First time hearing of Jackie Evancho and her ANGELIC version of Pie Jesu (Reaction!)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 3 дек 2024

Комментарии • 120

  • @joseluischaconpainemal7943
    @joseluischaconpainemal7943 11 месяцев назад +9

    She,s a gift for our souls...
    I Discovery her some years ago.
    And i was really impacted, emotioned, and happy that an angel lives between us.....greetings from chile. Jackie is very special. She was only ten years when she made that show with the super producer David Foster .

    • @teddytarp
      @teddytarp 7 месяцев назад

      No, that was AGT. DF joined the magic a few months later and put together her first DVD, "Dream with Me".

  • @jill-go7gd
    @jill-go7gd 7 месяцев назад +9

    I have never heard anyone that could hold a candle to Jackie

  • @joycook3093
    @joycook3093 Год назад +17

    Her voice still raises the hair on my arms!!! So pure and true. Thank you for playing this!!

  • @teddytarp
    @teddytarp 7 месяцев назад +5

    I managed to attend 13 of Jackie's concerts. Six were in rows 1 or 2. I sat with people who had attended over 80 of her concerts. Now that's a bunch of loyal fans

  • @davidvanriper60
    @davidvanriper60 Год назад +18

    Saw her live when she was 13!
    I was in the nose bleed section, so could watch the whole crowd. Concert ended precisely at 9:30 because of her young age....
    However, after a 3 minute standing ovation and not a soul leaving, Jackie returned with an encore.
    Then a second standing "O"...still no one left.
    She returned with a second encore.
    A final standing ovation, lasted at least 2 minutes...and finally people began drifting out.
    A mesmerizing performance by an angelic singer.

    • @rehoboth2721
      @rehoboth2721 Год назад +2

      Ohh.........great story!

    • @garyfranson1353
      @garyfranson1353 Год назад +2

      Sure wish I had been there. Have only heard her on RUclips and tv shows. Must be magic in person.

  • @dagnard5707
    @dagnard5707 Год назад +14

    love how you were talking and immediately stopped as soon as she sang the first note

    • @teddytarp
      @teddytarp Год назад +1

      I used to take Jackie's DVD's to nursing homes. An activities director came up to me after a show and said "There are people here who haven't responded to a single thing all day and now they're applauding!!!!!"

  • @ZATennisFan
    @ZATennisFan Год назад +11

    This is an example of being born with a talent and a gift. You cannot get that good at 11 yrs old just by practice. You have to be born with something

