That's her voice. Though she has a lot of variety and basically can do anything with her pipes. The rasp is natural. She is just phenomenal in that she is a phenomenon to behold.
I don’t think she was suggesting electronic effects, but rather whether Haley is putting on a voice for the style, which she is at times. I assume Haley’s natural singing voice is found in “can’t help falling in love.” With that said, her classical voice styling is probably my favorite sound in singing.
this is the interpretation of the song - isn't it also the arrangement? Probably PMJ works with the singer to get these results. But yes this is how we know her voice.
@@mannygee005 In this particular instance, Haley had been singing the song in this manner before the collab with PMJ. They heard her version, and created instrumentation around it.
Haley is the real deal. She does play a lot with her sound, as any good jazz signer does. It's natural in the sense that she seems to use it without thinking. It just fits perfectly with PMJ sound.
Well... its intentional. Yes, after singing for years, a lot of it "comes naturally" but thats the result of over a decade of focused training of her natural talent. She is basically a professional voice coach who has natural ability so when she plans a song... much like a choreographer planning a dance.... she designs the entire song for its effect and uses her voice just as any musician would use their instrument. She is phenomenal.
this was done in 1 take......1.....Scott Bradley has "revolving" musicians and singers and his collaborations are BRILLIANT and magic to our ears.....Love your analysis!
@@joehohmann6015 It's a testament with the experience that Haley has on stage and with her voice mostly. She could do a 2nd take and it would have sounded very different, but just as incredible. I've never heard her sing the same song even remotely similar twice.
I watched countless reaction to her performance, but yours is the most in depth breakdown of her incredible technique I've heard so far, great reaction, thank you! Peace and love from Bavaria!
If you hear and see Hayley Reinhart's covers of "Don't Speak" by No Doubt or "Seven Nation Army" by the White Stripes you will see she is magical through and through. Greetings from The Netherlands.
I really loved that as a classically trained vocalist that you could still appreciate all of the rules that Haley bends in this masterpiece. Not everybody understands jazz. Well done! I really enjoyed your breakdown.
It's so great to see a performer react to another performer with no ego. Thank you for that. Thank you for loving what she did. As a performer I know how hard it is to do this and you did an amazing job. Liked and subbed. We have a tendency to pick apart and not love what is being done and you did a great job loving what she did. Kudos to you, you rock!
She, without doubt is the greatest jazz singer of her generation ( and probably quite a few before), her voice control is immaculate as are the nuances with which she sings.
No two ways about it Jordan is more than accomplished singer but she cannot do what Reinhardt does. There is a fascinating performance of Reinhardt performing with Jeff Goodbloom and tge Mildred Snitzer Orchestra and with the best will in the world Jordan couldn’t pull off a performance like that with any credibility even if her life depended on it. I have to confess to a little bias because if I’m honest while I recognise that Jordan is an extremely talented vocalist, I just don’t like her voice. This is obviously a subjective point of view and it’s’ different folks for different folks but even objectively Jordon lacks the colour palette and the growl that Reinhardt brings to the party.
@@supertuscans9512 We can also tell you haven't listen to all of Angelina's covers or original songs cause I'm very sure she can sing any style of music but like Haley both are great jazz singers ,I love both ladies as to which is better I couldn't say it's a mater of preference . And remember Angelina's only 17 her voice is still not fully developed.
I hear what you say and I can see that Jordan is a gifted vocalist but I can’t listen to much of her music because for me her voice induces a similar effect to fingers nails running down a blackboard. I’m not in any way suggesting she is a poor singer, she just happens to be one whose voice I can’t stand.
Great in depth reaction. Haley is from Chicago. Her parents had a rock band for over 40 years, where Haley got her feet wet from a young age. Her dad was her scatting teacher from a very young age. She’s self taught in yodeling and was already a lead jazz singer in her high school jazz band. Haley is just as versatile singing jazz, blues, rock and anything in between. Her favourite musical group are The Beatles. The sound you reacted to is her natural speaking voice. To appreciate Haley’s true raw vocal, please search for Haley with her dad on guitar at Chess Records in Chicago. Her rendition of Can’t Find My Way Home and an original song Don’t Know How To Love You, are masterful.
Haley Reinhart (Heavily influenced by Jazz & Soul genres) came in 3rd place on season 10 of American Idol. Haley's most popular PMJ songs; other than Creep, are: 🤯❤ Seven Nation Army - by White Stripes (New Orleans Dirge/Jazz Cover) ft. Haley Reinhart🔥 Don’t Speak - by No Doubt/Gwen Stefani (‘60s Style Cover) ft. Haley Reinhart🔥
What a reaction!!! I always listen to you carefully to learn new things... but this??? You outdid yourself! I was already subscribed (almost a year now), but between the song and your reaction, I am blown away. So... the song... I had never heard of her before I heard this the first time (months ago). I hear the 'official' version first. I was completely mesmerized. I think this particular performance is one of the best vocal and instrumental pieces EVER. Her vocals are stunning, and the band??? just wow! True artistry here, and you nailed ALL of it in your analysis. GREAT reaction!!
If you watch a few videos of Haley singing, it becomes obvious that she has total control over her instrument. Everything that she does is intentional and perfected for its purpose. She is one of the, if not the best of vocalists performing today. Simply amazing!
Just to add to the legacy of Haley, looking back on her time on American Idol, she was on two consecutive seasons, though she was didn't make it on the first time, and even though she placed well the second season, a couple of the judges were brutal on her. Still, she had some firsts on the show. Sang LeAnn Rhimes Blue, did a jazz duet with Casey Abrams, doing the first scatting on Idol, and having her dad play lead guitar on one of her performances. (She also fell during that performance!) While she got a boost from PMJ, she gave a boost to PMJ, and still is arguably the most popular vocalists ever to perform with them. While she has remained an independent artist, she does have a platinum release of an Elvis song, been a voice actor on a Bill Burr Netflix series been in a couple movies (one to be released on Dec 1 of this year) and has four albums covering different genres, plus been a guest artist with a few jazz bands. I guess I should have told you to go look at her wiki. Finally, there are singers, vocalists and vocalist with a tonal quality to touch the soul of your ears. Like for me, Floor Jansen is a vocal master of her instrument, and while I refuse to compare the technical merits of their mastery, Haley just has a tone that I find most pleasing. Both I love but if stuck on an island with access to just one's voice it would be Haley.
