J vs Ben: HARDEST Harry Potter Magical Objects Trivia Quiz
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 27 авг 2024
- Download the DoorDash app in the App Store and enter code JVSB2021 to get 25% off and zero delivery fees on your first order!
Head on over to joinhoney.com/JVSB to get Honey absolutely free!
Today J and Ben face off once more to determine who knows the most about the wide array of Magical Objects in the Wizarding World of Harry Potter!
Play along with us :: www.wizardingw...
Popcorn Culture ::
podcasts.apple...
open.spotify.c...
#SuperCarlinBrothers #JvsBen #HarryPotter
Edited by :: Riley Murtagh
Carlin Brothers Coffee ►► www.CarlinBrot...
Super Carlin Brothers Merch ►► www.SuperCarlin...
J vs Ben ►► bit.ly/2I5xHee
Harry Potter Theories ►► bit.ly/2K2Rtru
Super Carlin Gaming ►► bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
BECOME A SUPER CARLIN FRIEND➜ / supercarlinbrothers
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
FOLLOW US:
P A T R E O N ➜ / supercarlinbrothers
J's V L O G➜ / jonathancarlin
T W I T T E R➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
I N S T A G R A M➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
F A C E B O O K➜ / supercarlinbrothers
G A M I N G ➜ bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Want to send us something?
Super Carlin Brothers
PO Box 4339
Roanoke, Virginia 24015
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Business Inquiries Only: carlinbrosrtp@gmail.com
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Intro Music Created by RKVC
/ @rkvc
Intro Animation Created by J. Cutt Productions
/ @j.cuttproductions
Every time you give us a thumbs up a Narwhal gets its horn! (maybe..)
Has anyone seen the Honey... asking for a friend.
Yes, I did see it but Tom Riddle/ valdemort took it to be his horcruks. Also sorry if i spelled that wrong hehe
Lol
Uuuuuuuugh.......... what no! Honey? Never heard of it
Your friend should check all the bookshelves.... hypothetically of course
If I lean back enough in my chair, I can just see the honey sitting on my counter.
If "up to no good" was a position on the clock Fred and George would never move
Or as Ben wrote, “up to KNOW good”
Well…until…
@@MasterCrander too soon
Fred's would.
And Ron's would have been on "with gf" for most of a school year.
Ben's genuine surprise, wonder and happiness of winning a quiz once every blue moon is one of those things that make life feel worth living.
This comment needs a spoiler alert 😂😂
@@morganwarner5181 Spoiler Alert, thr comment is from Ben ;)
Right?! So adorable!
SPOILERS
The fact that Ben occasionally dots his i’s with hearts is giving me life right now
Fun fact: In the book Ron didn’t sit on a stone horse chess piece, he just was a knight. When he was taken out by the White Queen piece it actually pounced on him and punched him in the face.
I thought I remembered that differently. They act like he was murdered in the game.
@@BlindJedi in all fairness, in the book, he should’ve died. He was an eleven year old boy who just got backhanded by a giant stone golem. How did he survive? My theory...Magic.
@@thewestfire9729 A wizard did it.
@@BlindJedi hello future me?
@@thewestfire9729 Why? Knocking people unconscious is a real thing. Not saying it would be very good for him, but considering the number of times that Harry gets knocked out in the series, who's say that Ron couldn't have. Also, from my memory he gets slammed on the top of the head rather than punched just to be pedantic
Fun Fact: "Exploding Snap" is translated as "Snape explodes" in the German Harry Potter version😂
That's fantastic
I'm currently reading the books in Portuguese. I feel so bad for the translators.
Der Fritz hahaha
I know it was like this in the first editions (I was always wondering what the heck that game was supposed to be 😂), once I read the original British versions I realized it must've been a translation mistake, right? So I wonder if it was changed in later editions? I never went back to the translations after switching to the original...
@@mehfin I don't think it was changed, but I was just as surprised to read it differently in the English version :D I assume it was on purpose to add another wording joke
I imagine the name Aragolas is a mixture of Aragorn and Legolas. Gimli is probably feeling left out
Gimli has deducted 50 deaths from legolas’ kill count in retaliation
My thoughts exactly
Oh thank god I'm not the only one that thought that-
Lol I thought the same thing!
