If you feel like Isabella was a little OOC, just read my analysis of her character. Isabella and Mirabel are both jealous of each other, Mirabel is jealous of Isabella place in the family and Isabella is jealous of Mirabel's freedom. I think that Isabela’s role of the “golden child” made her view Mirabel’s lack of a gift as a type of freedom. Isabela gave up her whole life and identity to play the part of a perfect child for Abuela and the town. From her perspective, Mirabel not getting a gift means that she is free from the pressure, stress, and expectations that comes with getting a gift and all Mirabel does about it is complain.(Of course she doesn’t see Mirabel’s suffering) To her, Mirabel is complaining about having the freedom that Isabela never had.
Funnily enough, this is how I think Isabella felt as well. It seems that all she wanted is freedom, and Mirabel wanted a place in the family. Both didn’t like each other bc of the way they saw each other and felt jealous of one another.
This video actually has the characters a lot more in character than any of the others I've watched, the only thing is that Isabela isn't likely to expose herself that easily, but it's still not too out of character. This was really well made!
This is the first reaction video I saw that actually tells Abuela that it's wrong about how she handles or say thing to Mirabel and even how she expects everyone of them to be prefect with there gifts,so in my opinion this video was the best I ever seen so far🤩, I hope u keep up the good work👍
Honestly, I don't know why people are hating on your videos. You're very observant and I love how you go about it. I love when people go more in depth about emotions rather then scratching the surface and stereotyping the characters.
This video is amazing! but i feel like some of the people don't really understand abuela's character. Abuela cares about the family more than the candle but losing her husband and having to lead the whole village by herself she may have trauma of losing her family again so she makes her family to be what she wants, to be perfect and strong but she went a little overboard with her emotions and expectations she ended up hurting her family but she doesn't want to. And at the end of the movie she apologized to her family and remake the house. But that's my understanding of abuela's character. I maybe wrong.
First, thank you so much for sharing your opinion with me without a death threat ( god knows how many I got for this 4 minute video…). I truly enjoyed reading it. To me, abuela seemed like a perfect antagonist. (Antagonist not villain) she wasn’t evil and yes, she did love her family dearly but that doesn’t change the fact that she was toxic. Having trauma is not an excuse to neglect and mentally abuse your family with or without your knowledge. For example Mirabel. Mirabel didn't get a gift, but the way Alma speaks about it, it makes it seem like Mirabel did something wrong. She was small when these ceremonies took place, a child, and she didn't do anything wrong. And let’s not talk about Bruno( pun intended) cause she handled that whole situation poorly ( who makes their son’s name taboo….) The amount of generational trauma this woman caused us unbelievable. I do like how she felt regretful towards the end but I think she got off rather mildly. I am, however, planning to make a video dedicated to just Abuela. She is one of my favourite characters in encanto (ironically lol)
I agree that she did care about her family, but that doesn't change the fact that she treated them terrible and the fact that she had that trauma doesn't make it okay to give her family trauma.
Hello!! I honestly think this is one of the best encanto react videos and its such a shame your getting death threats for such stupid and idiotic things. I really respect your opinion, its just that I feel like Abuela wouldn't be so "Evil" if you know what I mean? Because well in the movie, she saw her husband die right in front of her and she was traumatized. Im guessing she was abt 20 in that time? Well anyways, she was very grateful for the miracle and she became quite dependant on the gifts. She wanted to repay as much as she could. It was only somewhere about the end of the movie that she realized Mirabel didn't do anything and it was her, Abuela's fault. She didn't want to lose her home again and when Casita broke down she was really emotional. Of course, its your opinion about the video and how you want Abuela, and I just want to say don't let those idiots get to you! Nobody ever deserves to get death threats and I hope your fine :))
Guys, guys this is her au. Aus r not canon and yall know that. Dont threaten her with death threats. Please, its just disturbing. If its her au, its her au. period.😠
I don't know why people are sending hate comments and about skin tones, the tones you used are perfect. The only thing wrong is just Pepa's eye color since they're green instead of brown. These people need to just shove it
Hello!,New subscriber!! Isabella is always jealous of Mirabel unknowingly that Mirabel is the only person and reasons who made her powers grow and make new powers!!Which made like having a freedom that Mirabel got!!And Mirabel is jealous of Isabella unknowingly that Isabella would be happy with you forever!! This so amazing,hope you make more ✨
While I was scrolling through my searches a skeleton looking thing came and I scrolled so fast like I hate scary things but nice video it helped to calm for a bit
Hi silver Marie I watched one of your gacha videos like two days ago and I saw what you said in the beginning and honestly don't listen to those people yea your video needs work but everyone's videos needs work no one is perfect and I really liked it a lot your important and talented and I hope you continue making gacha videos❤
i might be wrong but i think mademoiselle is french! obviously i don't know whether or not you already know this, but i am just pointing it out!!! Awesome video!!! :)
The way you were talking to Abuela was so satisying, the only thing that was missing was just 1 bitch(the word) at the end and it would've been perfect
ABUELA IS NOT THE VILLIAN something I love about encanto is there is villain but there is people who make abuela the mean person SHE ISN'T alma has delt with seeing her husband get killed and the reason why she treated Mirabel like that is she scared the miracle is dying because of her the night after her not getting a gift as in the movie she worried about the magic and thinking her miracle is dying and i know you didn't want hate and this isn't SHE ISN'T THE VILLAIN
Some people give me death threats or threaten me to harm themselves if I don’t make a part two. Other day I should die for making a character out of character or sth.
