I think it's going to go to S*** and them some, for the townsfolk. Victor will disappear for three days and come back like a creepy Jesus. Some from colony house will resort to cannibalism (maybe season finale). Tabitha - paintings spoiler from the trailer could suggest Boyds wife was right and she needs to go back in full terminator mode to save them all.
I think those wood figures are the ones who moved Boyd and Sarah on season one but were unable to move them since it was a wood cabin instead of a tent, I theorize that they will be heavily connected to the lady in the kimono
ok so heres some opions i have on some of the mysteries. Fae is scottish for "from". the entity causeing all of this is a fae or fairy like folk creature. I think the stones are something like a wardstone in scottish folklore as well. Fae often kidnap children and even replace them with their own, akin to changlings. I think this entity has been around a long time, possibly made a deal with humans in the past and was either slighted or was the trickster type that turned on the humans it made a deal with. theres definetly some kidnaping of children involved and being used in some ritual that sustains it or gives it power. I think the symbol is indictive or a rune that deals with anchoring a point to many other places in the world, a kind of weave that lets it trap people from all over the world. hence the random point of origins. evil towns people are most like things akin to changlings i mentioned earlier. used to catch people offguard at first to torture them easily.
Kenny volunteered though. Another highlight to the type of person he is. Even when hating Sara last season when it came down to it he couldn’t hurt her or just watch her kill herself
And when Kenny comes back to town he'll find out her mother is *likely* dead or horribly injured, there's no more food for everyone and the monsters are smart, luring Boyd into a trap becuase of what he said ('you don't break me')
@@lordogxvii6034 I feel as if he volunteered solely because of Jim’s persistence to find Tabitha. If he would have stopped and thought like Boyd said, he would’ve realized what he said when him and Kenny were in the woods not protecting their families(that they shouldn’t have gone out there.) Thankfully Fatima was there to save Jim’s kids, but Kenny wasn’t there to protect his mom and I’m sure he’s gonna garner the guilt his mom felt about his dead’s death
Finally a review channel that just doesn't recap the episode we all watched! I love the easter eggs you highlight and linking them back to previous episodes. Thank you for taking the time.
HAve you realised there are soooooooooooooo many new ones now reviewing. Makes it harder to find the good ones. Getting a bit monotonous watching the same thing over and over again from different perspective. Lucky i found this one back again too 😅
@@bandit_six5418 Yeah, like... According to Harold Perrineau, this is not going to break him, this is going to make him pissed and go on the offensive. Kenny's gonna fucking break.
@@LampDoesVideogameNope. The trailer for next episode shows Kenny ready to go against the creatures. No tears. No sobbing. Just ready to take the fight to the monsters.
Am I the only one who thinks Fatima could have easily used a sink or bucket to be slightly nauseous in rather than making someone wait an hour to take a pee in a shared house?
That was annoying but i suppose she couldnt think reasonably because of her stress about her monster fetus. Tabathas actions also annoyed me for some reason. She didnt even check the date to see if time moves different inside the pocket dimension.
That person could have tried another bathroom. I suffer from nausea and the toilet is the best. Puking into things makes me more sick cause I have to look at it
Am I the only one that's questioning their stupidity, Going to get the farm Animals, It was blatantly a trap, when they could have left them they would have just been roaming somewhere,Where would they go, I'll hope the writers don't start making the characters make stupid decisions. It would turn me off to the show.
They had to get the animals that was the only source of food. Plus the monsters would have killed the other animals if they didn’t come out you see they killed the cow.
I understand that they get food from the crops they grow, but mind you, for 2 whole season I’ve never seen any barn animals, neither have I heard anyone talking about them. And always wondered where are they getting fresh water and juice from. Then all of a sudden in season there are barn animals ????
@@ExoticSpartain this episode they clearly said the soil was poisoned and that is why the crops were all rotten. They have shown the animals in other seasons. Boyd clearly stated in season 1 that one day he was in the woods and found them roaming. They have mentioned the animals several times actually.
So my theory is that they let Boyd live for the same reason victor is the way he is and survived so long, they even tell us with "we won't kill you, we want you broken". What if the monsters can't hurt anyone with a vital role in completing the "quest" so they emotionally break everyone instead to ensure they can't finish. I also think that's why they tried to have sarah try to Ethan, i think Ethan can assume victors role in the quest and be able to finish it. Let me know if I'm crazy.
Time doesn't flow differently between Fromville and the real world, Marielle mentions that Kristie had been missing for months by the time she arrived in the town which matches up with Kristie's experience. Victor got there in the 1970's and is in his late 50's, that aligns perfectly. They mention that the town has been in a state of perpetual summer for as long as anyone (Victor) can remember. The changing season isn't reflective of time passing, rather the environment changing and evolving to the townspeople
It’s true that From has never explicitly suggested that time flows differently between Fromville and the real world. There are key indicators that time aligns between the two. For instance, Marielle mentions that Kristie had been missing for months when she arrived in the town, which matches up with Kristie’s experience inside Fromville, confirming that time is consistent across both realms( Den of Geek Victor, who arrived in the 1970s and is now in his late 50s, also supports this theory. His age and timeline are consistent with the real world’s passage of time, further implying that there is no temporal distortion. However, what is unique is the town’s state of perpetual summer, as noted by Victor. This seems to suggest that while time moves forward normally, the town’s environment evolves independently, possibly as a mechanism tied to the supernatural forces at play The changing seasons or lack thereof reflect less about the passage of time and more about how the town itself manipulates or responds to its inhabitants. This could be a way to psychologically disorient the residents while keeping them physically in sync with the outside world.
My husband and I binged both seasons for the past few weeks and was so sad it ended! We had no idea season 3 was dropping just a few days later! Lol great timing!
Everybody has weird things happening to them individually, but yet nobody shares their experiences with nobody else and when they do, they act like they’re crazy and nobody believes them which is really odd because look where they’re at if somebody told me they saw weird things how could you not believe them?
