J vs Ben: ULTIMATE Harry Potter DARK ARTS Quiz
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 янв 2019
- Go to www.audible.com/SCB or text SCB to 500-500 to get a free book, 2 free Audible Originals, and a 30 day free trial!
Today J and Ben face off in the ultimate Pottermore Harry Potter Dark Arts Trivia Quiz to see who is the master of the dark arts!
Play along with us: www.pottermore.com/features/u...
Super Carlin Brothers Merch ►► bit.ly/2oDIxOL
J vs Ben ►► bit.ly/2I5xHee
Harry Potter Theories ►► bit.ly/2K2Rtru
Super Carlin Gaming ►► bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
BECOME A SUPER CARLIN FRIEND➜ / supercarlinbrothers
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
FOLLOW US:
V L O G➜ / jonathancarlin
T W I T T E R➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
I N S T A G R A M➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
F A C E B O O K➜ / supercarlinbrothers
G A M I N G ➜ bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
P A T R E O N ➜ / supercarlinbrothers
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Want to send us something?
Super Carlin Brothers
PO Box 4339
Roanoke, Virginia 24015
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Business Inquiries Only: carlinbrosrtp@gmail.com
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Every time you give us a thumbs up a Narwhal gets its horn! (maybe..) 
Кино
Who is your favorite Death Eater?!
Robert Pattinson
Bellatrix Lestrange.
Antonin Dolohov.
Why?
Because I like his name.
Bellatrix lestrange
Severus Snape (Bellatrix after him)
I think in the books the reason the location where Tom Riddle's diary is from is mentioned is because Harry does recognize it as a "muggle" neighborhood or something like that and it adds to the mystery of who tom riddle was. harry wonders if he must have been muggle-born or something i believe
Yes, exactly, which, in turn serves to trusting the diary, since Riddle is just like them and couldn't possibly be the Heir of Slytherin; little did they know that Voldemort was nuts from early on. Fun fact: tere's no Vauxhall Road in London, just a bridge.
Yes it is mentioned
@@specialbudgies4217 so if there's no Vauxhall Road, why did the diary say that? Could it have existed during Riddle's time? Or did he make a fake name? Which doesn't make sense, he would've wanted a magical place i think
@@adeeasrauf1710 i don't think every place in a fictional universe has to be real
Waiiiit, Suitor of Helena Ravenclaw should technically be correct as well because he kills himself after killing her.
Jen Parry ikr
mmm. I'd wouldn't really consider him one, as he was rejected by her. Doesn't one cease to become a viable option for her, the second she decides he isn't for her? I guess what I'm saying is that by the time he killed her, he was no longer a suiter, but a dangerous fanatic?
@@coolguyhino92 ehhhh I have heard both versions of suitor in other stories so the confusion is understandable (I also don’t know which is correct). One version of suitor is someone trying to woo a person regardless of rejection.
@@coolguyhino92 A suitor is just a man pursues a relationship with a woman. The fact that she wasn't interested has absolutely no bearing on the fact that he was a suitor.
@@thegreatfusili4673 Read the previous comments. There is more than one direct definition of a suitor.
17:03 Chamber of Secrets, chapter 13, page 231 for me:
“Harry turned to the back cover of the book and saw the printed name of a variety store on Vauxhall Road, London.”
“‘He must’ve been Muggle-born,’ said Harry thoughtfully. ‘To have bought a diary from Vauxhall Road...’”
How long did this take you to find this???
@@danhalen3775 not long a quick google search will find it
I always thought that Tom Riddle's diary was a normal, muggle diary. You know, until he made it EVIL.
almond potato and that ‘s exactly what it is:) it was a simple diary he bought in London that he made into a Horcrux. It was his first and kind of a “test Horcrux”, and the next one are precious items
@@noemicavada6795 Yes. So, because it is a normal diary turned EVIL, there probably is some sort of identification of where it was made. Also, where did Tom get that diary? I mean, whenever I try to find a good one they are always pink and sparkly.
almond potato try Vauxhall Road😂
Noemi Cavada It wasn't a test.
Ben Tarr I wrote *kinda of a “test horcrux”* and I put the word test on quite because with that I meant that being his first horcrux he didn’t have the idea of putting it his soul into precious objects
So, who else would totally listen to the Harry Potter series narrated by DK with J and Ben doing the character voices?.... This needs to happen.
