Best Dual-Cab Ute: 2018 HiLux v X250d v Ranger v Colorado v D-Max v BT-50 v Triton v Navara v Amarok
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 сен 2024
- 2018 Drive Commercial Car of the Year: Best Dual-Cab Ute
Toyota HiLux Workmate v Ford Ranger XLS v Holden Colorado LS v Isuzu D-Max SX v Mazda BT-50 XTR v Mercedes-Benz X250d Pure v Mitsubishi Triton GLX+ v Nissan Navara SL v Volkswagen Amarok Core 420
Our largest category has the biggest names in the ute market.
Read about our winner here: www.drive.com....
![Tee Grizzley - Blow for Blow (feat. J. Cole) [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wNLN5xsx5dc/mqdefault.jpg)
I've driven all of them many times, bar the Mercedes... and the Holden Colorado is definitely the fastest, that duramax is a ball tearer!! Easily spins first gear, huge amounts of torque.
Isuzu Dmax the real mans work car, enjoy your “luxury” I’ll enjoy real comfort, power,
Reliability, long lasting and a stress free life.
Martin Dziuba saw a d max climbing om a muddy stiffy hill and it can't
so true.. while those luxury looking toys like ranger is like ticking time bomb explode gearbox in just above 100k odo LoL!
@@ojiisan2088 goddamn , the isuzu dmax vcross is one of the best off roaders out there , what they hell are you on?
Another completely BS review. "The Toyota isn't particularly good in any area, so it wins this year's comparson test"
Jason Manning yep paid fo sure i drive hiluxes at work every day there junk
i wouldnt say they're junk, but they arent the greatest. lot more utes could go in front of it.
I have a 2013 for myself and it was very good so far,no problems and i dind t have to repair a thing so im pretty happy with my toyota now and i was for almost 5 years.
Fev Ola How did you manage to get this vehicle 10 years ago? I know the platform is over 15 years old [despite Toyota's spin], but you haven't own this model for 10 years.
Thanks for the review. The only thing missing, IMHO, is real world fuel consumption figures.
Excellent review
Thanks RMH!
The toyotas got less pwer smallest engine roughest ride least amount off tech but its the winner what the fuck ??????
golden pineapple juice they were paid off.
Well after reading the comments I still can’t decide.
Let’s face it . Toyota is not the best but it will outlast the rest.
Now review the updated MR Triton
Review was rubbish like most of reviews on internet, a lot of talking, no real facts, really disappointed. Why cant they load them fully, 5guys+500kg in the back + 2ton trailer, take an acceleration and braking test, measure noise and vibration with actual equipment on rough road empty and max loaded, take small off road course, and show all this on video so there would be a point watching it, which would be something we as a customer can not do until we actually buy the thing. Please exclude twins because they are just a different badge and trim level, we all know they perform the same way, putting them on the test is just waste of time. If anybody has ever seen a good review on youtube please put a link.
skogastransport probably because one or two of the Utes in this test that are not rated that highly for one reason or another , would probably show up some of the so called class leaders in this category when it came to hard work and this would take some of their polish away.
If they did that, they would have to hire real journalists and give back the bribe from Turdota
Toyota land Cruiser 79 pick up?
I remember working at a diesel repair shop and every day there would be a Navara come in.
Admittedly older versions but the engineering was so so bad.
The engine was placed so close to the firewall customers complained of knocks when it was the actual engine bashing the firewall.
Injector issues, chassis cracks, tray mounts shearing off.
With that in mind I can only imagine the Mercedes has taken an already badly designed cheaply built ute and added it's credentials of horrendous reliability and electrical issues on top, as well as premium purchase and repair costs with higher depreciation.
outwestlawns, agree... a friend of mine advised me t stay away from those vehicles... im now looking at the ranger or the bt 50
Nissan engineering is still bad...
outwestlawns same in the Philippines for ranger
Ranger would have been great of Ford wasn't so greedy. They purposely put that stupid oil pump in so it won't prime if you let the oil drain completely during an oil change so the engine blows. Now people are too scared to do their own oil changes they pay Ford $390 for it.
The new Raptor 2.l engine has a belt driven oil pump inside the crankcase oil....A BELT! the same as its timing belt. Sealed inside the engine oil. And an internal EGR system which needs a new head every time it gets blocked... Every 5 years or so.
Até a S10 taí, quem diria
You guys lose all credibility with this review. Shows you are just suits in utes. The Hilux underperformed when I owned one. Worst in class. Hilux is now just a badge. The Navara is much better every day. My 2017 Hilux smoked worse than the flying Scotsman steam train and spent more time in the dealerships workshop as did the other 20 in the fleet.
