinions than you, that says a lot about your lack of cognition

    • @andrewmoulton7429
      @andrewmoulton7429 25 дней назад

      ​@@rgood1204your right but I think MacKinnon has an argument, if he played 82 games a season he would have some hardware

  • @djdemers8709
    @djdemers8709 26 дней назад +1

    i think Logan Mailloux is going to be top 4 maybe top 2 Dman just wait......give this kid a few yrs.... cheers from Sudbury Tony!!!!🍻🍻🍻🍻

  • @ClaudeRivest
    @ClaudeRivest 19 дней назад

    Could Craig not buy himself a good mic? Sound is garbage.

  • @mr.nihilz3283
    @mr.nihilz3283 25 дней назад

    You guys need to have Button on less. How many times do we need to hear about Iginla and Morris trades??

  • @Str8FromMtl
    @Str8FromMtl 24 дня назад

    I dont get all the hype on Joshua Roy. He looks slow, and nothing in his fame stands out

  • @edtamboni4752
    @edtamboni4752 25 дней назад

    Button again???? Jeez...