  • @gebendeavors907
    @gebendeavors907 Год назад +8

    Jackie Evancho is a 23-year old American classical crossover singer. In 2010, as a 10-year old, Jackie came to fame when she came in second on America's Got Talent. At 11-years old, she was the youngest solo singer to ever have a concert at Lincoln Center (held at the Avery Fisher Hall). She is the youngest solo artist to ever go Platinum on an album in the US at 10-years old and the youngest to ever debut in the top 10 in the Billboard 200 (twice Jackie was #2 with the artist who just beat her the second time being Eminem). At 9-years old Jackie self-released the album Prelude To A Dream that peaked at #2 on the Billboard Classical Charts. The next 8 studio albums all peaked at #1 on the Billboard Classical Charts meaning that only Jay-Z, Eminem, Kanye West, Taylor Swift and The Beatles have had more consecutive Billboard #1 albums in a row. In 2011, when Jackie was 11-years old, Billboard ranked her as the #1 Classical Albums Artist of the year. In addition to the 9 studio albums, Jackie has 3 live albums, 13 music videos, and 35 singles. She has had 3 solo PBS concert specials (her first in 2011, Dream With Me In Concert, was the most broadcast program of the year for PBS and raised record amounts of money for PBS stations). When 11-years old, Jackie was chosen by Robert Redford to play his daughter in his film The Company You Keep. Jackie has sung (and in some cases recorded) with many famous singers including Dmitry Hvorostovsky, Sumi Jo, José Carreras, Andrea Bocelli, Tony Bennett and ‎Sarah Brightman. Sixteen-time Grammy winner David Foster has produced several things for her. She was Kity on season 3 of The Masked Singer, placing fifth. She has been on way too many to note TV shows. Jackie has signed record deals with SYCO Music, Columbia Records, Sony, Sony Masterworks, Portrait and now Melody Place. She also has her own label, JE Touring. And on, and on, and on. A tiny sampling of the videos of Jackie's performances include:
    ---- Dark Waltz (as a 10-year old. Sung on her Dream With Me In Concert: ruclips.net/video/dLxwAO3dDTw/видео.html)
    ---- Se (as a 12-year old. Sung on her PBS Special Music Of The Movies with full symphony orchestra. This song is from the great Italian film Cinema Paradiso and is many times known by the same name. Cinema Paradiso won both the Cannes Grand Prix and Best Foreign Film Oscar. Written by the legendary film composer Ennio Morricone. Jackie sang it in Italian: ruclips.net/video/doAvI71mUZQ/видео.html)
    ---- Bridge Over Troubled Water (as a 12-year old. Sung as guest performer for the Cirque du Soleil special charity show One Night For One Drop in Las Vegas. This was the first time that all seven Cirque du Soleil shows in Las Vegas were cancelled so the 1,700 employees could collaboratively participate in the show that had over 230 Cirque du Soleil artists and guest performers. This show was at the O Theater in the Bellagio and was streamed online worldwide. Millions of dollars were raised in honor of World Water Day: ruclips.net/video/_ntXQ5vqV-8/видео.html)
    ---- Writing's On The Wall (as a 15-year old. Sam Smith cover of the James Bond Spectre movie song. Sung in her music video for the song. This video done as a mini-movie with Jackie's older sister Juliette playing the villain: ruclips.net/video/RBjsDhqRMOA/видео.html)
    ---- Apocalypse (as a 15-year old. Original song written for Jackie. It is about the heartbreak one has after a breakup. A sophisticated music video. Jackie sung this using her pop voice: ruclips.net/video/J1iM3hOKFdg/видео.html)
    ---- Caruso (as a 16-year old. Sung on the PBS Special of Fernando Varela. Sung in Italian: ruclips.net/video/arhijZEgCmw/видео.html)
    ---- Music Of The Night (as an 18-year old. Sung a cutdown version of the song on first season of America's Got Talent - Champions show which was one year earlier than when Angelina sung on the second season: ruclips.net/video/CM1KN7zT3lE/видео.html)
    ---- Burn (as a 18-year old. Cover of song from the musical Hamilton. a sophisticated music video again as a mini-movie: ruclips.net/video/PDrM8-AXI3g/видео.html)
    ---- Dangerous Woman (as a 19-year old. Cutdown version of Ariana Grande's song. This is Jackie's first performance on The Masked Singer as Kitty. Completely different singing style than she has been known for: ruclips.net/video/wd2-cbQMSZ8/видео.html)
    ---- Dreams (as a 19-year old. Cover of Bazzi song. Sung in makeshift home setup. Just Jackie and a pianist. This is done in a jazzy style that is a very different style than the original: ruclips.net/video/-KfhcvbKcpo/видео.html)
    ---- River (as a 20-year old. Joni Mitchell cover. Sung in a music video shot completely in black and white: ruclips.net/video/Hl40RLU2KCQ/видео.html)
    ---- Both Sides Now (as a 22-year old. Joni Mitchell cover. Music video. The song was first recorded by Judy Collins in 1968. Joni Mitchell first recorded the song for her 1969 album Clouds. Rolling Stone magazine has it on its list of The 500 Greatest Songs: ruclips.net/video/hmbK_5coIIg/видео.html

  • @lorisharpe
    @lorisharpe Год назад +12

    First time I heard .. instant tears

  • @richardgleason5953
    @richardgleason5953 Год назад +15

    I saw Jackie in concert a few years ago. Wonderful.

    • @teddytarp
      @teddytarp Год назад

      I was at 13 of Jackie's concerts. Half of them in 1st or 2nd row. I experienced parts of the audience being left literally speechless by the end of the show.

  • @DDE_ADDICT
    @DDE_ADDICT Год назад +11

    she was perfect and still is

  • @rickhilde8281
    @rickhilde8281 Год назад +11

    I've been a fan of hers since this show. She is elegant in every way

    • @koolcat1375
      @koolcat1375 Год назад

      ruclips.net/video/TgCg3Ky3WmQ/видео.html

  • @rehoboth2721
    @rehoboth2721 9 месяцев назад +1

    Jackie is 23 now and writing her own music. Be great to hear and before and after comparison.

