Gateron Cap Switches or Milky-Top Yellows? | Review

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 89

  • @JayzBeerz
    @JayzBeerz 3 года назад +81

    I love how Gateron keeps improving their switches. Great video thank you.

    • @AustinV
      @AustinV  3 года назад +6

      Thanks! Yeah always nice to see companies innovate. Excited to see what's to come in the future

  • @xXHalfPrinceXx
    @xXHalfPrinceXx 3 года назад +40

    Love the new side by side comparison format in this

  • @Zarko1k
    @Zarko1k 3 года назад +20

    dude ur videos are so well done, ur probably gonna grow up any soon, keep it going!

    • @AustinV
      @AustinV  3 года назад +1

      Thanks so much!! I really appreciate it!

  • @dabeasthalofan6276
    @dabeasthalofan6276 3 года назад +16

    I lube linears with grade 2 dialectric grease, and I absolutely love the feeling more than grade 0 lubricant. Idk, it feels smoother, but heavier although light appliance will do the trick. Anyway, great video.

    • @bad9999
      @bad9999 2 года назад

      where can i buy some?

  • @bodythetan
    @bodythetan 3 года назад +8

    Awesome video; well done. So much work went into this, and it shows

    • @AustinV
      @AustinV  3 года назад

      Thanks so much!

  • @mellowistaken
    @mellowistaken 3 года назад +12

    I was thinking about getting the milky yellows, but that scratchiness killed it for me. Gonna stick with normal yellows lol. Great video!

    • @slackdm
      @slackdm 3 года назад +1

      Exactly my opinion and decision.

  • @MHilstrom
    @MHilstrom 3 года назад +5

    I'm guessing from the comments they didn't break in and get rid of the scratchiness? I am looking for some cheap into linears and found the Gay Yellows, which led me to the Cap Yellows. Would you say just to go with the older Gat Yellows?

    • @AustinV
      @AustinV  3 года назад

      Yeah I used them for a couple weeks after posting the video still and they sound maybe a touch better? But still definitely noticeable scratch.
      I think it depends on what you're looking for. If you want strictly smoothness, go for gat yellows. If you like the deeper sound profile and are willing to try breaking them in to get rid of scratch, go for caps

    • @Dyto69
      @Dyto69 3 года назад +9

      Gay Yellows Pog

  • @PanikNT
    @PanikNT 3 года назад +6

    Gateron caps just sound scratchier, original yellows are the way to go.

  • @SamBoga
    @SamBoga 3 года назад

    Just Got myself a Prebuilt Keyboard called FL esports FL680 with Cap yellow V1 ( Clear Top Milky Bottom) . It feels a bit smoother for that clear top housing to begin with.
    Make sure to do a follow up video in future with Gateron Cap v2 and Gateron Pro yellows. There are so many Gat yellows these days!

  • @xornedge8204
    @xornedge8204 3 года назад +3

    I heard there is a V2 for all of these switches now which improves their previous attributes. The Cap Milkies especially seem to be the bang for buck here.

    • @oeri1170
      @oeri1170 3 года назад

      Really? Where do I find them I've been looking at Milky yellows for the past hours and can't seem to find a good source

    • @kiwiasian
      @kiwiasian 2 года назад

      They still have a lot of off-centre scratchiness, even after lubing. Gat Yellows are much smoother.

  • @crainger
    @crainger 3 года назад +1

    I've just ordered some milky caps to test them out. I've heard you need to be careful lubing the cap switches as they can eject the lube via the airports and make a mess of your PCB.

  • @beaflm
    @beaflm 3 года назад +4

    For me, smoothness is the number 1 priority, and these cap switches sound and probably feel waaaay too scratchy lubed. It would drive me insane if I had to use them, I would probably end up over lubing them trying to make them smooth😅

    • @AustinV
      @AustinV  3 года назад

      Tbh even the lube couldn't save it from the extreme scratchy sound. I just hope they will smooth out over time through some kind of break in period, but I did take them out of my board already

    • @AustinV
      @AustinV  3 года назад

      @@louisdouvillebeaudoin4035 Honestly I'm not sure. I think the cap switches are the first ones to use this specific mix of plastic, so no previous experience of whether or not they'll lose their scratch over time. I will say that NK creams break in faster than the caps

    • @AustinV
      @AustinV  3 года назад

      @@louisdouvillebeaudoin4035 They're definitely the smoothest of the bunch

    • @AustinV
      @AustinV  3 года назад

      @@louisdouvillebeaudoin4035 I think it depends on how much time you're willing to put in. The sound isn't all too different but I would say there is a noticeable difference in the smoothness once you lube them. However, it takes a good few hours to lube them all

  • @robr640
    @robr640 3 года назад +3

    Were your CAPS switches actually 3 pin? The ones I got from Novelkeys was marketed as 5 pin, marked as 3 pin on the box, but ended up being 5 pin anyways. Wonder what that is all about?

