" He told Trelawney he saw a Hippogriff, which seems to be the answer she was looking for, as she immediately brought up Buckbeak's impending execution and asked Harry whether the Hippogriff looked headless. Harry, however, stated that Buckbeak looked to be fine and was in fact >flying away
The comment about the aquarium reminded me of that time years ago when Ben made a video saying that he was leaving the channel because he got a new job at an aquarium and I was upset until I looked at the date of the video and realized it was uploaded on April first. This comment has very little to do with the video, but it will help with the RUclips algorithm.
Then you might be interested about this podcast.. www.potterlesspodcast.com It is my favourite HP content alongside SCB. I practically binge listened it and I didn't think that was possible. 😄 (My dream is a Potterless SCB collab..😅)
Im so jealous of Scott, he has never read any of the books so he can still experience them all "for the first time".. I wish someone would just obliviate the books out of my memory so I can read them for the first time again!
I also wish they could obliviate the books and I could read the books first and imagine everything for mysel;f first. I didnt get into the books until like book 7 came out so the only one I read fresh was DH.
LOL That's how I came to remember 'Dobbin', because when first reading this in the book I was confused and thought they made a typo, and it said 'Dobby' :D
Hi don't know if this is the right place to post this but I have a theory, That Professor Trelawney is a Cassandra. Cassandra or Kassandra, was a priestess of Apollo in Greek mythology cursed to utter true prophecies, but never to be believed and subsequently others have been cursed the same. Also said that should they receive a vision of the importance they will be unable to remember it as please who suffer this curse often do because they have abused there gift. Just a theory I thought of and thought you might find interesting :)
I think Professor Trelawney's grandmother was a famous seer named Cassandra, so the curse you're talking about could have been inspiration for Trelawney's character
Fun fact: Shaggy is more often than not a vegetarian and even states his meat is veggi meat when rattling off ingredients in movies and such (see the first live action scoob movie). Not saying he's wrong in the half point question, as he has eaten meat in some shows and movies (Zombie island) but I thought it was interesting and wanted to share. :3 There was even a BK commercial set up for Shaggy's voice actor to do, but he strait up left the show for a couple years because he felt they didn't respect the character he was playing.
They made Shaggy a vegetarian to honor his original voice actor Casey Kasem who was a a vegetarian. Later after he retired as voice actor for him, the writers deviated from this at random but whenever he played the role, he was a vegetarian.
~"I was screaming a lot this weekend" ○" For good or bad reasons?" ~" Kind of neutral reason" ■" I WanT a SaNdwIch!" Also the sound effects at 27:00 are great
Fun fact: when trelawney makes the prediction about when 13 dine, the first to rise is the first to die, that later comes true twice. When they have dinner during Christmas, Ron has Peter pettitgrew in his pocket. The first to rise is dumbledore, who does die first. Second, just after mad eye moody dies, the thirteen people left sit down to drink. Lupin stands up first to go look for moodys body.
my husband hasn’t. I have been trying for years. He isnt much of a reader especially not for pleasure. He will read business related books and such but not novels. He said he would read them when he turns 80. I dont want to wait 30 years so Im trying to wear him down.
For some reason I really liked Scott in this quiz, it was wholesomely enjoyable even though he didn’t know that much about HP, he Just seemed to be excited to be apart of it!
Okay that's opened up something completely new to me. Do they try every subject before choosing which ones to do...? Even if I'm wrong, comments are good for the algorithm
@@Marigold11037 Interessting question, in the books they choose the subjects based purely on advise that is given by other people, It would be way better imo if they did do a trial period for each lesson. It would also give the reader more of an understanding of what subjects like arithmancy and muggel studies are.
In the third book ron accurately predicts Harry wining the try wizard tournament a tho indirectly he sees an acorn in Harry's cup which means a wind fall which unsuspected gold and what is the prize for the try wizard tournament 1,000 galleons and galleons are made of gold. Sorry this comment is really long but please read it.