Aragogimlas??
If I recall correctly the quil is super enthousiastic about writing down names based on the slighest hint of magic, but the book doesn't allow the quil to write in it until significant proof of magic is provided.
Absolutely correct
Yep, they messed up but that's ok, they can't remember EVERYTHING
The most magical thing in the set is definitely bens smile. It makes me so happy because hes so happy looking.
Overkill?
Why... Because!
It is oddly satisfying. 😅
He’s so genuine! Seeing someone so genuinely excited and happy is so heartwarming 💛🖤💛🖤
I feel like a proud parent seeing Ben win for the first time in AGES
Fun fact: the German version translated "Exploding Snap" into "Exploding Snape". So for the longest time I alsways wondered why this card game was not forbidden at Hogwarts.
I always thought it was invented by Fred and George or the Marauders due to that translation
Lol that's hilarious
yeah, I was so confused hearing the English version
The Hand of Glory never claimed any lives, but the Opal Necklace was the one with 19.
That's what I was wondering, the Hand of Glory just gives light to the user, how would it kill anyone?
Yeah I thought that but was strange but I presumed I was wrong 🤷♂️
I know alot, about the art of dark magic, the hand's just a candle holder. The opal necklace, is also found, in the novels for the forgotten realms. I point this out, because of the fact that in that world, the opals in the necklace are from a cursed bag of gems. The curse, was put on them, by an enraged witch. Ironically, her name's morgana.
@@iamnotamanatee... I suppose it would be, after the light goes out. I haven't read the books, in along time. It's a really, dark artifact, that's not just in the potter books. The books, I refere to, are the forgotten realms books.
finally, the prophecy has been fulfilled. It was said 10 years ago that Ben would finally win a quiz and on April Fools too
Hagrid First movie: "you are a Horcrux, Harry"
The hand of glory didn't claim any muggle lives. It was the cursed necklace. Both were in the same scene so it explains the mix up
Thank you! I thought I was going crazy. The hand glory gives light only to the holder and is not fatal.
@@desmondgentle1474 I mean, it's a Black Family heirloom. It would make sense if it was dangerous to muggles
Pardon me@@robinsuj but where does it say the Hand of Glory or the cursed opal necklace is a black family heirloom. I believe they were just items found in Borgin and Burkes.
I heard the question and went like: err... Trick question! Zero!
What's the Hand of Glory?
"I don't know if it's just good editing, or like . . . Rupert Grint got hurt on set. 'No-one tend to him yet, the shot's not over!'"
Fun fact I just learned recently - there's a deleted scene from the second movie, where Lucius and Draco go into Borgin and Burkes while Harry's there. Draco tries to touch something, and Lucius whacks his hand with his cane telling him not to touch anything. Well, apparently the fangs of the snake on his cane actually hurt Tom Felton (as far as Jason Isaacs knows it didn't draw blood, but he believes it did pierce the skin a little). They kept going, but the second they cut filming, Jason apologised to Tom, and Tom (who welled up a little from the hit) replied in a shaky voice "No no, it's okay, it's good for the scene."
That's such a cute story, he's such a dedicated little actor! Also I can imagine the shaky voice it seems so in character!
I love how in the intro they are always mirroring each other
Someone should get J and Ben a ruler so they can properly center their mugs 😂😂
I think you mean someone needs to get BEN a ruler!
LOL
Lol
It's the super carlin brothers
@@eyebrow5915 wow thanks
Neville: (After his remembrall changes color) Only problem is, I can’t remember what I’ve forgotten.
While being the only person in the room without his ROBES
Lol yep
Neville's robes lie on the bench beside him. You can see that in the shot from above. He just hasn't put them on.
I read that with his voice and accent in my head
Anyone else really miss " THESE SOCKS ARE AMAZING" at the end of videos 🙋♀️🙋♂️🙋
🙋🏻♀️
🙋♂️
🙋
🙋🏽♀️
same lol
"Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic."
- Arthur C. Clarke
"Any sufficiently unadvanced magic is indistinguishable from technology."