Danae McCune omg even if it was like a livestream or something that would be SO COOL
yeah cause it's such a great idea for these Americans to mispronounce the British names.
Dan 97 yea! Glad you agree it would be awesome
Nah, the Jim Dale versions already exist and are perfect. Plus, SCB couldn't make any money from such a series.
Oh I want this so much
Technically the Bloody Baron was a suitor of the Grey Lady and he killed himself. So Ben is right.
tcshack701 what does suitor mean
@@RedEveTillDawn A suitor means someone who wishes to marry a particular person. In this case the bloody baron wished to marry the grey lady.
But he also kills Helena Ravenclaw
@@ElurosAthena So both of them are right.
@@eccentrichorse11 yep!
10:51
It's says in Prisoner of Askaban that
"He pointed his middle finge as his index was missing"
Or something like that
But in the movie they say pinky (i saw it in french and they say "il ne restait qu'un doigt. Le petit doigt!" (All was left of him was a finger. A pinky.) I also read the books long ago so I assumed in the movie they would stay true to the book
Azkaban*
Majin Buu bruh, this was a year ago
Édith Gagnon well movies aren’t canon sooooo
@@Zenith_682 Yes they are
"Harry only uses two spells" LOOOOOL....... Thank God for Hermione...teaching us new spells throughout the years
@Cozy he knows them yes but all he really uses are expeliamus(sorry for that butcher) and the patronus charm
Don B but doesn’t he stun ?
@Cozy My personal favorite is "Accio Hagrid!"
@@donb7519 he also teaches stupify.
Cant remember if he did reducto in the books, Ginny is practicing it in the movie
Well if you read the book you’d know that Harry uses more than two spells
🎵 *_Just a spoonful of sugar helps the Dementors go down..._* 🎵
Thats Mary Poppins you all
@@pain2561
Y'all*
i love that so much you made my day!!!!!!!
yes
this actually works really well for 'skele-gro'
You guys should do a incantation spelling bee!
Engineerism not a bad idea
I think you mean a SPELLing bee
Wingardium Leviosa .. Ascendio descendio, avacadava ,
Or rank the chapters in the Harry Potter books
BRILLIANT idea
On the question about Peter’s missing finger: it is indeed specified in prisoner of Azkaban just after Remus and Sirius turn him back into a human. Peter was accusing Sirius of something and pointed at him, but it says specifically he was pointing with his middle finger because of his missing index finger.
Voldemort*AVADA KEDAVRA
Harry* EXPELLIARMUS
Avada Kedavra* DO I LOOK LIKE A JOKE TO YOU
Voldemort: AVADA KEDABRA
Hermione : stop stop stop your going to take someone’s eye out
AVADA KEDAVRA!!
Lord Voldemort Harry nose you are dead
kk Gaskin lol
Yes.
I like how they only just realised that Riddles Diary was a muggle book.
Especially as it is discussed pretty .edu as soon as Harry finds it in the book!
*discussed as soon as it is found
so he put a spell on it after getting in Hogwarts ?
Lauriti well it’s not that he puts a spell on it; he turns it into a Horcrux, so all the communication and possession is coming from the piece of his soul inside.
@@natashabaer2533 oooh I thought that BEFORE making it a horcrux he would have put a spell on it so he could write and nobody but him could read it. And after it becomes a horcrux, you could "comunicate" with that piece of him.
Quite an odd horcrux .... right? a muggle diary that served him no purpose or meant nothing to him?
Technically the suitor of the grey lady is the bloody baron and he killed himself so...
ninjagirl226 That was my thought also. He actually killed himself in addition to the Grey Lady. That should have been a “check all that apply” question.
Steve Primmer killing himself instantly after killing her because of the guilt. I love this little few lines in deathly hallows book, can really imagine the scene haha.
DRACO!!!!!! I LOVE DRACO !!!!
PS. Draco was actually the second best in their year. Hermoine always beat him. As an adult he would study alchemy for fun.