That's kind of my biggest problem with the show, but then the inverse will happen sometimes and arguably make things worse. Like, the worst part for me happened in season 2 when Boyd gets the worms and nobody sees it until a moment of convenience arises and then suddenly people can see them. Just weak writing for an otherwise very interesting show.
Weird stuff happens in real life all the time, and for many things that we actually can't explain and no one does research into these weird/unexplainable things/ppl/etc. because people thinks its pointless and will call you crazy, its extremely accurate of how human society has been since human society has started, and all these people come from human society, where even when there is weird stuff going on, your weird that you experience will still be considered crazy instead . also in our world almost everyone results to using Occam's razor to answer complex situations/things for unexplainable things, so they try to fit in. I'm not saying im above this level of thinking, but next time you ever see something weird, go and start telling people, and look at how they look at you. Have a great day/night
@@nelsonthatleast answer a few questions . What were the insects? What about the worms Who was the soldier locked up Where are they What was the music box Who or what are the kids What are the monsters? Are they people, were they regular people or prior townsfolk? Who was talkin on the radio Whos the boy in white What’s with the light house What’s the symbols on the cave walls How did the worms kill the monster Why do the talisman work? There’s atleast 10 more unanswered questions..they gotta answer a few
I’ve been starting to believe that Victor is (perhaps unconsciously) the mastermind behind everything. There are too many signs; he predicts events before they happen, he’s been there longer than anyone, his supply of canned pears is practically endless, and he has never faced real danger. What if his family escaped from him and not from the village? If the monsters know everyone’s names, why does he know everyone’s name? Another thing that makes me think this world is a representation of his mind is the electrical wires going into the wall with nothing behind them; he is fundamentally a child, and like a child, he knows the wires go into the wall but doesn’t know what’s behind it. I’m not sure it’s only about him, though; he’s definitely connected to everything. Maybe to avoid being alone, he created an imaginary friend, the boy in white, and the people who end up there are drawn to his unconscious thoughts of repopulating a village? What do you think? P.S. The father’s expression when he sees the lunchbox is one of terror, not amazement.
@@otunlamoses5853 maybe Victor's dad gets to a point where he over reacts on Tabitha, alerting the police to where she is. The hospital would already have alerted them as well, as seen in episode 1 of season 3
Oh man after seeing them torture tien-Chan, it would be vampire rules when morning comes. We going in there cave everyday till we find a way to kill them.
@@DiegoNewplanshadow they aren’t wendigo’s unfortunately. Wendigo have to consume flesh to survive. These monsters don’t even eat. Probably closer to seelie(Scottish folklore ) dark fairies
This is the part that pisses me off. Why are they not acting like "humans", even after seeing that they can actually kill these things? Humans would definitely invade their sleeping den and lay waste to every one of them and one problem solved.
But how would they kill them? The bullets dipped in the bile from the monster they killed didn't work, and they don't know of another way to harm the monsters other than when Boyd transferred his blood to Smiley.
Since the start of this show, there literally hasn't been one answer to one question that has been raised. If it wasn't for my wife wanting me to watch it with her, I would have bailed long ago. You've got to feed the viewer one in awhile.
the people behind it are saying we'll get some concrete answers to a bunch of questions this season, really hope thats true and that this isnt one of those 16 season type of shows where it gets insanely complicated
@@dannydishes i love mystery shows , this show is slow but it has ton of mystery , and dont worry man they mentioned there would be 4 or 5 season of from .
ok so heres some opions i have on some of the mysteries. Fae is scottish for "from". the entity causeing all of this is a fae or fairy like folk creature. I think the stones are something like a wardstone in scottish folklore as well. Fae often kidnap children and even replace them with their own, akin to changlings. I think this entity has been around a long time, possibly made a deal with humans in the past and was either slighted or was the trickster type that turned on the humans it made a deal with. theres definetly some kidnaping of children involved and being used in some ritual that sustains it or gives it power. I think the symbol is indictive or a rune that deals with anchoring a point to many other places in the world, a kind of weave that lets it trap people from all over the world. hence the random point of origins. evil towns people are most like things akin to changlings i mentioned earlier. used to catch people offguard at first to torture them easily.
That's your complaint? Seriously? Half the town was there, what prison is Boyd gonna lock them all up in? The tiny police station? Is he supposed to make enemies of the entire town's folk with all the problems they already have? That would've started a further riot. If that's your solution/take away from this episode I don't know what to say.......
@@_1Sentry1_ im reading your reply as if both of you are inside fromville and debating outside a house while im also standing beside both of you listening quietly lol and thinking what you are saying is true .
@@_1Sentry1_ are you okay? Did you have a troubling day? Because if you wanna talk about it I'd be glad to hear.ypu vent. I have empty of other theories and thoughts not quite as fleeting as this one lol
I believe the main theme of this show is good vs evil, light vs dark. The Boy in white reminds me of Jacob from Lost. The main villain or entity that we have yet to be introduced to controls the monsters, most likely that red demon we saw on the cave drawings. This entity can also take the form of dead people , similar to the smoke monster on Lost
The monsters are definitely playing on the conversations heard. I also think some of the monsters (not yet transformed) are hiding* in plain sight. Hence the nightmare/dream Elgin had and upon awakening saw that evil Fatima nor the (Tilly-lady*) next to him was there.
I think the pictures in the basement are from victors sister. Victor found his mums body but not his sisters so she probably made it out and got home. Probably drawing what she saw in the town and everyone thinks she's crazy so she might be in a mental hospital somewhere.