“Well magic is just science that we don’t understand, Arthur C. Clarke.”
- Jane Foster
"Any technology distinguishable from magic is insufficiently advanced."
- Gehm's corollary
“Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.”
- Cade Yeager
“Why on earth do you know that”
-Ron Weasley
The reason why we love Thursdays...
And Tuesdays of course
and also monday, wednesdays and fridays because of the pokemon nuzlocke and popcorn culture.
Dont forget about Sunday. Fine day, no post either
Yes
@@kennethgdula712 lol
Yeah
I thought the "He's like a clock" was going to turn into a "Only right twice a day" joke.
Missed opportunity
A slow clock is right even less often.
I only want magic so I can just sit down and enjoy watching the vaccum, vaccum the house, the windows being wiped, the washing folding itself and putting itself away and so many more house cleaning things.
same lol i would be much too busy enjoying these small luxuries to do any evil
Audience: What are we going to do this scenic route, Ben?
Ben: Same thing we do every scenic route, Audience; try and hide J's honey!
Now, I want him to have a live audience (from his perspective) for the scenic route just to see people's reactions
Literally the best Harry Potter content on RUclips!
Agreed.
I agree
The hand of glory doesn't kill anyone. It only gives light to the holder. That shouldn't be fatal. I think that patron got that mixed up with the cursed opal necklace.
Yep, I caught that too
The way of making one does involve killing people though. The hand or hands that kill more people makes them more powerful.
Fun fact: english is not my native language, and when reading the books in english, I was not steady in it, and I always read that game as «Exploding Snape» 😂 I could never picture what kind of game this was 😂
there is a misprint in one german edition of the first book (or it was translated wrong) and it actually says "exploding snape"... so you weren't that wrong haha
@@spideylou I was about to comment the same thing! It’s exploding Snape in the German version. ^^
A new J vs Ben makes being in bed sick with a migraine so much better
Get well soon!
First I hope it’s gone soon, but wouldn’t the noise make it worse?
@@AxH_ it doesn’t all the time. I can’t speak for them but I have chronic migranes and noise can make it better, at least the distraction.
@@AxH_ I have chronic migraines as well, and it actually depends on the day and the person. Different people have different sensitivities. Didn't know that myself 'til I was diagnosed and had to fill out a questionnaire as to what makes mine act up 🤷♀️
Your complaint isn't even the weirdest thing about the two-way mirror. It's that there is literally no explanation for Harry having it in the movies. He just has it suddenly in Deathly Hallows - Part 1 and it's of equal relevance to the plot. How hard would it have been to have Sirius give it away in Order of the Phoenix?
Plus it was a broken shard that he carried out of heartbreak for his Godfather. He never used it because he didn't want Sirius to leave his safe place of security. Then when Harry finally tried it, it was too late...Sirius didn't die with his mirror on him. Would it have worked in the netherworld? And Mundungas sold it to Alberforth. And why do only headmaster's get living portraits? Or some random old battle axe like Wulburga Black?
@@corinneadams5390 he didn't use it to contact Sirius at all. He tried talking to him in Umbridge's fireplace
@@Rebecca-vg2ef Didn't Harry think he might be able to contact Sirius with the mirror after Sirius fell through the
veil? That would be a cool follow up story "if" Sirius had the other piece of mirror in his pocket when he
fell to his untimely death. And he looked back at Harry and answered-I'm going to throw this away now but I wanted to say good-bye to you Harry...(end scene.)
As an English Ben myself I really feel the need to point out that Big Ben is in fact the BELL in the tower NOT the clock or the tower itself so ring those bells guys!! These two are great!!!
As soon as they said that I started checking the comments to see if someone had already pointed this out. (I'm also English)
Good day, chaps! Another fact-checking Brit, checking in!
Here is an American who spotted their mistake.
Mr Weasley winds up on "with boyfriend/girlfriend", the clock switched to "mortal peril" as soon as Mrs Weasley sees it. 8D
I love this. 🤣
This was one of the easiest quizzes l've ever seen you do. I got almost all of them right, and l'm usually stumped a lot.
