Ashari Asking Shamsi About The Attributes of Allah According To The Salaf | Speakers Corner
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 янв 2020
- Repelling Ashari Doubts
➜ www.asharis.com
Islam, Sunnah, way of the Salaf
➜ www.salaf.com
Terrorism in the guise of Islam
➜ www.islamagainstextremism.com
Subscribe to this channel for more content like this, and please give this video a thumbs-up and share it across all social media platforms.
Abu Hurraira narrated that The Prophet ﷺ said:
❝Whoever invites to guidance will be rewarded like those who follow him in guidance are rewarded, and that will not decrease the reward of those who have followed him❞.
[Collected by Imām Muslim]
To get in touch with a Muslim community or attend gatherings of knowledge that are local to you, email us and we will direct you in-shā Allah. We also welcome questions from non-Muslims who want to understand Islām.
Email: admin@dusunnah.com
SUPPORT MASJID DAARUSSUNNAH
➜ www.paypal.me/dusunnah
#SpeakersCorner #Islam #Salaf
Shamsi made slip of the tongue in this video at 04:56
17:54 Important information on the subject ➜ www.asharis.com
May Allāh forgive our brother. Amīn
DUS Dawah ameen
May Allah grant you more knowledge. Keep up the amazing work. You are a role model for these young generation. May Allah reward you shamsi brother. (Ameen)
@@IbrahimKhalil-bt9yh not jusy DUS AND spuds but all muslims inshAllah
@@user-bg9zg5dx8u Ameen
No matter how deviant a person is (and I’m saying this generally), I can always respect and appreciate that person if he or she is respectful and patient and honest and sincere.
The brother Yusuf is so humbled talking to Shamsi over Ali dawah.. this shows why you need to know what your talking about first. I watched the Ali one first and had doubts, this just clarified it
Shamsi explained very clear, like the moon and sun. The explanation of Mohamed Motabarija and Ali Needs Dawah was very confusing. May Allaah reward you guys.
Because they haven't studied the aqeedah of the salaf
Loll, Ali needs dawah
*_Masha'Allah Shamsi, Reason is only for those who seek the truth._*
The brother on the right has a surprising high about of knowledge. May Allah guide him to what is correct.
He knows about a lot of sects
He is actually a zaidi
@@aw6029 he changed to ashari
Masha Allah, beautifully explained.
Masya Allah...we learn something from Shamshi & Yusoff discussion. Alhamdulillah.
What did you learn
After seeing this video and these two muslim superstars, I now know why the islamic world is a flaming pile of camel dung.
Iv seen brother Yousuf before once in a video. MashaAllah TabarakAllah Alhamdulillah A very nice brother. I like him. Willing to learn. SubhanaAllah may ALLAH SWT reward him Abundantly. May ALLAH SWT reward Br Shamsi Abundantly.. jzk brothers..
Amazing video! May Allah bless our brother Shamsi for the clarification and guide the brother to the truth, ameen!
Aameen
ameen
Lol so he’s not on the truth? 🤔
@@pointdot094 not the complete truth no he isn't. This is clear from his recent videos
Who is not in the truth?
SubhanAllah. I do not ascribe to any specific aqeedah, but I always ask for proof from Quran and Sunnah with regards to any questions or actions. In my experience, it has always been the Muslim brothers who ascribe to the Salafi aqeedah that always... Always supply their proofs from Quran and Sunnah, and not from opinions or emotions.
It was the same experience with me.
Bro you need yo hsve an aqeeda,from quran and sunnah and the salaf
After seeing this video and these two muslim superstars, I now know why the islamic world is a flaming pile of camel dung.
very good discussion thaanks to the brother who asked questions may Allah bless him
Ali Dawah don't ask him ..... Ask him About Boxing ..😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🎆
Thats slander you know that right ?
Stop hating on muslims for couple of likes ......
@Umar ALi @4:00
@@xGAMER_chimpX That's not slander. It's 100% true. I hope you've already advised Ali needs dawah for the many many slanders he has made against the muslims?
@النفيس not slander
لا اله الا الله بارك الله فيك ونفع بعلمك وجزاك الله خير الجزاء، واسأل الله أن يهدينا ويهدي الأخ وجميع المسلمين ويصلح ذات بيننا.
بارك الله فيكم
Alhamdulillah, the Aqeedah of the Salaf is pure, free from any confusions.
