You’re mixing up Dobby and Trelawny with the bottle hiding. Trelawny hides her sherry bottles in the room, while Dobby finds butterbeer remedies and an elf sized bed for Winky.
I honestly liked the idea of it being Longbottom that found that out as they did in the movies. Not only did it give him a little bit of a play in a book where he had very little influence but would also have his good grades in Herbology become pretty useful. Plus it did add a little to the polymorfed whatshisface as that didn't seem quite as risky as just hoping Harry could find it out himself or that he just so happened to be overheard by a house elf that were on Harry's side. Would also make the small talk he had with Longbottom all the more meaningful as in the books it just seems like a simple way to make sure that his disguise isn't seen through but in the movies it seem like he did it on pupose simply so that he could manipulate and use Longbottom to avoid getting suspicion on himself. ..Plus that "I just killed Harry Potter!" joke was rather funny.
I think in every single J vs Ben, after losing a question Ben will say at least once, "You know, this is one of those things that..." and then go on to explain how he interpreted it or remembered it or something 😂
@@rosaliejo5682 I believe what was meant by that line, as odd as it sounds, is that if you pay attention to when they're using the floo powder to travel to Diagon Alley, the Weasley's have a hook above their fireplace that's shaped like a cat. I imagine that Mrs Weasley had washed it and hung it there to dry maybe? But also, in reference to the quizzes, they are usually based book knowledge unless otherwise specified, and that line is from the movie only. But still. Fred and George are also pranksters and could have shrunk her sweater and put it on the cat. Or could simply have meant that her sweater was lying ON the cat as it slept. But I wasn't aware they even owned a live cat as a pet. So. My thoughts. 🤣
@Madison Hachmann I love it when people say British slang. There's words that Scottish people say that nearly everyone in the South of England wouldn't understand 😂
Agreed! Also, is it just me or is J not very gracious when he loses to Ben? Ben almost always loses but still has fun. J gets a little too irritated when he doesn't win. 🤔
Yes that’s exactly what I thought. It’s almost like he thinks Ben is inferior or something. Also he gives himself points sometimes when he doesn’t deserve them. Not hating but he comes across a bit bitter haha
@@brendankeane7303 i mean he doesn't give himself the points Derek does all the editing but I guess he does go like "I think that counts as half a point" and he is quite bitter
Hay I just published my first story a few day ago check out the first 4 chapters tell me what you think I’m trying to get 150 readers by the end of September my.w.tt/vtex0zBcwP
10:53 When "Moody" was telling Harry about how he was the reason Harry got through the tournament, he named off a bunch of things he did to make sure Harry figured things out, and he says that one thing he did, after he saw how much Dobby admired Harry, was to have a loud conversation about Gillyweed while Dobby could hear, because he knew Dobby would tell Harry. So, yeah, we kind of do know why. 😂
Unrelated to the video, but I had a suggestion for another Disney theory. What if Dr. Fecilier from The Princess and the Frog is the son/grandson of Mama' Odie? It would explain her age if he was in his late 40's early 50's. Plus they both use voodoo magic, and are known to be royals of their craft. Mama' Odie is described as the "voodoo queen of the bayou" and Dr. Fecilier mentions how "I'm a prince myself on my mother's side." You don't have to do it, but it was just a thought.
wolf flame he was originally supposed to be Mama Odie's son and they were meant to have a showdown but, obviously, they changed the script. You can find it on Mama Odie's disney wiki page
I meant to add decedent in the comment as well. If he grew up while she was in her early to late 90's, it would explain why she is so old if they are related.
so, it's not that pastry-meat dish described in textbooks? (I'm from Eastern Europe, have never seen real English pudding, trying to clear things up for myself)
@@mycattypedthis2827 That sounds more like a pie? I'm not really sure what you're describing, but a pudding is always a sweet dish (usually eaten after dinner)
Dobby was out looking for a job for, in his own words: "two whole years", but that simply isn't true. He was freed from Malfoy on May 29th 1993, the same day he killed the basilisk. The day Harry meets Dobby at Hogwarts is in early December 1994, which means that it was AT MOST a year and a half Dobby was without a job.
that's still like 18-19 months and most people would just round up to two years because it's easier to say and closer to two years than it is to one year.
@@tomuchcamoflauge The difference between 1.5 and 2 years is 25%, which is fairly considerable. I would even assume a house elf knows the difference, so it would have made more sense for him to say "a year and a half" of even just "more than a year". Regardless, this is likely just an oversight by Rowling, and therefore also by the quiz makers. I just wish they got it right.
I completely agree with this PowerfulWarbird, except for the fact that if you read the comment closely, it says Dobby killed the Basilisk. Can't have a mistake in your post about accuracy. INVALID!