That’s Hailey alright 🫠 she did that in 1 take… on short notice… while she was sick! I absolutely LOVE watching people hear her for the first time lol I think I say “wait for it” about 10x each & every time 😏 She’s incredibly underrated.
Yeah that's her voice. She is one of those artists that you have to hear live. Without a doubt, one of the finest voice of a generation. If not of all time.
I remember asking for this in the comments as a masterclass after watching you for the very first time many moons ago! Hope you love it as much as I do! 💕
It's a shame you don't do streams so you can talk much more about such fabulous work as PMJ's and Haley's. It would be great to know many more details that I'm sure you've been able to notice throughout the times you've watched this video. Anyway, once again I reiterate that for me, your analysis are the best, so regardless of the surprises you may have in knowing different artists, any video of yours is very well received. By the way, in the live Franck the talked about The Warning, a band of three Mexican sisters of great quality. It would be interesting if you brought them to the channel, although you know that my favorite from that country is Juan Gabriel, and I would recommend the song Amor Eterno (if you do, don't forget to have the translation of the lyrics handy). A big hug, I look forward to your next video.
This performance is a master class in how an incredibly talented performer can demonstrate just about every type of vocal technique in one number and make it sound perfect.
I must have seen this video a hundred times now. It's just a masterpiece. She does this quick little nose twitch right before the final section that lets you know the Haley fireworks are about to get lit off.
Lmao, watching you struggle, knowing you need to pause it at some point, but you just can't stop, it's too good. until finally you hit the spacebar, but you do it with such disgust at the action, reeling your hand back afterwards like it was a hot stove. like you just had to force yourself to just get it over with... I imagine that's what addicts feel when trying to break free of their afflictions. Such a fascinating exposure of the mind in just over the course of the first two minutes.
I'm sooooo looking forward to this! I know how it's gonna go down cuz your face in the thumbnail says it all, and, well, because it's Haley, but damn, do I want to hear what you have to say about this performance. She was feeling under the weather and still nailed it.
Total control of her voice, she just has a switch, at her command, she can go from sweet to sultry and sexy to raspy to fry to distorted like it's nothing. She can belt, she can croon, she can whisper and she intertwines all these techniques like it's nothing, as effortless as breathing for her. The arrangement is beyond reproach as well. This is as good as it gets artistically.
Seriously the best contemporary female vocalist out there No autotone, just natural talent. I saw her live a few months ago and she was absolutely incredible.
This is her natural voice. The Fairy Voice Mother does a remarkable reaction/analysis with accurate demonstrations and explanations of the vocal techniques.
could be set in a 1950s jazz club, right? Scott Bradlee's arrangement is magic and Haley is, well, she's simply Haley......scotch and soda all around.......
It"s nice to see you enjoy one of these (as you did Morgan James/Dream On). Other Haley/PMJ collaborations that you may enjoy are Don't Speak and Seven Nation Army. One of my favorites is Habits. Thanks for you insights.
She is amazing and to me, perfection for what she does, she isninkynonenof a few to give me goosebumps every time I hear them signing and going all out. The be other two, Marko Hielta, and Floor Jansen. Tarja has, most times, but not everytime like those three do.
It is her. Try her version of "Lay it Down". a black and white version of just her and an organ player. She is very versatile but she really likes to jazz it up. Her covers with PMJ of "Black Hole Sun" or "Habits" is excellent. Good job picking her performance apart. I was surprised that you hadn't heard her before.
One of the best from PMJ is "All about that Bass" in which Reinhart is a third. Fantastic performance from all 3 ladies. Definitely worth a lesson for the vocals AND the instrumentals!
I have no experience with singing professionally, so I'm genuinely asking this. Do professional singers make these vocal decisions consciously during practicing sessions or are these things that are just internalized by training? Or are these things that are just innate when imagining a style or message?
I've heard the song before but it wasn't a favorite. If it came on the radio, I din't cjange the channel or lower the volume. I'm a fan of PMJ and I knew PMJ did a cover, but never watched it, so this is my first time watching and hearing their version. With that said, I don't know if this is an odd description, but it's what I was actually thinking as it sent shivers down my spine. It was hauntingly beautiful. I will definitely be listening to this again.
Thanks so much for your deep dive into Haley! She's one of my favorite PMJ vocalists. I'd love to see you react to more of her and PMJ. Either way, you won't be disappointed! :)
Nice commentary. I love to be away from all distractions when hearing this version of creep. The hair on the back of your arms suddenly gets to exercise, remind you they are there and stand tall!
The man "tickling the ivories" is Scott Bradlee. He is the genius behind the whole "Post Modern Jukebox" idea. He is the one who did the arrangement for the song that Hayley sang. The original song by Radiohead is much different from th8s version.
First. Great reaction. I appreciate the technical perspectives. Much appreciated. Second: Wow. I've never heard Ms. Reinhart or this song before. But holy freaking cow, what a voice.
Listen to Hayley sing "I can't help falling in love with you", just Hayley singing and Casey on the piano. I enjoyed your technical insights, just as I did with Elisabeth Zarhoff from "the Charismatic Voice", I for sure am going to search for your singing too Thank you
This is all Haley. You should watch her other vids. She has absolute control over her vibrato. It depends on the style she is singing. She is absolutely amazing.
Absolutely one of the top 2 or 3 performances I've seen on YT and probably my favorite to watch people react to. I didn't realize that you hadn't reacted to this one yet and was very excited when I saw it scheduled. Awesome job as always!!