JazakAllahu Khayran Ikhwaan
Nadheer Shongwe - alhamdulillah, i pray you and me wouldn’t die except upon manhaj salaf
@@sid4517 Aameen
I have a question. Why don't you say: "The aqeedah of the true Muslim is pure". Is the term muslim not enough? Why do we have to call ourself salafi?
@@TheRockyBalboa100
I said Salaf NOT Salafi
By Salaf, I'm referring to the First Three Generations of Muslims, we follow them in their Aqeedah and Manhaj, and thus we are Salafi
TheRockyBalboa100 no. Calling yourself Muslim in this age of confusion isn’t enough.
The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) described the saved group as the jamaa’ah, i.e., the consensus of the Muslim scholars. In other reports he also described them as “the vast multitude”, as in the hadeeth of Abu Umaamah and others which is recorded by Ibn Abi ‘Aasim in al-Sunnah (1/34) and al-Tabaraani in al-Mu’jam al-Kabeer (8/321), with an isnaad that is hasan li ghayrihi (hasan because of corroborating evidence).
The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) also described them in the following terms: “My ummah will split into seventy-three sects, all of whom will be in Hell except one group.” They said: Who are they, O Messenger of Allaah? He said: “(Those who follow) that which I and my companions follow.” This is mentioned in the hadeeth of ‘Abd-Allaah ibn ‘Amr which was recorded and classed as hasan by al-Tirmidhi (2641). It was also classed as hasan by al-‘Iraaqi in Ahkaam al-Qur’aan (3/432), al-‘Iraaqi in Takhreej al-Ihya’ (3/284) and al-Albaani in Saheeh al-Tirmidhi.
Now, the People of Bid’a (Ashari, Maturidi, Sufi, etc) all call themselves Ahlu Sunnah Wal Jama’a. This causes further confusion and in order to clarify one’s belief he can call him/herself Salafi as a distinction from these misguided groups.
I hope this has been helpful.
This two persons are amazing i love both of them, may this video enlightning others..
Just say ' Allah knows best' and move on , we shouldnt divide ourselves. May Allah forgive us all.
If he knows the question he can answer it and we can benefit from it? we don't need to say Allah knows best' for everything without answering the questions.
Jahil. We only unite upon the truth. You seem like a Liberal Muslim.
@@999legend8 more like ikhwani
May Allah Bless Yousuf , Good brother indeed , he turned to the right way . That is when you are not biased and asking with sincerity
I think the brother is searching for the truth but battling at the same time. I like how he nearly became salafi at the end if the video by affirming how the salafis affirm for Allah سبحانه و تعالى in ways that befit his majesty. Clear dawah and less stubbornness (of his own) will guide this brother to the truth إن شاء الله
Alhamdulillaah he is upon the salafi manhaj now.
@@user-sx6nn7ot9j How do you know akh?
@@kingklmak there was a brother on twitter who posted a voice note of shamsi saying that br yusuf has repented: mobile.twitter.com/AbuLut_/status/1216481363597189120
@@user-sx6nn7ot9j can you explain me the salafi manhaj?
@@TheRockyBalboa100 the salafi manhaj is the pure unadulterated way of Islam. The orthodoxy of Islam and the right path. The message the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him propagated and what his companions understood Islam to be in understanding and implementing.
This should help you brother:
www.abukhadeejah.com/what-is-salafism-and-salafiyyah/
May Allah azza'wajal guide you to the straight path and keep us all firm upon that, to live and die upon the correct path.
May Allah bless you brother Shamsi for the clear clarification
Just seen that yusuf has made tawbah and accepted Salafiyyah Allaahu akbar Alhamdulillah may Allaah accept his repentance and guide him and grant him firmness SubhanAllaah SubhanAllaah
His account was active last night but now can not be found but here is a link about it:
twitter.com/abulut_/status/1216481363597189120?s=21
Really?? SubhanaAllah. Allahuakbar!
Lawstidentity can you explain to me what is different about salafiya from other sects? Give me some examples.
What was he before?
khadija Ashari
Those who accuse Salāfis of Tashbīh/Tajsīm (anthropomorphism) are in fact guilty of their own accusation. Due to their own impulsive doubts in their hearts and the whispering of the shaytān, they fail to understand their misguidance.