@@PowerfulWarbird No, that seems plausible that someone would naturally round that up to 2 years, especially if it was still a bit before he got everything about his job finalized
I took a test today and when I finished I was like yay! And my teacher said “now that’s one less thing to worry about” and I started saying “one less thing to worry about, that’s one less thing to worry abou-out” and he just kinda stared at me confused lol
if Dobby had come to the Malfoy household with Narcissa from the Black family it is possible that he has a blood-related inclination to help Harry, as Harry Potter's grandmother was a Black
@Jarod Rhudy yea, Dorea Black. I doubt this is in the novels, I think it is on the Black family tree in the movie, and it's official on the wikis and stuff. Wife of Charlus Potter. Who I think did the Sleekeasy potion too? JK rly hates Death Of The Author.
My freind was in science class and they were doing stuff with socks and his teacher gave him a sock so he said “master has given dobby a sock, dobby is freeeeeee” and ran out of the class room...
I was worried my ravenclaw cosplay shoes would brake or hurt my feet and have to take them off at wizarding world. My friend said if I get stop by security for not wear shoes I had to run away screaming “DOBBY is a free elf!”
The "Come and Go Room" refers to the Room of Requirement as a whole, not the Room of Hidden Things specifically. And Dobby and Winky don't go the RoHT, for them it manifests as a bedroom with potions to sober her up.
@@Calvinosaur Oh yeah! Is that in the same book? IIRC Harry *hears* her in there, right? And doesn't know what it is until later in the book. But I don't remember why he was there or what book that is...
@@timkinney8719 Different books. In Order of the Phoenix, Dobby tells Harry about Winky's problem when he's explaining the Room of Requirement to him. In Half-Blood Prince, Trelawney happens to come into the room right after Draco finishes a successful test of the now-repaired vanishing cabinet. After Malfoy violently expels her from the room, Harry hears her scream and a breaking sherry bottle, and comes to investigate. (This chapter is The Seer Overheard, if you wish to check it out.)
See I have read them like 12 times or more so I remember most of these. I also read incredibly slow and remember everything. I remember stuff I read 20 years ago but I hated reading in school because there were always deadlines.
That discussion about how Ben's mind works was really interesting. I feel like that would be an interesting video at some point: How would you describe your mind? With all of you describing your minds. I always describe mine as a spiderweb. There are connections everywhere and if you follow the right one you'll get there eventually.
I thought about it for a second and my immediate thought was that I was controlling a trolley on a track that navigates through a bunch of notes, files, and books, and every now and then I just have to remember which way to turn the track at certain parts and where to stop at to find what I'm looking for, instead of going past it to unrelated things, and when I realize I went past it or made a wrong turn, I have to find my way back to what I was looking for and remember how far back I need to go. Sometimes, the papers may have been put in the wrong spot, because it would just be something unrelated to what I was looking at out of nowhere, when they should be similar topics.
Vendiagrams, so many Vendiagrams with half filled in information and irrelevant facts. Or a fact board like the one from always sunny when Charlie and Mac work for this place and he's describing how this one person doesn't exist
You have no idea how gutted I am you haven't done the Voldemort quiz yet :( Can confirm Jumper & Sweater is the same thing (at least in the UK where Potter is set) Pudding is basically anything you can eat as a dessert here. It's a catchall term.
Sweater is the American word for jumper so technically they're the same thing. But yes, in the UK a sweater is more like a hoodie without a hood lol, that's the best way I can describe it.
28:03 THEIR REACTION HILARIOUSSSSSS SN: everytime Jonathan cant think of the answer or he gets ot wrong he makes these grunting sound affect noises its so funny
18/30, 60%, an elf-y result. "You’re not a Dobby expert, but you’re certainly an elf enthusiast. We recommend a rigorous re-read of every single Dobby scene in the Harry Potter books." Well, I've been looking for an excuse to reread the series
J Dog I used to roll my eyes at this bit of trivia, cruelly thinking he could have suffered through it for art or some nonsense. A few years ago, I had an allergic reaction to contacts & visibly looked like a horror show! Now I understand him being allowed to pass.
I mean I can live with the blue, but at least match it with the eyes of the actresses that portrayed lily!! Severus: you have your mother's eyes Daniel: Uh no I have blue the other actresses have hazel and brown
You should do Comedy/Parody scetches sometimes. I laughed so hard when you simulated that talk about Gillyweed. I need more of this. not even a theory to go along with this just the comedy :P Congrats Ben! Always happy when you win!
y'know what I don't think they have. They should do it. I think I took it but can't really remember it. They should definitely do this quiz it would be amazing.
