Is there any play I should feature if I make a part 3? I decided not to feature the infamous “JT was short” play from Michigan vs Ohio State 2016 because it was an extremely close play, and I don’t think it’s fair to say it was a bad call by the refs. I tried to just feature plays that were objectively bad calls.
2019 South Carolina vs Florida. UF scores on a run in the 3rd quarter where the WR is pulling the SC DB continuously for 60 yards - no holding call: ruclips.net/video/hrPz6LVYOy4/видео.html
@@heatedchair. I'm convinced that first commentator was being sarcastic, but I do get annoyed when announcers give the "he should have known better" speech for excessive celebration penalties. If someone gets flagged just for showing some swagger without delaying the game or making a lewd gesture, I think that can be explained by the desire for a weak man ref to lash out at alpha-male athletes. My concession here is that my half-baked theory on the psychology of excessive celebration penalties does not explain why some of these refs who go viral for being ripped or outrunning high school players would make such calls.
I referee football and seeing him just watch makes me irritated. One of the first things I learned was when you see two players getting hot, you separate them immediately, never stand and watch
@@tigerguy1013 Did they not tell you about Lawyers where you work? They teach us NOT to touch the Kids. It is not our job to STOP Fights. It is our job to Prevent Fights and to Penalize Fights. - But what do we know? When I started 12+ years ago our Assignor a Retired NFL Official and a Current Replay Official and our SOO was a White Hat in the SEC. We had only put 12 Officials in the NFL and still had 8 there. Populated about 1/8 of the Big Ten, SEC, ACC, Big East, MAC, Sunbelt, C-USA, and anything East of the Mississippi River by training Officials OUR WAY - They teach us to control the players with your Words, your Whistle and your Presence. . When they know you are THERE by your Presence and your Words they will back down most of the time IF they are getting trained to that in every game from every Crew. As for the Whistle we teach that there should be ONE WHISTLE to end the play. And that it has to be blow LOUD. But the play does not REALLY end on the Whistle. The Play Ends When It Ends. And that brings judgement into the game with each official needing to KNOW what each player he is watching knows and it requires the Officials to be DISCIPLINED to stay in his Primary or his Zone.
@deci Dan Fouts made an ass of himself when Glen Sharpe held Chris Gamble. The official changed it from defensive holding to PI because the ball was in the air.
I think this goes beyond “bad calls.” When you have the advantage of instant replay, and you still call the other way, that isn’t a “bad call,” that’s corruption.
It feels like officials not wanting to look like they made a mistake so even when in the face of blatant evidence to the contrary they’ll stick with the original call to save their ego
@@Pensfan5919 They are gladiators! Party of the game is pomp and circumstance. They can't feel good about doing the nigh impossible? There's NO room for testosterone influenced jubilation?! It's insane.
It’s ridiculous that they expect young college athletes in a contact sport who have invested time and energy to get a chance to play, let alone score, to play like robots and not get emotional. Im loud as hell when i watch games. Im not even playing.
Defensive back: Grabs wide receiver's arm and pulls him back even though he already scored a touchdown. Officials: *WE SLEEP* Wide receiver: salutes to the fans. Officials: *WAIT, THAT'S ILLEGAL*
@@darthplagueisthewise4560 The biggest problem in that game was Arkansas being flagged for nonexistent penalties over and over which were not reviewable. I’m a Bama fan, so I was pretty unbiased about that game but at least the SEC office made an example out of the officiating crew. I felt really bad for Arkansas as it cost them the game.
@@brodielay7522 Yeah, I remember that game, too. In Jordan-Hare, this is known as “Auburn Luck”, where the ball always bounces in Auburn’s favor at the last seconds. Arkansas was robbed in that game via abysmal officiating. Goodbye Bryan Harsin. Hello unprecedented and never ending buyout carousel!
The vast majority of these are not SEC officials though. There is more big 10 refs. Several of these games arw bowl games that have outside conference officials so some of the games with an SEC team dont have SEC officials. Only 4 actual SEC officials compared to 6-7 BIG 10
You show up and make the calls. There is a shortage of Officials in every sport in every region of the World. These guys you all pathetic will even train you for FREE in hopes you might have what it takes to even stick with it through your 1st year before quitting because you can't do it. You would be embarrassed by the PeeWee Games they start you out on, 22 players, 2 Head Coaches and that puts you at being outnumbered at least 4 to 1 or more at all times. You only get 1 position where your eyes are and Monster Sized, Super-Fast Guys are moving in all directions. I guarantee you it is harder than anything you have ever done. Plus, you are judged by morons that don't even understand the rules being enforced enough to know the difference more than 3 times out of 10. Those morons doubt YOU know the Rules DESPITE the FACT that you have been Ace-ing tests on the Rules every year for 2 Decades or longer and proving yourself on over 99% of your calls and no calls every weekend for just as long. Yeah. Something is pathetic. But it isn't how often the Refs get it RIGHT despite doing a job that is nearly IMPOSSIBLE to get right and harder than anything you ever tried to do. Seriously... you show up and do it. I KNOW it bet it pays better than you earn per hour NOW to suck at you current job. And that's just the pay to work PeeWee games. But you won't show. All talk. No manhood.
brucemercer I’m a pharmacist. I make plenty of money and I’m pretty good at it. I am not an official. These guys are. They chose their positions, they should deal with the consequences of making mistakes. But no, they continually get away with garbage calls without any repercussions simply cus the leagues they work for would rather sweep their incompetence under the rug.
brucemercer and to think, I have filled thousands upon thousands of scripts and not once have I made a med error that harmed a patient. But the moment I harm ONE patient, I may get fired, and hell, go to jail and lose my license. I take that risk as a professional. These guys are professionals as well. They should get reprimanded for even one mistake, just like I would.
You do realize the referees don’t make the calls on instant replay right? There’s a crew of asshats in NYC that tell them whether the call is changed or not. In a game with as many moving parts as football, there will always be missed calls, but there is no excuse for missing a replay call. However, like I said, the refs don’t make that call
I completely understand missing a call in live action, but missing a call on review when you watch the play over and over from several different angles and in slow motion is inexcusable. Every single replay booth official featured in this should never work in football ever again.
The entire targeting rule is a mess. I totally get wanting to protect players and stop the head hunters out there. But the interpretation changes with every official there's no way these players can know to do it's far too inconsistent.
Bascially they want to make sure a hit where someone could be injured later in life is taken into account, the interpretation of that hit isn't just a referee thing though sonce the fans and the players also have strong opinions on hard hits and penalties The NCAA should just set a standard and stop appeasing to the media and what people think
ya i get the spirit behind things. But I've seen a lot of hits where a guy leads with his shoulder, doesn't launch, or like in the one clip here wraps up like he's taught, but still gets thrown out. It's too inconsistently called.
The rule is not the mess. The technique that players use as a way to try to get around the rule is the mess. They’re not using any effort to wrap up most of the time. And that is usually on purpose. Hence “targeting” and why the term “forcible contact” is used when explaining the rule. Obviously then they don’t see where they’re hitting the player and even if you try to use your shoulder instead of your helmet, if you hit the ball carrier in that area it doesn’t matter what you use to take the player down. The hit with Gerry was incorrect but the one on Denzel ward was correct because Ward doesn’t wrap up and hits the ball carrier up high. Ward had enough time to keep his eyes up and form tackle the ball carrier (the crown of the helmet was down). Interpretation is more and more difficult as long as the players don’t change their style. Point being, there’s a better way to make a big hit without getting yourself ejected.
The NCAA needs to eliminate mandatory ejections for targeting. There is a HUGE difference between somebody purposely leading with their head with an intent to injure another player, and incidental helmet to helmet contact. Case in point, that OSU-Clemson semifinal game where Lawrence lowered his head at the last second and Shaun Wade was thrown out for making a great play; totally changed the complexion of the game. Compare that to the one where the Georgia receiver got knocked out by Auburn a few years back, or Burfict knocking out Antonio Brown, or that Clemson LB taking a shot on the LSU WR in the championship game and it's an Apples to Oranges comparison. Guys in college shouldn't be getting thrown out unless they're purposely trying to hurt the opponent.