The shaytān did a number on mankind with this doubt as it's very difficult to escape from - except for whom Allāh ﷻ guides. Thus reaffirming the utter importance of instilling the correct understanding of Tawhīd in one's heart.
At least he's competent enough to not seek knowledge from the mule of the shaytān, the extremely ignorant stooge, Ali Drama.
@alphabolt DCUO
First of all, Wahābism doesn't exist. This derogatory term was invented by the Ottomans and the Brits to degrade the Salāfis who are the only Muslim sect upon the correct understanding of Islām. Secondly, your lack of affiliation with the Salāfi Creed and Methodology is in violation of the Prophet ﷺ as he clearly stated the nation will split into 73 sects.
Narrated 'Abdullah bin 'Amr رضي الله عنه:
that the Messenger of Allāh (ﷺ) said: "What befell the children of Isra'īl will befall my Ummah, step by step, such that if there was one who had intercourse with his mother in the open, then there would be someone from my Ummah who would do that. Indeed the children of Isra'il split into seventy-two sects, and my Ummah will split into seventy-three sects. All of them are in the Fire Except one sect." He said: "And which is it O Messenger of Allāh?" He said: "What I am upon and my Companions." [Tirmidhi 2641]
Salāfis don't believe in anthropomorphism except for it nullifies one's Islām.
We believe in Allāh's Attributes according to the correct understanding of the Qur'ān and the Sunnah. We affirm and negate for Allāh ﷻ what He and His Prophet affirmed and negated. Allāh ﷻ mentioned His Shin in the Qur'ān. He also mentioned nothing is like Him. So we believe in the Qur'ān and we believe in His Shin but without likening it to the creation because the 'how', the physical description of it hasn't been revealed thus it's from the matters of the Unseen. Nor do we distort the linguistical meaning as we understand from what is apparent.
For example, the Asharis distort the meaning of the Attribute of His Hands by claiming it's His Power. The Qur'ān and Sunnah doesn't explain it this way. Likewise, Allāh could've said His Power instead of His Hands in the Qur'ān.
And Allāh ﷻ Knows Best
@alphabolt DCUO who are you?
@alphabolt DCUO so when the prophet صلى الله عليه و سلم said that theres 73 sects and 72 are in the hell fire and one sect in jannah, are you in the saved sect or in the 72 sects
@@osmanjibril8940 that wat i am confused ,the salafi claim to be that saved sect while ahle sunnah wal jamaah (ashari and maturidi aqeeda) also claim to be from the saved sect so does the shia
@@maktabahassunnah Salām Alaykum Ahki, please email us via email in the description box.
Bārak Allah fīk
Allah hand?? No matter what .....only Allah knows about himself. SubhanaAllah...
It’s in the Quran you jahil
Assalaam Alaikum
Ma Sha Allaah this was excellent discussion Brother Shamsi clarified the Salafi Aqeedah regarding Allaah's Attributes.
But this Brother Yusaf had different tone with Ali Dawah who has no knowledge regarding Salafiyah
Baraka allaho fik brother
Alhamdulillah for Athariyyah...
I respect this Yusof. He is sincerely asking question and sound knowledge too about islam.
he’s now claiming to be a zaydi shia
@@muaaz8608where did you get this information
I really want to come to speakers corner and meet all the brothers. Living in Scotland sadly i dont get the chance
This guys is intelligent may allah guide us and guide him
Ma sha Allah. May Allah bless brother Shamsi
Allah akbar ☝️
jazakAllah khairan kaseera
Someone with proper good questions and Shamsi dealing with it much better than Ali Dawah , i actually learnt something from this one opposed to the same convo with Ali Dawah.
I hope what u learnt is not to listen to Ali needs Dawah
@@hl8302 in a paraphrasing way Ali did explain the same concept of the matter in English to that deceitful kid about Allah's hands but because Ali explain it mostly in English, and Ali did checkmate the ashari kid when Ali brought up the point of existence, I have the same aqeedah as shamsi, upon the way of the salaf, we know our difference with Ali, but it's not right to lie about him regarding his debate with that kid
So humble akhi yousouf may allah garant u jannah
This man became a zaydi akhi. Nothing humble about that
Allahummah Barik! Very Good. If only Ali needs dawah would bother to study his deen
!
