Great video! Instead of showing YOUR preferred way only you decided to show us a lot of different methods for different kinds of curtains and leaving the choice up to us. Thank you very much for that!!
Why thank you! I felt that all the methods are usefull and I usually start with the simpler methods and it they don't work I move on to the more complex methods. Actually using physical collider is the best way, but it takes a little more focus and a better pc
@@TommyLikeTom You kidding? When you worked on the "lovely, lovely" drapes and suddenly the mesh turned to mush (so elegant) and you were like "yeeuuuuhh" I lost it. Looking forward to more
EUREKA! I solved it! The copy scale constraint was not recognizing "z" because it has no dimension. The grid is a 2D object and will only recognize "X & Y" axis. Wow that took some time but the feeling of success is priceless!
Really helpful, also appreciate that you show what you're clicking and the keys you used because a lot of times those things get lost in verbal explanation and if you're a noob if throws you off.
13:40 i feel you so much bro, thanks for sharing your story, I have another channel curently at 10k subs, but Im pretty old for internet standard (over 25) and I regret so much and I havent been uploading my art when i was 14, 15,17.... good to hear Im not the only one haha excelent tutorial!!!
Scaling the torus down with the collision modifier just has it clip through the mesh without altering the simulation. It'll only recognize the torus on next replay and freak out
that's useful! thank you! this is soo clear and such as idiot like me can also work it by steps, looking forward that you can teach some 3D characters clothes
I use Marvelous Designer quite often, it's very useful for stitching patterns together as one would in reality. It's not easy coming from 3D software but I think it's probably easier than blender if you are coming from a tailoring background
Awesome video! super helpful! One question tho..why do i have only 250 frames to put the cloth in the right position in method 3? I changed the end frame to 500 but its like it doesnt matter, the simulation stops at 250. Help please!
Hi Grisha. Under the Cloth Physics tab scroll down to "cache" and set the number of frames to whatever you want. Also You need to change the amount of frames in your blender file by either going to render settings or by changing the number underneath the timeline
great tutorial! one problem though, i'm trying out the curtains with hooks and it's not turning out nice as yours 😥 it's bunching up nicely at the top but stays relatively flat at the bottom... I've tried playing around with the stiffness setting but no luck,, any ideas?
Hi there. I was actually stumped by this question and after some experimenting I found that your settings totally depends on the scale of your subdivisions. if you have a lot of vertices then it will fall more loosely, but if you have few vertices then you have to turn all of the stiffness settings down to get similar results. try using these settings under Stiffness: Tension: 1 Compression:1 Shear: 0.1 Bending:0.01 make sure you change these settings _before_ running the simulation.
@@TommyLikeTom thanks so much!! I ended up remaking because blender got glitchy but it's super helpful to know how the settings affect the results. time to wiggle my curtains in sculpt mode 😎😎
Do you have any ideas for lady drass patters or what ever the could. You know does fancy drasses with alot of cloth patters and layers i dont think you can suclpt all does details so a simoletion pin world make wanders
Yeah, follow the instructions carefully. I just did it on my PC from memory without following the steps. 1) pin the vertex group 2) add a copy scale constraint 3) press play and scale if you are following the steps and it's still not working then I'm sorry, it's probably your PC or graphics card driver.
Hey Pleyland, this is such an awesome video, thank you! My grids keep falling as soon as I press play, do I have to erase the gravity setting or is this a common problem that has another solutiuon?
You can turn down gravity if that's what you're after but in most cases people want gravity on, make sure you have a pinned vertex group to keep some vertices in place
im going to throw this whole desk out of the window. F these hooks and F cloth physics for curtains in blender * hey thanks for the tutorial, it now makes more sense since the other booboo gaga 10 minute tutorials dont actually show anything useful and I am working with animated curtains. Although you are using physics to sculpt, it made it clear to me how to work with the modifer and set my groups and goals for animating the cloth further (and not also have wind while i am hookin)
How can I make the curtain stop moving? If I move the keyframes or try to move their locations to show curtains staying still at the beginning of an animation they all seem to freak out. Any help concerning this, please?