That's Haley, If she were born 90 years ago we would still be talking about her legend. Biggest vocal tool kit out there. So many to hear. Master class in vocal techniques. Haley and PMJ; Lovefool, Blackhole sun, Seven Nation Army, Don't Speak, Her Live is the same, Crazy as it is. Her with Jeff Goldbloom and his group My Baby don't Care, Her original "I Don't know how to Love You" Is either a rock blues 60's version official video live at the radio station pure blues, or with the Impossible Project recording live to vinyl with a full Orchestra all versions are amazing. Oh ya, she can scat. 1 thing for sure, Oh, this is the 1 take mic drop while slightly ill video. Scott Bradlee, force behind PMJ, when Haley asked if they should do it again laughed and said nope! Great breakdown, loved the geek out.
Yep, She's that good. Saw Her and Morgan James up in NYC and after picking up my jaw off the floor...I realized This is special. I'm in awe of what the group of players of PMJ can do. And this is really saying something because I've played behind many great Musical Theater singers back in my hectic rush rush rush pit orchestra career. Very good through analysis from you too. Picking up nuances and greatness is sometimes not the easiest thing to do. There's just so much going on with many moving parts. ..Well you know.....*cheers*
Morgan James performing Dream on is another quality MV from PMJ. My favorite is All about the Bass with Haley, Morgan and an European singer. Great re arrangement.
I've loved Haley since her time in American Idol... still mad she didn't win. This is without a shadow of a doubt one of the best song covers out there. Right next to Johnny Cash's Version of "Hurt" and Disturbed's version of "Sound of Silence" Haley has done 3-4 more songs with Post Modern Jukebox and all are worthy of reviewing. "Seven Nation Army" is right up there for me as well
Haley is from Chicago. Both of her parents were in a band, and she hung out, traveled & sang with them from a young age. Yeah, Haley can bring out that rasp whenever she wants.😮 😏♥️🎙😎🤘Haley has her own U Tube channel & there is a fan channel called Haleys Tusk, which has a ton of live video of her from clubs all over the country. Here's a Haley original called " I Don't Know how to love you, " ❤ well worth a listen !
Take note of her inhales, once you focus on them you can’t unhear them, sucking in massive amounts of oxygen 👍Even her inhales are raspy, a vocal athlete
Wow - thanks for explaining the mystery of why this song is so frisson inducing!! Very fascinating. Reminded me of my classical piano lessons way back 35 years ago. hahaha.
I am sooooo enjoying your way of breaking down the details of the performance. I am a retired speech pathologist, so I love hearing about the connection between articulation and how the singer's sounds are perceived.
It's her voice, but she has vocal effects for days, which she is using a lot in this performance. She can quite literally do whatever she wants with her instrument.
could be set in a 1950s jazz club, right? Scott Bradlee's arrangement is magic and Haley is, well, she's simply Haley......scotch and soda all around........
Had American Idol had one vote per individual contestant, as opposed to almost unlimited power voting, Haley would have won American Idol in a land slide.
You could sure give the other reactor MAGGIE RENEE, quite a few pointers on how to dissect a song INTELLIGENTLY! She claims to be an Opera singer, and went to Julliard; Which i do question.
This is Haley's voice. This is a one take performance, no edits. She is amazing with PMJ, or just singing straight Jazz. She came 3rd on American Idol. She is from Wheeling, Illinois; and has the accent to prove it. Take water and snacks, this is a deep wabbit hole...Another PMJ, and solo singer to check out is Morgan James. Morgan is a Julliard trained opera singer, who sings blue eyed soul, and everything else, like crazy. Another cool Jazz voice is Rachel Price from the band "Lake Street Dive." She has a very cool groove.
"I'm curious to know what her accent is. I'm not sure where she's from." Haley counts Chicago as her hometown, but now resides in Los Angeles. She had a pronounced accent when she first appeared on American Idol, but is very polished when speaking now. Internet: The Chicago accent is famous for swapping out “th” with “d” (as in, “da Bears”). But a researcher told WBEZ Chicagoans also tend to elongate their vowels, transforming a word like “bat” into “b-eat-t,” and pronounce some “o” sounds like “a” - thus, Bob sounds like “Bahhhb.”
@@canopener6218 In this video from a performance at Hotel Cafe, Haley explains Mark Ballas and Dylan Chambers were poking fun at her accent: ruclips.net/video/pONoDTVenrE/видео.html ---- Haley on being cast in "F is for Family:" "That (Peanuts) audition was floating around and these guys heard it. I guess the fact that they were looking for someone from big cities and I have sort of a Chicago slang a bit, it came off in a good way for them ... and it was supposed to take place in Chicago in the 70s." ---- Idol: Haley approaching judges to see if she has made the live shows: "Hi guys. Hello again. How are ya-s?" "In Chicago, instead of simply saying 'you' to refer to a group, you often year people saying 'yous'." ---- Haley addressing a crowd at a corporate gig this year: ruclips.net/video/eCtqT0V7dNI/видео.html
Please react to her cover of “I put a spell on you” live !!!! She has such amazing musicality and musical intuition. Can switch from growls, to clear belts instantly and not forced. One of the best singers out today, but unfortunately chooses to remain an independent artist so she isn’t very well known. Her live performances are the best, but her studio recording aren’t great (not sure why, but she only sounds good live 😅)
Just found your channel in those little news boxes when you open google... I love PMJ and Haley… now, I would love❤ to see YOU making a collaboration WITH THEM … haven’t heard you singing yet, but I guess will be brilliant… curve is in.. now let the magic begins…
She has her own band. PMJ brings her in to sing certain songs like this one. If you liked that you would love, 7 NATIONS ARMY and ALL ABOUT THE BASS. They even have fun with the bass in ALL ABOUT THAT BASS.
Another female vocalist who knows how to play with her voice and also is very expressive physically check out chinchilla singing "fingers". The one with only a piano backing. That's the one to watch. Fair warning, chinchilla brings a whole different vibe than haley. Chinchilla is truly, I mean truly, unique
PMJ/Haley Seven Nation Army is a must. As is PMJ/Morgan James 'Dream On' (Aerosmith cover) is good to see another AMAZING cover from PMJ but with another outstanding singer.