  • @michaelbannon2525
    @michaelbannon2525 Год назад +7

    Stopped you mid sentence. I loved that

  • @deanyoho2755
    @deanyoho2755 Год назад +4

    She does a magnificent job with the Lord's Prayer and also How Great Thou Art.

  • @dixiehuston4869
    @dixiehuston4869 7 месяцев назад +2

    I Love your sincere response. I was moved as you were.
    Please listen to Imaginer by Jackie..the person on the piano was 16yrs old. This song will touch you as well
    All of her songs do..as you said..Angelic..Thank you again

  • @dennisharnish9063
    @dennisharnish9063 Год назад +3

    Jackie is amazing. You may want to view Amira Willaghan singing your love in the video she is 13 and shows amazing talent she won Holland’s Got Talent at the age of nine.

  • @Royalchess1
    @Royalchess1 9 месяцев назад +1

    Sebs,
    At 1:40" you got THE SAME REACTION as I got when I first heard Jackie, except that when Jackie sang THAT SONG, it was LIVE for me on August 15, 2010. Jackie was freshly 10 when she sang this. I could NOT believe the VOICE that SHE IS SINGING. Not too long after this, but before the end of 2010, I personally discovered, "JACKIE DOESN'T sing songs, she BECOMES THE SONG." And that dress she wore was angelic, Jackie was truly OTHERWORLDLY! You should listen to Jackie sing, (From her first cd, "PRELUDE", a year before AGT), ALL I ASK OF YOU (PHANTOM OF THE OPERA [That show is what got her singing]), DARK WALTZ, and IMAGINER, from her "DREAM WITH ME" cd, "YOUR LOVE", on (RUclips/RT w/David Foster, from/Once upon a time in the west), from her, "AWAKENING" cd, and watch her video, "BURN", and, when she was on, "THE MASKED SINGER" as 'KITTY' (on YT). YOU WILL HAVE NO CHOICE BUT TO BE A LIFER AFTER WATCHING THESE! Jackie just came out with a cd WITH ALL ORIGINALS! royalchess1@gmail.com

    • @rehoboth2721
      @rehoboth2721 8 месяцев назад

      Here's her latest music video, "Eye's" now #23 on the Billboard Top 100, freaking cool! ruclips.net/video/-kE7xXjpONA/видео.html

  • @roddiener1235
    @roddiener1235 Год назад +10

    Hers is a deep deep rabbit hole to fall in to, her Houston concert is a Masterpiece, 35 minutes, no break, zero mistakes, PLUS, she tackles Nessun Dorma and kills it.....

    • @teddytarp
      @teddytarp Год назад +1

      And she was still 10 years old!!!

  • @JohnPaul-hm2ys
    @JohnPaul-hm2ys Год назад +3

    She is naturally gifted. You can train someone to be bettee, but her age says she was born with that angelic voice. Have you reacted to any One Voice Children's Choir? It is an ever changing kids choir that covers all types of music.

  • @jordannash1998
    @jordannash1998 Год назад +6

    This was age 10 1/3 on AGT. By age 10 1/2 she was working with David Foster so by age 11 + 3 days, she recorded her "Dream With Me In Concert" which was a PBS "Great Performances" program, and used extensively that year for the PBS subscription drives. So, as good as this performance was, by the time "Dream With Me" dropped, she was so much better she was unbelievably good. And still is.

  • @rehoboth2721
    @rehoboth2721 10 месяцев назад +1

    Jackie was loads of fun as Kitty on the Mased Singer Season 3. Completely fooled the judges singing in a pop voice.

  • @SC-gp7kt
    @SC-gp7kt 10 месяцев назад +1

    Charlotte Church is another one you need to listen to. She did this song too, but I have to say Jackie's version is absolutely perfect. Perfect. (musician here)

  • @tammymoseley1348
    @tammymoseley1348 Год назад +5

    I remember watching this when it first aired. She was, and still is, amazing. Please watch her duet with Sarah Brightman from the finale.