Shamsi did an amazing job in this ma shaa Allah
ماشأالله جزاک الله اخی شمسی
Love you bro ,,for the sakke of Allah
The problem with Asharees and Maturidees is that they hear the words "hand, shin, finger" etc and Automatically want to remove THEIR OWN thinking of Allah to have attributes like Humans (because these words share the same name in creation), so they end up denying and not affirming attributes that Allah has affirmed for himself. It is their own polluted thinking in the first place. They want to flee from affirmation. No one is saying "how" the attributes are. It is clear how the Creed of Ibn Kullab is rooted from Aristotle and Plato.
It's an individual problem. The Asha’riyyah and Maaturidiyyah Aqeedah have been de Aqeedah of the ahlul sunna wa jammah. We should not say Salafis say Literally Allah swt he has a Hand (as the asharis claim. And the Ash‘aris say Allah has no hand(as the salafis claim) . Because in the original creed of the Asha’riyyah they affirm that Allah has a hand(pure linguistic because Allah said so) But they dwell deep on why Allah can not have a human hand. Likewise in the salafiyah its the opposite. I think there is just a big misconception between towards each other.
@@Sieghart5314 I don't think there's a 1000 year misconception where the past Imāms waged war against innovated beliefs due to the corruption and what it could lead to (Shaytaan ultimately wants kufr). The salafees Creed is that of the sahaabah, the 4 Imāms and scholars of hadith who followed the taabi'een. This is the haqq. The truth. The real authentic and correct creed from the companions. Asharees and Maturidees are innovated creeds that originate from the Kullabiyyah, then to the Mu'tazilah, then to the Jahmiyyah and finally to Greek philosophy based upon reason.
@@hussaingani 100% on point. Modern day Ash'aris are in actuality revivers of the Jahmi Aqeedah. Abul-hassan Alashari never went as far as these so-called Ash'aris went in relation to misunderstanding Allah's Attributes. Furthermore, he repented and died upon the sound Athari creed.
Salam walaiykum, just a quick question cause I'm still undecided which aqeeda I follow. So don't take this question like I have a view. If salafis believe Allah physically descends to the lowest heaven in the last third of the night, is he always descending because it's always last third of the night somewhere. Can you give an explanation for that? Also when Allah says he runs towards the believer, why would it not make more sense to understand that metaphorically? As appose to Allah literally running ? Jzk
yeh asharis are dumb, but how come mostg the scholars of aswj were ashari or maturidi
JazakAllah khair bro Shamsi.
Superbly explained by Shamsi. So many points of benefit here especially about the narration that both of Allah’s hands are right hands as the Arabs believed that the left hand isn’t blessed so this narration is to clarify that both of Allah’s hands are blessed. Subhanallah? ما قدر الله حق قدره
Waalahi this is beneficial to the Muslims, many of us youth are Jaahil in Aqeedah.
Alhamdullilah for the brothers like Abu Iyaad and Shamsi for clarifying this important point of Allah`s attributes.
On the other hand we see people like Ali Dawah who brang that Yusuf Estes who promoted the dead creed of the Jahmiyya cult on his channel and analyses MMA matches and reacted to the Prime Minister Of India falling down the stairs.
while he hasn't even studied Kitab at Tawheed or any other books of Aqeedah.
الله يحفظك اخوي شمسي و يدخلك الجنة من باب الصبر مع الصابرين 😄😄
The only thing that I have in my head after this video, is the fact that the white boi with blonde hair looks like an George from Ireland. But he's A Youssef with an very good Arabic pronounce, and talks like an Arab. Please, I want to know what his origins are or if he is a revert. 😂
احبك في الله 🌺
People like Ali dawah and Hijab should respect and acknowledge that they have to sacrifice much of their life to reach the level of Shamsi , Ali was completely schooled by this Ashari and look how Br. Shamsi explained him like a doctor resolving the issues of a patient.
Alhamdulilah, very good conversation and very clear clarification of the aqeedah of ahl sunnah wal jamma may allah keep us sincere
One slight point, I wanna made. Al-Bayhaqi came after Daraqutni. Abu Dharr al-Harawi was the student that was affected. Whilst, Abu Bakr al-Bayhaqi was affected by some praises that were made for some Ash'aris. BarakAllahu fikum.
