A Gracewind Tale - The Leeds Murder (Full Game)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 16 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 118

  • @arbitrary2868
    @arbitrary2868 Год назад +41

    0:01 Menu
    2:11 Game Start (Welcome to the X-Files Office and an Introduction to the Laziest Detective)
    2:48 Personal Note #1
    4:42 Before We Head Out The Door...
    5:55 Into the Woods (Rosswoo- I mean, Gracewind Park)
    6:38 Personal Note #2
    9:32 First Staircases, Now Doorways? What's Next, Elevators in the Woods?
    10:18 The Evil Dead House (With Evil Tree)
    11:20 Hello? Hell-o?
    11:44 Cabinet Note
    14:19 Table Note from 1879 (Regarding Eurydice, Ancestor of Liberty and Percerverance. Horror Babies Ancestor in Witch Hunt was around in the 1700s, so they probably never met.)
    15:43 Note Regarding Disbandment of Scouts
    16:49 Reminds Me of The Portraits Creepypasta
    17:08 Jiggling and Knocking
    18:42 Under the Bed
    19:18 Personal Note #3
    19:42 Journal Note
    20:52 There was a HOLE here. It's gone now.
    21:25 Kitchen Note
    24:08 Phillip Note
    28:06 B R E A D
    28:12 Back Out into Back-o-Beyond
    28:38 Anything you might need I got inside of you.
    28:44 Shed Note
    30:44 Speaking of Horror Babies Ancestors, Here's One Now! An Unholy Union of Librarian Candle and Horror Baby... Babyness?
    31:46 Flier Note
    32:40 The Rats In The Walls
    33:00 Drawer Note
    35:05 Observation and Summerization
    35:57 Stuck
    36:13 Finding the Way Forward
    38:22 Pages 1/8 *Boom* *Boom* (Tree Note)
    40:48 Nether Portal to Chili's (Doorway Again)
    41:17 No Escape (I prefer Don't Escape)
    41:44 Sacrificing the Unholy Wax Spawn (Plus Frustrations on the Games Design)
    42:39 Ah, Someone's Trying to Find Unsavory Stains
    44:10 You Better Hope That's Ectoplasm
    44:25 Insert Box to Continue
    44:56 Floor Note
    46:44 More Speculation
    47:06 Unlocking the Padlock
    47:21 The Librarian? More like The Musician
    48:29 Oh NOW You've Got Reservations On This!
    50:55 Unlocking the Door
    52:25 Personal Note #4
    53:05 That... Looks more like an acid bath than a baptism.
    53:30 TRAPDOORTRAGEDY (Four Seals Broken)
    54:08 Where Am I? Where Am I is a project by Indie developer Mark Hadley, creator of the original Slender (Start of Cycle 2)
    54:41 Personal Note #5
    57:01 Personal Note #6
    58:44 Searching Around
    59:18 Broken Dresser Note
    1:00:44 Trying Something Else
    1:01:19 Looking for Patrick Stars Home
    1:01:54 Dresser Key and Note
    1:03:10 Song of the Candleman (Piano Again)
    1:04:50 Love Potion Number Nine (Flask/Potion Bottle)
    1:05:20 Note From the Drawer Under the Flask
    1:06:46 Point of No Return Note
    1:07:58 Jumped the Gun (Bread Melting Obsession)
    1:09:00 Breaking The Seals (Again)
    1:10:50 I guess we go for another cycle.
    1:11:02 Spoke Too Soon 2
    1:11:39 Deja Vu (Start of Cycle 3)
    1:12:14 Check off moving objects, we should vote on it being a Poltergeist.
    1:12:29 Personal Note #7
    1:13:36 Librarian Attempting to Imitate Myuuji (Piano Again)
    1:14:10 Lost Again
    1:14:53 Finding the Path Again
    1:15:35 Frustrations at the Game Design 2
    1:16:28 "Let's just melt this little chibi" - Librarian 2023
    1:17:49 Personal Note #8
    1:18:28 Wat
    1:19:28 Please Be The Last Time We Have To Do This (Unlocking the trap door again)
    1:20:12 Personal Journal #9
    1:20:29 Who Put A Nether Portal In My House?
    1:20:54 Let's be honest, you'd be cacking your spaffs if this was happening to you.
    1:21:32 Do You Copy?
    1:23:02 Tower Note
    1:25:56 Your Running Down That Hill (Plus Thing In The Woods)
    1:26:41 Basically SCP-860 (The Blue Key)
    1:27:19 Breaking the Last Seal
    1:28:00 This felt like a time sink. You make us break the dang locks, yet don't allow us to see what's under there, even if it is nothing? What a Buzzkill, dev.
    1:28:55 Taking The Road Home
    1:29:18 Fin(ally)
    1:29:25 Ending Thoughts (I've got some choice words of my own. I'm honestly burnt out on the whole "one space many cycles" gimmick. It just feels like our time is being wasted with a single padded experience, supplemented by a ton of notes and half-baked puzzles, that is repeated over and over again. The dev did great with "Do You Copy?" which means they excel at shorter experiences. They did really well with the atmosphere too. This game was not their best showing. I'll be even more honest, I tuned out several times this video because the game just wasn't that compelling or engaging to me. This could have been a significantly shorter experience and benefitted from it without losing anything. If this reflects in the timestamps, then I'm sorry, I really did try to pay attention.)
    1:33:51 Outro
    1:34:17 Patrons