Cause she is the antagonist to put it simply. Abuela is my favourite character but she wasn’t exactly the A book definition of great parent nor grandparent. Also bear in mind that this is past Encanto reacting. I know that Abuela is a good person but her actions at the beginning showed a high degree of trauma which she handled by pressuring her children and grandchildren. Her priorities was skewed. I will eventually give her a character development lol but for now she is going to be going through some self assessment 😅
Well I mean everything has a villain/antagonist and when you think about it who's done the most damage? I mean Isabela was sorta one but quickly sorted out later
Yeah. Seriously make them darker. Wtf is wrong with u? Creators like u are the reason we don’t have good things. Maybe u should stop making bad quality gacha and just end it 😑🤦🏻♀️
Oh sorry. I didn’t mean to white wash them. I’ll make sure to darken their skin for part two. I just realized Disney has put out a color pallet so I’m going to follow that!
Omg is it that bad? I thought it seemed accurate. I didn't want her skin tone to be the exact same as Isabella cause to me she seemed a bit darker so I tried to change it to a different shade rather than lightening her but I guess it didn't workout...I will change it for part two!
I wasn’t being rude I was stating the truth. Abuela was an abusive person. Yes a person can still be abusive even if they are not aware of it. I do understand that she was a victim too and I will make a reaction video for her. As a matter of fact the third part is about her but for now she must realize her wrong doing specially since this is a PAST encanto reaction video
I dont like how u are making issabella here the wrong one they are all at problem im pretty sure you know that, This was annoying since isabella is who i kin in encanto i understand her problem and i relate to it, So its much annoying how u did this
@@allysar.3678 first thank you so much for being respectful about your opinion. I actually kin Isabella too! In the pin comment I explained the reason why Isabella might seem a little rude or OOC as some would say! And yes the whole family was a disaster. Don’t we all love a dysfunctional family with zero communication 😂🥲
@@silvermarl5015 ohh i see the pinned comment sorry i did not quite see it 😕 i thought it was just some announcements so i did not decide to read it sorry again ☹️ As a sorry for my mistake i would subscribe to you!
Sorry I can’t do that. My videos are generally filled with many talking and interaction between characters cause I find that to be more engaging. Sorry
Isabela ily but if u think ur life is the worst let's break it down into pieces 1. You treated mirabel like a outcast only bc she lived free and that is not fair 2. Mirabel was bullied by abuela bc she had no gift you were treated like a queen bc u had one 3. If u were jealous then atleast speak up and tell abuela about ur feelings then u will live like mirabel (sorta) 4. You were perfect but mirabel was just a piece of trash and had no one to understand her pain even tho were her older sis u never decided to know ur sis and what she was going through *think about that.* Edit:no hate to the creator I was just a little anoyed that she was jealous even tho she had a perfect life
If you feel like Isabella was a little OOC, just read my analysis of her character. Isabella and Mirabel are both jealous of each other, Mirabel is jealous of Isabella place in the family and Isabella is jealous of Mirabel's freedom. I think that Isabela’s role of the “golden child” made her view Mirabel’s lack of a gift as a type of freedom. Isabela gave up her whole life and identity to play the part of a perfect child for Abuela and the town. From her perspective, Mirabel not getting a gift means that she is free from the pressure, stress, and expectations that comes with getting a gift and all Mirabel does about it is complain.(Of course she doesn’t see Mirabel’s suffering) To her, Mirabel is complaining about having the freedom that Isabela never had.