Alhamdulilah how can one not love the salafi aqeeda
Imam at-Tirmidhi (may Allah have mercy on him) said, after narrating the hadith, “Allah accepts charity and takes it in His right hand,” in his Sunan (no. 662):
More than one of the scholars has spoken about this hadith and similar reports that referred to divine attributes and the descent of the Lord, may He be blessed and exalted, to the lowest heaven every night. They said: We affirm the reports concerning that and we believe in it, but it cannot be imagined or asked how it is. Similarly, it was narrated from Maalik, Sufyaan ibn ‘Uyaynah and ‘Abdullah ibn al-Mubaarak that they said concerning such hadiths: Let it pass without discussing how. This was the view of the scholars of Ahl as-Sunnah wa’l-Jamaa‘ah. As for the Jahamis, they denied these reports and said that this is likening Allah to His creation.
Allah, may He be glorified and exalted, has mentioned His hand, His hearing and His seeing in more than one place in His Book. The Jahamis misinterpreted these verses and explained them in a way different from the scholars; they said: Allah did not create Adam with His hand. And they said that what is meant by the hand here is power.
Ishaaq ibn Ibraaheem said: Rather likening Allah to His creation is saying that He has a hand like their hand, or hearing like their hearing. If someone says that Allah has hearing like their hearing, this is likening Him to His creation. But if he says, as Allah, may He be exalted, said: A hand, hearing, sight - without discussing how or saying it is like their (attributes), this is not likening Him to His creation; rather it is as Allah, may He be exalted, says in His Book (interpretation of the meaning): “There is nothing like unto Him, and He is the Hearing, the Seeing” [ash-Shoora 42:11].
The salafi aqeedah from the salaf
And a refutations of the modern day mutazila/jahmiya who are asharia and matarudis. Who are known as the deobandis, brelwis and sufis.
One proof should be sufficient
@Hiba Jama so 🤨 not liking something doesn't mean it's not true
Alot of people hate Mohammed peace be upon him doesn't mean that he's not a true messenger
@@tewfikbk8683
Prophet Muhammad SAWS !!!
The majority of the Ummah is Ashari Maturidi Alhamdulillah.
Hanzala quick question were the companions of the messenger Ashari? If so please provide the evidence and proofs from the books of the salaf.
كلام السلف قليل كثير البركة وكلام المتكلمين كثير قليل البركة
صدقت
Tell me if I make mistake in translating it. "Words of salaf is few but a lot in blessings and words of the mutakallims is a lot but few in blessings"
أقول كلام المتكلمين عديم البركة أو مليئ بالفساد
الاخطاء التي كانت في هذه المناظرة لا تعد ما يقولاه ليس المعتقد الاشعري
MashaAllah Shamsi. May Allah bless.
This guy is obsessed with ma'na and yad
ma'na boi
Hahahahahaha the ma’na guy
Please more videos of this selam aleykum from Germany (turkish salafi muslim)
Wahhabi is no Muslim no salafi. The maturidiyya and ashariyya are Muslim and Ahlussunnah.
@@noahboah2310 😂😂😂😂😂
May Allah help you and guide you shamsi
This is a second video of this young man. Who is he actually. He seems to be caucasian but has a good knowledge on the issues of creed.
May Allah guide him to the truth.
İslam is the truth. You dont have to be a salafi to be on the right path. Wash your washed brains again to be free again
@@ahok123 Mr Ahmet Allah gave proofs in His Noble Book concerning the excellence of the Salaf as-Salih, and following their way, Allah said:
And the first to embrace Islam of the Muhajirun and the Ansar and also those who followed them exactly. Allah is well pleased with them, as they are well pleased with Him. He has prepared for them Gardens under which rivers flow (Paradise), to dwell therein forever. That is the supreme success.
[Collected by Bukhari & Muslim]
Therefore, the Companions are the example and they are the ones to follow. It is obligatory upon every Muslim to follow them in what they understood from the evidences of the Book and the Sunnah, because they were the most knowledgeable of the people and they had the most correct understanding of the Sharia’ texts out of all the people. Consequently, if a Muslim takes other than their understanding then he will deviate away from the straight path, since the Companions stood with insight, and they viewed everything with their perceptive knowledge.
Salam wa3leykum from an Moroccan Amazigh ! ☝️❤
@@jetx5408 Wa3alaykom assalam brother !
Great video, the only thing that annoyed me was the brother was chewing with his mouth open.
