Netanyahu is a Drunk Driver in Government, I Have a Deal With Hamas That Can Work-Israeli Negotiator
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 сен 2024
- Netanyahu is "a drunk driver in the seat of government"; I have worked out a deal with Hamas that can work: Israeli hostage negotiator, Gershon Baskin, to Karan Thapar for The Wire.
..........................................
The man who is internationally acclaimed for securing the release of Israeli solider Gilad Schalit from Hamas custody in 2011 has described Prime Minister Netanyahu as “a drunk driver in the seat of government”. Gershon Baskin says Netanyahu’s belief that military pressure can defeat Hamas and secure the release of hostages is wrong and is likely to lead to the opposite outcome i.e. the killing of the hostages. As he put it: “Military pressure has killed and is killing hostages”.
In a 30-minute interview to Karan Thapar for The Wire, Gershon Baskin, who is also the Middle East Director of the International Communities Organization, spelt out the details of a deal he has worked out with Hamas for the release of all 101 hostages, dead or alive, the end of the war, a full Israeli withdrawal from Gaza and the agreed release of Palestinian prisoners by name and number. Dr. Baskin says he has received a written message from an unnamed Hamas leader (on 3/9) which says: “We support your proposal” adding “all leaders” do. Dr. Baskin says that rather than take his word for it Israel should get Qatar and Egypt to clarify and verify with Hamas whether they have accepted this deal or not.
Speaking about the so-called Biden peace deal, a new and updated version of which could be announced in the very near future, Dr. Baskin called it “a bad plan (which) doesn’t end the war (and) doesn’t return all hostages.
I will stop there. I am only giving you the main broad important points made by Dr. Baskin. There’s an awful lot of detail in the interview which you must hear yourself.
Dr. Baskin speaks in detail about why the Biden plan is a bad plan. He explains why Netanyahu’s insistence that Israel must control the Philadelphi Corridor is an attempt to scupper the Biden plan but also unnecessary because, as he explains, Egypt has already effectively closed access to Gaza through the corridor.
Dr. Baskin speaks at length about why Netanyahu’s belief that military pressure can release the hostages is mistaken and wrong and dangerous.
Dr. Baskin gives extensive details of his own plan, his approaches to Qatar, Egypt and America to get them to seriously think about his plan and the response he’s got from Hamas. He also explains why, unlike what he’s done in the past, he’s gone public with the details of his plan.
You must see the interview for all of this.
Join The Wire's RUclips Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews
Bravo Dr Baskin...Our appreciation for the TRUTH and prayers for the success of your untiring efforts to unite Palestine and Israel. ❤❤❤
Baskin is amazingly honest, bold and knowledgeable. Hats off to him for his clear explanations and visions of long-term peace and dignity for Palestinians.
The respectful man got it right, you can not colonize others lands and take away their rights and not expecting any form of resistance
The drunk driver is not my friend. And his friends are not my friends.
Perfectly said sir, no peace can ever come from an occupied land.
Real human being ❤ may God Bless him for honesty
🙏
Hope the arc of history will bend towards peace. As quickly as possible. My heart is with peacemakers like you.
Only this man can bring the world to an end and save a lot of life. Pls kindly sponsor this video and let the whole world see it.
Bless you for trying and working for Peace
Fortunately there are also sane and reasonable voices. Thank you. ❤
@@MendeMaria-ej8bf Not many left
@@Ahmat_Sila In any case, they are all in a very difficult and maybe precarious situation.
I VOTE for 💚JILL STEIN for President of America 💯. Jill STEIN is Against Genocide Wars.
Wishing you all the best!
Hamas started it
@nirmalbhel3231 Hamas was created by Israel by stealing Palestine 🇵🇸 land and locking up over 2 million Palestine people in a prison concentration camp called Gaza. History did not start on Oct. 7 try before 1948. Look at the UN United Nations video for more proof 🙏
Ur in thr car with drunk drivers
If Netanyahu is a drunk driver, why is that the passengers in his véhicule dont stop him.
It's a Drunk n Sick Society!!
They all are drunk
Drunk On Power & Greed
They knew they were living in STOLEN LAND, so all sinking together
The far right radical ones are protecting him.
I quote General Matti Peled of the IOF in his submission to the Israeli government after the 1967 war, at the prospect of the illegal occupation of the Palestinian territories.