  • @frankscarborough1428
    @frankscarborough1428 Год назад +2

    Sung so beautiful thanks

  • @stevepasin5975
    @stevepasin5975 Год назад +4

    PERFECT. Now you know the difference between a voice and a world class voice that commands an astounding feel of pitch and tone that other singers merely stab at. I'm so glad I got to be in her life.

  • @elizabethhurley1129
    @elizabethhurley1129 Год назад +10

    Thank you so much. I'll be sending some more Jackie suggestions. ❤

  • @BBBYpsi
    @BBBYpsi Год назад +1

    This song when Jackie performs it gets me every time. I have a suggestion if you want Angelic voices. Gerphil Flores singing a live recording of "Somewhere in Time" from the movie somewhere in time. If Disney was smart they would sign her to sing in their animated movies. Her voice is that of a Angel.

  • @Kjetil-wn6ls
    @Kjetil-wn6ls Год назад +3

    Jeeeesus, what a voice.

  • @jethebest1yak
    @jethebest1yak Год назад +4

    Try - "LOVERS" Jackie Evancho (Dream with me ) concert. Thank you.

  • @richardduffy3115
    @richardduffy3115 Год назад +3

    Highly under rated and a highly forgotten talent.
    One of the best voices to come along in this century.
    She still sings but because of the trashy songs and lack of interest in truly talented singers these days, Jackie has been forgotten, but not by me!!

  • @MrJoeym78
    @MrJoeym78 Год назад +5

    You should listen to her cover of Rains of Castamere from Game of Thrones. If you are fan that is.

  • @gustog3893
    @gustog3893 Год назад +11

    Jackie still has a great voice to this day, try some of her recent stuff for comparison. Lots of people don't like her for non-musical reasons but a beautiful voice will always defend itself.

    • @OldBoiler62
      @OldBoiler62 Год назад +5

      Why would anybody not like her? Is it because she had the gall to perform the National Anthem at Trump's inauguration? I've always thought that that is the reason more reactors don't do her videos, above and beyond the copyrite restrictions. What other reason could there be and those people don't deserve mention. She does more behind the scenes than most people do who crave the spotlight. She should be praised for overcoming what she has been through physically and emotionally for almost a third of her life.

    • @elizabethhurley1129
      @elizabethhurley1129 Год назад +1

      ​@OldBoiler62 I was hoping no one would bring up that fiasco - please leave politics out of any Jackie discussion. This reactor did listen, so let's leave the mention of other reactors off his page.

    • @OldBoiler62
      @OldBoiler62 Год назад

      @@elizabethhurley1129 She did a superb job singing, especially since she was sick and had lost her voice two days prior. Not a fiasco at all. Merely asking what non-musical reasons he was referring to.

    • @elizabethhurley1129
      @elizabethhurley1129 Год назад

      ​@@OldBoiler62 Her singing wasn't a fiasco - the politics of it was. Best not to mention it. She was 16 - she now regrets it, so people on both sides should be happy. Just don't bring it up. A reaction channel is just about her voice.

    • @OldBoiler62
      @OldBoiler62 Год назад

      @@elizabethhurley1129 I didn't bring up people not liking her for non-musical reasons. That was in the initial comment. I merely posited a possible reason. I questioned why anyone would not like her. You're the one that made it political.

  • @cl9786
    @cl9786 Год назад +5

    At age 10 with her album, "Oh Holy Night", Jackie became the youngest Platinum solo artist in US history, the distinction previously held by Michael Jackson......How extraordinary is that for a young classical crossover artist. She has not been surpassed.

  • @Kjetil-wn6ls
    @Kjetil-wn6ls Год назад +3

    Yes. It is perfect.Who is the little angle?

  • @kathyellison332
    @kathyellison332 Год назад +5

    She's all grown up now. She sings all types of music now. I also watched her on Masked Singer. I knew who it was right away! lol

  • @kerryminner8052
    @kerryminner8052 Год назад +10

    You need to get to check her flow. Her evolution is dynamic. She came back to AGT, was Kitty on Masked Singer (should have won all 3 competitions) and is unquestionably one of the top 3 crossover singers of all time.

  • @HS-hr5wp
    @HS-hr5wp 3 месяца назад

    Imagine the host of heaven singing in unison with the elect. Cant wait

  • @michaelbannon2525
    @michaelbannon2525 Год назад +5

    You really need to see her sing Lovers I. The Dream With Me Concert.

