'Only Hindi...': Why Piyush Goyal's refusal to answer question in English angered Tamil MPs
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 фев 2022
- There was a heated exchange of words between DMK MP A Ganeshamurthi and Union Minister Piyush Goyal in Lok Sabha on Wednesday after the latter refused to answer a supplementary question in English. The DMK MP, who asked the question in Tamil, was angry over minister's reply in Hindi and insisted on the reply in English. However Goyal categorically refused to reply in English and continued in Hindi, saying the translation is available in English. Watch the faceoff in this video.
#Hindi #Tamil #Languagewar #LokSabha #PiyushGoyal #DMK 
Развлечения
![Skilla Baby - Misfit (Feat. Polo G) [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/IjsylSnNMyw/mqdefault.jpg)
if u can ask question in TAMIL
get ready for reply IN HINDI
why expect ENGLISH??
Yes 👍👍👍
Exactly.... 👍👍👍
@UC5MTUZV4MJZ3fZip-71FHLg Ayoo anna 2 plate Idli Sambar lagao na😎
Exactly..I'm not from hindi speaking state but still I hate this tamil politicians attitude..both hindi and tamil r indian languages..why they r having pblm in others replying in hindi
@@varsha2692 DMK always behave like virtual separatist
As an Indian from Southern state Tamilnadu,I support Union Minister Piyush Goyal's stance.DMK MP is promoting Language politics, if he needs answer in English he should've asked questions in English then.Why is he asking in Tamil and expecting answer in English?He knows that his question will be translated so union minister too replied in Hindi bcz he too mentions that it will be translated.Then why is the issue now?DMK as always using Language politics Trump Card whenever they need publicity.
Exactly bro
I support tamil as a North Indian but
Doesn't like english the colonial mindset language
Everybody should respect their mothertounge
Don't mind me brother , bt u have chose a moron in beautiful tamilnadu, land of Shiva, aidmk was at moderate, DMK is pure devil
I believe we need a common medium language t9 communication between all states
DMK is creating divisons
And I believe Hindi is not a common language, sanskrit should be our common medium language , sanskrit was always our civilizational language, even The Great Chola Empire used Sanskrit as their Civilizational language and Main language to rule whole South East Asia
I dont believe in Language separatism.Our parliament's language system works fine but some are disrupting it deliberately.
Being a Tamilian, I strongly believe that the MP's problem is not promoting tamil but to make problems using the language
Cong dmk cannot win seek votes on merits because they are deep in corruption so what they do is play identity politics. Brainwash the people of TN that BJP is anti tamil so the corruption becomes secondary issue in the minds of tamil voters and they vote for dmk. This strategy worked for them successfully in 2019 elections when entire India voted for modi except TN. The same identity politics strategy is being replicated in other parts of India too
That's how they have ruled there
It's bad reporting, as I have seen the same minister answering in english to an indian from south.. The thing is that the minister doesn't know Tamil well so he answered in hindi as no matter what it will be translated to tamil..
It's because of Dravidian chauvinism followers DMK Hindi is kept away from Tamil Nadu
@@WorkWizdom why the heck we need hindi in first place.
As a kannadiga and a non-native speaker of Hindi, I completely support Piyush Goyal's move. If the M.P from TN has the right to ask a question in his mother tongue, it is only fitting that Piyush ji replies to him in Hindi.
Please read my comment also.
Cong dmk cannot win elections because they are deep in corruption so what they do is play identity politics. Brainwash the people of TN that BJP is anti tamil so the corruption becomes secondary issue in the minds of tamil voters and they vote for dmk. This strategy worked for them successfully in 2019 elections when entire India voted for modi except TN. The same identity politics strategy is being replicated in other parts of India too
अरे यार मुद्दा क्वेश्चन पूछने का नहीं है असलियत में इन सब को लड़ाई करना है😂
@@Aj-pu8sg I wish that Ammamalai sir and BJP get majority vote .Jai Hind. JAI Shri Ram
Pani puri born
I am from tamilnadu.
I support Piyush goyal
He has Every right to answer in hindi.
And tamil mp has every right to ask question in tamil..
Absolutely Right
Correct brother, diverse languages is pride of India
Absolutely correct thambi 😊
True.
Ya bro all languages are equal....
Piyush said right, when he spoke in tamil he put translator, but when he speak in hindi or English he responded speak in tamil.
That's not what he meant and this video is conveying wrong story. probably made in a hurry.
@@gplayj9984 then what did he mean ?
@@gplayj9984 puncture shop wale ho kya ?
@@gplayj9984 he wanted answer in English. The respondent can speak in any language and the listener can use the translator. The question was asked in Tamil and Piyush used the translator to understand so it is his choice to answer in the language of his choice. dmk r just stooges of Vatican City. Al they prompt is colonial style hatred by divide policy and give a free run to Christian missionaries. Come here and see the ground reality.
Hindi vs Tamil
Search for classical languages of India. Mentioned in constitution
Which has more than 1000 year of history.
When asking question in Tamil and expecting in English 😂😂Good lession taught by Piyushji 👍👍
I m a hindi speaker and i m proud of tamil language just like i am proud of sanskrit.
Piyush sir has all the rights to reply in hindi.
"We don't accept Hindi as it can endanger our Tamil culture". But I don't know when did English become a dialect of Tamil? Learn English for jobs, hate Hindi for votes. Just DMK things. Their party's name itself is based on Aryan - Dravidian theory which was proved false by many Historians and Ambedkar himself. Still they didn't change it.
I'm from Hindi belt and I don't find any reason that if someone speaks in Hindi then Tamil culture would be endangered.
I have read in book that Tamil language is the ancient language of India, so Tamil culture is our heritage. It's not limited to Tamilnadu only. Tamil culture is the heritage of whole country and we are bound for its protection. And this culture is not so weak that speaking in other language would make it vulnerable. Tamil is the pride of this nation and its not only about Tamil language, but also about Malyalam, kannad, Telugu.
🤣🤣🤣🤣 nonsense
@@AMITKUMAR-bv7qm you don't find the reason cz you are from hindi speaking states. I am not from TN but if hindhi is made mandatory in schools then they will say we can put hindhi as link language and many more. I dont mind if hindhi is given as optional subject in schools rather than making it as mandatory.