The reason Dobby was so driven to help Harry is because during Voldemorts rein of terror house elves and some other magical creatures had been treated even worse than they had previously and in some cases worse than they are now. This is why other house elves who meet Harry (like winky) are also as happy to have met him as they saw his defeat of Voldemort as an end to the horrible conditions they had to work under. Although given how some of them are treated in the books I don't know how much worse it could have got. Thanks guys for the great videos
Some British translations for you guys: a jumper is what we call a sweater; a pudding is just another name for a dessert (so a restaurant menu would probably be more specific)
I don’t know what it is about these challenges that are so addicting... maybe the fact you’re both in them... but I swear I watch one a day, no matter how many times I’ve seen them, simply because they calm me down at the end of the day
10 galleons a week and weekends off (Dumbledore) 1 galleon a week and one day off a month (Dobby) Did any other people realize that Dobby worked Dumbledore down from $73.50 a week? For a job that normally doesn't pay! Wow!
Dobby goes to a special Elf-sized Room of Requirement with butterbeer antidotes and a bed for Winky, I think that he also hides the butterbeer bottles in that room! And Dobby sends Harry the painting for Christmas in Order of the Phoenix, so they are at Grimmauld Place.
Please please please tell me someone else got excited about Ben's mind palace please! Cause y'all. BEN HAS A MIND PALACE. HE HAS *pause for dramatic effect* A MIND PALACE.
Jeopardy in the last 10 years has definitely taken on that question style you guys mention haha My dad watched it daily growing up, and he was a Latin teacher and knew all the tough questions, I could snag a good amount as a trivia and history buff but then they made it where every question has like 2 hints in it by default and hints to others in the category
I love these quiz games! Of course, you guys know so much more than me, but they are really fun to watch with you guys being confused and the sometimes cringeworthy jokes......
Oh you two are just the best ever! Your videos make me smile so much! I've only just found your channel, and have just been binge watching your videos for the last week. Your knowledge is incredible, and the laughs and happy vibes just make my day :) Thank you for all you do, you're awesome. Sending lots of Potter love over from the UK, from a proud Hufflepuff! xx
Ben and J, I really appreciate your dedication and knowledge on all the things you share with us. Thank you for continuing to make the effort and posting great content.
Dobby was not hiding the butterbeer bottles to the Room of Requirement at any point. Professor Trelawney does hide her sherry bottles there in the the Half-Blood Prince.
My problem with question 15 is that the math doesn't add up. Dobby was freed at the end of Chamber of Secrets, around June 1993. However he arrived back at Hogwarts at the beginning of the school year in Goblet of Fire, early enough that he was able to assist Harry for the second task on February 24th 1995. This is a time period less than two years. Now it may have said two years in the book but it was clearly meant to be used as an estimate, so that information due to its factual inaccuracy should not be used in a quiz.
I only have grey socks so they can never not match! I do often wear my shoes to bed though! And sometimes I take them off in the morning and don't put them back on till bedtime thus succeeding in shoe role reversal!
In Canada pudding is a snack or dessert item with a less wobbly/thicker consistency than Jello and is milk/cream-based, normally flavoured with chocolate or vanilla.
Yup! I guess I remember that in particular quite vividly , cause i've just finished GOF... There's one with snitches and the other has broomsticks stitched on it , if I am not mistaken , that is..
You’re mixing up Dobby and Trelawny with the bottle hiding. Trelawny hides her sherry bottles in the room, while Dobby finds butterbeer remedies and an elf sized bed for Winky.
I was going to comment this, but then I saw you already had. So thanks smart stranger. :)
Yes! About to comment the same thing!
Yup. Was also about to say the same
3 years later and I was going to type that, only to see it written already!
I genuinely laughed at the discussion about Moody talking loudly so Dobby would overhear because that's how I imagined it in my head :P
Me too and he would of seen him coming ie his magic eye
I know I'm late but, I heard it in the actors' voices too, in my head. And an "what the heck are you blabbering about" from McGonnagal too. :D
Yeah I was thinking that that was really lucky that Dobby heard him but then we learn that that was actually Moody's plan.
But, wasn’t he Barty Crouch Jr then?
I honestly liked the idea of it being Longbottom that found that out as they did in the movies.
Not only did it give him a little bit of a play in a book where he had very little influence but would also have his good grades in Herbology become pretty useful.
Plus it did add a little to the polymorfed whatshisface as that didn't seem quite as risky as just hoping Harry could find it out himself or that he just so happened to be overheard by a house elf that were on Harry's side.
Would also make the small talk he had with Longbottom all the more meaningful as in the books it just seems like a simple way to make sure that his disguise isn't seen through but in the movies it seem like he did it on pupose simply so that he could manipulate and use Longbottom to avoid getting suspicion on himself.
..Plus that "I just killed Harry Potter!" joke was rather funny.
I'm voting for a future episode on the Room of Requirement.
Easy listening music
I remember Trelawney stowing alcohol there. Well, something that put her under the influence.
Yes 30/30
@@LadyhawksLairDotCom yup, Sherry bottles
I think in every single J vs Ben, after losing a question Ben will say at least once, "You know, this is one of those things that..." and then go on to explain how he interpreted it or remembered it or something 😂
And J will start crying at almost every question he gets wrong by trying to get himself the extra point
#“Dobby has not slept for a week, Harry Potter!” said Dobby
proudly, swaying where he stood.
