Correction: Fallen Leaves returned to his ancestors after the Great Battle. It's still sad because he'll fade and never see Hollyleaf again, but at least he isn't trapped in those tunnels for eternity.
Bright Guardian Akira GOOD LORD WAT WIT DAT FACE FOR..........No eyes person......is his name bone...? But seriously DATS DANG FREAKY Edited: oh wait it’s rock
Random badger- *kills Cinderpelt* Random Starclan cat 1- "WAIT BUT SHE WAS A FAN FAVORITE WHAT WILL WE DO" Random Starclan cat 2- "Actually the Power of three is kind of soon, and that series will have the reincarnation insanity, so let's prepare our readers and make cinder fans happy by nonsensically reincarnating her" Random Starclan cat 1- "Yeah sure, this kitten kind of looks like her" *tosses Cinderpelt's soul in a random babie's body*
Ikr? And it's not just them either. Petalnose (Sagenose & Mintfur's single mum) and Rockshade (Pebbleshine's uncle) both just vanish without explanation, too. I know most people don't care, especially since these four were introduced in super additions nobody cares about, but *I* liked them :0)
I also have a mystery why don’t cats know about the dark forest in the full arcs? It shows that in pinestar’s choice, when they are talking about what mapleshade did, he says ‘if she doesn’t go to the place of no stars than there is no justice’ so it shows that they know about it so why don’t the cats know about before omen of the stars or power of three?
I think it's because the first arc is from FireStar's perspective and as he was a kittypet, he didn't know about StarClan or the dark forest. He was told that StarClan existed, but nobody mentioned the dark forest, at least not in front of him. Dunno what's up with the second series..
1. They were pointless. 2. yES because she’s stubborn 3. well dUH of course 4. because she’s one of the *best cats ever* 5. She is an excuse to be a very good badger that speaks to cats and always save the day 6. His purpose is to be the ugliest cat in Warriors and to make Jayfeather obey him 7. to give hOlLyLeAf a FrIeNd 8. It works. There. Those are my answers. Edit: oh my goodness 55 likes?! Thank you so much! Edit 2: 101 LIKES? OH MY GOODNESS! Edit 3: 301 likes. Wow.
Actually the Midnight mystery is not a mystery (sry if this is rude), reading from the Warriors Ultimate Guide: Midnight is no ordinary badger: With Rock, she had watched the very first sunrise over the lake and had seen reflected in the fiery surface the futures of Clans, Tribes, Ancient cats, and more. Together, Midnight and Rock watched over the cats by the lake and prepared for the day that could have been the sunset of the ways of the Clans, but instead heralded a new dawn. Meaning she is imortal. Just saying.......
or it’s just another inconsistency in the Ultimate Guide. I’m pretty sure Rock says that he never left the cave at one point. i wouldn’t use the ultimate guide as fact or a good source
7: Fallen Leaves is basically just like Rock, a distraction. The explanation to why is he trapped is that, probably, the tunnels are like StarClan to him. He can hunt, just like the cats from StarClan can hunt on their lands.
But why is he alone there, except for Rock? I honestly can't believe he's the only softpaw who hasn't returned from the tunnels in the entire existence of the Ancients.
Yeah. It's so confusing how prophecies are made. From the book, Midnight, Bluestar said she had a prophecy or something about the clans being destroyed. Then she gives that prophecy to Brambleclaw and acts like she made that prophecy. How does that work?
About Fallen leaves, is why it labeled them mates is because Fallen leaves got out of the tunnels after Hollyleaf died, and they both went to star clan with Everyone else.
I’ve come up with an idea about Rock. What he lives in a endless cycle where he sees all the events of warriors over and over and he is forced to say and do everything he does in every incarnation of the cycle. This would why he is so harsh when saying that the clans should have forgotten about the dark forest cat so they didn’t get too powerful, because he doesn’t have the ability to forget anything ever. Also I like the idea that he basically adopted Midnight (if she was ever living) and taught her how to speak cat.
1. Why was the mouse Longtail tried to get for Mousefur so important? 2. Why is Yellowfang's ghost so annoying? 3. What color are Dovewing's eyes (hint: green) 4. What color is Scourge's collar? (hint: purple)
Ideas: 1. They probably just died off screen somehow 2. Considering The Broken Code is almost over, I will say they won’t come back. 3. No. A Place of No Stars disproves this. 4. Cinderpelt died at the same time Cinderkit was born. This is why. 5. Midnight is a spirit (this may have been confirmed). I think she is meant to be mysterious and unknown. 6. I don’t know enough about Rock to answer this question. 7. Fallen Leaves never went to StarClan, because it didn’t exist back then. He is a ghost and ghosts don’t fade. 8. I don’t know. It just does.
Maybe Rock was not "Cursed" exactly but planned from the very begging as the cat who would lead the Ancients to join with StarClan as well as tell Jayfeather about things and influence him, just to stop the Dark Forest and keep the line of living cats going, because Jayfeather got a lot of info out of Rock, and maybe Rock misunderstood his purpose as a curse? And maybe even for the Clan Cats to save the tribes from the rogues and keep balance between the Dark Forest, StarClan, the Ancients, the Tribes, the Tribe of Endless Hunting, and any other religion that might be out there. Speaking of other religions if StarClan is there, the Ancients are there, the Tribe of Endless Hunting, who else it out there? Is there more dead cats that are there and the Clan Cats just don't know because, well, their on one continent in one country in one state, so there might be more out there than no one dares to search for? And maybe StarClan is there to make sure the Clans live from the beginning, flourish, and stay a thing. Same for the Tribes, but not everyone can be accepted into StarClan as some are evil, so the Dark Forest is there to punish those who try and break that same order. As well as maybe Scourge, Darktail, and kittypets have a different place they go to since they didn't really bathe themselves in StarClan and the Dark Forest 24/7, so they probably have a different place they go to, because if a rogue isn't evil but one is, like Scourge is evil he shouldn't go to the Dark Forest and the non-evil rogue go there, too. Or the other rogue just fade instantly, that would make it unbalanced, so there must be another place like StarClan and the Dark Forest, but pretty different.