Yep, absolutely not targeting! But SEC refs didn't want super powerful Ohio State playing their LSU in the next game... plus scrawny whiny diva Trevor Lawrence likes to fake injuries...
I remember watching a game between West Virginia and Oklahoma, I can't remember the exact play, but a WR got absolutely lit up by a DB on a deep ball. Absolutely wiped out, looked to be inentional, as intentional as it gets, and there was no call whatsoever. Maybe somebody can find that video.
@@BuzzLOLOL Personally me I think that Trevor Lawrence will be a bust my friends think I'm a idiot but I just don't think he has the work ethic of other players
@@dawsonbaker1557 - He may grow up in time before he gets thrown out of NFL... or maybe not... he doesn't have much time left... he certainly was no #1 NFL pick... there's a lot of politics in sports starting in grade school on...
The fact that they overturned that Clemson fumble to be incomplete is mind boggling. If it was called on the field incomplete fine whatever but replay overturned it is insane
@@Brettmanandrobin No, the flag was thrown by the official on the other sideline. The hit happened near UCLA's bench, the dissenting official was on Nebraska's sideline.
The Clemson-North Carolina onside call was a classic example of officials REALLY being directed to ensure that a particular team won a particular game. There is literally no other rationale for that call.
@@encycl07pedia- Right but they may not get the same angle on video from the replay that the announcers or the viewers at home get to see. It was an issue at the NFL level too where it was the broadcast booth that dictated what angles the Refs can see at... and if the angle they need to see to make the correct call isn't present then the ruling on the field stands, because they literally weren't given the evidence to overturn it (despite their being evidence that could have overturned it) In this way whoever controls the broadcast booth could either intentionally or non-intentionally rig a game.
To me there’s almost nothing worse in sports than officials making bad calls, and then confirming those horrible calls even after watching everything back in replay from multiple angles. I get making a bad call off the bat during live play, but to confirm it on replay when it’s blatantly wrong is just atrocious. It’s probably the biggest thing I hate about sports. I honestly don’t know how the players and coaches can keep their cool, especially when it happens repeatedly in a game and it’s specifically against your team.
@@tom-zk9izI often times think that too. I wish a team would just say you know what we refuse to play under these circumstances. We’re gonna take a stand. And then just walk off. But I assume it’s deeper then that and it’s not that simple.
That holding call on Higdon of Michigan was pretty recent. I watched it live and remember exactly what the announcers said. StIll hard to believe that happened. I went back and recorded that sequence and sent the video to friends. Nobody had an explanation for that most ridiculous call.
Notice Michigan gets the most screwed.. I was thinking they were going to include the 2016 #1 OHST #2 Michigan game with that bad spot, unsportsmanlike on Harbaugh and several other 50/50 calls that went the buckeyes way.. It's ridiculous with replay tech.. at least be consistent
@@ballhead1150 I've always said this! No matter what team, if its MSU, Michigan, Lions, Tigers, Pistons, or Wings we are literally always screwed over in ridiculous ways
As an MSU fan, I can safely say that when Michigan teams play each other, the refs screw both of us. I loved the MSU win in 2015 at the big house, but every call on both sides sucked. Idk what these guys are seeing
3:13 "You're a senior, you should know better" as he literally just throws a quick salute to the crowd, like damn I'm surprised at most of these calls being so bad under a bad call compilation Edit: Usually I try to think of officials throwing games as bonkers but damn some of these calls are making me feel like its the only explanation
its so frustrating watching a "targeting" foul and a player ejected after review for it when the play does nothing wrong and is literally doing what he is taught to do to stay safe like wrapping up the player instead of leading with the helmet
LSU fan here. Yes, the Buckeyes were screwed by the officials. It infuriates me when replay can't get the call right. And the scoop & score was not even close--clearly it was a catch and a fumble.
If I remember correctly, I heard someone on ESPN the next day point out it was an illegal formation. I don’t know the rules for kick off formations so I could easily be wrong. But I think it might have been that they just called the wrong thing
Every team has some calls that go there way, and some that don’t. For example in the 2020 championship, Clemson got called for a bs pass interference on a play that would have given tee Higgins a record
@Morgan Norris I think I remember that too. Still frustrating; if it is an illegal formation then call it illegal formation, not offsides when it clearly wasn't.
2:30 I kinda agree with the announcers. Normally the officials are going to penalize the guy that retaliates but in this case I would say you should’ve also flag the guy from Tennessee because you literally saw the play happened right in front of you
"That is a penalty from MARS. You've got to be kidding me." (7:46) That excellent quote could apply to any of these HORRENDOUS calls, non-calls and rulings.
He decelerated and wrapped him up... it was actually extremely gentle for a tackle at any level of football... I honestly don't know what the player could have done to be anymore gentle and still be considered an actual player doing his job.
There's a still image out there that clearly shows Stave's knee on the ground. Also, by rule, the QB doesn't even need to touch the ground with his knee if he's giving up, just the kneeling motion should be enough for the play to die. The refs should have stopped the clock when ASU jumped on the ball and at the very least they should have spotted the ball faster. This is about 5 different errors by the refs that cost Wisconsin a win due to the chip shot the FG would have been. I remember screaming at my TV about this one.
The QB, legendary Joel Stave, kneeled before he set the ball on the ground, which wouldve placed the ball right in the middle of the hashes, giving wisconsin enough time to get another snap off and spike the ball to get the field goal unit out there. Instead, in all the pandemonium, the ref didnt even give them time to run a play and time ran out.
“You never see the first one do you?” Meanwhile, the official watched the whole thing fold out and still decided to give the penalty to the wrong team.😂
Right off the bat man, I can still remember like it was yesterday watching Okudah knock that ball out and thinking “ok this will make up for us struggling in the redzone so far” but when they called it back and then Wade got kicked out... it was only a matter of time. Just painful to watch man. That buckeye team was by far the best we’ve had in a long time, even better than the one in 2014-15.
That should have been a 42 - 0 shutout of Clemson by Ohio State... but before the half could see Ryan Day shrug and realize we weren't going to be allowed to do that!
If the receiver doesn't run a corner route instead of a post on the last drive OSU still wins the game 30-29. QB was expecting a post and the receiver breaks to the pylon... interception, ouch. I always feel those shouldn't go on the QB's record -- that INT should be charged to the receiver, he's the one who effed up.
@@dentonyoung4314 - Actually nothing that happened at the end of the game should have mattered because the score by then should have been Ohio State 42 - 0 Clemson !!!
7:33: So... The Running Back gets tackled to the ground... And gets called for a Holding Penalty now... Alright then. The announcer was right. "That is a penalty from Mars!"
5:56 The Memphis one was extra bull because anyone with eyes can see he caught it and it ruined what would otherwise be our 1st 12-0 perfect regular season.
When Baylor beat UCLA in the Holiday Bowl the refs gifted UCLA a TD on the last play of the game. The player was clearly down at the 3 yard line. The Baylor head coach was trying to protest and get it reviewed but his defensive coordinator Phil B physically stopped him from having the score reviewed. That bogus gifted 6 points on the final play of a blowout made the "over" bettors winners. Tens of millions of dollars was at stake and the refs and the Baylor defensive coordinator were clearly involved in the "fix". Why doesn't congress or the feds prosecute those involved in ripping off millions of dollars DAILY? Because most of congress and feds are being bought off too or are the ones paying the crooks to alter performances. Intercollegiate sports is truly owned by crooks and gamblers. Bettors are really betting that their crooks carry more clout than the other guy's crooks do. Hell the federal reserve stole control of the US Treasury and put OUR NATION'S MONEY IN THE HANDS OF CROOKED BANKSTERS. There's absolutely nothing federal about the federal reserve. I'm surprised that GOD tolerates the human infestation on this planet.
@@MrBenHart I'm with you, it DEFINITELY looked like the nose of the ball made contact with the ground and since the receiver never had full possession that would be ruled incomplete then and there.
