India Special: Khalistan, G-20 Summit, and BJP in Conversation with Ali K Chishti | Podcast #88
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 июл 2024
- Ali K Chishti is a journalist, author, and technologist known for his extensive writings on various subjects related to Pakistan and Karachi politics. He has also contributed to Indian newspapers and actively advocates for peace and improved relations between India and Pakistan. Besides, his deep understanding of history further enriches his efforts in promoting dialogue and cooperation in the region.
Clips Of this Podcast : www.youtube.com/@daniyalsheik...
Daniyal Sheikh Instagram : / daniyal.sheikh1
Daniyal Sheikh Facebook : / daniyal.sheikh123
Daniyal Sheikh Tiktok : www.tiktok.com/@daniyal.sheik...
Spotify : spotifyanchor-web.app.link/e/...
Google Podcast : shorturl.at/nuwO2
Apple Podcast : podcasts.apple.com/pk/podcast...
00:00 - Intro
05:29 - The historical context of the Khalistan Movement
19:38 - The impact of Indira Gandhi's assassination on India's internal dynamics
22:35 - Was Pakistan involved in Khalistan Movement?
26:00 - Khalistan Movement was ended because of Benazir Bhutto
30:19 - Canada has become a hub of terrorism because of Khalistan Movement
36:30 - Why Pakistan wasn’t in G-20 Summit?
39:07 - S. Jaishankar is a distinguished diplomat on the global stage
41:47 - Impact of G-20 Summit on India
45:30 - Difference between Pakistan and India’s foreign diplomacy
50:18 - Muhammad Ali Jinnah never wanted a partition of India
01:05:21 - Advocating for people-to-people connections between India and Pakistan
01:08:35 - BJP's potential for a third consecutive term in Indian governance
01:15:32 - False historical narratives are being fed to Indians and Pakistanis.
01:19:11 - There’s an institutional racism against Muslims in India and Hindus in Pakistan
01:25:12 - Modi will win the next election because of Amit Shah
01:30:14 - India should have come to Pakistan for Asia Cup
01:33:47 - Is India involved in terrorism in Pakistan
I am a SIKH..
India is our nation and anybody in India acting against India is our enemy.
To those who are giving too much importance to Khalistanis:
1. 93000 Pakistanis had surrendered to a Sikh man Jagjit Singh Arora who was representing India in 1971.
2. Balakot strikes decision was taken by Modi ji implemented by air chief Marshal Dhanoa, an Indian Sikh..
3. Abrogation of article 370 may have been thought by Modi ji but was advised and implemented by army commander KJS Dhillon, an Indian Sikh..
4. Siachen's highest peak was captured by Bana Singh in 1984, and so was named as Bana Post and Bana Singh was awarded Param Vir Chakra..
Last but not the least, it was a Sikh commander Lieutenant Brar who headed operation bluestar to flush out Khalistani terrorists from Golden temple and it was a Sikh police Chief KPS Gill who wiped out Khalistani terrorists from Punjab..
So just chill, we Sikhs know how to flush out the bad apples from our community!!
20:20 not hindu vs Sikhs it terrorist party congress done crimes on Sikhs
Paaji 🙏🙏🙏🙏❤❤❤❤
Salute paji ❤
Salute paji,you earned my respect.❤.
both are liars .
direct action day called by jinnah
The Biggest Joke of this Podcast is
Jinnah Never Wanted the Partition
😅😅😅
He is a great personality.
sach hai till 1920 khilafat movement me gandhi ke aane baad sab change hua hai dynamics
@@ShivamShukla-kh6ke haaa bat shi pr jitna angrejo ka hath hai utna kisi ka nhi hai koi nhi chahta tha partision pr sb geo politics ka khel hai babu 😌
😂
yah madrasa education hai na 😂
ye 72 ko bhi jante hai
I am also a sikh but i always love
Hinduism my all friends are hindus and i full support modi
Fundamentals of Sikhism and sanatan are same and we both give equal respect to each other's holy places.❤
@@martin96991 100% right
Sikhism is the bhakti sect of same Hindu culture. No difference.
1st of all the sikh who wantrd khalistan they didn't Leave in Punjab
And we indian also have sympathy what the suffered in 1984 the dirty political game
Congress did same that US did
Us made Osama and when you adopt snacks in your backyard you cannot expect they don't bite you
Same congress made bhindranwala just reduce the influence of akali dal and than he bites congress and innocent suffer
😂sikhs love all religions and they never create fake accounts...they are brave...... unfortunately some andhbhakts from cow belt hindi states do so
Pakistan wanted revenge for 1971 humiliation; that is when they started supporting khalistan movement.