(My Opinnion) I think that Starclan felt guilty for making Cinder'pelts life really hard and messed up. They gave her second chance because she was really close to be a warrior but lost that opertunity because she got hit by a "monster" that should have killed Blue'star.
i’m so curious about maggotail! all we know about him is that he’s in the dark forest, but we don’t even know what for. we don’t know his appearance either. all he’s ever said was “big words for one so small”
Another question of StarClan: Why do they have to be so vague? It's shown they can hold a normal conversation, but as soon as they have to talk about a prophecy, they just say some random stuff and disappear before they can answer any questions. (I'm on River of Fire, I don't know if it's shown in any later books why)
Rock is my teacher, Lionblaze and Dovewing are just students... and Im Jayfeather.. Hates everyone! Edit: everyone in my class thinks my teacher is annoying and isnt Jayfeather annoyed at Rock?
One thing that always put me off is how Bluestar says "It's not StarClan's place to judge him/her" but then two chapters later Yellowfang is all "StARclAn wILl JudGE ThAt" like DOES STARCLAN JUDGE OR NOT??
Another mystery is why do they change their names. They started out with names like Gray Wing then for what ever reason changed to Graywing. Why did they do that and when?
My theory is that the original leaders (Thunder, Tall Shadow, Clear Sky, Wind Runner, and River Ripple) lead Starclan and the first cats to enter the Dark forest are the leaders there
Now that The Broken Code is ending, we sadly know that Sol and Sleekwhisker didn't return. And taking into account how old Sol must be by know, I doubt he'll ever return (and before someone mentions Mistystar or Graystripe: clan cats live longer because they have medicine cats who take care of them; Sol is a rogue who can easily fall victim to blood loss, disease, or other wounds).
1. They were no matter to the book. 2. There were to many bad guys. 3. No, Snowtuft is not Snowkit. Snowtuft was born BEFORE Snowkit was even a thing. 4. BECAUSE SHES THE BEST THING EVER IN THE BOOKS, SHE IS THE CINNAMON ROLL 5. Because shes already a spirit, maybe she has a time limit to be on Earth. 6. So Jaybae can be entertained. 7. So Hollyleaf can have a boyfriend. 8. Its where dead cats go and they suddenly become special. OKAY THERES UR ANSWERS
I have other mysteries to put down: 1. Is there a cannon reason to why mumblefoot came back? 2. Where do you go after you fade? 3. Is yellowfang liying about where you go after you fade? 4. How does a cat become immortal? 5. What if thristleclaw became deputy? 6. If thristleclaw became duputy would he have loved spottedleaf? 7. why is there no redemption arc's for villans in the warriors series? 8. What happened to the bloodclan cats in the last book of tigerstar & sasha? 9. Did bloodclan reform with another cat on top like brick? 10. What if we face off with bloodclan again for the next villan? 11. If bloodclan does end up living will they be powerful enough to have their own starclan? 12. Will we ever see an arc where windclan digs tunnels again?
1. Imma google that. 2. Maaaaayyybeeeeee.. 3. No...Snowkit wouldn't be evil! 4. Ikr..Feathertail needed to be reincarnated. 5. Because maybe badgers aren't all bad and she likes cats? 6. Rock is Jayfeather's relatable *_pal_* so maybe the Hunters wanted another immortal cat. I also lile your theories lol. 7. HE'S SUS.. 8. StarClan is like Heaven but I don't recall my relatives and random twolegs (or cats) talking to me. They may not have a purpose if, Rock is right, StarClan doesn't have any power to prevent anything happening.
The reason fallen leaves us atill alive is cuz the erins wanted a new fanfiction to read besides fire x blue. Ok but really though, it says it in one of the books that since he got trapped in the tunnels he cant go to starclan so i assume that since he cant go to star clan, he will never fade away.
4. Cinder pelt was an amazing cat, and she ACTUALLY did good in her life. Meanwhile, Snow Kit , hadn’t done anything YET for the clan, so star clan just *ignored it like they always do* (poor snow kit :( )
Egg was one of my favourite characters- he was so interesting, I was so happy when he joined the clan - and so mad when he just vanished- I wish that they would've at least mentioned that he died - even if it was from a greencaugh or something off screen - anything but what we got :(
Am I the only one who wants to know more abt the ancient versions of Dovewing and Lionblaze???? For some reason neither of them find out or have any connections to their past lives. Why does Jayfeather get to but they don’t? And why doesn’t he tell them abt this?? Why do we know absolutely nothing about them? It’s weird. I feel like they had ideas for them but then changed their mind and never went back to fix what became a huge red herring/disappointment. Edit: ALSO SHOULDNT THAT MEAN THAT THERE IS AN ANCIENT VERSION OF FIRESTAR AS WELL?!?!?!?