First theory - I was thinking, what if the real world effects "From town". At the end of this video when it showed some stuff thats going to happen during this season you see paintings of the mysterious children in from town. In this video it was thorised that the dad could see visons of the children and then paints the children. But what if its the other way around? What if paintsing and drawings introduce stuff to "From town"? The intro shows paintings of monsters and events which has happend/ will happen on the show. But what if these monsters only came about because someone (e.g. a child) decided to draw some scary images/ their nightmares and it conjured the monsters into "From town". Some characters have been shown in the show to see the future and somewhat recognise the town before even entering it. But what if the reason they recognise the town is because they seen drawings of the the town in the real world, and the drawings conjured up "from town". The next thing im going to say has less probably going for it than what I talked about above, but if it does turn out that images effect "From town" then what if photos can too. People used to think that photos steal people's souls, what if having a photo of a person and placing it with "from town" pictures transport people to the town? (I think that second part is unlikely but it was an idea I had that I was thinking about). Second theory - in the upcoming episodes you see a bottle tree in the real world. I wonder if the bottle tree could be used to send stuff between worlds.
I’m pretty sure we learned time in fromville and the real world is the same in season 2 when Marielle told Kristi it had been 6 months since she went missing
@@sbaa33ii96 ok so heres some opions i have on some of the mysteries. Fae is scottish for "from". the entity causeing all of this is a fae or fairy like folk creature. I think the stones are something like a wardstone in scottish folklore as well. Fae often kidnap children and even replace them with their own, akin to changlings. I think this entity has been around a long time, possibly made a deal with humans in the past and was either slighted or was the trickster type that turned on the humans it made a deal with. theres definetly some kidnaping of children involved and being used in some ritual that sustains it or gives it power. I think the symbol is indictive or a rune that deals with anchoring a point to many other places in the world, a kind of weave that lets it trap people from all over the world. hence the random point of origins. evil towns people are most like things akin to changlings i mentioned earlier. used to catch people offguard at first to torture them easily.
Gives us more time to look for clues in the previous episode & discuss it. Ppl are way too impatient now. I just hope we get some answers this season. They owe us a big payoff otherwise I doubt I will stick around for S4.
@beewest5704 I agree. An early big reveal will ruin a show. I was 18 when twin peaks premiered. The reveal of the killer was a Shotgun blast to the face of that show.
When Tabitha was walking through town, was it just me or did some of the pedestrians walking along the street notice something odd? Some pedestrians who had been walking behind her were walking in the opposite direction from where she was walking in the right next scene. I don't think this was their mistake on using background actors🤔
The drowned lady didn't look like Fatima to me when they showed her this season. Maybe she is someone from Elgin's past, since he seems to be the only one seeing her.
While I like this series, its really starting to remind me of lost. Full of intriguing ideas and neat concepts, but they dont follow up on plot points. They ask a whole lot of questions without ever giving answers, to the questions they are asking. The writing is tending to get a bit lazy to me. Watch this all turn out to be a dream!
What I think is, these all are imagination of Victor. Somehow, his imagination as a child became true, and those paintings in the basement are made by Victor, when he was a child! Like, victor is the only one, who spent most of his life there in the town and he is still alive! He knows, where the faraway three, where it is headed but still he never left the town!
ok so heres some opions i have on some of the mysteries. Fae is scottish for "from". the entity causeing all of this is a fae or fairy like folk creature. I think the stones are something like a wardstone in scottish folklore as well. Fae often kidnap children and even replace them with their own, akin to changlings. I think this entity has been around a long time, possibly made a deal with humans in the past and was either slighted or was the trickster type that turned on the humans it made a deal with. theres definetly some kidnaping of children involved and being used in some ritual that sustains it or gives it power. I think the symbol is indictive or a rune that deals with anchoring a point to many other places in the world, a kind of weave that lets it trap people from all over the world. hence the random point of origins. evil towns people are most like things akin to changlings i mentioned earlier. used to catch people offguard at first to torture them easily. so maybe this could work if he was a fan of fairy tales or scottish folklore?
@8:06 I thought Tilly had four kids and seven grandchildren? Could be misremembering but I just recently rewatched the episode where she says that to Fatima.
I was upset at the ending, she's an OG, she never said much throughout the past seasons BUT, she was still a pillar in the series IMO 😭. I DID NOT like the ending (regarding my feelings), but show wise, it was a good ending.
Dude- I am taking Nicky’s side on the BATHROOM man. In a house full of roommates, there is NO justification to take the bathroom for an hour. Has Fatima ever heard of a bucket, a bowl, or a small trash can!? Puke in your own bedroom girl and leave out the bathroom
Though I normally avoid watching horror thrillers, I loved the first season of _From_ and was optimistic for S2. But then by the finale, I lost interest because the showrunners barely answered any of the burning questions from S1, but instead doubled down on posing more questions by introducing more immenent risks to the townspeople, as if they haven't been traumatized enough. It was incredibly frustrating! So suffice it to say, I will not be watching S3, but I will still watch your breakdowns, analyses, and predictions to find out if they stick the landing in the end. Thanks for these breakdowns tho. I appreciate it.
Another thing that seems kind of funny at first they would not open the door after dark, but then later on a cricket can fart and they open the door and it’s no issue what’s going on here?
Death of tien chan was such a shocker and how they slowly torture her infront of boyd to break him wht an ending. 2. The episode was kinda avg but the ending was really good
> Kennys mum: You killed Kennys mom you bastards. This again gonna cause more divide between Boyd and Kenny. First his dad and Boyd covered for Sarah who's responsible for his death. This time Kenny leaves the town and kennys mom dies. Tabitha: Great she's made to the real World. Now what? She's avoiding the police so they don't put her in asylum. Atleast she's out. If she can figure out how the tree in the road manifests, she can end the loop and get everyone out. Jim & Kenny journey: Smart move by Jim to decide to comeback. Was just me or one the voodoo doll statues looked like (2nd one) Fatima. What's the show showing us by an old village maybe before 50s Town ended up here, there were wood hut town. Maybe showing link between town and witchcraft. Monsters: Now they setting traps for the people. That's new I guess if you can't run then you have traps. Surprised the monsters tried this for the first time. They showing more calculating and torturous side to them. If remember in season 2 they left woman with rebar through her head. That nearly sent Christie into a emotional breakdown. Town: Who's listening to their every word. Monster at end of the episode tells Boyd so you think this town won't break you. Boyd said that earlier when dealing with Randal Food: Seems gonna be main theme. I keep imagining there's gonna be food TRUCK gonna roll up any day. They must have had food shortages before to plant crops and being here 50 plus years. How long was Victor eating peaches for? How did tinned peaches got to town?