I agree and there were a lot more Magical objects to vex these guys-Probity Prob's, enchanted coins, books from the restricted section (oh a Magical book quiz would be delightful), the Sorting Hat, the Goblet of fire...this quiz could have been much longer...
The only one I have wrong is "many moving planets" leaving out the hands on the watch. I consider those parts independent of the face.
@@helenamirian908 No offense, you might have 2 wrong since the guys didn't check and the 2nd patreon submitted question was how many muggles were killed by the Hand of Glory (who knows is the right answer) 19 if you ask how many muggles were killed by the cursed opal necklace...
In the movie the Weasley clock is shown with a Dentist setting which is weird cuz later on in the series Hermione says her parents are Dentists at Slughorns party and no one knew what a Dentist was.
Yea but the movies had to add so many little details, that I'm sure lots of them were contradicted in the books later.
I like to imagine that was Mr. Weasley's addition on the clock, like he thought dentists sounded amazing and wanted to go someday
@@ghostie4485 BOOKS ARE BEFORE THE MOVIES!!!!!
@@morrigankasa570 The books weren't finished when the first movie came out
@@ghostie4485 but the first 2 or 3 where. The rest of the films came out after the rest of the books.
Fun Fact about "Exploding Snap"
In the german versions the translation is slightly off in the first book versions, so its called "Snape explodiert", obviously meaning "Exploding Snape" and for years I thought the have like a bewitched card game with Snapes face on it and theyre trying to let these cards explode or something alike.... :D
The hand of glory didn’t kill anybody, it was the opal necklace that Katie bell got cursed with that killed 19 muggles
That makes so much more sense. I was really confused at the time.
my sister’s a writer and she says she uses alternate words for regular colors all the time
2:22 OH MOM GET THE CAMERA
Also I gotta say I love seeing Ben beat J 😂
23:10 Fun fact: The German translation of the books changed „Exploding Snap“ into „Exploding Snape“ for the first four books. You don’t have an idea of my disappointment when I found out this game wasn’t about little figures of Snape that would explode...
Happy Bday to Gred and Feorge 💜 and congrats Ben on finally winning one!
Hi guys you’re the only people I watch for Harry Potter fan theories!!
Don’t, watch seamus goreman. He collabed with them and is really in the knows with Harry Potter.
I used to watch Harry Potter folklore and movieflame but not really anymore now I just watch them
@@ob1knob71 yes I agree
@@darthjarjar2742 I still watch movieflame
@@ob1knob71 Yes, Seamus Gorman is also quite good. Other than SG and SCB, there really aren't any other really good HP channels out there.
HOW COULD YOU FORGET LOST???? I am sorry but out of all of these quizzes this one is the one that really got to me. I was even yelling at my TV lol
I’ve literally been watching old J vs B videos all day and haven’t seen Ben win yet... so happy
Saying "Do you know what word I can't pronounce?" is almost always a recipe for disaster, lol.
Scb are like the only people who could get me interested in Harry Potter content these days. After the whole jk Rowling stuff, I basically went from an avid fan to utterly disinterested. And then rick riordan entered the chat, and all stuff Harry Potter was snuffed out of my mind.
But with scb, I always feel like I’m watching an scb video first, and a Harry Potter video second
You guys know how to keep me engaged regardless of content
UNCLE RICK! 😍🤩
Wow, being this early you'd think I had a time turner
DO YOU???
@@SuperCarlinBrothers I do let me lift it up WiNgArDiUm LeViOsAaA oops hermione said it’s Leviosa! Not LeViOsAaA
The ministry of magic wants to see you.
Uh, n..no... I just uh... worked things out with professor McGonagall..
Scott: we're halfway through, you know what that means!
Me: scenic route!
Scott: halfway halfpoint!
oh
I know this video is like 2 years old, but I just watched it, and a couple things that stood out was that one of the questions asked how many lives the Hand of Glory has claim, when it wasn’t claimed any, it’s the Opal Necklace that had killed 19 muggles. Another thing is that in the book, Ron doesn’t actually ride the knight piece, he just stands in its place just like Harry and Hermione do. The line in the book reads something like “The three pieces, as if listening to Ron, moved off the board to make space for them to play.