But what happened with Bluestar’s kits because they had the same kit name in Thunderclan then after a couple of gatherings they were in Riverclan with a different suffix. Shouldn’t Thunderclan be suspicious?
SnowKit and Snowtuft, Snowtuft didn’t know how he died nor what his life was like before he died. He also doesn’t know why he ended up in the dark forest, so is it possible? Maybe. But I might have gotten my facts mixed up.
I made a video on this but since I think Fireheart, Greystripe And Ravenpaw look like Lionblaze, Jayfeather and Hollyleaf... since ravenpaw left the clan... that’s why hollyleaf was never part of the three... I haven’t thought about who was Dovewing (maybe silverstream?) with Fireheart and Greystripe...
1. Can't answer that, I didn't read the SkyClan book or any of the mangas. 2. Good theory, hopefully the Erins' publishing team doesnt screw that up if they try to do that. 3. Snowkit and Snowtuft are NOT the same cat. 4. I honestly dont know. Maybe your right. 5 and 6. Midnight and Rock are both dead. Theyre ghosts. One of the Erins said it herself, I think it was Vicky. 7. In Hollyleaf's novella, Fallen Leaves says that he cant leave, because Broken Shadow (his mother) would come for him to take him to the afterlife. He still thinks that she's coming for him. 8. TennelleFlowers and Moonkitti kinda had a discussion on Drawing A Blank Live stream a few weeks ago. It was super interesting.
Answer to unkniw disapearences. The forgot about them and were halfway through making the book when "Oh wait we forgot to add these guys." "Well we cant add them now.... Oh well too late there dead now-" Im on the fourth apprentice book sooo yaya me more spoilers for me-
With 2, imagine if Sol, Sleekwhisker, the rogues from the Tribe and maybe even the remnants of bloodclan all banded together to take revenge on the clans
I have a lot of questions that actually stem from the whole Cinderheart/Cinderpelt thing. Why not reincarnate dead kits like Wishkit and Hopekit, Finchkit, Mapleshade's three kits ect. I think a cool story arch would be the leader of say riverclan is a reincarnation of let's say patchkit one of Mapleshade's kits and they're the leader of riverclan because of Appledusk or a kit is born and bares very strong resemblance to Yellowfang because it's reincarnated Wishkit or something
I think that Cinderpelt kinda deserved to be reborn if im honest. Shes been in 10 books and during the period of Fire and Ice and Twilight shes done so much. She was upset after her accident but adapted so easily, she gave up so much for example she never had her accident she could have been Firestars mate, like in rising storm when she almost confessed but when she realized he didnt understand maybe she didnt fully confess because she knew he didnt know AND she had medicine cat duties she practically is the reason sandstorm is firestars mate she told him sandstorm liked him first, she died to save sorreltail and her kits and accepted her death so maturely and was fine with dying. It would've been awesome if at some point something happened to Brambleclaw before he became bramblestar and something happened similar to graystripe and he came back to Cinderstar!
For Fallen Leaves, I think that you can't reach the afterlife from the tunnels (I heard somewhere that when Hollyleaf got trapped in the tunnels she died but she couldn't reach Starclan so Fallen Leaves managed to bring her back to life. I think the same thing happened to Fallen Leaves, but he really died.) But since we see him fighting in the battle at the end of OotS, I think he managed to somehow escape the tunnels, and then instead of returning to the tunnels he went to the afterlife so he could be with Hollyleaf. Also, since we see multiple Ancients fighting in the battle even though they're extremely old and probably should be faded by now, I think that maybe the Ancient cat spirits just don't fade. Anyway, this was a really long comment and I know Bright Gaurdian Akira probably won't see this, but that's just what I think happened.
5,6: Writing books is really hard, and sometimes people run out of ideas of what could the cats do, so the readers need some "distractions". Midnight and Rock are these distractions, they're just like when StarClan sends useless signs(like, when cats know what they have to do, but StarClan still sends a sign/sends a StarClan cat talks to a living cat, probably to make sure the cats know what they have to do). And, Rock does not influence the future, since he cannot just go to the cats and tell them what to do, besides that he cannot do that, it's most likely that they won't believe him. He cannot make the decisions and, as a result, he cannot influence the future.
I actually have a theory about how the afterlife works in warriors, once you die, you join the group of the religion you believed in, if you didn't believe in any, you might be able to start your own (I'll continue this in a second.). The more LIVING people believe in your religion, the more powerful and influential you are. Power among dead cats is spread across the most remembered cats, with the forgotten ones getting less and being dead (For real.). I have no idea how you would start a religion, but it did happen, From what I've read, Starclan and the tribe's religion(I don't remember what it was called) don't seem to be connected in any way other than the fact that they have similar powers. Everything is connected to the moon, which I believe is the "real" god in this situation. The moon could be a higher power that explains where the three got their powers, and why all this random magic stuff exists in the first place. maybe you just become a ghost if you are atheist instead? Then again, it could just be a book with little hidden lore and rules to the universe that were thought out over hours and hours of discussion, like my books... NO!... That couldn't possibly be the case! It couldn't possibly just be a fun project with less thinking than we expected...
I think the answer to number 4 is that, because Starclan says the cats all have a destiny, maybe Snowkit’s destiny was to die to the hawk, while Cinderpelt’s destiny was to become a warrior, but it never happened because Tigerclaw set up that trap and accidentally hit Cinderpelt instead, so Starclan gave her a second chance so she could live out her true purpose.