Number 47 was on the radio as well when they were in the RV and they heard a banging sound from below and the music was playing from the radio which was busted.
As a Knox county resident (grew up there), I don’t like how much of this story is being centered around Camden, Maine. Making me think I’m about to be targeted 😂
Hit me with your best theories for season 3!
Check out my other FROM videos here: ruclips.net/p/PLY9KJ1cFVs7gQJ_cXCUJfSWrpd4uksXuZ
Haven't watched episode 1 yet but I hope to soon. I bet this Season is going to be a great one.
I think it's going to go to S*** and them some, for the townsfolk. Victor will disappear for three days and come back like a creepy Jesus. Some from colony house will resort to cannibalism (maybe season finale). Tabitha - paintings spoiler from the trailer could suggest Boyds wife was right and she needs to go back in full terminator mode to save them all.
I think those wood figures are the ones who moved Boyd and Sarah on season one but were unable to move them since it was a wood cabin instead of a tent, I theorize that they will be heavily connected to the lady in the kimono
Is it strange that I feel comforted by Daddy loves you very much?
ok so heres some opions i have on some of the mysteries.
Fae is scottish for "from". the entity causeing all of this is a fae or fairy like folk creature.
I think the stones are something like a wardstone in scottish folklore as well.
Fae often kidnap children and even replace them with their own, akin to changlings.
I think this entity has been around a long time, possibly made a deal with humans in the past and was either slighted or was the trickster type that turned on the humans it made a deal with. theres definetly some kidnaping of children involved and being used in some ritual that sustains it or gives it power.
I think the symbol is indictive or a rune that deals with anchoring a point to many other places in the world, a kind of weave that lets it trap people from all over the world. hence the random point of origins.
evil towns people are most like things akin to changlings i mentioned earlier. used to catch people offguard at first to torture them easily.
Mrs. Liu's death was brutal. It was like Donna's description her sisters death.
Bet she's not dead yet. I bet they left her alive.
@@mreed7947that would be grim, and then Boyd has to put her down. Wow they went far enough lol.
@@mreed7947 oh damn i hope not
@@mreed7947wtf man
Dude.. that's immediately what I thought of. This is one of the few shows that I legitimately can't wait for the next episode.
Jim making Kenny leave town just to realize he shouldn’t have left was such a asshole move, instead of his kids losing both parents Kenny has 😓
Kenny volunteered though. Another highlight to the type of person he is. Even when hating Sara last season when it came down to it he couldn’t hurt her or just watch her kill herself
And when Kenny comes back to town he'll find out her mother is *likely* dead or horribly injured, there's no more food for everyone and the monsters are smart, luring Boyd into a trap becuase of what he said ('you don't break me')
@@lordogxvii6034 I feel as if he volunteered solely because of Jim’s persistence to find Tabitha. If he would have stopped and thought like Boyd said, he would’ve realized what he said when him and Kenny were in the woods not protecting their families(that they shouldn’t have gone out there.) Thankfully Fatima was there to save Jim’s kids, but Kenny wasn’t there to protect his mom and I’m sure he’s gonna garner the guilt his mom felt about his dead’s death
I don't like Jim personally, but Kenny coming along with him was all Kenny's idea. No one put a gun to his head.
@@MChantal76 you’re right I just don’t like Jim 😭😭😭
This show is geneuinly criminally underrated.... It's darn good....
Truly facts amen
Not that good sorry
AMEN!!!🎉🎉
Mrs. Liu ending death was pretty tough to see
it hurt my soul
I think he's having a dream like the psychic boy did about knitting and that lady.
I really hope it's a dream😭@@Mekea1000
It was tearful to hear. Like losing a long time friend
Hopefully that's the case@@Mekea1000
That ending was brutal!😢😢😭😭
Yes it was 💔😭😭😭
When Tien cried out Boyd's name 😢
It made me feel sick 😭
Finally a review channel that just doesn't recap the episode we all watched! I love the easter eggs you highlight and linking them back to previous episodes. Thank you for taking the time.
I was looking for him haha, made sure to sub this time. Not going through that again. Remember back early in the year watching him
HAve you realised there are soooooooooooooo many new ones now reviewing. Makes it harder to find the good ones. Getting a bit monotonous watching the same thing over and over again from different perspective. Lucky i found this one back again too 😅
The only reason Jim went to the forest, is because the little kid kept putting himself in risk. Honestly, this whole family keeps screwing the town.
Except for Tabatha. She's actually progressing the story
@@aigakomine You're right, she dig under the house, she kept looking for clues.
Not really, Jim is such a stupid character. He couldn't be take care of his children and that¿s why the boy was always messing around stuff
I'm devastated, Tian was one of my favorite characters. it's been a while since I've felt actual sadness from a fictional character dying.
Same it really hit me and I'm a broken jaded horror fan
@@picvegitaI'm pissed at those people barging in and stealing from her after everything she's done for those ingrates.
Should've let the animals wander around until sunrise.😂😂
Aswell as her son, lost both parents to the town
If you want me to make it much, much worse, the thing she was screaming over and over was something akin to "No, Kenny will be alone"
Somehow the scariest thing in the show is still Kristi's haircut.
Ikr😂😂
bro is ruthless
😂😂😂
Lololololololol... Facts
I like it
A woman being peeled like a banana is NOT a cliffhanger.
It's traumatic
🙄 the cliffhanger is the responses everyone else will inevitably have to it.