  • @karenfabery8986
    @karenfabery8986 2 месяца назад

    I live 30 miles south of her

  • @patbrewer4205
    @patbrewer4205 Год назад +6

    She has performed all over the world

  • @wesleystace9962
    @wesleystace9962 Год назад +3

    now that little girl has some talent I remember seeing her when this was aired

  • @slowride1963
    @slowride1963 22 дня назад

    Cool

  • @kathyellison332
    @kathyellison332 Год назад +3

    Great actress, too! She was in a movie with Robert Redford.

  • @stuarthornsby7023
    @stuarthornsby7023 Год назад +7

    How did that young girl even have enough years on the Earth to practice and be that good! Amazing sound & control.

    • @davidvanriper60
      @davidvanriper60 Год назад +2

      somewhere on youtube-if it is still up- there is a video of Jackie at 9 years old, performing at a small talent competition.
      by the time Jackie finished singing, the lady in charge was weeping...

    • @rd1903
      @rd1903 Год назад +2

      @@davidvanriper60 Search youtube: Jackie Evancho singing 'O Mio Babbino Caro' on 'Talent Quest' at 9 years old. Host's name is Debra Crosby who wept openly at hearing Jackie sing for the first time.
      Also search youtube : Jackie's earliest video on youtube is from the 'Kean Idol' competition at 7 years old singing 'Wishing You Were Somehow Here Again' from the Broadway play 'Phantom of the Opera' all the videos of it are poor quality (144p) but 'visualbully' has the best video of it).

    • @elizabethhurley1129
      @elizabethhurley1129 Год назад +2

      Jackie doesn't practice much - she just sings this way. After working with a vocal coach on AGT and her first concert tour (Dream With Me), her parents pulled back on training because they thought she was starting to sound too much like a "typical opera singer," and they believed her unique "Jackie sound" is what makes her special. I think they're right.

  • @rosemariediamond5948
    @rosemariediamond5948 Год назад +6

    If you want to hear a phenomenal voice listen to Lara Fabian. Her songs Broken Vow, Je Suis Malade and Adagio will blow you away

    • @elizabethhurley1129
      @elizabethhurley1129 Год назад +2

      Lara Fabian thought so highly of Jackie's voice that she wrote the French lyrics for Jackie to sing Broken Vow. It's called Imaginer in French - different lyrics appropriate for a child, but the exact melody.
      ruclips.net/video/hX3s2v6qGYo/видео.html

  • @alanschechterly245
    @alanschechterly245 Год назад +10

    I have been following Jackie for over 13 years now. From her audition on AGT through her Semi Final performance on The Masked Singer she has had a brilliant career. One of her career hightlights has to be her Dream With Me world tour. And a notable performance of that concert is "Lovers". It brings me to tears every time. - ruclips.net/video/6qj8bDnLUrM/видео.html

    • @elizabethhurley1129
      @elizabethhurley1129 Год назад +3

      Lovers is amazing!!!!

    • @1845c-z3r
      @1845c-z3r Год назад

      First: there was no "Semi Final performance for Jackie Evancho on The Masked Singer, she was eliminated in the quarter finals.
      Second: there was no "Dream With Me world tour" She did however tour Nationally and later had a concert in Tokyo.

    • @bigd205
      @bigd205 Год назад +2

      @@1845c-z3r You'll get no likes for being truthful here.

  • @JF-dy2dr
    @JF-dy2dr Год назад +5

    Her cover of Bridge over Troubled Water.....

  • @rehoboth2721
    @rehoboth2721 8 месяцев назад

    Here's her latest music video, "Eye's" now #23 on the Billboard Top 100, freaking cool! ruclips.net/video/-kE7xXjpONA/видео.html

  • @bennybuffylove
    @bennybuffylove Год назад +4

    I've have followed Jackie since 2010 till now. I still watch and/or listen to all her stuff frequently. When she was 10 - 16 she was unbeatable. For me personally, she is better than Angelina Jordan by far.

  • @rickrack4812
    @rickrack4812 Год назад +2

    23 now, and still a PERFECT voice.
    10 y.o.here.