The 2019 CFP semifinal games were both utter shams. ACC intentionally missing a flagrantly obvious PI on LSU, along with the SEC throwing the game in favor of Clemson over Ohio State...this only proves that conferences that have teams in the playoffs should never officiate in the playoffs.
tbf even if they called PI on LSU, they still would've blown out Oklahoma. It's one of the worst calls of the year but it wouldn't have made a difference.
@@WaffleWARZ idk about that. After that call Oklahoma seems to lose a lot of confidence. Yes I do agree it may still have been a blow out but I believe if OU kept it close they would have at least tried a bit more than basically meh for the rest of the game. I do believe LSU would have won either way though.
@@johnvanmeter1549 If Oklahoma "lost confidence" over a missed PI call then they weren't really that good. Bad calls are going to happen--they suck, but they're inevitable. If you let a call affect you like that in the first half, then you weren't prepared to play.
@@dankeykang159 dude Alabama was in that year the most penalized team in the sec while other teams were rarely when playing them , get off your bama gets the brakes crap
I've been watching college football for years and years. You just HAVE to believe there's stuff going on behind closed doors when the replay is CLEAR AS DAY, and the call still goes the other way. Seen it far too many times.
@@oddoperator3524 Correct, southern officials. I know LSU needed no help against OU but that PI non call was laughable. The SEC and ACC definitely have a "You scratch my back Ill scratch yours" going on.
@@BucksLAN Both of their networks are owned by ESPN. Some people were saying that ESPN wanted a Tiger/Tiger final even before the playoffs started. My speculation says that they bumped LSU up to #1 in order to avoid having them play Clemson before the final.
the play at 11:20 blew my mind, msu # 74 threw mi# 35 onto their qb after the play, and #35 got a targeting and ejected from the game, #35 was our senior ML that called all defensive plays & audibles, the BIG TEN had just started a ref review booth that year and the play by play guy stated why even have a review booth if they are gonna miss a call that should be overruled this badly !!
HerrKlausinger the commentators have extra angles the refs only have one or two. That’s not defending them btw, thats more than enough to get the call right
I don’t like OS either being a Rutgers (home of the worst team ever) alum, but I rooted for them because they are Big Ten. That call was straight up robbery. Big Ten’s top team got robbed by the officials in favor of the South.
It's amazing how often the home team gets the call in their favor. What 90% or more? I cant believe there are no clips from Notre dame games at south bend.
If you do a part 3 to this, Ole Miss vs Alabama 2007. Shay Hodge was pushed out of bounds by defender but they reviewed it and even when the review showed him to be pushed out they still called illegal touching and Rebs lost the game.
There is absolutely NO EXCUSE for these calls (the ones that were reviewed). As an official myself, I will be the first to tell you that refs are going to get some calls wrong because the play unfolds too fast, but that’s what instant replay is for: to make sure we get the call right. And it’s not even the refs who are making these calls, there were some where they had it right until the idiots in NY told them to reverse it, which the ref can not argue with. Quite honestly I feel bad for these refs because they are the ones who got blamed for calls that weren’t their decision.
Contrary to Joel Klatt's bewilderment, it was clear cut targeting straight from the rulebook. He made forcible contact to the head or neck area to a defenseless player.
"You never see the first one, do ya?" As the officially literally dead eyes the tennessee player smacking the Florida player first then calls the Florida player for the retaliation lol.
Man watching that Ohio State play, I never realized how bad that call was. Don't think it would've made a difference in the championship but that's just crazy. *Good lord it looks like a political debate in the replies. What have I done?*
@Nicholas Esposito it would've been a better game. IMO OSU was The only team that could of beat LSU. They had the offense to keep up and the defense to stop lsu. Osu imo was the best complete team in the nation
@Nicholas Esposito they definitely couldve. I just think osu was the team that had all the pieces to stop lsu. They had an outstanding defensive back field, dline, oline, qb, rb, wr, and a good lb Corp. Lsu imo didn't have the defense to stop osu. So all osu defense had to do was get a few stops.
I'm glad the Michigan vs MSU one made it. I will never forget them throwing out the michigan player for being thrown on to the down qb and then get ejecting for a phantom targeting on his last game against msu.
11:00 I’m a diehard LSU fan and I can’t believe they didn’t call that. I can’t blame stingley, he was taught to do that on that side of the field, but it should have 100% been called.
Oh yeah. That call was atrocious, and it's sad because it happens upsettingly often when there is a clear favorite in the semi-finals. Alabama and Clemson have both had some bad one's too. Its not like these teams need the help.. Geaux Tigers tho.
That's the only call on here where I don't think it was a bad call. Your QB blew the game for you by putting the ball down and then nobody on Wisconsin realizing the clock was still running until it was too late. I watched this game live, cheering for the Badgers, but I was more pissed at Stave than I was at the refs.
Great stuff. I'll need to go through these Parts without distractions to see if below 2 plays are included. From a Sooner perspective: 1984 OU Texas. Seconds remaining. 15-12 OU. Rain soaked artificial turf. Sooners' Keith Stanberry with end zone INT. He is like 2 yards in bounds and slides out. SWC Ref ruled him out. UT kicked FG for 15-15 Final. Dallas News headline the following morning was, "Texas Plants Wet Kiss on OU" 2006 OU at Oregon. On Ducks onside kick, ball is loose and many players are in a pile fighting for it. Crowd goes crazy. Ducks players jumping and pointing their ball. Pac 12 Ref signals Ducks' ball. Ducks then go on to win. Problem is, ball was NOT in pile. Ball was just outside pile and OU player picked it up. For some reason OU player was not animated about recovering it. I seem to recall ABC had bad camera angles of play. You had to study it to see OU player pick up ball. Blood pressure still rises as you may notice given I rambled on here.
The Charles White fumble on the 2 for a touchdown was the first Rose Bowl I remember watching as a kid. Seems to have a set a pattern for the decades that followed.
As a Michigan fan, I still hate John O’Neill eternally and his entire crew for ejecting Joe Bolden vs. MSU in 2015. He literally got thrown down by another player. I had forgotten about that and my blood was boiling again watching this. 🤬😡🤬😡
Michigan fan here. I feel you. What really baffles me about that play is how does replay not overturn it. Things happen fast on the field and referees could potentially miss that Bolden was blocked in, depending on what angle they had. But how does the replay official not overturn this???
Oklahoma @ Oregon 2006 (I think). The onside kick that saw the OU player standing outside the pile HOLDING THE BALL trying to give it to an official, while other officials are trying to unscramble the pile to see who has the ball. Oregon was given possession, officials were suspended. Pac10/12 officiating crews getting suspended is par for the course. Central Michigan @ Oklahoma State 2017. Apparently officials can just make a new rule on the spot and extend the game. Edit: no one will ever feel bad for Texas being on the receiving end of a bad call. Ever.
@@maxwell285 Yeah that one still hurts Lions fans to this day, but at least every team that plays the Lions can be grateful that Football games have 4 quarters instead of 3 periods, otherwise your Bears would not have won yesterday and the Lions' wins would start looking more like the Patriots. We deserved to lose that one though. How do you blow a 23-6 lead in one quarter lol. And even then we still could have won if we didn't drop that pass in the endzone. Can't blame the refs or anyone if you can't even play football.
0:25 As an Ohio state fan watching that game I was screaming at the top of my lungs. I then threw the remote at the floor as hard as I could. It broke into many pieces.
Not a Michigan fan but what's his nuts was still short of the line of gain in 2016 😂 wasn't even close. That's why the leagues should have the residency rules like the pros. To keep Ohio born and raised refs from being fan boys and throwing games.
@11:17 I harbor no love for Michigan but they got royally screwed on this one. It's flat-out ridiculous. That linebacker is being blocked by a lineman and *falls over* on top of the runner after being shoved hard. What the hell? Was he expected to levitate? Also, the helmet-to-helmet is incidental and was so minor that the MSU player gets right up without any problem. I get that the NCAA and universities are nervous about the liability risk of head injuries, but they have GOT to figure out how to enforce this targeting rule in a way that makes sense.