But Pakistan started 1971 themselves by ill treating Bangladeshis
Right that's why isis funded this movement
True😂😂😂
pakistan did not start khalistan movement Indara Gandhi was responsible for that. but Pakistan support, funds, train and give weapons to khalistani.
@vishvajitkumar9497 she didn't started 😂 idiot fellow go and read history initially supported bhindrawale against akali dal but isi taken advantage of that
I am sikh and majority of sikh want united india
Yeah we can see what jaat sikh is doing in Canada and australia.
they r ruining it for everybody@@naveenawadhi6240
Jen sikho ne 84 daikha hai who united india mai believe nahi karta agar Hindu Rashtar ban sakta hai to….
20% jatt sikhs k alava koi interested nahi hai. aur woh sikhs bhi koi innocent nahi hai, bohot hindus ko bus se nikal nikal k maara hai. so stop the sikh victimhood.
Modi has tried his best to reach out. but still those sikhs cozy upto the gandhis and congi.@@dhanwantmoga
I have Sikh friends..and they are very patriotic to this country.... waheguru ji 🙏🙏
20:20 not hindu vs Sikhs it terrorist party congress done crimes on Sikhs
me also Jay Hind waheguru ji
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa jai hind
I am sikh we want united india secular india
I'm Sikh living in Canada I love my motherland India jai hind
A 16 year old from Punjab knows better than the so called experts!
The demand for separate Punjabi sooba was from a particular party Akali Dal and Singh Sabha ( which collaborated with the British intelligentsia to create a rift between hindu -sikhs which were till then termed as 'nauh -maas da rishta'.
Singh Sabha stooges went on to felicitate General Dyer, the perpetrator of the Jalianwala Bagh massacre, with a siropa at the Golden Temple!
They even offered to decorate him , a cigarette smoking firang, as 'Khalsa'!
Trifurcation of Punjab on linguistic basis happened in mid 60's and not 50's
Radical Khalistani terror attacks ( a movement predominantly of Jat sikhs) started happening as early as 1978 with targetted killings of Hindus, Non jatt sikhs as well as Nirankari sikhs !
Anneya che kaana Paxstaan che siyaana 🤡
Ohi gall ayy ehna di
#Correction: It was not Sikh vs Hindu Riots, it was Congress goons who did the massacre against sikhs after Indira's assassination.
Waheguruji🙏🏻
JaiShriRam🚩
Bro it was sikh vs hindu in the end all over india hr states ma sikhon ko mra tha and gurudwara jla dia
@@animex8129lol Congress supporters are all over the country... 😂
My family is a kattar hindu.. But we didn't care about Indiras assassination... So dont blabber crap..
@@animex8129stop this nonsense, it was Congress vs Sikhs. Come out of this victim mentality.
@@mr.nobody5244 bhai phla ma ve yhi sochta tha ya cong vs sikh tha lakin jb maina khud dekha ke hmara sikhon k sth ky ky hua uss time smj aya k ya sikh vs hindu tha jsa jodhpur ma ak mughal kila hai whn ak chota sa gurudwara hua krta tha usma sikh guru ke padukain tbi lakin hundu radicals na wo gurudwara jla dia and whn p jo 2 sewadar tha unha zinda jla dia and nra lg rha tha jai shree ram ab issa zyda ky proof hai.
@@animex8129 you are a biggest fool.
Waqf board of india (Exclusive muslim body ) owns third most land of india after indian army and indian railways !!
Condition of oppressed muslims in india 😊
In uthoyo ka Sare hindu mar jaye bhi toh
Muthalman Par Zulmm dikhega 😂😂
Ye koi proud wali baat nahi hai....
@@ranarajput7368Let yogi become pm only he can remove that draconian waqf act , modi lack balls to do it .
dostcast wali podcast dekh ke aya hai na chutiye
@@Princeyadav-kh4goyou just serve your a## to the Brahmins.
“ No one died for Pakistan but Millions of innocents died because of Pakistan”
-Moeenuddin Ahmad Qureshi
Former Prime Minister of Pakistan.
They’ve understood that speaking positive about India will earn them money through viewership.