"Holding on to the West Bank was contrary to Israel’s strategy of building a secure Jewish democracy with a stable Jewish majority. If we kept these lands, popular resistance to the occupation was sure to arise, and Israel’s army would quell that resistance, with disastrous and demoralizing results. This would turn the Jewish state into an increasingly brutal occupying power.". Do you think he was correct? I think the ICJ agreed with him wholeheartedly.
Such an honest person
There are few humane angels in Isra'el, this gentleman is one of them among the majority barbarians!
where were he before 7 oktober???
Are u in the car with the drunk driver? Or u are ignorant about Oct 7th what about before 7th October
Superb analysis and interview- thank you
May God bless you brother.
Finally, one that makes sense in I5rael in these dark times in the Region.
Great coverage thank you very much
Finally he has spoken truth
This is the most realistic deal we have heard of in ten months. It gives me hope, and certainly others too. I pray for a successful outcome and lasting peace in Palestine. Thank you 🙏
Wonderful Gershon Baskin!
Thank you Mr. Gershon Baskin 👍🏻❤️❤️❤️
Military Complexes r running wild in US so y u think they ll stop Netanyahu n Israel ? 🤷♂️
The guest is totally right with his statements, evaluations & recommendations.
Wonderful man. Wish that people like you ruled Israel.
Its a civilization war Islam vs Jew just like Islam vs Hindu or Islam vs Christianity, just one man is not responsible. As long as followers of Quran is there, this will nor end
Where were they before 7 oktober why didnt stand up for justice for the palestinian people???
Good interview Karan
Another great interview. Very elaborate and answers the very critical questions. Thank you Karan and thank you The Wire .
Its a civilization war Islam vs Jew just like Islam vs Hindu or Islam vs Christianity, just one man is not responsible. As long as followers of Quran is there, this will nor end
Oh I can very much imagine the kindergarten-like behavior & ways of thinking. I’ve been seeing it all along. Beginning with Netanyahu, Biden, & Blinken. I don’t know which is worse.
All of them one worse than the other!
All monsters
What about the Palestinian prisoners Israel has? Mostly held for merely being Palestinians? That injustice is another terror the Palestinians have had to fear. Are those human beings held not to be valued?
As per Talmud, they are animals
Wonderful human being
Thx Gershon standing up against injustice from South Africa
Its a civilization war Islam vs Jew just like Islam vs Hindu or Islam vs Christianity, just one man is not responsible. As long as followers of Quran is there, this will nor end
We don't know if Hamas killed those hostages or not. Hamas has never not claimed actions it has taken. They stated these were killed by IDF.
@@machsimillian14 remember they admitted the killing of one israel by an upset hamas who got news of the death of his child I believe.I don't think their belief allows them to kill the israel hostages.
This verbal agreement reached with Hamas is crucial and is actually good development..Hopefully Israel agrees especially Bibi. He must NOT hinder it !
NETANIAHOU will not agree, he will boycott any settlement because he wants to remain a FREEMAN. THE DAY THERE IS NO WAR NETANIAHOU WILL BE JUDGED AND SENT TO PRISON FOR THE REST OF HIS LIFE BECAUSE OF HIGH CORRUPTION CHARGES PENDING. WE FOUND THAT NETANIAHOU is the RICHEST PRIME MINISTER IN OUR PLANET! In a small country like Israel! THINK ABOUT.
NETANIAHOU will not accept!
NatWho needs to never see light again.
Absolutely
Karan Thapar You beauty
There is only 1 chance if there is any for ceasefire, put Lebanon on table n talk Palestine 🤨
This war must end give chance of a breath to its people of both side any deal should lead to permanent peace in the region.
very good sir
Great interview, thank you!
Meanwhile The Israeli families are stll waiting and the People are suffering and the war is not ending 75 years UK is 99 percent to blame
thanks
How does the nation of Palestine heal from loosing 40,000 people in this war ?
World must realize and especially Israel muSt realize that Palestinians are human beings too !
@@Loretti_Pinto that’s only what’s been officially confirmed, let’s not forget that there are way more since the figure you mentioned came out. As a matter of fact, The Lancet report estimates a minimum of 180,000 civilians k!ll€d and this report came out about a month or two ago!!! The report doesn’t mention all those who are severely injured, contracted a disease or were already suffering from severe illnesses and are on the brink of dying from lack of medicine/medical care!!! Further, all those traumatized and will most likely be traumatized for life!!!!