I see what you did there. Don't forget helping summon Savatar lol
alchemy and forensic science
Bunny Cortez Then he changed his name to Julian and got a PHD in Alchemy. He then got controlled by the god of speed for a lil bit
Will yeah he also disappeared right afterwards for some reason
I get it
The fact that Dark Marks are red is mentioned in Goblet of Fire. I re read it last week so I remeber. Normally I wouldn't know. As for Pettigrews finger it says "he was pointing with his middle because his index was missing" in Prisoner of Azkaban.
Yup 👍🏼
ok it's embarrassing how excited I get when I know an answer they don't lol
I got the Vauxhall Road question right lol but I saw all the options and for some reason it looked really familiar
Same! It seems dumb but I’m always like yaaaaaaaayyyyyy
Storribook same but I got it right without the options
Same, but I feel bad as I just finished a read through and I know some of those answers were a quick one line. Pettigrew's finger? It's a single line that says he pointed with the middle finger next to a missing index. Vauxhall road? It's just Harry commenting to himself that it's a muggle shop. Red Dark Mark? I believe Snape says it grew darker red all year before burning black that night. This really was an indepth quiz after Q9
Yep. They couldn’t hear Cole!
Ooft that simultaneous 'this is Pottermore' at 25:10 was filled with so much dispair
On Harry Potter Wiki...
‘ An inactive Dark Mark appears as a faint mark on the inner part of the left forearm, similar to that of "a vivid red tattoo"; an active one is jet black. ‘
Could not find any reference to it on Pottermore
It's in GOF when Voldemort calls the Death Eaters
Pretty sure this is always mentioned in the books. How the mark is pretty much just a faint scar on luscious and others until voldemort regains his power and the it starts to itch and turn black
In goblet, karkarof goes into a potions lesson and Harry sees that karkarof shows snape something red on his forearm. So it mentions it
In Goblet of Fire, on page 645, Harry sees Wormtail’s mark and describes it as “a vivid red tattoo”, then Voldemort touches it and Harry sees that “it had turned jet black”.
28/30
Your result:worrying
Oh dear... you know a lot about the dark arts don’t you? Me we advise staying away from dark arts textbooks and invest in a basket of puppies instead?
Lol ok pottermore
27/30 (me)
I got 28/30 too😅
0/30 My memory is just the worst.
I just misread the title as “dank arts”, am I watching too many memes?
Quite possibly. But there's no such thing as watching too many memes.
Definately need more memes in your life: it is the only cure.
You can never go wrong with memes comrade
Memes are art so I understand the mistake
Ah yes, that was my favorite class. Defense against the *Dank* Arts.
I always assumed that Dark Marks were gray when they were inactive and darkened to black as Voldemort came closer to regaining a body. It makes more sense to go from gray to black as it darkens than it does to go from red to black, unless it's just a red outline when it's inactive.
Chris Concannon I always assumed it was red kinda like irritated or scared skin
@@morgynkivimaa8179 That makes sense to me.
It talks about this in Goblet of Fire when Voldemort uses Wormtail’s to summon everyone.
I was with Ben on this one, since they are similar to human tattoos which, when they are faded, have ablue-ish colour.
I always thought they weren't visible when not activated, because you would think that SOMEONE would've noticed that all captured death eaters had the same tattoo on their forearm
If it walks like a horse, if it talks like a horse...it probably summons.
🤣🤣🤣
27:56 DK’s laugh is priceless
love these hp vs videos ⚡
hey, you're cool, wanna get bubble tea?
Love how he still hasn't forgiven you for wadiwasi
I love how J will literally just repeat the question after Derek says it 😂😂
I knew the Vauxhall Rd answer as I was listening to Chamber of Secrets today! It’s important because Harry realises Riddle was raised by muggles and therefore feels more sympathetic towards him not wanting Hogwarts to close as he too feels like Hogwarts is more of a home to him than the Dursleys
I must not tell lies professor - Harry Potter
Best burn in the series
will crosby no it’s
No need me to call professor, sir.
@@saqibsiddiqi1355 true that's also good sassy Harry is the best but I like Snape much more then umbrige and Harry uses "i must not tell lies" when he talks to scrimgor when he was try to get Harry as a propaganda tool
@will crosby definitely not as good the second time he says it in part 1.
