Top 5 Sherried Scotch

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 16 янв 2025

Комментарии • 120

  • @lyacoubian
    @lyacoubian Год назад +8

    After watching you pull out all those mouth watering gems, all I can do is add a couple of bottles that I think are worth mentioning. 🥃
    1) Lower proof - Edradour 12 Caledonia. Full sherry impact.
    2) Higher proof - Macallan Classic Cut. Assertive sherry and oak.
    3) Peated - Lagavulin Distiller's Edition. PX at its best..!!!

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад +2

      This was a very hard video to shoot. My mouth was indeed watering the entire time. I feel like I should have had a bib on.

    • @rajeshdixit3104
      @rajeshdixit3104 7 месяцев назад

      Adding 2 more.. Royal Brackla 12 & Old Perth

  • @tonylastname6468
    @tonylastname6468 Год назад +16

    I'm no master blender, but I play one at home. Glen Dronach with a hit of Aberlour A'Bunadh is just wow.

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад +4

      I always forget to try blending. I need to do that. I'll put a sticky note on my desk. Next time I wont forget.

    • @tonylastname6468
      @tonylastname6468 Год назад +4

      @whiskeyisajourney I was blending a bit this evening with Glenfarclas 15 and Bunnahabhain Stiuireadair. 50 50, no refinement, but I think the result was greater than the sum of the parts. Sometimes, it's a total debacle. It's fun regardless.

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад

      @@tonylastname6468 sounds amazing!

    • @Iceman-xe7jo
      @Iceman-xe7jo Год назад

      I’ll have to try that.

    • @tonylastname6468
      @tonylastname6468 Год назад

      ​@Iceman-xe7jo missclicked the thumbs down. These eyes ain't what they use to be. No idea how it is with the new Aberlour finished in bourbon casks.

  • @dane5896
    @dane5896 Год назад +5

    One the best I've had was an early batch of Aberlour A'bunadh. Also loved the GlenDronach 15 & 18.

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад +1

      The only Aberlour I have is the A'bunadh Alba CS matured in bourbon barrels. It was the first cask strength I ever had and it just about cauterized my esophagus shut.

  • @TJO1913
    @TJO1913 Год назад +1

    Hi Pete, The YT algorithm finally dropped this video into my feed. Enjoy your style and perspectives. It's especially nice to find a whiskey-tube channel based in Arizona as I'm just north of Tucson and I should be able to find bottles that you feel are interesting. (I had to go out of state for the Bunna 12 C.S. too.) I agree with you about sherry matured/finished, peated single malts; probably my favorite style.

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад +1

      I can't figure out the algorithms of RUclips, but I'm happy it dropped into your feed. I appreciate the feedback and I hope you continue to find value in the videos and can pick up some bottles. I was in your neck of the woods a few weekends ago at Whiskey Del Bac for the distillery tour and tasting. Cheers !

  • @tommysimpsonandtheloadeddice
    @tommysimpsonandtheloadeddice Месяц назад

    It's a crime to leave out Edradour from this list! Haha. Great selection.

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Месяц назад

      If I had the bottle it would probably have been included. A lot of people love it, but it's not available in my area. Cheers!

  • @tommysimpsonandtheloadeddice
    @tommysimpsonandtheloadeddice Месяц назад +1

    Glenallachie 15, Bunna 12 CS, Edradour Caledonia, Balcones Cataleja would be my top Sherried flight.

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Месяц назад

      I like the addition of the Balcones! Nice list. Cheers!

  • @mk.5706
    @mk.5706 11 месяцев назад +2

    Before the last one i was pretty sure about what it would be. Heavily sherried, heavily peated whisky, you all know and love it, it´s THE classic, that´s what i understood from the sound of your voice, what means there is only one answer: Ardbeg Uigeadail.

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  11 месяцев назад

      It was close, but I went with "special" and more a lot of my friends would have had the opportunity to have the Octomore. The Uigeadail would be a great pour as well so I'm not going to argue that. cheers!

    • @JosephC9
      @JosephC9 10 месяцев назад

      My friends and I: OOOooogeadail~~~

  • @teachergregory291
    @teachergregory291 Год назад +1

    Great list

  • @WhooshFlyingHorse444
    @WhooshFlyingHorse444 Год назад +2

    Nice selection!

  • @bb4726-h5e
    @bb4726-h5e Год назад +4

    Great list as usual Peter, you know your whiskey. Here are a few more bangers: Laphroaig PX Cask, Arran Sherry Cask, Kilkerran 8 Sherry Cask, Tomatin Cask Strength, and of course Aberlour 12 and A'bunadh.