You should check out her own RUclips channel to listen to her own music, she has made several albums on her own. My favorites are “Shook”, “Lay it Down”, and “Deep Water” off of her Lo-Fi Soul album. Her cover of Elvis’ “Can’t Help Falling in Love” is spectacular and was picked up by Extra Gum for one of their ad campaigns. She also does a great cover with another PMJ Alum Morgan James when they sing Dear Prudence with just Morgan’s husband playing acoustic guitar (it’s on Morgan’s RUclips channel)
Heh - I knew you'd freak out over this one as soon as I saw the thumbnail. Good analysis, nicely done.👍 Here's a singer I think you'd find really interesting. She can do everything from soft ballads to the hardest rock and has even sung on stage with Pavarotti! Band: Skunk Anansie Singer: Skin Song: Brazen (Weep) Video title: Skunk Anansie - Brazen (Weep) (live at Nulle Part Ailleurs) Link: ruclips.net/video/F9ZmkDQQ5p4/видео.html
do the Morgan James cover of "Come Together"! I guess you´ll love it! Or "take me to Church". or a beautiful duet: Tennessee Whiskey by PMJ/Ryan Quinn, Jennie Lena
Well! I was quite surprised you being an Opera Singer I thought you were going to give Haley a👎but I was very wrong, I've liked most everything she's done since America Has Talent show years ago, I also like the way she does "Baby It's You "you might want to lessen to that one.💯🤔
Like so many others ,this video sent down the rabbit hole of PMJ. Except its not a rabbit hole. It is a humongous cavern of the most amazing re imaginations of songs. There are so many that get recommended for these reaction videos. But dig deep and you will find the most incredible cover of Prince's Purple Rain( and I think everyone knows how Prince feels about covers of his music). There is also an audition video of a 15 year old Sarah Baran,not 100% sure on that name, who was going to do the Creep video originally. Also fantastic.
This is an *awesome* performance, but I am surprised to see that you haven't reacted to PMJ's All About that Bass with both Haley, AND Morgan James, PLUS the daughter of actor Telly Sevalas. I love Morgan's solo in that, but the whole video is great, including the surprise with the bass.
PMJ was on its first European tour, On a day off, they recorded "Creep" with Haley and a couple of other songs including "All About That Base." Haley wasn't ill, but expressed she thought she might need vocal rest since they were still on tour. Scott Bradlee believed they could nail it on a single try, so she agreed to give it a go. This was a good call. Haley's "Creep" with PMJ is the channel's most-viewed video and the group version of AATB they recorded is the second-most viewed video.
You should definitely watch their cover of Seven Nation Army or I Can't Help Falling In Love With You, or her live on tour version of I Put A Spell On You!!! She is just INCREDIBLE!! Been watching her here and there for many years!!
Look up PMJ Tour schedule. Its worth a day’s travel. 6-8 singers rotating all night. W a tap dancer in the spirit of a 30s traveling show. Some of purest music ive ever heard at a show. 😊 really, dont miss it
Been bugging you for a year or two to react to Haley's Creep. :) Felt certain that you would LOVE it. And what a fantastic and wonderfully detailed analysis! Best Haley reaction yet! Her versions of ''Oops I Did it Again'' and ''Habits'' are brilliant. And her performance with Jeff Goldblum's jazz group is fun - ''My Baby Just Cares for Me''
That's her voice. Though she has a lot of variety and basically can do anything with her pipes. The rasp is natural. She is just phenomenal in that she is a phenomenon to behold.
I don’t think she was suggesting electronic effects, but rather whether Haley is putting on a voice for the style, which she is at times.
I assume Haley’s natural singing voice is found in “can’t help falling in love.”
With that said, her classical voice styling is probably my favorite sound in singing.
It's her voice, but you don't get to control it like she does without a *lot* of work on it.
this is the interpretation of the song - isn't it also the arrangement? Probably PMJ works with the singer to get these results. But yes this is how we know her voice.
@@mannygee005 In this particular instance, Haley had been singing the song in this manner before the collab with PMJ. They heard her version, and created instrumentation around it.
This was performed in one take!!
Haley is the real deal. She does play a lot with her sound, as any good jazz signer does. It's natural in the sense that she seems to use it without thinking. It just fits perfectly with PMJ sound.
I agree!
Well... its intentional. Yes, after singing for years, a lot of it "comes naturally" but thats the result of over a decade of focused training of her natural talent.
She is basically a professional voice coach who has natural ability so when she plans a song... much like a choreographer planning a dance.... she designs the entire song for its effect and uses her voice just as any musician would use their instrument.
She is phenomenal.
@@chandie5298 she was singing before she talked - her dad got her singing that early. and the rest is herstory!
this was done in 1 take......1.....Scott Bradley has "revolving" musicians and singers and his collaborations are BRILLIANT and magic to our ears.....Love your analysis!
1 Take ??? Wow...didn't know that. That's a testament to the artists who performed this piece.
@@joehohmann6015 It's a testament with the experience that Haley has on stage and with her voice mostly. She could do a 2nd take and it would have sounded very different, but just as incredible. I've never heard her sing the same song even remotely similar twice.
I watched countless reaction to her performance, but yours is the most in depth breakdown of her incredible technique I've heard so far, great reaction, thank you! Peace and love from Bavaria!
Thank you!
Tara Simon is also one of the best reactors, try her too.
@@jessicasopranonotesHi, beautiful woman! Do you remember Diana Ankudinova?
😊😊 I 💯 👍🏼 agree
You get the most information out of Fairy voice godmother, Julia nilon , and the charismatic voice. Jessica soprano notes is up there with them.
If you hear and see Hayley Reinhart's covers of "Don't Speak" by No Doubt or "Seven Nation Army" by the White Stripes you will see she is magical through and through. Greetings from The Netherlands.
Her cover of the Tove Lo's music os awesome too
Also from American Idol her singing Benny and the Jets
I really loved that as a classically trained vocalist that you could still appreciate all of the rules that Haley bends in this masterpiece. Not everybody understands jazz. Well done! I really enjoyed your breakdown.