@@bandit_six5418 Yeah, like... According to Harold Perrineau, this is not going to break him, this is going to make him pissed and go on the offensive.
Kenny's gonna fucking break.
@@LampDoesVideogameNope. The trailer for next episode shows Kenny ready to go against the creatures. No tears. No sobbing. Just ready to take the fight to the monsters.
@@bandit_six5418thats not what a cliffhanger is. Stop changing the definitions of words
Am I the only one who thinks Fatima could have easily used a sink or bucket to be slightly nauseous in rather than making someone wait an hour to take a pee in a shared house?
That was annoying but i suppose she couldnt think reasonably because of her stress about her monster fetus. Tabathas actions also annoyed me for some reason. She didnt even check the date to see if time moves different inside the pocket dimension.
That person could have tried another bathroom. I suffer from nausea and the toilet is the best. Puking into things makes me more sick cause I have to look at it
@@princessplam maybe there's only one bathroom?
@@numberone991she just got pushed out a lighthouse, I don't think she's thinking clearly.
No you’re not the only one. I was saying the same thing! Go outside!
Am I the only one that's questioning their stupidity, Going to get the farm Animals, It was blatantly a trap, when they could have left them they would have just been roaming somewhere,Where would they go, I'll hope the writers don't start making the characters make stupid decisions.
It would turn me off to the show.
Or just bring one or two of the animals in the nearest house instead of all the way to the barn.
They had to get the animals that was the only source of food. Plus the monsters would have killed the other animals if they didn’t come out you see they killed the cow.
I understand that they get food from the crops they grow, but mind you, for 2 whole season I’ve never seen any barn animals, neither have I heard anyone talking about them. And always wondered where are they getting fresh water and juice from. Then all of a sudden in season there are barn animals ????
@@ExoticSpartain this episode they clearly said the soil was poisoned and that is why the crops were all rotten. They have shown the animals in other seasons. Boyd clearly stated in season 1 that one day he was in the woods and found them roaming. They have mentioned the animals several times actually.
@@kassiemontedoro4637 I was not talking about the crops because I know the soil was rotten. Just about the barn animals.
So my theory is that they let Boyd live for the same reason victor is the way he is and survived so long, they even tell us with "we won't kill you, we want you broken". What if the monsters can't hurt anyone with a vital role in completing the "quest" so they emotionally break everyone instead to ensure they can't finish. I also think that's why they tried to have sarah try to Ethan, i think Ethan can assume victors role in the quest and be able to finish it.
Let me know if I'm crazy.
It makes sense, i agree with you
This is actually a great theory!
Time doesn't flow differently between Fromville and the real world, Marielle mentions that Kristie had been missing for months by the time she arrived in the town which matches up with Kristie's experience. Victor got there in the 1970's and is in his late 50's, that aligns perfectly. They mention that the town has been in a state of perpetual summer for as long as anyone (Victor) can remember. The changing season isn't reflective of time passing, rather the environment changing and evolving to the townspeople
But victor's dad looks pretty young to me
Either he is in great shape or he had children when he was 15
@@Shailesh_Sharma doubt that dude is in great shape lol
@@punakahuna4803 in better shape than victor though!
It’s true that From has never explicitly suggested that time flows differently between Fromville and the real world. There are key indicators that time aligns between the two. For instance, Marielle mentions that Kristie had been missing for months when she arrived in the town, which matches up with Kristie’s experience inside Fromville, confirming that time is consistent across both realms(
Den of Geek
Victor, who arrived in the 1970s and is now in his late 50s, also supports this theory. His age and timeline are consistent with the real world’s passage of time, further implying that there is no temporal distortion. However, what is unique is the town’s state of perpetual summer, as noted by Victor. This seems to suggest that while time moves forward normally, the town’s environment evolves independently, possibly as a mechanism tied to the supernatural forces at play
The changing seasons or lack thereof reflect less about the passage of time and more about how the town itself manipulates or responds to its inhabitants. This could be a way to psychologically disorient the residents while keeping them physically in sync with the outside world.
@@Shailesh_Sharmahe hasn't been trapped in a inescapable town with vampires so yeah
Boyd’s poor shoulder will never fully heal
lol i think he is more worried about his life than his shoulder .
For carrying the goddamn series! And the whole town too 😂
@@Nasipecel_pedes_pol😂😂😂 seriously we can’t lose him ‼️
My husband and I binged both seasons for the past few weeks and was so sad it ended! We had no idea season 3 was dropping just a few days later! Lol great timing!
you guys are lucky
Tabitha just entered level 2 of simulation. Simple😂
😂
That would be crazy😂
👍👍👍
What's wild is that this idea is still on the table and can't necessarily be ruled out.
OMG so glad I found a review channel. I love this show. It keeps me on the edge of my seat.
Everybody has weird things happening to them individually, but yet nobody shares their experiences with nobody else and when they do, they act like they’re crazy and nobody believes them which is really odd because look where they’re at if somebody told me they saw weird things how could you not believe them?
That's kind of my biggest problem with the show, but then the inverse will happen sometimes and arguably make things worse. Like, the worst part for me happened in season 2 when Boyd gets the worms and nobody sees it until a moment of convenience arises and then suddenly people can see them. Just weak writing for an otherwise very interesting show.
Weird stuff happens in real life all the time, and for many things that we actually can't explain and no one does research into these weird/unexplainable things/ppl/etc. because people thinks its pointless and will call you crazy, its extremely accurate of how human society has been since human society has started, and all these people come from human society, where even when there is weird stuff going on, your weird that you experience will still be considered crazy instead .
also in our world almost everyone results to using Occam's razor to answer complex situations/things for unexplainable things, so they try to fit in. I'm not saying im above this level of thinking, but next time you ever see something weird, go and start telling people, and look at how they look at you. Have a great day/night
Brutal ending, didn’t anticipate that. The show writers aren’t afraid to get deep and dirty in the horror show, it’s good
This show needs to give us answers this season enough with the mysterious bushit
Ever watched lost? Yeah they kept that going for over 12 seasons and then ended it all with “suprise , you’ve been dead this whole time “
But if they do that, how will they set up future seasons? 😅😂
@@nelsonthatleast answer a few questions .