@@saqibsiddiqi1355 I think you mean "No need to call me sir, professor" not "No need *me* to *call* *professor* sir"
@@40wd oh wow, I just autocorrected it in my mind; I hadn't even noticed
HAPPY BIRTHDAY SNIVELLUS!!! 🤩
P.s. I remember Pettigrew pointing with his middle finger in PoA, cause, you know, his index was missing😆
Yup
Another small detail that couldve helped them is that lupin says voldemort, so it couldnt be him for the quote question!
now that you mention about it, he did!
MrEevee true 😃
Harry: He must've been Muggle-born to have bought a diary from Vauxhall Road.
Honestly, don't you two read?
I know what you mean. There are times when I have serious doubts Ben has read then.
I think it’s just they have so many details to remember that some just slip away
well i can't imagine it's easy to remember every detail
@@emilyrae158 yh lol
wasn't one important part of the diary the fact that its muggle-made...
You so sneaky giving yourself a point 10:21
done out of habit lol
It was two points! 10:17
Sneaky Slytherins 😏
Vivian Silveira ... No it wasn't...
I saw,and it looked so natural
Technically during Voldemort's reign there was no Defense Against the Dark Arts class....its just Dark Arts
Also FINALLY A TIMER
I need to reread the books again, it’s been a fat minute since I have.
I got Vauxhall Road correct, but I had the benefit of the multiple choice.
The first question was actually who never taught HARRY D.A.D.A ? Then whichever Carrow was on the list was a good answer since harry wasn't around when the Carrows were in Hogwarts
Also when returning to Hogwarts weren't we told that the Carrows were straight up teaching "Dark Arts" classes (and using it as an excuse to torture the students or possibly get them to cast curses and the like on each-other? might be misremembering that last bit), rather than DADA? So even if Harry had been at the school at that point, it still would've been a valid answer.
tpbloomfield no because they never taught him
I like how they tried to trick us by putting Moody in the list.
@@justgiz I know. It almost got me.
@@justgiz ikr? I was like is this a trick cause technically moody never taught him
AY! I got Vauxhall Road correct.
I just finished Chamber of Secrets again, so it was “Pretty Obvious.”
I read this in Lockhart's actor voice xD
How is J not a Ravenclaw? I’ve watched several quizzes and he always seems to remember the smallest details in articles he-read 2 years ago!
@@XxGreymoonxX No sorry, you are thinking of Ben, And Ben always get Ravenclaw or Huffelpuff. But J lands in Slitherin anytime.
Ibahalii * he always wants to get into slytherin though sooooooo...
Also Louisa Coyote, they always listen to the books over and over again
The other houses are not downright dumb either.
He does but he's still a slytherin
17:22 "Hello diary" - J flirting with a horcrux 😂😂😂😂
These videos are my favorite on this channel and I look forward to them every single post! The friendly competition as well as watching you guys struggle through fun trivia just makes these videos the highlight of my day!
Every time I see that Pottermore has a new quiz I'm like "I can't wait for J and Ben to do this!"
Agreed
Agreed! I like this channel okay but when I see a J vs. Ben, it jumps right to the top of my watching list.
So on my channel I just reviewed the Gaunt Horcrux Ring. And in that video I said that my birthday is Jan 20th so I am getting a Noble Collection Wand. And towards the end of the video there is a poll about which one i should get. Please help me out and vote!! (sorry bout the promo but it’s urgent!)
What a nice comment. Reading this just made me really happy. :)
J vs Ben never gets old
Those are all muggle places in London, you are correct!
My favorite Death Eater is Severus Snape. You will be missed Professor Snape....😭
HARRY!!!
Always
U love snape♡♡♡ he had a good life......
I don't understand why people like Snape so much. He was a screwed up puppy.
Allan Rickman(sorry if I spelled it wrong) played snape so well. He will be missed...always
I’m reading the Harry Potter books for the first time (because I got them for Christmas, I’ve watched the movies though) and I really want to watch this video but I want to take all the Pottermore quizzes (and watch your videos) AFTER I’ve read the books. 😂😅 So, imma just drop a like. 👍
Ima tell you whats going to happen.
You will put it into your watch later playlist or an extra playlist, read the books and forget to watch the video after.
Oh man. You're in for such a treat! I reread the books constantly. And I love them every time. But it's never the same as the first time. ENJOY! You'll discover the movies got quite a bit wrong. On top of the vast many things left out entirely. SPOILER... Harry dies. 🤣
Tyler Messer Hahaha, yes I am enjoying them so far!