It's so great to see a performer react to another performer with no ego. Thank you for that. Thank you for loving what she did. As a performer I know how hard it is to do this and you did an amazing job. Liked and subbed. We have a tendency to pick apart and not love what is being done and you did a great job loving what she did. Kudos to you, you rock!
She, without doubt is the greatest jazz singer of her generation ( and probably quite a few before), her voice control is immaculate as are the nuances with which she sings.
Angelina Jordan is of a newer generation, yet is the best current jazz singer. And, I love Haley - and Yebba, as well.
No two ways about it Jordan is more than accomplished singer but she cannot do what Reinhardt does. There is a fascinating performance of Reinhardt performing with Jeff Goodbloom and tge Mildred Snitzer Orchestra and with the best will in the world Jordan couldn’t pull off a performance like that with any credibility even if her life depended on it.
I have to confess to a little bias because if I’m honest while I recognise that Jordan is an extremely talented vocalist, I just don’t like her voice. This is obviously a subjective point of view and it’s’ different folks for different folks but even objectively Jordon lacks the colour palette and the growl that Reinhardt brings to the party.
@@supertuscans9512 We can also tell you haven't listen to all of Angelina's covers or original songs cause I'm very sure she can sing any style of music but like Haley both are great jazz singers ,I love both ladies as to which is better I couldn't say it's a mater of preference . And remember Angelina's only 17 her voice is still not fully developed.
I hear what you say and I can see that Jordan is a gifted vocalist but I can’t listen to much of her music because for me her voice induces a similar effect to fingers nails running down a blackboard. I’m not in any way suggesting she is a poor singer, she just happens to be one whose voice I can’t stand.
That's a bold statement considering Samara Joy exists lol.
Great in depth reaction.
Haley is from Chicago. Her parents had a rock band for over 40 years, where Haley got her feet wet from a young age.
Her dad was her scatting teacher from a very young age. She’s self taught in yodeling and was already a lead jazz singer in her high school jazz band.
Haley is just as versatile singing jazz, blues, rock and anything in between.
Her favourite musical group are The Beatles.
The sound you reacted to is her natural speaking voice.
To appreciate Haley’s true raw vocal, please search for Haley with her dad on guitar at Chess Records in Chicago. Her rendition of Can’t Find My Way Home and an original song Don’t Know How To Love You, are masterful.
As perfectly and beautifully explained as the sweet tracks you suggested of her and her dad, doing what they do best, making great music!!
@@sunshynffprobably my favourite Haley video. Live, raw and natural.
Wheeling Illinois finest! She's in the land of "Da Bears" and can sing like Etta James
Haley Reinhart (Heavily influenced by Jazz & Soul genres) came in 3rd place on season 10 of American Idol. Haley's most popular PMJ songs; other than Creep, are: 🤯❤
Seven Nation Army - by White Stripes (New Orleans Dirge/Jazz Cover) ft. Haley Reinhart🔥
Don’t Speak - by No Doubt/Gwen Stefani (‘60s Style Cover) ft. Haley Reinhart🔥
What a reaction!!! I always listen to you carefully to learn new things... but this??? You outdid yourself! I was already subscribed (almost a year now), but between the song and your reaction, I am blown away. So... the song... I had never heard of her before I heard this the first time (months ago). I hear the 'official' version first. I was completely mesmerized. I think this particular performance is one of the best vocal and instrumental pieces EVER. Her vocals are stunning, and the band??? just wow! True artistry here, and you nailed ALL of it in your analysis. GREAT reaction!!
If you watch a few videos of Haley singing, it becomes obvious that she has total control over her instrument. Everything that she does is intentional and perfected for its purpose. She is one of the, if not the best of vocalists performing today. Simply amazing!
Just to add to the legacy of Haley, looking back on her time on American Idol, she was on two consecutive seasons, though she was didn't make it on the first time, and even though she placed well the second season, a couple of the judges were brutal on her. Still, she had some firsts on the show. Sang LeAnn Rhimes Blue, did a jazz duet with Casey Abrams, doing the first scatting on Idol, and having her dad play lead guitar on one of her performances. (She also fell during that performance!) While she got a boost from PMJ, she gave a boost to PMJ, and still is arguably the most popular vocalists ever to perform with them. While she has remained an independent artist, she does have a platinum release of an Elvis song, been a voice actor on a Bill Burr Netflix series been in a couple movies (one to be released on Dec 1 of this year) and has four albums covering different genres, plus been a guest artist with a few jazz bands. I guess I should have told you to go look at her wiki.
Finally, there are singers, vocalists and vocalist with a tonal quality to touch the soul of your ears. Like for me, Floor Jansen is a vocal master of her instrument, and while I refuse to compare the technical merits of their mastery, Haley just has a tone that I find most pleasing. Both I love but if stuck on an island with access to just one's voice it would be Haley.
That’s Hailey alright 🫠 she did that in 1 take… on short notice… while she was sick!
I absolutely LOVE watching people hear her for the first time lol I think I say “wait for it” about 10x each & every time 😏 She’s incredibly underrated.
Yeah that's her voice. She is one of those artists that you have to hear live. Without a doubt, one of the finest voice of a generation. If not of all time.
I remember asking for this in the comments as a masterclass after watching you for the very first time many moons ago! Hope you love it as much as I do! 💕
I loved it!
It's a shame you don't do streams so you can talk much more about such fabulous work as PMJ's and Haley's. It would be great to know many more details that I'm sure you've been able to notice throughout the times you've watched this video. Anyway, once again I reiterate that for me, your analysis are the best, so regardless of the surprises you may have in knowing different artists, any video of yours is very well received.
By the way, in the live Franck the talked about The Warning, a band of three Mexican sisters of great quality. It would be interesting if you brought them to the channel, although you know that my favorite from that country is Juan Gabriel, and I would recommend the song Amor Eterno (if you do, don't forget to have the translation of the lyrics handy).