1888sparky how do you know it’s worst in the class if you only tried one vehicle in the class ?🙃
Hilux is and always will be the best end of story
Hazardbone kinda sketchy when you see the people who review cars for money favorite the comment of a guy who said one brand is the best forever
Allah O'ahu well its facts hilux has a long long history of reliability all these other utes are relatively new to the game hilux is tried and proved give the other ones a couple more years then we'll see
"and always will be"
Allah O'ahu yes now your getting it
what are quotations?
6:06 "It (Mitsubishi Triton) gets digital radio; and I'm sick of commercial radio" 🤔 Umm, I don't think he knows what digital vs analog ("commercial") radio is. It is a retransmission, of same content, as a digital signal. Maybe he is confused with Satellite radio, eg. Sirius XM in the U.S. 😅
PA TV have u listened to digital radio? DAB actually has stations without commercial content or ads, so he is sort of correct
PA TV Snap. I was going to write the same thing. A completely retarded judgement. I think he believes it means he can get Spotify and internet radio.
steve N Any new stations that are taking advantage of the freedom of the new digital broadcast medium and are operating without ads will not be around for long. It's a commercial reality - pardon the pun.
by digital radio he would likely mean spotify / pandora etc or your own music streamed digitally.
The Eye-suzu D-Max is the only real proper truck here with a proper truck engine. Will outlast all the of these.
S a n d s indeed
Mohd Azizul
Only person who seems to know his stuff.
Isuzu d'max is the only true workhouse not made for luxury just work and off road. Simply because its what makes it reliable. With a truck engine and transmission these are unbeatable for the money.
I had a isuzu dmax new 2015 lasted 3 weeks biturbo failed 3 times within 11000km never found problem after 6months from new got money back never buying one again
aedan bryan bi turbo Isuzu? Think not
@@1nzloyal
We don't have the bi-turbo in Australia. We have the reliable and proven 3 litre 4JJ1 engine.
How about a review on the DPF system in the Hilux, Mazda and Ranger?
I’ll take a small reverse camera screen over a 14k DPF replacement.
As someone who is in the market for a new Ute, thats the real world stuff I want to know.
And not one mention of actual pricing, just fluffing around the subject.
These videos are worth nothing if you don’t review the hard facts. They are just paid advertising.
There are many others on RUclips that are doing a better job at the hard questions.
ottoswinebar Do your homework on hilux and dmax dpf issues mate. And Isuzu small truck dpf issues aswel. This enviro crap is killing great cars and reliability.
I wonder if vehicles with adblue have these issues.
Dynamic D I am trying to do my homework mate (I actually edited my post after I did on the Isuzu) that’s why I was watching this video, which offered absolutely nothing in terms of real world stuff.
Oh well, could be worse, they could catch on fire😜
ottoswinebar alot of people with new utes at work and the utes with the least issues seem to be the triton and ranger.
Dmax hilux and amarok not so.
I got a ranger only issue in 3 years fingers crossed is a blown intercooler hose. Tows very well fuel economy round town is ok but on highway is great. And it's pretty good offroad aswel.
The 5 year unlimited warranty is tempting. Im due a replacement now and was waiting out for ford to put the 3l v6 diesel in next ranger but looks like no go. So not sure what ill do now maybe see what the merc v6 goes like.
I’ve owned a BT50 coming up to 3 years now and in that time I’ve had no problems what so ever with its reliability, no engine, turbo , gearbox , drivetrain or the so called dpf issues that people seem to quote all the time. As a tradesmen myself, I am in contact with a lot of other guys in trade with a wide range of Utes and most , if not all of them are not having these so called problems that the doomsday sayers go on about , but in saying that there is the odd one here and there at times but that does not make all of a manufacturers product defect because of one or two issues from time to time. Seems like a lot people latch on to one issue a manufacturer may have had with a couple of vehicles here and there and the bloody sky has fallen down for them and that’s it for that make or model of ute ,its shit from then on in !! Rather a funny outlook if you ask me .😎 that’s what a vehicles warranty is to cover if any issues arise.
Dra Tempest
yeah too true. The keyboard warriors.
I'm just saying we have issues with our fleet atm. All the Toyota's prior to these new ones only one ever had issue and that was a fuel pump on a prado it had 380k on clock. We got one that is 2.5 years old with nearly 450k on clock and no issues at all apart from wheel bearings but that's wear and tear item and that was at 350k. They were very good vehicles.