Disco Jellyfish Nah, I’m subbed to ‘em. 😜
Enjoy your first time reading them! They're amazing.
J is terrible at scoring himself correctly. He shouldn’t have given himself that point for the colour of an inactive dark mark! :D
HitchikerHobbit glad I’m not the only one who notices because it started to bother me at question 14. 😅
I was scrolling the comments to see if I was the only one who noticed.
he does it alllllllll the time
He did!? Wait... that means his score is 21 which MEANS!! I did better than him. I am the probable next best buddy of Bellatrix on the good side if that is even possible. I am too kind and too warm hearted. I could never hurt anyone while she enjoys it. I just know two much thanks to Harry and Pottermore and Fanficksions. My score was 22/30.
@@elanorallmann same but i did not use multiple choice
I love how people read older books and papers saying "wow, they were so good at predicting what technology would be like!", but they forget...… IT'S THE INSPIRATION FOR WHAT WE HAVE.
It isn’t
Harry uses 4 spells that I can remember... Expelliarmus, Sectumsemra, Expecto Patronum and Accio
Emma Marani you forgot Stupify-the stunning spell. Harry uses that a lot.
And to be fair, he only used Sectumsempra twice-once on Draco, and then a failed attempt on Snape.
He also uses imperio i think
@@trentyoung6791 tries but fails in the battle of the ministry in the order of the phenox on bellitrx and she taunts him telling him he has to mean it
alex wood He uses it in Gringotts to get access to a vault
Also, lumos
18:37 Derek struggling to say names that to a Brit are so normal!
And yes they make reference to the writer must have been muggle-born to get a diary from Vauxhall road!
IKR I found it so funny
Superstitious people: *_dabbling in black magic again?_*
Isn't that the coolest kind of magic? Without dark magic we wouldn't have legends like Ancalagon the Black
@Natalie Emelia Mitchell it can since Mr. Bigger Than A Mountain is indeed a magical creature.
Kremit the frog is everywhere! How does he apparate so quickly?
for a sec i thought this said "dabbing in dark magic" and i just-
lol
I love Ben’s reaction to his 16th point 😂
6:10: Loved how Ben says they're gonna inevitably make a series on Potter. I've been dreaming of a GoT level series on HP which follows the canon strictly and doesn't leave out anything from the books(in fact has added material courtesy JKR).
Tough one for #teamben. Keep the faith everyone
How did they not know Helena's name? She's such a facinating character, and one of my favourites, even if she isn't there for long.
Ahem... men generally just remember faces?
And to be fair, he killed himself as well.
And Riddle's notebook, how can they be surprised it's a muggle book? I remembered specifically it saying Vauxhall inside
Her ghost is mentioned in book 1. "A tall long haired female ghost glided past," or something like that.
They did, they were just confused by their friend's username, it could have been the name of her OC eg
11:23 Ben had the same argument in the redemption quiz when he got it wrong again 😂
Derek I think the word you were searching for, for Harry's lack of spell use is versatile. And Bellatrix is my favorite Death Eater.
Isn’t versatile meaning changeable or something
My guess of "Destroying Horcruxes 101" wasn't very good it turns out.
Omg Des I'm subbed to you as well haha, just watched your newest spoiler vid before this, love your channel
Ew what’s the filth doing here
My guess was "Magik Most Foul" but I think Hermione read that trying to figure out what a Horcrux actually is.
My guess was magic most evile because i recognized that. Also hi des
So, both Jay got the answer to the last question is wrong. The quiz had the right answer but only because it omitted James. This is actually an error that the J K Rowling made in Goblet that has bugged me for years. The correct answer is actually "Cedric, Frank, Bertha, James, Lily", which is NOT the order that Harry's parents died in.
I quote "And now another head was emerging from the tip of Voldemort's wand... and Harry knew when he saw it who it would be... he knew as though he had expected it from the moment when Cedric had appeared from the wand... knew because the man appearing was the one he'd thought of more than any other tonight." And then, a paragraph later, "'You're mother's coming...' he said quietly. 'She wants to see you... It will be all right... hold on...'"
Although, it's possible that J K Rowling fixed this in later prints of the book. Anyhow, just a fun fact. Jay wins either way. (Sorry Ben!)