Interesting problem. I haven't done any cloth animations, this tutorial is just for modeling, but I imagine there must be a way to do it. Try searching for baking cloth animations or initial starting conditions for cloth animation
⚠⚠ Error resolution! CTRL + SHIFT + Numpad+ is not working? I had the same problem as you (the person reading this) and I spent a few hours trying to fix it, and I found the solution. Pay attention! There is a solution, and it can be accessed through two different methods, one from the interface and the other through keyboard commands. Method using keyboard commands: Select the desired object and press the TAB key to enter Edit Mode. Press the Shift + Space keys. A window will appear. If it disappears, press Shift + Space again and make sure not to move the mouse. Without touching anything and without moving the mouse, press the W key (note that the window that appeared when you pressed SHIFT + Space should be displayed on the screen). Now, you probably noticed that the mouse arrow in the left part of the screen where you have the top column with the modeling tools has changed. Now, you can select one point (check at the very top to make sure the point mode is selected (not line, not face)). Select one point, leave two points free, select the next one, and finally, you can press CTRL + Shift + Numpad+ and it will work. Press CTRL + Shift + Numpad+ as many times as needed. Congratulations! You may be wondering how to return to the old mouse selection form? Press Shift + Space, do not touch anything so that the window does not disappear and press the B key. That's it.
if i move my curtain made with method one to the desired location, it loses its refined shape and become sort of a smooth blob. any way to prevent this?
With industry keymap i don't have translations. for example i'm pressing R for scale and does nothing. Is there any idea how can i use these methods with industry keymap?
Unfortunately I have no idea what that is. You can use tools from the toolbar instead of shotcuts. Also you can look in preferences to see the keymap for the default software but also for installed addons in the addon menu. Press f3 to search for functions, the key will be displayed next to the function. You can right click on any function to create a shortcut or add to favourties. Favourites are accessed with Q
You need to start a pattern of selection before using that shortcut. If there is no vertex in to select that would fulfill the pattern, it gives that error.
Hey! Doubt I'll get a response for this, but I figured it was worth a shot--I'm currently trying to use the vertices hook method (like w/ the curtain with the bunched center), but for some reason, when I move the empty it won't do anything? The vertices are shown to be different in frame 1 (though the cloth physics don't effect it), but any frames after don't react to the movement at all and stay in the normal square grid shape. I'm not sure if it's a version difference or something, but I've no clue what setting could effect this, so help would be appreciated?
@@TommyLikeTom I have my transform tools set to gizmo and I wonder if that has anything to do with it. Some of my tools don't work the same as other people. I can't transform any object while the animation is playing. I have to pause it to move anything. Maybe it's a setting somewhere. thanks for the reply :)
Shift-Ctrl_Numpad+ to repeat selection doesn't work for me. I get an error message "selection pair not found". Does anyone know why? I'm in 2.9. Thank you!
Yes, you need to precede that command by at least 2 selections that follow a logical pattern. If the computer is unable to find a logical pattern from your previous 2 selections, then it will throw that error message at you
@@TommyLikeTom Thank you for your reply. I selected the corner vertex of a grid object, then shift selected the third edge vertex, and with both selected, Shift-Ctrl-Numpad+ and got the error. I tried in both 2.92 and 2.93.
Hi. I want to make a curtain with method 1, but the curtain falls when running the simulation and doesn't form any folds. Only the size of the plane changes when the cube is scaled. Help to understand, please.
you need to pin a vertex group in the cloth physics sections. Create a new vertex group and then select it under the pin section of the cloth physics menu
As great as this tutorial is... he completely blew past that you have to press the "assign" button when you assign a vertex group. He pressed it in the video, but the speed of the mouse clicks and his quick narration are too fast, so it is easy to miss. But even in his response to your question here, he skipped over actually saying that you must assign the vertex group... by pressing the "assign" key.
@@TommyLikeTom it started on the second example, if any of my scales go below .5 on the parented objects the curtain mesh seems to explode during the tweak while the sim is running.