@@soulwritez850 no one make it mandatory
Learn from Marathi peoples 😂 something we don't give a shit we happily accept all languages
It's fun man
Language is just way to express ur feelings ur emotions in some various sounds 😂
Why make politics on it 🥴
The answer to this issue is give special status to Tamil Language because it's oldest language and people will learn and understand tamil dialect.
When you speak in your mother tongue, others can also speak.
Don't spread hate, all indian languages are to be respected 🙏🇮🇳
Edit: wow so many likes and so much arguments in comments.i myself being South Indian,I would like to say everyone fighting that we have 22 official languages and every one of them is equally beautiful and must be respected equally 🙏🇮🇳
Don't impose Hindi
@@sauron2000000 Don't impose Sharia.
DMK MP REPRESENTATIVE OF TAMILNADU HON UNION MINISTER Piyush representative of union of India big difference .minster have hidden agenda BTW I am strong supporter of modiji
Yes ❤️
@@sauron2000000 don't impose Urdu
I am Tamil and in this issue I am with Piyush. When Tamilnadu MP can ask questions in Tamil, why can't Piyush reply in Hindi
Piyushji, you’ve every right to choose the language you feel comfortable in responding. How can anyone demand you respond in one language or the other?
Cong dmk cannot win seek votes on merits because they are deep in corruption so what they do is play identity politics. Brainwash the people of TN that BJP is anti tamil so the corruption becomes secondary issue in the minds of tamil voters and they vote for dmk. This strategy worked for them successfully in 2019 elections when entire India voted for modi except TN. The same identity politics strategy is being replicated in other parts of India too
The stupid guy speak Hindi
I thought that the comment box would be filled up with linguistic hatred but after going through a few comments i came to the conclusion that most of us respect both hindi and tamil which made me regain confidence in the concept of 'unity in diversity'. Well done my fellow indians.....keep going.
Jai hind!!!
This diversity driven with politics and religious extremism from christans and muslims will be the dividing factor for India in the future...this fraud concept was deliberately promoted by congress and still lives on
@@wagner_108 These conspiracy theories fueled by Hindus will destroy India.
Every Indian should respect every fellow Indians mother tongue. That's why we don't have a national language. I want to hear those that represent this nation speak in their mother tongue. It won't cost us more to have translators to ensure everyone is understood. Why English would be the go to language to unite Indians is beyond me also. Its the language used by colonizers when they oppressed, looted, r/ped and k/lled us. I'd be much more for Sanskrit before English and I'd much rather we all respect and hear each other's mother tongue as it shows the diversity of Bharat.
@@panjabipandit No offence, whatever you have said may fetch you good marks in a descriptive paper, but the fact of the matter we all need a common language. At this point of time english is the best option. The way Jagan has gone ahead and done away with state board, others should do the same.
PS :- bdw everything has got the right to question/ans in his/her native language.
Hatred is not in India, it is in the mind of few congress members, communist, few regional parties, westners and few separatist religions, who can't digest Modi's success...
Each language is unique .He asked question in tamil .He answered in Hindi simple
As a tamilian I accept your point.
@@thirukumaranl9335 even me bro 🙌
@@thirukumaranl9335 but everybody shouldunderstand English as well as hindi
@@user-uy2kl9gj9c No there should not be any impostion on
Learning Hindu.In lok they have translators,and the congress allied MP
Is doing politics out of nothing.
@@user-uy2kl9gj9c *Hindi
Just as the DMK MP has every right to ask a question in Tamil, so does Piyush Goyal the right to respond in an Indian language of his choosing. Seems like the question was only a pretext to pander to parochial regional sentiments. All Indian languages deserve the equal respect.
This DMK party can only do hindi vs tamil except development
Im from Tamilnadu I support Piyush ji reply...he has the right to answer in Hindi 👍👍 DMK is doing very cheap politics .. Tamilnadu is failing because of these Dravidian parties 🤦♂️
Piyush Goyal's final question to the Speaker was spot on .. There is no regulation in the Parliament which compels one to respond in the same language as the questioners .. That shut everyone up
Was he asking to answer in Tamil? 🤷
This is absolutely reprehensible conduct. Just to humiliate another person
@@user-qd8in7uw5q no but when translation is available then why to create mess
Tamil politicians : always using language card.
This is shit! BJP had pressed MPs to speak in Hindi before 2014.
I am from Tamil Nadu and I would accept what Piyush did here and it's very natural. Everybody has the right to speak in their native language regardless of whether he/she knows English or not. Let's respect each other's difference and use our intellect to grow as one!
This was nothing to be debated and make it a issue ok he asked in Tamil how will piyush goyal answer in Tamil? their are translators in the house too .
But opposition wants drama to be created even in single thing and to spread hate .
And I totally respect Tamil and Hindi both ..
But how opposition is using to divide us is rubbish
Tamil is beautiful language and the politics on tamil language is ugly... I am a telugu person
@@perambu3441 cry harder kid
@@perambu3441 I am not a brahmin and I am not a supporter of BJP as well. In fact I am a supporter of DMK.
@@perambu3441 nobody gives a shit about tamil, it may be a OLDEST language but nobody speaks rather than uour state people. Out of your state NOBODY can speak tamil, where as Hindi is spoken by more than one COUNTRY. asshole
Disappoints are bound to happen in such a diverse nation❤️ I love the way they dealt with it👌🏻
I am raised & brought up here in South India and believe me every inch of South India is nationalist ideology except for a Tamilan's ego I've observed this very keenly this is bitter truth.
Deep down in every Indian's hearts we all know that given a chance Tamil Nadu can happily make a seperate nation just like Sri Lanka this is LTTE ideology & it is completely toxic.
no chance for separate nation with tamils... just the thought that they have to get visa to go to pondicherry or karnataka to buy booze is their worst nightmare
what you said is right. I'm from AP and we too don't like the nature of many Tamil's.