    • @arbitrary2868
      @arbitrary2868 Год назад +6

      P.S: Sorry for putting these up waaay later than usual, it was a busy day today.

    • @flaneurmarin
      @flaneurmarin Год назад +1

      i want you to know i appreciate the monument mythos reference

  • @callumjames7854
    @callumjames7854 Год назад +147

    As someone who comes from the city of Leeds in England I must admit I got excited but then realised it was taking about something else.

    • @GorgeousGeorge056
      @GorgeousGeorge056 Год назад +16

      I also thought it was talking about Leeds England

    • @tommeakin1732
      @tommeakin1732 Год назад +11

      I've only been there once to go to the Armouries, and for some reason I really liked the vibe of the place. But it's more likely you'll have a game dev based from Leeds making a game set in muricaland than you'll find a game even set in the UK lol

    • @chicken9847
      @chicken9847 Год назад +2

      Same

    • @katelyynnss
      @katelyynnss Год назад +1

      same omgggg

    • @Cocc0nuttt0
      @Cocc0nuttt0 Год назад +1

      my favorite online schizophrenic is from Leeds 😊

  • @FiatUno2003
    @FiatUno2003 Год назад +25

    Your update schedule is just perfect. It's raining a lot here and watching your videos while laying down comfortably on my bed is just awesome.

  • @henkdachief
    @henkdachief Год назад +20

    sometimes i fall asleep to a librarian video and then he wakes me up because he is screaming

    • @79Bobola
      @79Bobola Год назад +6

      😂 me too

    • @PersonaKing32
      @PersonaKing32 Год назад +4

      My first time hearing him scream was in the haunted gmod maps video, like 2 and a half minutes in or something

  • @bosselotiscanon
    @bosselotiscanon Год назад +80

    i'm stressed as shit right now and the way you analyze video game environments along with the tone/rhythm you speak with is uniquely calming, thank god for your upload schedule's timing

    • @mudnarchist
      @mudnarchist Год назад +3

      What's stressing you?

    • @bosselotiscanon
      @bosselotiscanon Год назад +3

      @@mudnarchist classes, primarily. i purchased a used textbook that i'd otherwise have to get overseas for nearly 100 dollars if i wanted it in mint condition, so i'm very concerned about it shipping in time for my weekly class and also i'm very concerned with pages potentially being ripped out even though i purchased it from a reputable seller and also it was listed as "good condition" (which, from said reputable seller, usually means "practically mint with a few scuff marks")
      and another concern of mine is potentially having the wrong edition because this textbook has had a few revisions over the years and a lot of websites mistakenly list the ISBN for the edition that i need for other incorrect editions. sure, i could order this textbook through my teacher as she offered to do it for me, but i've got terrible social anxiety and i'd have to meet with her in person to pick it up. the class is online only, but i don't think she's picked up on the fact that i'm like 19 while everyone else i'm taking this small class with is in their late 20s. and to make matters worse, i'm a really short and feminine sounding guy, so any brief interactions turn into this huge ordeal about how i sound and look with or without taking my relatively young age into account because people where i live are WAY too friendly. :(
      which, to close this off: i caught the librarian's upload between neurotically checking my order's tracking with fedex and biting my nails over the thought of interacting with another human being.
      this is a lot of word vomit over a textbook but thanks for welcoming me to rant online lol, it's a language class if you were curious

    • @mudnarchist
      @mudnarchist Год назад +6

      @@bosselotiscanon If it makes you feel any better, I have extreme anxiety and I wasn't able to focus on my classes in college. Not cuz I am feminine, but cuz I thought I was ugly. General stuff like that. Also textbooks are overpriced asf.