Michael Hummel me during finals week 😂👌🏻😅
Was dobby just in malfoys dorm, sitting. Did malfoy wake up to eyes in the corner?
Love Dobby
i hadn't slept in a week, i was weak, i was awake
(continue chain if you get what i mean ;))
"Mum have you seen my jumper?"
"Yes dear, it was on the cat."
Sophi23 I never understood that line, I always figured I was hearing it wrong. How could it be on the cat 😂
Rosalie Jo shrinking
@@rosaliejo5682 I believe what was meant by that line, as odd as it sounds, is that if you pay attention to when they're using the floo powder to travel to Diagon Alley, the Weasley's have a hook above their fireplace that's shaped like a cat. I imagine that Mrs Weasley had washed it and hung it there to dry maybe? But also, in reference to the quizzes, they are usually based book knowledge unless otherwise specified, and that line is from the movie only. But still. Fred and George are also pranksters and could have shrunk her sweater and put it on the cat. Or could simply have meant that her sweater was lying ON the cat as it slept. But I wasn't aware they even owned a live cat as a pet. So. My thoughts. 🤣
i love this
@Madison Hachmann I love it when people say British slang. There's words that Scottish people say that nearly everyone in the South of England wouldn't understand 😂
Hey it’s ur British translator
Pudding is either a spongy cake traditionally with fruit inside
Or it’s another name for the dessert course
APJD Plays mostly the second one
I send thanks from America
Hi I am also British and I've always considered it as desert but never spongy fruit
In my country it's milk soup that contains rice .
Omar Sabry we call it rice pudding
Petition to have DK(the question asker) narrate all the Harry Potter books
You have my signature!
Mine too! xd
Do it.
Do it!!!
agreed im in
Dobby's first words to Harry: Harry Potter
Dobby's last words to Harry: Harry Potter
:((((((((((
Ya lol
@@asiyak.4423 what is lol in that?????
@@ruchikhera7013 laugh out loud lol
@@jackdownton5654 Actually it's laughING out loud
Dobby's eyes were green like Lily's. Dobby has Harry's mother's eyes.
His eyes are as green as a fresh pickled toad
Dobby is Harry's uncle...
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Snape loved dobby the hole time
It says right in the beginning of chapter 2 (Dobby’s Warning) of CoS that Dobby has “bulging green eyes the size of tennis balls.”
Ben should have gotten half a point for the sock question
Agreed! Also, is it just me or is J not very gracious when he loses to Ben? Ben almost always loses but still has fun. J gets a little too irritated when he doesn't win. 🤔
Yes that’s exactly what I thought. It’s almost like he thinks Ben is inferior or something. Also he gives himself points sometimes when he doesn’t deserve them. Not hating but he comes across a bit bitter haha
Exactly!!! I'm not hating or anything...their videos are quite amusing. Maybe it's a firstborn thing??? LOL!!!
But he should have known they would be mismatched.
@@brendankeane7303 i mean he doesn't give himself the points Derek does all the editing but I guess he does go like "I think that counts as half a point" and he is quite bitter
In Britain, Pudding is something sweet that you have after Dinner. It’s normally sweets or cake.
It is the British word for dessert
The once proper English turned slang is often the most loose defined, so odd.
They can also be savory; like Yorkshire puddings, haggis, black pudding, and kidney pie. :)
I love how they didn’t know what puddings or jumpers were, I didn’t even realise that our English words were so different to the American ones.
Hay I just published my first story a few day ago check out the first 4 chapters tell me what you think I’m trying to get 150 readers by the end of September my.w.tt/vtex0zBcwP
Surely Ben should have been given half a point for getting one of the socks correct?
I really do love J vs Ben videos!
Absolutely, if it was J he would've cried for a full 2 minutes about getting a half point.
10:53
When "Moody" was telling Harry about how he was the reason Harry got through the tournament, he named off a bunch of things he did to make sure Harry figured things out, and he says that one thing he did, after he saw how much Dobby admired Harry, was to have a loud conversation about Gillyweed while Dobby could hear, because he knew Dobby would tell Harry. So, yeah, we kind of do know why. 😂
Honestly I love it when Ben wins because he just always seems so happy. I'm here for it. Big Mood.
Unrelated to the video, but I had a suggestion for another Disney theory. What if Dr. Fecilier from The Princess and the Frog is the son/grandson of Mama' Odie? It would explain her age if he was in his late 40's early 50's. Plus they both use voodoo magic, and are known to be royals of their craft. Mama' Odie is described as the "voodoo queen of the bayou" and Dr. Fecilier mentions how "I'm a prince myself on my mother's side." You don't have to do it, but it was just a thought.
wolf flame he was originally supposed to be Mama Odie's son and they were meant to have a showdown but, obviously, they changed the script. You can find it on Mama Odie's disney wiki page
i love that movie, it's so underrated
Why would it explain it her age? She's supposed to be about 157 years old, isn't she?