Fun fact: Big Ben is actually the name of the bell inside of the Elizabeth tower that sounds on each hour and not the name of the clock tower itself.
Fun fact , no it isn't
Big Ben Is just a nickname the actual bell is called the great bell
Waiting for the time where Johnathan brings the honey with him and does the honey sponser while Ben is looking for the honey thru out the sets and gets hungry halfway through and orders food that arrives at the end of the quiz.
Would be kind of funny if they just comletely switched roles for that segment, without even acknowledging it.
Can you do a Beth verses Alice??? And than you guys can ask the questions
Now THAT would be cool!
I knew "Lost" was one on the clock
Also, authors ABSOLUTELY have lists of synonyms for colors (and other things) on hand when writing.
Ben: do authors just have lists of alternative words
Me, a self proclaimed author: absolutely
I've detected what I think is a wrong answer. The Hand of Glory claimed zero lives, it granted light from a torch/candle to the carrier of the hand only. Friend of thieves, etc. It was the necklace that had claimed the lives of 19 users to date (and was later used on Susan Bones [Edit: Katie Bell] by Malfoy).
Also, a Ben win! Well done, Ben! Now I'm going to have to start rooting for J. LOL
Katie Bell, not Susan Bones
@@deadfish3789 You're correct, thank you for that!
I’d love to see some quizzes centered on the Avatar universe (ATLA and Korra). 😁
'A thing that only Scot does'....
I love that so much😂😂😂😂
One thing that I really liked about the Percy Jackson series is that technology is there but there’s a reason why they’re not really used
yeh same!! it doesn’t completely disregard the technology that would make so many things much easier but because it doesn’t wanna make everything easy there’s an excuse as to y they’re never used
imo that’s a clever way to write that lots of authors i’ve read books of don’t use
Hello! I just started wondering something whilst watching this quiz: what happened to Fred’s hand on the clock after he died? Did it go to mortal peril? Did it disappear? Did they have to remove it? Maybe you could make a video out of this? Or if anyone knows the answer; please let me know! :)
Also, does the clock show the Weasley's grandchildren when they are born? That'll be a lot of hands!
@@kaybrann I feel a “how does the weasley clock work” video coming up 😜
These brothers are so evil first Ben hides J's honey and then J doesn't share his doughnuts.
Absolutely love the fact checker element! Always love when you add book text and things and the fact checker just seems like a very good addition to that, excellent video!
I can't be the only one who saw "Aragolas" as one of the names and immediately thought Lord of the Rings, right? Aragorn and Legolas? I thought it was an obvious reference, but maybe I'm wrong and it's actually just that person's name
Ben's excitement at pronouncing 'anonymity' correctly - made my day! ❤
edit: and the excitement just keeps coming back!! So fun! Congratz Ben on your win 😊
Me: Authors don’t just have this „List for colours“, Ben, they have a list for every word. It‘s called „thesaurus“. Pronounce that, will ya?
Scott: said exactly that.
Don't know if this has been commented before but fun fact about Exploding Snaps: In the German version of the books this was mistranslated to "Snape explodiert" which literally means "Snape explodes" because someone got confused about Snap and Snape. It's my favorite bit of trivia about the books!
Look forward to videos every week! Miss the trivia Friday’s tho!! 💕💕
Hahaha Ben, “I guessed.” After J explains his whole long process about the poem question. The SASS!! 💙
I always assumed Exploding Snap is just the normal 'Snap' but instead of reaching out to hit the deck when there's a pair, the entire deck explodes. Building card towers would just be another fun thing they do with the deck, not part of the game itself
Thank goodness i was just reaching the end of the j vs ben playlist for my rewatch binge
Ben thank you 😭💙
The editing in this video is a step above
2:38 "Do you ever wonder if authors have like lists of alternative word choices for... ..."
*Yes. Yes we do.* And the Thesaurus is always on standby.