    • @bosselotiscanon
      @bosselotiscanon Год назад +4

      @@mudnarchist yeah, people really underestimate just how damn hard it is to exist in public sometimes. but i persevere!

    • @hazzmati
      @hazzmati Год назад +2

      oh man

  • @jc008titan
    @jc008titan Год назад +4

    Games like this with story being told by notes is so good for making me fall asleep while I watch your videos. I've fallen asleep 3 times since I started watching this, and this is the 4th time, when I finished watching all the video. It may be an annoying for you, but seeing you getting stressed out by stuff that makes no sense is so funny and calming. The dark atmosphere, the quiet place with a little bit of story related sounds, the rain, and the calming librarian voice reading the notes on top of those is the stuff that makes librarian videos be the best for fixing a VERY BAD sleeping schedule.
    I want to see more videos like these when I wanna sleep(gmod is fine i guess), but I need some horror games for entertainment, prefferably those where you get jumpscared and react.

  • @MrsGordonFreeman
    @MrsGordonFreeman 9 месяцев назад +2

    I appreciate you taking your time with this game. I've seen other play throughs and they move way too fast and miss stuff or get too animated and it really takes from the immersion.

  • @winter.archivist
    @winter.archivist 4 месяца назад +3

    Im sad it didnt live up to the expectation of Do You Copy, but your covering of it certainly improved upon it. Can't wait for more content from our favorite horror archivist.

  • @NonneinP
    @NonneinP 11 месяцев назад +1

    I come across this channel randomly. I'm sold.

  • @ohbabyitsaj
    @ohbabyitsaj Год назад +28

    i think you should definitly play bioshock if you havent already! its very dated but extremely creepy and comfy. right up your alley!

  • @montypi1037
    @montypi1037 3 месяца назад +1

    I thought all those comments about the bread were so funny
    28:03 - “Ooh. This game has interactive bread!”
    37:51 - “Since we can’t interact with most things, I’m assuming that the bread is in some way significant. Like, can we eat it to find the wind-up key at the center of it or something?”
    50:26 - “Maybe the bread has more secrets to reveal… No. It’s still just bread.”
    1:08:05 - “‘I could probably dissolve something organic in there’- YES! Like BREAD! … Okay, I guess not like bread.”
    Also, that rant at 41:55 XD

  • @vicooficial
    @vicooficial Год назад +15

    That's wasnt what i was expecting for a sequel of Do You Copy?. From that game i thought it was to be something like that hunting game that you played that ended up in you killing a humanoid with deer skull. But seems like the authors maybe thought that "bigfoot chasing" thematic was too trivial for a long-awaited sequel and decided to follow a different formula to make something that looks like an hybrid of Witch Hunt, From the Darkness (if you didnt said it was a sequel of Do You Copy? i would thought it was another game of same author), The Caretaker and I Remember This Dream.
    Sometimes the most "straight" and "boring" choices are the most appropriate ones.

  • @wutaguy
    @wutaguy Год назад +8

    I love watching you play these indie horror games. Keep up the great work.

  • @79Bobola
    @79Bobola Год назад +26

    I absolutely LOVED “Do you Copy”, but this game didn’t seem to live up to that. Irregardless, I enjoy watching you play and always look forward to new uploads 😊

    • @Slimpicken
      @Slimpicken Год назад

      Felt like an improvement to me honestly...

    • @vicooficial
      @vicooficial Год назад +3

      Yeah, no matter how bad is the game, Librarian always delivers a superb experience!

    • @HamazuraGOD
      @HamazuraGOD Год назад

      ​@@Slimpicken
      This was such an insane downgrade from Do You Copy that I've never been able to finish it. I actually even ended up forgetting about it entirely, when I clicked this and was reminded, I stopped watching.