Surah 3 verse 7 says 'And no one knows it's interpretation except Allah:
It is He who has sent down to you, [O Muḥammad], the Book; in it are verses [that are] precise - they are the foundation of the Book - and others unspecific.1 As for those in whose hearts is deviation [from truth], they will follow that of it which is unspecific, seeking discord and seeking an interpretation [suitable to them]. And no one knows its [true] interpretation except Allāh. But those firm in knowledge say, "We believe in it. All [of it] is from our Lord." And no one will be reminded except those of understanding.
- Saheeh International
I love brother Shamsi .
كما يليف لشانه ، According to Allahs Majesty
that we all agree subhanallah. yet see the harm from this why it shouldn't be a point of debate . as " According to Allah's Majesty " inshallah all agree , and debating makes it sound like " Tajseem/Mujassimah" . where at beginning and end the usool is free from that " كما يليق لشانه " Anyways , Allah accept all the good amaal and ikhlaas off all the brothers ameen Ya Rabb
He knows the site asharis.com which dismantled the deviant beliefs of the ashari yet chooses to ask the same question which have been clarified there
Yahya a debate with a human is always fine when handled like mans
Well it helped him. The brother accepted Salafiyyah Alhamdulillah
Lol when did he accept it? Not in that discussion he didn't
@@jbrhussain683
He put it on his Twitter and made tauba aboit things he said before. Shamsi confirmed it himself
By saying "limb" he's actually answering the _how_ and not the meaning
Exactly
Shamsi to clever for him thats why he calm and not arguing.like he does with hijab and Ali dawah
Allah is the Greatest!
Assalamualaikum.
Allah said in the Qur'an, Surah as-Shura :
Laisa kamitslihi syaiun
There is nothing like Him(Allah)
Barakallahu Afeek
Don’t forget the next part akh, “wa huwas samii'ul bashiir”
We (humans) hears and sees, but Allah’s hearing and sight is not like ours, perfect.
@@aw6029 yes, I am aware of it. Syukran.
@@i-Glassif you are aware of it why you don’t finish the verse? You asharis love to only quote this verse and you don’t like to finish (ALWAYS)
@@Prayformetobeagoodmuslim me asharis? 😂😂😂😂😂.
I have no control over your mouth.
@@i-Glass what do you mean? You’re not ashari? I’m sorry I misunderstood you
When Allah said in the Quran : "And the Jews say, "The hand of Allah is chained." " He replied :"Chained are their hands, and cursed are they for what they say. Rather, both His hands are extended; He spends however He wills" . You can notice that the jews said " his hand" which is singular, then Allah said " both his hands are extended" adding a second hand to the equation. So if Allah's hands were not litteral hands, what would be the point of talking about two hands?
Well you could consider them metaphorical , that "The hand of Allah is chained." is metaphorical for Allah being impotent, being constrained rather than having a literal hand in chains, and the extended two hands could mean not only is Allah potent but more so than imagined. Of course if it is metaphorical then that requires a step in interpretation and that leads to potential ambiguities. It also leads to how do you know when and when not such a interpretative step is required, maybe even apparently straight forward statements could in fact be intended to be metaphorical, how would you know, there is no rule telling you when and when not to understand statements in a literal or metaphorical manner.
@@tdsdave the chaining is metaphorical, not the hands, since you can apply the same metaphorical expression on human hands without having doubts that the human in question has hands. the example of Adam given by brother Shamsi is enaugh in my opinion , because what makes Adam so special is , like Allah mentioned it was that he created him with his hands .( notice Allah, once again mentioned two hands). But some people like it complicated. May Allah guide us all.
@@tdsdave By the way, there's nothing called " you could consider it so and so" in Aqeeda.
@@adelkl5711 allah swt has two hands like in the verse. how they look like no one knows
@@adelkl5711
Hey ,
Of course there is so & so, for example there are several theological takes on what to make of Allah's hands. That you hold to one version does not mean there are not others.
Jack ma here offers one version, that it is accepted that Allah has two literal hands, but at the same time it'd be denied that it could be understood what these hands really are. Even this conception of Allah's hands is derived from an interpretation of the texts in an effort to make doctrinal ideas like Allah is unlike his creation , fit with hands being a feature only known to us in creation. This understanding has problems it amounts to saying that Allah's hands could be, may be required to be, vastly removed from what we understand hands to be. If that is the case what is the purpose in Allah communicating this to us at all, by definition if we do not know what Allah's hands are we cannot understand text where it is referenced. There is also no rule available that itself is not also product of a credal conclusion, about when this deference to ignorance should be applied. Should we also do it for Allah being merciful , the creator , why should we imagine these attributes are not as incomprehensible to us as Allah's hands are deemed to be.
