Sir, North Indians don't consider South Indians inferior because they are darker. From where does Dr. Hoodbhoy get these stereotypes? In fact, north Indians respect south Indians for their culture, traditions, high education, cleanliness and many other things. Rabid racism based on skin color is a hallmark of Muslim psyche. Non Muslims tend to evolve /reform. Color based discrimination is therefore less. Besides, we are equally Indians, whether North, South East or West Indians.
He is "secular" Islamist who wakes up each day just to bark that if islamic Republic of hira Mandi bhikharistan porkistan Pakistan is shitty so are every other nations That's what quraand expects these rape jihad ki najayaz paidaish secular Islamists to do😂😂
Bro, there was a time when in most Bollywood movies the role of the comedian was always played by a "Madraasi'. In closed circles, the word "Khatta" was used to refer to South Indians. Things have gotten much better in the last two decades, but still the insistence for South Indians to speak to North Indians in Hindi , while being in South Indian states is there, may not be as bad as how easy Pakistanis were forced to speak Urdu, but it is a problem nonetheless
@@sujaysukumar123 Comedian was never 'always' Madrasi in Bollywood, except in a couple of films in which Mahmood played the role of a south Indian speaking Hindi in South accent. I have not encountered any north Indian mentioning south Indians in a condescending manner at all. In fact, I've always heard them addressing people from South as the brain and culture of India. Actually at times I've encountered prejudiced attitude/statements of SIs, especially from Andhra Pradesh, towards north Indians. In large cities, north -south marriages are common now. Also NIs live and work in South & vice versa. People are close friends also. As for the languages, everyone is free to speak their language, there's no force. North Indians raised in South fluently speak Tamil /Telugu /Kannada or Malayalam. That is great. If one can learn more languages, why not? There's no superior or inferior. Every state, race, language or culture is equally rich/precious and unique in India. Let's preserve and cherish our diversity. This makes a composite, strong identity of India, which is unity in diversity.
@@Soullight09You are talking about the current scenario where the racism on south indians have reduced and the hoodbhoy was also saying the same that it 'used to' happen and now its different. I agree that it used to often a lot few decades back, not anymore
@@chittaranjanshetty4546 Even in the past, where there was cosmopolitan North -South -East - West Indian mix crowd, there was no deliberate persecution of South Indians. In fact, Northies preferred South Indians for their intelligence and work ethics. Maybe a few made fun of South accent. This was wrong, but that was it. My great grandfather had a dear South Indian colleague, my grandfather worked under a respectable South Indian boss, my parents have colleagues & friends from South. Now some of my cousins /niece /nephew are married with South Indians. The racism of Pakistani "white" Muslims against "dark" Bangladeshi was dangerous. There was systematic persecution. The former killed thousands of Bangladeshi for upholding their language and culture. This can't be compared in any way with past- if at all- North/South difference in India. In any point of time in my opinion, South Indians were never considered "inferior" in India. In fact, even from my great grand father's version I've heard nothing but respect for South Indians. They recounted how SIs were superior in many ways. To consider anyone superior or inferior based on skin color or money comes from the lowest, smallest of human conscious & character.
one can see sadness and helplessness in his eyes as if he is tired of problems of his country. A True patriot of Pakistan though he denies he is not a patriot.
Hoodbhoy sir, I am from India and I always follow you for your intellectual discussions. But at the same time, I also disagree with you at many points specially when you talk about India. Even in this discussion, you said that north Indian were doesn't like South Indian because of their height, color or language which is totally wrong. It never happens here. India is far greater than anyone even can imagine.
@KARTIKEY AGARWAL U R A LITTLE OFF TARGET WHAT DR.HOOODHBOY SAID ABOUT SOUTH INDIAN N NORTH INDIAN IS TRUE TO SOME EXTENT. ABOUT 30 YRS BACK THE AVERAGE NORTH INDIAN USE TO LOOK DOWN ON THE SOUTH AS NOT WORTH TALKING TO. BUT KNOW THE SITUATION HAS CHANGED THE SOUTH BECAUSE IT WAS MORE FOCUSED MADE RAPID STRIDES IN EDUCATION N MADE A NAME FOR THEMSELVES, ALSO THE SOUTH LED IN INNOVATION N TECHNOLOGY THAN THE NORTH. BUT YES IN TODAYS WORLD, TIME N SITUATIONS HAV BROUGHT US TOGETHER AS INDIAN'S, WHICH I AM VERY HAPPY FOR. IF V DONT UNITE AS ONE THEN WE SA INDIAN'S N SANATANI WILL B NO MORE. TODAY IF U COME TO ANY SOUTH INDIAN STATES EVEN IN TIER 2 N 3 CITIES HAV LOTS OF NORTH INDIAN IN VARIOUS FIELDS N VICE VERSA. HISTORY HAS TAUGHT US VERY HARD LESSONS WHICH WILL STAND US IN GOOD STEAD.🙏🙏🙏🙏
@@kashifpeterify south Indian I love north India we are siblings we fight love eternal north resources make south rich tax to north not Pakistani punjab eating other resources 😮 accept reality Anna baloch gas bengal Karachi budget was gone to punjab In India We aren't like that Anna nin maka hogo navu south Indian Nam India ❤ more more than all.
As a matter of fact Indians of different states are different - in appearance, physique etc. Not just South India vs north India. It is incorrect to say that all Indians of North are fair and that of South are dark. Within the state too people are slightly different from region to region. Still we are one, north to south, east to west. Like a lot of flowers make one garland.
Very good discussion. When Mr Hoodbhoy suggests that 'india took advantage' of in 1971. What does it mean? Should the operation searchlight be kept hidden from the public?
Advantage in the sense of attacking on a part which was vulnerable in that point of time n india had taken the advantage of internal situation of a newly formed country, its just like srilanka had a economic melt down n some country attack it n take advantage of the situation, pakistan although had also attacked indian side from the west pakistan position and had captured thousands of indian troops which later exchanged during the release of POW from each sides.
Drama of nonsensical military action and surrender in east Pakistan was staged for the sole political benefit of India, independence of East Pakistan was already agreed upon between USA USSR China Pakistan India and Bangali leadership for months. Read, "white house years", by Henry Kissinger.
@@biggdaddyy I'm from north side I know how education system is very bad here students are very clueless about their future and all also frustrated for not being employed
Huge fan of Dr. Hoodbhoy. He chooses to live in Pakistan despite of all odds.. He is the most patriotic person Pakistan has got! He is the torch of wisdom .. hope sane people in Pakistan will use his advice.
Rightly said Sir. During working in Kuwait and Dubai we Pakistanis were laughing at Bangladeshis but now They are laughing at us bcz of current situation in Pakistan. Shameful
@shameemqureshi2774 dont worry, agar reality and truth accept kar rahe ho , toh sahi raah par ho...pahunchta koi nahi hai...sahi raah bas enjoy karni hoti hai... jhooth se kam stressful hoti hai maybe... (my 2 cents)
As an Indian, it pains me whenever a literal scientist, a liberal, a free thinker like Pervez Hoodbhoy uses "Indian" and "Hindu" interchangeably. You are not doing justice to a big chunk of minorities by not including them in India's growth.
He has to talk in terms that people use around there, otherwise har cheez ki definition aap logon ko samjhane chalenge toh baat bhool jayenge... audience ki language and level ke according bolna padta hai, vo fool nahi hai, for this he is wise.
Sir why don’t you conduct the interviews in English? Being the South Indian could not follow it had of you are talking. Though your analysis are very good and realistic.
Hood bhai you critisize Pakistani atom bomb why not Indian bomb? I think you are dishonest intlectual. Sorry to say that your name is Hood Bhai but due to your prejudiced comments it seems that you are Hanood bhai or yahoo bhai.Being a Pakistani and against Pakistan is matter of shame on your part.