Sare pakistani yahi to kar rahe hai ajkal dekhlo pura yout tube bhara pada hai sab india ki chat chat ke kama rahe hai
true only thing they want is that money and business of India
Tum pakka tanatani andhbhakt ho from cow belt Hindi states
@@nikhildeshmukh6221achcha tu bada padha likha hai…padha likha ganwar😂 or should I say literate ganwar? Samajh aaya?
Ganwar jisko sirf likhana aata hai, vo hai tu!
very true, they just want business
😂😂😂 it's hilarious to see the wrong info propogated by pakistanis about India. Why do you think now India should fall for this honeytrap from Pakistan again ? We know how your crickters have talked about attack on India like Shahid Afridi , Shohaib Akhtar ( Gazwa-e-hind) 🤷🤷 so forget this cricket thing. We have seen your cricketer/Maulanas always trying to convert other cricketers.
Bilkul ye cricket ke naam pe humko aur sine me chura nhi hona
Inke dilo me khunas hai indian ke baare me to inko relation Krna hi kyu hai.
@@swapnilraipure3314 The more unfortunate thing is our foolish low iq people of India always fall for this terrible honeytrap by these radical jihadis of pakistan. So, our Indians are more intellectually bankrupt than pakistanis. 😑😑 the only thing I like about this government is that they are better with their aggressive diplomatic relations with pakistan. If it was Congress instead of the current government, then they would have given visas to these jihadis so easily. Otherwise, we have so many secular fools who will even eat sh** of pakistanis despite getting terror attacks. These secular fools of our country should remain secular for India only, not for epicenter of terrorism. When Imran Khan stopped the trade and Afghanistan got Taliban government, these same people were celebrating Khan. So I don't take these people much seriously. Unfortunately, many of our foolish people do take them seriously. Which is disappointing and pathetic. Our Indians are enough to damage India while befriending such modern jihadis.
Right ye churan bht bech liya hum to ekko hi hai blah blah Bhai door rho humse gazba e Hind or Hindus ko kafir bolne Wale log Hume nahi chahiye hamare player nahi jate Pakistan pata n q aa jate hai Bhikari
Ummah>>>>loyalty to the nation
100 ki seedhi bat
Right
In hindsight we Indians consider partition as blessing, out of 60 crore radicals we're left only with 20 crores.
Mr Chishti's take is wrong on partition but I appreciate his hard hitting facts Khalistan.
Hinduism and Sikhism are same❤
Until the early 2000s, most Pakistanis may have emphasized connections to Arab and Turkish roots, reflecting the influence of Islamic history. However, after 2010 changing geopolitical dynamics, increased communication, a more globalized world and the economic success of India have contributed to shifts in perspectives of almost all podcast hosts coming from Pakistan say, that they have more similarities with India, culturally and linguistically.
its out of compulsion not love. they hate us internally
I like how the Pakistanis now acknowledge and understand that india is a country unlike (unfortunately) pakistan where people from all different sects and religions live harmoniously together and perhaps wants to emulate this in their country as well, if they succeed will be good for the whole region!! Best of luck!✌️
brother living im pakistan and you living in inda i dont dislike you you dont dislike me but the goverments make us to dislike eachother you knoow very well!
More a society is islwmic, more barbaric it'll become.
They are islamisist, right now they need money. They will praise you then take what's yours and kick all non believers out. This is what's happening everywhere.
Bang on. A lot of gullible indians cant read between the lines.
perfect@@gjoswal256
He is good analyst but at 18:29 it was the indian police that carried out the operation.
Here in india army is not allowed to operate on civilian land. Except some enclaves and with special legislative permissions.
This man has own story, cut pieces from here and there. I am Sikh and I don't know at the time of partition Sikhs demanded for separate country. But this man knows 😂😂
Liberal pakistani read Romilla thapars book. She introduced such craps into her books.
Bhai,many of our Indian historical also told about Sikh asked for different country just after partition on the basics of religion..even I saw many Sikh on utube telling about this story..
@gouravbansal51192 those 5% you will find in every religion. It doesn't mean Sikhs demanded separate country. When we have big country & a state, why foolish 5% asking separate country? Because they are out of India and cannot enter.
Yes ! They have demanded but later they abandoned it when they heard that a separate Muslim state will form which includes the West Punjab .
One must read about Jay shah. He is in cricket association for 15 years & his business is to take Indian cricket to next level.
Jay shah is the one, who applied "EQUAL PAY POLICY" to both Men & women Teams. He is the one, who raised Infrastructure for Women Cricket & you can see the GROWTH of Indian Women Team & the same Jay shah Started WOMEN PREMIERE LEAGUE ( WPL) & in it's first year, WPL IPL valuation is ₹1,250 Crore in Media rights & profits & ₹4,670 in franchise selling.