    • @Slimpicken
      @Slimpicken Год назад

      @@HamazuraGOD i don't even remember typing my comment. I agree it sucks ass. Maybe the atmosphere was cool but the puzzles were executed god-awefully.

  • @byard2354
    @byard2354 Год назад +5

    I love watching every game you play, your commentary is great lol

  • @zanehalsey2421
    @zanehalsey2421 Год назад +18

    A murder mystery game! Both creepy (obviously), and a nice comfy roleplay.

  • @TreWilder
    @TreWilder Год назад +14

    I'm 20 minutes in... And every time I see you peer through a gap in the wall, I instinctively cringe and look away.
    Suite 776 broke something in me.

    • @TheLibrarianYT
      @TheLibrarianYT  Год назад +7

      Oh god, don't remind me!

    • @FranciumBoron
      @FranciumBoron Год назад +4

      ​@@TheLibrarianYT **[Casually reminds you with malicious intent]**

    • @BinaryBolias
      @BinaryBolias 11 месяцев назад +2

      @@FranciumBoron **ahem**
      _So yeah Suite 776 was pretty cool, wasn't it?_

  • @Wrixchanger
    @Wrixchanger Год назад +4

    Don't forget about "Night Shift at Lenny's Moths" another game from the grace wind mythos series

  • @generatoralignmentdevalue
    @generatoralignmentdevalue Год назад +3

    We've had this weird weather lately where it's freakishly hot and sunny in the day, then we get a cool thunderstorm (rare here) right around my bedtime. This is the perfect thing to watch as I wait to see if the pattern repeats.

    • @kptlt.phillipthomsen5973
      @kptlt.phillipthomsen5973 Год назад

      That kinda just sounds like regular summer weather, especially if you live down south
      Storms grow under the sun but only reach you when its already dark

  • @thenoobbrothers0000
    @thenoobbrothers0000 Год назад +1

    it is talking about Micheal Leeds, if you investigated further when you played do you copy?, there is a news paper pinned to the wall talking about Micheal Leeds.

  • @jamiebonczek8026
    @jamiebonczek8026 Год назад +10

    Keep up the great videos man! Enjoy every video..

  • @liamhunter1197
    @liamhunter1197 Год назад +1

    Another good, spooky game with a narrator who's good at making a cozy atmosphere. Nice work.

  • @SkeleTonHammer
    @SkeleTonHammer Год назад +5

    I agree with you about notes. I feel like you can deliver a story through notes, but the notes need to be BELIEVABLE and they need to have realistic gaps in information that leave a lot to the imagination and leave interesting questions, and give you an opportunity to form a conclusion yourself. Basically, when the notes read like someone writing a note for a video game rather than someone actually writing a note that needed to be written it's a problem.
    Like, 90% of the time in a video game, notes serve literally no purpose in-world. Why did they write them? Who writes a random note that is paragraphs long, isn't a journal entry, and has no recipient? Why describe your master plan, how to undo it, and then call it a secret that must never be discovered and leave the note sitting in plain sight? It's definitely silly. A lot of times, storytellers have a problem "keeping it in their pants" metaphorically speaking.
    And as a dev, one thing that really bothers me is when a game that is note-heavy uses computer fonts for the handwriting. It's honestly a great and cheap effect to just handwrite your notes and scan them in a cheap printer and use that as a texture map for the note. Adds a lot of character and personality to the notes, and you can crowdsource them to your friends and family to get different handwriting for different characters.

  • @generalelectricmotor9084
    @generalelectricmotor9084 Год назад +8

    Now we need a victims perspective game made by the same developers
    The should stumble upon an abandoned watchtower from "Do You Copy?"

  • @classicaudioadventures
    @classicaudioadventures Год назад +4

    As far as free games go I enjoyed playing this overall, but I mostly share your final thoughts, and I felt more invested in the story told by Do You Copy. Your commentary is on-point, as always.

  • @thegratrix453
    @thegratrix453 Год назад +5

    man i'd love to see you play bramble the mountain king would be great with your commentary I think

  • @The_Vent_Goblin
    @The_Vent_Goblin Год назад +5

    Have you ever played CONTROL? it's a bit long, but it's made by the same folks as Alan Wake and even set in the same universe

  • @kaiyotee2475
    @kaiyotee2475 Год назад +2

    33:14 AND FADIN' FAST
    LIFE IS TOO SHORT TO LAST LONG!