So other takes on this, such as treating the statements, where they cause conflict with other doctrines as metaphor or platonic, solve somewhat some of these problems . Often though you never escape all the problems.
All the best.
The scholars have differed concerning the meaning of Muhkam and Mutashabeehaat ayaats in the Qur'aan. Qadhi Aboo Ya'la; who mentions 4 opinions in his book 'iddah:
1. The Muhkam is clear and doesn't need explanation. The Mutashabeehaat needs explanation.
2. The Mutashabeehaat is that which is difficult to comprehend for the layman, but not for he 'Ulema. This is similar to ayaat that outwardly contradict each other but don't, i.e. "Verily you guide not who you like” (Al-Qasas 56) and the ayah “Verily, you are indeed guiding (mankind) to the straight path” (Ash-Shura 52). The first ayah refers to the success of one's actions and the second ayah refers to a proof and leads to the Truth.
3. The Mutashabeehaat are the letters that are unconnected and found at the beginning of the surahs i.e. Alif Laam Meem, Alif Laam Ra. etc.) The Muhkam are letters other than these.
4. The Muhkam are the ayaat of the halaal. haraam. promises, and punishments. The Mutashabeehaat are the ayaat of stories and parables, basically the Muhkam on this opinion are the ayaat that establish verdicts and the Mutashabeehaat are the ayaat that don't
Mashaallah
15:33
Do you believe that Allah is alife ...
So good question !
In quran said there is two things there is ayatul muhkemat and ayatul muteshabigat
عقيدة أهل السنة والجماعة نأمن بأن الله له يدين كلتاهما في اليمين ونأمن أن الله له عينان تليق بعضمت جلالته وليس كمثله شيء ماأثبته الله لنفسه أثبتناه وما سكت عليه سكتنا عنه لا نمثل ولا نكيف ولا نعطل....إن أسماء الله أعلام وأوصاف وكل إسم يتضمن صفة وكل صف تتضمن إسم وليس كل صفة تتضمن إسم.
الحمد لله على نعمة السنة
After watching recent video between him and bro Adnan Rashid, this yusuf doesn't seem really sincere. He's got agenda
The guy is everything. Salafi, ashari, zaidi 😂😂😭🤦♂️
@@zccau2316 and insincere
Just because one person understands this verse in one way another will understand it differently. Don't try to enforce your understanding on all people
May Allah bless you brother Shamsi
Have a good tasty dinner together brothers. Shamasi gives the brother respect..good to see.
Mashaalah
Just read Surah ال عمران: 7.
The talk about the level of the 3oelama, Is Very High but the level of this Guys is for me High👍❤ Respect for this Guys.
Mr chubby is well spoken and seems intelligent he debates and also has a willingness to take on board what other brothers say
dont call him chubby
❤
ممكن الترجمه
Where does this guy come from ???
This man is Zaidi Shia. He is not ash'ari.
He keeps on changing his beliefs. Now he's Ithna Ashari Shia.
Beginner question here: When it says Allah has a hand...why can't it just be metaphorical?
Yusuf it's simple: say Allah's hands are one and only, Allah's hands are the only eternally self-sufficient hands that every other hands needs and received sustainance from but Allah's hands are never in needs from no other hands, Allah's hands are not the hands of one who given birth nor birth was given by a parent to Allah's hands(no) and there are no other hands that are compare to Allah's hands....
@Hiba Jama shoes got face and tongue, but you also got face and a tongue but does this mean your face and your tongue are similar to the shoes face and shoes tongue or do you become a shoes now cause u got face and tongue like how the shoe got face and tongue or you should be consistent with your misunderstanding and now say you don't got no face and no tongue cause your not a shoe, unless you dumbass have to agree now' that two unlike things can have the same linguistic uniformitive title or label but still share no comparison, just like Allah says HE got Hands in the Quran but Allah also tells us in the same Quran that there nothing like unto him' meaning the human being hands are not like Allah's hands
Salam alaykum akhi I understand that you are trying to defend the aqidah towards Allahs hands but i would advise with not speaking about Allah in a way the salaf did not speak about Him. It is not know from the salaf to put Allahs hands in surah ikhlas jazakhAllah kheir
@dusdawah genuine question... is the 'hand' of Allah and the power of Allah 2 separate attributes?
yes
The jahmiyah say hands mean power refer to jami ul kabeer chapter fadail sadqah
Why is it relevant for “us” as regular believers and non scholars, to debate or to discuss about these things? From a personal perspective, Im worried allot more about improving my own deen and beeing united with fellow Muslims. Again what’s the importance for us regular young Muslims to be so preoccupied with this?