Interesting information! As an Indian, I used to believe Jay Shah entered BCCI after BJP came to power. It's crucial to delve into personalities before forming opinions. Ali K Chishti often makes uninformed claims about India, yet he sheds light on past events in Pakistan, which I find valuable. Even if he spreads propaganda, I view it as insight into Pakistan's narrative. When I consume Pakistani content, I perceive it as their perspective rather than pure facts.
Indians must recognize that individuals with an Abrahamic mindset may struggle to present unbiased arguments. However, we can't dismiss their narrative, given the constant target placed on Indians by our neighbors. We shouldn't blindly trust Pakistanis, but we shouldn't disregard what they say, especially intellectuals like Ali K Chishti and Shehzad Ghias. Their viewpoints carry weight among influential Pakistanis and can impact unsuspecting Indians.
Now Indian Govt must try any how to not to send Indian Team in Champions trophy in Pakistan.
Jay shah is president of bcci because he is son of amit shah lol
Definitely hume kisi bhi Pakistani ko dhayan se sunna hoga ..... Use your rationale .... Don't follow blindly and counter if any wrong facts are presented in comment section ......
He's the one managing Indian cricket and bringing reforming policies for both men and women cricket
Bahot wakt ho gya. In the context of 26/11, it is not that easy to forget things knowing that the culprits are not only roaming freely but also addressing large rallies and stuff.
Whole india saw that attack live on tv and that is the generation now working on every sector of India.
Mr. Chisti knowledge on Khalistan issue is flawed, neither Nehru nor Indian government promised anything special to Sikh leaders, it’s true during Independence Akali-Dal then demanded for a separate nation for Sikhs before joining India or Pakistan, but Sikhs were sure they were not going to join Pakistan either to remain independent or merge in India, they wanted their separate nation which included parts of Pakistani Punjab and Indian Punjab but Master Tara Singh & other Sikh leaders and Maharaja of Patiala decided to merge in India without any special treatment for sikh in India.
20% truth + 70%lies+ 10%bakchodi
True 😂. This asshole is trying to sideline pakistan's involvement in khalistan issue.
Everything crap
Yogi =yoga 😂😂
Itni confidence kaha se late ho 😂😂
Yogi means saint 😂😂
😂😂 bhai take it for entertainment value
@@Takecare55wohi toh dost 😂😂
Kitne padhe likhe hein yeh elite porkies😂😂
He is saying right Yogi is for yoga only the one who learns yoga .. now learn the meaning of yoga
Rishi ko saint bolte hain
Adiyogi shivji ko bolla jata hai ..
Proud to be a sikh ❤.
😂are bhai merekoto 10th tak pata bhi nahitha ki sikhisam aur hinduisam alag alag hotahe mato donoko akhi religion mantatha 😂😂😂
This is only guy who knows about India properly. Not because he is praising india but genuinely.
How ?? He is justifying pakistan involvement in khalistani movement by saying that - "Bahar Wale toh fir involve honge hi".
Bruh he completely ignored the fact that a plane can not be highjacked without pakistan help to khalistani.
@@AYUSHKUMAR-yw7hjvo to thik hai par ye hindi speaking waalo ko dusro pe hindi impose karne ki kya chul lagi rehti hai?
@@raghuveersinghrathore7395HINDI is still not the official language of India and that's it unlike Pakistan
He does not understand india. If Jinnah was not interested in partition. He would not done direct action day.
He would have actively worked to stop riots in Punjab which started from Rawalpindi in March 1947. Do not lie plz
@@nishu413 🤣🤣...haan...yes person who doesn't agree with your narrative that person doesn't understand India....u people only like those pakistani those only bash pakistan and the moment that very same person applies same logic on India then he/she doesn't understand India...have u been to pakistan, Europe, US or china but I can bet u have opinion about these countries but other person can't have his or her opinion because he or she hasn't been in India
India should not give visa to Pakistani... We shud completely isolate pakistan and not have any relationship with Pakistan be it trade, visa, arts... If pakistanis think there be no politics in arts and sports.. Then I tell the pakistani to open visas and sports to Israel 😂
As an indian I think we need the reconciliation for our history where we need greater acceptance with clear picture and I think l this conversation is doing great job in that, Good work buddy
There cant be any reconcilliation.