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад

      Bangers for sure! I like it. Kilkerran is good stuff! As is everything on your list.

    • @mattfalk8493
      @mattfalk8493 Год назад

      Yea boi I'm sipping a Laphroaig PX as I'm watching 🥃🥃

  • @RobertUWL
    @RobertUWL 9 месяцев назад +2

    amazing drams !
    i would suggest
    Dalmore 12, 15, Cigar Malt and King Alexander
    Aberlour a'Bunadh
    Glendronach 15 Revival
    Laphroaig 10 Sherry Cask
    Mortlach 12
    The Arran Sherry Cask Bodega CS
    Edradour 10
    Glenfarclas Heritage CS
    Benriach 12
    oh so many i love them all

  • @johnk7093
    @johnk7093 Год назад +1

    heres a list... I want to try octomore soo bad... I want a bottle...will have to order on I guess. never have seen it in the stores.
    cheers, great list... this one was really great..

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад +1

      Thanks John! It was a delicious video to shoot. My mouth was watering the entire time.

  • @-beno-
    @-beno- Год назад +1

    Good list! My list
    Sherry Scotch Blend - Cheap: Old Perth Sherry - Cask strength ---- Normal/high price: Old Perth PX limited Cask strength
    Sherry Scotch - Cheap: Bunna 12 ---- Normal/high price: Bunna 12 - Cask strength, Tamdhu Cask strength, or Aberlour A'bunadh (or other 200 good stuff)
    Peated Sherry Scotch - Cheap: Ardbeg 5YO Wee Beastie ---- Normal/high price: Laphroig PX csak, Ardbeg Uigeadail, Benromach Contrasts: Peat Smoke Sherry Matured (or other 200 good stuff)

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад +1

      Great choices in your list! Aberlour has come up a lot in other people's lists as well. Thanks for sharing. Cheers!

    • @-beno-
      @-beno- Год назад +1

      @@whiskeyisajourney Aberlour Sherry Whiskey standard - (really good - but if it's really sherry fun - lots of specials, limited editions, etc. there is a release or an independent bottling whiskey, which is better, everyone should discover what they like)

  • @nzmarco
    @nzmarco Год назад +1

    Some I would add, Edradour 10, Glengoyne 12, Glenfarclas 15 and Glendronnach 15. Nice video btw

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад

      Thanks for sharing. I appreciate it. I've only had Glengoyne and Glenfarclas. Cheers!

  • @mattfalk8493
    @mattfalk8493 Год назад +1

    Just about to finish off a bottle of the Glendronach Cask Strength Batch 11... luckily I have another one on the shelve next to my Batch 10 as well 🥃🥃

  • @MartinP-ke9ys
    @MartinP-ke9ys 9 месяцев назад +1

    Great suggestions, I would have given exactly the same!!! I would though add aberlour abundah, even tough it has skyrocketed in price lately.

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  9 месяцев назад

      Nice call on the Aberlour. Unfortunately I don't have that one. I only have the ex-bourbon cask strength release. Cheers!

  • @graveshotx
    @graveshotx Год назад +1

    Up front, I swear I'm not bragging. I only have 6 solely sherried scotchs, and all are great. Here's the order I'd serve them:
    1. Glenallachie 12
    2. Ledaig 19 year Olorosso
    3. Laphroaig Cairdeas PX Sherry
    4. Bunnahabain 12 Cask Strength
    5. Hazelburn 15 year Olorosso
    Special - Glenallachie Single Sherry Cask Pick by Ralfy
    I saw the glendronach CS the other day and didn't know they were discontinuing them. Might of picked it up if I knew. Anyways, great list as always!

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад

      Right back at you. Great list! Ledaig 19 year sounds intriguing.

    • @BaWBarmy
      @BaWBarmy Год назад +2

      I think I'd serve the Bunnahabhain before all the peated stuff.

  • @CGsYTChannel
    @CGsYTChannel Год назад +1

    I love Octomore 13.2!! I just picked 10.4 the other day. My list would have that plus Macallan 12, Glendronach Batch 11 Cask Strength, Dalmore Cigar Malt, Dalmore 15yr, and Bunnahabhain Stiuireadair.

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад

      I'm not familiar with the Stiuireadair, but if it's coming out of Bnnahabhain I'm in!