A big hug, I look forward to your next video.
This performance is a master class in how an incredibly talented performer can demonstrate just about every type of vocal technique in one number and make it sound perfect.
I must have seen this video a hundred times now. It's just a masterpiece. She does this quick little nose twitch right before the final section that lets you know the Haley fireworks are about to get lit off.
If you really want to see how sultry she can sing, you should check out her (also with PMJ) version of The White Stripes' "Seven Nation Army".
Lmao, watching you struggle, knowing you need to pause it at some point, but you just can't stop, it's too good. until finally you hit the spacebar, but you do it with such disgust at the action, reeling your hand back afterwards like it was a hot stove. like you just had to force yourself to just get it over with...
I imagine that's what addicts feel when trying to break free of their afflictions. Such a fascinating exposure of the mind in just over the course of the first two minutes.
Haley is on tour!! Seeing her on the 15th!!! She's a tremendous and unique talent. ! Thanks for this outstanding reaction!!! Loved it!❤
Wow, I hope you have an amazing time!
I’m seeing her tonight and I’m SO EXCITED. I’ve never gotten to see her in person before and I can’t wait
I'm sooooo looking forward to this! I know how it's gonna go down cuz your face in the thumbnail says it all, and, well, because it's Haley, but damn, do I want to hear what you have to say about this performance. She was feeling under the weather and still nailed it.
Total control of her voice, she just has a switch, at her command, she can go from sweet to sultry and sexy to raspy to fry to distorted like it's nothing. She can belt, she can croon, she can whisper and she intertwines all these techniques like it's nothing, as effortless as breathing for her. The arrangement is beyond reproach as well. This is as good as it gets artistically.
Yep, that’s her voice. Stunning. Haley has her own alphabet consisting of 26 vowels 😎
Seriously the best contemporary female vocalist out there No autotone, just natural talent. I saw her live a few months ago and she was absolutely incredible.
She is from Illinois. Her mom sings, her dad plays guitar. She has one of the most stylized voices ever. Lots of jazz and blues influences.
This is her natural voice.
The Fairy Voice Mother
does a remarkable reaction/analysis with accurate demonstrations and explanations of the vocal techniques.
could be set in a 1950s jazz club, right? Scott Bradlee's arrangement is magic and Haley is, well, she's simply Haley......scotch and soda all around.......
It"s nice to see you enjoy one of these (as you did Morgan James/Dream On). Other Haley/PMJ collaborations that you may enjoy are Don't Speak and Seven Nation Army. One of my favorites is Habits.
Thanks for you insights.
If you want a real wild one- Ella Fitzgerald meets Billie Holliday meets Jessica Rabbit....Haley/PMJ doing 7 Nation Army. Woah...
check this pairing up when they do White Stripes; 7 Nation Army. You won't be disappointed. It's sultry and amazing!
She is amazing and to me, perfection for what she does, she isninkynonenof a few to give me goosebumps every time I hear them signing and going all out. The be other two, Marko Hielta, and Floor Jansen. Tarja has, most times, but not everytime like those three do.
It is her. Try her version of "Lay it Down". a black and white version of just her and an organ player. She is very versatile but she really likes to jazz it up. Her covers with PMJ of "Black Hole Sun" or "Habits" is excellent. Good job picking her performance apart. I was surprised that you hadn't heard her before.
Huge props for acknowledging the arrangement here. PMJ arrangements are almost always incredible and this one is no exception.
One of the best from PMJ is "All about that Bass" in which Reinhart is a third.
Fantastic performance from all 3 ladies. Definitely worth a lesson for the vocals AND the instrumentals!
I have no experience with singing professionally, so I'm genuinely asking this. Do professional singers make these vocal decisions consciously during practicing sessions or are these things that are just internalized by training? Or are these things that are just innate when imagining a style or message?
Fun and insightful reaction. You have a great smile. I didn't read all the comments but just in case you should know this was done in 1 take.
I've heard the song before but it wasn't a favorite. If it came on the radio, I din't cjange the channel or lower the volume. I'm a fan of PMJ and I knew PMJ did a cover, but never watched it, so this is my first time watching and hearing their version. With that said, I don't know if this is an odd description, but it's what I was actually thinking as it sent shivers down my spine. It was hauntingly beautiful. I will definitely be listening to this again.
Thanks so much for your deep dive into Haley! She's one of my favorite PMJ vocalists. I'd love to see you react to more of her and PMJ. Either way, you won't be disappointed! :)
Been in love with Hailey for years. Thats her voice. She is literally Jessica Rabbit in the flesh.
Nice commentary. I love to be away from all distractions when hearing this version of creep. The hair on the back of your arms suddenly gets to exercise, remind you they are there and stand tall!
Haley control every vocal color at you ever effortlessy and tastefully. There's a reason why this has 120 million views, because Haley is special
The man "tickling the ivories" is Scott Bradlee. He is the genius behind the whole "Post Modern Jukebox" idea. He is the one who did the arrangement for the song that Hayley sang. The original song by Radiohead is much different from th8s version.
I've been waiting for you to find Haley for almost two years! You didn't disappoint! Love your reactions.
First. Great reaction. I appreciate the technical perspectives. Much appreciated.
Second: Wow. I've never heard Ms. Reinhart or this song before. But holy freaking cow, what a voice.
Check PMJ with Haley Reinhart - Habits. ❤️
Amazing. Sounds like she went through a singing techniques glossary and used it as a checklist. She was doing so many things, it was incredible.
Listen to Hayley sing "I can't help falling in love with you", just Hayley singing and Casey on the piano.
I enjoyed your technical insights, just as I did with Elisabeth Zarhoff from "the Charismatic Voice", I for sure am going to search for your singing too
Thank you
Nah, the sound quality on that video sucks in comparison to the Extra Gum music Video.
Please do haley reinhardt post modern juke box seven nation army it will blow your mind
No question: If that were an aria in a modern opera, it would bring down the house.
I saw her on American Idol, and I was shocked she didn't win!!!