Has anybody ever noticed that all the main characters that are introduced as warriors or apprentices end up becoming leader med cat or part of a very important plot twist/prophecy what is with that I mean why can’t we have a normal warrior protagonist??? Anyways great vid like if u agree
Fallen leaves did die but Star clan was like ' We don't want him and the dark forest was like ' We don't want Him ' so he is forgotten but nobody wants him
I have another big theory that you could include in a next video: What actually happened to Deadfoot? I mean, he was a good warrior and deputy, but did he die? And he's not mentioned in StarClan or Dark Forest. Just what exactly could've happened to him?
Correction: Fallen Leaves returned to his ancestors after the Great Battle. It's still sad because he'll fade and never see Hollyleaf again, but at least he isn't trapped in those tunnels for eternity.
Bright Guardian Akira hi
Bright Guardian Akira GOOD LORD WAT WIT DAT FACE FOR..........No eyes person......is his name bone...? But seriously DATS DANG FREAKY
Edited: oh wait it’s rock
Rocks’s purpose was to make it more interesting and just.... he’s cool
I don't think he will fade to quickly because he is mentioned in bramblestars storm and he is remembered.
Bright Guardian Akira Hello!
4:57
Jayfeather's blind eyes look up in disgust as a giant rock glares down at him.
Plasma Kitten help I saw in my head a big rock legit- just a big stone- staring down at a disgusted JayFeather XD
@@Makoishere4 That's actually what I thought they meant 🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂
Rock is a big boi now.
W h a t
Isn't he blind..?
What about the mystery of why Thornclaw goes on so many patrols?
Lol
Because he's the patrol guy
He is an *e n e r g y b e a n*
IKRRR
because he has to get money to pay rent
Answer to 4. Because Starclan likes certain cats more
starclan is corrupt
that also explains why yellowfang was punished more than leafpool!
Because cinderpelt the waifu
Probably because cinderpelt got a life changing injury from a villain aka tigerstar
@@az_drawsyt8057 yeah. she had her path laid out for her and tigerstar caused her injury
My theory. HOLLYLEAF HAS POWERS TO SEE FALLENLEAF!
Yes!!!! Best fan theory ever!!!!!!
@@chloenyancatthing6249 Yaas! Now everyone must Know!!
YES THIS IS MY HEAD CANON
@@dougwalker4313 I just love Hollyleaf, more than her brothers lol
This could be Hollyleafs power we never saw, she can see and sense faded cats
Random badger- *kills Cinderpelt*
Random Starclan cat 1- "WAIT BUT SHE WAS A FAN FAVORITE WHAT WILL WE DO"
Random Starclan cat 2- "Actually the Power of three is kind of soon, and that series will have the reincarnation insanity, so let's prepare our readers and make cinder fans happy by nonsensically reincarnating her"
Random Starclan cat 1- "Yeah sure, this kitten kind of looks like her" *tosses Cinderpelt's soul in a random babie's body*
No those are members of the editing team
@@sylveoncovers4603 ?
IoI-
@@sylveoncovers4603 It's a joke.
Whelp, I’m with you, that’s DEFINITELY how it happened. No further questions needed.
*looks through all the books* EGG, SHREWTOOTH where y'all GO? 🤔
Did we check the super editions?!
@@sinister_cat2486 true 🤔
@@cyraphe6153 do we even *WANT* do find them? We need egg but... What about shrewtooth?
@@sinister_cat2486 honestly I don't remember much about Shrewtooth 🤔 but it be interesting to know what happened to him.
Ikr? And it's not just them either. Petalnose (Sagenose & Mintfur's single mum) and Rockshade (Pebbleshine's uncle) both just vanish without explanation, too. I know most people don't care, especially since these four were introduced in super additions nobody cares about, but *I* liked them :0)
Because Rock and Midnight are too epic to die or have a reason not to.
Yes they're very epic
*Your swag will make you immortal*
@@MATOGAST. That is why Mistystar refuses to die
Midnight is a spirit/ghost.
I also have a mystery why don’t cats know about the dark forest in the full arcs? It shows that in pinestar’s choice, when they are talking about what mapleshade did, he says ‘if she doesn’t go to the place of no stars than there is no justice’ so it shows that they know about it so why don’t the cats know about before omen of the stars or power of three?
I think it's because the first arc is from FireStar's perspective and as he was a kittypet, he didn't know about StarClan or the dark forest. He was told that StarClan existed, but nobody mentioned the dark forest, at least not in front of him. Dunno what's up with the second series..
Because the Erin’s didn’t think of it until ark three.
@@wooshifgay5626 ya
The Erins didn’t hint of the idea until’ the Power of Three
@@cinderfall1303 Arc two actually; Tigerstar trained Bramble and Hawk.
1. They were pointless.
2. yES because she’s stubborn
3. well dUH of course
4. because she’s one of the *best cats ever*
5. She is an excuse to be a very good badger that speaks to cats and always save the day
6. His purpose is to be the ugliest cat in Warriors and to make Jayfeather obey him
7. to give hOlLyLeAf a FrIeNd
8. It works.
There. Those are my answers.
Edit: oh my goodness 55 likes?! Thank you so much!
Edit 2: 101 LIKES? OH MY GOODNESS!
Edit 3: 301 likes. Wow.
Midnight is a spirit
Mates*
Make that 65 XD
Hollyleaf dont a friend...