@@TommyLikeTom, Yes I did but only the edge with the "X" constraint was active. The "Z' is totally non-responsive. The version is 3.3 Will try again later
@@TommyLikeTom so i hope you dont mind if i ask again... I was just about to say that i love your video. I was wondering if you knew a way to achieve any of your methods with rigging instead of animating? I would love to make this with a rig instead of static mesh.....
By the way you’ve just saved me days of work making curtains fold correctly
that is what I am here for. Pity I don't have your job. I do accept tips
Great video!
Instead of showing YOUR preferred way only you decided to show us a lot of different methods for different kinds of curtains and leaving the choice up to us. Thank you very much for that!!
Why thank you! I felt that all the methods are usefull and I usually start with the simpler methods and it they don't work I move on to the more complex methods. Actually using physical collider is the best way, but it takes a little more focus and a better pc
Thanks for this excellent demonstration of Blender's power.
best blender video about how to make curtains in human history. hats off
Many many thanks
thank you for the baby steps really useful and straight to the point
I was like "cool, nice tutorial" but the thing that sold me was the French accent on the method texts. Made me subscribe immediately.
It's one of those things that can turn people away too, but at least I'm attracting the _right_ kind of people
@@TommyLikeTom You kidding? When you worked on the "lovely, lovely" drapes and suddenly the mesh turned to mush (so elegant) and you were like "yeeuuuuhh" I lost it. Looking forward to more
EUREKA! I solved it! The copy scale constraint was not recognizing "z" because it has no dimension. The grid is a 2D object and will only recognize "X & Y" axis. Wow that took some time but the feeling of success is priceless!
This made me smile, I'm glad you are making progress
THANK YOU!! I was wondering why the "Z" axis wasn't working but, this makes so much sense.
How did you make it work on the Z axis ? 😖
@@agathelcz5361 instead of adding a plane (for the curtain) add a grid :) sorry for the late answer but I just dicovered it too
@@hielolicuado omg yes thank you for the advice!! I will definitely reuse this!
Really great tutorial. Been looking for some more advanced cloth info. Thank you!!!
Glad it was helpful!
YOU MADE MY DAY SO MUCH HAPPIER! JUST LOVED IT!!
Wow, this is the kind of comment that really sticks in one's mind. Thank you for the kind words. שלום
Mind blowing. Even at a slower pace. Cloth simulations are just, wow. :D
amazing, this is such a great help, thx so much!
It works , many thanks !
My pleasure
This is just amazing. I just did a delivery for a client and I work on Maya but this is so much better. I have to transition to Blender soon.
Soon? What are you waiting for?
Amazing tutorial!
Youre tutorial is entertaining and you have a good charisma, thanks for the video
This is the best cloth simulation in blender toutrial thank you
Thank you! I think maybe for curtains, yes, but for general cloth no, there are much better tutorials that cover clothing and stitching!
@@TommyLikeTom
i learned a lot, thanks!
Hearing you say 500 subscribers man , its good to see howmuch you have grown
thank you for your support
Really helpful, also appreciate that you show what you're clicking and the keys you used because a lot of times those things get lost in verbal explanation and if you're a noob if throws you off.
I'm glad I could be of service. Imagine I was something awful like a lawyer! Those guys suck and only make humanity worse!
13:40 i feel you so much bro, thanks for sharing your story, I have another channel curently at 10k subs, but Im pretty old for internet standard (over 25) and I regret so much and I havent been uploading my art when i was 14, 15,17.... good to hear Im not the only one haha
excelent tutorial!!!
Super useful tutorial...perfect overview! Thanks a lot for sharing knowledge!
love the tutorial! the title card referencing the spongebob french narrator, love it
Scaling the torus down with the collision modifier just has it clip through the mesh without altering the simulation. It'll only recognize the torus on next replay and freak out
RUclips should put this video in the first search results when someone searches for Blender cloth modifier
yes
Aweh bru love the accent 🤣 thanks for the easy to follow Tutorial
Thank you
I am overwhelmed with a feeling of calmness
Just what I was looking for, great technique!
thank you!
great methods!!