![[#2024MAMA] G-DRAGON - 무제(Untitled, 2014)+POWER+HOME SWEET HOME+뱅뱅뱅+FANTASTIC BABY | Mnet 241123 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Ox29z5Nf1Uk/mqdefault.jpg)
Is there any play I should feature if I make a part 3? I decided not to feature the infamous “JT was short” play from Michigan vs Ohio State 2016 because it was an extremely close play, and I don’t think it’s fair to say it was a bad call by the refs. I tried to just feature plays that were objectively bad calls.
I think that goes into the category of controversial calls, which I think should be a video topic you should make next
Florida vs FSU in 2003, FSU had I believe 4 or 5 fumble calls go their way and all were blatantly bad calls.
Do the pass interfirances from the michigan ohio state game. Same games as jt was short. Also but jt was short in part 3
2019 South Carolina vs Florida. UF scores on a run in the 3rd quarter where the WR is pulling the SC DB continuously for 60 yards - no holding call: ruclips.net/video/hrPz6LVYOy4/видео.html
Unsportsmanlike conduct against alabama vs duke
2:25 "You never see the first one, do you?" As the ref literally stands there watching both players hit one another.
@@heatedchair. I'm convinced that first commentator was being sarcastic, but I do get annoyed when announcers give the "he should have known better" speech for excessive celebration penalties. If someone gets flagged just for showing some swagger without delaying the game or making a lewd gesture, I think that can be explained by the desire for a weak man ref to lash out at alpha-male athletes. My concession here is that my half-baked theory on the psychology of excessive celebration penalties does not explain why some of these refs who go viral for being ripped or outrunning high school players would make such calls.
I referee football and seeing him just watch makes me irritated. One of the first things I learned was when you see two players getting hot, you separate them immediately, never stand and watch
He was poking fun of the referee for not seeing the first one I think
@@tigerguy1013 Did they not tell you about Lawyers where you work?
They teach us NOT to touch the Kids. It is not our job to STOP Fights.
It is our job to Prevent Fights and to Penalize Fights.
-
But what do we know? When I started 12+ years ago our Assignor a Retired NFL Official and a Current Replay Official
and our SOO was a White Hat in the SEC. We had only put 12 Officials in the NFL and still had 8 there. Populated about 1/8 of the Big Ten, SEC, ACC, Big East, MAC, Sunbelt, C-USA, and anything East of the Mississippi River by training Officials OUR WAY
-
They teach us to control the players with your Words, your Whistle and your Presence. .
When they know you are THERE by your Presence and your Words they will back down most of the time IF they are getting trained to that in every game from every Crew.
As for the Whistle we teach that there should be ONE WHISTLE to end the play. And that it has to be blow LOUD.
But the play does not REALLY end on the Whistle. The Play Ends When It Ends.
And that brings judgement into the game with each official needing to KNOW what each player he is watching knows and it requires the Officials to be DISCIPLINED to stay in his Primary or his Zone.
Bullshit
It makes me feel better tho when even the commentators call out bad calls.
No cap
facts
Except when the color guy is wrong.
@deci Dan Fouts made an ass of himself when Glen Sharpe held Chris Gamble. The official changed it from defensive holding to PI because the ball was in the air.
H gt
Best moment at 9:21, when the side judge on the Nebraska sideline shakes his head and says "no way" at the booth confirming the bad targeting call
I was hoping somebody commented about that 🤣🤣🤣
What a great catch
I was comin to see if anyone else caught that 😆 good eye
Also at 10:21 "They gotta figure out this targeting rule." Its 2022 and they still havent figured it out
But was it a penalty from Mars? 😂
I think this goes beyond “bad calls.” When you have the advantage of instant replay, and you still call the other way, that isn’t a “bad call,” that’s corruption.
1000%
Yep. Unfortunately it’s all about large fan base and tv money.
Or incompetence.
It feels like officials not wanting to look like they made a mistake so even when in the face of blatant evidence to the contrary they’ll stick with the original call to save their ego
The officials on the field do not make the replay decisions. I would assume all of you are signing up for this coming season to officiate.
"You're a senior."
Don't excessively raise your excessive arm in an excessive flexing manner so as to excessively celebrate excessively.
What a joke.
Baylor and West Virginia got called for that a couple weeks back. Bullshit. At the highest level.
@@Pensfan5919 They are gladiators! Party of the game is pomp and circumstance. They can't feel good about doing the nigh impossible? There's NO room for testosterone influenced jubilation?! It's insane.
The defender wasn't penalized for hitting him after he had scored the TD.
It’s ridiculous that they expect young college athletes in a contact sport who have invested time and energy to get a chance to play, let alone score, to play like robots and not get emotional. Im loud as hell when i watch games. Im not even playing.
Defensive back: Grabs wide receiver's arm and pulls him back even though he already scored a touchdown.
Officials: *WE SLEEP*
Wide receiver: salutes to the fans.
Officials: *WAIT, THAT'S ILLEGAL*
I remember that Florida - Arkansas game. There were so many blown calls against Arkansas that the SEC actually suspended the officiating crew.
That should happen more if there are horrible blown calls after review.
The officials in that game should’ve been handcuffed on the field and taken to jail.
@@darthplagueisthewise4560 The biggest problem in that game was Arkansas being flagged for nonexistent penalties over and over which were not reviewable. I’m a Bama fan, so I was pretty unbiased about that game but at least the SEC office made an example out of the officiating crew. I felt really bad for Arkansas as it cost them the game.
@@KPX-nl4nt arkansas gets screwed like that all the time like auburn 2 years ago when bo nix threw the ball backward and it was a “spike”
@@brodielay7522 Yeah, I remember that game, too. In Jordan-Hare, this is known as “Auburn Luck”, where the ball always bounces in Auburn’s favor at the last seconds. Arkansas was robbed in that game via abysmal officiating. Goodbye Bryan Harsin. Hello unprecedented and never ending buyout carousel!
Two take aways:
1. The targeting rule is complete garbage
2. SEC officials suck
Thank u
3. SEC officials really suck
4. SEC officials really really suck
5. SEC officials really really really suck
The vast majority of these are not SEC officials though. There is more big 10 refs. Several of these games arw bowl games that have outside conference officials so some of the games with an SEC team dont have SEC officials. Only 4 actual SEC officials compared to 6-7 BIG 10
“WHAT!?” I yell multiple times as if I didn’t already know these would be bad calls
Exactly lol. I'm like Jim Harbaugh, "WHAT DID HE DO?"
My brother and friend crying how bad these calls are lol
The bang..bang calls are forgivable. But the replay or lack of action ones are bs.
I yelled too. It’s so bad to see these refs
I had to stop watching!
I got about 2/3 the way thru this and gave up on both the refs AND the review booth!
“That is a penalty from Mars” lol. That commentator had me laughing.
Joel Klatt!! Love him. He is awesome and typically spot on with his analysis.
It's true though fuckin refs are stupid asf might be more rigged then the nfl
Was looking for this comment
The great Joel klatt that’s why we love him
The refs had money on some of these games for sure..
It’s pathetic how officials at such a high level of their careers can get a call wrong, look at the replay, and still get the call wrong.
You show up and make the calls. There is a shortage of Officials in every sport in every region of the World. These guys you all pathetic will even train you for FREE in hopes you might have what it takes to even stick with it through your 1st year before quitting because you can't do it.
You would be embarrassed by the PeeWee Games they start you out on, 22 players, 2 Head Coaches and that puts you at being outnumbered at least 4 to 1 or more at all times. You only get 1 position where your eyes are and Monster Sized, Super-Fast Guys are moving in all directions.
I guarantee you it is harder than anything you have ever done. Plus, you are judged by morons that don't even understand the rules being enforced enough to know the difference more than 3 times out of 10. Those morons doubt YOU know the Rules DESPITE the FACT that you have been Ace-ing tests on the Rules every year for 2 Decades or longer and proving yourself on over 99% of your calls and no calls every weekend for just as long.