    • @AustinV
      @AustinV  3 года назад +1

      Yeah mine were both 3 pin

    • @ATDStudios
      @ATDStudios 3 года назад +1

      The ones I got from Novelkeys were 5 pin as well, which I didn't mind at all.

  • @a7mad9999999
    @a7mad9999999 3 года назад +5

    great video man, love your presentation. i got a question. I have the anne pro 2 keyboard and thinking about getting the gateron whites/clears MILKY switches, I don't understand the 3/5 pin / pcb mount things? do they matter?

    • @AustinV
      @AustinV  3 года назад +7

      Thanks! So 3 pin means that on the bottom of the switch, there is only going to be that large circular thing sticking out in the middle and the 2 metal pins sticking out for the soldering connection. 5 pin will have all those plus 2 more little plastic pins sticking out to help keep it aligned better.
      They don't make a huge difference unless you're gonna build your board without a plate (PCB mount). Most of the time, the plate will take care of aligning the switches (Plate mount)

    • @a7mad9999999
      @a7mad9999999 3 года назад +2

      @@AustinV thanks for your explanation, king

    • @AustinV
      @AustinV  3 года назад

      @@a7mad9999999 I gotchu

  • @brewnewb
    @brewnewb 3 года назад +4

    Hi Austin. When you lube it, did you wash the factory lube first or just do it?

    • @AustinV
      @AustinV  3 года назад

      Yeah I wiped it off with some electronics cleaning swabs

  • @urmom-ck3gf
    @urmom-ck3gf 3 года назад +5

    Those sound so nice stock and lubed... Idk bro... sooooooooooooooo nice

    • @AustinV
      @AustinV  3 года назад

      I really like the deep sound profile of them but the intense scratchiness really needs an improvement imo

  • @nateon360hz7
    @nateon360hz7 3 года назад +3

    Do you need a switch puller to get them out of the box or original case?

    • @AustinV
      @AustinV  3 года назад

      Yeah they're pretty stuck in there. I used a switch puller to remove them

    • @nateon360hz7
      @nateon360hz7 3 года назад

      Austin V does it come with one or do you have to buy an additional one?

    • @AustinV
      @AustinV  3 года назад

      @@nateon360hz7 You have to get one

  • @enoziz6491
    @enoziz6491 3 года назад +2

    in your opinion which one d o you prefer

    • @AustinV
      @AustinV  3 года назад

      I think I kind of prefer the cap switches. I am willing to deal with the scratchiness since they have such a deep sound

  • @breakingmac7316
    @breakingmac7316 2 года назад

    Thanks for the vid. Any sites where I can buy shorter springs for the CAP? Haven’t found any and would like to swap.

  • @kinmonon4677
    @kinmonon4677 3 года назад +4

    I just got the switch in the mail and it got almost non the scratchiness like in the video, either way that's a good thing lol/

    • @AustinV
      @AustinV  3 года назад +2

      Dang you really lucked out! Maybe newer batches are smoother?

    • @qwq7108
      @qwq7108 3 года назад

      @@AustinV I've heard that Gateron improves the same switch through out the time, so the the latest batch of Cap yellow would be different from the the earliest ones.

  • @wil-
    @wil- 2 года назад

    The packaging is clean

  • @GuillermoCendejas-o7o
    @GuillermoCendejas-o7o 7 месяцев назад

    How do you get them out of the acrylic case?????????? :BIG QUESTION MARK EMOJI, DEsPERATE EMOJI

  • @lowbeam5005
    @lowbeam5005 3 года назад

    was thinking about upgrading from yellows to golden caps, can't believe they are that scratchy even after lubing:(

  • @burger9726
    @burger9726 3 года назад +3

    i like the normal gat yellow lubed sound better i dont hear a scratch at all

    • @AustinV
      @AustinV  3 года назад

      They are the budget kings for a reason!

    • @burger9726
      @burger9726 3 года назад +1

      @@AustinV are they eatable

    • @AustinV
      @AustinV  3 года назад

      @@burger9726 Let me know!

  • @davidwomack550
    @davidwomack550 3 года назад +1

    great video well made this described and showed everything i needed to know and more all my questions are answered thank you

  • @girsu9834
    @girsu9834 3 года назад +2

    I just have a quick question since im new to mechanical keyboards and i wanted to know if I can just put a 3 pin switch in a pcb with 5 holes for 5 pin switches since i wanted to buy the kbd67 lite and wanted to use milky yellows with 3 pins

    • @cowpuncher3007
      @cowpuncher3007 3 года назад

      yes, you can!