@@ravinunna1168 Yes, Lankans have infiltrated Tamil Nadu or else it is a very rich state in every aspect (history never lies)
@@ravinunna1168 but most of those TN politicians are telugu..your telugus
Being a Tamil, I love the way Piyush given reply in Hindi. Like Tamil MP, Piyush too has right to reply in his mother tongue. Divisional politics of Tamil Nadu based MPs need to be handled firmly and to show them their place in national politics.
Sir keep in mind HINDI is not a mother tongue it is only language spoken by North Indians. Please don't feel offended you are part of India
@@aakashratti don't mind but please attend your online classes sincerely or if you're not a student then search "what is mother tongue"
@@aakashratti What is this hypocrisy?? The DMK MP wants a reply in English.... But he himself is asking the question in Tamil.
vote for me in next elections
I will unite India then we will only focus on development not these peculiar barriers
@@aakashratti hindi is my mother tounge
Happy to see that members can speak in their own mother tongue. Don't impose any language on anyone. It reeks of hypocrisy when the DMK MP speaks in Tamil and expects an answer in a language of his own choice.
Now there is a translator so it's fine but otherwise, the official languages are English and Hindi and official communication should preferably be done in those languages.
I was humiliated in Chennai and tamilnadu when I went from North to south for studies they impose Tamil on me and say if you not learn Tamil we will not going to talk to you. This is your bigotry. If Tamil is good for you. But my Hindi is mother tough. I feel proud on it
DMK is Seperarist party and has alliance with Seperarist Congress. So as expected from congress ally.
@@bi125ji4 Same goes for Hindi people addressing South Indians as madrasis. You can't expect nice behaviour here with that attitude.
@@athullal7438 Those days are gone. May be old people do. But new generation calls mostly as South Indians. Not madrassi.
What’s the problem he asked in Tamil ,which was translated, then minister replied in Hindi , which will also be translated into Tamil. These DMK politicians can only do language politics and dividing north and south india. This kind of replies cause hatred between south and North Indians . Stop this dirty politics DMK 🙏🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳
After reading all the comments, I must say that, we are really in love with each other...
WE ARE THE PEOPLE OF 🇮🇳. AND We love every culture and language of this diverse land. Jai Hind...
The people of tamilnadu will never accept the way the MP demanded answer in English. We expect truth, logic and justice. And what he is demanding is illogical.
Cong dmk cannot win seek votes on merits because they are deep in corruption so what they do is play identity politics. Brainwash the people of TN that BJP is anti tamil so the corruption becomes secondary issue in the minds of tamil voters and they vote for dmk. This strategy worked for them successfully in 2019 elections when entire India voted for modi except TN. The same identity politics strategy is being replicated in other parts of India too
@@shantharamPK8160 No party plays fair. Everyone takes up the sensational things that can garner votes for them. Identity politics, anti corruption politics, religious politics... Someone's there to take them and create differences. As long as people act on orders of some bosses without thinking or questioning, all kinds of separatist politics will happen till no date.
Sry but Is Oscar ur surname surprising 1st time seeing such as surname....
"Please answer Minister!" I love the way the speaker was so confident with his own broken English, we need not be ashamed of our own languages whether they be tamil or hindi.
Exactly......we must not forget that English is the Language of our Colonial Masters
@@sunnymitra6372 and we must not forget that hindi is our nation language
Every one should atleast understand that
@@sagarchettri4531 no it's not
@@subaasmita3465 here comes one of those guys
@@sagarchettri4531 it is not bro
I remember when I went to Chennai for a trip, people there could understand absolutely everything I was talking about (in Hindi) but refused to help or talk back to me if i didn't speak in English or their native language. They acted as though they didn't understand Hindi. I don't blame all but some who really seemed fake and superficial. Sad this country is so divided.
Dude😂, it's not like that. They don't really understand.
They are congested mind people
Differences of habit and language are nothing at all if our aims are identical and our hearts are open.
@@Sanjeevi7 not true , some can speak but choose not to
So you came to chennai and expected them to speak your hindi this is why you northies are getting hate thinking that everyone will speak your bloody hindi.
This MP is just pathetic. DMK does not miss a chance to do language politics even in a slightest thing🤦♂️ Humiliating whole Tamils.
Piyush goyal did the right thing.
I'm Tamil myself but I feel ashamed of DMK mp.. playing language politics
Right bro
Fake account
First Tamil who accepts this 😂
It's good that Tamil people slowly understanding the fakes in the name of regionalism above nation
@@suryanshrathore6997 there are lot of tamil people who support speaking hindi bro pls dont genrelise
DMK - We speak Tamil, rest of India should speak Tamil or English but we will not speak English or Hindi
Wtf😂
Dmk mpr in Delhi will talk in hindi and english and out side parliament and in canteen they speak very good hindi to fill their stomach 💀😊☺😘🐼😁
@@balasubramaniamramaswamy4889 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣I can't stop laughing
@@balasubramaniamramaswamy4889 that's so true man, I saw them in Tamil Nadu Bhawan's Canteen in Delhi.Unlike other states bhawan this tamil nadu bhawan's canteen is open to all general public, so i went there to have dosa. There were many DMK leaders talking to each others in Tamil but to waiter they were communicating in Hindi. I was totally shocked to see them.
Yeh sab DOGLAPAN hai politicians ka. That DMK MP and Piyush Goyal might have shared a coffee on their way back to home.
There agenda is to make India split into different states so that there is nothing to unite, nothing to connect, different government, no central authority. Rahul Baba's gyan on India being union of states was the beginning of new Congress agenda to split the nation.
मैं यदि लोकसभा या राज्य सभा में मंत्री बनकर गया तो ओड़िआ भाषा में हीं वक्तव्य दुंगा भले हीं मुझे कितनी हीं अच्छी हिन्दी क्यों न आती हो च्यूंकि मेरी मातृभाषा में मेरी जो पकड़ है वह किसी दुसरी भाषा में हो हीं नहीं सकती ... मैं अपनी मातृभाषा में जितनी स्पष्ट व खुले तौर पर बोल सकता हुं वह किसी दुसरी भाषा में नहीं कर सकता । लिहाजा सभी २१ भारतीय राजभाषाओं को समान मर्यादा मिलनी चाहिए यह हमारा अधिकार है और इसे हम पाकर रहेगें ।
These people think their language is above all and no other language is important. If the MP has the freedom of asking a question in Tamil, then even the others have the freedom to answer in the language of their choice. How the hell did the MP think he can stop others from talking in a language when he himself is talking in the language of his choice.