I love my ranger, there are 6 of us at work with them as our private cars and mine is only one that has had an issue. The intercooler hose.
One of the girls has a bt50 and it does alot of towing at max gcm and it has done an auto. But Mazda were amazing to deal with apparently and she said they went above and beyond. Both on the phone Mazda australia and the dealer.
I know quiet a few with bt50 and that's only major issue and the other was the air con dual zone controls would click. All fixed no questions asked.
My ford dealer wasn't and still isn't that marvellous to deal with and this last ute I never bought locally because of them.
My oldies have a Colorado and they love it. It tows their van well. Gets better economy then mine but I don't feel it's in same league as mine. It's not this last updated model tho. It doesn't burn any oil like some do. Dad's best friend has one and it was burning oil but they changed the weight and viscosity of oil and its fine now.
Just get a new ranger and be done with it and you missed out on the free bbq deal they had going aswel they fixed that fire issue haha.
Cheers mate 😁 and good luck
Isuzu D-Max good vehicle👍
hmm base model Amarok reviewed not the V6???
Toyota’s market lead is from volume sales at the bottom end, so these guys are on the money.
the no frills market likes the beige, not particularly good at anything, low powered reliable & most of all Cheap workhorse.
At the other end Ford is absolutely putting Toyota to the Sword.
Ranger > Hilux
I'm sorry but the hilux is not the best I could honestly say the best best for a family is the triton. Best for truck use is the d-max best for being uhh... shit best for indestructiblity is hilux?
Australians are so bad ass They came up with their own brand: eye - suzu
Colorado wins by the length of the flemington straight. Most powerful with all the technology needed and most capable towing. Cheaper than most counterparts too.
Colorado is shit they should’ve kept the 4jj1 engine in the dmax.
It's the ugliest
@@Luca-xh2fq they did keep the 4jj1 in the D Max
@@twooccystraps6458 yeah man I know, I think what I was trying to say is they should’ve put the 4j in them cause they had them in the rc Colorado’s previous to the newer ones.
It looks fair but what’s curious to me is how the three twins here (Dmax-Colorado, Ranger-Bt50 and Navara-Xclass) differs in its configurations and features. Kinda weird they are not more close to each other being the same car with different dress. Pretty interesting.
Humberto Rubi dmax and colorado are so far from twins now, have been for some time
So .. made a point about fords NEW 5 year warranty something Mitsubishi has had for how many years 🤔 .. biased?
Umm why are u complaining that the ranger has a tiny screen when you get a low class ranger
Mitsubishi is the best Japanese made car because Mitsubishi is the first Japanese manufacturing car company in Japan, the heavy industry of Japan, Mitsubishi also the winner of any rally championship since 1950 car and Pajero categories
Test drove all these vehicles except the X class. Personally found the Ranger and Navara to be the most enjoyable to drive unloaded.
I agree with you man. But the coil springs at the back of it are a problem. Especially if you want to load it up with a canopy and draws and such. Would need to add a airbags to the rear.
Everyone here likes a different ute and comments better this better that,so i like the hilux (not the workmate equipment level) and its for sure the most reliable but that doesnt mean i have to comment stupid shit "hilux is the best" "ford,isuzu,nissan sucks" like most of you here.......
What a crock ! Seriously , half a ton less towing , guttless , ugly , seating position from hell , class average resale , nasty interior , hairclip leafsprings wont last 3 months before they sag , etc etc , how does the hilux win , how ? D Max runs circles around that thing , better towing , great resale , 4jj1 is the best donk going . So many problems with the hilux these days may as well buy a great wall .
Why you put 2 Navaras the one with Mercedes badge ?
the title already mentioned "best commercial car". sure it will goes to Toyota. or isuzu for second best car at least. hahaha
Hilux wins ???? No power, suspension are sh.t, no room inside (if you try and compare it with other utes you would agree with me especially back seats) and HILUX WINS ......how much Toyota paid this one. 👎👎👎👎
and the model shown still fails the moose test
only 1 variant of the hilux passed the moose test... with heavy tweaking especially tyre pressure which nobody will do so
most 2017 variants still fail the moose test... only selected variants are deemed worthy
did you watch to the end? only for euro dual cab models with 16" tires and lower tire pressure...
it is only for euro just to show what if they had done their job right... if they want to prevent accidents, it would long have been improved... other players can do it, dont see why toyota screwed it up
It doesn't take a genius to know that the contest is between the d-max and colorado. Test are junk or outdated.