I can understand why pervez Houdaboy feels great because he is probably the only pakistani to get PHD from MIT. We have more than 100's of PHD from Harvard, MIT, Princeton, Stanford, Berkeley, Caltech etc
Hindus never begged or asked Britishers for education and science, India was one of the oldest civilizations which talked about science. As far as education is concerned, Nalanda and Takshashila were one of the oldest universities in the world which were destroyed by white huns (Iranians) and Khiljis respectively even before the Mughals came to India. So Science based on logic and experiments was part of ancient India and its culture which also helped us to gain a humungous amount of wealth and wisdom and all the tribes and rulers from Ghazni and Ghori's of the world to Britishers everybody came to have a piece of it. The education system you see today is a product of capitalism and the post-modern world.
Thanks God Bangladesh has been saved from hybrid colonial system of Pakistan in 1971.Almighty Creator is a great planner & just.. Otherwise Bangladesh would had been situation like as Baluchistan or Afghanistan.
Muslim in India are not happy.. When Pakistan is going to finish it's task of taking Indian Muslims😢... Plz take Indian Muslims... And give us leftover Hindus sikh Christian
Indian Muslims are 15% of the population. So if this 15% population joins Pakistan, then they'll take 15% of the India's land with them. Which parts of land would they get?
@@imgn8r715Pakistan received more land in proportion to it's population. So India should actually demand land from Pakistan, even after full population exchange.
i think sir your DNA brought you back same thing happened to me too now i am satisfy here i was in america lived for 10 years tought math in houston college but unsatidfied.
Al-Khwarizmi refers to Indian mathematicians in his work. In his book *Kitab al-Jabr wa-al-Muqabala* (The Book of Algebra and Al-Muqabala), Al-Khwarizmi mentions several Indian mathematicians, including Brahmagupta and Aryabhata. He also refers to the Indian numeral system, which he called the "Hindu numerals". Al-Khwarizmi's work was heavily influenced by Indian mathematics, and he acknowledged this in his book. He wrote that he had "collected the rules of this science from the Hindus" and that he had "arranged them in an orderly manner". Al-Khwarizmi's work on algebra was a major contribution to mathematics, and it helped to spread Indian mathematical ideas to the West. His work was translated into Latin in the 12th century, and it became an important source of mathematical knowledge for European mathematicians. Here are some of the Indian mathematicians that Al-Khwarizmi referred to in his work: * Brahmagupta (598-670 CE): An Indian mathematician and astronomer, Brahmagupta is best known for his work on the Brahmasphutasiddhanta, a treatise on mathematics and astronomy. [Image of Brahmagupta, Indian mathematician] * Aryabhata (476-550 CE): An Indian mathematician and astronomer, Aryabhata is best known for his work on the Aryabhatiya, a treatise on mathematics and astronomy. [Image of Aryabhata, Indian mathematician] * Mahavira (800-870 CE): A Jain mathematician, Mahavira made important contributions to the field of numerical mathematics. He wrote a treatise on numerical mathematics titled Ganita Sara Sangraha, which includes a discussion of decimal fractions, the rules of arithmetic, and the solution of linear and quadratic equations. [Image of Mahavira, Indian mathematician] Al-Khwarizmi's work on algebra was a major contribution to mathematics, and it helped to spread Indian mathematical ideas to the West. His work was translated into Latin in the 12th century, and it became an important source of mathematical knowledge for European mathematicians.
Unfortunately still people of Pakistan think that they lost half of the country in1971.Basically Pakistan lost his colonial part in 1971 that was East bengal. so east bengal was never a part of pakistan but a colony of pakistan .when you never respect someone or any specific area as equally. Claiming that colony as a own part then it does not make any sense or make any change The actual relation between Pakistan and East Bengal was like owner and slaves ,Boss and Servants. Pakistan & people of pakistan treated Bengal and bengali people as 3rd class people & burden of pakistan from the first day. People of pakistan loved to use some racist word against bengali people like Kala Bengali and Bukha Bengali. Even after 1971 still today people of pakistan love to use some word like ""daw take ki aurat"" to devalue the currency of Bangladesh. But now that two taka equal to almost 6 pakistani rupee. so pakistan did not lost his half of a country but lost his colony in 1971. its a harsh reality of the history. people of pakistan should not claim that lost half of the country in 1971 and should stop claiming that it was a part because it does not make any sense or any change. that's why pakistan has never take a lesson from 1971 because it was not part of pakistan . its a real fact that state like pakistan never take a lesson from colony
Study your recent political history, from 47 to 71, especially the sixties, south Indians were demanding independence. The US state department was extremely concerned because India was on the verge of disintegration, that's why they (USA) staged Bangladesh drama.
i have seen 1000s of masjid have been destroyed latest one peshawar by bomb blast in pakistan by ttp (monster created by pakistan army to disturb peace in india ) can u give me example in which masjid have been destroyed by bomb blast in india inflation in india 6% inflation in Pakistan 40% whose is more happier Pakistani india export 900 billion dollar Pakistan export 30 billion india forex $600 dollar Pakistan forex $3 billion 8 lakh muslim pakistanl left Pakistan fortress of islam 2 lakh(10000 Indian muslim) india left india in 2022 india population 140 crore Pakistan population 22 crore now u decide who is more happier Pakistani musalman or Indian muslaman muslim in india have increased from 9% to 16%
I heard a reference to Algebra and Arabs … I think the Pakistanis should know that Algebra is an ancient Indian invention .. those people might even be the ancestors of the Pakistanis 🤣🤣
Algebra is not made by Arabs but was made under Hind Shahi dynasty ( Hindu kingdom is present day Afghanistan, which was a part of Bharat in vedic ages)
There are a number of Pakistani intellectuals like Dr. Pervej who are constantly trying to enlighten the Pakistanis about their country, its history, its governance and trying to guide their country towards a good future. They, however, suffer from two problems-One, they never criticize the army which is at the root of their problems and two, they seem to harbour some grudge against India. That deep rooted belief that "they" belong to the "conquerer's" race and are superior to the "native" Hindus runs in their mind even as they see and realize the fact that natives are outperforming them in all walks of life. This is what happens when a people follow a person who wanted to be head of state at any cost. But the effort does not seem to be bearing fruit.
This man is very clear in his thouts and views and says what he beliews in unlike others who are intellectually dishonest.They can not say what they want to say but cant say.Had he been in some other country he would have been given a high responsible position for the betterment in his feild of science and other social activities.Such people are never retured and their services are utilized any time any day till thier willingness to perform. I pray for his good health.
Pakistan needs few thousand Hoodbhoy's and other population should follow them to become a better place for better life . And first of all Pakistani people should get rid of Confused identity and resolve their identity crisis
Hindu-Arabic numerals, set of 10 symbols-1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 0-that represent numbers in the decimal number system. They originated in India in the 6th or 7th century and were introduced to Europe through the writings of Middle Eastern mathematicians, especially al-Khwarizmi and al-Kindi, about the 12th century. Read about -: Katyayna 300 BC Pingla 500 BC Aryabhatta Bhaskaracharya Brahmagupta Baudhāyana Mahavira Sridhara Varahmihhira Yativarsabha All these people born way before your Arabic scholars.
As an Indian we will be happy to witness growth of Pakistan in the educational sector which should be a nations top priority. But sorry to say that given the current leadership at place it will be very difficult to turns things around in the near future.
@@osamarehman3120 Abusive comment can't change the fact : science is always stays with us not religion . Chuslim is far behind science ( do you like this comment ? Sorry to other muslim persons ).
Partition was a great thing. If you look at the present scenerio India is having difficulty with muslims in India. Imagine the plight if there were 80 crore of them living in 7th century mentality.
India didn't take advantage of the situation in east Pakistan...it got sick of the refugee crisis that your army created there. It couldn't handle the influx that happened then ...infact we are still suffering from the lot that entered in the '70- '71!
Dr. Hoodbhoy is a very knowledgeable, sensible and honest individual. All sensible persons respect him. The govt of Pakistan should make him the minister of education and give him full freedom to reform the Pakistani educational system.