J and Ben PLEASE do this!!!!!!!!!
I meant to add decedent in the comment as well. If he grew up while she was in her early to late 90's, it would explain why she is so old if they are related.
From an English fan, pudding is the UK synonym for destert
so, it's not that pastry-meat dish described in textbooks? (I'm from Eastern Europe, have never seen real English pudding, trying to clear things up for myself)
@@mycattypedthis2827 That sounds more like a pie? I'm not really sure what you're describing, but a pudding is always a sweet dish (usually eaten after dinner)
Yeah, typically takes a liquid form though whilst dessert has more solid connotations. Pudding also seems more posh.
Is destert the UK synonym for dessert?
No it's not a word lol
"Dobby is used to death threats sir, dobby gets them five rimes a day!" I remember this distinctly.
Camryn Garcia same
I too remember all the rimes Dobby has gotten.
Dobby was out looking for a job for, in his own words: "two whole years", but that simply isn't true. He was freed from Malfoy on May 29th 1993, the same day he killed the basilisk. The day Harry meets Dobby at Hogwarts is in early December 1994, which means that it was AT MOST a year and a half Dobby was without a job.
that's still like 18-19 months and most people would just round up to two years because it's easier to say and closer to two years than it is to one year.
@@tomuchcamoflauge The difference between 1.5 and 2 years is 25%, which is fairly considerable. I would even assume a house elf knows the difference, so it would have made more sense for him to say "a year and a half" of even just "more than a year". Regardless, this is likely just an oversight by Rowling, and therefore also by the quiz makers. I just wish they got it right.
@@PowerfulWarbird Or maybe it's an oversight by the character Dobby. Or do you never round up 1.6, 1.7 years to 2 years?
I completely agree with this PowerfulWarbird, except for the fact that if you read the comment closely, it says Dobby killed the Basilisk. Can't have a mistake in your post about accuracy. INVALID!
@@PowerfulWarbird
No, that seems plausible that someone would naturally round that up to 2 years, especially if it was still a bit before he got everything about his job finalized
No one:
The answer: 1 week
My brain: "I hadn't slept in a week I was weak, I was awake"
The man who wrote the lyrics for Hamilton ghost writes for Nicki Minaj
He also is a ghost in hog warts castle
I took a test today and when I finished I was like yay! And my teacher said “now that’s one less thing to worry about” and I started saying “one less thing to worry about, that’s one less thing to worry abou-out” and he just kinda stared at me confused lol
Still waiting on that crucial Hannah Abbott quiz.
Trexosaurus Justin Finch-Fletchley Quiz
What was your score?!! Did you beat us?
No...:(( i love you
Well I never read the books I heard them (thank you audible) but ya I did
Probably not. I haven’t watched the video yet.
Yew
28/30 as well!
Absolutely you should make one, even if not a pottermore official one, and we all can take it.
DK has the most smooth voice I’ve ever heard, please make Harry Potter audiobooks
Who?
@@hailey5828 Guy who read questions
@@hailey5828 Donkey Kong
“ Where was dobby buried”?
J: writes in the air while saying “ in the ground”!
J: prove me wrong!
True j very true! 😂😂😂
You're right that is what they say in the video good job.
if Dobby had come to the Malfoy household with Narcissa from the Black family it is possible that he has a blood-related inclination to help Harry, as Harry Potter's grandmother was a Black
@Jarod Rhudy yea, Dorea Black. I doubt this is in the novels, I think it is on the Black family tree in the movie, and it's official on the wikis and stuff. Wife of Charlus Potter. Who I think did the Sleekeasy potion too? JK rly hates Death Of The Author.
Randall Randall so how closely we’re Sirius and James related? Would that make them 2nd cousins or soemthing
@@crisatwood6899 just looked at the fam tree, Sirius's grandparents are siblings of James' parents so first cousin twice removed I THINK
Randall Randall oh god well once it gets to the removed stuff I don’t know how any of it works. But very cool ty
@@crisatwood6899 "removed" is generations back but i cant say im very familiar with the system either
THE HATS LOOK GREAT
the next fashion trend coming your way
Don't you mean "THESE HATS ARE AMAZING?"
Yeet
Where did they buy that? :o
My freind was in science class and they were doing stuff with socks and his teacher gave him a sock so he said “master has given dobby a sock, dobby is freeeeeee” and ran out of the class room...
LSHMSFO
lol did he come back?
LegoMinerSwag99 idk, were not in the same clas
I was friends with a guy in Jr high, and he would totally do that 😂
I was worried my ravenclaw cosplay shoes would brake or hurt my feet and have to take them off at wizarding world. My friend said if I get stop by security for not wear shoes I had to run away screaming “DOBBY is a free elf!”