Yeah. Something is pathetic. But it isn't how often the Refs get it RIGHT despite doing a job that is nearly IMPOSSIBLE to get right and harder than anything you ever tried to do.
Seriously... you show up and do it. I KNOW it bet it pays better than you earn per hour NOW to suck at you current job. And that's just the pay to work PeeWee games. But you won't show. All talk. No manhood.
brucemercer I’m a pharmacist. I make plenty of money and I’m pretty good at it. I am not an official. These guys are. They chose their positions, they should deal with the consequences of making mistakes. But no, they continually get away with garbage calls without any repercussions simply cus the leagues they work for would rather sweep their incompetence under the rug.
brucemercer and to think, I have filled thousands upon thousands of scripts and not once have I made a med error that harmed a patient. But the moment I harm ONE patient, I may get fired, and hell, go to jail and lose my license. I take that risk as a professional. These guys are professionals as well. They should get reprimanded for even one mistake, just like I would.
It is because a lot of these examples are for the purpose of fixing games.
You do realize the referees don’t make the calls on instant replay right? There’s a crew of asshats in NYC that tell them whether the call is changed or not. In a game with as many moving parts as football, there will always be missed calls, but there is no excuse for missing a replay call. However, like I said, the refs don’t make that call
10:03 Denzel Ward obviously was ejected for having "barbecue back there" and refusing to share
😂😂😂
HURT MY FEELINGS
Omg I click on time stamp and a TGI fridays comercial comes on with baby back ribs lmfao
He hurt his feelings
It was an epic hit he shouldn’t be ejected
I completely understand missing a call in live action, but missing a call on review when you watch the play over and over from several different angles and in slow motion is inexcusable. Every single replay booth official featured in this should never work in football ever again.
Literally, like 6:14 the ball doesn’t touch the ground while the guy has possession but the still rule it as incomplete!
Corruption
2:24 is my favorite part. "you never see the first one, do ya???" while the ref is literally looking right at the play
The other ref at 9:23 is even shaking his head at that targetting call.
He mouthed "there's no way"
Bro that ref was in disbelief at his coworker
The entire targeting rule is a mess. I totally get wanting to protect players and stop the head hunters out there. But the interpretation changes with every official there's no way these players can know to do it's far too inconsistent.
any big hit is basically a flag
Bascially they want to make sure a hit where someone could be injured later in life is taken into account, the interpretation of that hit isn't just a referee thing though sonce the fans and the players also have strong opinions on hard hits and penalties
The NCAA should just set a standard and stop appeasing to the media and what people think
ya i get the spirit behind things. But I've seen a lot of hits where a guy leads with his shoulder, doesn't launch, or like in the one clip here wraps up like he's taught, but still gets thrown out. It's too inconsistently called.
This is football, the players know the risk they're taking
The rule is not the mess. The technique that players use as a way to try to get around the rule is the mess. They’re not using any effort to wrap up most of the time. And that is usually on purpose. Hence “targeting” and why the term “forcible contact” is used when explaining the rule. Obviously then they don’t see where they’re hitting the player and even if you try to use your shoulder instead of your helmet, if you hit the ball carrier in that area it doesn’t matter what you use to take the player down. The hit with Gerry was incorrect but the one on Denzel ward was correct because Ward doesn’t wrap up and hits the ball carrier up high. Ward had enough time to keep his eyes up and form tackle the ball carrier (the crown of the helmet was down).
Interpretation is more and more difficult as long as the players don’t change their style. Point being, there’s a better way to make a big hit without getting yourself ejected.
The NCAA needs to eliminate mandatory ejections for targeting. There is a HUGE difference between somebody purposely leading with their head with an intent to injure another player, and incidental helmet to helmet contact. Case in point, that OSU-Clemson semifinal game where Lawrence lowered his head at the last second and Shaun Wade was thrown out for making a great play; totally changed the complexion of the game. Compare that to the one where the Georgia receiver got knocked out by Auburn a few years back, or Burfict knocking out Antonio Brown, or that Clemson LB taking a shot on the LSU WR in the championship game and it's an Apples to Oranges comparison. Guys in college shouldn't be getting thrown out unless they're purposely trying to hurt the opponent.
Yep, absolutely not targeting! But SEC refs didn't want super powerful Ohio State playing their LSU in the next game... plus scrawny whiny diva Trevor Lawrence likes to fake injuries...
I remember watching a game between West Virginia and Oklahoma, I can't remember the exact play, but a WR got absolutely lit up by a DB on a deep ball. Absolutely wiped out, looked to be inentional, as intentional as it gets, and there was no call whatsoever. Maybe somebody can find that video.
@@BuzzLOLOL Personally me I think that Trevor Lawrence will be a bust my friends think I'm a idiot but I just don't think he has the work ethic of other players
@@dawsonbaker1557 - He may grow up in time before he gets thrown out of NFL... or maybe not... he doesn't have much time left... he certainly was no #1 NFL pick... there's a lot of politics in sports starting in grade school on...
@@BuzzLOLOL Ohio State was never going to win that year kid
The fact that they overturned that Clemson fumble to be incomplete is mind boggling. If it was called on the field incomplete fine whatever but replay overturned it is insane
Please Don't make a Part 3. There shouldn't be a time where I feel pissed off watching College Football
No kidding
To be honest,that's a part of sports in general when the refs make a bad call,when your team lose,etc
Facts cause I’m getting pissed by watching this
0:47 pissed me off
Lmfao
9:22 at least one ref knows how the targeting rule works.
Had to pause and look if I was the only one who saw this
"After review, it has been determined that the NCAA would really prefer if Clemson won this game... the pass is incomplete".
💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀
😂🤣😂🤣 buckeye fan still salty
@@101Navyseals I am a Michigan fan. No salt here!
eh tbh I truly believe that it is incomplete
@@101Navyseals I was wondering how long I had to scroll to find a salty Buckeye fan. Apparently not far. Go Blue!
Look at the ref behind the coach at 9:20. Even he smells the bs.
He's the one who threw the flag too.
Lol
@@Brettmanandrobin No, the flag was thrown by the official on the other sideline. The hit happened near UCLA's bench, the dissenting official was on Nebraska's sideline.
3:10 You're a senior. You gotta know better than to... salute to the crowd after scoring the potential game-tying touchdown in a bowl game?
Broadcaster made no sense there. It's a game. The kid's having fun, not taunting the other team. Just a joke.
I saw the same thing at Texas A&M game. The RB scored a TD and did salute. What was even worse is that the game was Military Appreciation Day!!!
@@jjmanzano9 and how A&M is an SMC so Military Appreciation Day means a lot to the university.
I remember that game. New York team in a New York bowl
The Clemson-North Carolina onside call was a classic example of officials REALLY being directed to ensure that a particular team won a particular game. There is literally no other rationale for that call.
“The ruling on the field stands” is biggest cop out it sports.
Sometimes they just don't have the right camera angle to see it. There's not much else they can do if the replay doesn't even show it.
@@encycl07pedia- ruclips.net/video/Ja1kLQTvwSs/видео.html This one horrendous. No idea what they were looking at.
Bell interception vs Ohio State was because a computer in the review booth crashed and they couldnt say the replays.
2018 Ohio State vs Clemson none of the field calls stood if upstairs refs changing them helped Clemson!
@@encycl07pedia- Right but they may not get the same angle on video from the replay that the announcers or the viewers at home get to see. It was an issue at the NFL level too where it was the broadcast booth that dictated what angles the Refs can see at... and if the angle they need to see to make the correct call isn't present then the ruling on the field stands, because they literally weren't given the evidence to overturn it (despite their being evidence that could have overturned it)
In this way whoever controls the broadcast booth could either intentionally or non-intentionally rig a game.
3:49 Imagine grabbing a guy and then getting mad at him for contacting you.
To me there’s almost nothing worse in sports than officials making bad calls, and then confirming those horrible calls even after watching everything back in replay from multiple angles. I get making a bad call off the bat during live play, but to confirm it on replay when it’s blatantly wrong is just atrocious. It’s probably the biggest thing I hate about sports. I honestly don’t know how the players and coaches can keep their cool, especially when it happens repeatedly in a game and it’s specifically against your team.
at what point , will a team just walk off the field ?