    • @CGsYTChannel
      @CGsYTChannel Год назад +1

      @@whiskeyisajourney It's very good! It has a aqua ish color label on it

  • @peterpete5848
    @peterpete5848 Год назад +1

    Edradour Caledonia, Arran Bodega, Glenfarcals 105, Glendronach (any), Tamdhu (any), A'Bunadh, Hibiki Blossom Harmony (finished in sakura - japanese cherry).

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад +1

      Nice list. I need to pick up the Caledonia.

    • @BaWBarmy
      @BaWBarmy Год назад

      The Hibiki isn't a Scotch

    • @peterpete5848
      @peterpete5848 Год назад

      @BaWBarmy Still good juice. Yes, it's not a scotch.

  • @kevinnordby4808
    @kevinnordby4808 Год назад +1

    Fantastic list Peter! However….where is Edradour 12 Caledonia???? It’s a must have in my collection and I would love to see you review it.

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад +1

      It's not carried in my market, but I'll look into seeing where I can get it. Can't promise anything but I'll see what I can do.

    • @kevinnordby4808
      @kevinnordby4808 Год назад +1

      @@whiskeyisajourney it’s not carried in my market either….I’ve been getting it for $87 at Blackwell’s, shipped from San Francisco.

  • @rhayes458
    @rhayes458 Год назад +1

    Thanks for another great video, Peter! I haven’t had much Scotch but definitely intrigued with the sherry. Is there a difference in flavor/experience between aging in a cask vs butt?
    I did try a sherry finished bourbon recently for the first time, and I really enjoyed it. It was the Nelson Bros. Sherry Finish. I can totally understand the dark raisin notes.

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад +1

      A butt (500 liters) is larger than the standard American cask or barrel (200 liters). So I would think the surface ratio to liquid being less in the sherry butt the sherry influence in the butt would be less. How much less and how much of a factor would that influence the amount of sherry that comes through in the whisky...I don't know. I think there are more factors involved. Especially how active the cask or butt is and how long it's in each.

    • @rhayes458
      @rhayes458 Год назад

      @@whiskeyisajourney very helpful!

  • @roychen9257
    @roychen9257 Год назад +1

    What do you think about Westland single cask 2635 compared to the sherry whiskies in the video?

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад

      I think it's delicious, but slightly cask influence heavy. I'd put it up there with the Tamdhu 15 as far as how much cask influence it has. You really need to like raisins, dates, and plums in order to like cask 2635.

    • @roychen9257
      @roychen9257 Год назад +1

      @@whiskeyisajourney I'm contemplating pulling the trigger on this bottle, haha. I'm totally fine with a heavily sherry profile. However, I'm curious if it leans towards being overly oaked, potentially resulting in a too bitter finish?

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад

      @@roychen9257 I don't think it's over oaked at all and I don't pick up on anything that would be called bitterness, but that's my palate. Where are you located that you can pick up a bottle?

    • @roychen9257
      @roychen9257 Год назад +1

      @@whiskeyisajourney Thanks for the info. I am at Southern California, total wine and more currently has it! Just check the inventory online to see which stores are in stock!

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад +1

      @@roychen9257 If you get it check back in and let me know what you think of it.

  • @pizzawarlord9232
    @pizzawarlord9232 Год назад +1

    Love the Whiskey Exchange in London but their shipping is pathetic so only buy there when in London. Shipping was about $50 a bottle. Just a great store with non competitive shipping prices. Was there last month and was going to ship home 6 bottles but shipping was almost $250. Places in Ireland and Scotland ship by box so $75 can be 2-5 bottles.
    Need to try the Tamdhu still. Have all the others but Octo and Kilchomam.
    Those Bunnahabain 12CS are incredible. Glad I bought two. A few stores still have them on shelf surprisingly

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад +1

      Shipping prices are kicking me hard! I actually had 2 Bunnahabain 12 CS in my cart and at the last min. took it out and added the Ledaig 18. Very happy with the Ledaig, but sad I only have the 1 bottle of Bunnahabain.

  • @kenwhitman1055
    @kenwhitman1055 Год назад +1

    I stand corrected regarding age certification of scotch, days as a customs and border protection ( trade) CFR 27 5.30 are for US imports to be no less than three years old, yet if a 12 year old is blended with 3% of a three year old, per US regs the lowest aged is to be stated. I wonder if I had read Scottish law regarding exported whiskey. Either way I routinely purchase stated age, Buchanan’s master blends 12 is a great sip

  • @Abby_Normal_1969
    @Abby_Normal_1969 Год назад +1

    I love Glenfarclas. I don't get butterscotch, though. I have been looking Glenfarclas 105.