The "Come and Go Room" refers to the Room of Requirement as a whole, not the Room of Hidden Things specifically. And Dobby and Winky don't go the RoHT, for them it manifests as a bedroom with potions to sober her up.
Yeah, it's Trelawney who always hides her alcohol bottles in there.
@@Calvinosaur Oh yeah! Is that in the same book? IIRC Harry *hears* her in there, right? And doesn't know what it is until later in the book. But I don't remember why he was there or what book that is...
@@timkinney8719 Different books. In Order of the Phoenix, Dobby tells Harry about Winky's problem when he's explaining the Room of Requirement to him. In Half-Blood Prince, Trelawney happens to come into the room right after Draco finishes a successful test of the now-repaired vanishing cabinet. After Malfoy violently expels her from the room, Harry hears her scream and a breaking sherry bottle, and comes to investigate. (This chapter is The Seer Overheard, if you wish to check it out.)
Every time I watch these, I really question the fact that I read all these books
Reading for fun and reading to remember details are way different.
Same
See I have read them like 12 times or more so I remember most of these. I also read incredibly slow and remember everything. I remember stuff I read 20 years ago but I hated reading in school because there were always deadlines.
That discussion about how Ben's mind works was really interesting. I feel like that would be an interesting video at some point: How would you describe your mind? With all of you describing your minds. I always describe mine as a spiderweb. There are connections everywhere and if you follow the right one you'll get there eventually.
@bnananananananananan
*_A P P A R I T I O N_*
I thought about it for a second and my immediate thought was that I was controlling a trolley on a track that navigates through a bunch of notes, files, and books, and every now and then I just have to remember which way to turn the track at certain parts and where to stop at to find what I'm looking for, instead of going past it to unrelated things, and when I realize I went past it or made a wrong turn, I have to find my way back to what I was looking for and remember how far back I need to go. Sometimes, the papers may have been put in the wrong spot, because it would just be something unrelated to what I was looking at out of nowhere, when they should be similar topics.
Mine is a bottomless pit with memories engraved into the sides and I have to grab on to look at them.
Vendiagrams, so many Vendiagrams with half filled in information and irrelevant facts. Or a fact board like the one from always sunny when Charlie and Mac work for this place and he's describing how this one person doesn't exist
You have no idea how gutted I am you haven't done the Voldemort quiz yet :(
Can confirm Jumper & Sweater is the same thing (at least in the UK where Potter is set)
Pudding is basically anything you can eat as a dessert here. It's a catchall term.
Jumper and sweater are different things. A jumper is knitted and a sweater is not.
*Amelia Wass*
Say that to grandma's knitted sweater, I dare you!
Sweater is the American word for jumper so technically they're the same thing. But yes, in the UK a sweater is more like a hoodie without a hood lol, that's the best way I can describe it.
In Canada (yes, Canada) most people I know call rompers jumpers, and we also call “ugly Christmas sweaters” Christmas jumpers.
UK jumper is a US sweater, Uk sweater is a US sweatshirt, Uk pinafore is a US jumper.
I got 24/30 and I still haven't forgiven J.K. Rowling for killing Dobby.
Dorian Ridley same
Same
I absolutely hate that Fred died(
8:04 CAN WE TALK ABOUT THIS PHOTO UNM
@Madz yeah it’s gross bro
I know!😂
It's terrifying 🤣🤣
28:03 THEIR REACTION HILARIOUSSSSSS
SN: everytime Jonathan cant think of the answer or he gets ot wrong he makes these grunting sound affect noises its so funny
18/30, 60%, an elf-y result. "You’re not a Dobby expert, but you’re certainly an elf enthusiast. We recommend a rigorous re-read of every single Dobby scene in the Harry Potter books."
Well, I've been looking for an excuse to reread the series
Thumbnail looks like dobby is about to wipe out half the galaxy
XD the balance must be kept
You are amazing
LMAO
Dude. Really?
TOO SOON!
Warner Brothers tried putting green contacts into Daniels eyes but he had an allergic reaction so he couldn't wear them
J Dog I used to roll my eyes at this bit of trivia, cruelly thinking he could have suffered through it for art or some nonsense. A few years ago, I had an allergic reaction to contacts & visibly looked like a horror show! Now I understand him being allowed to pass.
They could have digitally color corrected his eyes. It was an important detail in the story and no contacts would have been needed.
Harley Quinn this could very well give them a reason for a very specific _remastered_ version
I mean I can live with the blue, but at least match it with the eyes of the actresses that portrayed lily!!
Severus: you have your mother's eyes
Daniel: Uh no I have blue the other actresses have hazel and brown
Harley Quinn You say that like it breaks the story...
It's better to be as realistic as possible, so keeping the natural blue eyes is best.
27:08 that's a pretty unique way of describing thinking through memory
"If somebody is having fun it is a crime to take that away from them." Words to live by Ben.