A telescope was presented to Jehangir by a European visit. He showed no interest and instead was very fascinated by some wine bottles given to him. This is why India made no scientific contributions from 1000 AD to 1700 AD during Islamic invasion.
A nation that celebrates going against Allah's commands and commemorates it with a day called Yaum e Takbir, is there any hope left ? Quran orders NOT to destroy non-fighting people, animals, cities or crops etc. even during war or for it. The Pakistani atom bomb I guess will nevee be able to be as selective as Quran orders to be.....do you see how delusional the Pakistanu mindset is ...
Ravindranath Tagore of Bengal was the first Asian who received noble prize in 1913 , Amartya sen 2nd Bengali who got noble prize in economics , Avigit Benerjee 3rd Bengali got noble prize in economics, Mohammed yunis of Banla Desh got noble prize in economics , Tagore got noble prize in literature, forwriting Gitanjali in Bengali / English language,
Thank you Sir for presenting Mr Hoodbhoy Sir an outstanding scholar of Pakistan and his comment and your discussion is just outstanding in all respect. Hats off to both of you. My best Regards to Sir Hoodbhoy. India🇮🇳
Hoodbhoy is one of the best minds we have in Pakistan.I wish & hope that we could take full advantage of people like him. May Allah Subhanatallah have mercy on us and put us on the right track.
Religion and Science do not go together! His message is about SCIENCE - Science and Religion MUST be separated big time! His message on education means you have to close all crazy Madarsas and teach proper secular STEM (Science Technology Engineering Math) to kids. The Indian and Pakistani DNA is SAME - the ONLY negative for Pakistan is too MUCH emphasis on the PAST glory of ISLAM and TOO little emphasis on Science & Innovation. India was lucky to have leaders like Nehru (IITs) and Modi (Heavy Innovation Guy) and Manmohan Singh (Heavy financial deregulation guy) - they focused on NON religious education and focus on excellence. Pakistan's political environment is so lousy that a genius mind like Hoodbhoy is under-utilized. and side-lined. India made people like Abdul-J-Kalam - a true scientist as President (despite him being a MUSLIM!!) while Pakistan has had only LANDLORDs and FAUJIS as leaders - completely mindless when it comes to innovation.
Great Interview... Prof Hoodboy is one of the finest ppl around... He speaks the TRUTH... Uncomfortable at times... but, that's what TRUTH is all about... :)
Even an educated person like Mr. Hoodbhoy doesn’t have the complete information by 1947 Hindus got 2 Nobel prize 1. Rabindra Nath Tagore ( Literature) 2. C.V. Raman ( Physics) And Pakistan call people like this intellectuals. #irony_prevails
Once their fix their identity by acknowledging they are converted Hindus and hating Hindus is not good for them, things will improve for them. It will take another 100 years for them to clean up their minds
Could have had a significant better execution. Immediate migration was not needed. Could have been carried out in long phases to avoid loss of lives. And complete population exchange should have taken place, as only Muslims were given the right to vote for partition, so why should India bear the burden of muslims after creation of Islamic nation state(s).
In 1956 when we came from south to Delhi and stayed amidst refugee and north dominated colony most of locals used us blackie and fun such as eating with hand,chutias are weak because they eat rice etc etc.Ssme situation as with bengalis in pakistan. Fortunately central govt policies snd movement of people created nearness and adjustment.
The only one who recognizes that atom bomb is actually unislamic ! Because Quran, Sunnah and History tells that even in war the Prophet PBUH ordered NOT to harm anyone or anything other than the ones actually fighting with you! Since atom bombs cannot follow this maxim, it is going straight against orders of Allah and to add insult to it this nation calls it Yaum e Takbeer! Await a terrible recompense in Allah's court very soon indeed, for lying and lying in Allah's name itself !
Dr Pervez hoodbhoy is a great professor born in Pakistan. He should be in India because India can utilize the intelligence of this man. Pakistan can't use this man for his country because of cruel nature. He is the ocean of knowledge in physics. He is also truth spoken. He was lovable person joking sometimes. Love you sir but you should be in India. Pakistan can't deserve you. 💕
Parvez sir you are gem. If Pakistan listen to you then they solve there every problems. Sorry to say indian listen him more because indian know the values of gem. Diamond in coal
Words of Dr Pervaiz Hood Bhai, are words of wisdom. Such personalities should be frequently invited to open common person's minds to retrack our direction, if we want development in Modern Studies of the world.
18:47 Sir Hoodboy I respectfully disagree that you just handed the torch of rationale and referred those Mutazallas as Muslims which were persecuted and discriminated by other Muslims and weren't even considered muslims as they denied Qur'an being the most knowledgeable book while also denying the implication of the Shariah. They were against it and were persecuted. It's like wiping out all Kadyanis as they aren't muslims but calling them as Muslims when you want to gain some advantage
Dr Hoodbhoy is an inspiration and a Global role Model. It is sad to see the frustration of this brilliant mind. There are amazing lessons for everyone who wants to listen.
What a sorted personality Pervez Saab I do appreciate his honest opinions and clarity of thoughts. Anybody who is having negative comments, pleaae try to understand that he is geniunely trying to address the wrongdoing of past generations and seek better future for every human being. The young chap sitting next to him is also very mature and seeks to address the issues. By the way, i am from India and not muslim. When i meet some good pakistani people in Dubai, i knew that we are same. Just keep religion aside for a moment and we are same ....Human. i wish we do have people on both sides of border thinking in same way
Out of depth mostly by being MohMadden because MohMadism makes him lose his roots. His ancestors like Jinah's took Bedouinized Yahoodi names to get business contracts and avoid Jiziya. China treats MohMadism as Mental Disease and so puts MohMadden males in concentration camps like mental asylums and uses MohMadden wombs to breed Haan Chinese kids. India needs learn from China the master of slave Pakistan. China killed original AbraHarami gangs/legions Christianity & Islam wearing burkha of Marxism. It knew these gangs Christianity & Islam are Weapons of Mass Destruction or toolkits for Anglos and the West to be used against natives and their nation building. Depression & Maniacal Violence is much more prevalent in AbraHaramized societies compared to Dharmic societies like Bharat, Bhutan, Nepal, Mayanmar, Tibet, Baali, Thailand etc. AbraHarami societies are rootless parasitic in nature. They can only survive on robbery, banditry & killing. In such AbraHarami societies if one cannot rob or kill others then one starts harming & killing oneself. Khalifa Al Lundoni Chiknah Jinah & EkBall were Western in thought and dress. Edu= Innate native skills Cate=Care/Nurture. Moulvi of madarassa & mosque, Padri of church & convent & urban Naxals KaamRaids are not in education but they are in deracination or cutting native roots business. Dharma is native and organic. Christianity, Islam, Marxism and Fiat Currency like $ driven Hedonistic Consumerism are legions/gangs to grab REgal political power to enslave/colonize, rob and deracinate converts so that they hate everything native and willingly serve as cannon fodder to create & maintain evil empires for VatiCunning Pope, Lecherous Khalifa, BriShit Queen, Politburo KaamRaid Honcho and Wall Street, Hollywood crooks. The natives who have taken Bedouinized Yahoodi, Romanized Yahoodi names and have cut their native roots cannot be considered citizen of a Dharmic nation like Bharat. So what's this minority & majority? These gangs & their gang members have done majority almost 99% of killings since their inception 1600 years back. They are majorly responsible to make this planet unlivable. No wonder Hoodboy doesn't talk about native Kanad Rishi who preceded Greeks thousands of years. Rootlessness is taught from the childhood. Science Mullah ho ya Madarassa Mullah, hai toh woh Mullah. Final result is Pakistan, Bangladesh, 26/11 & 9/11.
I am surprised that such intelligent people like Hoodbhoy exist in Pakistan. Your knowledge of History is even better than Science. You deserve to be in India not Pakistan.
I am a Bengali, Pakistani army is a Butcher of Bengal. Jab tak Pakistan ye Islam ka Concept se nikal nehi payega tab tak iss ka kuch na ho payega. For Bengalies it is Bangla Language first not islam, and more over we are hindu so now way. Now i am an Proud Indian.
