Would be nice to see Gavin play with Steven again tho. Porcupine Tree was amazing before Gavin joined but their music was immediately made even more amazing because of him
@@captaindeadeye788 Even though I like PT, it doesn't beat this. I think there's a reason Raven That Refused to Sing and Hand Cannot Erase are Steven's best work ever. The band he had was near perfect.
@@securityman6666 Now imagine a band this good...with two drummers like him. Good news, that band exists. They're called King Gizzard & The Lizard Wizard.
+thiagotecnico lol.. bro.. you need to expand your musical pallet. Bass is crucial on almost any song.. why do you think a bass is included in just about every genre of music, but not other instruments. ;-)
+thiagotecnico lol.. bro.. you need to expand your musical pallet. Bass is crucial on almost any song.. why do you think a bass is included in just about every genre of music, but not other instruments. ;-)
Robert Stofa Because as a bassist I normally feel like not important for those non-musician people. "the guy with the other guitar" you know what i mean...
+Robert Stofa some time ago I saw a video where they cut the bass off the mix of a song extract and then put it back so you could see the difference it makes, that was astonishing to hear what bands sound like without bass guitar
I think that 10 years from now most people will realize that this was a great era in Progressive Music, led by Steven Wilson. His music incorporates much older, classic stuff from 70s/80s, and at the same time it feels as if his music is way ahead of time. Brilliant musician.
@@psychodelian Oh I think this kind of music will last... But not just Porcupine Tree, the entire Prog genre is a huuuge hidden gem, and one day the world will realise it. Probably not in ten years though, more likely in a 100. Untill than, we, as unknown fans from unknown bands, will continue to preach our children, friends and family the true gospel of Prog, so that it is able to exist for eternity, going from generation to generation(May Pink Floyd be our inspiration). Existing bands like Dream Theater, The Pineapple Thief, Riverside, SW's solo-albums which are almost as good as Porcupine Tree... They will be acknowledged for their true greatness one day, since their music is more than just a message or just a tune, it's a true art, it's pure heart but at the same time extremely technically skillfull and hard to recreate, it's everything combined in all. The flock is just blind yet. One day they will see.
Nick Beggs on bass is brilliant! The man is a superstar that rocks Fretless and plays the Chapman Stick! No wonder he has been playing with Wilson for years! His background vocals, playing and overall stage presence adds to every show or album Steven does! Love Nick with Steven!
+Al Schuppe Oh, I thought that was Pipi Longstockings on bass. (You'd think that someone like me, who came of age in the 60's would refrain from making jokes about a musician's hair... but, if you thought that, you'd be wrong.)He is good, though.
+Protagonist That is so great! Those guys are so talented and yet I bet they're humble and great to chat with, from what you say. It's a small world - I'm in the US but I now listen to Steven Wilson and his band's music more often than most other bands. I was 'introduced' to their music by someone here chatting on RUclips. Really amazing. Take care my friend.
I have had the privilege of seeing Porcupine Tree in Melbourne Australia twice, and both times I was totally impressed with how down to earth Steven Wilson was. The fact they brought the whole touring band, (inc John Wesley) with all their own gear, to a reasonably small show, demonstrates the attitude toward the music and the fans. I would say that Steven Wilson is not only a rare talent, but genuinely respects his audience.
steve wilson is undoubtably one of if not the greatest rock composers ever way more complex and melodious gifted composers of all time his complexity and and self taught musicianship is mind boggling hes truly will be remembered as as. one of the greatest ever what a genious he truly is
@@chrissmith3668 Nno. I went off subject of Wilson to a drummer kinda like Gavin but more rock jazz. Marc played on Shockwave Supernova by satriani as well as the crats.
The whole song is a masterpiece... I cant believe its been two years since it came out... Ugh but that part from 8:38 to 10:03... It just gives me goosebumps... Its my fave part of Luminol Steven Wilson is just a musical genius. Period.
@@pinkraven4402 Hell yeah those have some of the best moments in music, ever! I gotta add the last guitar solo from Dream Theaters Octavarium to that list though!