@@tom-zk9izI often times think that too. I wish a team would just say you know what we refuse to play under these circumstances. We’re gonna take a stand. And then just walk off. But I assume it’s deeper then that and it’s not that simple.
“That is a penalty from MARS”
Trevor Lawrence: let me duck my head and get this dude ejected
The Clemson fumble against Ohio state not being called will haunt me
I was at that game. I was one of the few who thought it was the right call. Over time, I'm sort of changing my mind.
And the fake targeting call was even worse!
Refs gifted Clemson that win.
@@handleunavailable - It was the upstairs review refs... refs on field prolly would have gotten punched out for doing that...
In super-slow montion, it looks like a fumble. Full-speed, it's incomplete pass.
Sorry, tigers.
That holding call on Higdon of Michigan was pretty recent. I watched it live and remember exactly what the announcers said. StIll hard to believe that happened. I went back and recorded that sequence and sent the video to friends. Nobody had an explanation for that most ridiculous call.
Notice Michigan gets the most screwed.. I was thinking they were going to include the 2016 #1 OHST #2 Michigan game with that bad spot, unsportsmanlike on Harbaugh and several other 50/50 calls that went the buckeyes way..
It's ridiculous with replay tech.. at least be consistent
I lost my mind on that call
As a Michigan fan, I will never understand the penalty in the Northwestern game.
We always get screwed over, the entire state of Michigan is screwed over in sports
It's quite simple. The penalty is from Mars.
@@ballhead1150 I've always said this! No matter what team, if its MSU, Michigan, Lions, Tigers, Pistons, or Wings we are literally always screwed over in ridiculous ways
As an MSU fan, I can safely say that when Michigan teams play each other, the refs screw both of us. I loved the MSU win in 2015 at the big house, but every call on both sides sucked. Idk what these guys are seeing
Joel Klatt never will either if you ask him he will say the same thing. "That is a penalty from Mars"
3:13 "You're a senior, you should know better" as he literally just throws a quick salute to the crowd, like damn I'm surprised at most of these calls being so bad under a bad call compilation
Edit: Usually I try to think of officials throwing games as bonkers but damn some of these calls are making me feel like its the only explanation
The play by play guy really shouldnt have been so critical
And he was out of the end zone was he not?
That targeting against 35 for Michigan still feels like yesterday to me. I will never forget that.
I still can’t believe the call at 7:12. He was getting tackled, yet he gets called for holding?
Michigan Player: *cough*
Ref: Personal foul... holding... ten yard penalty... Michigan player is disqualified.
They clearly called the wrong number. The holding call was supposed to be on tight end 83 but even that is VERY questionable.
@@nickgoesvestmode Can't be the tight end, who is 82. All he did on the play was reach out and barely touch a Northwestern player.
@@nickgoesvestmode there was no holding 82 wasn't blocking and 83 could be called for block in the back but even that would be outrageous
It's become a pastime to cheat on Michigan.
its so frustrating watching a "targeting" foul and a player ejected after review for it when the play does nothing wrong and is literally doing what he is taught to do to stay safe like wrapping up the player instead of leading with the helmet
thankfully from here on out players will only get ejected if the call is confirmed
To be fair, it has been mostly fixed.
The Ohio state Clemson awful fumble call was a tough pill to swallow as a buckeye fan. Absolutely heartbreaking.
LSU fan here. Yes, the Buckeyes were screwed by the officials. It infuriates me when replay can't get the call right. And the scoop & score was not even close--clearly it was a catch and a fumble.
As a buckeye fan myself, what infuriates me is people still think this is a bad call
@@GeorgeOrwell-tp8dwMaybe because it is?
God that UNC vs Clemson offside call still blows my mind. Not even close to offsides.
Landon Walters Dabo pays the refs every game
If I remember correctly, I heard someone on ESPN the next day point out it was an illegal formation. I don’t know the rules for kick off formations so I could easily be wrong. But I think it might have been that they just called the wrong thing
Every team has some calls that go there way, and some that don’t. For example in the 2020 championship, Clemson got called for a bs pass interference on a play that would have given tee Higgins a record
@Morgan Norris I think I remember that too. Still frustrating; if it is an illegal formation then call it illegal formation, not offsides when it clearly wasn't.
Matthew Hall I don’t know if you remember but against Notre dame Clemson lost over 50 total yards and 2 takeaways due to bad officiating
2:30 I kinda agree with the announcers. Normally the officials are going to penalize the guy that retaliates but in this case I would say you should’ve also flag the guy from Tennessee because you literally saw the play happened right in front of you
"That is a penalty from MARS. You've got to be kidding me." (7:46) That excellent quote could apply to any of these HORRENDOUS calls, non-calls and rulings.
9:03
Those refs should have been fired immediately, especially the replay ref
He decelerated and wrapped him up... it was actually extremely gentle for a tackle at any level of football... I honestly don't know what the player could have done to be anymore gentle and still be considered an actual player doing his job.
In the shot of the coach you can see the other ref shaking his head no. Totally a legal play.
Jesus is Lord
@@j.j.sweeney853that ref knew that call was bullshit
It’s insane how much of a power trip sports officials have 4:00
He's so proud of himself like "everyone look! This is a touchdown!"
3:13 Saluting gets you ejected in football, but saluting was Jaromir Jagr’s signature celebration in the NHL. Lmao
I’m a Clemson fan and the first one is bad
He did fumble that ball and you could agree that those refs screwed ohio state. Even though your a clemson fan can you agree that we wouldve won?
@@michaeldrake7775 OSU should have won with that and the bad Targeting call
True, there were bad calls, but it's always cool to see OSU lose, I love it
@@nickyg3000 better for the ass Clemson if they played a sheldue they would be ass
Michael Drake I don’t think that that had any effect
That Wisconsin - Arizona State one is confusing as heck.
HeatedChair Same
It was supposed to be a fumble but called it a spike for some reason. Then they took forever to spot the ball for the offense to snap it
There's a still image out there that clearly shows Stave's knee on the ground. Also, by rule, the QB doesn't even need to touch the ground with his knee if he's giving up, just the kneeling motion should be enough for the play to die. The refs should have stopped the clock when ASU jumped on the ball and at the very least they should have spotted the ball faster. This is about 5 different errors by the refs that cost Wisconsin a win due to the chip shot the FG would have been. I remember screaming at my TV about this one.
The QB, legendary Joel Stave, kneeled before he set the ball on the ground, which wouldve placed the ball right in the middle of the hashes, giving wisconsin enough time to get another snap off and spike the ball to get the field goal unit out there. Instead, in all the pandemonium, the ref didnt even give them time to run a play and time ran out.
You can give yourself up by putting the ball on the ground but what it looked he did was the quick kneeling motion and then set the ball for the ref
“You never see the first one do you?” Meanwhile, the official watched the whole thing fold out and still decided to give the penalty to the wrong team.😂
"The wrong team" nothing. That should have been offsetting Unsportsmanlike Conduct fouls on BOTH teams.
Right off the bat man, I can still remember like it was yesterday watching Okudah knock that ball out and thinking “ok this will make up for us struggling in the redzone so far” but when they called it back and then Wade got kicked out... it was only a matter of time. Just painful to watch man. That buckeye team was by far the best we’ve had in a long time, even better than the one in 2014-15.
That shit still hurts to think about. I’m just happy that burrow and LSU beat the crap out of Clemson
Fax I can’t even watch the highlights of the game without thinking about what could have been
That should have been a 42 - 0 shutout of Clemson by Ohio State... but before the half could see Ryan Day shrug and realize we weren't going to be allowed to do that!
If the receiver doesn't run a corner route instead of a post on the last drive OSU still wins the game 30-29. QB was expecting a post and the receiver breaks to the pylon... interception, ouch. I always feel those shouldn't go on the QB's record -- that INT should be charged to the receiver, he's the one who effed up.
@@dentonyoung4314 - Actually nothing that happened at the end of the game should have mattered because the score by then should have been Ohio State 42 - 0 Clemson !!!