Tere ko bahut chul machi hai tu Pak chala ja.yeh dono chutiye aera bankar peda khaane koshish kar rhe hai Pak side ke taraf Jo katal hua unki baat ki inhone?
1:20:15 for your information..... A new anti mob lynching law.....which has death penalty.... passed by BJP govt.
I think pakistan needs more educated and open minded people like u🙌🙌
he is not presenting facts, he presenting his own narrative which shares similarities with Ayesha Jalal that Jinnah didn't want partition, that Nehru indirectly force Jinnah to get partition. Another mythmaking that Jinnah didn't want separate electorates? As I understand, when INC refused to have separate electorates that Jinnah went for Partition. And having a separate electorates would have been worse than Partition
exactly. good decision by Nehru for a change@@paulhall1612
BCCI IMF of the cricket 🏏😎💪😈
Muslim Muslim Muslim fikar hai to le lo....first of all apne minorities ki fikar kaaro....even your constitution says no non Muslim can be on bigger position....from president to air chief....from chief justice to principal secretary saare muslim rhe hain...hum partition bhi saahe aur gaali bhi sune...no relations at all
1. Bro you say BCCI done wrong.
Pls reply me that last 15 year how many bomb blast happen in pakistan and in india?
2. How many international designated terrorist in pakistan and in india?
3. In Ahmedabad, if pakistan people allowed to watch match then there is a possibility of public violence inside the stadium. It will be hard to stop.
There is always a reason behind everything. Use internet.
They still teach Indian hate in schools
India ne Bilkul thik kiya, in Bw ko jahaan hai wahi rehne de, lekin pata nahin ye apne aapko apni identity ko India-Bharat se kyu Jodate hain, pata nahin kyunki sach to yahi hai ki ye log ya to Arabic hain, Ya fir Central Asia se, ya to Iran se ya to Turkish aur abhi-abhi Indian bhi ho gaye.
For me the two best thing happened for india was freedom from Britishers and partition of India 🇮🇳
Ye adami alag he nashe mai hai … Pakistan Aur Pakistani Ko hum barabar ka maante he nahi hai … iska alag he Sapna hai … aur ye jaise log humare under graduate se bhi kam jaante hai
bhai to lag raha hai aap up ke under graduate ko nhi jaante hai ye podcast waale to nasha kiye hi hai
As a Bharatiye, Why would I want *Pakistani version* of MY history and seeing Bharat from Pakistani eyes. What is the point of listening to this podcast? None Whatsoever, except Pakistani insecurities whom we don't care about.
I like when ali said "unka perception tho ban gaya hai na". I feel you should have gone more in depth into that topic. This aptly depicts my outlook on Pakistan. I feel we(indian government) should keep treating Pakistan as a non existent entity politically and economically. Military albeit they're a smaller threat but they're still a threat.
This attitude of abhi chod do, cricket ko tho chod do, art ko tho chod do... Kyun chod de bhai? Ustad Rahat fateh ali khan himself says he got much more respect in india than in pakistan. You bombard us with insurgencies, terrorism, firing on the LOC, bomb blasts, suicide attacks etc etc and then you want our respect and our money? We are a democracy and we cant control our population like an autocracy where we tell them to not support you. So we'll just not let you enter India. Kuch bhi nahi chahiye pakistan se. Art, music, food... Sab kuch rakhlo apne paas.
The reasoning you are giving behind karachi ka food pure india par bhari hai... That people from all over india came there. Bhai you think we cant achieve the same thing here?... You are under the assumption that all people will stay in their own cities forever? We are completely free and enabled to travel wherever we want. We have state of the art airports, trains, automobiles, roadways... Nowadays water taxi as well. People of different cultures have mingled and in lot of cases, intermarried as well.
I'm from Bengaluru but i have cousins in Mumbai, so when i visit them, I'm introduced to Maharashtrian culture, food, cinema, music etc. I have business dealings in chennai and i also grew up with tamil friends, so I can gel well there also. This assumption in completely wrong that karachi food is better than all of India. I'm a vegetarian, can you honestly tell me I would be getting better vegetarian options in karachi than in Bengaluru? And I also have a huge problem with Pakistanis saying culture bhi ek hai, khana-peena sab ek hai about India. You only have common culture with the hindi speaking belt of north india and mostly culturally punjab. Tell me what similarities you have with me, a South Indian?... Absolutely nothing... Food, culture, music, traditions, everything is different. What common culture do you have with a pahadi?... Someone from himachal... Or an assamese person, absolutely nothing. Even the people from the 4 south indian states differ from each other a LOT. I doubt if you can even name the laguages of the people in south india properly or know anything about our culture.