I know right? thanks
Tahnk you so much!
thank you
You're welcome
lOVE THIS! tHANKS MUCH!
Honestly. Amazing video!
Glad you enjoyed it
that's useful! thank you! this is soo clear and such as idiot like me can also work it by steps, looking forward that you can teach some 3D characters clothes
Thank you so much!!
No problem!
This is very useful and to the point. Thanks!
Insane tutorial!!!
You're a good man, Maxwell
Amazing! Thank you so much!
you are very welcome!
Great and clear tuto, thanks for sharing
exeptional totorial
thonk yo
thanks a bunch for making this tutorial. I have been using Marvelous but it is a nightmare to use due to the horrible performance/usability.
I use Marvelous Designer quite often, it's very useful for stitching patterns together as one would in reality. It's not easy coming from 3D software but I think it's probably easier than blender if you are coming from a tailoring background
and it's my pleasure, glad I could help
awsome tutorial!! what i was looking for!! thank you!
super helpful thank you!
So glad!
Great tutorial, thanks!
you are welcome
You are the god man!
That's what I keep telling everyone
@@TommyLikeTom that's good one!
Thank you very useful!
I hope it can serve as a reference!
Thanks man! Great video, grazie for effort to record!
Thanks for all the different methods, nice work.
thanks
thank you so much, that was really helpful
Very useful, thanks!
You're welcome!
I want this!! 6:15 thx so much!!!
It's 🍌. Very nice tutorial!
Thanks a 🍇
Pretty useful, buddy. Thanks!
Glad it helped!
This is so cool! Some day I’m going to be as good as you
You can do it!
I will!
god feckin bless you
I love you to bits
nice
noice
😍 Perfect tutorial, thank you
Awesome video! super helpful! One question tho..why do i have only 250 frames to put the cloth in the right position in method 3? I changed the end frame to 500 but its like it doesnt matter, the simulation stops at 250. Help please!
Hi Grisha. Under the Cloth Physics tab scroll down to "cache" and set the number of frames to whatever you want. Also You need to change the amount of frames in your blender file by either going to render settings or by changing the number underneath the timeline
Good
Hai... excellent tutorial.. but if you have an each method individual and slow tutorial video please send a link... Thank you..
NEAT
Wow! So amazing! Thank you!!!
great tutorial! one problem though, i'm trying out the curtains with hooks and it's not turning out nice as yours 😥 it's bunching up nicely at the top but stays relatively flat at the bottom... I've tried playing around with the stiffness setting but no luck,, any ideas?
Hi there. I was actually stumped by this question and after some experimenting I found that your settings totally depends on the scale of your subdivisions. if you have a lot of vertices then it will fall more loosely, but if you have few vertices then you have to turn all of the stiffness settings down to get similar results. try using these settings under Stiffness:
Tension: 1
Compression:1
Shear: 0.1
Bending:0.01
make sure you change these settings _before_ running the simulation.
my above answer was just the result of minimum experimenting so please try other settings as well to achieve your desired effect.
@@TommyLikeTom thanks so much!! I ended up remaking because blender got glitchy but it's super helpful to know how the settings affect the results. time to wiggle my curtains in sculpt mode 😎😎
Do you have any ideas for lady drass patters or what ever the could. You know does fancy drasses with alot of cloth patters and layers i dont think you can suclpt all does details so a simoletion pin world make wanders
Thank you for the lesson! But I can't understand why I have 0.1 fps curtains when calculating the physics ... Processor i9 4Ghz and Nvidia 1080ti.
unfortunately i9 means very little to me without the processors generation. Good GPU though. how many subdivs are you using?
Nicee...
Suscribed
Thanks for the sub
Any tips for getting the simulations to run quicker?
faster computer, less programs, less vertices, colder weather.
omg finallly u !
Can't get the first one to work. Any tips? Following all steps exactly in blender 3.4
Yeah, follow the instructions carefully. I just did it on my PC from memory without following the steps.
1) pin the vertex group
2) add a copy scale constraint
3) press play and scale
if you are following the steps and it's still not working then I'm sorry, it's probably your PC or graphics card driver.