Here we all are born into a struggle To come so far but end up returning to dust Oxfam panache and tips his hat (laces undone) He has no truck with idle chat (work to be done) The songs he learned from scratched LPs Stops in mid-flow to sip his tea He strums the chords with less than grace (songs we all know) Each passing year etched on his face (sun, rain or snow) The words he sings are not his own They speak of things he'll never know
Posłuchałem ich ostatniej płyty - naprawdę kapitalne granie i bardzo dużo melotronu. Dzięki wielkie za polecenie, bo jestem pewny, że polubię się z zespołem Anekdoten.
Nobody seemed to have mention the drummer Marco Minnemann. Hi is precise, crisp he is amazing. Played in numbers of incredible groups... He is doing here what he always does, plays great music ... (o:
Steven Wilson is for me one of the most interesting musicians of the modern music scene, his broad musical culture allows him to compose music with many facets ... Moreover he is a guitarist of high flight, a singer of great talent, in the current lack of creativity, Steven reconnects with his predecessors of the 1970s ... filled with creativity. I send him all my friendships and admiration! (a professional drummer-composer and French drummer who played with great musicians (Etienne M'Bappé, Guy N'Sangué, Rhoda Scott, David Jacob and many other artists)
Me and my friend has on several occasions laughed merrily at the goofyness in beggining of Adam's solo at 2:52 - found it incredibly funny in a good way.
Can't. Get. Enough. So much talent. Priveleged and truly honored to have discovered PT primarily and then love his solo work just as much. Steven never ceases to amaze me!
I love watching this live. Everyone of those musicians are world class and steven wilson is like an 8 year old kid playing in his room directing the music with his actions. A real maestro. Its beautiful to watch.
There’s just something magical about seeing Steven play… You just feel the beats of everything he and his team plays like you’re playing it with them. It’s a full body experience.
The first thing that occurred to me in the first minute & a half of this was that Steven has been listening to Ozric Tentacles! Such a brilliant, incredible musician...and that band of his is out of this WORLD.
NEW Progressive Rock at its' best... A little melancholy at times, but Steven Wilson is like that.. A Miles Davis Keyboardist, Marco Minneman on Drums, a Modern Virtuoso... The Guitarist was later replaced in a bold but brilliant move, by the GREAT Guthrie Govan. Look him up...
Aaron Kennedy The guitarist niko tsonev is a class in itself, he's no virtuoso like Guthrie but got some tasty tricks up his sleeve and is very soulful in his playing.
I'm 61 and prog rocker from an era of ELP, Yes, King Crimson, Todd Rundgren's Utopia, Gentle Giant, Tull and on and on. These type groups set the stage for great musicians like Steve Wilson. Fortunately, technology has caught up with some of the groups I mentioned, so they can still play their classics on par with groups like Wilson's, who have been able to play with newer tech since they started. Add it all up and prog never faded, it's the non prog audiences who now get it.
This is so great!!!!!!!! It reminds me of times when band were not afraid to do out of the normal realm!! It's all about music, the universal language!!! reminds me of classical with movements to play on emotions,
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
Marco is such an energetic drummer man.
Would be nice to see Gavin play with Steven again tho. Porcupine Tree was amazing before Gavin joined but their music was immediately made even more amazing because of him
@@captaindeadeye788 Even though I like PT, it doesn't beat this. I think there's a reason Raven That Refused to Sing and Hand Cannot Erase are Steven's best work ever. The band he had was near perfect.
This drummer is amazing. And I have the highest respect for Gavin.
@@securityman6666 Now imagine a band this good...with two drummers like him. Good news, that band exists. They're called King Gizzard & The Lizard Wizard.
i agree . he is the best
Can we all apreciate how great is the sound mastering???
FlipperWolf incredible
Yes mate definitely.
Great sound. I agree.
It´s incredibly good indeed
Agree, wonderful sound.
i love how a bassist is important on this song.