  • @bitnewt
    @bitnewt Год назад +3

    The bread never paid off :(

  • @CramHuntsCryptids
    @CramHuntsCryptids Год назад +2

    Leeds murder? As in the Leeds family of the Pine Barrens? As in...the home of the Leeds Devil? Color me intrigued

  • @rondeelauralnaman5397
    @rondeelauralnaman5397 Год назад +2

    Another daily hour with librarian ❤

  • @conorgarrett5893
    @conorgarrett5893 Год назад +1

    You just earned a new subscriber and also I didn’t know that do you copy has a sequel

  • @tactical_ghost54
    @tactical_ghost54 Год назад +3

    Can't wait to watch this tonight

  • @FranciumBoron
    @FranciumBoron Год назад +2

    I really loved _“Do You Copy?”._ I’m not too sure about this one, though.

  • @deadlyadder2330
    @deadlyadder2330 Год назад +2

    "this game has interactive bread" i cant breathe dude

  • @TheBlueDragon86
    @TheBlueDragon86 Год назад +2

    I was gonna say Liberty! So glad to see the crossover and glad I was introduced to your channel!

  • @loop827
    @loop827 Год назад +4

    Mr Librarian I hope you're reading this. I made a comment on the Amanda the Adventurer vid about a part in the video that I would like you to see.

  • @KefkeWren
    @KefkeWren Год назад +1

    I don't know about this game, but Control definitely does share a universe with Alan Wake.

  • @dargunsh7156
    @dargunsh7156 Год назад +5

    There's a new note every minute or so, if this game is calling itself a detective horror game then any book is a cinematographic treasure-trove of detective storytelling

  • @kameleon_rap
    @kameleon_rap Год назад +2

    Watching already! Have a great night!

  • @am-180
    @am-180 Год назад +4

    hi librarian- got a bit of a weird suggestion. have you heard of the custom DOOM map MyHouse? it might not sound like your kind of thing, but i think you'd find it more up your alley than one might expect at first glance. very surreal, exploration-based, and with some big house of leaves vibes, and such- its very much a narrative and atmospheric thing

  • @PeterBee911
    @PeterBee911 Год назад +2

    1:24:34 Judging by the view, it is the exact same tower as in "Do you copy?".

  • @Car_man_2
    @Car_man_2 Год назад +1

    I was watching this like window slats my hand on my face

  • @smolbirb6497
    @smolbirb6497 Год назад

    OH GOD PHILLIP IS THE MONSTER FROM DO YOU COPY!

  • @rick-deckard
    @rick-deckard Год назад

    Cant wait for a Control playthrough! 💪💪

  • @anttitapio4145
    @anttitapio4145 2 месяца назад

    "Organic...YES, like BREAD!"

  • @sleepythemis
    @sleepythemis Год назад

    Oh man I was wondering why Gracewind sounded so familiar, Do You Copy is one of my favorite short horror experiences.

    • @FranciumBoron
      @FranciumBoron Год назад +4

      Yeah. Too bad this one just was nowhere near as good as the first one.

  • @TheRogueWolf
    @TheRogueWolf Год назад

    I think maybe you need to have a nice long chat with Liberty about her past.
    Maybe you can pick up some tips.

  • @soldierski1669
    @soldierski1669 10 месяцев назад

    No grand ending, really let me down.
    But you got a sub.

  • @oldspicey6001
    @oldspicey6001 Год назад +1

    Who's getting tired of the "As a (. ), I'm..." And "as someone that (. )" Comments ?

  • @theotherone7556
    @theotherone7556 Год назад

    oh nice, interactive bread

  • @UfO1
    @UfO1 Год назад

    Great video

  • @RedtheRadical
    @RedtheRadical Год назад +2

    Say, librarian? Where do we send you fanart?

  • @ExecutiveLush
    @ExecutiveLush Год назад +1

    Average Librarian W Post

  • @zakshei
    @zakshei Год назад

    Would you ever consider playing babbdi? It has a brutalist aesthetic and I feel like you’d like it

  • @thefmx001
    @thefmx001 Год назад +3

    any plans on playing any of the myst games ?