7:33: So... The Running Back gets tackled to the ground... And gets called for a Holding Penalty now... Alright then. The announcer was right. "That is a penalty from Mars!"
That Michigan luck for you
@@winniethedrew I wouldn't say it's "Michigan Luck", per say... "Michigan Luck" would be referring to the, like, dozens of ways they've lost games...
I’m a Michigan fan and every first game we play I think that this is the year. That never happens
@@winniethedrew And Ohio State keeps making you... Well, you know...
Here is the point we’re I try to make the saying, This is the year!
5:56 The Memphis one was extra bull because anyone with eyes can see he caught it and it ruined what would otherwise be our 1st 12-0 perfect regular season.
Not only did it not hit the ground before he controlled it. It didn't even hit the ground at all. My condolences, what a clown crew officiating
Oh, I'm not a fan of either team, and I was ready to throw my computer. Those are the type of calls that aggravate me to no end.
That’s why the refs threw that game. The system is rigged they want certain teams to win.
Cost us an undefeated season. I'm still angry about it.
I’m impressed these players aren’t losing their minds after these atrocious calls
I swear these officials must've never played sports in their lives. To get these calls so wrong is just infuriating.
0:31 as an Auburn fan I can tell you this is the worst ref in history. I hate him more than Alabama. I don't know how he still has a job.
6:16 somebody paid the ref to make that call the ball was nowhere close to touching the ground?
When Baylor beat UCLA in the Holiday Bowl the refs gifted UCLA a TD on the last play of the game. The player was clearly down at the 3 yard line. The Baylor head coach was trying to protest and get it reviewed but his defensive coordinator Phil B physically stopped him from having the score reviewed. That bogus gifted 6 points on the final play of a blowout made the "over" bettors winners. Tens of millions of dollars was at stake and the refs and the Baylor defensive coordinator were clearly involved in the "fix". Why doesn't congress or the feds prosecute those involved in ripping off millions of dollars DAILY? Because most of congress and feds are being bought off too or are the ones paying the crooks to alter performances. Intercollegiate sports is truly owned by crooks and gamblers. Bettors are really betting that their crooks carry more clout than the other guy's crooks do. Hell the federal reserve stole control of the US Treasury and put OUR NATION'S MONEY IN THE HANDS OF CROOKED BANKSTERS. There's absolutely nothing federal about the federal reserve. I'm surprised that GOD tolerates the human infestation on this planet.
I disagree after he initially catches/touches it, the contact with the ground knocks it loose for a second. Then he re-catches it.
@@MrBenHart but it never touched the ground stupid
@@Minh-fo5fd Here's a freeze frame from a different angle not shown in this clip. imgur.com/a/rl1w6NY
@@MrBenHart I'm with you, it DEFINITELY looked like the nose of the ball made contact with the ground and since the receiver never had full possession that would be ruled incomplete then and there.
Contact with an official: exists to prevent violence against officials, called if you so much as look at one
Officials often get in the way and get run over... usually ref knows he was wrong...
Some of these refs need a couple games on the ice
@@byedinphukskhids4811 - Just simply corrupt refs...
Notice how many of these bad calls helped Alabama. ESPECIALLY the bad offsides call on the blocked punt.
The 2019 CFP semifinal games were both utter shams. ACC intentionally missing a flagrantly obvious PI on LSU, along with the SEC throwing the game in favor of Clemson over Ohio State...this only proves that conferences that have teams in the playoffs should never officiate in the playoffs.
tbf even if they called PI on LSU, they still would've blown out Oklahoma. It's one of the worst calls of the year but it wouldn't have made a difference.
@@WaffleWARZ idk about that. After that call Oklahoma seems to lose a lot of confidence. Yes I do agree it may still have been a blow out but I believe if OU kept it close they would have at least tried a bit more than basically meh for the rest of the game. I do believe LSU would have won either way though.
@@johnvanmeter1549 If Oklahoma "lost confidence" over a missed PI call then they weren't really that good. Bad calls are going to happen--they suck, but they're inevitable. If you let a call affect you like that in the first half, then you weren't prepared to play.
Just watch any SEC game when Auburn Plays LSU or Alabama and you will see the worst no calls
Like Ohio State vrs (insert Big ten team here)
Lol let’s see what Arkansas and ole miss fans have to say about this comment
*when anyone plays Alabama
@@dankeykang159 dude Alabama was in that year the most penalized team in the sec while other teams were rarely when playing them , get off your bama gets the brakes crap
@@1969chgoodwin wtf I dont think so. Bama gets a lot of favorable calls at crucial times
I've been watching college football for years and years. You just HAVE to believe there's stuff going on behind closed doors when the replay is CLEAR AS DAY, and the call still goes the other way. Seen it far too many times.
As a Clemson fan sitting with an OSU Fan I was pissed when I saw that touchdown and then when it was overturned I was confused
Wow what is with osu and fumbles as well as bad targeting calls
Sec refs for this game and acc refs for LSU vs OU rigged I think so
Yep.
@@oddoperator3524 Correct, southern officials. I know LSU needed no help against OU but that PI non call was laughable. The SEC and ACC definitely have a "You scratch my back Ill scratch yours" going on.
@@BucksLAN Both of their networks are owned by ESPN. Some people were saying that ESPN wanted a Tiger/Tiger final even before the playoffs started. My speculation says that they bumped LSU up to #1 in order to avoid having them play Clemson before the final.
Look at the Ohio state Bama game back in 14 there where Pac 12 refs
the play at 11:20 blew my mind, msu # 74 threw mi# 35 onto their qb after the play, and #35 got a targeting and ejected from the game, #35 was our senior ML that called all defensive plays & audibles, the BIG TEN had just started a ref review booth that year and the play by play guy stated why even have a review booth if they are gonna miss a call that should be overruled this badly !!
Honestly, why can't the commentators have a say in anything? They are 99% right almost all the time...
Right, right?? Like why are they paying the refs when the commentators get it right like every time?
HerrKlausinger the commentators have extra angles the refs only have one or two. That’s not defending them btw, thats more than enough to get the call right
aaron4094 _ actually the refs also get those angles and more they should get these correct more
Because then the predetermined winners wouldn't win.
Calls are a lot easier in super slow mo with 3 looks.
9:28 Rest in piece, Daniel Dufrene
Mills Productions What happened?
@@andy7376 I don't know. Juice Williams said that it involved shooting. I'm not sure tho.
look like he broke his fingers on that play
You could do a full compilation on all the times John O’Neill has screwed over Penn State...
The Swindle in the Swamp needs its own video.
As much as I don't like Ohio State, that call against Clemson was such bs.
Agreed
We got jobbed
I don’t like OS either being a Rutgers (home of the worst team ever) alum, but I rooted for them because they are Big Ten. That call was straight up robbery. Big Ten’s top team got robbed by the officials in favor of the South.
OSU getting robbed a lot in this video.
Agreed
I'm glad this highlights how much Michigan gets screwed
yupp its annoying how much it happens you can even see harbaugh laughing at one point since he's used to being screwed
9:24 Even the other ref can’t believe that call.
It's amazing how often the home team gets the call in their favor. What 90% or more?
I cant believe there are no clips from Notre dame games at south bend.
That would require a 60 minute special to cover all the Notre Dame stadium "magic".
These videos makes me believe that college sports are low key rigged in the big moments
Low key? It's blatant
They are and it's not low key
OKST v TEXAS 2015
it's not rigged and there isn't some sports wide conspiracy sorry to disappoint. refs just suck
The worst part is that they couldn't get it right WITH replay. Amazing.
Maybe you should do worst calls in college football history by conference, every team if you can
I will look into it, that would be a fun project.
If you do a part 3 to this, Ole Miss vs Alabama 2007. Shay Hodge was pushed out of bounds by defender but they reviewed it and even when the review showed him to be pushed out they still called illegal touching and Rebs lost the game.
9:23 - Side Judge shaking his head... Love it
Man couldn't believe it.