Did you know that when a rabbit is very happy they do a "binky"? It is a jump, twist or turn in the air that looks absolutely stunning! We have a rabbit named Inky!
Scott sound like the cutest human being alive. I don't know why, bit he does, also reminds me of drawfee I just love it. Please join us more often Scott
"You guys are freaking amazing" reminded me of "These socks are amazing!" You could began to use the phrase "These guys are amazing!" always (or sometimes) at the end of the video, when the list of patreons is scrolling on the screen :D
*gazes across the room dreamily. Speaks with spooky voice* I predict that we, the fans, are the true winners of the quiz. For we get to watch J and Ben talk about Harry Potter trivia.
The reason it's the Left Hand to swirl the cup is due to your heart being on your Left Side, additionally most people are Right Handed and one could argue that is your open/outer self while your Left Hand is your closed/inner self. So combine the Heart with the inner self is more mystical/future. What's more, a reason for 3 times is because 3 is a common "sacred/magical" number throughout various cultures and associated with Triangles which are one of the most stable/secure shapes.
Just wanted to drop in because I saw you guys did another quiz and I wanted to say I hope you guys never stop doing these. Love playing along with you guys.
A-are you telling me... that they are just “selling candles over on Carlin Brothers Coffee” and not selling Carlin Brothers Candles or Carlin Candles or any other form of alliteration?
15:05 as a former (kinda) teacher's pet, there's always a type of teacher who just puts the hair on your back up and turns you into the most resistant and stubborn version of yourself.
The fact that Scott from Nerdsync works for the Carlin Brothers just makes me happy. Not just because it's 2 youtubers whos content I enjoy, but because Scott's videos (for the last couple years especially) have been SO great, but as a direct result of the amount of effort he has to put into them the turnaround isn't really... quick. So when all the ad-pocalypse stuff was going on and RUclipsrs were getting screwed over he was the only one I follow who I actually felt worried for. Glad to see he's got something stable to support him between videos. Side note, go check out Nerdsync!
Join us LIVE tonight at 6pm Eastern for more Harry Potter trivia!
I will be there!!!!
I'll try and join!! ^w^
I cannot it is my mom’s birthday. I love these trivia nights tho.
SuperCarlinBrothers I CANT WAIT! 😁🙃
I will try to get in
Actually the way Percy suggests taking divination was clever: "it's never too early to start thinking about the future"
Yes.
I agree.
Why is there a new person reading the questions every 4 months now?
Did that position got jinxed like defense against the dark art teacher?
😂 😂 😂
this person did a great job
@@nn-nu8hf he has his own RUclips channel if you're interested. Nerdsync. I love his channel.
Seamus Gorman (aka Tom Riddle) jinxed it, ofc |D
I still want to know what happened to derrick.
My dear Ben doesn’t even fathom winning these quizzes 😂😂 I will always support the underdog Ben, #TeamBen!
" He told Trelawney he saw a Hippogriff, which seems to be the answer she was looking for, as she immediately brought up Buckbeak's impending execution and asked Harry whether the Hippogriff looked headless. Harry, however, stated that Buckbeak looked to be fine and was in fact >flying away
Scott making sure that they got half-points is the most wholesome thing ever
Then they turn around and say they hate all of the above type questions xD
I love that it was Scooby-Doo themed
I thought the best wood for Seer wands question might be Cedar.
Like, See-dar. It helps you cedar future.
Hahahaha
Punny fun.
I was thinking holly because grindlewalds wand has a thorne
ba da dum
.......i see what you did there
The comment about the aquarium reminded me of that time years ago when Ben made a video saying that he was leaving the channel because he got a new job at an aquarium and I was upset until I looked at the date of the video and realized it was uploaded on April first. This comment has very little to do with the video, but it will help with the RUclips algorithm.
J saying ‘yikes’ at the Scoob question WHEN THE OPPORTUNITY TO SAY JINKIES WAS RIGHT THERE
or zoinks!