What is wrong with this DMK leader . He asked in Tamil , Piyush Goyal got it translated and spoke in Hindi and DMK leader should got it translated to Tamil . He was not forced to speak in English or Hindi . How can you force other to speak in a particular language ? Few days ago a minister in Odisha assembly was thrown out because he deliberately spoke in Hindi because he didn't care for local language . But this is national assembly . Ridiculous .
DMK always behave dirty ...
I believe we need a common medium language to communication between all states
DMK is creating divisons
And I believe Hindi is not a common language, sanskrit should be our common medium language , sanskrit was always our civilizational language, even The Great Chola Empire used Sanskrit as their Civilizational language and Main language to rule whole South East Asia
because they wants divide politics which was introduced by britishers, They wants to divide and rule which will Allow them to remain in power
They just wants to show their fellow Tamil people's that They're their Savior, if u want to keep Tamil language than Vote for us , They wants to propagate Aryan inv asion , Migration, tourism, picnic theory which has already been debunked, The whole India has same R1A happlo group same Genetic from Kashmir to kanyakumari
Just to remain in power and to Enjoy power DMK continously spreads venom and Propaganda and plays language politics, divide and rule politics
@@nsk3210 par woh hai one of the oldest language jo abhi bhi bohat log bolte hai.
@@gplayj9984 not the oldest its sanskrit
@@tamoghnagangopadhyay2847 oh not again stop bragging and check your facts.
Just because he decided to reply in Hindi it triggered him. That's ridiculous.
IKR, sometimes these politicians act more like children than adults.
because they wants divide politics which was introduced by britishers, They wants to divide and rule which will Allow them to remain in power
They just wants to show their fellow Tamil people's that They're their Savior, if u want to keep Tamil language than Vote for us , They wants to propagate Aryan inv asion , Migration, tourism, picnic theory which has already been debunked, The whole India has same R1A happlo group same Genetic from Kashmir to kanyakumari
Just to remain in power and to Enjoy power DMK continously spreads venom and Propaganda and plays language politics, divide and rule politics
Hindia is not a national language just a mother tongue of other states
@@rohakadventure9027 but he also gave his speach in Tamil so why can't piyush goyal speak in Hindi ?
@@shub_2146 u people always do like tht werever u go
The official languages of the Parliament are Hindi and English and for the members who don't speak either, translation is provided. I don't see the problem?
If foreign Islamic invaders origin language Hindi can be called official language, why not all the pure Indian languages of "infidels". Clearly you Islamic origin Jihadi people want to justify that foreign Islamic invaders language Hindi forgetting the BRUTAL VIOLENT ISLAMIC HISTORY that produced it.
@@iis9822 yikes dude. Try therapy ❤️
@@aishwarya2426 Reality may be surprising, it may hurt simply denying it is same as lying.
I'm proud of Tamil people for their right stance on the issue 👏👌
Our Sabha is like a nursery class and speaker is the only adult . 😂😂
True
Ikr!
Faxx
😂
😅😅😅😅
I'm absolutely in love with this sensible comment section! This is what we need in these times of extremism and polarization. Jai Hind!
We Tamils love our language but this MDMK MP is pointless.
All meture Tamils accept it.
Jai Hind
Absolutely. This comment section is a vibrant extraordinary continuation of the message of unity in diversity which continues unabatedly since our freedom struggle. 🙂🙂
Jai Hind from Hindi belt!
Huge respect for Old Tamil literature and exquisite Tamil Language 🙏🙏
I am tamil. I support piyush ji on this .he has every right to speak in his mother tongue. And this dmk Mp impose English on him.
@@SkumarC seceded from DMK headed by viko.
Bassed on Dravidian ideology.
Now alliance with DMK
@@vijayakumar2967 bro, just asking, like why tamil leaders have such name which is far from Indian culture, I mean 'viko', 'stalin', I mean how people connect with them...
Need SANSKRIT all over in atleast Indian Judicial , Parliamentary , Academic talks ......
Dream ha 😂🤣😜 brahminji temple looter
I am a South Indian and I know that there are other problems also...like discrimination faced by south Indians in North India which particularly a north Indian never face in south India.
But still on language problem I support Piyush goyal.we south Indians must understand that no one is saying to stop using your mother tongue. Hindi doesn't mean North India every state has its own mother tongue some of them have no similarities with Hindi at all but still they speak Hindi very well.
They have already become dielects of hindi and mumbai have become hindi city and for everything they depend on hindi there, this is how hindi will make the language useless, understand why people are speaking against hindi imposition then speak.
ALL CENTRAL NORTH AND EAST AND WEST REGION OF INDIA ACCEPTED HINDI,NO IMPOSITON WAS AMADE ON THEM,WE PORUDLYSPEAK HINDI AND OUR MOTHER TONGUE,SO DONT FUSS ABOUT IT@@Attitudezero884
I am from Tamil Nadu. I love my language and proud of it. But at the same time I respect other Indian languages. Each one unique in their own way. DMK do nothing other than language politics to hide thier inefficiency in governance.
👍🙏
I believe we need a common medium language to communication between all states
DMK is creating divisons
And I believe Hindi is not a common language, sanskrit should be our common medium language , sanskrit was always our civilizational language, even The Great Chola Empire used Sanskrit as their Civilizational language and Main language to rule whole South East Asia
because they wants divide politics which was introduced by britishers, They wants to divide and rule which will Allow them to remain in power
They just wants to show their fellow Tamil people's that They're their Savior, if u want to keep Tamil language than Vote for us , They wants to propagate Aryan inv asion , Migration, tourism, picnic theory which has already been debunked, The whole India has same R1A happlo group same Genetic from Kashmir to kanyakumari
Just to remain in power and to Enjoy power DMK continously spreads venom and Propaganda and plays language politics, divide and rule politics
@@umbrellacorporation5723 yes sanskrit should be the medium. This should be made national language
Asking Just for curiousity brother...what are the political conditions there if election happens there
@@iamhb1006 sanskrit is the mother of all the language. What is the problem in making it our national language?