Ben got an eraser?? What about the lucky smudges?
$20 that Ben's mind lamp is the Pixar Lamp
I was wondering if I was the only person who thought of that!
That or the stereotypical movie lamp with the green glass top
Thats exactly the lamp imagined when he said it lol
You should do Comedy/Parody scetches sometimes. I laughed so hard when you simulated that talk about Gillyweed. I need more of this. not even a theory to go along with this just the comedy :P
Congrats Ben! Always happy when you win!
Cassandra Müller Yes!!!!!
Love it when Ben does actually win. He looks so pleased
When J keeps saying Dobby is hiding the butterbeer bottles I know he’s confusing it with Trelawney hiding her sherry bottles.
That discription of your brain was really good Ben !
Description*
My brain is like my life, organized CHAOS! 😂
+SuperCarlinBrothers
Your quiz would be all the Hannah Abbot questions from every HP quiz
I can imagine that since dobby can go into the room of requirements he just polishes the diadem and part of voldemort's soul
Keeping his soul nice and clean 🤣
Dobby was too kind for this world.😢
27:06 I love this description of your mind. My dad has a filing cabinet and roledex. I have a memory warehouse.
Rank every Harry Potter book PLEASE!!!!!!!
yes yes yes yes YES!!!
Best to worst. deathly hallows. prisoner of askaban. half blood prince. Sorcerers stone. Order of phoenix. Goblet of fire. Chamber of secrets
@@bendavis5460 is that supposed to be objective? as in by sales? or is it just your opinion
Ben Parsons just my opinion
@@bendavis5460 oh yeah good cuz order of the Phoenix is my favorite
HEY BROTHERS! Idk if you guys have done the ultimate Voldemort quiz yet but if not that quiz is amazingly difficult!
Yes please do it!
y'know what I don't think they have. They should do it. I think I took it but can't really remember it. They should definitely do this quiz it would be amazing.
I think its time to come out and say it.The hats were a good idea.
The reason Dobby was so driven to help Harry is because during Voldemorts rein of terror house elves and some other magical creatures had been treated even worse than they had previously and in some cases worse than they are now. This is why other house elves who meet Harry (like winky) are also as happy to have met him as they saw his defeat of Voldemort as an end to the horrible conditions they had to work under. Although given how some of them are treated in the books I don't know how much worse it could have got. Thanks guys for the great videos
11:15 "McGonnagal was like, 'You're a blithering idiot'" -Ben
FINALLY!!! THE DOBBY QUIZ!!!!!
Also also actually actually, I got 22/30 on this quiz!
There were 25q
Same
Same
Ali khan No, there definitely was 30 questions, since I got 25 correct.
I got 27 correct.
Omg the hats... Sorry, first thing I saw :) :)
Some British translations for you guys: a jumper is what we call a sweater; a pudding is just another name for a dessert (so a restaurant menu would probably be more specific)
I don’t know what it is about these challenges that are so addicting... maybe the fact you’re both in them... but I swear I watch one a day, no matter how many times I’ve seen them, simply because they calm me down at the end of the day
I'm only watching the ad and I have already liked it also the ad was the new trailer for the crimes of grindalvald
I think you mean the trailer for Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald
That’s literally what he said
J: Sue Sylvester
Me: *high pitch squeal*
SAME! They know about Starkid and AVPM and everytime they reference it I scream
❤❤❤
This is the most likes and replies anything I’ve ever commented got and I did the squeal again.
10 galleons a week and weekends off (Dumbledore)
1 galleon a week and one day off a month (Dobby)
Did any other people realize that Dobby worked Dumbledore down from $73.50 a week? For a job that normally doesn't pay! Wow!
Dobby goes to a special Elf-sized Room of Requirement with butterbeer antidotes and a bed for Winky, I think that he also hides the butterbeer bottles in that room! And Dobby sends Harry the painting for Christmas in Order of the Phoenix, so they are at Grimmauld Place.
I love how Ben describes his thinking process, i immediately thought of Sherlock's "Mind Palace". Nice one.
Love the "Lost & Found" room!
Please please please tell me someone else got excited about Ben's mind palace please! Cause y'all. BEN HAS A MIND PALACE. HE HAS *pause for dramatic effect* A MIND PALACE.
I wonder if the kids thought of *GILLYWEED*
............
Question Five. What do people call Dobby the House Elf?
Correct answer is the Batman of Harry Potter.
Jeopardy in the last 10 years has definitely taken on that question style you guys mention haha
My dad watched it daily growing up, and he was a Latin teacher and knew all the tough questions, I could snag a good amount as a trivia and history buff but then they made it where every question has like 2 hints in it by default and hints to others in the category
J: “what is a pudding?”
Me: “is chocolate goo your eat with a spoon.” 😂
yum
Yumm
No,pudding is what we call dessert in the UK
I was too excited to see ben win
16:58 WHY WOULD THEY BE THE SAME COLOUR?? WHY WOULD THEY MATCH???