The Erin’s confirmed that snowkit is not snowtuft
Actually the Midnight mystery is not a mystery (sry if this is rude), reading from the Warriors Ultimate Guide: Midnight is no ordinary badger: With Rock, she had watched the very first sunrise over the lake and had seen reflected in the fiery surface the futures of Clans, Tribes, Ancient cats, and more. Together, Midnight and Rock watched over the cats by the lake and prepared for the day that could have been the sunset of the ways of the Clans, but instead heralded a new dawn. Meaning she is imortal. Just saying.......
Midnight is actually a spirit.
Your right but still imortal
how did rock watch the sunrise
@@deerprynce I think at that point he wasn't blind.
Idk.
or it’s just another inconsistency in the Ultimate Guide. I’m pretty sure Rock says that he never left the cave at one point. i wouldn’t use the ultimate guide as fact or a good source
7: Fallen Leaves is basically just like Rock, a distraction. The explanation to why is he trapped is that, probably, the tunnels are like StarClan to him. He can hunt, just like the cats from StarClan can hunt on their lands.
But why is he alone there, except for Rock? I honestly can't believe he's the only softpaw who hasn't returned from the tunnels in the entire existence of the Ancients.
@@IDK-l1f5j Maybe they all faded?
I've always been wondering how prophecies are created :P
Yeah. It's so confusing how prophecies are made. From the book, Midnight, Bluestar said she had a prophecy or something about the clans being destroyed. Then she gives that prophecy to Brambleclaw and acts like she made that prophecy. How does that work?
Maybe the faded spirits give them the prophecies??
Chloe Nyancat playz
I have no idea, but I wanna know desperately...
Shimmerpelt Of heatherclan
Interesting theory...still there’s the question then how they know what’s gonna happen 0.0
Oh wait true... Yeah, how do they happen? 🤔
About Fallen leaves, is why it labeled them mates is because Fallen leaves got out of the tunnels after Hollyleaf died, and they both went to star clan with Everyone else.
I’ve come up with an idea about Rock. What he lives in a endless cycle where he sees all the events of warriors over and over and he is forced to say and do everything he does in every incarnation of the cycle. This would why he is so harsh when saying that the clans should have forgotten about the dark forest cat so they didn’t get too powerful, because he doesn’t have the ability to forget anything ever. Also I like the idea that he basically adopted Midnight (if she was ever living) and taught her how to speak cat.
1. Why was the mouse Longtail tried to get for Mousefur so important?
2. Why is Yellowfang's ghost so annoying?
3. What color are Dovewing's eyes (hint: green)
4. What color is Scourge's collar? (hint: purple)
I hate that Longtail died for one stinking MOUSE. Also Number 2 is a very important question.
Ideas:
1. They probably just died off screen somehow
2. Considering The Broken Code is almost over, I will say they won’t come back.
3. No. A Place of No Stars disproves this.
4. Cinderpelt died at the same time Cinderkit was born. This is why.
5. Midnight is a spirit (this may have been confirmed). I think she is meant to be mysterious and unknown.
6. I don’t know enough about Rock to answer this question.
7. Fallen Leaves never went to StarClan, because it didn’t exist back then. He is a ghost and ghosts don’t fade.
8. I don’t know. It just does.
Rock is me in math
Lol
Maybe Rock was not "Cursed" exactly but planned from the very begging as the cat who would lead the Ancients to join with StarClan as well as tell Jayfeather about things and influence him, just to stop the Dark Forest and keep the line of living cats going, because Jayfeather got a lot of info out of Rock, and maybe Rock misunderstood his purpose as a curse? And maybe even for the Clan Cats to save the tribes from the rogues and keep balance between the Dark Forest, StarClan, the Ancients, the Tribes, the Tribe of Endless Hunting, and any other religion that might be out there.
Speaking of other religions if StarClan is there, the Ancients are there, the Tribe of Endless Hunting, who else it out there? Is there more dead cats that are there and the Clan Cats just don't know because, well, their on one continent in one country in one state, so there might be more out there than no one dares to search for?
And maybe StarClan is there to make sure the Clans live from the beginning, flourish, and stay a thing. Same for the Tribes, but not everyone can be accepted into StarClan as some are evil, so the Dark Forest is there to punish those who try and break that same order.
As well as maybe Scourge, Darktail, and kittypets have a different place they go to since they didn't really bathe themselves in StarClan and the Dark Forest 24/7, so they probably have a different place they go to, because if a rogue isn't evil but one is, like Scourge is evil he shouldn't go to the Dark Forest and the non-evil rogue go there, too. Or the other rogue just fade instantly, that would make it unbalanced, so there must be another place like StarClan and the Dark Forest, but pretty different.
Jake appears to be blushing. I wonder why. ;)
XxBlossom-1003579xX *insert some pic of TallStar*
He's looking at you. He's your father. He lives in Alabama.
@@irelyndoyle115 *SWEET HOME ALABAMA*
He's loking at Tallstar. Because his family is the only one Jake isn't related too.
Oops *looking
Rock's face will haunt me forever
Same dude, same.
Lol scary I tried to redraw it on my computer and it turned out worse
I think the pic of rock here is cute af XD
U guys are just rude. Rock can’t help he is blind and if u have a problem with bothering him for something he can’t change then leave.
Look in the Ultimate Guide lel
Mystery 9, what happened to Firestar's collar after Longtail ripped it off in 'Into the Wild'???