    • @AustinV
      @AustinV  3 года назад

      Yeah 3 pin switches can go in 5 pin boards. I actually put these switches in my own kbd67 lite and had no issues

    • @girsu9834
      @girsu9834 3 года назад

      @@AustinV ok thanks

  • @ARCHONFella
    @ARCHONFella 2 года назад

    does this have interference for north facing leds on Cherry keycaps?

  • @devilmayclarify666
    @devilmayclarify666 3 года назад

    The milks sound deeper to me. Am I crazy?

  • @RiceWater0
    @RiceWater0 3 года назад +1

    6:28 is the sound test

  • @NameLess-lk2qu
    @NameLess-lk2qu 3 года назад

    do we need to film this switch? if so what film do you recommend?

  • @pisanglaut7950
    @pisanglaut7950 3 года назад

    I love yellows! Can’t go anywhere

  • @ph7neutral
    @ph7neutral 3 года назад

    lubed gateron yellow dont have any changes in sound vs stock -__-'

  • @rloj4144
    @rloj4144 3 года назад

    Does the Milky Top yellows have spring ping or leaf ping?

  • @jdoroz1870
    @jdoroz1870 3 года назад +3

    a big scratchy but they sounds pretty nice!

    • @AustinV
      @AustinV  3 года назад +1

      Deep thock is quite nice. Just hoping they will break in like creams or something to remove the scratch

  • @cowpuncher3007
    @cowpuncher3007 3 года назад

    what about milky yellow switches with black bottoms?

  • @rui9812
    @rui9812 3 года назад

    Can someone help me? I’m stuck between ordering this keyboard in Gateron cap yellow or Kailh Box reds. I like the sort of click sound with the Cap yellow but I like the deeper tone of the Box Reds. Is anyone of them smoother or better than the other?

  • @ffmac2215
    @ffmac2215 3 года назад

    does it fit the gateron switches the samducksa arcade buttons?

  • @adambtww9360
    @adambtww9360 3 года назад

    can i put these on the gk61, if not what keyboards can I put them on, do you have any recommendations?

    • @AustinV
      @AustinV  3 года назад

      These will fit on any mx compatible board so your gk61 will be good

    • @crainger
      @crainger 3 года назад

      Will work as long as it's not an optical hotswap GK61, which seems to be the more common version now.

  • @gdead2
    @gdead2 3 года назад

    u telling me these gateron switches can LIE?!?!?! 😳

  • @GamesTogether1000
    @GamesTogether1000 3 года назад +4

    Reaaaallyy great video, definetly a like and sub worth

    • @AustinV
      @AustinV  3 года назад +1

      Thanks!! Appreciate it!

  • @x2stormzees552
    @x2stormzees552 3 года назад +2

    Have you tested the cap switches with uhmwpe stems and if you have does it get rid of the scratch sound?

    • @Linc-77
      @Linc-77 3 года назад +4

      i dont think the stems are compatible at all, please refer to 1:40.

    • @AustinV
      @AustinV  3 года назад +4

      Yeah Lincoln is right. These are a new type of switch so no current standard mx-style stems (UHMWPE included) are compatible. As far as I know, these are the first switches that have been made available in this variant

    • @x2stormzees552
      @x2stormzees552 3 года назад +1

      @@AustinV ah ok thank you

  • @skwamytypes9621
    @skwamytypes9621 3 года назад +1

    where is ur question mark????

    • @AustinV
      @AustinV  3 года назад

      The R shift key works as the /? key if you tap it

  • @vertzz2223
    @vertzz2223 3 года назад

    yoooooooooooooooooo

  • @2mmdefeaterr621
    @2mmdefeaterr621 3 года назад +1

    What keyboard is that?

    • @AustinV
      @AustinV  3 года назад

      Board Specs
      Case: TOFU60 Aluminum (e-white)
      PCB: DZ60 RGB
      Plate: Aluminum
      Stabilizers: Durock Screw In, lubed with Krytox 205G0, KBDFans foam stickers for bottom out
      Caps: OEM Profile PBT caps from Amazon (amzn.to/37joUTQ​)
      *Added foam in between case and PCB
      *Silicone O-rings on standoffs for softer bottom out (amzn.to/2V7mQsw​)
      FYI: In the future, you can always look for my board specs in the description :)

    • @2mmdefeaterr621
      @2mmdefeaterr621 3 года назад +1

      @@AustinV Ok thanks for the response :)

  • @robertrichards9565
    @robertrichards9565 3 года назад

    Bruh, use your pinkies man.

  • @xXHalfPrinceXx
    @xXHalfPrinceXx 3 года назад +1

    First!