I need a video series about Scott reading the HP books and reacting to every chapter
Then you might be interested about this podcast.. www.potterlesspodcast.com It is my favourite HP content alongside SCB. I practically binge listened it and I didn't think that was possible. 😄 (My dream is a Potterless SCB collab..😅)
@@annaviragklausz SAME, i am reading the books for the third time alongside him. Its sooo good!
@@annaviragklausz I wonder if SCB know about this podcast. Would be cool to have Mike on the show
We need this, really
YES YES YES
"Today we find out who knows more about Divination"
"Can I move my eyebrows more than you?"
Answering the most IMPORTANT questions!
@@SuperCarlinBrothers Indeed sire!
Who else thinks that The Carlin Brothers sense of Priority is the Best? PLZ LIKE!!!! reply if objection. IF YOU OBJECT... 🤬
@Dawn Everly I do not object but I accidentally replied to your comment when you hadn`t edited it so here I am now. P.S I already liked the comment.
@@A-sketchbook-tiger-lilly If it was, the video would have been released on Thursday..
Scott coming in with so much joy to announce he has a Scooby Doo themed question had me laughing. Too cute, too funny!
Im so jealous of Scott, he has never read any of the books so he can still experience them all "for the first time".. I wish someone would just obliviate the books out of my memory so I can read them for the first time again!
Yea I agree
I also wish they could obliviate the books and I could read the books first and imagine everything for mysel;f first. I didnt get into the books until like book 7 came out so the only one I read fresh was DH.
J: "What is Dobbin?"
ME: "Dobbin is a free house elf"
X'D
Mackenzie Hamilton thats the joke
😂😂😂
huh. Do you mean dobby?
LOL That's how I came to remember 'Dobbin', because when first reading this in the book I was confused and thought they made a typo, and it said 'Dobby' :D
Quiz: what's the old divination standby
Ben: "make it cup"
Me: ... actually I believe that's the old Transfiguration standby
Hahahaha
Well, that's definitely the only thing we see them learning in Transfiguration in the movies.
I shouldn't be laughing this hard. Every time I see it, I laugh again
Hi don't know if this is the right place to post this but I have a theory, That Professor Trelawney is a Cassandra. Cassandra or Kassandra, was a priestess of Apollo in Greek mythology cursed to utter true prophecies, but never to be believed and subsequently others have been cursed the same. Also said that should they receive a vision of the importance they will be unable to remember it as please who suffer this curse often do because they have abused there gift. Just a theory I thought of and thought you might find interesting :)
I think Professor Trelawney's grandmother was a famous seer named Cassandra, so the curse you're talking about could have been inspiration for Trelawney's character
When asked to predict who would win, I didn't predict anything. Does that mean I predicted correctly?
Absolutely
there’s something hilarious about ben automatically assuming he lost
He usually does. I haven't seen all of the J v Bens, but of the ones I've seen (besides this draw), he lost every Harry Potter quiz but one.
"There wasn't as many pencils as I thought in Pennsylvania"
Loved it
We seem to have a pencil shortage (I STILL can't find any in my house!)
Fun fact: Shaggy is more often than not a vegetarian and even states his meat is veggi meat when rattling off ingredients in movies and such (see the first live action scoob movie). Not saying he's wrong in the half point question, as he has eaten meat in some shows and movies (Zombie island) but I thought it was interesting and wanted to share. :3
There was even a BK commercial set up for Shaggy's voice actor to do, but he strait up left the show for a couple years because he felt they didn't respect the character he was playing.
They made Shaggy a vegetarian to honor his original voice actor Casey Kasem who was a a vegetarian. Later after he retired as voice actor for him, the writers deviated from this at random but whenever he played the role, he was a vegetarian.