Someone should write a fanfic about this... THAT SOMEONE IS ME MWAHAHA
Gosh that Rock drawing is freaky
Same dude, same.
Those eyes stare into the depths of your soul....
Freaky but accurate
(My Opinnion)
I think that Starclan felt guilty for making Cinder'pelts life really hard and messed up.
They gave her second chance because she was really close to be a warrior but lost that opertunity because she got hit by a "monster" that should have killed Blue'star.
i’m so curious about maggotail! all we know about him is that he’s in the dark forest, but we don’t even know what for. we don’t know his appearance either. all he’s ever said was “big words for one so small”
Another question of StarClan: Why do they have to be so vague? It's shown they can hold a normal conversation, but as soon as they have to talk about a prophecy, they just say some random stuff and disappear before they can answer any questions. (I'm on River of Fire, I don't know if it's shown in any later books why)
Rock is my teacher, Lionblaze and Dovewing are just students... and Im Jayfeather.. Hates everyone!
Edit: everyone in my class thinks my teacher is annoying and isnt Jayfeather annoyed at Rock?
Omg excuse my rudeness I don’t remember saying this 🤦🏽♀️
Lps Angel that’s mean.
LapisLPS It kinda is, though.
So I did a good job on Rock's design then :"D
Oooh, Dakota! Fancy seeing you here. Yep, gotta say, that design is something else!
@@NightLightanimation no its not..
Oof I that drawing of my crazy scientist named Rock. Wow.
Time to make a novella!
Rocks’s eyes, though...
Same.
Yes. Those eyes stare into the depths of your soul......
Lol
...
I commented about it and the artist bashes on me. I feel some cannot take criticism
Awesome video, I agree that sol and sleekwhisker returning would be cool oh yeah yeah!!!!
One thing that always put me off is how Bluestar says "It's not StarClan's place to judge him/her" but then two chapters later Yellowfang is all "StARclAn wILl JudGE ThAt" like DOES STARCLAN JUDGE OR NOT??
Another mystery is why do they change their names. They started out with names like Gray Wing then for what ever reason changed to Graywing. Why did they do that and when?
Maybe they were lazy. Also how did they change from names like Gray Wing to Gray Wing of a Random Raven?
* insert some amazing comment here that will definitely not get a lot of likes and a heart from the ultra amazing Akira *
pathetic. *likes*
Yikes
kdewidow yep I’m pathetic :P
This is so stupid....you just want a heart and a like.. *slowly taps the like button and exits quickly out of RUclips*
Angela Bollman lol thanks
Don’t forget SkowKit was deaf and SnowTuft isnt
7:45 **Ahem** “Ten” mysteries.
oh so you noticed too, cool.
The video originally had ten mysteries, but I cut two of them out because they weren't good enough.
Bright Guardian Akira Ah, I see.
@@BrightGuardianAkira What were the other 2?
@@BrightGuardianAkira Why? Were they boring? (I know you won't respond :c)
*You know the drill.*
Reply with what cat you are!
0. Snowfur
1. Mapleshade
2. Brokenstar
3. Bluestar
4. Oakheart
5. Silverstream
6. Scourge
7. Spottedleaf
8. Alderheart
9. Twigbranch
Spottedleaf
Bluestar
Mapleshade
Here’s a mystery: There’s a leader to the dark forest, what about starclan?
Cookie ! Mapleshade is leader of the dark forest
Bluestar is leader of starclan
My theory is that the original leaders (Thunder, Tall Shadow, Clear Sky, Wind Runner, and River Ripple) lead Starclan and the first cats to enter the Dark forest are the leaders there
I agree with Elenore_Gacha.
@Tigerlynx 101 Hey, they say great minds think alike so
Now that The Broken Code is ending, we sadly know that Sol and Sleekwhisker didn't return. And taking into account how old Sol must be by know, I doubt he'll ever return (and before someone mentions Mistystar or Graystripe: clan cats live longer because they have medicine cats who take care of them; Sol is a rogue who can easily fall victim to blood loss, disease, or other wounds).
Wasn't egg torn to pieces by a dog? I explicitly remember hawkwing being horrified by the sight.
that was darktails friend toad that was killed
I was just looking if you uploaded!
1. They were no matter to the book.
2. There were to many bad guys.
3. No, Snowtuft is not Snowkit. Snowtuft was born BEFORE Snowkit was even a thing.
4. BECAUSE SHES THE BEST THING EVER IN THE BOOKS, SHE IS THE CINNAMON ROLL
5. Because shes already a spirit, maybe she has a time limit to be on Earth.
6. So Jaybae can be entertained.
7. So Hollyleaf can have a boyfriend.
8. Its where dead cats go and they suddenly become special.
OKAY THERES UR ANSWERS
I have other mysteries to put down:
1. Is there a cannon reason to why mumblefoot came back?
2. Where do you go after you fade?
3. Is yellowfang liying about where you go after you fade?
4. How does a cat become immortal?
5. What if thristleclaw became deputy?
6. If thristleclaw became duputy would he have loved spottedleaf?
7. why is there no redemption arc's for villans in the warriors series?
8. What happened to the bloodclan cats in the last book of tigerstar & sasha?
9. Did bloodclan reform with another cat on top like brick?
10. What if we face off with bloodclan again for the next villan?
11. If bloodclan does end up living will they be powerful enough to have their own starclan?
12. Will we ever see an arc where windclan digs tunnels again?
Are you getting better at drawing? *Also Skyclan is one of my favourite clans*
1. Imma google that.
2. Maaaaayyybeeeeee..
3. No...Snowkit wouldn't be evil!
4. Ikr..Feathertail needed to be reincarnated.
5. Because maybe badgers aren't all bad and she likes cats?
6. Rock is Jayfeather's relatable *_pal_* so maybe the Hunters wanted another immortal cat. I also lile your theories lol.