Absolutely right hum to ekko hi hai blah blah ye churan bht bech liya hum ek nahi hai tum khush rho apne yaha most of Pakistani have jihadi hindu hatred mindset they called us kafir
The vastness and diversity of India is beyond there comprehension, specially Pakistani Punjabis think whole India limited to Punjab.
I am Odia living in Jharkhand . I must say not only South India & Pahadis Pakistan (even if Bangladesh which was formerly East Pakistan) also has no cultural similarities with Odisha , Jharkhand , Chattisgarh , Goa , Andaman & Nicobar , Lakshdweep & North East (except Assam) at all .
Ki nah never wanted partition what a joke 😂😂😂
He wanted 35%
Power transfer to muslims
Which would After all divide Indian society 😂😂
And may be you are Reading a book written by Ayesha Jalal 😂😂
Jinnah did correct but coward didn't transfer total population of Muslims to Porkiestan 😂😂
Buri cheez yahi lagi hai ki pakistan ke involvement ke bare me sunke aapka acceptance kahi nazar nahi aata...jabki india ki galtiyo ko aap jaldi acknowledge karte ho...grow up Danial bhai...acceptance is the start up of evolvement..kyoki usse aap apne aap me sudhar late ho...one more thing...i wd request u to invite ali bhai for more such topics...unko sunana bahot hi achha lagta hai...its a treat to watch❤
Hmmm so called educated Pakistani think 26/11 hum kre bomb hum phode or galti b Indian Mane seriously
Jay shah is secretary not president. He was secretary even when Ganguly was president. Now Rodger Binny is the president
But there was a nonwritten rule between india and pakistan board since 2008 that neither asia cup will play in india and pakistan. In 2018 india was host of asia cup but it was held in UAE. Problem is that this time pakistan went crazy it desperate to host asia cup. Pakistan was behaving stubborn.
The culture similarities in the region are called Hindutva (Hinduness) and the land is called Hind
There is a certain mindset issues with lots of Pakistanis... the Mulla mindset. The day Pakistan prioritises education & developemental mindset over religious fantisim & terrorism, only then can there be scope of trust.
nehru and patel understood and didn't speak against partition beacause they knew that they would not be able to make a modern state with institutions based on scientific temperament with such a large muslim population in the country.
Beggars 20 hota to pakistan ka naam hota😂😂😂 this was the best line in this podcast.
Inhone india problematic country kaha hai 😮
Yogi=yoga hota
madarsa education
now when the ball is in india's corner and everything going right for it, suddenly "jinnah did not want partition and of course that is true because he kept a house in india"
what a bunch of jokers. very glad partition happened.
this emotional drama can be seductive to a lot of people but not all
i would say ali is 90% knowledgeable person, but still there are things on which mr ali is not correct.
1st. Jinnah was in full support of partition, the whole idea or two state came through him and boosted by him.
2nd. Direct action day happened because of jinnah, because jinnah wanted to prove brits that muslims and hindus can’t stay together.
Khalistan ki history wah bhai waah . So called intellectual of Pakistan 😂😂🤣🤣😂.
K2 plan after 1971 humiliation.
When you yourself don't trusts your army. Then how do you expect Indians to trust them!
Your claim that Jinnah did not support two country theory is completely false.
Please read history.
On 23 March 1940, at a meeting of the Muslim League in Lahore, Jinnah had endorsed such a demand, though without naming “Pakistan”. The proposal of the Muslim League resolution, to unite the Muslim majority provinces and carve out a separate nation was resisted by the Congress at the outset.
Jinna wanted the partition. He wanted the India name for the newly formed County. He only regretted it when he was dying
Modi government forever... 🇮🇳
forever? ferto india democracy kaha raha?😶 India has a powerful ruling party but it needs a powerful opposition as well
Well it sounds wierd but partition of india was inevitable. Totalitarian views of Islam doesn't allow a kafir to rule momin.
I watched 7 second and moved to comedy show.. Better directly watch comedy show 😂😂😂
Ye Pakistan ke intellectuals hai 😂😂😂
Doesn’t seem like this guy was properly prepared for his podcast.