Hey Pleyland, this is such an awesome video, thank you! My grids keep falling as soon as I press play, do I have to erase the gravity setting or is this a common problem that has another solutiuon?
You can turn down gravity if that's what you're after but in most cases people want gravity on, make sure you have a pinned vertex group to keep some vertices in place
im going to throw this whole desk out of the window. F these hooks and F cloth physics for curtains in blender
* hey thanks for the tutorial, it now makes more sense since the other booboo gaga 10 minute tutorials dont actually show anything useful and I am working with animated curtains. Although you are using physics to sculpt, it made it clear to me how to work with the modifer and set my groups and goals for animating the cloth further (and not also have wind while i am hookin)
u sound like narrator from spongebob
He has a name 🙄
Pleyland : "... the hook..."
me: **right ear gets blow at** "wtf, who did that?"
Default cube with the uppercut (boolean)
How can I make the curtain stop moving? If I move the keyframes or try to move their locations to show curtains staying still at the beginning of an animation they all seem to freak out. Any help concerning this, please?
Interesting problem. I haven't done any cloth animations, this tutorial is just for modeling, but I imagine there must be a way to do it. Try searching for baking cloth animations or initial starting conditions for cloth animation
⚠⚠ Error resolution!
CTRL + SHIFT + Numpad+ is not working? I had the same problem as you (the person reading this) and I spent a few hours trying to fix it, and I found the solution.
Pay attention! There is a solution, and it can be accessed through two different methods, one from the interface and the other through keyboard commands.
Method using keyboard commands:
Select the desired object and press the TAB key to enter Edit Mode.
Press the Shift + Space keys. A window will appear. If it disappears, press Shift + Space again and make sure not to move the mouse.
Without touching anything and without moving the mouse, press the W key (note that the window that appeared when you pressed SHIFT + Space should be displayed on the screen).
Now, you probably noticed that the mouse arrow in the left part of the screen where you have the top column with the modeling tools has changed.
Now, you can select one point (check at the very top to make sure the point mode is selected (not line, not face)). Select one point, leave two points free, select the next one, and finally, you can press CTRL + Shift + Numpad+ and it will work. Press CTRL + Shift + Numpad+ as many times as needed.
Congratulations! You may be wondering how to return to the old mouse selection form?
Press Shift + Space, do not touch anything so that the window does not disappear and press the B key.
That's it.
Thanks I'll look into this
if i move my curtain made with method one to the desired location, it loses its refined shape and become sort of a smooth blob. any way to prevent this?
Yes, apply the constraint or convert the object to a mesh
How can I pin cloth to two differnet objects?
hooks
I am noticing your grid in in object mode and your subdivision command is active?
With industry keymap i don't have translations. for example i'm pressing R for scale and does nothing. Is there any idea how can i use these methods with industry keymap?
Unfortunately I have no idea what that is. You can use tools from the toolbar instead of shotcuts. Also you can look in preferences to see the keymap for the default software but also for installed addons in the addon menu. Press f3 to search for functions, the key will be displayed next to the function. You can right click on any function to create a shortcut or add to favourties. Favourites are accessed with Q
For me dont work CTRL + Shift + Numpad + ( ERROR : Selection pair not found ) .
You need to start a pattern of selection before using that shortcut. If there is no vertex in to select that would fulfill the pattern, it gives that error.
Hey! Doubt I'll get a response for this, but I figured it was worth a shot--I'm currently trying to use the vertices hook method (like w/ the curtain with the bunched center), but for some reason, when I move the empty it won't do anything? The vertices are shown to be different in frame 1 (though the cloth physics don't effect it), but any frames after don't react to the movement at all and stay in the normal square grid shape. I'm not sure if it's a version difference or something, but I've no clue what setting could effect this, so help would be appreciated?
probably is the different version.
I somehow didn’t consider this, but that’s probably it 😅 thanks!! Luckily I managed to make it look alright without using that exact method, though :D
I can't move the controllers while animating. Do I need to activate something?