It was fixed in later versions because of fans pointing it out to jk Rowling on how she explains the thing and it reversing in order of last spells cast and since Lily was killed after James she should have come out before him
Yup, you're right. I didn't realize that this was fixed in reprints. I've always read and listened to the original versions, so I had no idea. I wonder if anything else has been changed since...
@@loopkill there were quite a few things fixed that I can't name off the top of my head. You can look them up though ^^
10:52 in prisoner of Azkaban I vividly remember for some reason the book saying that Peter pointed at something with his middle finger, because the index was missing
I think the only DADA teacher that was actually good was lupin. Lol
Lupin as well as Harry, who was the true DADA teacher during Order of the Phoenix (despite not actually being an actual teacher at the time).
28:07 SCB will now stand for Super Close (to every answer) Brothers!
You guys need to sort Marvel characters into Hogwarts houses...please!
dustin tirey little did you know, little did you know
I love the J vs Ben videos, but I think its so funny when doing the scripted parts like the intro and outro because when Ben isn't talking he looks like he's just listening to J but when Ben is talking J looks likes he's impatiently waiting to talk again.
binge watching these quiz videos haha
Change the colour of the timer! So we can see it too =)
The Baron kills Helena because she won't visit her dying mother, he's come to take Helena to Rowena, but when she refuses to come he loses his temper and kills her (and himself).
27:57 Derek, WTH is that laugh?!?! 😂😂
9:52 I'm currently listening to Goblet of Fire and after Voldemort comes back, he uses Wormtail's dark mark to summon everyone and before he does that, it's described as a vivid red tattoo.
I just checked in "Prisoner of Azkaban" Peter Pettigrew has a missing ringfinger (left hand) not a missing
index finger. So you again got confused by the movies. :)
Edit: To be clear: I meant his ringfinger is missing if you look at his hand. (sorry for bad grammar I'm german)
the movie confused me there too
But Ben wrote Ringfinger... Or do you mean in the Prisoner of Azkaban movie they changed it?
I remember distinctly that Harry describes Pettigrew pointing with his middle finger because he's missing his index. Maybe that's in a later book though, so JKR got confused herself.
@@masha7377 Yes he points with his middle finger at Sirius in the Shrieking Shack as he has no index!
In the movie version in spanish is the pinky. I don’t get why so many finger changes are necessary xD
The final question is kind of a trick question because in the first edition of Goblet James comes out of the wand before Lily and they changed it in later editions.
‘Where in London was Tom Riddle’s diary from?’
*laughs from england*
(And it’s pronounced like Vox-hall)
Hey Ben your answer at 14:55 is correct!! He also kills himself after killing Helena
Btw, love this channel!
What to call what happens after question 10...How about The Thief's Downfall...
Wait. Is Ben now officially Ravenclaw?
(Does victory dance if answer is yes)
i got the question of the diary wrong and i work on vauxhall road lol :(
16:11 the correct answer is...
Waddiwasi!
The "Ender" series with the original 4 book and with the "Shadow" series is my favorite sci-fi universe.
"I think it is impossible to really understand somebody, what they want, what they believe, and not love them the way they love themselves."
Speaker for the Dead
Orson Scott Card is a genius. His imagination give him realisation about fundamental things. He was right about the direction computers evolved. I believe he is right about almost everything he wrote. He gave me insights into human nature 3 decades ago, and so far they all turned out to be correct. Also, I am an astrophysicist. His sci-fi is truely scientific. His idea about the Parck shift is genius. His ansible theory is possible. His phylosophy about the nature of "the universe, life and everything" is the perfect fusion of science and religion. The idea for FTL is mindboggling.
I think the Ender series are a "must read" for everybody who loves sci-fi.
It is a hard read. Those who just want action, but dont care about backstoryes, consystency, immersion and scientific imagination, those usually find them boring.
To me these books are among the very best.
Did you know there is a movie of it?
I am going back and rewatching these J vs. Ben videos because I love them but I wonder how long it actually takes them to film
The first question is actually incorrect, moody comes back and teaches defense against the dark arts for the end of the year after the triwizard tournament
Did Dolores Umbridge even teach anything? I always thought her approach was textbook only.
@@jeffburnham6611 she really didn't, but she was still technically a dado teacher
Not in the books. Harry meets the real Moody for the first time in the Dursleys' kitchen.