Lovely reaction and picked apart!
Paolo Nutini - Iron Sky (live from Abbey Road) would be tremendous!
This is all Haley. You should watch her other vids. She has absolute control over her vibrato. It depends on the style she is singing. She is absolutely amazing.
Their/her take on No Doubt’s “Don’t Speak” is a bit more current and equally if not more impressive.
Absolutely one of the top 2 or 3 performances I've seen on YT and probably my favorite to watch people react to. I didn't realize that you hadn't reacted to this one yet and was very excited when I saw it scheduled. Awesome job as always!!
That's all her. No manipulation.
This is her. She has a very husky speaking voice, and a generally sultry, Jessica Rabbitesque way about her.
Wow, I can't wait
That's Haley, If she were born 90 years ago we would still be talking about her legend. Biggest vocal tool kit out there. So many to hear. Master class in vocal techniques. Haley and PMJ; Lovefool, Blackhole sun, Seven Nation Army, Don't Speak, Her Live is the same, Crazy as it is. Her with Jeff Goldbloom and his group My Baby don't Care, Her original "I Don't know how to Love You" Is either a rock blues 60's version official video live at the radio station pure blues, or with the Impossible Project recording live to vinyl with a full Orchestra all versions are amazing. Oh ya, she can scat. 1 thing for sure, Oh, this is the 1 take mic drop while slightly ill video. Scott Bradlee, force behind PMJ, when Haley asked if they should do it again laughed and said nope! Great breakdown, loved the geek out.
Yep, She's that good. Saw Her and Morgan James up in NYC and after picking up my jaw off the floor...I realized This is special. I'm in awe of what the group of players of PMJ can do. And this is really saying something because I've played behind many great Musical Theater singers back in my hectic rush rush rush pit orchestra career. Very good through analysis from you too. Picking up nuances and greatness is sometimes not the easiest thing to do. There's just so much going on with many moving parts.
..Well you know.....*cheers*
Morgan James performing Dream on is another quality MV from PMJ. My favorite is All about the Bass with Haley, Morgan and an European singer. Great re arrangement.
I've loved Haley since her time in American Idol... still mad she didn't win. This is without a shadow of a doubt one of the best song covers out there. Right next to Johnny Cash's Version of "Hurt" and Disturbed's version of "Sound of Silence" Haley has done 3-4 more songs with Post Modern Jukebox and all are worthy of reviewing. "Seven Nation Army" is right up there for me as well
Haley is from Chicago. Both of her parents were in a band, and she hung out, traveled & sang with them from a young age. Yeah, Haley can bring out that rasp whenever she wants.😮
😏♥️🎙😎🤘Haley has her own U Tube channel & there is a fan channel called Haleys Tusk, which has a ton of live video of her from clubs all over the country. Here's a Haley original called " I Don't Know how to love you, " ❤ well worth a listen !
You need to hear her sing Dont Speak....Seven Nation Army....Black Hole Sun....All About That Bass....all with Post Modern Jukebox......fantastic!
Fun fact: the PMJ video has captions. Go watch it with captions on and you will wholeheartedly agree with what it has to say about her scatting.
Take note of her inhales, once you focus on them you can’t unhear them, sucking in massive amounts of oxygen 👍Even her inhales are raspy, a vocal athlete
Wow - thanks for explaining the mystery of why this song is so frisson inducing!! Very fascinating. Reminded me of my classical piano lessons way back 35 years ago. hahaha.
I am sooooo enjoying your way of breaking down the details of the performance. I am a retired speech pathologist, so I love hearing about the connection between articulation and how the singer's sounds are perceived.
Oh, interesting! I’m sure your thoughts on performances and articulation would be particularly interesting!
It's her voice, but she has vocal effects for days, which she is using a lot in this performance. She can quite literally do whatever she wants with her instrument.
could be set in a 1950s jazz club, right? Scott Bradlee's arrangement is magic and Haley is, well, she's simply Haley......scotch and soda all around........
Shame on you American idol, Haley was clearly the winner
Had American Idol had one vote per individual contestant, as opposed to almost unlimited power voting, Haley would have won American Idol in a land slide.
You could sure give the other reactor MAGGIE RENEE, quite a few pointers on how to dissect a song INTELLIGENTLY! She claims to be an Opera singer, and went to Julliard; Which i do question.
This is Haley's voice. This is a one take performance, no edits. She is amazing with PMJ, or just singing straight Jazz. She came 3rd on American Idol. She is from Wheeling, Illinois; and has the accent to prove it. Take water and snacks, this is a deep wabbit hole...Another PMJ, and solo singer to check out is Morgan James. Morgan is a Julliard trained opera singer, who sings blue eyed soul, and everything else, like crazy.
Another cool Jazz voice is Rachel Price from the band "Lake Street Dive." She has a very cool groove.
"I'm curious to know what her accent is. I'm not sure where she's from."
Haley counts Chicago as her hometown, but now resides in Los Angeles. She had a pronounced accent when she first appeared on American Idol, but is very polished when speaking now.
Internet:
The Chicago accent is famous for swapping out “th” with “d” (as in, “da Bears”). But a researcher told WBEZ Chicagoans also tend to elongate their vowels, transforming a word like “bat” into “b-eat-t,” and pronounce some “o” sounds like “a” - thus, Bob sounds like “Bahhhb.”
Haley's accent from American Idol to today hasn't chanted one iota.
@@canopener6218 In this video from a performance at Hotel Cafe, Haley explains Mark Ballas and Dylan Chambers were poking fun at her accent: ruclips.net/video/pONoDTVenrE/видео.html
----
Haley on being cast in "F is for Family:"
"That (Peanuts) audition was floating around and these guys heard it. I guess the fact that they were looking for someone from big cities and I have sort of a Chicago slang a bit, it came off in a good way for them ... and it was supposed to take place in Chicago in the 70s."
----
Idol: Haley approaching judges to see if she has made the live shows:
"Hi guys. Hello again. How are ya-s?"