I was looking for this comment. I could of sworn when they listened the ingredients that shaggy was a vegetariam🤣
Editor: i wanna give you a hint but thats not fair
Ben: *winces* yeaah thats not fair *puppy eyes*
J:*looks lost* yeah thats not fair
Fun fact a "Binky" is the name of a movement that rabbits do where they jump in the air and twist, they do it when they're happy and it's adorable
This is the funnest fact I've ever read that was preceded with "fun fact" 👍🐇
My guinea pig does that it’s called popcorning, because he jumps and pops.. like popcorn lol
~"I was screaming a lot this weekend"
○" For good or bad reasons?"
~" Kind of neutral reason"
■" I WanT a SaNdwIch!"
Also the sound effects at 27:00 are great
Fun fact: when trelawney makes the prediction about when 13 dine, the first to rise is the first to die, that later comes true twice. When they have dinner during Christmas, Ron has Peter pettitgrew in his pocket. The first to rise is dumbledore, who does die first. Second, just after mad eye moody dies, the thirteen people left sit down to drink. Lupin stands up first to go look for moodys body.
Well we're not told if tonks or lupin dies first but that's so sad if its true
I think Scott’s voice is cute. It’d be fun if he and his Scooby Doo questions return in future episodes!
Definition of dobbin
1 : a farm horse
2 : a quiet plodding horse
And it's also sort of the horse name equivalent to what Fido is to a dog.
"constantly screaming"
"for good or bad reasons"
"oh, just neutral reasons"
"I WANT A SANDWICH"🤣🤣❤️❤️
Mood
CONSTANTLY SCREAMING FOR NO REASON
NO YELLING IN THE HOUSE!!!!!
Can you imagine how angry Molly Weasley would be at Charlie if the dragon broke free to attack Harry?
The grossest plant I can think of, is a Rafflesia “Flower” it smells of rotting corpses and attracts flys instead of bees for pollination.
@You're Gonna Hate This that’s cold.
That sounds pretty gross
\
Scott: I have never read the Harry Potter books.
Me: Wait... that's illegal.
Came here to say the same. Like who has not read the Harry Potter books?? Especially on SCB?
Me, a massive Star Wars fan: *insert is it legal/I will make it legal prequel meme here*
wow
my husband hasn’t. I have been trying for years. He isnt much of a reader especially not for pleasure. He will read business related books and such but not novels. He said he would read them when he turns 80. I dont want to wait 30 years so Im trying to wear him down.
Despite his lack of HP knowledge I found this quizzer quite entertaining.
Scot has his own youtube channel, Nerdsync.. it's quite good but more focused on comic books n such
It’s the editter
@@FaithOriginalisme*Scott. Though I did have to check his channel to be sure.
@@owenmartin6203 3 years is a long time to wait for a correction.. lol.. thanks
Fun Fact: Roses don't actually have thorns, they have prickles.
That's cool, what's the difference?
@@ShirinRose size and shape
Scott has such a great personality! He doesn’t know too much about HP, so he creates his own section to contribute to the quiz!
I really like Scott. He makes me feel nice in my not knowing the answer to almost any of the questions but just enjoying the experience
Rewatching this, and his commentary at 11:50 just warms me. Scott is great (:
“Your bottom is better” -Ben Carlin 2020
😄
Imma print that out and tape it to my mirror.
“Because RUclips comments are good for the algorithm”
Ben is so delighted by the half point question, meanwhile J is absolutely fuming
27:15 Ben wrote “a B C 4” and I started laughing so hard
I love being able to see everything they write as they write it 😂😂
27:17
Is anyone else gonna talk about how Ben just wrote a b c and 4 😂
Paha! Thank you so much I didn't see that!
I'm glad someone else noticed! Lol
I’m sad that they don’t do anymore halfway half points, such a cool segment. I wish they use it more often.