  • @lavidaeshermosa8168
    @lavidaeshermosa8168 Год назад +2

    I can't believe that this damn world could have almost destroyed this beautiful angel

  • @janiceobernberger8846
    @janiceobernberger8846 Год назад +2

    Seen her on agt she's great

  • @demarcuswitten9723
    @demarcuswitten9723 Год назад

    She was 10 on the show in 2010

  • @JDK44
    @JDK44 Год назад +1

    My dude. If you haven’t yet listened to then you should hear “That’s something to be proud of” by Montgomery Gentry.
    Edit to add. Love the Chanel my guy. Keep it up.

  • @jayjackson8480
    @jayjackson8480 Год назад +1

    I understand your reaction to Jackie, because I felt just as you did hearing Jackie for the first time. In fact I love listening to beautiful voices so much that when I find one as remarkable as Jackie's I do all I can to hear more. Like many, I first saw her on AGT, and I was hooked. I searched the internet to see what else there was out there about her to be found. That was 13 years ago, and I'm still searching, and still amazed by her. Jackie's concerts are more amazing than anything on youtube. That said I still hope to see more reactions to Jackie from you. There are a lot of videos on youtube of Jackie singing, and I am sure you would be impressed by her performance no matter which you see. But I would most like to see your reaction to Jackie singing "Danny Boy", there is no video of her performing it, in fact she has only sang it ONE TIME, because David Forster asked her to record it for an album he was producing for her, called "Dream With Me". I love "Danny Boy" and I believe I have searched out EVERY performance of it available on youtube, male and female, and for my money Jackie's rendition is the BEST. I would really like to hear your opinion of her interpretation.

  • @ShelbyFarrow
    @ShelbyFarrow Год назад +2

    I believe she was only 10 when she performed this on AGT in 2010.

  • @chacho761
    @chacho761 Год назад +3

    what happened to you has a name: the evancho effect... she sings, the listener cries

  • @demarcuswitten9723
    @demarcuswitten9723 Год назад

    Btw she is in her 20's not teen's

  • @Enfield-1853
    @Enfield-1853 Год назад +1

    Need to listen to Celtic Women's version of this.

  • @dougk5187
    @dougk5187 Год назад +2

    She is the youngest in music history to have her debut album go Platinum !!!!!!!!

    • @jordannash1998
      @jordannash1998 Год назад +2

      More than that, she hold the record for the youngest solo artist to go platinun, beating out Michael Jackson. She STILL holds that record along with many other records.

  • @Kjetil-wn6ls
    @Kjetil-wn6ls Год назад +1

    Jackie something?

    • @rehoboth2721
      @rehoboth2721 9 месяцев назад

      Jackie Evancho, check the Guiness Book of World Records for the Youngest Solo Artist ever to go Platinum.

  • @williamdunphe-bh2pu
    @williamdunphe-bh2pu Год назад +1

    She's amazing and should have won agt season 2 wild bill

  • @rehoboth2721
    @rehoboth2721 Год назад

    Selecting Jackie Evancho for a "Great Voices" series is Masterful, even if by accident. Then I noticed you've never reacted to Karen Carpenter iconic vocals. H😉w long you were a monk? ruclips.net/video/CQKnpJul8MU/видео.html

  • @pickin4you
    @pickin4you Год назад +2

    She was 10 here. She became the youngest solo artist to go Platinum, beating Michael Jackson. She did that at age 11. She is a far better classic singer than pop. She is world famous and has sold multiple gold and platinum albums. She is far better than Angelina. Sorry but Angelina cannot sing on pitch. Jackie can. Look forward to seeing you so more of hers. She was a guest singer on the finals of BGT the next year where she CRUSHED Nessun Dorma. You need to watch that one next.

    • @brgilbert2
      @brgilbert2 Год назад

      [Steve] Seriously, get your ears checked. Angelina may have missed notes when she was sick, "At Last" the one I am thinking of and she may have tackled Whitney Houston to early but to say ""she cannot sing on pitch" is pure exaggeration.

    • @pickin4you
      @pickin4you Год назад +1

      @@brgilbert2 My ears are fine. I have near perfect pitch. Sorry but Angelina cannot sing. She hurts my ears. Look it up. Those who have what I have, when someone sings off pitch it hurts to listen to it. Sorry your hearing is not as good as mine. I have mentioned before that she would not even make it on my HS choir. They all sang better than Angelina and another bad songs that has made
      Millions all due to auto tune is Taylor Swift. She can’t stay on pitch either. She is actually worse than Angelina. They don’t sell singers these days. They sell popularity. Screw it if they can’t sing. A computer can fix that for them.

