The Great Debate: To Aliyah or Not to Aliyah
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 сен 2024
- Josh Wander is a self-defined "Aliyah Commando", dedicating himself to convincing American Jews (most notably Orthodox) to come home to Israel. While he is an ardent lover of Israel, Adam Eliyahu sees no point in trying to convince exile Jews of the obvious. As current events heat up, making it clear that the US is on a pre-Holocaust trajectory, the fate of American Jews hangs in the balance.
Follow Josh at:
/ israeltorah
/ jwander
Please feel free to email me at eliyahu@wrestlingtheangel.com
You can help support our efforts by donating to Paypal:
adamberkowitz@yahoo.com
Check out Adam Eliyahu's books on Amazon:
www.amazon.com...
www.amazon.com...
www.amazon.com...
Shalom Aleichem,
it is really an indictment and it is shameful that so many would rather stay in America than in Eretz Israel.
Acheinu Kol Beit Yisrael will come together soon we just need them by our side especially in this hard and difficult time we are in now and will be in the future...Torah observance will be the hallmark.
I would also like to express my great respect to Josh Wander for his strong commitment and for not shying away from standing in front of the Lubavitcher movement.
It is an indictment. And I feel honored to call Josh 'friend'.
Amin
FYI, land thieving, ethnic cleansing, and genocide are not very godly endeavours, gentlemen!
We have been saying that to Hamas for decades.
Secular Israeli here who works for Chabad. Definitely siding with Josh. Curious if you guys can eventually address new military draft rules
Would love to!
But first, I’d have to address the fact that I don’t believe that any Jewish Israelis are “secular”
I'm personally not living in Israel anymore but I believe my family is secular. How would you describe a Jew that חילוני and nowhere close to being frum or traditional?
@@whodafunk9000 a Jew by definition cannot be Chiloni, because a Jews essence is connected to God. They may be more or less observant of the commandments, but even the most religious Jews aren’t perfect with those…
@@whodafunk9000 A jew
Should non-Jews leave America too? What about Noachides?
Should? IMHO, no.
Stop the cruelty.
What cruelty?
@@Wrestlingtheangel Cruelty of ethnic cleansing and genocide...
Honestly im from america, im a christian. The fear is here too so im not sure that is the best arguement for not going back to israil. With the current administration, America is going to be in war as well very soon.
America is now a sinking ship. 'Israel' built the ship, with Christian labour, and they've drilled the holes in the bough and the ship is doing down. They know the devastation that is on the way, because they have planned it. ,which is why they're encouraging Jews to make aliyah. Trump is going to be brought back to captain the sinking ship, to make sure it hits the bottom and cannot recover. Far from them being "in exile", it's actually the Christians that are living under an oppressive foreign Jewish rulership.
I hear. But as a Jew, I am more scared of what is happening in the US.
I think you overestimate the strength and influence of the .03% of the population that is Jewish. But I have read something like that. It is in a book called "The Protocols of the Elders of Zion."
@Wrestlingtheangel yes, the US is a nightmare right now. It's crazy how in 3 years we've gotten to this point where our admin has destroyed us, is taking God out of everything and letting everyone over that wants to harm us. I pray a lot right now for all of us. The world is in such chaos!
Stay put right where you are, gentlemen. Palestine belongs to Palestinians, your aliyahs will have to wait.
Palestine? Never heard of it. Maybe you can give the coordinates on Google Maps or show me an entry in a history book that describes an independent Arab country named Palestine. Or maybe you can find a Palestinian who can actually pronounce 'Palestine'.
1. Go to Israil and live a life of perpetual fear and tumult in a warzone
2. Stay in America, enjoy life, support aipac & endless foreign wars as well as fight the propaganda war.
I would stay in America.
You clearly have never been in Israel. "Go to Israil and live a life of perpetual fear and tumult in a warzone". I also wonder if you know anything about life in the US. Also, AIPAC and the ADL abandoned Israel a long time ago, choosing the democratic party over everything else.
@@Wrestlingtheangel I have lived in tel aviv and ramallah many many times before and people are always scared of the next rocket from hms or hzblh. AiPAC and IDL will never abandon Israel because thats their reason to exist, what they have succeeded in doing has been to awaken american conciensce that they should be registered as foreign agents and have greatly diminished the value of the label 'anti-semite' but you wouldnt know this because u sound brainwashed like most people who live under a colonial state