This is DOBBY we're talking about.
I love these quiz games! Of course, you guys know so much more than me, but they are really fun to watch with you guys being confused and the sometimes cringeworthy jokes......
Oh you two are just the best ever! Your videos make me smile so much! I've only just found your channel, and have just been binge watching your videos for the last week. Your knowledge is incredible, and the laughs and happy vibes just make my day :) Thank you for all you do, you're awesome. Sending lots of Potter love over from the UK, from a proud Hufflepuff! xx
0:24 simultaneous finger raise😱😱
OMG 😂 I played it like 50 times haha
Kaley Rice ikr lol
New hat, who dis?
I've been excited for this all day!!!
I bet Seamus is watching 😂
Elina Flinn And probably yelling in the comments about what pudding is 😂
Came a little later but Dobby was alive when I arrived.
Joseph Michnik Seamus Gorman
the part about mismatcheed sockss... woooww...le4t's justk say the ocean isn't the only thing that's wet...
I don’t think I’ve ever seen J win ..... but I always see him talking about how he won, that one time, back when, days of old
You must not watch a lot of them, then, because he seems to win the majority. xP
it's Ben who doesn't win a lot
I was gonna say, you must mean Ben.
Actually J wins most of the times...You must not have seen but that's true...
Wait,
if bens mind works like a desk with a lamp what if the sheets piled up too close to the lamp and burned???
He forgets whatever was on those sheets.
Dude you’re way overthinking this 😂
But what if they did?????
I think that the only real reason he was trying to protect Harry in book two was because he hated the Malfoy family.
And was unbelievabley grateful for Harry freeing him
@@katarinabrunk8698 he tried to protect Harry long before being freed by him.
I feel like it was because Harry was a symbol of hope
@@occheermommy he said that before Voldy-thing fell, house elves were treated like vermin, "but Dobby is still treated like vermin!"
Official, serious sounding voice: "I think a sweater and a jumper might be the same thing"
No a jumper is wool a sweater usually isn’t
@@neillomas2717 so like a woolen sweater
I could watch these quizzes all day. I am in love with Derek's voice 😍
Ben and J, I really appreciate your dedication and knowledge on all the things you share with us. Thank you for continuing to make the effort and posting great content.
Dobby was not hiding the butterbeer bottles to the Room of Requirement at any point. Professor Trelawney does hide her sherry bottles there in the the Half-Blood Prince.
pudding in britain is like deserts like cake, jelly, ice cream and you'd have them after dinner
My problem with question 15 is that the math doesn't add up. Dobby was freed at the end of Chamber of Secrets, around June 1993. However he arrived back at Hogwarts at the beginning of the school year in Goblet of Fire, early enough that he was able to assist Harry for the second task on February 24th 1995. This is a time period less than two years. Now it may have said two years in the book but it was clearly meant to be used as an estimate, so that information due to its factual inaccuracy should not be used in a quiz.
Year and a half would be closer.
I was thinking the same!
I lauded the video and came to the comments to see if anyone talked about this. I guess they rounded up?
Yeah, I think it was approximately 14 months. Dobby described it as two years.
@@naterudolph4035 he brought Winky with him so it had to be after the Quidditch cup in GoF
Dobby gives harry socks every birthday, including his fourth one
the glee reference threw me for a LOOP
OMGS YOU GUYS REFERENCES GLEE AND YOU LIKE STARKID YESSS
Also, I always wear mismatched socks. In fact, I don’t even own matching socks
Me2 mostly because my socks get stolen
Naya Diab my dog has a thing for stealing my socks
Same 😂
I only have grey socks so they can never not match! I do often wear my shoes to bed though! And sometimes I take them off in the morning and don't put them back on till bedtime thus succeeding in shoe role reversal!
Pudding in the UK is basically desert Like cake and such
how do you guys not have way more subscribers !???
I love it when you guys take quizzes. The videos are always laugh out loud entertaining. Thumbs up.
Today I was re-reading Deathly Hallows and I finished up after they left Shell Cottage so I thought I'd pay my respects to Dobby by coming here☺️
In Canada pudding is a snack or dessert item with a less wobbly/thicker consistency than Jello and is milk/cream-based, normally flavoured with chocolate or vanilla.
JJProductions That's what it is in the United States, too.
1:05 hoo remembers what dobby gave Harry in his 4th year was socks red and green socks
Yup! I guess I remember that in particular quite vividly , cause i've just finished GOF... There's one with snitches and the other has broomsticks stitched on it , if I am not mistaken , that is..
Finally!!!!!! Ben won a game!!!! I have always been rooting for him!
2:42 how can you say no to that cute face awwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww
Do a Dolores Umbridge Origins Video pretty please!!!!!
Harry Potter folklore or movieflame has done it
Harry potter folklore have done it.