It will be better if we all be able to speak to each other in our own language
This is the first time when MPs are confident enought to speak in their own mother tongue. Good to see that we are gradually getting decolonized. I don't see a problem here if anyone speaks in their mother tongue. Equal respect for Hindi, Tamil and every other Indian languages.
-From an Indian who happens to speak Bengali as his mother tongue. 🇮🇳 🇮🇳 🇮🇳
I wonder why doesn't that dayan momotha understand such a simple thing & labels every Hindi speaker--an outsider when illegal Bangladeshis are WELCOME inside, even to cast VOTES?
Dada bangali mp raa ki parliament e banglay kotha bole naa hindi te??
@@hank561 Apnar TMC r mp gulo k jigges korun parliament e giye bangla bhule hothat kore ingrez hoe jai kno
@@soumyadeep5 aare ami genuinely jiggesh korchilam 🤦🤦.... Aar TMC r mp der bepaare ami ki kore janbo, ami to west Bengal er i naa...... Ami tripura e thaki aar amader ekhaan theke ebaar jini mp gechen uni ekdom boder baksho...... parliament e giye bangla naa bole hindi bola suru kore daii..... Tai jiggesh korchilam j west Bengal er mp raa kon bhashay kotha bole....
Decoloninized?? What do you mean?? Even you had written the comment english.
A day in Indian Parliament without "bhasad" is a day wasted......
Kudos to Indian MP 👏
As a North Indian, after seeing comments section now i can understand why are South Indian state are more prosperous.
TN politics depend on language, caste & who speak against Modi .
@@anujrbx Lol.. joke?
@@anujrbx not really
@@anujrbx , 😂😂converted will say hii.
Better' than illiterates atleast
@@Ajdjdkalw better than lavnasur
Full support piyush sir
Piyush Goyal did the right thing. The fanaticism that some Tamilians have towards Tamil is appalling. Most Tamilians have no respect or tolerance to anything non Tamil. They are fine with learning languages like French, Spanish but have no tolerance or interest in learning or even just understanding other Indian languages.
Why are we so divided 😢 I’m an Indian American and I agree with Piyush here. Let’s accommodate people’s comfort. There are translations easily available for each language. Let’s not force anyone n suck it up!
When the translator is there with the M.P, still he wants to force the minister to submit it in English.......ridiculous. Hijab row isn't enough for them, now next they want language row.
Maybe some kind of election ahead 😁
I am from TAMILNADU..It's purely DMK govt language politics,they want to be famous in TAMILNADU that's all.
Dude we love tamil or any other language in North. Ughh.. These parties are stupid.
This was nothing to be debated and make it a issue ok he asked in Tamil how will piyush goyal answer in Tamil? their are translators in the house too .
But opposition wants drama to be created even in single thing and to spread hate .
And I totally respect Tamil and Hindi both ..
But how opposition is using to divide us is rubbish
Our MPs are fighting for ur Tamil rites...Tamil is our first identity..
@@MultiBalachandran yr rights r limited, not absolute. U cannot force anyone to speak in your language just becz u r obsessed with your language. Respect every language and try to accommodate all knowledge u can get, rather than restricting yourself just becz of an idealogy.
I feel ashamed being a Tamilian. That DMK MP wants to just create controversy so that he can come back to TN and spin stories around him "protecting" the language. It's all politics, no good will.
A tight slap for the DMK by Piyush Goyal ji..
I'm a Tamizhan. As much as respect should be given to every Indian language, the vast majority of Indians understand Hindi and not English. This is an undeniable fact. When I travel to interior Karnataka or AP, there are only a handful who understand English. It is much easier to communicate in broken Hindi with them. Generations of Tamilians have been denied an opportunity to learn Hindi (me included) because of petty politics. And no, Hindi can never be considered as a threat to Tamil. Learning Hindi opens many more opportunities to Tamilians, just like how English did.
Nandri
Jai Hind
I am from Rajasthan and in Rajasthan alone there more than 54 language and people still talk in their own language but also speak in hindi
I really dont understand how understanding hindi will make people less tamilian
@@chilpeeps in UP there are 4 -5 languages. People speak different languages depending on who is speaking.
@@user-ml1mr1ls2y its very common in Northern region i think all this language barrier thing is pure politics
👍
Bang on ,the more languages u know .the faster and quicker the rapport kind rgds
As indian it's our duty to respect everyone's culture and language ,What piyush goyal did was totally correct ,he didn't forced or compelled DMK minister to speak in english or hindi ,if translation is available then why this nuisance
They always like that nuisance
DMK's sole agenda is to be a nuisance in Parliament. They are worthless
may be all looted money G scams is over - now they are shouting as begging practice...these same leaders they donot even show any respect when HINDU TEMPLES IDOLS were broken down recently or temples were broken down ...
Please read my comment also.
This is the beauty of India, speaking different languages under the same roof. 👏👏👏
That Speaker is like a caring mother. Scolding with a smile. The true beauty of democracy ♥️
A Tamil MP can speak in Tamil, a Telugu MP can speak in Telugu, a Malayali can speak in Malayali and a HIndi speaker can speak in Hindi why so much fuss about it? Who is British here to speak in english. This pure politics of polarization by some MPs to gain self goals.
@@varshavanchi3425 this is where african lemurian stands
This was nothing to be debated and make it a issue ok he asked in Tamil how will piyush goyal answer in Tamil? their are translators in the house too .
But opposition wants drama to be created even in single thing and to spread hate .
And I totally respect Tamil and Hindi both ..
But how opposition is using to divide us is rubbish
Sutta k plan h aaj 😆
@@mayankmishra5927 theek h. hmko follow mat karo lekin.
It is Pakistani language people (Hindians) who are playing politics along with their Dravida partners. In the Madrassahs like Kendriya Vidyalaya, CBSE, ICSE etc etc, only Islamullah Jihadi language is forced and the infidel India languages are banned. Muhammad Amit Shah is known by record to declare that Islamullah language should be the "link" language. So that Pakistani language people started it.