I actually really like this idea cause I feel like it would actually be the case
I love this occ and i see it can they react to mirabel theory of mirables gift
Funnily enough, this is how I think Isabella felt as well. It seems that all she wanted is freedom, and Mirabel wanted a place in the family. Both didn’t like each other bc of the way they saw each other and felt jealous of one another.
I actually think this really fits both of them
I love this, this is actually what happens in the film but everyone kinda just brushes over this entire topic. 😊
This video actually has the characters a lot more in character than any of the others I've watched, the only thing is that Isabela isn't likely to expose herself that easily, but it's still not too out of character. This was really well made!
This is the first reaction video I saw that actually tells Abuela that it's wrong about how she handles or say thing to Mirabel and even how she expects everyone of them to be prefect with there gifts,so in my opinion this video was the best I ever seen so far🤩, I hope u keep up the good work👍
Honestly, I don't know why people are hating on your videos. You're very observant and I love how you go about it. I love when people go more in depth about emotions rather then scratching the surface and stereotyping the characters.
It also reveals perspectives on characters I never noticed.
This is officially my favourite encanto video! *MORE, PLEASE, I BEG!!!*
I love how you make Dolores make her say that "He didn't really leave tho"
Finally!!! One that actually makes sense, hope you do more
0:29 Madmoiselle is french.......
Pfftt- I can't stop laughing 🤣😂
THIS IS THE BEST ONE IVE EVER SEEN THIS IS SO GOOD NEW SUB AAAAAA
This video is amazing! but i feel like some of the people don't really understand abuela's character. Abuela cares about the family more than the candle but losing her husband and having to lead the whole village by herself she may have trauma of losing her family again so she makes her family to be what she wants, to be perfect and strong but she went a little overboard with her emotions and expectations she ended up hurting her family but she doesn't want to. And at the end of the movie she apologized to her family and remake the house. But that's my understanding of abuela's character. I maybe wrong.
First, thank you so much for sharing your opinion with me without a death threat ( god knows how many I got for this 4 minute video…). I truly enjoyed reading it. To me, abuela seemed like a perfect antagonist. (Antagonist not villain) she wasn’t evil and yes, she did love her family dearly but that doesn’t change the fact that she was toxic. Having trauma is not an excuse to neglect and mentally abuse your family with or without your knowledge. For example Mirabel. Mirabel didn't get a gift, but the way Alma speaks about it, it makes it seem like Mirabel did something wrong. She was small when these ceremonies took place, a child, and she didn't do anything wrong. And let’s not talk about Bruno( pun intended) cause she handled that whole situation poorly ( who makes their son’s name taboo….) The amount of generational trauma this woman caused us unbelievable. I do like how she felt regretful towards the end but I think she got off rather mildly. I am, however, planning to make a video dedicated to just Abuela. She is one of my favourite characters in encanto (ironically lol)
I agree that she did care about her family, but that doesn't change the fact that she treated them terrible and the fact that she had that trauma doesn't make it okay to give her family trauma.
We Need Part 2. Bro/Sis this is so good, keep on The good work!
Am I the only one concerned with the "death threats" part at the beginning?
No, I'm worried too. What does she mean by that....
Ironically I got some for this video too lol
How? Who? Why? Do people not have anything better to do?
@@psychohound8340 i
assuming they don’t but it’s fine. I just have to keep deleting them 😅🥲
@@silvermarl5015 But why, did you ever do something, or are they just being a**holes?
Hold it right there are you getting death threats for your opinions? wtf I knew the internet was bad but like that's a WHOLE NEW LEVEL.
Ah yes. I got some for this video too but y’know.😀
Hello!! I honestly think this is one of the best encanto react videos and its such a shame your getting death threats for such stupid and idiotic things. I really respect your opinion, its just that I feel like Abuela wouldn't be so "Evil" if you know what I mean? Because well in the movie, she saw her husband die right in front of her and she was traumatized. Im guessing she was abt 20 in that time? Well anyways, she was very grateful for the miracle and she became quite dependant on the gifts. She wanted to repay as much as she could. It was only somewhere about the end of the movie that she realized Mirabel didn't do anything and it was her, Abuela's fault. She didn't want to lose her home again and when Casita broke down she was really emotional. Of course, its your opinion about the video and how you want Abuela, and I just want to say don't let those idiots get to you! Nobody ever deserves to get death threats and I hope your fine :))
Guys, guys this is her au. Aus r not canon and yall know that. Dont threaten her with death threats. Please, its just disturbing. If its her au, its her au. period.😠
This was outstanding!!! The best I have ever seen in my whole life!!!!!!!!!