Nethanyahu is the bravest, strongest n most capable leader in the world. So have faith in his leadership because he knows exactly what he is doing in order to prevent the destruction of Israel by the cult of Islam n to ensure victory for Israel in this war n to ensure the eternal existence of the State of Israel.
Another wonderful interview, thank you so much!
Elizabeth
Once Netanyahu feels safe politically this operation of his will end. Give him some political position or promise him a safe retirement...
@@FreddieMurphy746He needs to be removed.
@@chriss2452 He won't go down without making a mess out of the whole region
This guy never talks about the Palestinian hostages and getting them home.
True. You must be an optimist, for peace.
Is USA becoming irrelevant looking at Israel Hamas and Ukrain Russia conflicts.?
US is right now more inclined towards its own Presidential election. Democrats can't risk their chances against Trump, who is a master in encashing even a penny worth of controversy. And there's always a chance that the peace deal may backfire or even if successful, may leave many burnt fingers.
Nazi Netanyahu 😡😡😡
Its a civilization war Islam vs Jew just like Islam vs Hindu or Islam vs Christianity, just one man is not responsible. As long as followers of Quran is there, this will nor end
This person’s find reliable n speaks perfectly which are acceptable/ trustworthy if Israel listen to this negotiator
This negotiator looks fair n tells the right thing to go to peace treaty
He's lying about no tunnels under the Philadelphi corridor.
Mr Karan request you to arrange a interview with a Bangladeshi journalist about the crime happening against christian and other minorities in recent days in Bangladesh thank you
Are Weapon exporter European nations paid commission to some political leaders in the democracies??????
FREE palestine Sea to river and Land from apartheid Israel apartheid
Great and super video you will never see all this on BBC CNN DW NEWS FOX News MSM sky news etc!!!
Blah Blah Blah - Netapyscho has turned down every single deal.
Bibi is the bravest, strongest n most capable leader in the world. So have faith in his leadership because he knows exactly what he is doing in order to prevent the destruction of Israel by the cult of Islam n to ensure victory for Israel in this war n to ensure the eternal existence of the State of Israel.
He participated in the genius Shalit negotiation.
we support the speaker hope for peace
The "Philadelphia Corridor" (also known as the **Philadelphi Route** or **Philadelphi Corridor**) is a narrow strip of land that runs along the southern border of the **Gaza Strip** and **Egypt**, particularly near the city of **Rafah**. This corridor lies along the border between **Egypt** and the **Gaza Strip** and is significant for both military and security reasons, especially regarding Israel's concerns about arms smuggling and the movement of goods through underground tunnels between Gaza and Egypt.
Historically, this corridor has been a point of contention and conflict. After Israel's withdrawal from the Sinai Peninsula in 1982 as part of the Egypt-Israel Peace Treaty, this strip became a buffer zone. Israel maintained control over the corridor after the 1967 Six-Day War, but the situation shifted when Israel disengaged from Gaza in 2005, relinquishing control of the area.
The corridor has been critical in efforts to prevent the smuggling of weapons into Gaza, especially through a network of underground tunnels that have been used to transport arms, goods, and sometimes militants. Israel and Egypt have worked to monitor and close these tunnels in order to restrict arms flow to militant groups in Gaza.
In more recent years, the Egyptian government has increased its efforts to seal the border and the tunnels, often by flooding them or demolishing buildings that hide tunnel entrances, as part of its broader security campaign to stabilize the Sinai region and prevent militant activity.
Thanks!
Yes sir freedom for Palestine 🎉
Левые евреи в Израиле и в сша 🇺🇸 больше опасны для Израиля чем изверги хамаса! Факт.
Благослови господь натанияху
Netnyahu is really badest Administrator and Ruined humanity and Mankindness ...Worst
Hamas ruined gaza and west bank.
@@pradipray1251who created khamas?
@@truthprevails567 Islam
He is disingenuous about tunnels under the Philadelphi Corridor.
Great great kind generous man n but this gentleman tells about peace/ prosperity/ 2- state solution ❤
why folks like peace so much? if u got to fight a war, u go fight it ...