Even he knew that was bullshit
There is absolutely NO EXCUSE for these calls (the ones that were reviewed). As an official myself, I will be the first to tell you that refs are going to get some calls wrong because the play unfolds too fast, but that’s what instant replay is for: to make sure we get the call right. And it’s not even the refs who are making these calls, there were some where they had it right until the idiots in NY told them to reverse it, which the ref can not argue with. Quite honestly I feel bad for these refs because they are the ones who got blamed for calls that weren’t their decision.
10:03 "Hitting too hard, number 12. Thant's a 15 yard penalty and ejection."
Contrary to Joel Klatt's bewilderment, it was clear cut targeting straight from the rulebook. He made forcible contact to the head or neck area to a defenseless player.
"You never see the first one, do ya?" As the officially literally dead eyes the tennessee player smacking the Florida player first then calls the Florida player for the retaliation lol.
Man watching that Ohio State play, I never realized how bad that call was. Don't think it would've made a difference in the championship but that's just crazy.
*Good lord it looks like a political debate in the replies. What have I done?*
Yea I was baffled when they overturned that. He took so many steps with the ball, I just can’t comprehend how that’s not a catch.
@Nicholas Esposito it would've been a better game. IMO OSU was The only team that could of beat LSU. They had the offense to keep up and the defense to stop lsu. Osu imo was the best complete team in the nation
@@pschighlights head coordinating official of the ncaa went on to say it was a bad call.
@Nicholas Esposito they definitely couldve. I just think osu was the team that had all the pieces to stop lsu. They had an outstanding defensive back field, dline, oline, qb, rb, wr, and a good lb Corp. Lsu imo didn't have the defense to stop osu. So all osu defense had to do was get a few stops.
@Nicholas Esposito well bama also beat them twice
That TENN vs UF one is atrocious lol. He was looking at BOTH GUYS!
I'm glad the Michigan vs MSU one made it. I will never forget them throwing out the michigan player for being thrown on to the down qb and then get ejecting for a phantom targeting on his last game against msu.
auburn this year is getting gifted with wins. first against arkansas then ole miss. you could make an auburn refs suckiness compilation
11:00 I’m a diehard LSU fan and I can’t believe they didn’t call that. I can’t blame stingley, he was taught to do that on that side of the field, but it should have 100% been called.
Oh yeah. That call was atrocious, and it's sad because it happens upsettingly often when there is a clear favorite in the semi-finals. Alabama and Clemson have both had some bad one's too. Its not like these teams need the help.. Geaux Tigers tho.
True, but im pretty sure it didnt make a difference in who won the game lol
My blood pressure didn’t need this video lol
And my team wasn’t even in any of the clips
That Wisconsin vs ASU game will haunt me forever
That's the only call on here where I don't think it was a bad call. Your QB blew the game for you by putting the ball down and then nobody on Wisconsin realizing the clock was still running until it was too late. I watched this game live, cheering for the Badgers, but I was more pissed at Stave than I was at the refs.
Great stuff. I'll need to go through these Parts without distractions to see if below 2 plays are included. From a Sooner perspective:
1984 OU Texas. Seconds remaining. 15-12 OU. Rain soaked artificial turf. Sooners' Keith Stanberry with end zone INT. He is like 2 yards in bounds and slides out. SWC Ref ruled him out. UT kicked FG for 15-15 Final. Dallas News headline the following morning was, "Texas Plants Wet Kiss on OU"
2006 OU at Oregon. On Ducks onside kick, ball is loose and many players are in a pile fighting for it. Crowd goes crazy. Ducks players jumping and pointing their ball. Pac 12 Ref signals Ducks' ball. Ducks then go on to win. Problem is, ball was NOT in pile. Ball was just outside pile and OU player picked it up. For some reason OU player was not animated about recovering it. I seem to recall ABC had bad camera angles of play. You had to study it to see OU player pick up ball.
Blood pressure still rises as you may notice given I rambled on here.
The Charles White fumble on the 2 for a touchdown was the first Rose Bowl I remember watching as a kid. Seems to have a set a pattern for the decades that followed.
5:05 that ref must've thought this was the nfl lol
If you look at the replays that cbs provided, he actually had two feet in. I remember like it was yesterday.
It was an NFL level interception ,which makes it even more inexcusable!!
As a Michigan fan, I still hate John O’Neill eternally and his entire crew for ejecting Joe Bolden vs. MSU in 2015. He literally got thrown down by another player.
I had forgotten about that and my blood was boiling again watching this. 🤬😡🤬😡
Eternally? Dammn! Time to move on Weston!
@@LaBanane-rp7myNo
Michigan fan here. I feel you. What really baffles me about that play is how does replay not overturn it. Things happen fast on the field and referees could potentially miss that Bolden was blocked in, depending on what angle they had. But how does the replay official not overturn this???
The dude wasn’t thrown down, he turned towards the QB and “flopped” it basically 😂
Oklahoma @ Oregon 2006 (I think). The onside kick that saw the OU player standing outside the pile HOLDING THE BALL trying to give it to an official, while other officials are trying to unscramble the pile to see who has the ball. Oregon was given possession, officials were suspended. Pac10/12 officiating crews getting suspended is par for the course.
Central Michigan @ Oklahoma State 2017. Apparently officials can just make a new rule on the spot and extend the game.
Edit: no one will ever feel bad for Texas being on the receiving end of a bad call. Ever.
As a Detroit Lions fan, seeing these "catches" is causing me to wonder how they were better than Megatron's catch.
Jazz Peavy can empathize with Megatron for a highway robbery by the officials on a clear catch.
I am a die hard Bears fan, but even I said that was a catch watching it live.
@@maxwell285 Yeah that one still hurts Lions fans to this day, but at least every team that plays the Lions can be grateful that Football games have 4 quarters instead of 3 periods, otherwise your Bears would not have won yesterday and the Lions' wins would start looking more like the Patriots. We deserved to lose that one though. How do you blow a 23-6 lead in one quarter lol. And even then we still could have won if we didn't drop that pass in the endzone. Can't blame the refs or anyone if you can't even play football.
0:25 As an Ohio state fan watching that game I was screaming at the top of my lungs. I then threw the remote at the floor as hard as I could. It broke into many pieces.
You now understand how Michigan fans feel
@@ballhead1150 Lol. OSU IS BETTER
Not a Michigan fan but what's his nuts was still short of the line of gain in 2016 😂 wasn't even close. That's why the leagues should have the residency rules like the pros. To keep Ohio born and raised refs from being fan boys and throwing games.
I’m a Bama fan and I was heated asf at that call lmao
@@ballhead1150 it’s gonna keep happening until you get rid of Harbaugh
Bro the UCLA Nebraska targeting call was ridiculous. That is literally a perfect and clean tackle
That one LSU Texas a&m game was a missed fumble exactly like Ohio State Clemson one
Brandon Mason we won 19-7 it wouldn’t have mattered
No it wasn’t. If that play had happened in the end zone, you’d be saying it was incomplete, and you know it.
Neil Baker jace sternberg obviously caught it and fumbled
@11:17 I harbor no love for Michigan but they got royally screwed on this one. It's flat-out ridiculous. That linebacker is being blocked by a lineman and *falls over* on top of the runner after being shoved hard. What the hell? Was he expected to levitate? Also, the helmet-to-helmet is incidental and was so minor that the MSU player gets right up without any problem.
I get that the NCAA and universities are nervous about the liability risk of head injuries, but they have GOT to figure out how to enforce this targeting rule in a way that makes sense.
That Nigel bradham hit is still one of the hardest, cleanest hits I've seen
"After reviewing the play, the blown call on the field is confirmed."
LOL!!!!
2:27, you never see the first one. Unless you're looking right at it.
Some of those calls, especially the replay calls, makes you wonder if the officials had bets on the games.
LMAO: This video is dangerous, I wonder how many people punched a whole in their computer screen watching this ,,,,,,,,, !
I say it every year, they need to start implementing ridiculous fines for these officials.
Every excessive celebration call ever called is a bad call
6:48 still haunts me to this day. Go Heels