He is sounding intellectual because he is just one rational speaking Pakistani. Every university in India has super intellectual teachers and professors. Just that they are too focused in teaching their students and making building blocks of India’s bright future.
@@osamarehman3120rape jihad ki najayaz paidaish ganduudin namazi aashiq gay rasool, u pakis born after rape jihad of ur begairat behaya ghasti raped and converted musalmina ammi khala behen by qasim ghori ghazni Babar Aurangzeb nadir Shah abdali Arab Turk Irani Afghans surely look like gay ganduudin when u all raise ur islam filled ghazi haji pichwada in air 5 times a day for doggy style namaz in halala chudai ka adda masjid 😂😂😂
i have seen 1000s of masjid have been destroyed latest one peshawar by bomb blast in pakistan by ttp (monster created by pakistan army to disturb peace in india ) can u give me example in which masjid have been destroyed by bomb blast in india inflation in india 6% inflation in Pakistan 40% whose is more happier Pakistani india export 900 billion dollar Pakistan export 30 billion india forex $600 dollar Pakistan forex $3 billion 8 lakh muslim pakistanl left Pakistan fortress of islam 2 lakh(10000 Indian muslim) india left india in 2022 india population 140 crore Pakistan population 22 crore now u decide who is more happier Pakistani musalman or Indian muslaman muslim in india have increased from 9% to 16%
All people of Pakistan must accept that basically they are Indian upto 1947 and then they became pakistani. In no way they are Turkish, Arabin Or from any other parts of the world.
Even if the Kashmir dispute were to be resolved, the animosity between the people of India and Pakistan would persist due to a tumultuous thousand-year history marred by religious conflicts. The strained relationship between India and Pakistan stems not solely from religious differences. In my view, the internet stands as one of the most remarkable inventions in human history, providing a platform for sharing knowledge and fostering understanding. I firmly believe that, one day, the citizens of Pakistan and India will come to comprehend the futility of religious discord and embrace atheism-an ideology that promotes tolerance, critical thinking, and a shared humanity. By transcending the limitations of religious divisions, both nations can embark on a path of mutual respect and cooperation, leading to the resolution of all outstanding issues. Atheism can serve as a catalyst for a new era of peace and harmony, where differences are celebrated rather than used as a basis for hatred and conflict.
China and Vietnam, both atheist countries fought against each other . Atheist Soviet union invaded Czechoslovakia and Hungary . Khmer Rouge, synonymous with Genocide , outlawed religion . Saying that abolishing religion will end human conflict is too simplistic world view .
Sir, North Indians don't consider South Indians inferior because they are darker. From where does Dr. Hoodbhoy get these stereotypes? In fact, north Indians respect south Indians for their culture, traditions, high education, cleanliness and many other things. Rabid racism based on skin color is a hallmark of Muslim psyche. Non Muslims tend to evolve /reform. Color based discrimination is therefore less. Besides, we are equally Indians, whether North, South East or West Indians.
He is "secular" Islamist who wakes up each day just to bark that if islamic Republic of hira Mandi bhikharistan porkistan Pakistan is shitty so are every other nations
That's what quraand expects these rape jihad ki najayaz paidaish secular Islamists to do😂😂
Bro, there was a time when in most Bollywood movies the role of the comedian was always played by a "Madraasi'. In closed circles, the word "Khatta" was used to refer to South Indians. Things have gotten much better in the last two decades, but still the insistence for South Indians to speak to North Indians in Hindi , while being in South Indian states is there, may not be as bad as how easy Pakistanis were forced to speak Urdu, but it is a problem nonetheless
@@sujaysukumar123 Comedian was never 'always' Madrasi in Bollywood, except in a couple of films in which Mahmood played the role of a south Indian speaking Hindi in South accent. I have not encountered any north Indian mentioning south Indians in a condescending manner at all. In fact, I've always heard them addressing people from South as the brain and culture of India. Actually at times I've encountered prejudiced attitude/statements of SIs, especially from Andhra Pradesh, towards north Indians. In large cities, north -south marriages are common now. Also NIs live and work in South & vice versa. People are close friends also. As for the languages, everyone is free to speak their language, there's no force. North Indians raised in South fluently speak Tamil /Telugu /Kannada or Malayalam. That is great. If one can learn more languages, why not? There's no superior or inferior. Every state, race, language or culture is equally rich/precious and unique in India. Let's preserve and cherish our diversity. This makes a composite, strong identity of India, which is unity in diversity.
@@Soullight09You are talking about the current scenario where the racism on south indians have reduced and the hoodbhoy was also saying the same that it 'used to' happen and now its different. I agree that it used to often a lot few decades back, not anymore
@@chittaranjanshetty4546 Even in the past, where there was cosmopolitan North -South -East - West Indian mix crowd, there was no deliberate persecution of South Indians. In fact, Northies preferred South Indians for their intelligence and work ethics. Maybe a few made fun of South accent. This was wrong, but that was it. My great grandfather had a dear South Indian colleague, my grandfather worked under a respectable South Indian boss, my parents have colleagues & friends from South. Now some of my cousins /niece /nephew are married with South Indians. The racism of Pakistani "white" Muslims against "dark" Bangladeshi was dangerous. There was systematic persecution. The former killed thousands of Bangladeshi for upholding their language and culture. This can't be compared in any way with past- if at all- North/South difference in India. In any point of time in my opinion, South Indians were never considered "inferior" in India. In fact, even from my great grand father's version I've heard nothing but respect for South Indians. They recounted how SIs were superior in many ways. To consider anyone superior or inferior based on skin color or money comes from the lowest, smallest of human conscious & character.
one can see sadness and helplessness in his eyes as if he is tired of problems of his country. A True patriot of Pakistan though he denies he is not a patriot.
He is not a nationalist or patriotic in nature but he loves the country n the people..
Ye Dr. Abdussalam ke Shagird the, to vSoch bhi wessi hi hi paye. Allah in ko slamat rake.
Hoodbhoy sir, I am from India and I always follow you for your intellectual discussions. But at the same time, I also disagree with you at many points specially when you talk about India. Even in this discussion, you said that north Indian were doesn't like South Indian because of their height, color or language which is totally wrong. It never happens here. India is far greater than anyone even can imagine.
@KARTIKEY AGARWAL U R A LITTLE OFF TARGET WHAT DR.HOOODHBOY SAID ABOUT SOUTH INDIAN N NORTH INDIAN IS TRUE TO SOME EXTENT. ABOUT 30 YRS BACK THE AVERAGE NORTH INDIAN USE TO LOOK DOWN ON THE SOUTH AS NOT WORTH TALKING TO. BUT KNOW THE SITUATION HAS CHANGED THE SOUTH BECAUSE IT WAS MORE FOCUSED MADE RAPID STRIDES IN EDUCATION N MADE A NAME FOR THEMSELVES, ALSO THE SOUTH LED IN INNOVATION N TECHNOLOGY THAN THE NORTH.
BUT YES IN TODAYS WORLD, TIME N SITUATIONS HAV BROUGHT US TOGETHER AS INDIAN'S, WHICH I AM VERY HAPPY FOR. IF V DONT UNITE AS ONE THEN WE SA INDIAN'S N SANATANI WILL B NO MORE. TODAY IF U COME TO ANY SOUTH INDIAN STATES EVEN IN TIER 2 N 3 CITIES HAV LOTS OF NORTH INDIAN IN VARIOUS FIELDS N VICE VERSA. HISTORY HAS TAUGHT US VERY HARD LESSONS WHICH WILL STAND US IN GOOD STEAD.🙏🙏🙏🙏
Accept reality
@@kashifpeterify the reality is .. north indian don't hate south indians and visa versa ... but pakistani can live their deluded lives ..nobody cares
@@kashifpeterify south Indian I love north India we are siblings we fight love eternal north resources make south rich tax to north
not Pakistani punjab eating other resources 😮 accept reality Anna baloch gas bengal Karachi budget was gone to punjab
In India We aren't like that Anna nin maka hogo navu south Indian Nam India ❤ more more than all.