1:34:30 khof of modi among pakistanis is next level 😂😂😂😂
this man have High knowledge in geo politics like abhijeet chavda
Rehne de धिम्मी
I Appreciate his understanding of why Indians have a hatred towards Pakistan, There's solid reason and evidence to it. I understand that things should move for better, but try explaining that to the Victims of 26/11, Parliament Attacks, All 4 Wars, Pathankot, URI and What not. Have some sense on why we behave towards Pakistanis the way we do.
They are same mindset doing al thaqia( harbar hate in heart, show sweet in words) infront of others
@@user-ju1fm8rn1gtum pakka tanatani andhbhakt ho from cow belt jaahil backward hindi states.....aur pushpendra kulshrestha Sanjay dixit Sai Deepak bajarang dal Hindu mahasabha dhirendra shastri svami narsinganand sadhvi pragya Singh Kapil Mishra and sanatani bramhnavadi organisations ko dekhate rehte ho aur india ko hindu pakistan banane me lage ho
@@nikhildeshmukh6221 ohh adltry alla gay mmad follower justice for aisha complete kaatna Of mmad deep inside 😂😂😂😘
@@nikhildeshmukh6221 but mostuslims rape dalit girls in up your seculars are silent
Really Yogi adityanath transform UP into near 1 trillion dollar state.......his some of the projects and policy are next biggest Film industry in Uttar Pradesh, largest religious tourism State, construction of Ram mandir, one district one product, encounter of goons and land mafia, easy FDI process and so on.
K2 module khalistan and Kashmir 😂due to Bangladesh
Excellent podcast and very emotional too. Ali Shb's knowledge on India and Pakistan is very refreshing.
Great Podcast Daniel!!!! Wish more people to people contact is established and India Pakistan brotherhood is established like never before and we can visit each other countries.
I am an Indian and wish to host Pakistani as guest in India.
For Pakistanis cricket is everything. For Indians it’s not. It’s another tournament … even if we lose that’s ok. But no Pakistanis in Indian soil for their fundamentalist mindset.
Enjoyed the podcast. Very balanced and realistic views. thanks for a grate job.
Superb podcast... but real reason behind the sour relation of Pak n India is bcoz of establishment in Pak not politics.. establishment of Pak hatred towards India is bcoz of their prosperity n India a major Hindu country
To update you Sir,
Indians know practically who is with them and who's not !
--- India Is United always !
Islamic state ke khalifa Al -baghdadi bhi hamesha maszid me chupta tha... Jaha usa usko drone strike pe mara
Bhindrawale ne bhi isi liye golden Temple me ghati gara...
Alibhai gotta get up early tomorrow but den saw your snapshot so just can't miss it. Love u bhai. God bless u and you speak logic & fact which is a rarity in Pakistan
Ali Bhai should have his own channel.
Jinnah never wanted partition 😂😂
Bhai, this is Biggest joke I have ever heard😄
Till 1920
Dear Indians, do not get fooled by their +ve approach. Probably they were also put forward by ISI, just like Zaid Hamid or even Imran Khan.
Sir I am from rampur near of Delhi I relate all things of both side .
Thanks Daniyal Bhai for making this series. And of course Ali K Chishti bhai is one of my favorite Human Beings. :)
We don't want any relation with Pakistan we should ignore them
Really love the podcast. One thing I disagree with statement regarding to Muslim have to prove their loyalty towords India because they hated Pakistan due the soldiers are dying in border thats the reason.
1:13:30 if planning is spot on even neighbours can change.
How very little knowledgeable people speak about something he did not knew ...however made a full podcast 🤠 out of it..... great
😂true
It wasn't a Hindu Sikh riots it was congress Sikh riots. Whatever happened I as a Hindu Punjabi will always feel the pain of the 84 riots.
what is the source that nehru promise any land in india
@onlyrugged who the ful is he
this is not some secret . master tara singh was promised a autonomous sikh state by congress leadership . there were 2 group of sikhs groups in punjab . majority of sikhs wanted a sikh state which they got in 1966 and a minority who wanted Khalistan . these khalitani were too small in numbers to make any political impact so that lead to militancy in punjab after 1966.
@onlyrugged😂
ese up me progress dikh raha hai bahut jayada 2021,2022,2023 wala PET ka paper dilado job mil jayegi bhai ko 20 crore ke state ke pass apna shikshak bharti board hi nhi hai aur kon se government school me teacher time par aate hai mai to up se hi hu, corruption bhi bahut hai up me aur kon se iit open ho rahi hai c** ko pata bhi nhi hoga iit state government open nhi karti hai 20crore population par two iit kanpur, iit bhu progress@@payalmishra___567
ali k chishti look like a educated man
with a pinch of salt😂😂
Point to be remember
Trade Pakistan ne bandh kiya tha... India ne nahi.