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад +1

      If you like Glenfarclas, then just wait. July 7th I'm doing my flight fight of all the Glenfarclas I have. 12, 15, 17, 21, 25 and the 105. I found the 105 at a local AJ's. I have never seen it anyplace else. Cheers!

    • @Abby_Normal_1969
      @Abby_Normal_1969 Год назад +1

      @whiskeyisajourney - sounds pretty amazing. I will admit, I checked a local Total Wine after I saw your video. It's in stock now, but the price went up $25.

  • @mikeogurec
    @mikeogurec Год назад +1

    Nice vid!

  • @djbeacon6895
    @djbeacon6895 Год назад +3

    Not to repeat any distillery:
    1) Naked Grouse (recently renamed?)
    2) Glendronach 15 The Revival
    3) Bunnahabhain 12 CS
    4) Glengoyne CS Batch 006
    5) Signatoy CS Series Deanston 2007 13 year
    SPECIAL = Springbank 12 year CS Batch 21

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад +1

      Nice list. Springbank 12 CS sounds interesting.

    • @djbeacon6895
      @djbeacon6895 Год назад +1

      @whiskeyisajourney Batch 21 is kinda Frankenstein monster made up of many finishing parts: 45% sherry, 25% bourbon, 25% burgundy and 5% port.

  • @petevj
    @petevj Год назад +1

    Excellent selection! I'd replace Glenfarclas and Tamdhu with one of the Benriach peated PXs, an Ardnamurchan and, if you can get it in your market the Deanston 2008 oloroso. The Lagavulin 2022 Distillers Edition is also excellent, although I would probably take the Kilchoman over it.

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад

      I only get the Deanston 12 and the Organic 14 in my area. I have been liking the Kilchoman very much lately. Not sure If I have ever seen the Benriach peated PX, but I will look for that one next time I'm out.

  • @TryinitwithOliver
    @TryinitwithOliver Год назад +1

    For the most part does high proof scotch drink much hotter than an equivalent bourbon of the same proof???

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад

      That has not been my experience, but I am sure there are examples that will dispute what I have experienced.

  • @notorious_raksasa
    @notorious_raksasa Год назад +1

    Tamdhu BS, Glendronach CS, Bunnahabhain 12 CS, Glenallachie 10 CS, Edradour 10 CS. Bonus bottle would be either Benromach CS, Laphroaig Cairdeas PX CS, or Kavalan Solist Oloroso Sherry

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад +1

      That would be an incredible flight. A few of these are in the running for my scotch of the year.

  • @canal-do-guga-namura
    @canal-do-guga-namura Год назад +3

    The Glenfarclas 15 wipes the floor with the 12. Vastly superior.

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад

      If that's what you think then you will be happy with next Friday's video.

    • @davegilmour1895
      @davegilmour1895 2 месяца назад

      And the 18 year old Glendronach is far superior to the 12 or 15.

    • @peterwilcox7188
      @peterwilcox7188 Месяц назад

      Totally agree,why they don’t put everything out at 46% abv I don’t know ,would be so much better.

  • @RovingPunster
    @RovingPunster 23 дня назад +1

    Its been 20+ years since I last ran a whisky or bourbon tasting, or consumed it regularly, but from memory my fave sherry finished and readily available offerings at the time were:
    Glenlivet 12 Sherry Cask finish
    Macallan 12
    Lagavulin 16 (elegant & balanced islay up front, with a silky cream sherry finish)
    Different finishes/bottlings have since expanded a lot, so im outta touch on whats popular now.

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  23 дня назад

      Every once and a while I think the world of finishing is way too overwhelming. I know it's the trend right now, but there is nothing wrong with just having the distillate and a good oak barrel speak for itself.

  • @Robert.Sheard
    @Robert.Sheard Год назад +3

    Uigeadail? Oh, man. I forgot about Octomore because the version I got was bourbon-matured.

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад

      Uigeadail is up there, but the Octomore overrides everything.

    • @Robert.Sheard
      @Robert.Sheard Год назад +1

      @@whiskeyisajourney My first Octomore is the new 13.4. It's ex-bourbon matured and then put in a second virgin oak barrel. Right up my alley. Looking forward to cracking it soon. Uigie won my March Malt Madness tournament, which surprised me because I tend to favor ex-bourbon over ex-sherry. But clearly when the sherry's done really well, it's hard to beat.

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад

      I have the Kilkerran 8 bourbon cask matured at cask strength and the Aberlour A'Bunada Alba also bourbon cask matured at cask strength. What are some other bourbon cask matured scotches that you like?