There is a crayon factory in pencil vania, does no one else think that is ironic
*illuminati theme
I thought having read Harry Potter would have been a requirement to be employed at super Carlin brothers
Same
Ben's alternatives at the final question:
a)
b)
c)
4)
Omg I didn't even notice X'D X'D
But...why would he unconsciously do that? XD
That’s Ben being Ben
No one:
J, Ben, and Scott: CoMmEnTs aRe gOoD FoR tHe AlGoRItHm
Ben’s cursive “M” was actually an “N”
Am I the only one that misses Tyler when he's gone...? Not that there's anything wrong with this fellow, but Tyler's oaky voice is a bit magical
The editor makes it cool cuz he’s not a book fan so he’s like learning as they guess 😂😂.
Tyler is the best host.
Gilly_Talks nah the first guy was the best host but I forgot his name.
Joseph Arvizu i miss him oh my
@@BDGilly1990 Wrong! Derrick was better.
Ok so I had the stop when Ben said "I was really let down when there wasn't as many pencils as I thought in Pennsylvania" ... My life is complete ❤️
“It’s just kind of a tree”. I had to stop the video for way too long because I was laughing too hard.
Between Scooby Doo and Ben's drawing, this quiz is glorious chaos and I need more
3:36
J: Seamus *Gorman/Finnegan*
Me: I see what you did there!! Nice shoutout! 😉
@Edwina nope
"That's not an issue unless dragons can fly....." 😂
i loved the half point thing, host should always get to throw in a half time half point question of his own choosing haha
Screaming for neutral reasons perfectly encapsulates my entire existence.
“I think you’re so far ahead I can’t catch up”
*tied*
i think it’s so funny how Ben automatically assumes he lost 😂
For some reason I really liked Scott in this quiz, it was wholesomely enjoyable even though he didn’t know that much about HP, he Just seemed to be excited to be apart of it!
it bothers me how j’s ipad holder is holding his ipad
edit: i’m glad ben made him fix it
3:30 Dean Thomas was the one who stabbed random subjects, becease he has no wizarding relative to give him advise.
Okay that's opened up something completely new to me. Do they try every subject before choosing which ones to do...?
Even if I'm wrong, comments are good for the algorithm
@@Marigold11037 Interessting question, in the books they choose the subjects based purely on advise that is given by other people, It would be way better imo if they did do a trial period for each lesson. It would also give the reader more of an understanding of what subjects like arithmancy and muggel studies are.
In the third book ron accurately predicts Harry wining the try wizard tournament a tho indirectly he sees an acorn in Harry's cup which means a wind fall which unsuspected gold and what is the prize for the try wizard tournament 1,000 galleons and galleons are made of gold.
Sorry this comment is really long but please read it.
I love the way Scott speaks and reads questions🤣
"There weren't as many pencils in pensivenia as I was expecting"
That's like year one ben content and I miss it so much
"I didn't read the books." I'm sorry, but what?!
😂 Scott as the quiz master is very entertaining
27:14 I love how Ben put "A B C 4"
And "a" is lower case but "B" and "C" are capital letters :D
I didn't notice that 😂
When he said he was screaming all weekend, for some reason all I thought was him sitting on his bed literally going “AAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHH”.
I feel like this quiz was so off topic and random, but it was so much fun!
Did you know that when a rabbit is very happy they do a "binky"? It is a jump, twist or turn in the air that looks absolutely stunning! We have a rabbit named Inky!
I predict that this will help the algorithm...
The algorithm is just a self fulfilling prophecy. All is chaos...
The algorithm is cake
What fossil did they pick? Whoops wrong channel
Eat this, algorithm!
Hmm I hope it does help the algorithm.
The hidden disappointment in their faces when the host said he didn't read HP.
Actually the host did a great job. Cheers!
You know what would be really fun? An open book J vs Ben so they have all the books in front of them and they have like 20 seconds to find the answers
Love how they tied score its so wholesome
Scott sound like the cutest human being alive. I don't know why, bit he does, also reminds me of drawfee I just love it. Please join us more often Scott
"You guys are freaking amazing" reminded me of "These socks are amazing!"