Scam.. most of the review for 218 goes either ranger top or amarok... Lol that hilux
Why didnt you guys put the LDV T60 in this?
We requested a LDV for testing but we couldn't't be accommodated.
Drive.com.au
Bugger, think its snapping at the heels of most of this lot albeit better equipped inside!
Some extra time on the suspension and a bit more boost for the next update will put some of this lots price in question imo
took one for a drive the other day. great to drive except the fact its under powered as hell.
I own a Hilux and I know it isn't the best. It's between the Ranger and the Amarok.
superb Toyota.
#Hilux1
Wow make it obvious that toyota paid $$ to be the one that wins 😂
We should have had you on our test so you could see why it won in person, no cash for comments here!
The triton should have one this.
Mitsubishi Triton, Ford ranger, Nissan navara
Very interesting to hear everyone’s opinions. I have driven them all also (apart from the Merc) and have found the Amarok outstanding. All great utes though. I found the Dmax to be very noisey. Very hard to beat the Colorado and Ranger as fantastic package deals but it’s the Amarok for me. $40,000 drive away 2 weeks ago. V6 currently 49,990 drive away. Spoilt for choice!
Renault Alaskan
Do a real test towing on dirt ,corrigations and in heavy sand.You will soon realize hilux is a pile of rubbish.Underpowered ,consumes heaps of diesel ,transmission to higher geared and then starts to have electrical faults.4wd system doesnt engage at times.Very unreliable 4wd.
I own a 2.8 diesel auto sr.
Worst car ive ever owned.Car only has 18000 kms on the clock.
Rangers are shit theres to much going on and repair bills are huge. Hilux is a under powered joke. Nissan and Mitsubishi are average. Forget about VW very hard to work on and parts are expensive. Isuzu and Colorado are the pick. Isuzu because they are easy to work on and tough. Colorado because most power in the 4 cylinder range and there almost an Isuzu .
Hate these reveiws
All it is is how it looks, what gadgets it have its power
Do a 0-100,000 k test in same 3 driving conditions
1 being small runs, 2 being long drive 3. Offroad
Do a real test on reliability
3:30 Shows a leaf spring different instead for a coils at the rear for Navara?
Yeah in the middle east all versions are leaf springs the only coil nissan pick up is patrol y61
Maybe the standard SL version has leaf spring, V, VL, XE, LE has coulspring. The x class is just..navara with a lot of expensive makeup...
Pourquoi acheter une X-class ou une Alaskan...? Pff 😓
Pourquoi pas une Navara qui coûte moins chère.., en plus ça reste le King parmis les trois..,
De même pour la Triton et la Fulback..., 😏
Apples oranges and dog turds. All dirrerent classes and levels of trim, no towing 2.5 ton test which is where most all of these get used. Take this review like a grain of salt as its by far not the best for these vehicles.
Well i was thinking why would Mercedes launch a 4x4! and its pricy and didn’t perform well like the ford..
I notice that 2018 isuzu in thr video is not the same here in Philippines 2018...
Good review :) Where's the LDV T60?
Rusting in a scrapyard.
Wow, no mention of the wide range of well documented issues plaguing some of these tops utes. Another bs review not worthy of potential buyers.
Not sure they got it right both the Colorado and BT-50 are better than the Toyota
Don't you mean "drink" oil?
True, but only Turdota were willing to splash the cash
I have one, and it does consume oil. It consumes about a liter per 10k. Recently the dealership changed the oil viscosity to 5w40 i hope this solves the problem.
80s and 90s utes are better because they don't have as much technology that could fail easily
Put a bigger engine in the hilux with more torque come on toyota and do a v6 petrol next time
guys, why didn’t you include great wall in this review?
boy teebah because its BEST 2018 4×4s
Isuzu disel storng
Ford ranger the best
Wish I had that large touchscreen in my hilux E variant.
3:30 mentions the navara being on coils all round, then shows underbody shot of a truck with solid rear axle? Don't think the editor knows what you're on about.
It is a solid axle vehicle with coils, they just showed the wrong video..
Defeating Toyota in this game is almost impossible until Subaru decides to step in and show everyone how a work ute is done correctly.
Until you have to change spark plugs.