Correct
Natanyahu will never accept a ceast fire.
Well said
Nethanyagu is right leader
Occupied Palestine must be freed and let palestinian in hail freedom.
💚Jill Stein💚for president
The proposed deal may be viable to Israel, if it is added a condition that complete withdrawal of military from Gaza except for control over Philedelphia Corridor.
Nonsense. Let ISRAEL fight their fight.
Frantic conversation/s…,! Really😮?!
Netanyahu is a A Driver driving downhill. The brake Fails. Road in front forks into two.
On left road are 1000s of people. On right only a few.
Which road should Netanyahu take ?? Which road would you ?
Difficult decision no doubt. But Country and people come First.
Gershon Baskin's situation is like Ghandi as in 1946/47 his interactions with Muhammad Ali Jinnah and he use to propose and promise Many things to Muslim league and Quaid E Azam but when Muhammad Ali Jinnah use to ask him would congress agree to his prospal he said I can't say that
Dear sir
I always get enlightened by the way u r asking critical questions ( which are in the mind of the viewers (most ) ). I would request you to keep it with 12 to 14 min and not more than 15 min. These will help most of us to get the benefit in total❤❤
Someone said to cut the interviews to 15 mins i politely disagree these durations are very good and if not shorter than required in my opinion
I mean, can we stop playing games here?,, We know exactly when this thing is gonna take a break.,, after the elections. How long do you need to be on this planet earth to understand what’s going on?.
Do you believe after releasing hostages, will Hamas stop attacking Israel ?
Country which is at war have rich friends it is unlikely they will listen to poor and battered people. One has to realise that we depend on each other and need each other for many years to live in tolerance and peace then we have a chance to save whatever we want to save. All over world including India we are facing lot of unrest, suppression and injustice. As he said they behave like kindergarten kids... Fire and bombs are no kids stuff.
Its a crime to stay on land of Israel no matter whats ur faith.
Insha'Allah, husbunallahu wanamal Wakeel. Free palestine
Its a civilization war Islam vs Jew just like Islam vs Hindu or Islam vs Christianity, just one man is not responsible. As long as followers of Quran is there, this will nor end
Needs to be in the crosshairs soon 😂😂
So now please interview a Netanyahu supporter to show us the other side. Otherwise, this interview would just be considered part of anti-Netanyahu propaganda.
Indeed india need to learn same in kashmir when you accopied others land and expect from then to do nothing against indian army barbarian act of killing innocent kashmiris striping everything they own expect then to sing wande matram absolutely rubbish mindset india need to rethink there policies in kashnir.kashmiri need a independent country we don't need to live under the rule of india nore pakistan,now or in 100s year after kashmir will ve independent from india and pakistan!!! ❤
Long live republic of kashmir.
Do you think Pakistan will allow you to live independently? Kashmir was a free country and India supported it. Pak attack in 47 changed the fate of Kashmir. In all wars, locals helped Indian Army. If Indian Army leaves Kashmir tomorrow then Pak Army will enter the next day. Indian Army took Bangladesh in 71 but gave back everything to them. See my dad was in Indian Army so I know their moral. They are not barbarian, what they will do if you take money from Pakistan and throw stones on Indian Army
The quataris allowed the Indians to spy for Israel😂😂
Look which Pakistani is talking ?
Netyanahu is guarantee of Isreal victory and end of Terrorist and rapist organisation HAMMAS
NETANIAHOU wants to remain a FREE MAN. IF THERE IS PEACE, NETANIAHOU WILL HAVE TO ANSWER THE CHARGES PENDING AGAINST HIM OF GRAVE CORRUPTION AND NOT ONLY. THIS IS HIS PROBLEM!!
He might be a negotiator but A person with horse view only
Its a civilization war Islam vs Jew just like Islam vs Hindu or Islam vs Christianity, just one man is not responsible. As long as followers of Quran is there, this will nor end
You have a reputation Karan, why interview biased, partial people?
Kamal hassan some how popped up in negotiations!
I was wondering what you meant. Then I heard the interview.
Mr thappar needs a thsppar6for his prozionist interviews
Read the Bible- the old testament and you will know that Bibi is a leader and is doing the right thing
Are Well culture political leaders very few in the democracies nations?????
And absent in muslim world.
@@pradipray1251mentally absents think so