    • @Robert.Sheard
      @Robert.Sheard Год назад +1

      @@whiskeyisajourney I've been meaning to pick up that Aberlour. It sounds perfect for me. Most of the ex-bourbon bottles I have are not cask strength: Deanston 12, Bruichladdich Classic Laddie, Glenfiddich 14, Auchentoshan American Oak. But for cask strength, I get some from the SMWS that have been terrific.

  • @Heyth3re
    @Heyth3re Год назад +1

    Man! I've been looking for that bunnahabhain cs here in Phoenix, but nobody carries it. 😢

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад

      I'm out making my rounds 3 days a week and I have never seen it. I just gave up and ordered it online.

  • @canal-do-guga-namura
    @canal-do-guga-namura Год назад +1

    GlenDronach 18, Edradour Caledonia, Tamdhu 15, GlenAllachie 15, Ardbeg Uigeadail.
    Honorable mentions - Bunnahabhain 12, Glenfarclas 15, GlenAllachie 12.

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад

      Tamdhu, GlenAllachie, Balblair, Speyburn and Glenfarclas are going head to head in next Friday's video.

  • @richardnixon8795
    @richardnixon8795 Год назад +1

    Looking forward to trying some of these. BTW, the Bunnahabhain 12 Year Old - where was it $69 in Phoenix? Total Wine is charging $82.99. I know prices have gone up but wow, that's quite a jump! Never mind - Bevmo is showing it for $71.99. Wow, some difference!

  • @neilrobertson6849
    @neilrobertson6849 Год назад +2

    Just thought I'd say - if you like sherried scotch, you should be drinking more sherry! The sherry market keeps shrinking making it harder for distillers to get quality sherry barrels. Most now are just sherry "seasoned" or are conditioned by sherry lodges with a relatively quick soak of low quality wine that they usually toss afterward. Also if you find yourself thinking "what would this whisky taste like with a sherry finish", you can try rinsing a glass with sherry before pouring a whisky. This is a trick that some blenders use for testing barrel finishing ideas.

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад +2

      That's a genius idea! Next time I'm out I'll pick up a bottle of Sherry. Great suggestion!

    • @neilrobertson6849
      @neilrobertson6849 Год назад +1

      @@whiskeyisajourney Don't forget sherry is a complicated category and there's a range of styles and sweetness levels, so not every sherry will work. also try other trendy "finishes" like rum, port, calvados, tequila, cognac, madeira, Kool-aid, etc. Go nuts!

  • @rajeshdixit3104
    @rajeshdixit3104 7 месяцев назад +1

    Would be a good to see a “ flavor profile” flight and top 10 - Non Peated and Peated categories… !!
    Dried fruits and raisins
    Sweet and spicy
    Light, fruity and mellow
    Sweet and dry

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  7 месяцев назад

      I like those ideas. I have a lot planned out for a few months I'll keep this post in mind and see what I can do in the future. I appreciate the ideas. Cheers!

  • @patrickbennett439
    @patrickbennett439 4 месяца назад +1

    I can tell you like quality liquors. Im taking notes. It will pay off. Im just picturing the future and my mind being blown with some of these.

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  4 месяца назад

      I am fairly new to whiskey (a little over 2 years) and I went all in with the bottles I have. Cheers!

    • @patrickbennett439
      @patrickbennett439 4 месяца назад

      @@whiskeyisajourney Me too. I just all sudden like a little whisky at the end of certain days. At 42 i can finally enjoy alcohol. I never was able to drink right. Now, i just skip hangovers and puking because I actually drink resposibly. Cheers.

  • @DileepB
    @DileepB Год назад +1

    For something different try M&H Elements Sherry Cask, Paul John Oloroso Select Cask , Kavalan or REDBREAST Lustau Single Pot .

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад

      I keep seeing the M&H and some Paul John. Oh man and how about the Redbreast PX! When I first had it I thought it was a flavored whiskey. PX overload.

  • @rajeshdixit3104
    @rajeshdixit3104 7 месяцев назад +1

    Belvine 15 sherry cask Single Barrel is just impossible to find

  • @DileepB
    @DileepB Год назад +1

    Billy Walker bought GlenAllachie in 2017. So his influence on the 12 and 15 year old bottlings is minimal.

    • @whiskeyisajourney
      @whiskeyisajourney  Год назад

      Makes sense. 2016/2017 is when he bought it so...2028 will be his 12 year? That would be an interesting comparison.