Toyota must pay you a lot, since out of the group they are the least reliable
Bleh . I want a 6month after review . Lol ... that's when the problems start
Toyota
i love the navara
Are you kidding me? Once again the Hilux / Landcruiser "Cool Aid" has been consumed. You guys seriously chose the HiLux out of all those utes??! Lets see: Bland? Tick. Underpowered? Tick. Uncomfortable? Tick. Conservative? Tick. Overpriced? Tick. .....look at all those ticks....must be a Toyota then! So all Toyota has to do is create a "perception" of reliability & toughness (they're actually no tougher than any other ute) and then they can produce a sub-par product year after year & everyone loves it? Cool Aid.
This review wasn't sponsored by Toyota at all.....
It was not a 3.2L Ford Ranger and all the cars are not the high standard models
Ford ranger I see one catching on fire every week in my country. lol
Hilux, one of the highest grand theft vehicle in my country.
Amarok never seen one before in my country...maybe rarely seen more GTI golfs thou.
Navara is decent but meh.
D-max ...same as navara.
Triton seen in accidents alot.
x-class...none existent in my neighborhood.
I keep my ram 1500 ecodiesel LEREMIE
Ranger for the win.
Anyone who has driven most of these trucks and who wasn't being bribed by Turdota would agree.
Yeah, what are they recalling them for this week, I hear they now have dodgy steering shaft welds, will the recalls ever end!
yeah they win at having their transmissions shit emselfs quicker then a man with gastro on laxitives
So ugly bacause of the base design, I only like the Chevy Colorado because of nice interior and exterior.
Hassanal Asri and the 3l per 100 oil consumption
Ive done 5000k on a new model ....oil level same as new.....maybe theyve addressed that issue....?
Why is the hilux the winner in the dual and single cab utes?
cars4days because they pay the most in advertising.
No mention about shitty 6 month and 10000km service intervals. Make it 12 months like just about every other manufacturer.
We all know the Ranger is number one in the real world. 😉
Money, money, money...
Dynamic D true my dad owns one
How many does the Triton burn?
Triton is one ugly truck! 🙈🙈🙈
I love Mitsubishi
Nissan navara
Power???? VW 3.0TDI is well over 165kw and 600NM why use the small engine and the Hilux is made in the same factory as plastic containers
I guess you missed their criteria, these aren't the top of the range utes they're testing, they're the low to middle of the range work/fleet orientated utes so hence why they did not get the V6 Amarok, they didn't even go for the SR Hilux which is another work orientated ute, the 2.8 diesel in the SR would have been a better competitor however the workmate is a great no frills ute that just gets the job done.
Seems like we have a bunch of pussies buying utes now sadly, can't handle a bit of rough and toughness the old basic utes had, imagine if these clowns had to drive or review trucks, goodness me they couldn't cope, no climate control air con, limited seat positions, hard ride, sluggish acceleration...
Nissan Navara
Hilux...are you serious...
Nissan Navara IS the best
can you include the Ssang Yong Musso next time?
What?
Mmmm
What about the Chevy Colorado anyone no ok.
The Chevy Colorado is called a Holden in this video.
Wheels mag did a comparison review in the latest issue and hilux came 7th with some scathing comments, worth a read
Sounds interesting Tony, was it specifically for work vehicles tested with weights in the tray etc?
Nissan all the way
Mahindra
I love Holden
Nice concise review
Im guessing Ford didn't pay for this video like they normally do
pete a Ford usually win these tests because the Ranger is easily the best vehicle. When compared back to back, the Ranger rides miles better than the Fortuna, let alone the Revo. This is obvious if you take the time to make the comparison like I have.
Jason Manning no kid, normally these test by a bunch of nerds that have never worked a hard day in there lives. There test are paid for by Ford
pete a I've driven most of the current trucks and the Ranger feels like 2 gens newer than most and 1gen newer than some. I haven't driven either the VW or the current Chevy/ Holden though.
Jason Manning now I know you are full of shit because in Australia they aren't trucks. They are duel cab utes. Go away you American groupie
pete a I'm English (and therefore actually know how to use English correctly) and I live in Thailand (home of the Australian motor industry).
_____ NAVARA the best !! ______
Hang on the tosser wants to have a diesel not to use its torque to get around and up hills??? Get a petrol if you want it to rev
3rd like and 1st comment!
Sergiu Puscasu grow up kid
the dmax uses the same auto transmission as the 200 series landcruiser.
Toyota Hilux #1 😎
Nissan Navara and Mercedes x class are twin under skin also
Hilux 😘😙😎
Amarok👍👌
Colorado 😗
Ranger ☺
Triton☺
Mercedes🙂
Dmax 🙂
BT50🙂
Navara😝
Sólo es mi humilde opinión Saludos a todos
Amarok V6 #1
Did not watch... Ranger won