I am a KERALITE, except in Tamil Nadu all South Indian states don't have any issue with Hindi. Just go to Bangalore, auto drivers , local sellers all speak Hindi. Nowadays almost entire India speaks Hindi.
The same people will go to army and have no issue in learning Hindi. You will get only good from learning Hindi. It will help in your business and day to day life
But no one ask dmk mp to talk in hindi he was the one who is forcing others to speak in English
I also learned hindi when I was 6, my grandfather taught me. Idk why these politicians create divide.
I'm a north indian. I think you should preserve your language but this politics around language and regionalism feels alienating to north indians, sometimes TN people spread hatred of how we're stealing jobs.
Government shouldn't impose hindi neither promote language politics.
It's not about Hindi Tamil .
That guy wanted him to answer in Tamil.
Piyush goyal being maharashtrian how will he know Tamil .
But still if he wanted in Tamil their are translators in parliament too
True.
I am from odisha.
I love my language odia.
Speaking Hindi is not a problem to me or to my language.
Hindi is not our language.
Infact hindi is nationally communicative language.
We should respect.
This DMK MP playing politics here.
I had opportunity to work with few north indian colleagues .one thing which angered me is their attitude to impose hindi and expecting others to speak their language and eat their cuisine
Shame on you Piyush Goyal this shows how much you respect southern states....#FailedGovt
Piyush Sir is a Charted Accountant.. I'm really impressed.. Coz I'm also a CA student..
Where are you doing ek ka double now 😁😁
😂who cares if he is CA.....our teleprompter Reader is no-1🥸
@@YPR4022 5 vi fail
@@YPR4022 he is well educated than you KcR supporter.😂😂
@@suhailbhat1996 Madrasa graduate
I'm from UP and I can speak both Hindi and Tamil. That DMk MP was doing nothing but playing Politics to create more divisions in our Country.
u have learnt wrong southern language 😁
@@Uda_dunga Your mother gave birth to a wrong baby.
I feel very lucky to have so many Language and variety of culture in our country ...I love listing songs and watching movies from different part of country.I feel it's our strength
TAmil Malayalam should be speaked in parliament our language also need independence
Bharat is a Land of Diversity... And we must Respect every official Language & Culture... That's the Beauty of Bharat...!
Pls Don't Get Divided over Language Culture which is beneficial for the Political Parties only...!
Stay United 🙏🙏
Separationists shouldn't be treated kindly.
@Nikunj Somani While BJP is spreading communal hatred between school going children
@@petfauna1445 If you can watch a Video with a Nuetral Mindset..,
You're one RUclips search away - "How Jamaat-e-Islami is Funding the Hijab Controversy"...
Just watch it Once as a Nuetral Man & then analyse yourselves on the fact Whether BJP is spreading Communal Hatred in Students or Someone else is Spreading it...! 🙏🙏
@@renabmusiq8936 Okay even if you are right (which I don't think so) the Supreme leader oh I mean our Prime minister himself was giving a hateful speech in a temple recently you are also one search away! And BJP has been using the divide and rule game for a long time now it's not a big surprise! The guy you are talking about could be funding the thing but he didn't start it!
@@petfauna1445 I asked you to watch a Video with a Nuetral Mindset... But before watching it, you came into your own judgement & defending your Statement...
Which Clearly Indicates that, Your Mindset is one Sided Bias...! ( Every Hindu Knows Which Party is Utilising the Divide & Rule Policy for the Greed of Power)...
No More Arguments... Thank You... 🙏🙏🙏
feeling proud for own language is one thing and ...forcing other to do the same ...when it's not someone's mother tongue. .
Tamil MP needs to understand ..
I believe we need a common medium language to communication between all states
DMK is creating divisons
And I believe Hindi is not a common language, sanskrit should be our common medium language , sanskrit was always our civilizational language, even The Great Chola Empire used Sanskrit as their Civilizational language and Main language to rule whole South East Asia
because they wants divide politics which was introduced by britishers, They wants to divide and rule which will Allow them to remain in power
They just wants to show their fellow Tamil people's that They're their Savior, if u want to keep Tamil language than Vote for us , They wants to propagate Aryan inv asion , Migration, tourism, picnic theory which has already been debunked, The whole India has same R1A happlo group same Genetic from Kashmir to kanyakumari
Just to remain in power and to Enjoy power DMK continously spreads venom and Propaganda and plays language politics, divide and rule politics
This was nothing to be debated and make it a issue ok he asked in Tamil how will piyush goyal answer in Tamil? their are translators in the house too .
But opposition wants drama to be created even in single thing and to spread hate .
And I totally respect Tamil and Hindi both ..
But how opposition is using to divide us is rubbish
@@umbrellacorporation5723 stop spamming. There is no need for it
Cong dmk cannot win seek votes on merits because they are deep in corruption so what they do is play identity politics. Brainwash the people of TN that BJP is anti tamil so the corruption becomes secondary issue in the minds of tamil voters and they vote for dmk. This strategy worked for them successfully in 2019 elections when entire India voted for modi except TN. The same identity politics strategy is being replicated in other parts of India too
Politicians will always try to divide us whether in tamil nadu or any south indian states they will divide us on the basis of language or in North india they will divide us on the basis of religion and caste ,it is upon us whether we want to live Unitedly and progress together or remain divided by coming in influence of these politician's,their children will go to study abroad but they will make us fight
Why doesn't ask the question in English? If he can speak the language he chooses then the minister can also reply in the language he chooses. We have to respect each other's language but not offend anyone else or take offense from anyone else. The minister in no way disrespected Tamil
I always wonder how India manages all these languages and cultures. We have only one language - Turkish in my country and yet the politics looks so complicated and messy.
Thats the beauty of India.. Unity in diversity.. Many famous personalities predicated of Balkanisation of India due to its diversity, but India overcame the challenges and stood strong and united
Hello Türkiye!!!
Language was never a Problem in India.......People in Different States speaks Different Language. These Politicians are only creating troubles on these petty issues.