I don't know why people are sending hate comments and about skin tones, the tones you used are perfect. The only thing wrong is just Pepa's eye color since they're green instead of brown. These people need to just shove it
Thank you. Honestly I don’t know why either. 😅 I never thought I would get so much hate comments in one video. I will fix pepa’s eyes for part two!
@@silvermarl5015 if they make you feel bad or go too far you can turn off comments :)
ayo I love this I keep rewatching it btw new sub
We demand a part 2
I am obssesed with your awsome work. it is just perfect :)
Haha yes I love the grandma slander :)
Please make a pt 2 if u can this is so good!
Abuela's eyes: 👉👉
Me: how the fuc did she see the vid
There was an ad and the ad said your "life seems super sad" and I said "is the video going to be angst?"🤔
😂😂😂😂😂
Omg the way im enjoying this video 😍
This is why Julieta is my comfort character
Why did I cry over a gacha vid omg
Dam the Abuela slander in this video is very krispy
My theory:mirabel miracle WHAT U know shes the miracle
yesss good and see so sorry to her okk
Hello!,New subscriber!!
Isabella is always jealous of Mirabel unknowingly that Mirabel is the only person and reasons who made her powers grow and make new powers!!Which made like having a freedom that Mirabel got!!And Mirabel is jealous of Isabella unknowingly that Isabella would be happy with you forever!!
This so amazing,hope you make more ✨
FINALLY REAL ANGST 😭-
Wow nice video to it had a lot of emotion and I loved it
This is amazing
®eally cool
Drama. This is all the video is and I love it
THIS IS THE ONLY GOOD REACTION VID I FOUND DO A PART 2 PLEASE
While I was scrolling through my searches a skeleton looking thing came and I scrolled so fast like I hate scary things but nice video it helped to calm for a bit
Hi girl I'm the new subscriber because i love your video
This is so good part 2 pls!
10/10
Hi silver Marie I watched one of your gacha videos like two days ago and I saw what you said in the beginning and honestly don't listen to those people yea your video needs work but everyone's videos needs work no one is perfect and I really liked it a lot your important and talented and I hope you continue making gacha videos❤
This video was great I believe you deserve at least 3-4k subscribers because this is magnificent!
Stop looking at me Creek
The video was amazing!!also were can you watch Encanto cause I cant really find a website or An app to watch it on
i might be wrong but i think mademoiselle is french!
obviously i don't know whether or not you already know this, but i am just pointing it out!!!
Awesome video!!!
:)
I need part 2
AHHHH I LOVE THIS SO MUCH IT WAS SO GOOD
The way you were talking to Abuela was so satisying, the only thing that was missing was just 1 bitch(the word) at the end and it would've been perfect
ABUELA IS NOT THE VILLIAN
something I love about encanto is there is villain but there is people who make abuela the mean person SHE ISN'T alma has delt with seeing her husband get killed and the reason why she treated Mirabel like that is she scared the miracle is dying because of her the night after her not getting a gift as in the movie she worried about the magic and thinking her miracle is dying and i know you didn't want hate and this isn't SHE ISN'T THE VILLAIN
Bruno probably saw how bad Mirabel was treated cause he probably watched over her and the family.
Time to ask the big question, wanna see how yall think, is abuela a bad person?
make them reacting to Mirabel and candle
put abuela in her place
3:46 what version of the song is that
Now i get it why mirabel is not thier because its past 😐
Im a simp for Camilo😩😂
Hi!
Hi part 2?
4:05 what name of music
2-6-22 encanto!
2:01 does anyone know the song name?
Who sings the songs in of the edits?
Parte2
Part 2?
😘👌
4:06 whats the songs name please?
Whats the song of the first tiktok if anyone knows?
1-28-22 i havent seen this movie yet so
maybe their next reaction will be to issabela?
hello! i would like to say (no hate) i think dolores should be darker and less ashy?