7. HE'S SUS..
8. StarClan is like Heaven but I don't recall my relatives and random twolegs (or cats) talking to me. They may not have a purpose if, Rock is right, StarClan doesn't have any power to prevent anything happening.
The reason fallen leaves us atill alive is cuz the erins wanted a new fanfiction to read besides fire x blue.
Ok but really though, it says it in one of the books that since he got trapped in the tunnels he cant go to starclan so i assume that since he cant go to star clan, he will never fade away.
I really like your interpretation of StarClan. It makes sense with the point about leaders/med cats
4. Cinder pelt was an amazing cat, and she ACTUALLY did good in her life.
Meanwhile, Snow Kit , hadn’t done anything YET for the clan, so star clan just *ignored it like they always do* (poor snow kit :( )
This is gonna be good!
Remember that one scene where there like no you already got to choose a cat for the last prophecy nows my turn in one of the prologues!
Egg was one of my favourite characters- he was so interesting, I was so happy when he joined the clan - and so mad when he just vanished- I wish that they would've at least mentioned that he died - even if it was from a greencaugh or something off screen - anything but what we got :(
Am I the only one who wants to know more abt the ancient versions of Dovewing and Lionblaze???? For some reason neither of them find out or have any connections to their past lives. Why does Jayfeather get to but they don’t? And why doesn’t he tell them abt this?? Why do we know absolutely nothing about them? It’s weird. I feel like they had ideas for them but then changed their mind and never went back to fix what became a huge red herring/disappointment.
Edit: ALSO SHOULDNT THAT MEAN THAT THERE IS AN ANCIENT VERSION OF FIRESTAR AS WELL?!?!?!?
I like to think that every cat that ever died younge or didnt get to live there dreams gets reancarnated
Snowkit and snowtuft aren't the same cat because snowtuft was from windclan
Early squad! I
3:20 Midnight is a spirit
*DONT YOU INSULT MY PURE BOI FALLEN LEAVES*
*hiiiiiiiiiiiisssssssssss*
But what happened with Bluestar’s kits because they had the same kit name in Thunderclan then after a couple of gatherings they were in Riverclan with a different suffix. Shouldn’t Thunderclan be suspicious?
I’m actually first! Wow!
LapisLPS good job!
yep, congrats!
claps
Tysm for the nice replies!
Do a video on all the cats who died so far
I see Bright Guardian Akira
I clicc
SnowKit and Snowtuft, Snowtuft didn’t know how he died nor what his life was like before he died. He also doesn’t know why he ended up in the dark forest, so is it possible? Maybe. But I might have gotten my facts mixed up.
07.45 tEN
oh you noticed too, cool
Snowkit: dies as a innocent baby.
Starclan: fine, kits don't deserve lives anyway.
Cinderpelt: dies
Starclan: this eye-catching needs to be reborn.
She-cat
I’m eighth!
congrats
Doritokat 9 7th 😂
128, 369th (at this time I might have already watched this video)
Rocks Purpose...The supper addition!!!
Moo
I made a video on this but since I think Fireheart, Greystripe And Ravenpaw look like Lionblaze, Jayfeather and Hollyleaf... since ravenpaw left the clan... that’s why hollyleaf was never part of the three... I haven’t thought about who was Dovewing (maybe silverstream?) with Fireheart and Greystripe...
MagicalFireKitty I would probably say that Dovewing looks similar to Cinderpelt.
You missed out 9: HOW COME WHEN I PET NY CAT HE PURRS AND WHEN EVERYONE ELSE TOUCHES HIM, HE BITES!?!
Cinderpelt never wanted to be a medicine cat. But she had to because of TigerStar.
1. Can't answer that, I didn't read the SkyClan book or any of the mangas.
2. Good theory, hopefully the Erins' publishing team doesnt screw that up if they try to do that.
3. Snowkit and Snowtuft are NOT the same cat.
4. I honestly dont know. Maybe your right.
5 and 6. Midnight and Rock are both dead. Theyre ghosts. One of the Erins said it herself, I think it was Vicky.
7. In Hollyleaf's novella, Fallen Leaves says that he cant leave, because Broken Shadow (his mother) would come for him to take him to the afterlife. He still thinks that she's coming for him.
8. TennelleFlowers and Moonkitti kinda had a discussion on Drawing A Blank Live stream a few weeks ago. It was super interesting.