+thiagotecnico lol.. bro.. you need to expand your musical pallet. Bass is crucial on almost any song.. why do you think a bass is included in just about every genre of music, but not other instruments. ;-)
+thiagotecnico lol.. bro.. you need to expand your musical pallet. Bass is crucial on almost any song.. why do you think a bass is included in just about every genre of music, but not other instruments. ;-)
Robert Stofa
Because as a bassist I normally feel like not important for those non-musician people. "the guy with the other guitar" you know what i mean...
+thiagotecnico word.. I do know exactly what you mean. they just don't know how important we really are to a song.
+Robert Stofa some time ago I saw a video where they cut the bass off the mix of a song extract and then put it back so you could see the difference it makes, that was astonishing to hear what bands sound like without bass guitar
I think that 10 years from now most people will realize that this was a great era in Progressive Music, led by Steven Wilson. His music incorporates much older, classic stuff from 70s/80s, and at the same time it feels as if his music is way ahead of time. Brilliant musician.
unfortunately it was not to last
@@psychodelian Oh I think this kind of music will last... But not just Porcupine Tree, the entire Prog genre is a huuuge hidden gem, and one day the world will realise it. Probably not in ten years though, more likely in a 100. Untill than, we, as unknown fans from unknown bands, will continue to preach our children, friends and family the true gospel of Prog, so that it is able to exist for eternity, going from generation to generation(May Pink Floyd be our inspiration). Existing bands like Dream Theater, The Pineapple Thief, Riverside, SW's solo-albums which are almost as good as Porcupine Tree... They will be acknowledged for their true greatness one day, since their music is more than just a message or just a tune, it's a true art, it's pure heart but at the same time extremely technically skillfull and hard to recreate, it's everything combined in all. The flock is just blind yet. One day they will see.
It may take some time but people will eventually appreciate the amazing art that is prog rock.
Four years later, if you're still that much into these guys, you're gonna love King Gizzard & The Lizard Wizard...especially live.
Even Steven Wilson got tired of this haha
Here we all are, born in to a struggle, to come so far, but end up returning to dust!
Mad respect for Nick Beggs. My wife gave me the DVD as a b-day present this morning. I watched in awe of Steven and his entourage of musicians.
W wife
Will always be one of my favorites! To see it live will always be in my top 10 musical moments. I'm watching again for the 20th time! it is AMAZING!
Nick Beggs on bass is brilliant! The man is a superstar that rocks Fretless and plays the Chapman Stick! No wonder he has been playing with Wilson for years! His background vocals, playing and overall stage presence adds to every show or album Steven does! Love Nick with Steven!
Love the old school ford vans in this movie, gotta love ole Skool vans!
he plays bass with Steve Hackett too. Awesome
Chapman stick? Ha ha 🍌
@@poulmortensen4753
...???...
Nick Beggs on bass - wow, he's good!
+Al Schuppe Oh, I thought that was Pipi Longstockings on bass. (You'd think that someone like me, who came of age in the 60's would refrain from making jokes about a musician's hair... but, if you thought that, you'd be wrong.)He is good, though.
+Protagonist That is so great! Those guys are so talented and yet I bet they're humble and great to chat with, from what you say. It's a small world - I'm in the US but I now listen to Steven Wilson and his band's music more often than most other bands. I was 'introduced' to their music by someone here chatting on RUclips. Really amazing. Take care my friend.
Apart from that, I love the harmonisation he provides by singing in higher pitch. Makes the vocals so beautiful.
Yes, I agree. He has a great voice too.
YES and super nice guy, too!!
this show was filmed before the raven came out; imagine the reactions of the audience when they all heard that for the first time
I was at one of these shows. For months, I tried to remember the guitar harmony because I had loved it, and couldnt. This was really hard :D
This has a strong King Crimson "feel" to it.
and YES :)
youtube put this in my playlist, without looking at it, i thought it was King Crimson.
And Jethro Tull
totally !
@@philipmazonson4694 And Floyd !
I have had the privilege of seeing Porcupine Tree in Melbourne Australia twice, and both times I was totally impressed with how down to earth Steven Wilson was. The fact they brought the whole touring band, (inc John Wesley) with all their own gear, to a reasonably small show, demonstrates the attitude toward the music and the fans. I would say that Steven Wilson is not only a rare talent, but genuinely respects his audience.