As a matter of fact Indians of different states are different - in appearance, physique etc. Not just South India vs north India. It is incorrect to say that all Indians of North are fair and that of South are dark. Within the state too people are slightly different from region to region. Still we are one, north to south, east to west. Like a lot of flowers make one garland.
Very good discussion.
When Mr Hoodbhoy suggests that 'india took advantage' of in 1971. What does it mean? Should the operation searchlight be kept hidden from the public?
He should have fed the 10 million refugees.
Advantage in the sense of attacking on a part which was vulnerable in that point of time n india had taken the advantage of internal situation of a newly formed country, its just like srilanka had a economic melt down n some country attack it n take advantage of the situation, pakistan although had also attacked indian side from the west pakistan position and had captured thousands of indian troops which later exchanged during the release of POW from each sides.
@@wajidabid961 did Pak studies teach you this?
@@Dhhu333 you can read indian pow in 1971 stories which ur media and studies have ignored due to bangladesh.
Drama of nonsensical military action and surrender in east Pakistan was staged for the sole political benefit of India, independence of East Pakistan was already agreed upon between USA USSR China Pakistan India and Bangali leadership for months.
Read, "white house years", by Henry Kissinger.
Just for your knowledge, ISRO is mostly headed by South Indians and most employees are from South.
Indian of south are very knowledgeable nd intelligent
Sir, Aap Indian Sub Continational Product, Soch Vahi, Rahan Sahan Vahi. Khup Brilliant thanks, 👏 👌 Tum Sach Bolane Vale Shaksa 😀 👏 Sir, Badnasibi.
Brilliant & Very good 👍 Discussion. Que& Answer's Scientific. Future is 👎 no Bright. Army & Mahajab ki Soch Fake haii.
Most of the billionaires and big corporates are from north . Founder of ISRO was also from north .
@@biggdaddyy I'm from north side I know how education system is very bad here students are very clueless about their future and all
also frustrated for not being employed
Huge fan of Dr. Hoodbhoy. He chooses to live in Pakistan despite of all odds.. He is the most patriotic person Pakistan has got! He is the torch of wisdom .. hope sane people in Pakistan will use his advice.
Rightly said Sir. During working in Kuwait and Dubai we Pakistanis were laughing at Bangladeshis but now They are laughing at us bcz of current situation in Pakistan. Shameful
I wish they laugh more and more loudly. We’ve earned it.
@@shameemqureshi277411:33
@shameemqureshi2774 dont worry, agar reality and truth accept kar rahe ho , toh sahi raah par ho...pahunchta koi nahi hai...sahi raah bas enjoy karni hoti hai... jhooth se kam stressful hoti hai maybe... (my 2 cents)
You're not from pakistan a fake indian I'd pretending pakistani here lol😂😂
Shameem behan keya app discussion ke aya sakti hein
As an Indian, it pains me whenever a literal scientist, a liberal, a free thinker like Pervez Hoodbhoy uses "Indian" and "Hindu" interchangeably. You are not doing justice to a big chunk of minorities by not including them in India's growth.
He has to talk in terms that people use around there, otherwise har cheez ki definition aap logon ko samjhane chalenge toh baat bhool jayenge... audience ki language and level ke according bolna padta hai, vo fool nahi hai, for this he is wise.
Upar se neeche tak har koi jihadi Hai inke yahan
Pakistan can't deserve this person.
He is a gem
Kuch tou rehnai do bhai hmarai paas😂
@@haseebahmed2039 lmao brother
Sir, it’s the Muslim ruler who burnt Nalanda University without even knowing the value of what they were doing!
Sir why don’t you conduct the interviews in English? Being the South Indian could not follow it had of you are talking. Though your analysis are very good and realistic.
Hood bhai you critisize Pakistani atom bomb why not Indian bomb?
I think you are dishonest intlectual.
Sorry to say that your name is Hood
Bhai but due to your prejudiced comments it seems that you are Hanood bhai or yahoo bhai.Being
a Pakistani and against Pakistan
is matter of shame on your part.
I can understand why pervez Houdaboy feels great because he is probably the only pakistani to get PHD from MIT. We have more than 100's of PHD from Harvard, MIT, Princeton, Stanford, Berkeley, Caltech etc
where are they? He is the only guy constantly shouting but no one seems to be listening.
Because he is an educated fanatic among the uneducated stupid fanatics.
Hindus never begged or asked Britishers for education and science, India was one of the oldest civilizations which talked about science. As far as education is concerned, Nalanda and Takshashila were one of the oldest universities in the world which were destroyed by white huns (Iranians) and Khiljis respectively even before the Mughals came to India. So Science based on logic and experiments was part of ancient India and its culture which also helped us to gain a humungous amount of wealth and wisdom and all the tribes and rulers from Ghazni and Ghori's of the world to Britishers everybody came to have a piece of it. The education system you see today is a product of capitalism and the post-modern world.
Thanks God Bangladesh has been saved from hybrid colonial system of Pakistan in 1971.Almighty Creator is a great planner & just.. Otherwise Bangladesh would had been situation like as Baluchistan or Afghanistan.
thank the Iron Lady Indira Gandhi
@@vivekmohanty1987 zero grototode in bonglodosh for liberation from Pokoshton
Only one solution-limit quoran to mosque or home, fill library with books, don't ever burn books, one who burns it are the worst
Muslim in India are not happy.. When Pakistan is going to finish it's task of taking Indian Muslims😢... Plz take Indian Muslims... And give us leftover Hindus sikh Christian
Indian Muslims are 15% of the population. So if this 15% population joins Pakistan, then they'll take 15% of the India's land with them. Which parts of land would they get?
Yes... Correct..
India🇮🇳 can learn from Pakistan how to reduce minorities to less than 1%
@@imgn8r715 India has learnt lessons from pakistan how to bring 15% of your population to 1% and take its land back from Bangladesh. Thanks!
@@imgn8r715Pakistan received more land in proportion to it's population. So India should actually demand land from Pakistan, even after full population exchange.
@@imgn8r715 why you people need land? When you already living in la la land?
Prof. Hoodboy,
I am an Indian Professor (retired)...always enjoy your discussions....your lucidity and your pragmatism...immensely enjoyeď
Hoodbhoy is still a racist and has a lot of obvious, open anti India bias.
Excellent discussion, one of the most revered intellectuals of the Indian sub-continent.
Pakistan needs a civil society where the Army stays in the garrison and where the politicians work on a stable relationship with India.
Sir, a mix of confusion, fantasy and fear, plus a good person.
AG: we would like to see your profile to determine ur worthiness.
He cannot speak more than that....
Intellectual and unbiased personality. 🙏🙏🙏🙏
bbhyminy
And a bit sad, feel bad for his sadness.
Wrong.
Ek dam Katar Hindu hater, India Bashir!
Hum aur India ek saath bane...
This is the biggest confusion of the Pakistani people...
Aap log bane ho Hum saadiyon se hain aur rahenge..
Indian delusions 😂 you were mughal before the British 😅
To jo Pakistan ki land hy vo sadion se Mars par thi?
You are also created, modern India is also an experiment of western powers.
Yes
i think sir your DNA brought you back same thing happened to me too now i am satisfy here i was in america lived for 10 years tought math in houston college but unsatidfied.
This professor never criticizes the army.
Obviously he wants to live
He does not have a death wish. Ex Pakistani
India never was interested in attacking Pakistan. Contrarily, Pakistan did.
Love his modesty. Big fan of Dr.Hoodbhoy from India
The interview was conducted in a very good manner and Dr. Hoodbhoy gave excellent answers
Al-Khwarizmi refers to Indian mathematicians in his work. In his book *Kitab al-Jabr wa-al-Muqabala* (The Book of Algebra and Al-Muqabala), Al-Khwarizmi mentions several Indian mathematicians, including Brahmagupta and Aryabhata. He also refers to the Indian numeral system, which he called the "Hindu numerals".