Because we have translator 😁
simple they don't understand each other ...😂😂
When you have a right to ask question in tamil the minister even has a right to answer in Marati ( as he is from Maharashtra). Petty politics by DMK. I am from TN but learnt Hindi the hard way when I became wife of an Indian Army officer. Learnt many other languages when we shifted to different parts of the country. We don't need a single language to rule the nation but the heart and will to learn as many languages we can and live in harmony with other religion and culture
Indian Army has the best ecosystem for these things , I'm too from an Army background, love the way here people have respect for others .
Pleasure to read about your experience and thoughts.
I respect your decision that you learnt Hindi and I also belonged to a army family . I live in west bengal and a Bengali I always love my native language and Hindi both..same .
I just hope everyone( Tamilnadu) can understand the fact and respect every language .
Please read my comment also.
Cong dmk cannot win elections because they are deep in corruption so what they do is play identity politics. Brainwash the people of TN that BJP is anti tamil so the corruption becomes secondary issue in the minds of tamil voters and they vote for dmk. This strategy worked for them successfully in 2019 elections when entire India voted for modi except TN. The same identity politics strategy is being replicated in other parts of India too
When TN MP questioned in English he should be replied in English
Great Slap to All Such People by Piyush Goyal ji🙏
As a hindi speaker who can understand Tamil i feel Dmk leader was playing language politics when there is option of translation for both the parties
Our all languages are beautiful.
If DMK asked in Tamil, how can it expect to get reply in English?
Translation is available, but he is politicising Tamils.
Keep your stand with true conviction , let the others bark..good job piyush ji
Only answers & truth please
full support to piyush Goyal on this. Very scared of India's opposition parties now. For the greed of gaining back power they will go to the extent of breaking this nation. As citizens we should take charge and make our voices more audible to these iditoc politicians who for their massive ego are becoming roadblocks in the country's progress.
They don't need to be scared.We will have to crush them ideologically.
I am from Karnataka.... What piyush sir did was lit af 😂 the DMK person could have asked the question in English and would have definitely got the answer in English
Cong dmk cannot win seek votes on merits because they are deep in corruption so what they do is play identity politics. Brainwash the people of TN that BJP is anti tamil so the corruption becomes secondary issue in the minds of tamil voters and they vote for dmk. This strategy worked for them successfully in 2019 elections when entire India voted for modi except TN. The same identity politics strategy is being replicated in other parts of India too
or Hindi. I don't see why that matters what the language of response would be. There is translation and the Tamil guy should use that. I'm a south Indian and I side with Piyush Goyal on this one. He is free to use his mother tongue as much as I am free to use my Malayalam
bhai try to understand he is not fluent in English 😂 that's why he already told someone that he is going to questioning in tamil 😂
@@Uda_dunga then go to school and learn...
@@utkarshshukla accept the truth
Don't you feel like it's group of backbenchers..just the classroom chaged in lokhsabha
This comment section is gold , whenever language controversy erupts , i will come and read the comments , these are very good
🙏
And the last smile of Hon' Speaker
Takes away the scene 🤣
Both are constitutional language mentioned in the 8th schedule. Unable to understand why was DMK MP so adamant ?
They always do language politics
He could have asked translators too instead making it drama This was nothing to be debated and make it a issue ok he asked in Tamil how will piyush goyal answer in Tamil? their are translators in the house too .
But opposition wants drama to be created even in single thing and to spread hate .
And I totally respect Tamil and Hindi both ..
But how opposition is using to divide us is rubbish
@@nsk3210 shut up all madrasi ppl are not like that, point your hate towards DMK, don't blame al madrasi.
My madrasi friends i apologise for his comment
@@worldisone8282 SSOUTHIE:SAAR NAARTH INDIAN ARE IMPOSING HINDI ON US SAAR😭😭😭,BJP IMOSING HINDIN ON US SARR,THIS GUY NOW ALSO IMPSOING HINDI SARR,NAARTH ENDIAN ARE WORST ,CUNNING,DIRTY,FILHTY SAAR🤣🤣🤣🤣,MEANWHILE:::::::::MODI(GUJARAT),AMIT SHAH(GUJARAT),THIS GUY NOW IS ALSO GUJARATI WHO THEMSELVES ARE WESTERN INDIAN,SO I WONDER HOW THEESE PEOPLE WILL THINK EVERY HINDI WALLAH AS NORTH INDIAN,,,,,,,,,NORTH+EASTERN+WESTERN+CENTRAL REGION OF INDIA ALL ARE UNITED THROUGH HINDI WITH LOVE AND SPEAK THERI OWN LANGUAGE,WHILE SOUTHIE CANT EVEN UNDERSTAND EACH OTHERS LANGUAGE AND UNITE BY HATE TOWARD HINDI,
WE WANT DRAIVDA NADU SAAR IMPSIING HINDI ON US SAAR,AFTER DRAVIDA BODU:TAMIL BASTA@S (THE MOST RUBBISH SOUTHIES(TAMILS)):SAAR THESE NORTH DRAVIDIANS(TELUGUS) IMPSOING TELUGU ON US SAAR,THESE PEOPLE ARE MORE IN NUMBER SAAR TLEUGU IMPOSING SAARRRRRRRRR,MY TAMIL IS DINOSAUR LANGUAGE SAAAAAR🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣,SOUTHIE AND THEIR HATE TOWARD HINDI NEVER STOPS TO AMUSE ME😆😆😆
So they want North Indians to speak southern languages in the south but won't let them speak their own language in the sabha. Hypocrites.
Every MP has the right to speak in the language of his choice. Tamil MPs can speak in tamil, telugu MPs can speak in telugu and soo on.. we have translators already. Just stop this language politics.
Why these tamil politicians always play Tamil card in education, language etc
DMK toolkit
@Daiksu kambe politics!!!
@Daiksu kambe who doesn't love their language (except ofcourse wannabe angrez Indians)
@Daiksu kambe everyone loves their language coz that is the language they r most comfortable with but it doesn't mean u can't respect any.
They win elections by doing this .
I'm from Bengal .... I love all Indian languages. Language is a tool to use communicate each other. So please don't separate us by language politics. Jai Hind ❤️❤️🇮🇳🇮🇳
Exactly.
বোকাচোদা
@@user-wq3gw1lg6f yes you
Right, let Momotha hear abt this...