"In Chicago, instead of simply saying 'you' to refer to a group, you often year people saying 'yous'."
----
Haley addressing a crowd at a corporate gig this year: ruclips.net/video/eCtqT0V7dNI/видео.html
@@vidpie Like I said, wingnut, Haley's accent hasn't changed one iota since her American Idol days.
Te aconsejo TI AMO COSI: Lara Fabián, Dimash, Aida Garifullina y Igor krutoy!!! 👏👏👏👏 bravoooo
Please react to her cover of “I put a spell on you” live !!!! She has such amazing musicality and musical intuition. Can switch from growls, to clear belts instantly and not forced. One of the best singers out today, but unfortunately chooses to remain an independent artist so she isn’t very well known. Her live performances are the best, but her studio recording aren’t great (not sure why, but she only sounds good live 😅)
Just found your channel in those little news boxes when you open google... I love PMJ and Haley… now, I would love❤ to see YOU making a collaboration WITH THEM … haven’t heard you singing yet, but I guess will be brilliant… curve is in.. now let the magic begins…
What a sweet comment, thank you!
Great, great reaction! :-)
You really should check out PMJ's version of ALL ABOUT THAT BASS. 🙃
She has her own band. PMJ brings her in to sing certain songs like this one. If you liked that you would love, 7 NATIONS ARMY and ALL ABOUT THE BASS. They even have fun with the bass in ALL ABOUT THAT BASS.
Another female vocalist who knows how to play with her voice and also is very expressive physically check out chinchilla singing "fingers". The one with only a piano backing. That's the one to watch.
Fair warning, chinchilla brings a whole different vibe than haley. Chinchilla is truly, I mean truly, unique
PMJ/Haley Seven Nation Army is a must. As is PMJ/Morgan James 'Dream On' (Aerosmith cover) is good to see another AMAZING cover from PMJ but with another outstanding singer.
You should check out her own RUclips channel to listen to her own music, she has made several albums on her own. My favorites are “Shook”, “Lay it Down”, and “Deep Water” off of her Lo-Fi Soul album. Her cover of Elvis’ “Can’t Help Falling in Love” is spectacular and was picked up by Extra Gum for one of their ad campaigns. She also does a great cover with another PMJ Alum Morgan James when they sing Dear Prudence with just Morgan’s husband playing acoustic guitar (it’s on Morgan’s RUclips channel)
Heh - I knew you'd freak out over this one as soon as I saw the thumbnail. Good analysis, nicely done.👍
Here's a singer I think you'd find really interesting. She can do everything from soft ballads to the hardest rock and has even sung on stage with Pavarotti!
Band: Skunk Anansie
Singer: Skin
Song: Brazen (Weep)
Video title: Skunk Anansie - Brazen (Weep) (live at Nulle Part Ailleurs)
Link: ruclips.net/video/F9ZmkDQQ5p4/видео.html
You're picked the very best version and legend tells, she was NOT healthy that day and was NOT happy with her performance... Can U Imagine 😮
Somebody needs to send this woman a cushion with the letter "R" embroidered on it. Then she can sit on that letter to her heart's content!
React to her version of, “I Can’t Help Falling In Love With You.” The performance music video that’s shot in black and white. It’s phenomenal
Haley can sing anything & any style. She is also very improvisational & never sings ANYTHING the same way twice including Creep...
I love your analysis! Just subscribed. :D See Haley's "Seven Nation Army". You'll LOVE it!
do the Morgan James cover of "Come Together"! I guess you´ll love it! Or "take me to Church".
or a beautiful duet: Tennessee Whiskey by PMJ/Ryan Quinn, Jennie Lena
Well! I was quite surprised you being an Opera Singer I thought you were going to give Haley a👎but I was very wrong, I've liked most everything she's done since America Has Talent show years ago, I also like the way she does "Baby It's You "you might want to lessen to that one.💯🤔
You are fantastic. I smile every time I watch your react. Paece and Love to You and to Yours.
Like so many others ,this video sent down the rabbit hole of PMJ. Except its not a rabbit hole. It is a humongous cavern of the most amazing re imaginations of songs.
There are so many that get recommended for these reaction videos.
But dig deep and you will find the most incredible cover of Prince's Purple Rain( and I think everyone knows how Prince feels about covers of his music).
There is also an audition video of a 15 year old Sarah Baran,not 100% sure on that name, who was going to do the Creep video originally. Also fantastic.
This is an *awesome* performance, but I am surprised to see that you haven't reacted to PMJ's All About that Bass with both Haley, AND Morgan James, PLUS the daughter of actor Telly Sevalas. I love Morgan's solo in that, but the whole video is great, including the surprise with the bass.
Please, see and listen to this, it is unbelievable. A lot to analyze: "The Good, the Bad and the Ugly - The Danish National Symphony Orchestra (Live)"
apparently she was ill that day so she did one take and went home crazy
PMJ was on its first European tour, On a day off, they recorded "Creep" with Haley and a couple of other songs including "All About That Base." Haley wasn't ill, but expressed she thought she might need vocal rest since they were still on tour. Scott Bradlee believed they could nail it on a single try, so she agreed to give it a go. This was a good call. Haley's "Creep" with PMJ is the channel's most-viewed video and the group version of AATB they recorded is the second-most viewed video.
You should definitely watch their cover of Seven Nation Army or I Can't Help Falling In Love With You, or her live on tour version of I Put A Spell On You!!! She is just INCREDIBLE!! Been watching her here and there for many years!!
Look up PMJ Tour schedule. Its worth a day’s travel. 6-8 singers rotating all night. W a tap dancer in the spirit of a 30s traveling show. Some of purest music ive ever heard at a show. 😊 really, dont miss it
Been bugging you for a year or two to react to Haley's Creep. :) Felt certain that you would LOVE it. And what a fantastic and wonderfully detailed analysis! Best Haley reaction yet! Her versions of ''Oops I Did it Again'' and ''Habits'' are brilliant. And her performance with Jeff Goldblum's jazz group is fun - ''My Baby Just Cares for Me''