Al-Khwarizmi's work was heavily influenced by Indian mathematics, and he acknowledged this in his book. He wrote that he had "collected the rules of this science from the Hindus" and that he had "arranged them in an orderly manner".
Al-Khwarizmi's work on algebra was a major contribution to mathematics, and it helped to spread Indian mathematical ideas to the West. His work was translated into Latin in the 12th century, and it became an important source of mathematical knowledge for European mathematicians.
Here are some of the Indian mathematicians that Al-Khwarizmi referred to in his work:
* Brahmagupta (598-670 CE): An Indian mathematician and astronomer, Brahmagupta is best known for his work on the Brahmasphutasiddhanta, a treatise on mathematics and astronomy.
[Image of Brahmagupta, Indian mathematician]
* Aryabhata (476-550 CE): An Indian mathematician and astronomer, Aryabhata is best known for his work on the Aryabhatiya, a treatise on mathematics and astronomy.
[Image of Aryabhata, Indian mathematician]
* Mahavira (800-870 CE): A Jain mathematician, Mahavira made important contributions to the field of numerical mathematics. He wrote a treatise on numerical mathematics titled Ganita Sara Sangraha, which includes a discussion of decimal fractions, the rules of arithmetic, and the solution of linear and quadratic equations.
[Image of Mahavira, Indian mathematician]
Al-Khwarizmi's work on algebra was a major contribution to mathematics, and it helped to spread Indian mathematical ideas to the West. His work was translated into Latin in the 12th century, and it became an important source of mathematical knowledge for European mathematicians.
Thanks for being truthful And focused And humanitarian
Unfortunately still people of Pakistan think that they lost half of the country in1971.Basically Pakistan lost his colonial part in 1971 that was East bengal. so east bengal was never a part of pakistan but a colony of pakistan .when you never respect someone or any specific area as equally. Claiming that colony as a own part then it does not make any sense or make any change The actual relation between Pakistan and East Bengal was like owner and slaves ,Boss and Servants. Pakistan & people of pakistan treated Bengal and bengali people as 3rd class people & burden of pakistan from the first day. People of pakistan loved to use some racist word against bengali people like Kala Bengali and Bukha Bengali. Even after 1971 still today people of pakistan love to use some word like ""daw take ki aurat"" to devalue the currency of Bangladesh. But now that two taka equal to almost 6 pakistani rupee. so pakistan did not lost his half of a country but lost his colony in 1971. its a harsh reality of the history. people of pakistan should not claim that lost half of the country in 1971 and should stop claiming that it was a part because it does not make any sense or any change. that's why pakistan has never take a lesson from 1971 because it was not part of pakistan . its a real fact that state like pakistan never take a lesson from colony
Islam is an obstacle in development of Pakistan.
Sir yeh north India and south India ka nya concept Kahana se laye
Study your recent political history, from 47 to 71, especially the sixties, south Indians were demanding independence.
The US state department was extremely concerned because India was on the verge of disintegration, that's why they (USA) staged Bangladesh drama.
Haa
@@arifsaleem5467 wah, USA supported india during 71 war?? This show your garbage knowledge.
Country which donot have atom bomb whether the country died?
Pakistani need no atom bomb, we need basic humanitarian rights
i have seen 1000s of masjid have been destroyed latest one peshawar by bomb blast in pakistan by ttp (monster created by pakistan army to disturb peace in india ) can u give me example in which masjid have been destroyed by bomb blast in india
inflation in india 6% inflation in Pakistan 40% whose is more happier Pakistani
india export 900 billion dollar Pakistan export 30 billion india forex $600 dollar Pakistan forex $3 billion 8 lakh muslim pakistanl left Pakistan fortress of islam 2 lakh(10000 Indian muslim) india left india in 2022 india population 140 crore Pakistan population 22 crore now u decide who is more happier Pakistani musalman or Indian muslaman
muslim in india have increased from 9% to 16%
Poocha kisi nay chu😂
We need both things for our survival. Otherwise, we'll collapse.
True
@@MrAlyyyBangladesh, Nepal, Sri Lanka and Bhutan have all survived without an atom bomb.
Salute Parvez Hoodhoy on your sacred souls and sweet speeches. I want to touch your feet for truth speaking.
I heard a reference to Algebra and Arabs … I think the Pakistanis should know that Algebra is an ancient Indian invention .. those people might even be the ancestors of the Pakistanis 🤣🤣
Algebra is not made by Arabs but was made under Hind Shahi dynasty ( Hindu kingdom is present day Afghanistan, which was a part of Bharat in vedic ages)
😂😂lindu ashramchap
@@alamgirhossain2791please study history islam scat boy.islam is a scat invented by Muhammad the pedophile
@@alamgirhossain2791tere pedophilee mohammmad Kai madarso Kai tum apni Amiya ko halala karte ho
@@alamgirhossain2791aata chahiye bhikhari..???
There are a number of Pakistani intellectuals like Dr. Pervej who are constantly trying to enlighten the Pakistanis about their country, its history, its governance and trying to guide their country towards a good future. They, however, suffer from two problems-One, they never criticize the army which is at the root of their problems and two, they seem to harbour some grudge against India. That deep rooted belief that "they" belong to the "conquerer's" race and are superior to the "native" Hindus runs in their mind even as they see and realize the fact that natives are outperforming them in all walks of life. This is what happens when a people follow a person who wanted to be head of state at any cost.
But the effort does not seem to be bearing fruit.
This man is very clear in his thouts and views and says what he beliews in unlike others who are intellectually dishonest.They can not say what they want to say but cant say.Had he been in some other country he would have been given a high responsible position for the betterment in his feild of science and other social activities.Such people are never retured and their services are utilized any time any day till thier willingness to perform. I pray for his good health.
Pakistan needs few thousand Hoodbhoy's and other population should follow them to become a better place for better life .
And first of all Pakistani people should get rid of Confused identity and resolve their identity crisis
Hindu-Arabic numerals, set of 10 symbols-1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 0-that represent numbers in the decimal number system. They originated in India in the 6th or 7th century and were introduced to Europe through the writings of Middle Eastern mathematicians, especially al-Khwarizmi and al-Kindi, about the 12th century.
Read about -:
Katyayna 300 BC
Pingla 500 BC
Aryabhatta
Bhaskaracharya
Brahmagupta
Baudhāyana
Mahavira
Sridhara
Varahmihhira
Yativarsabha
All these people born way before your Arabic scholars.
Facts cannot change. What is yr point. .?
@@jenifferbrown2297 u can't sustain facts ! Clearly
As an Indian we will be happy to witness growth of Pakistan in the educational sector which should be a nations top priority. But sorry to say that given the current leadership at place it will be very difficult to turns things around in the near future.
Humanity is greater than any religion.dr hoodbhoy is great personality in Pakistan
Greater then linduism too😂
@@osamarehman3120 Abusive comment can't change the fact : science is always stays with us not religion . Chuslim is far behind science ( do you like this comment ? Sorry to other muslim persons ).
@@osamarehman3120 yes and also greater than islam
@@osamarehman3120greater than allah aur mohammad pedophile too
@@osamarehman3120 Greater than any religion literally means that. Education is clearly a joke in your country.
Partition was a great thing. If you look at the present scenerio India is having difficulty with muslims in India. Imagine the plight if there were 80 crore of them living in 7th century mentality.
Dr. Hoodbhai is a great human being.
India didn't take advantage of the situation in east Pakistan...it got sick of the refugee crisis that your army created there. It couldn't handle the influx that happened then ...infact we are still suffering from the lot that entered in the '70- '71!
False Islamic ideology is the main reason of fall of Pakistan.
Very good and honest discussion.
Dr. Hoodbhoy is a very knowledgeable, sensible and honest individual. All sensible persons respect him. The govt of Pakistan should make him the minister of education and give him full freedom to reform the Pakistani educational system.
A telescope was presented to Jehangir by a European visit. He showed no interest and instead was very fascinated by some wine bottles given to him. This is why India made no scientific contributions from 1000 AD to 1700 AD during Islamic invasion.