What were the insects?
What about the worms
Who was the soldier locked up
Where are they
What was the music box
Who or what are the kids
What are the monsters? Are they people, were they regular people or prior townsfolk?
Who was talkin on the radio
Whos the boy in white
What’s with the light house
What’s the symbols on the cave walls
How did the worms kill the monster
Why do the talisman work?
There’s atleast 10 more unanswered questions..they gotta answer a few
last two episodes are called "revelations" lets hope
@@jaece6245 damn.. you're actually right lmfaoo geesh.
I’ve been starting to believe that Victor is (perhaps unconsciously) the mastermind behind everything. There are too many signs; he predicts events before they happen, he’s been there longer than anyone, his supply of canned pears is practically endless, and he has never faced real danger.
What if his family escaped from him and not from the village? If the monsters know everyone’s names, why does he know everyone’s name?
Another thing that makes me think this world is a representation of his mind is the electrical wires going into the wall with nothing behind them; he is fundamentally a child, and like a child, he knows the wires go into the wall but doesn’t know what’s behind it.
I’m not sure it’s only about him, though; he’s definitely connected to everything. Maybe to avoid being alone, he created an imaginary friend, the boy in white, and the people who end up there are drawn to his unconscious thoughts of repopulating a village?
What do you think?
P.S. The father’s expression when he sees the lunchbox is one of terror, not amazement.
I like this sir
....no
I mean yeah why would he be amazed that a random lady has his sons lunchbox who has been missing for over 40+ years
Interesting theory
Very interesting theory 😮
this is such an underrated show!!
i think Tabitha is coming back to From town with a police officer in that ambulance. maybe Henry will be with them.
That would be foolish of her though. Police to do what? Arrest demons?
@@otunlamoses5853 maybe Victor's dad gets to a point where he over reacts on Tabitha, alerting the police to where she is. The hospital would already have alerted them as well, as seen in episode 1 of season 3
Oh man after seeing them torture tien-Chan, it would be vampire rules when morning comes. We going in there cave everyday till we find a way to kill them.
Wendigos.
@@DiegoNewplanshadow they aren’t wendigo’s unfortunately. Wendigo have to consume flesh to survive. These monsters don’t even eat. Probably closer to seelie(Scottish folklore ) dark fairies
kenny's going to feel so guilty next week. :(
They could attack the monsters in their weakest state. While they're sleeping in the cave.
yeah but we now know they listen to conversations and they actually can wake up even when they are sleeping so ...
This is the part that pisses me off. Why are they not acting like "humans", even after seeing that they can actually kill these things? Humans would definitely invade their sleeping den and lay waste to every one of them and one problem solved.
They can Actually kill them "with the Fvcking worms only"....
But how would they kill them? The bullets dipped in the bile from the monster they killed didn't work, and they don't know of another way to harm the monsters other than when Boyd transferred his blood to Smiley.
@@ugochukwuezenwankwo7151 how the Fvck Will the Humans kill them?
Since the start of this show, there literally hasn't been one answer to one question that has been raised. If it wasn't for my wife wanting me to watch it with her, I would have bailed long ago. You've got to feed the viewer one in awhile.
It’s from the writers of lost. Pretty much that experience all over again.
the people behind it are saying we'll get some concrete answers to a bunch of questions this season, really hope thats true and that this isnt one of those 16 season type of shows where it gets insanely complicated
@@dannydishes i love mystery shows , this show is slow but it has ton of mystery , and dont worry man they mentioned there would be 4 or 5 season of from .
ok so heres some opions i have on some of the mysteries.
Fae is scottish for "from". the entity causeing all of this is a fae or fairy like folk creature.
I think the stones are something like a wardstone in scottish folklore as well.
Fae often kidnap children and even replace them with their own, akin to changlings.
I think this entity has been around a long time, possibly made a deal with humans in the past and was either slighted or was the trickster type that turned on the humans it made a deal with. theres definetly some kidnaping of children involved and being used in some ritual that sustains it or gives it power.
I think the symbol is indictive or a rune that deals with anchoring a point to many other places in the world, a kind of weave that lets it trap people from all over the world. hence the random point of origins.
evil towns people are most like things akin to changlings i mentioned earlier. used to catch people offguard at first to torture them easily.
@fredrickfalana328 this is the best from theory I've read
Ppl tried to steal all the food...the fact they didn't get locked up proves the monsters are smarter than the town people lol
That's your complaint? Seriously? Half the town was there, what prison is Boyd gonna lock them all up in? The tiny police station? Is he supposed to make enemies of the entire town's folk with all the problems they already have? That would've started a further riot. If that's your solution/take away from this episode I don't know what to say.......
@@_1Sentry1_ im reading your reply as if both of you are inside fromville and debating outside a house while im also standing beside both of you listening quietly lol and thinking what you are saying is true .
@@_1Sentry1_ are you okay? Did you have a troubling day? Because if you wanna talk about it I'd be glad to hear.ypu vent. I have empty of other theories and thoughts not quite as fleeting as this one lol
@@sbaa33ii96 hahaha you win
@@ShoofAloofnarcissistic tendencies...go to a theraphist man.
Thank you!! Always anticipating your breakdowns. This season premiere was bananas!
At this point, the scariest thing will be if they cancel this show. I hope they make a lot of money and people share and talk about FROM more.