"Jinnah never wanted partition" is Ayesha Jalal's thesis. Please read Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmad's book "Jinnah: His Successes, Failures and Role in History" where he refutes this claim objectively.
Frustration dekh raha hein binod 😂😂😂
When you know you are doing good work without compromising your ideals trolls and haters hardly matters ❤
Muslim League fought 1946 elections on religion, Jinnah was jealous of Gandhi as he stole the thunder post 1920. Pre independence Muslims were in majority in police jobs and army so they wouldn't have any problem in united India. still M-League dog whistled and played into hands of British (British wanted buffer b/w russia and India, also wanted us keep fighting so we wont develop) . India become independent , Pakistan got separated. Basically a bunch of Muslim feudal lords wanted control post independence that cannot be achieved in India due to congress so without much future plan and constitution got a country easily. Only organization is Army that is structured, trained.
Pakistan 🇵🇰 Ko INDIA se 50 Saal pichhe h Apko educational ko update karna padega 20 saal purana education systumm nhi chalega
Hey bro I'm from NEPAL🇳🇵Daniyal you're doing great job i used to listen your podcast while I'm in kitchen even in t**let also
Kata bata ho timi ??
Ho muji podcasts wala aaley xa 30%fact
70%misinformation 😂😂
00:00 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Daniyal i'm agree with you in all the points , You guys almost represnt the facts very nicely but i'm disagree with you only one point. Mohm Ali Jinnah demanded to break away the indian subcontinent on the basis of religion. It is historically proven truth can't be denied.
Why did Jinnah gave call for Direct Action Day if he didnt want partition?
These people have to tell the lies because the truth is so hard to swallow.
54:59 ha bilkul Pakistan ki galti nahi hai syed ahmed khan ki galti hai
I enjoy your videos Daniyal. Love from India. I really hope you are able to visit your ancestral place in India someday.
Love bsdk
Udhar hee chala ja .tere phhufa hein nah wo
Madarchod
Aagar same hota toh abhi tak nahi hota jinda😊
Tum Bengaliyo ko kabhi akal nhi ayegi. Aren’t you enjoying the current peaceful community’s government in Bengal?
@@Aashu299 padhai karlo thoda, different logon se mil lo, ghum lo thoda, jan jaoge, duniya aur zindagi Tik Tok reels aur keyboard nationalism se bohot badi hai, aur yeh ghisi piti 'Bengali' walla dialogue mat sunao, it makes you sound as communal as the people you are alluding to.
'Allude' ka matlab maulm nahi to dictionary dekh lo.
@@ronojoybasu9126 beta sunn, pichle 12-13 saal se follow kar rha hu Pakistan ko main. Inke slangs, Urdu/Punjabi tak samajhne laga hu main ab. 4 cheeze pooch lunga to muh ban jayega tera. Waha Hindu beheno ko ye ghar se utha k le ja rhe h aur tu inki dalali kar rha h. Tu gaya h kya Pakistan jo gyaan pel rha h?
@@ronojoybasu9126that's why your state is in the current mess.
Your agencies were providing them weapons. When bhindranwale siege golden temple. He had weapons with him.
No plane can be highjacked without external help.
Pakistan has been adding fuel to the fire.
If kulbhushan is a spy then why did your government failed to prove it in international court of justice.
Same Benazir Bhutto gave huge push to terrorists in Kashmir during 90s and in result 5 lakh Hindus became refugees in their own country, thousands hindu pandits got killed. 😢
49:51 Na Bhai you will be next North Korea.
1:30:32 upar wale ne ni bhai power khud banai hai..we INDIAN believe in work.. pakistan hi upr wale ke bharose rete😂😂
I request my fellow citizens to not fall for the information warfare. Plz listen to J Sai Deepak and Sanjay Dixit on why Pakistan can never leave hostile behaviour towards us. It’s not about Kashmir, it’s about k@fir Hindus.
1:05:50 aby takle wo welcome har team ko mila tha.
If any GORA would visit he would receive same hospitality
Pakistan can get huge benefit from india. If pak stop lie, punish wrong group and individual, only talk positive
Talk positive and India will believe? That's off the table now 😂
Wow! The clarity about India and history of India Ali has is amazing. Brilliant podcast
If Pakistanis were so disheartened by the horrors of partition what made them invade j&k within days of independence???
These double standards