    • @bosselotiscanon
      @bosselotiscanon Год назад +2

      seconded, i would love to see that on this channel

  • @clock____93
    @clock____93 Год назад

    This is do you copy cuz the goat man is in here the scream is same the park in the game do you copy is grace wind park

  • @boblambert8985
    @boblambert8985 6 месяцев назад

    Eurydice is pronounce yoo-rid-i-see, with the second i pronounced exactly as the i in rid.

  • @Jaybird196
    @Jaybird196 Год назад

    You-rid-iss-sea

  • @domarkerus
    @domarkerus Год назад

    Let’s go!

  • @nathanh.5373
    @nathanh.5373 Год назад

    Liberty lore:

  • @ConifuriousTree
    @ConifuriousTree Год назад

    What happened to the mew-zak

  • @kptlt.phillipthomsen5973
    @kptlt.phillipthomsen5973 Год назад

    1:07:51 It turned it into LEAN

  • @Plain_Observer
    @Plain_Observer Год назад +1

    you should play oxenfree

    • @Plain_Observer
      @Plain_Observer Год назад

      idk what its about but i remember it being creepy for some reason

  • @Amgarrak
    @Amgarrak 10 месяцев назад

    I feel its interesting, but narratively it doesn't actually make a lick of sense. There is way too many inconsistencies.

  • @O_2og
    @O_2og Год назад

    this felt like there was no play testing by anyone other then the dev

  • @Kidobhuan
    @Kidobhuan Год назад +1

    alice in chains

  • @D0ASKE
    @D0ASKE Год назад

    that office gave me flashbacks to the horrors of vr sex videos

  • @yolobrush2374
    @yolobrush2374 Год назад

    Hello

  • @Sm-iw2vh
    @Sm-iw2vh 3 месяца назад

    I was so gutted with this, genuinely gutted, “do you copy” was so simple and yet so creative. This….abomination is just like the other million “horror” games behind and after it. The notes are interminable and take away any atmosphere. The puzzles (Ughh puzzles) glitchy and obtuse. The setting is great but that’s about it.
    What a waste.
    What a shame.
    This game will fall into obscurity as it rightly should.
    1/10

  • @RealUnreal-yh5bw
    @RealUnreal-yh5bw Год назад +2

    Too much reading notes.

  • @Cole_1
    @Cole_1 Год назад

    hi

  • @supernovaitup
    @supernovaitup Год назад

    This game doesn't even work as a murder mystery. For a title like "The Leeds Murder" you'd expect Leeds to be an important person in the story, or at least have some sort of unraveling mystery that evolves as you uncover clues. The entire framing device of being a P.I. and investigating a missing person is entirely unneeded. Might as well have you be some random hiker stumbling on this cabin.

  • @dargunsh7156
    @dargunsh7156 Год назад +2

    I'm honestly tired of seeing notes after notes as a tool to create world building

    • @NotMorganFreeman.
      @NotMorganFreeman. 10 месяцев назад

      It's a method too many indie horror game developers use too often, and it starts to become tiresome reading note after note.

  • @kabuki7038
    @kabuki7038 Год назад

    Horror game devs need to understand that you should ONLY have "spook" sounds when something is happening. If your game involves a fair bit of exploration and puzzle solving it ruins the vibe when you have a stinger because it feels like something is about to crash through the door.

  • @SteackDeLamasticot
    @SteackDeLamasticot Год назад

    Too many notes for such a short game, killed the vibe for me, much better when its told swat 4 style.

  • @GhoulGhoul-yw9cf
    @GhoulGhoul-yw9cf Год назад

    early!

  • @droughty666
    @droughty666 Год назад +2

    Adventure/point and click/ mystery game with retarded leaps of logic? Say it ain't so. It's good to see someone not ingrained in the genre point out it's many faults.
    If you didn't like this kind of crap, do yourself a favor and don't play anything point&click/mystery from 2000~ and before, you'll give yourself an aneurysm.

  • @bojidarivanovv8678
    @bojidarivanovv8678 3 месяца назад +1

    This game is so disappointing

  • @mothmantra6289
    @mothmantra6289 Год назад

    Im so confused by the ending lmfao. There was a lake monster who could do time loops and a witch (?) and the witch was trapped (?) and the monster wanted you to let her out...? Or the monster was trapped? And then there was the monster in the woods...and also this started because someone went missing and i dont know how that was dealt with either. You just kind of leave lmfao. Man this game kind of sucked idk