@@lazytuber3521 Ek Bihari sau bimari.
This is not an issue at all. Both of them spoke in their mother tongue. Zero issue here. DMK MP is a bum.
Just answer to the question 🙋
When you can ask question in Tamil to a Hindi speaker then you have to take answer in Hindi. Otherwise why shouldn't the other person expect you to ask in hindi?
Bamnya gapp bas
@@warrior4454 ka dukhat ahe kay?
@@vaibhav.dvd55 tuzi kay dukhtey ..
Tuza navra ahe ka goyal🤣
@@warrior4454 tuzza bayko ahes ka To DMK MP,
Jali gali
I hail from the Southern part of India . Apart from my mother tongue which is a Southern Language , I can read and speak fluent Hindi, Marathi & Gujarathi . Often in my professional work, I have to interact with professionals . But, I find the Hindi Language to be the most effective language when it comes to communication. For me Hindi is the best language for me to communicate and convey my ideas and thoughts . Even my south Indian brethren find it easy to speak and communicate in Hindi . Really speaking Hindi unites me with the masses and I am proud to be speak in Hindi .
Kudos to you... Well explained...Hindi for practical reason that it is spoken by nearly half of the population qualifies as a good candidate for national language.... Please google... List of languages by number of native speakers in India
@SigmaHitman thik khyo yaar
Yes, Hindi should be adopted and even English. Do one expect south language be spoken and understood in NE India too.
Proud on your culture and respect others, that's what our parents taught us. Not like these political goons who make issue of nothing
Please read my comment also.
Request is turned down
I see my TAMIL bros very logical and understanding in commentbox।
This is the INDIA we wanted brothers।❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Foreigners/some politicians have used our languages as a tool to make difference between us just to gain political benifits।।
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
I really like Om Birla's subtle sarcasms and those mischievous smirks. I observed this during the Budget Speech also. Parliament is such a fun place to be in 🤣 reminds me of my schooldays.
it's just a classroom without a teacher...
Piyush Goyal is spot on here. Did the DMK MP ask in English, no he asked in Tamil, Piyush Goyal Ji has full right to reply in his mother tongue then!! DMK plays dirty politics. By the way, I love Sanskrit and Tamil equally, love the literature of the Tamil Siddhars, these local parties like DMK play divide & rule for their dirty politics. Tamil saints have been some of the highest epitomes of Sanatan Dharma. 🇮🇳 DMK, you can't sow your seeds of hate here!
Tamil is beautiful language and the politics on tamil language is ugly... I am a telugu person
But Islamic Piyush Muhammed Goyal instead answered in the Islamic invaders origin language, and not a proper Indian language.
I am north indian.., lives in chennai and love tamil culture a lot..but I also fully support piyush goyal ji..People must respect other people feelings..no linguistics politics please .
Respect n recognise each others traditions. As a whole 🇮🇳 must go fwd
These days we have excellent technology to translate languages very quickly - just as they are spoken. So, everyone should speak in the language they are comfortable in. The real issue here is Tamil Nadu is failing miserably in attracting FDI due to poor ease of doing business rankings and also a lack of respect for wealth creators. In the name of social justice, entrepreneurs and wealth creators are disrespected though these are the very same people who pay taxes that are used to give subsidized idlis and dosas and electricity to the freeloaders, instead of imparting vocational skill sets so people can work and earn on their own. Then the TN State runs liquor shops to finance these subsidies plunging the State into further doom. Look at TN’s electricity board - completely bankrupt - due to not collecting dues and giving away electricity for free. The reality is TN’s youth do not have access to decent jobs and have to leave the state and work in places like Hyderabad and Bengaluru. This is similar to States like Kerala and Waste Bengal, where crony social justice parties have plunged the future of the youths there and they all have to seek jobs elsewhere. Where is the Tamil pride when you cannot even create jobs for the people? All that is left is unwanted Tamil stronk in the parliament. Ridiculous.
Same happening in AP welfare schemes are more money distributing at peak and reducing salaries with reverse prc, govt running liquor shops, theatres, cement, sand everything here being sold by govt
I believe we need a common medium language to communication between all states
DMK is creating divisons
And I believe Hindi is not a common language, sanskrit should be our common medium language , sanskrit was always our civilizational language, even The Great Chola Empire used Sanskrit as their Civilizational language and Main language to rule whole South East Asia
because they wants divide politics which was introduced by britishers, They wants to divide and rule which will Allow them to remain in power
They just wants to show their fellow Tamil people's that They're their Savior, if u want to keep Tamil language than Vote for us , They wants to propagate Aryan inv asion , Migration, tourism, picnic theory which has already been debunked, The whole India has same R1A happlo group same Genetic from Kashmir to kanyakumari
Just to remain in power and to Enjoy power DMK continously spreads venom and Propaganda and plays language politics, divide and rule politics
Agreed.
@@umbrellacorporation5723 yes, make sanskrit lingua franks, everybody have to learn
You are just a north Indian bhakt from cow belt, demonising Tamil Nadu
DMK keeps saying Tamil Tamil and then destroys our temples. What kind of self respecting Tamilian does that? 🙏
You can answer this in any language. The answer will not change.
Hahaha, what's the problem in destroying temples. Wasn't Jesus tamilian? Ask Stalin 😁
which temples.? where and when.?
More than 170 temples has been destroyed by DMK government in less than a year
DMK and other Dravida parties is a partner of Islamullah Jihadi party BJP and Congress. The real answer is Islamic parties like BJP and Khangress want to establish ISLAMIC SHARIA in India. That is why BJP Congress and Dravida are all involved in temple destruction. Also Dravida parties are NON TAMIL parties using MONEY POWER, MUSCLE POWER, ROWDISM for votes. The Hindi operated Election Commission never disqualified these parties in spite of huge evidences.
Could you name any temple please?
Please comment the truth not your what's app forward
The way speaker is smiling 😂
MP's screaming out in Parliament and not allowing others to speak despite the speakers requests should be Gun Butted by parliamentary guards to remain silent unless they get their chance. Maintain decorum fools, ask my teacher used to say, "This isnt a fish market"