That's the first time I've heard that problem. Are you sure you didn't add any constraints?
@@TommyLikeTom I have my transform tools set to gizmo and I wonder if that has anything to do with it. Some of my tools don't work the same as other people. I can't transform any object while the animation is playing. I have to pause it to move anything. Maybe it's a setting somewhere. thanks for the reply :)
@@esther9433 having the same issue of can't scale while animation is playing. Wondering if you figured out how to fix this?
Shift-Ctrl_Numpad+ to repeat selection doesn't work for me. I get an error message "selection pair not found". Does anyone know why? I'm in 2.9. Thank you!
Yes, you need to precede that command by at least 2 selections that follow a logical pattern. If the computer is unable to find a logical pattern from your previous 2 selections, then it will throw that error message at you
@@TommyLikeTom Thank you for your reply. I selected the corner vertex of a grid object, then shift selected the third edge vertex, and with both selected, Shift-Ctrl-Numpad+ and got the error. I tried in both 2.92 and 2.93.
Hi. I want to make a curtain with method 1, but the curtain falls when running the simulation and doesn't form any folds. Only the size of the plane changes when the cube is scaled. Help to understand, please.
you need to pin a vertex group in the cloth physics sections. Create a new vertex group and then select it under the pin section of the cloth physics menu
As great as this tutorial is... he completely blew past that you have to press the "assign" button when you assign a vertex group. He pressed it in the video, but the speed of the mouse clicks and his quick narration are too fast, so it is easy to miss. But even in his response to your question here, he skipped over actually saying that you must assign the vertex group... by pressing the "assign" key.
The Copy Scale on Z axis isn't working. I followed every step (except the mistake). Any clue what I might be missing?
EDIT: I didn't apply rotation on the cloth.
good to know for future reference. Hey everyone, remember to apply rotation on the cloth if things seem wacky!
Seems to explode when I make tweaks. Blender 2.83 is my current version. Anything I can do to keep it from exploding?
I'm sorry but I need more details to assess the problem. At which point in the video does it start to explode?
@@TommyLikeTom it started on the second example, if any of my scales go below .5 on the parented objects the curtain mesh seems to explode during the tweak while the sim is running.
@@TheD3vilHimself I had the same issue (though for me it was below .8). Updating to 2.93 has fixed the issue for me
@@gaalla Thanks I will give that a try
I am at a loss as to how the curtain top remains straight in method 4. Been trying almost whole day with no success.
I'm confused cause my curtain doean't work.when I scale only the selected vertex move but others didn't.
I'm sorry to hear that. Try playing the simulation and make sure the physics is on.
OMG
Did you have a revelatory experience?
@@TommyLikeTom Of course, I already applied it in my project, thanks!
Hey can you help me with some specific kind of curtain?
yes, my email is ttorr27@gmail.com
I've tried method 3 to the letter many times with no success. The edges are being scaled with no animations taking place.
Sorry to hear that. Perhaps something has changed with the updates. Are you sure you pressed play?
@@TommyLikeTom, Yes I did but only the edge with the "X" constraint was active. The "Z' is totally non-responsive. The version is 3.3 Will try again later
Fucking máster 🤲🏽❤️
Omg its so fast
ermergerrrrrrd
Do I detect a South African accent there? 😉
ewe
hmm strange how all the sudden my comment disappeared or got deleted
It wasn't me, I have the settings set to remove any harmful comments, sorry if it deleted a regular comment by mistake
@@TommyLikeTom so i hope you dont mind if i ask again... I was just about to say that i love your video. I was wondering if you knew a way to achieve any of your methods with rigging instead of animating? I would love to make this with a rig instead of static mesh.....
le baby carton...
qu'est-ce que c'est?
Too fast
TOO FAST SPEECH
ME THINK GOOD SPEED
нихера не понятно, еще и мычит под нос...
возможно выучить английский...
@@TommyLikeTom There is no problem with that. But it won't fix your pronunciation, man.
Good lesson, sad that can't hear almost anything
👎👎👎
you mumble to yourself, and the speed of action is so fast that i have to set the speed to 50%