Metallica Bassist Vocals Comparison

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 19 окт 2024

Комментарии • 48

  • @angeloliv
    @angeloliv 28 дней назад +335

    Jason was the only guy who could make James sound like a backing singer

  • @inphievthedev
    @inphievthedev 28 дней назад +245

    man jason's voice was something else! shame that he left metallica...

    • @joshuatidy-bl9ue
      @joshuatidy-bl9ue 25 дней назад +20

      I miss his howl in of wolf and man

    • @blupandaxalt
      @blupandaxalt 25 дней назад +40

      He didn't just leave Metallica. HE FOCKING LEFT THE BAND

  • @ams_mace3084
    @ams_mace3084 28 дней назад +220

    Cliff backing were so good and jason captures his energy as well

  • @GregGallagher
    @GregGallagher 25 дней назад +147

    Jason’s “DIE, MOTHERFUCKER DIE!” will never be topped. Rob does a wonderful job whenever he does have to do his minimal backing vocals, and he’s arguably a better fit as far as his playing style but Jason brought so much raw energy and obvious passion for the music. He put it all out there for everyone to see and hear every night, which is probably why he’s still so widely respected and admired among longtime fans. The most common criticism I hear, which is also the dumbest IMO, is how he played with a pick. Who fucking cares?! The dude was great at what he did for nearly 15 years. Newsted will always be my favorite Metallica member

    • @blupandaxalt
      @blupandaxalt 25 дней назад +10

      I think every bassist they had fit the best for their era, although Cliff's era was sadly too short. Also I don't understand the pick criticism either

  • @dreamreaper5336
    @dreamreaper5336 23 дня назад +59

    Holy fucking shit, I never knew Cliff sounded like that

  • @StormbringerI
    @StormbringerI 25 дней назад +116

    I would argue Cliff was the better BACKING vocalist but Jason was all around a superior vocalist

    • @blupandaxalt
      @blupandaxalt 25 дней назад +20

      Jason is basically just an evil metal vocalist

    • @Caamileo
      @Caamileo 14 дней назад +3

      No way cliff was the better backing vocalist, he was the better bassist but when it came to singing jason was by far the best

  • @adiian_008
    @adiian_008 19 дней назад +26

    If you ever feel useless, just know that Kirk also has a microphone

  • @andrepaul3483
    @andrepaul3483 25 дней назад +52

    Jason is the reason on why I picked up the bass and on why I want to do backing vocals. What a BEAST. Cliff's backing vocals are insanely good too. But Jason's stage presence is INFECTIOUS and I love it!

  • @thedinkster5772
    @thedinkster5772 25 дней назад +31

    I always thought it was cool that when Jason was in the band, they’d let him sing lead parts of Whiplash and Seek and Destroy sometimes

  • @Vladnight28
    @Vladnight28 26 дней назад +28

    One of the reasons why I still miss Jason :((

  • @Jhonnyblaze93
    @Jhonnyblaze93 25 дней назад +25

    0:43 it seems (and sounds) like Day on the green

    • @wiktorz8524
      @wiktorz8524 24 дня назад +4

      it's not, it's from Hampton Coliseum 1986

  • @Reckless_Metal
    @Reckless_Metal День назад +2

    Rob is so good playing-wise but his vocals sound a little quiet almost like they turned his mic way down compared to the other two. My favorite performance of Rob is definitely WRATH OF MAAAAN but you can't compare the other two in that case because the song was released recently. If you don't think Rob has it like Cliff and Jason, you may be right, or you just haven't seen him play 72 Seasons live!

  • @ceciliamackie
    @ceciliamackie 9 дней назад +2

    It's impressive how fantastic your content is!

  • @_master_of_darkness_
    @_master_of_darkness_ 24 дня назад +31

    Roberto Agustín Miguel Santiago Samuel Trujillo Veracruz 🗣️🗣️‼️‼️🔥🔥💯🚨🚨💯‼️

  • @gymguy25
    @gymguy25 23 дня назад +6

    Bass playing ability aside, when it comes to backup vocals, Jason was the best!