17:50 syed ahmad muslmano ko reform nahi karna chahta tha,wo kewal asraf muslmano ko reform karna chahta tha, hoodyboy ko history ka kuch bhi nahi pta
His understanding is really Deep.... Similar to Yuval noah Harari
Hope Pakistani people and the government learn something from this discussion!🙂
Never
A nation that celebrates going against Allah's commands and commemorates it with a day called Yaum e Takbir, is there any hope left ?
Quran orders NOT to destroy non-fighting people, animals, cities or crops etc. even during war or for it. The Pakistani atom bomb I guess will nevee be able to be as selective as Quran orders to be.....do you see how delusional the Pakistanu mindset is ...
We Pakistani refuse to learn we wallow in our ignorance and relish it
Not possible. 😢
So intelligent, full of wisdom, brilliant personality. Fittest person to be the pm
Sir, mother tongue is everyone’s identity. When you lose this you lose your identity. This is what has and is happening with Afro-Caribbeans.
Ravindranath Tagore of Bengal was the first Asian who received noble prize in 1913 , Amartya sen 2nd Bengali who got noble prize in economics , Avigit Benerjee 3rd Bengali got noble prize in economics, Mohammed yunis of Banla Desh got noble prize in economics , Tagore got noble prize in literature, forwriting Gitanjali in Bengali / English language,
Thank you Sir for presenting Mr Hoodbhoy Sir an outstanding scholar of Pakistan and his comment and your discussion is just outstanding in all respect. Hats off to both of you. My best Regards to Sir Hoodbhoy.
India🇮🇳
He is antihindu
Free speech freedom of expression and opinion freedom of expression of constructive criticism and critical thinking
perfect recipe for religious disaster and economic progression.
Arabic numerals which are used today was invented by indians❤
That’s why they’re called Arabic numerals? You’re real a smart guy
@@zv8135 bro better you research first before commenting.
@@zv8135do google hindu Arabic numeral.
@@HimanshuShukla0802 i did it... But the person who invented was from area of Multan today's Pakistan 😂
@@osamarehman3120There was no Pakistan then. So get out of this dream.
Hoodbhoy is one of the best minds we have in Pakistan.I wish & hope that we could take full advantage of people like him.
May Allah Subhanatallah have mercy on us and put us on the right track.
Religion and Science do not go together! His message is about SCIENCE - Science and Religion MUST be separated big time! His message on education means you have to close all crazy Madarsas and teach proper secular STEM (Science Technology Engineering Math) to kids. The Indian and Pakistani DNA is SAME - the ONLY negative for Pakistan is too MUCH emphasis on the PAST glory of ISLAM and TOO little emphasis on Science & Innovation. India was lucky to have leaders like Nehru (IITs) and Modi (Heavy Innovation Guy) and Manmohan Singh (Heavy financial deregulation guy) - they focused on NON religious education and focus on excellence. Pakistan's political environment is so lousy that a genius mind like Hoodbhoy is under-utilized. and side-lined. India made people like Abdul-J-Kalam - a true scientist as President (despite him being a MUSLIM!!) while Pakistan has had only LANDLORDs and FAUJIS as leaders - completely mindless when it comes to innovation.
Always pleasure hearing you Sir. I just wish people of Pakistan listen and understand your thoughts and feelings 🙏🏻🙏🏻
Yes, otherwise Pakistan would be bombed by india by now.
He is antihindu though
No he isn't @@Salmonellatyphi
Great Interview... Prof Hoodboy is one of the finest ppl around... He speaks the TRUTH... Uncomfortable at times... but, that's what TRUTH is all about... :)
Even an educated person like Mr. Hoodbhoy doesn’t have the complete information by 1947 Hindus got 2 Nobel prize
1. Rabindra Nath Tagore ( Literature)
2. C.V. Raman ( Physics)
And Pakistan call people like this intellectuals.
#irony_prevails
New converted are pathetic everywhere 😂
He is again the mouthpiece of isi he didn't accept how ak qadir steal blueprints at nuclear power plant
The above two'r elite Brahmins at that time 70,% does not primary school education
A very Frank discussion and direct comments from my favourite Prof. Hoodbhuoy. Listening ro rhe professor is learning.🙏
Points raised are insightful! We need more intellectuals like him who can bring reason & practicality to society! 👍
Mei bhi intellectual hoo... Science ki bajai sab pay baat kar sakta hoo
@@osamarehman3120یہ لہجہ ءجظظپ بچے شر نہ بے دخل ی ہیں ہیں😊 کک کہ
It is high time that Pakistanis should realise their ancestors are from Hindustan and not from Arab
Once their fix their identity by acknowledging they are converted Hindus and hating Hindus is not good for them, things will improve for them.
It will take another 100 years for them to clean up their minds
Partition was the best thing to happen to india
Thanku jinnah
Although we lost many lives
Could have had a significant better execution. Immediate migration was not needed. Could have been carried out in long phases to avoid loss of lives. And complete population exchange should have taken place, as only Muslims were given the right to vote for partition, so why should India bear the burden of muslims after creation of Islamic nation state(s).
Awesome podcast
Pakistan should consider direct democracy
🙏
This fellow, Dr. Hoodbhoy should stick to physics, history is not his cup of tea☕... Particularly 🇮🇳 history.....
In 1956 when we came from south to Delhi and stayed amidst refugee and north dominated colony most of locals used us blackie and fun such as eating with hand,chutias are weak because they eat rice etc etc.Ssme situation as with bengalis in pakistan. Fortunately central govt policies snd movement of people created nearness and adjustment.
Hood bro is one of my favourite intellectuals very honest and hard working
The only one who recognizes that atom bomb is actually unislamic !
Because Quran, Sunnah and History tells that even in war the Prophet PBUH ordered NOT to harm anyone or anything other than the ones actually fighting with you! Since atom bombs cannot follow this maxim, it is going straight against orders of Allah and to add insult to it this nation calls it Yaum e Takbeer!
Await a terrible recompense in Allah's court very soon indeed, for lying and lying in Allah's name itself !
Dr Pervez hoodbhoy is a great professor born in Pakistan. He should be in India because India can utilize the intelligence of this man.
Pakistan can't use this man for his country because of cruel nature.
He is the ocean of knowledge in physics. He is also truth spoken. He was lovable person joking sometimes. Love you sir but you should be in India. Pakistan can't deserve you. 💕
Parvez sir you are gem. If Pakistan listen to you then they solve there every problems. Sorry to say indian listen him more because indian know the values of gem. Diamond in coal
Words of Dr Pervaiz Hood Bhai, are words of wisdom. Such personalities should be frequently invited to open common person's minds to retrack our direction, if we want development in Modern Studies of the world.
I hope you guys like content! Do let us know what topics you’d like us to cover next.
This fellow, Dr. Hoodbhoy should stick to physics, history is not his cup of tea☕... Particularly 🇮🇳 history.....
Domestic violance
@@dineshshetty875 No Hoodbhoy was correct , you know its bitter truth
Invite Bangladeshi intellectuals for discussion
18:47 Sir Hoodboy I respectfully disagree that you just handed the torch of rationale and referred those Mutazallas as Muslims which were persecuted and discriminated by other Muslims and weren't even considered muslims as they denied Qur'an being the most knowledgeable book while also denying the implication of the Shariah. They were against it and were persecuted. It's like wiping out all Kadyanis as they aren't muslims but calling them as Muslims when you want to gain some advantage
@tkhamza8557 he is not an Islamophobe rather a rationalist who keeps facts and logics above Islam. Hardcore dmbos call him Islamophobe
Interviewer:Pakistani
Interviewi : Pakistani
Audience : Indian 91% in comments
Hence proved where pakistanis are standing 👁👅👁
Mainly because of the title of the video.
Wow!🎉🎉
Dr Hoodbhoy is an inspiration and a Global role Model. It is sad to see the frustration of this brilliant mind. There are amazing lessons for everyone who wants to listen.