That drawing of rock is terrifying
Answer to unkniw disapearences. The forgot about them and were halfway through making the book when "Oh wait we forgot to add these guys." "Well we cant add them now.... Oh well too late there dead now-"
Im on the fourth apprentice book sooo yaya me more spoilers for me-
With 2, imagine if Sol, Sleekwhisker, the rogues from the Tribe and maybe even the remnants of bloodclan all banded together to take revenge on the clans
I have a lot of questions that actually stem from the whole Cinderheart/Cinderpelt thing. Why not reincarnate dead kits like Wishkit and Hopekit, Finchkit, Mapleshade's three kits ect. I think a cool story arch would be the leader of say riverclan is a reincarnation of let's say patchkit one of Mapleshade's kits and they're the leader of riverclan because of Appledusk or a kit is born and bares very strong resemblance to Yellowfang because it's reincarnated Wishkit or something
'Sleekwhisker, the cat who never got attention'
In the background: **'Attention' intensifies**
I think that Cinderpelt kinda deserved to be reborn if im honest. Shes been in 10 books and during the period of Fire and Ice and Twilight shes done so much. She was upset after her accident but adapted so easily, she gave up so much for example she never had her accident she could have been Firestars mate, like in rising storm when she almost confessed but when she realized he didnt understand maybe she didnt fully confess because she knew he didnt know AND she had medicine cat duties she practically is the reason sandstorm is firestars mate she told him sandstorm liked him first, she died to save sorreltail and her kits and accepted her death so maturely and was fine with dying. It would've been awesome if at some point something happened to Brambleclaw before he became bramblestar and something happened similar to graystripe and he came back to Cinderstar!
For Fallen Leaves, I think that you can't reach the afterlife from the tunnels (I heard somewhere that when Hollyleaf got trapped in the tunnels she died but she couldn't reach Starclan so Fallen Leaves managed to bring her back to life. I think the same thing happened to Fallen Leaves, but he really died.) But since we see him fighting in the battle at the end of OotS, I think he managed to somehow escape the tunnels, and then instead of returning to the tunnels he went to the afterlife so he could be with Hollyleaf. Also, since we see multiple Ancients fighting in the battle even though they're extremely old and probably should be faded by now, I think that maybe the Ancient cat spirits just don't fade. Anyway, this was a really long comment and I know Bright Gaurdian Akira probably won't see this, but that's just what I think happened.
Maybe Snowkit is not is StarClan because he was forgotten :0
5,6: Writing books is really hard, and sometimes people run out of ideas of what could the cats do, so the readers need some "distractions". Midnight and Rock are these distractions, they're just like when StarClan sends useless signs(like, when cats know what they have to do, but StarClan still sends a sign/sends a StarClan cat talks to a living cat, probably to make sure the cats know what they have to do). And, Rock does not influence the future, since he cannot just go to the cats and tell them what to do, besides that he cannot do that, it's most likely that they won't believe him. He cannot make the decisions and, as a result, he cannot influence the future.
Fallen leaves is trapped because he is a cat with “unfinished business” like Needletail and Pebbleshine.
I actually have a theory about how the afterlife works in warriors,
once you die, you join the group of the religion you believed in,
if you didn't believe in any, you might be able to start your own (I'll continue this in a second.).
The more LIVING people believe in your religion, the more powerful and influential you are.
Power among dead cats is spread across the most remembered cats, with the forgotten ones getting less and being dead (For real.).
I have no idea how you would start a religion, but it did happen,
From what I've read, Starclan and the tribe's religion(I don't remember what it was called) don't seem to be connected in any way other than the fact that they have similar powers.
Everything is connected to the moon, which I believe is the "real" god in this situation.
The moon could be a higher power that explains where the three got their powers, and why all this random magic stuff exists in the first place.
maybe you just become a ghost if you are atheist instead?
Then again, it could just be a book with little hidden lore and rules to the universe that were thought out over hours and hours of discussion, like my books...
NO!... That couldn't possibly be the case!
It couldn't possibly just be a fun project with less thinking than we expected...
I think the answer to number 4 is that, because Starclan says the cats all have a destiny, maybe Snowkit’s destiny was to die to the hawk, while Cinderpelt’s destiny was to become a warrior, but it never happened because Tigerclaw set up that trap and accidentally hit Cinderpelt instead, so Starclan gave her a second chance so she could live out her true purpose.
yellow fang and brightheart are my favorite cats ever
r.i.p yellow fang
3. I think I know why people say is snowkit and snowtuft the same cat. Is snowkit was reborn and became snowtuft
Snowtuft was a Windclan cat apparently so it´s debunqued (I think?) (srry for grammar mistakes)
Has anybody ever noticed that all the main characters that are introduced as warriors or apprentices end up becoming leader med cat or part of a very important plot twist/prophecy what is with that I mean why can’t we have a normal warrior protagonist??? Anyways great vid like if u agree
I dont think that Snowkit and Snowtuft are sane cats, beacuse Snowtuft had green eyes and Snowkit blue
2:18
Snowfur died,but why isn't there a theory about that?
Toms....
REEE
Akira snow kit has been used for showing how blue star went dark because she didn't care about snow kits life problems
Fallen leaves did die but Star clan was like ' We don't want him and the dark forest was like ' We don't want Him ' so he is forgotten but nobody wants him
oh um, for Snowkit and Snowtuft, in the arc omen of the stars it Snowkit is in starclan and Snowtuft is in the dark forest.
That drawing of rock makes my uncomfortable 😣
2:49
Because we ALL love her. She is an amazing cat.
I have another big theory that you could include in a next video: What actually happened to Deadfoot? I mean, he was a good warrior and deputy, but did he die? And he's not mentioned in StarClan or Dark Forest. Just what exactly could've happened to him?
He is mentioned in Starclan, in the first prologue of the new prophecy he was the one who chose Crowpaw
The biggest mystery of all is
What colour are Dovewing's eyes?
I haven't read any Warrior Cats books but I still like watching these videos
Thank you for bringing up Jake....... I lv him and Talltail
I don't think Cinderpelt is recarnated because she I been seen in starclan even when cinderheart was alive