    • @elizabethhurley1129
      @elizabethhurley1129 Год назад

      Quit comparing them - they sing differently. They are both incredibly talented and deserve to be respected, not compared. It is utterly ridiculous to compare them - their styles are different, and their genres are different. Quit being negative - they both deserve so much better.

    • @elizabethhurley1129
      @elizabethhurley1129 Год назад

      ​@@brgilbert2 Angelina is pure magic (and I'm a huge Jackie fan).

    • @elizabethhurley1129
      @elizabethhurley1129 Год назад +1

      ​@Steve It is so rude to criticize another singer on a post about a different singer. I know Jackie wouldn't like it. Just stop. Angelina is so unique - there is no one who sings like her. She is phenomenally talented, not to mention one of the kindest, most compassionate humanitarians on the planet. You are being unbelievably rude. I love Angelina, but just to let you know, I'm a huge Jackie fan, and I sponsored this reaction.

  • @The_Judge300
    @The_Judge300 Год назад +2

    Yes, Jackie Evancho was amazing for her age at that time, but she is really not that special of a singer for her age now.
    She has really not developed as much as you would think during those years and she is at about the same level now as she was then.
    At 23 she is at about the same level as so many woman at her age is.
    She is just a good singer that looks good and is pleasant to listen to, but nothing that stands out at all.
    I doubt she would get very much attention if it was not for the fact that she is American and what she did at a young age.
    Like in this video.
    If she was a 23 year young woman from England, France, Germany, Norway; Sweden or any other country than USA and singing as she is now, no one in USA would think she was anything special.
    I guess her die hard fans will come for this comment, but I don't care, because what I say is the reality and the truth.

    • @elizabethhurley1129
      @elizabethhurley1129 Год назад +3

      She can sing even better than she did at 10 or 11 - she is choosing to sing less difficult music - less classical, more contemporary. Her voice is just as beautiful. She sings a combination of O Mio Babbino Caro and Nessum Dorma in her concerts that is breathtaking. She can still hit all the high notes, and she still has perfect pitch. Do you know she's struggling with anorexia because of the criticism she gets because she's not 10 anymore? Why would you want to say anything unkind when you could be silent?

    • @The_Judge300
      @The_Judge300 Год назад

      @@elizabethhurley1129
      What did I say that was unkind?
      Was it unkind of me saying that she is a good singer that looks good and is pleasant to listen to, but is nothing really special that stands out from so many other good singers?
      If you think that us unkind, then you clearly are a snowflake and you think she is a snowflake as well, thinking she would get hurt by that.

    • @jordannash1998
      @jordannash1998 Год назад +1

      depends on what she is singing. When she sings Pop, some of what you say it true, she gives up a lot of her advantage. She seems to sing to the back of the room, not relying on the sound system to get her voice out there. This creates more overtones. But when she is singing into her mike as if she was alone in the room, she is STILL absolutely stupendous because she is singing in a 'storytelling' voice with a pure set of overtones.

    • @elizabethhurley1129
      @elizabethhurley1129 Год назад

      ​@carnivore2023 so you double down and say something unkind AGAIN - that's your answer? Since you made a "snowflake" remark, I think I know your problem. You're the snowflake - you read where Jackie said she regrets singing for the Trump inauguration (her team pushed it) and wishes she hadn't. So, you troll her - how pathetic.

    • @richardduffy3115
      @richardduffy3115 Год назад

      ​​@@The_Judge300
      You have to be a Trump supporter to use Snowflake to describe people that don't agree with you.
      That would explain everything, including your poor judgement of a world class singer like Jackie. 🤫

  • @Cosmo-Kramer
    @Cosmo-Kramer Год назад

    Pretending to wipe away tears that don't exist is lame, transparent, and got you a DISLIKE from me.

  • @robertevers6239
    @robertevers6239 Год назад +2

    Now the Best singer today or May be ever.

  • @JuanHernandez-ry9dr
    @JuanHernandez-ry9dr Год назад +3

    The one with Streisand was sublime.