I feel like Steven Wilson will usher in another golden age of progressive music.
It'd be awesome but selling 100K albums won't make it. Still for very selected group of people.
yeah well we listen to it.
he's actually pretty popular . even in my country ( Iran ) he has some fans here and a big number of them play instruments and play music .
Well, the last two albums have each earned a gold certificate, which is 500k. So not too shabby.
The Ayatollah allows your friends to play publicly?
steve wilson is undoubtably one of if not the greatest rock composers ever way more complex and melodious gifted composers of all time his complexity and and self taught musicianship is mind boggling hes truly will be remembered as as. one of the greatest ever what a genious he truly is
Listen to selling England by the Pound by Genesis
@@brucegelman5582 ...and?
Travis Leahy Facts as such...tell me that I should have become a musician rather than a philosopher.
Sassari Scot comparison is so foolish
No hes quite average and dull.
I hear, King Crimson.Rush,Yes,Steve Hackett (Genesis) and Pink Floyd all within this tune!....Well put together!!!!
Randy Ewing Don’t forget the Generator
@@MarcusL1995 The only people that forget VDGG never heard of them in the first place
Randy Ewing Amazing music, isn’t it?
A bit of camel/caravan too.
Little bit of Drama
Only Steven could make a live album that sounds this good.
Si è incredibile
The flute solo always gives me chills.
Gavin Harrison on guitar
Marco Minniman, drums. Aristocrats is where he really shines. "Blues Fuck Up". Check it out.
I think he’s saying the guy on stage right looks like Gavin
@@chrissmith3668 Nno. I went off subject of Wilson to a drummer kinda like Gavin but more rock jazz. Marc played on Shockwave Supernova by satriani as well as the crats.
Uhhhhhhh what?
he looks like him, his name is Niko Tsonev
The whole song is a masterpiece... I cant believe its been two years since it came out...
Ugh but that part from 8:38 to 10:03... It just gives me goosebumps... Its my fave part of Luminol
Steven Wilson is just a musical genius. Period.
Shiryou EDR agree with you....the blend of mellotron and taurus bass pedals along with the chord progression is just fantastic. Love it.
Eduardo Ramirez +1 to goosebumps during that part!
It's my favourite climax moment in entire music together with ones from Pink Floyd "Echoes", Yes "Close To The Edge" and King Crimson "Starless"
Love this part.
@@pinkraven4402 Hell yeah those have some of the best moments in music, ever! I gotta add the last guitar solo from Dream Theaters Octavarium to that list though!
That moment when Marco starts grooving around 3:23 and whole band looks at him smiling
Emkarcinos made my fucking day😂
SW - wait..we didn't rehearse that bit
8:38 - 10:00 : I didn't know combination of flute and mellotron could sound THAT epic
Absolutely marvelous
you obviously haven´t heard Genesis or King Crimson before!!!
I love Steve Wilson, he makes music I've never heard before - that seems unique nowadays
very similar to genesis and the original progressive rock styles
@@ifitsnotrockandroll I heard a lot of Yes in this one too, specifically around the Drama era
@@Cobalt985 you're right. This is fairly reminiscent of tempus fugit
Here we all are born into a struggle
To come so far but end up returning to dust
Oxfam panache and tips his hat
(laces undone)
He has no truck with idle chat
(work to be done)
The songs he learned from scratched LPs
Stops in mid-flow to sip his tea
He strums the chords with less than grace
(songs we all know)
Each passing year etched on his face
(sun, rain or snow)
The words he sings are not his own
They speak of things he'll never know
The bass part for this song is SO much fun to play!
Chris McCartney my hand hurts xD
Fun? my left hand is about to tear up in two
This song is a masterpiece,luminol in the future will be remember like one of the many bests... I've no doubt
Steven Wilson brought mellotron back to life.
+Kamil Pietrzyk I'd say it was not him but Anekdoten. ;p
Widzę, żeś rodak, więc po polsku będzie - dzięki za polecenie, nie znałem tego zespołu, chętnie się zapoznam. Pozdrowienia!