''you two are both magical people'' ... god, I love and miss Scott
I always prefer doing the questions here with you than just reading them myself :)
An alle deutsche Potterheads: Schaut mal vorbei, jeden Mittwoch gibt es eine neue Podcast Folge über einen Harry Potter Charakter :)
I thought Scott was the editor? Who is Riley? Would be cool to see a supercarlinbrothers behind the scenes team video when things are all safe COVID wise
Riley is a/the new editor (not sure if sharing with Scott or replacing him...)
Clarke's law: any advance form of technology is indistinguishable from magic
SCB: “why doesn’t everyone have two way mirrors?”
Fanastic Beasts writers *frantically writing in that Aberforth plot at the last minute*
Imagine if then Ginny had the clock and it DID say “with bf/gf” and during the school year Albus’ suddenly flicks to it 🤭😅😂
The hand of glory didnt claim the 19 lives, it was the cursed necklace that is later used in HBP. The hand is only mentioned after
I’ve been trying to tell Jay what exploding snap actually is for years and he’s never seen!
Snap is an extant British children’s card game, where you split the pack equally among the players and everyone takes it in turns placing cards face up in a pile in the middle until two of the same numbers get put down one on top of the other, and once you get a match, every player must yell “SNAP!!” and fling their hand onto the pile of cards. Whoever’s hand lands on the pile first gets those cards, and everyone continues putting cards face up in the middle until the next “SNAP!!” The aim of the game is to end up with all 52 cards.
Exploding snap just adds in the excitement of random explosions every now and then. And Ron just happens to be building a card castle out of the cards from an exploding snap pack at one point.
Love J vs Ben's. They should have one bi-weekly.
HAPPY BIRTHDAY GRED AND FORGE!!!
Yeeeyyyyyy
I mean a week of SCB content I'm here for it
I absolutely love the Halfway Half Point! I started getting excited from when I heard his voice at the start of the video!
i find it hilarious that when the name "aragolas" came up, they just were like "oh that's a cool name" and didn't realize it's the ship name for legolas x aragorn
Last time I was this early, dumbledoor had a big plan
Lol
well I was listening to random German folk tunes but then I saw this come up in my bell, and my eye started twitching to answer harry potter questions. so here I am a few minutes after debut.
Funny how Ben is the Ravenclaw and J is the Slytherin, yet Ben is wearing green and has a Gryffindor cup, and J is wearing blue. At least J has the Slytherin mug. 😹
Snap is a card game of its own, in which players are trying to win all the cards. The books talk about Ron USING Exploding Snap cards to build a house, but also talk about people playing Exploding Snap, so I took at as two different activities, and assumed Exploding Snap was Snap with exploding cards.
Big Ben isn’t a clock, it’s the bell inside the clock (which is called the Elizabeth tower)
Had to scroll too far for this. I hope they take this opportunity to tell people at the end of the video to subscribe and click on big ben to get notified about new videos. But whoever reads through the towel section first has to get this far into the comments.
Whoa, really? Pretty sure most people in the US call the whole clocktower Big Ben. Learn something new everyday.
I love these videos! You guys are so funny and good at trivia!
I am glad I remembered the Lost function on the clock. It was seemed the weirdest because 'Oh no Arthur, Ron's Lost! What should we do? ....'ummmm nothing, how can we find him if even he doesn't know where he is'
J: He's like a clock.
Me: Big Ben isn't a clock, it's a bell behind a clock. (or 4)
I now only will refer to captain americas hand as the hand of glory.
Ben's face when he is told he might have won is the purest thing
The hand of glory never claims any lives. It only gives light to the weirder. I think they were thinking of the opal necklace that had claimed 19 lives.
There's an old saying about even a broken clock being correct twice per day, and Big Ben would fit that description perfectly.
Ben: Do you ever wonder if authors have lists of alternative word choices?
Me, aspiring writer with my lists of alternative word choices: ……I’ve been found.
"Do you ever wonder, if authors have lists of alternative words..." You mean a thesaurus? That would be an affirmation to your query.
Technically, there is no gem encrusted into the sword of Gryffindor, a gem can be set, mounted, or even embedded into another object, but the word encrusted refers specifically to multiple objects covering over the surface of something larger.
Way to go Ben! You broke your streak. Time to celebrate with donuts of your own!
SCOTT!!! Such a treat - and his voice IS soothing