As Indian I genuinely feel that Only,, shariya can save Pakistan ,, nothing else ,, implement sahriya as soon as possible,,
What a sorted personality Pervez Saab
I do appreciate his honest opinions and clarity of thoughts. Anybody who is having negative comments, pleaae try to understand that he is geniunely trying to address the wrongdoing of past generations and seek better future for every human being. The young chap sitting next to him is also very mature and seeks to address the issues.
By the way, i am from India and not muslim. When i meet some good pakistani people in Dubai, i knew that we are same. Just keep religion aside for a moment and we are same ....Human. i wish we do have people on both sides of border thinking in same way
🙏
Mr Hoodboy is always out of his depth when he talks about anything else than science.
Out of depth mostly by being MohMadden because MohMadism makes him lose his roots. His ancestors like Jinah's took Bedouinized Yahoodi names to get business contracts and avoid Jiziya.
China treats MohMadism as Mental Disease and so puts MohMadden males in concentration camps like mental asylums and uses MohMadden wombs to breed Haan Chinese kids. India needs learn from China the master of slave Pakistan.
China killed original AbraHarami gangs/legions Christianity & Islam wearing burkha of Marxism. It knew these gangs Christianity & Islam are Weapons of Mass Destruction or toolkits for Anglos and the West to be used against natives and their nation building.
Depression & Maniacal Violence is much more prevalent in AbraHaramized societies compared to Dharmic societies like Bharat, Bhutan, Nepal, Mayanmar, Tibet, Baali, Thailand etc. AbraHarami societies are rootless parasitic in nature. They can only survive on robbery, banditry & killing. In such AbraHarami societies if one cannot rob or kill others then one starts harming & killing oneself.
Khalifa Al Lundoni Chiknah Jinah & EkBall were Western in thought and dress. Edu= Innate native skills Cate=Care/Nurture. Moulvi of madarassa & mosque, Padri of church & convent & urban Naxals KaamRaids are not in education but they are in deracination or cutting native roots business.
Dharma is native and organic. Christianity, Islam, Marxism and Fiat Currency like $ driven Hedonistic Consumerism are legions/gangs to grab REgal political power to enslave/colonize, rob and deracinate converts so that they hate everything native and willingly serve as cannon fodder to create & maintain evil empires for VatiCunning Pope, Lecherous Khalifa, BriShit Queen, Politburo KaamRaid Honcho and Wall Street, Hollywood crooks. The natives who have taken Bedouinized Yahoodi, Romanized Yahoodi names and have cut their native roots cannot be considered citizen of a Dharmic nation like Bharat. So what's this minority & majority? These gangs & their gang members have done majority almost 99% of killings since their inception 1600 years back. They are majorly responsible to make this planet unlivable.
No wonder Hoodboy doesn't talk about native Kanad Rishi who preceded Greeks thousands of years. Rootlessness is taught from the childhood. Science Mullah ho ya Madarassa Mullah, hai toh woh Mullah. Final result is Pakistan, Bangladesh, 26/11 & 9/11.
A true intellectual and worthy of inspiration
I am surprised that such intelligent people like Hoodbhoy exist in Pakistan. Your knowledge of History is even better than Science. You deserve to be in India not Pakistan.
What will he do here? Participate in the shouting match in the media or justify how cow dung and urine is the answer to all problems?
@@sandeepshah105why not? He can research why goat urine is not as pure as cow?
@@sandeepshah105 😀😀😀
I am a Bengali, Pakistani army is a Butcher of Bengal. Jab tak Pakistan ye Islam ka Concept se nikal nehi payega tab tak iss ka kuch na ho payega.
For Bengalies it is Bangla Language first not islam, and more over we are hindu so now way. Now i am an Proud Indian.
Pakistan protected to hai. Syria,Iraq,Afghanistan,Libya ya Yemen hota Pakistan nuclear weapons ke begair.
Aby isko ek narrative banana hai Pakistan kay khilaf... Iss liyay asa bol raha hai
Long live hoodbhoy .. long live
India should invite Hoodbhoy sir for lecture in any big University
Dr Hoodbhoy had been in India 10-12 years back and had visited quite a few universities.
He is sounding intellectual because he is just one rational speaking Pakistani. Every university in India has super intellectual teachers and professors. Just that they are too focused in teaching their students and making building blocks of India’s bright future.
He doesn't stand a chance in front of informed debaters...
@@afterburner2828bhosri ke, he isn't even debating
He's zero... he's merely bluffing
Hood bhoy sir aap jese insan ko ham hindustan k log bahot pyar karte he
Dr. Saab Zindabad. Greeting and warmth from India :). May the almighty give you a healthy and long life, we all need people like you, Sir.
Gay chili rand
@@osamarehman3120rape jihad ki najayaz paidaish ganduudin namazi aashiq gay rasool, u pakis born after rape jihad of ur begairat behaya ghasti raped and converted musalmina ammi khala behen by qasim ghori ghazni Babar Aurangzeb nadir Shah abdali Arab Turk Irani Afghans surely look like gay ganduudin when u all raise ur islam filled ghazi haji pichwada in air 5 times a day for doggy style namaz in halala chudai ka adda masjid 😂😂😂
Prof. Pervez Hoodbhoy, Incredible. -- From India.
Hoodbhoy is wrong in the time of partition we had 2 nobel prize, 1913 Rabindra Nath Tagore and C V Raman.
Pakistanis are being forced to ' live in the past'
i have seen 1000s of masjid have been destroyed latest one peshawar by bomb blast in pakistan by ttp (monster created by pakistan army to disturb peace in india ) can u give me example in which masjid have been destroyed by bomb blast in india
inflation in india 6% inflation in Pakistan 40% whose is more happier Pakistani
india export 900 billion dollar Pakistan export 30 billion india forex $600 dollar Pakistan forex $3 billion 8 lakh muslim pakistanl left Pakistan fortress of islam 2 lakh(10000 Indian muslim) india left india in 2022 india population 140 crore Pakistan population 22 crore now u decide who is more happier Pakistani musalman or Indian muslaman
muslim in india have increased from 9% to 16%
All people of Pakistan must accept
that basically they are Indian upto 1947 and then they became pakistani. In no way they are Turkish, Arabin Or from any other parts of the world.
Even if the Kashmir dispute were to be resolved, the animosity between the people of India and Pakistan would persist due to a tumultuous thousand-year history marred by religious conflicts. The strained relationship between India and Pakistan stems not solely from religious differences. In my view, the internet stands as one of the most remarkable inventions in human history, providing a platform for sharing knowledge and fostering understanding. I firmly believe that, one day, the citizens of Pakistan and India will come to comprehend the futility of religious discord and embrace atheism-an ideology that promotes tolerance, critical thinking, and a shared humanity. By transcending the limitations of religious divisions, both nations can embark on a path of mutual respect and cooperation, leading to the resolution of all outstanding issues. Atheism can serve as a catalyst for a new era of peace and harmony, where differences are celebrated rather than used as a basis for hatred and conflict.
China and Vietnam, both atheist countries fought against each other .
Atheist Soviet union invaded Czechoslovakia and Hungary .
Khmer Rouge, synonymous with Genocide , outlawed religion .
Saying that abolishing religion will end human conflict is too simplistic world view .
I like the personality you have dr. Parvej Because one who doesn't consider everything as a matter of religion
Hood bhai :
28:10
யாதும் ஊரே யாவரும் கேளிர்
தீதும் நன்றும் பிறர்தர வாரா
- Kaiyan Poongundranaar. Written more than 2000 years back in Tamizzh.
Very fruitful discussion (Podcast)
🙏🙏
Excellent and true history informed by Mr. Hood Bhoy ❤ and very essential questions by anchor ❤
Thanks for inviting him
🙏🙏
Mind boggling criticism my beloved Hood bro l wish l could meet you hug you and kiss your heart
High respect for this man...rare asset for Pakistan...
Loved the pod caster... extremely understated but never submissive!!!