Posłuchałem ich ostatniej płyty - naprawdę kapitalne granie i bardzo dużo melotronu. Dzięki wielkie za polecenie, bo jestem pewny, że polubię się z zespołem Anekdoten.
+Czyszy Can you name a song of theirs?
*****
Groundbound for example
Nobody seemed to have mention the drummer Marco Minnemann. Hi is precise, crisp he is amazing. Played in numbers of incredible groups... He is doing here what he always does, plays great music ... (o:
Nick Beggs is a handy man to have round... Awesome bass n' stick player, and backing vocals blend in pretty well with Steven!
He can give your living room a good lick of paint, too.
His vocals were awesome.
I can't believe I'm just hearing about him now but, wow, I'm happy I did.
how can people dislike this piece of art? seriously? :/
Nick Beggs is a BEAST! And that drummer.....I ain't got the words.
this is some of the best music I've heard in ages!
Watching ANYTHING Steven Wilson *LIVE* is like listening to the studio recording
Can't believe it's already been over two years since this song came out
EuriLochus four and a half*
pr0ng Blows my mind, i remember when the notification for this video popped up
And that was 5 years ago !
six years now
lol
A 12 minute spectacle of talent. Wow !
Just now heard any of this guy. Completely blown away. Amazing
Steve knows how to pick drumers.
And kick em out too
@@srikarvenky true, man
Better than the studio version..
Great Progresive beautiful music, awesome, warm hugs from Guatemala in Central America
What an energetic performance.. I love "Luminol", but seeing this video makes it even better. They work so well together.
The smile on Marco's face is the best thing ever.
How can one person compose such great music? and then hire some of the bets musicians of his time to play it for him. man Steven is awesome.
Steven Wilson has got to be one of the most talented musicians I have ever seen.
Minnemann und Beggs! Kreativkopf Wilson machts möglich! Genial
Steven Wilson is the greatest expression of prog rock today.
Thanks for your work, genius.
Nick Beggs, crushes Bass with this song and this band! Nick Beggs is a "Bass GOD!"
This is prog rock!
It sure is.
😅
One of my most respected rock-musicians!
I’ve been an EL&P fanatic for half a century, but theses guys are as close as it gets to greatness in modern prog.
Compositional Rock & Roll at it’s best. Wilson is the holder of the torch !
This is the type of music I’m alive for.
he really understand progressive rock
You can just relate to his interpretation of prog rock... likewise, his work is stunning!
This is not music! This is a slap on the face for all us wannabe musicians out here that really need to practice more!
Its not only about practicing my friend! This is compositional genius that a few people have! So 😏
Man i cant get over how awesome this music is
You should check Snarky Puppy.
Fantastic song. Also great to see that Beggs, Travis, and Wilson are looking at Marco Minnemann (at 03m20s) with a big smile on their faces!
If someone says bass isn’t important, show them this
Possibly the best jazz rock piece of music of all time!
Steven Wilson is for me one of the most interesting musicians of the modern music scene, his broad musical culture allows him to compose music with many facets ... Moreover he is a guitarist of high flight, a singer of great talent, in the current lack of creativity, Steven reconnects with his predecessors of the 1970s ... filled with creativity. I send him all my friendships and admiration! (a professional drummer-composer and French drummer who played with great musicians (Etienne M'Bappé, Guy N'Sangué, Rhoda Scott, David Jacob and many other artists)
This is for class audience. And the day when such songs are appreciated is the day when the world will be liberated
That bass is insane. And the tone! Wow.
A modern-day King Crimson. Simply amazing.
Me and my friend has on several occasions laughed merrily at the goofyness in beggining of Adam's solo at 2:52 - found it incredibly funny in a good way.
Douglas Sandberg sounds dank
You are the best, Nick.
Can't. Get. Enough. So much talent. Priveleged and truly honored to have discovered PT primarily and then love his solo work just as much. Steven never ceases to amaze me!