You tell abuela
LOL
why are you getting death threats :
Some people give me death threats or threaten me to harm themselves if I don’t make a part two. Other day I should die for making a character out of character or sth.
@@silvermarl5015 aww you don't deserve that they need to realize you're still a human being that still needs to rest,eat etc just like they do \:
@@getepicallynoob Thank you 😭 😭 😭
@@silvermarl5015 np!
Isabella did something wrong and you made her play the victim. no
Hey so things wrong the beast part
😔😣😣🥺🙏🏻
Is it me Julieta is a little to little same as abuela
Why does everyone make abuela the bad😃
Cause she is the antagonist to put it simply. Abuela is my favourite character but she wasn’t exactly the A book definition of great parent nor grandparent. Also bear in mind that this is past Encanto reacting. I know that Abuela is a good person but her actions at the beginning showed a high degree of trauma which she handled by pressuring her children and grandchildren. Her priorities was skewed. I will eventually give her a character development lol but for now she is going to be going through some self assessment 😅
You got a point!
Well I mean everything has a villain/antagonist and when you think about it who's done the most damage? I mean Isabela was sorta one but quickly sorted out later
have you watched the movie
Sorry but you should fix Abuela's and Dolores' skin tone, it's super close to white washing
Yeah. Seriously make them darker. Wtf is wrong with u? Creators like u are the reason we don’t have good things. Maybe u should stop making bad quality gacha and just end it 😑🤦🏻♀️
Oh sorry. I didn’t mean to white wash them. I’ll make sure to darken their skin for part two. I just realized Disney has put out a color pallet so I’m going to follow that!
@@suzylmao5761 that’s…not very nice….I literally said at the beginning to not send me death threats. Can you please stop?
@@silvermarl5015 Alr then thank you
@@suzylmao5761 Bruh? Why so rude?! They just made the skin color lighter. They should not end it out of what? A mistake they made?
Why is dolores’ skin tone so light and gray. Not trying to accuse you of whitewashing or anything it just looks strange and not like her skintone
Omg is it that bad? I thought it seemed accurate. I didn't want her skin tone to be the exact same as Isabella cause to me she seemed a bit darker so I tried to change it to a different shade rather than lightening her but I guess it didn't workout...I will change it for part two!
@@silvermarl5015 You prob want her a little darker but other than that I think it's fine.
@@derpe4123 Noted👍🏻
Abuela isn’t that mean
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Gosh why is everyone making alma so mean
Pls Stop Being Rude To Abuela
I wasn’t being rude I was stating the truth. Abuela was an abusive person. Yes a person can still be abusive even if they are not aware of it. I do understand that she was a victim too and I will make a reaction video for her. As a matter of fact the third part is about her but for now she must realize her wrong doing specially since this is a PAST encanto reaction video
Please fix isa skin tone
It's fine wdym
I think it looks , normal
I dont like how u are making issabella here the wrong one they are all at problem im pretty sure you know that, This was annoying since isabella is who i kin in encanto i understand her problem and i relate to it, So its much annoying how u did this
But i still support your channel My reason about this video does not make a reasoning about me hating your channel.
@@allysar.3678 first thank you so much for being respectful about your opinion. I actually kin Isabella too! In the pin comment I explained the reason why Isabella might seem a little rude or OOC as some would say! And yes the whole family was a disaster. Don’t we all love a dysfunctional family with zero communication 😂🥲
@@silvermarl5015 ohh i see the pinned comment sorry i did not quite see it 😕 i thought it was just some announcements so i did not decide to read it sorry again ☹️ As a sorry for my mistake i would subscribe to you!
STOP TALKING MORE REACTING😡😡
Don't be rude.
Sorry I can’t do that. My videos are generally filled with many talking and interaction between characters cause I find that to be more engaging. Sorry
Isabela ily but if u think ur life is the worst let's break it down into pieces
1. You treated mirabel like a outcast only bc she lived free and that is not fair
2. Mirabel was bullied by abuela bc she had no gift you were treated like a queen bc u had one
3. If u were jealous then atleast speak up and tell abuela about ur feelings then u will live like mirabel (sorta)
4. You were perfect but mirabel was just a piece of trash and had no one to understand her pain even tho were her older sis u never decided to know ur sis and what she was going through
*think about that.*
Edit:no hate to the creator I was just a little anoyed that she was jealous even tho she had a perfect life