His name should be bob, BOB FROM TEKKEN is back
Yusuf sometimes shia, sometimes zaidi and now ashari. Bro Shamsi should be an example of all Muslims.
﴿قُل هُوَ اللَّهُ أَحَدٌ﴾ [الإخلاص: ١]
Say, "He is Allāh, [who is] One,
- Saheeh International
﴿اللَّهُ الصَّمَدُ﴾ [الإخلاص: ٢]
Allāh, the Eternal Refuge.
- Saheeh International
﴿لَم يَلِد وَلَم يولَد﴾ [الإخلاص: ٣]
He neither begets nor is born,
- Saheeh International
﴿وَلَم يَكُن لَهُ كُفُوًا أَحَدٌ﴾ [الإخلاص: ٤]
Nor is there to Him any equivalent."
- Saheeh International
Where's this Yusuf fellow from?
The last point didnt make any sense
This Deviant claims to accept salafiyah and then called himself an ashari but then called himself a zaydi
How do you know?
@@RealSupaHotFireVEVO Brother Yusuf said on his twitter page,
"I have left the Ash'ari creed and now following the kitab wa sunnah. Alhamdullilah for Shamsi and @DusDawah for the dawah they give. I was confused but Allah guide me to Salafiyyah. May Allah reward @DusDawah ."
@@SunniAthari
where he is from?
@@notknownmirza743 fifth madhab?
@@sm-yo6pt he's half Italian half russian.
"Limb" - Ashari guy, that's his problem with his argument right there, he's assuming too much hence why there is so much misinformation against salafis
ScritzCure Alhamdulillah news has come, he's a salafi now.
Aryan81304 so he’s been lying ? Do u have proof akhi
@@JustObserving7860 the proof is after this conversation him accepting Salafiyyah on his twister and then later on going up to adnan rashid to accuse him of tajsim. He lied and he teamed up then on other Muslims with the Shia Muhammad, then he exposed himself as he said he is a Zaidi Shia
@@Salafiyahisthehaqq yes akh i saw this khadab lie
the way hes chewing the gum is the most annoying اداب الحوار؟
focus the debate not the mouth of the poeple
He also doesn't look at Shamsi while talking, I think he has ADHD or such
Why are you so immersed in the man's actions
What is the name of the Zaydii brother?
How would you explain the verse in surah rahman where it says the face of your lord will only remain
only Allah knows that ..
"No one walks likes him on the face of the earth"... Does it means earth has a face you're argument is weak
When a person does something embarrassing and says how will I show my face to people does this now mean he/she is only talking about the face only?
SubhanAllah sneeky Guy! With Ali dawah he had the worst adab and making fun of salafiyah and took out albani ibn uthaymin and bin baz from the salafi aqeedah. Now with shamsi he is like a little lamb and ”understands” everything. A real ashari!!
Alhamdulillah for salafiyah
#salafi from Sweden
Sen Sin Alhamdullilah broder
Sen Sin so true ahki i seen his twitter account it’s filled with sufis and ashari also lying against shamsi saying he said Allah got hand while it’s mentioned in the Quran ... difference why he acts different with Shamsi is cause he knows shamsi got knowledge that will embarrass him while Ali dawah has no clue of the salafi aqeedah in detail since he openly said he hasn’t studied the books of tawheed when he was confronted by shamsi years ago
@@Yahya-gw5qw what's his twitter or youtube channel?
Byte89 he's become salafi!
Kun faya kun
The Truth is from thy Lord,so be not at all in doubt.( QS Al Baqarah: 147)(QS Ali Imraan: 7)
Allah creates what He wills,Allah says Be and it is. (QS Yasin : 82)
I heard this brother repented and reverted to salafiyyah after a private chat with Shamsi.
Soebhan Allaah
Alhamdulillah
Reversion is a strange term for what your describing
Wa he born Muslim before he looks Irish
“Reverted”?