9:01 give me the chills. I was at the Cleveland show last spring and seeing this live was a religious expereience
I love watching this live. Everyone of those musicians are world class and steven wilson is like an 8 year old kid playing in his room directing the music with his actions. A real maestro. Its beautiful to watch.
There’s just something magical about seeing Steven play…
You just feel the beats of everything he and his team plays like you’re playing it with them.
It’s a full body experience.
What a magnificent ensemble on a magnificent song.
Luminol one of the best songs in the progre, they use a lot of instruments like the root of the progressive.
The middle so awesomely Yes’ South Side of the Sky. Amazing song in all its movements.
THIS. IS. EARGASM! I CAN'T BELIEVE I'VE LISTENED TO THIS KINDA TUNE IN 2013!
Perfect band for the perfect album!
Nick Beggs!!! Awesome playing!!!
El sonido puro como en la versión de estudio, la pasión de STEVE con que ejecuta todos los instrumentos, de otro mundo.
Chido pienso igual
The first thing that occurred to me in the first minute & a half of this was that Steven has been listening to Ozric Tentacles! Such a brilliant, incredible musician...and that band of his is out of this WORLD.
IN THE NAME OF ANYTHING HOLY!
THIS IS MAGIC
Wow, what have i been missing all this time, mind blown + Nick Beggs the legend
NEW Progressive Rock at its' best... A little melancholy at times, but Steven Wilson is like that.. A Miles Davis Keyboardist, Marco Minneman on Drums, a Modern Virtuoso... The Guitarist was later replaced in a bold but brilliant move, by the GREAT Guthrie Govan. Look him up...
Aaron Kennedy
The guitarist niko tsonev is a class in itself, he's no virtuoso like Guthrie but got some tasty tricks up his sleeve and is very soulful in his playing.
I'm 61 and prog rocker from an era of ELP, Yes, King Crimson, Todd Rundgren's Utopia, Gentle Giant, Tull and on and on. These type groups set the stage for great musicians like Steve Wilson. Fortunately, technology has caught up with some of the groups I mentioned, so they can still play their classics on par with groups like Wilson's, who have been able to play with newer tech since they started. Add it all up and prog never faded, it's the non prog audiences who now get it.
How can one "Not be much of a fan of" Genesis and write 8:38. Literally WHAT. lmao.
I was in Paris... alone. Well, not alone : I had those incredible musicians with me ;)
,Wonderful timeless musical masterpiece
To play this jazz improvisation is the sign of great musicianship...very cool indeed
qué canción tan preciosa y qué tremendo bajo, me encanta Luminol, creo que es mi favorita de Steven Wilson. Ojalá lo hubiera conocido antes
This never gets old. Thank you.
I love this version way more than the CD one
Stunning stuff and Beggs is the Clapton of bass
one word...TIGHT
Real music. Refreshing ....and its live!
the chord progression from 9:40 to 10:00 is the best thing i've ever heard
steven and his band are perfect and also the guys he is playing with here.. they are fucking amazing!!
Guitar, yep. Drums, yep. Bass, yep, Keys, yep. The actual use of real flute and sax is just icing on this cake! Really well done!
did anyone else have an eargasm
I was there and I remember they asked us to be in silence at the beginning of the recording
That Mellotron part.... Gosh! There are some great 'new' artists doing great sh*t, man... Steven's stuff sounds better than ever.
musicianship at its finest
How can you manage to get the best musicans to play for you? Write the best songs and they will follow...
Taunt Progressiv and Guthrie wasn't even there at that time
That guitarist is garbage! Too bad Guthrie wasn't there. This guy fucked up the entire guitar solo. Sounded like amateur hour
Good musicians love to work with creative people like Steven Wilson or Robert Fripp.
Actually he couldn't, that's why he left PT
Masterpiece over all masterpieces!
Steven dando cátedra de talento musical 😎🤟🏽
10:47
That root piano variaton into the original rhythm at the beginning of the song... Chills every time, so well composed.
This is so great!!!!!!!! It reminds me of times when band were not afraid to do out of the normal realm!! It's all about music, the universal language!!! reminds me of classical with movements to play on emotions,
That really is the CORRECT answer to the question.