  • @mitch1847
    @mitch1847 17 дней назад +5

    Jason and Cliff? Flip a coin. Both are incredible. Rob? He's a good bassist but he's been a place holder for 20 years.

  • @toobcat24
    @toobcat24 23 дня назад +5

    Rest in Peace Cliff

  • @ROB_LAW98K
    @ROB_LAW98K 29 дней назад +35

    Let my people go

    • @crossingdragon5032
      @crossingdragon5032 26 дней назад +3

      I just watched finished prince of Egypt like 30 minutes ago and this song was on my mind the entire time

    • @Mr_Egg04
      @Mr_Egg04 25 дней назад +4

      Land of goshen

  • @brianmay1983
    @brianmay1983 21 день назад +2

    Jason is the best! Best bassist/backing vocalist/force of nature they ever had!

  • @johnhavardvalebrokk6151
    @johnhavardvalebrokk6151 18 дней назад +3

    Jason was the one who could do lead vocal better than James sometimes. Incredible guy.

    • @qwepeksoy5797
      @qwepeksoy5797 6 дней назад

      after james blew his voice, they would make jason sing seek n destroy time to time, there are footage of him singing songs like whiplash, the four horsemen and bell tolls. He probably had a better technique than james, seeing that he can still do the growls and james just mimicking and sometimes not even doing the screams nowadays.

  • @РоманСмирнов-ц2н
    @РоманСмирнов-ц2н 21 день назад +5

    Jason is the only one who was really good as vocalist imo.

  • @Skeevee
    @Skeevee 3 дня назад

    0:51 holy shit cliff

  • @CizerKedi
    @CizerKedi 20 дней назад +3

    Jason is the best

  • @MacsInghioRockBand
    @MacsInghioRockBand 24 дня назад +6

    JASON

  • @franciscopalacios8682
    @franciscopalacios8682 4 дня назад

    Jason’s vocals are insane

  • @bdr113080
    @bdr113080 12 дней назад

    I miss Jason in the band so much when it comes to their live performance. Don’t get me wrong. I love Rob. I think he’s one of the best active bass players today. He can do some things that not everybody can do when it comes to plain base and if we can’t have Jason, I’m glad we have Rob but man Jason‘s vocals live just added like an extra layer of energyto the feeling in the arena

  • @adhritkhanna2833
    @adhritkhanna2833 24 дня назад +4

    Who all love Metallica?

  • @GeekFurious
    @GeekFurious 15 дней назад +2

    Jason > Cliff > Rob but Rob has gotten soooooo much better. He was pretty terrible the first few years.

  • @gblackbird
    @gblackbird День назад

    Bring Jason back! Help James' tired voice and extend the career of Metallica.

  • @chriswiggins1679
    @chriswiggins1679 4 дня назад

    Cliff was the best bassist, but you got to give credit to Jason for the overrall package. Dude was a monster on backong vocals. Robs pretty decent too, his crab walking ass.

  • @MONSTERKING69420
    @MONSTERKING69420 24 дня назад +1

    If you can’t tell almost all their best backing was on creeping death, this confirms it’s the best off of RtL (in my opinion)

  • @OgyTheOldMetal.
    @OgyTheOldMetal. 17 дней назад

    Forever ROCK...

  • @mrnogot4251
    @mrnogot4251 12 дней назад

    Matters more than the bass playing lol

  • @rohannidhitiwari9365
    @rohannidhitiwari9365 20 дней назад +2

    Jason was better than James Cliff Robert

  • @arrayofemotions
    @arrayofemotions 17 дней назад

    Imagine how useless kirk felt when he had to do backing vocals alongside Jason.

    • @bdr113080
      @bdr113080 12 дней назад

      All the times I saw them live was back in the day when Jason was with them I really want to see them with Rob. I think Rob is a phenomenal player but man when Jason would do backing vocals, I swear Kirk would just be mouthing it sometimes like I couldn’t hear him at all And then one time Jason couldn’t get to the time, but Kirk didn’t know that and there was no sound coming from Kirk at all lol . And I love Kirk and Metallica is my favorite band but when Jason stepped up to the mic, he was the lead vocalist it felt like.