Aye man it's been 2 seasons, they need to start giving us answers.
that’s kinda how i feel at this point
💯💯
I believe the main theme of this show is good vs evil, light vs dark. The Boy in white reminds me of Jacob from Lost. The main villain or entity that we have yet to be introduced to controls the monsters, most likely that red demon we saw on the cave drawings. This entity can also take the form of dead people , similar to the smoke monster on Lost
The monsters are definitely playing on the conversations heard. I also think some of the monsters (not yet transformed) are hiding* in plain sight. Hence the nightmare/dream Elgin had and upon awakening saw that evil Fatima nor the (Tilly-lady*) next to him was there.
If im nit mistaken i think when she called her mom she said the police have been looking for her for a couple months
I think the pictures in the basement are from victors sister. Victor found his mums body but not his sisters so she probably made it out and got home. Probably drawing what she saw in the town and everyone thinks she's crazy so she might be in a mental hospital somewhere.
I like this theory
Thank you no one ever showed or explained what happened to his sister 🥹
That would be so exciting if she knew how to get out if Fromville.
Interesting how the actor of the boy in white never ages.
What...
That's the idea
First theory - I was thinking, what if the real world effects "From town". At the end of this video when it showed some stuff thats going to happen during this season you see paintings of the mysterious children in from town. In this video it was thorised that the dad could see visons of the children and then paints the children. But what if its the other way around? What if paintsing and drawings introduce stuff to "From town"? The intro shows paintings of monsters and events which has happend/ will happen on the show. But what if these monsters only came about because someone (e.g. a child) decided to draw some scary images/ their nightmares and it conjured the monsters into "From town". Some characters have been shown in the show to see the future and somewhat recognise the town before even entering it. But what if the reason they recognise the town is because they seen drawings of the the town in the real world, and the drawings conjured up "from town".
The next thing im going to say has less probably going for it than what I talked about above, but if it does turn out that images effect "From town" then what if photos can too. People used to think that photos steal people's souls, what if having a photo of a person and placing it with "from town" pictures transport people to the town?
(I think that second part is unlikely but it was an idea I had that I was thinking about).
Second theory - in the upcoming episodes you see a bottle tree in the real world. I wonder if the bottle tree could be used to send stuff between worlds.
Boyd smashing the music box was a verse in the song. The last part of the song said, "Unless you can stop the melody."
I feel like they need to stop keeping secrets from the rest of the town. They might have got their ish together if they all had the information.
I’m pretty sure we learned time in fromville and the real world is the same in season 2 when Marielle told Kristi it had been 6 months since she went missing
I'm curious about Kenny's response when he found out his mother died😢
😭😭😭😭 our boy has been through too much.
I do want some answers but I like this a lot. So I can wait a bit longer. A little longer.
Me too . Though Kinda annoyed that Stan puts out only one episode per week. I hate when streaming apps make you wait.
@@Lunakitty1234 dude im with u guys , i love mystery so much even if it takes longgggg time to get answers but one episode per week suck .
@@sbaa33ii96 ok so heres some opions i have on some of the mysteries.
Fae is scottish for "from". the entity causeing all of this is a fae or fairy like folk creature.
I think the stones are something like a wardstone in scottish folklore as well.
Fae often kidnap children and even replace them with their own, akin to changlings.
I think this entity has been around a long time, possibly made a deal with humans in the past and was either slighted or was the trickster type that turned on the humans it made a deal with. theres definetly some kidnaping of children involved and being used in some ritual that sustains it or gives it power.
I think the symbol is indictive or a rune that deals with anchoring a point to many other places in the world, a kind of weave that lets it trap people from all over the world. hence the random point of origins.
evil towns people are most like things akin to changlings i mentioned earlier. used to catch people offguard at first to torture them easily.
Gives us more time to look for clues in the previous episode & discuss it. Ppl are way too impatient now.
I just hope we get some answers this season. They owe us a big payoff otherwise I doubt I will stick around for S4.
@beewest5704 I agree. An early big reveal will ruin a show. I was 18 when twin peaks premiered. The reveal of the killer was a Shotgun blast to the face of that show.
When Tabitha was walking through town, was it just me or did some of the pedestrians walking along the street notice something odd?
Some pedestrians who had been walking behind her were walking in the opposite direction from where she was walking in the right next scene.
I don't think this was their mistake on using background actors🤔
I noted it & thought I was just looking too closely seeing everything as a sign or clue ir something.
What if Tabitha goes back with Victor's dad to Fromville through the tree with bottle in Camden?
The drowned lady didn't look like Fatima to me when they showed her this season. Maybe she is someone from Elgin's past, since he seems to be the only one seeing her.
My thought is tailisman doesn't work at all it's just a game for the monsters, they will start running again watch
I was thinking this!!
I was eagerly anticipating your breakdown
I do not trust Tilly either. She is the only resident who seems to enjoy being stranded there and she does not seem to be afraid of the monsters
Those monster are really went smarter than earlier which is not good.
Unbelievable episode. I still can't believe the ending.
While I like this series, its really starting to remind me of lost. Full of intriguing ideas and neat concepts, but they dont follow up on plot points. They ask a whole lot of questions without ever giving answers, to the questions they are asking. The writing is tending to get a bit lazy to me. Watch this all turn out to be a dream!
Thank God was waiting for you
This show would make a great video game if done right. Like the old horror RPGs of the 90s.
What I think is, these all are imagination of Victor.
Somehow, his imagination as a child became true, and those paintings in the basement are made by Victor, when he was a child!
Like, victor is the only one, who spent most of his life there in the town and he is still alive!
He knows, where the faraway three, where it is headed but still he never left the town!
Maybe because he knows and thinks he has nowhere to go to if he leaves the town
ok so heres some opions i have on some of the mysteries.
Fae is scottish for "from". the entity causeing all of this is a fae or fairy like folk creature.
I think the stones are something like a wardstone in scottish folklore as well.
Fae often kidnap children and even replace them with their own, akin to changlings.
I think this entity has been around a long time, possibly made a deal with humans in the past and was either slighted or was the trickster type that turned on the humans it made a deal with. theres definetly some kidnaping of children involved and being used in some ritual that sustains it or gives it power.