You could began to use the phrase "These guys are amazing!" always (or sometimes) at the end of the video, when the list of patreons is scrolling on the screen :D
I think this has become my favorite channel on YT
Please make Scott the official quiz master. He’s hilarious and adorable!
Definitely accurate Harry Potter theory: Harry and Ron are actually great seers. My proof, Jk Rowling never said it wasn’t true. 😉😉😉
She has said Ron predicts a lot in the books and has an inclination toward Divination.
I love it when you guys are like that’s wrong and you’re right!!
Re-watching the quiz series! Delighted this video is just as entertaining after multiple viewings as it was the first time 😁
*gazes across the room dreamily. Speaks with spooky voice* I predict that we, the fans, are the true winners of the quiz. For we get to watch J and Ben talk about Harry Potter trivia.
Scott did amazing as the Quizmaster! More of him, please!
Also, I surprised myself with how many of these I knew.
The reason it's the Left Hand to swirl the cup is due to your heart being on your Left Side, additionally most people are Right Handed and one could argue that is your open/outer self while your Left Hand is your closed/inner self. So combine the Heart with the inner self is more mystical/future.
What's more, a reason for 3 times is because 3 is a common "sacred/magical" number throughout various cultures and associated with Triangles which are one of the most stable/secure shapes.
I can't believe it took me *this* long to realize that Ben is now ACTUALLY 'Uncle Ben'.
Scott won my support the second he chose Scooby-Doo for his half-point question. Much good. Very success.
Petition for the next J Vs Ben to be combat.
With swords.
Then you use a time turner to stop it from becoming Supercarlinbrother.
Your approach when asking for comments was refreshing and appreciated. Here you go.
Just wanted to drop in because I saw you guys did another quiz and I wanted to say I hope you guys never stop doing these. Love playing along with you guys.
Moldivort likes trains.
You’re welcome, RUclips algorithm
A-are you telling me... that they are just “selling candles over on Carlin Brothers Coffee” and not selling Carlin Brothers Candles or Carlin Candles or any other form of alliteration?
Petition to make it Carlins Candles
I love Scott in the video. He does the most and it’s amazibg
15:05 as a former (kinda) teacher's pet, there's always a type of teacher who just puts the hair on your back up and turns you into the most resistant and stubborn version of yourself.
I miss, “these socks are amazing”.
Yeah me too
I do too!
Always
Me too!!!!!
I wonder why they did away with it^
The fact that Scott from Nerdsync works for the Carlin Brothers just makes me happy. Not just because it's 2 youtubers whos content I enjoy, but because Scott's videos (for the last couple years especially) have been SO great, but as a direct result of the amount of effort he has to put into them the turnaround isn't really... quick. So when all the ad-pocalypse stuff was going on and RUclipsrs were getting screwed over he was the only one I follow who I actually felt worried for. Glad to see he's got something stable to support him between videos.
Side note, go check out Nerdsync!
I adore Scott. More of him, please
Ben: "If it rhymes with cat it's fine."
Me: Brings a bat.
You can tell J watches MDB: "Comments are good for the RUclips algorithm"
Was just listening to today’s podcast, now I get a J vs. Ben😄
Same
Brianna Nice :D
Same xx
It's now, J&Ben vs Scott(whose never read the Harry Potter Books)
No spoilers! Haven’t listened yet
Love the halfway half-point idea! Also loved that it was Scooby-Doo!
The half way half point was delightfully absurd, thank you scott!
You need to have candles that smell like what Harry and Hermione smelled in the amortentia.
I would love them to have a little quiz that tells you your amortentia smell and on its basis they could produce a personalised candle for you ✨
Kinga T that would be cool
Samantha August I can’t remember but didn’t hermione’s have Ron’s hair so that wouldn’t be that good.....
@@kinga3731 that’s a great idea!
@@pheonix__kit-kat897 hermiones was freshly mowed grass, the smell of new parchment, and ron.
It was Dean Thomas who stabbed randomly at the paper!