Defense Against the Dark Arts after Crouch Jr was caught was cancelled for the rest of the year. Moody never taught the class
Who would have thought, JORDAN makes an appearance! 😊
When?!?!
I'm watching the video now but tried using the thumbnails
Jenny Schumacher, I heard her, somewhere half-way. 15:20
Am I the only one who says hey brother back at my phone 🤪
nope, i always do
...always
Same!
Always 😝
Doe
"Heyyyyyy brotherrrrrrrrrr"
i could watch these all day
Video starts at 3:18
The new term is the Carlin curse
incantation: hey brother!
30:20 J's answer is actually wrong. James comes out first and tells Harry that his mother is coming. In the movie it's fixed but canon is based on books.
I know! That always annoyed me in the books!
@Laziness4 yes they did!
@Laziness4I just checked my copy and saw the correction. The one I originally read from was a library book, so I assume it was an earlier one. Thanks for telling me that!
@Laziness4 i now need to check my book. Lol
I used yo have an older version.. tbis one is the corrected version.. good to know. :) i never realized before
I got "Avada Kedavra" it's "Worrying" Pottermore has requested that I stay away from Dark Arts textbooks and invest in a basket of puppies instead! XD
11:04 i knew it was index because i remember when i read the books i found it hilarious that he had to point at everything with the middle finger( i was 10)
Andrew Sokatch I’m 14 and I find it hilarious
I got 22/30 which was "Death Eater in Waiting." I'm a Hufflepuff! How can I help that I have a mind like a steel trap and remember all this stuff!
Exactly. Once you 'found' the books/Pottermore facts, you couldn't lose them. ;)
@@Tam_Miri 🤦♂️
@@Tam_Miri But seriously good one.
welcome to the dark side - i mean dark arts!
@Edward B Massey Get. Out.
The Carrow's taught the dark arts not defense against the dark arts.
Oh that’s true!!!!
Og yeah
Also never taught Harry at all, so it's still a valid question
@@SheepdogSmokey true
I know this is an older video but you guys really help me get through tough times
As soon as I saw the thumbnail I knew it was Morsmorde. Not sure how I knew that from memory but I’m happy I did :)
20:00 LUPIN SAYS VOLDEMORT NOT HE-WHO-MUST-NOT-BE-NAMED
But Karkaroff shouldn't have said "Dark Lord"?
@@Salvation393 Yeah that's why I presumed it wasn't Karkaroff!
@@Salvation393 hmm that's true
That was how I determined it wasn't Dumbledore or Barty Crouch Jr.
@@kateworkman921 But didn't Barty Crouch Jr say the Dark Lord too!?
18:41 when Americans try to pronounce Tottenham Court Road always makes me laugh. (Tottnum court road)
Can we appreciate Derek's laugh around the 27/28 minute mark xD such a contagious laugh!
When Harry first finds Tom Riddle's diary he figures he must have been muggle born because the diary was from Vauxhall Road.
So I think that was an early indicator of Riddle's past, before GoF...
Dark Arts
Don't become a Death Eater
Spaghetti Batman hey I haven’t saw u in a while! Now I remember!
I’ve heard Draco was top of the class after Hermione but I don’t know if it’s true
Originals by The Mario's in chamber Malfoy is getting roasted by his dad about doing badly in his 1st year exams, so he definitely wasn’t then, but I guess he could of improved.
The Mario's is your channel photo you guys and Shane
@@afrokid3890 I thought his dad was roasting him for not scoring as high as a muggle born I:E Hermione? Which would put him second in the class
Forest Grump Yeah that’s how I remember it
When Draco is asking about he Hand of Glory, he is told it is the best friend of thieves and plunderers. His dad gripes that he hopes his son would amount to more than a thief or plunderer, but if his grades don’t improve he may not. I always assumed that his grades got better since he was made a prefect, but compared to the other Slytherin guys in his year, it wouldn’t take much to outperform everyone else.
It’s funny how baffled they get when talking about something British 😂
20:03 Well you have to understand that Lupin does not says He Who Must Not Be Named instead he says his name Voldemort. Dumbledore also says Voldemort and barty crouch jr. refers to him as the Dark Lord so Karkaroff remains.