I think the symbol is indictive or a rune that deals with anchoring a point to many other places in the world, a kind of weave that lets it trap people from all over the world. hence the random point of origins.
evil towns people are most like things akin to changlings i mentioned earlier. used to catch people offguard at first to torture them easily.
so maybe this could work if he was a fan of fairy tales or scottish folklore?
@8:06 I thought Tilly had four kids and seven grandchildren? Could be misremembering but I just recently rewatched the episode where she says that to Fatima.
How did the soil become poisoned?
I’m so happy to see this review
That was a very cruel and brutal episode, but, I want some answers, this show drives me crazy lol
This whole time, the monsters could release their unsecured cattle as traps?
Did I miss something but have they tried 🔥 on the creatures? I really don’t want to have to start over.
Great breakdown. 💪🏾 great start to the season as well.
I was upset at the ending, she's an OG, she never said much throughout the past seasons BUT, she was still a pillar in the series IMO 😭. I DID NOT like the ending (regarding my feelings), but show wise, it was a good ending.
I can't wait until Sunday....
my heart at the end of this episode
It took you long enough I have been waiting so long 💋💗💗
Dude- I am taking Nicky’s side on the BATHROOM man. In a house full of roommates, there is NO justification to take the bathroom for an hour.
Has Fatima ever heard of a bucket, a bowl, or a small trash can!?
Puke in your own bedroom girl and leave out the bathroom
i just watched the full episode that ending had me sad af
I think that old lady from bus is A Monstar
Though I normally avoid watching horror thrillers, I loved the first season of _From_ and was optimistic for S2. But then by the finale, I lost interest because the showrunners barely answered any of the burning questions from S1, but instead doubled down on posing more questions by introducing more immenent risks to the townspeople, as if they haven't been traumatized enough. It was incredibly frustrating!
So suffice it to say, I will not be watching S3, but I will still watch your breakdowns, analyses, and predictions to find out if they stick the landing in the end. Thanks for these breakdowns tho. I appreciate it.
Has no one thought of just burning down the whole forest? Especially before nightfall?
That would kill them too.
Thanks F!! it's still mysteries we dont know the clue
Another thing that seems kind of funny at first they would not open the door after dark, but then later on a cricket can fart and they open the door and it’s no issue what’s going on here?
The talisman made them more brave?
"Papa Victor" And that's what I will call him until the end of time.
Absolutely depraved ending.
If it's some nightmare inception world then whoever's it is has a fck tonne of trauma.
Been waiting on you T.S. !!!!
I feel like Tabitha didn’t tell the priest a gender and he knew it was a boy.
He’s in on it
God damn, Tien.
That shit wrecked me
Why is no one asking victor what happened with Tabitha?
he only led her where she wanted to go. thats all he would know
Poor Kenny first his dad now his mom dang he's going lose it
Victor sister will play a major part
Thanks I needed this.
After watching episode 1 my mind was in a boggle and I was like what the hell did I watch.
I love that Rick pfp
I had a dream these creatures came to our world and for a very long time they walked slowly but then start to run really fast best dream ever
Does nobody wonder why they suddenly starting opening and closing stores?
What do you mean
@@MCreedon34 The monsters opened the barn & gate door to let the animals out. But they also locked people into the barn in the end...
@@toothflossthe simple answer is probably they're getting smarter.
Death of tien chan was such a shocker and how they slowly torture her infront of boyd to break him wht an ending.
2. The episode was kinda avg but the ending was really good
> Kennys mum: You killed Kennys mom you bastards. This again gonna cause more divide between Boyd and Kenny. First his dad and Boyd covered for Sarah who's responsible for his death. This time Kenny leaves the town and kennys mom dies.
Tabitha: Great she's made to the real World. Now what? She's avoiding the police so they don't put her in asylum. Atleast she's out. If she can figure out how the tree in the road manifests, she can end the loop and get everyone out.
Jim & Kenny journey: Smart move by Jim to decide to comeback. Was just me or one the voodoo doll statues looked like (2nd one) Fatima. What's the show showing us by an old village maybe before 50s Town ended up here, there were wood hut town. Maybe showing link between town and witchcraft.
Monsters: Now they setting traps for the people. That's new I guess if you can't run then you have traps. Surprised the monsters tried this for the first time. They showing more calculating and torturous side to them. If remember in season 2 they left woman with rebar through her head. That nearly sent Christie into a emotional breakdown.
Town: Who's listening to their every word. Monster at end of the episode tells Boyd so you think this town won't break you. Boyd said that earlier when dealing with Randal
Food: Seems gonna be main theme. I keep imagining there's gonna be food TRUCK gonna roll up any day. They must have had food shortages before to plant crops and being here 50 plus years. How long was Victor eating peaches for? How did tinned peaches got to town?
Enjoyed reading your comment, thanks
The monster stop all them from entering the barn it separate jade and Victor it only wanted Boyd and Kenny mom
Does anyone ever arrive alone? I feel like the town picks someone but the ppl that show up with them are collateral damage.
Kristi and fatima arrived alone.
5:23 She for sure died. They were wheeling a body in at the start of the trailer.
They killed kenny's Mom to prove a Point....Hope Boyd doesnt break😅
I’m so excited
Love you so much ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Boyd has been there before
She gave birth to 4 kids and had 7 grandchildren lol
Que sera sera… whatever will be will be
It was 4 kids and 7 grandkids if I think.
omg thats the same numbers on the playing cards
any idea what the card number 8 could represent?
Number 47 was on the radio as well when they were in the RV and they heard a banging sound from below and the music was playing from the radio which was busted.
@@Jawbrah93 Any idea what the 8 is for? 🤔
@@aigakomine No sorry.
Man this show is getting more confusing episode by episode
the lunch box is what transported her
As a Knox county resident (grew up there), I don’t like how much of this story is being centered around Camden, Maine. Making me think I’m about to be targeted 😂