Where else in the world can Jews openly express their Jewish identity without being subjected to verbal, physical or online abuse ? No where else but Israel.🔯 🇮🇱
100 years ago, most Arab countries had large Jewish communities. Now there are very few Jewish communities living in Arab countries due to anti Jewish racism. Only 3 Jews live in Syria in 2024. Very few Pro Palestine supporters dare to mention it, let alone discuss this openly.
palestinians who named themselves a false indentidy palestinians (means "invaders" originated from philistine) claimed to be indegenous but erase the aboriginous jws from Dome of rock. funny. why dont we create Meccaians who built a country on top of Mecca and be rocognized by the muslim countries?
@@RifndjsklljuwhdnchAfacnxla do you know how many foreign names there are in the Levant and North Africa? Does it mean the citizens of Alexandria of Egypt are Macedonians?
An American born kid, growing up in America, claiming land and rights in a country across the world is peak colonialism. I get connecting to your roots, but saying a place you have never been to owes you anything is incredibly fucked up.
@@bluestar6879 I understand you believe that all Jews are from Israel, but when you look into the history of the area the reason why so many “Arab” peasant farmers in Palestine held Jewish traditions from the Old Testament is because many Israelites chose other religions over time. Hellenistic religions, Christianity, Islam. That’s why when you take samples of genetic DNA from Israelite sites the closest living relatives are Samaritans and Palestinians. Levantine Arabs are not from Arabia. They’re not real Arabs. Neither are Moroccans or Sudanese or Egyptians by the way. So having a group of people come from outside and claim the entire land of Israel for themselves is a bit threatening in that context, no?
@@shannonweatherly3940 precisely, just how Native Americans predominantly speak English now, doesn't mean they are not sons of the soil. Palestinians are pretty much the same people who were there thousands of years ago, they just adopted the language of those who came to rule over them (Umayyads, etc).
@@gangstanongrataI agree! The way I explain it to people is Mexicans speak Spanish language, have a Spanish culture, and adopted a Spanish religion aka Christianity. They identify as Hispanic aka from Spain. But they’re native because the majority of their ancestors are from Mexico going back thousands of years. I think a lot of people don’t realize Arab and Arabian are different. Once you see “Arabs” stand together and you see white skin, brown skin, black skin, red hair, brown hair, black hair, blue eyes, brown eyes, green eyes, then it starts to click they’re not homogenous for a reason. I’ve visited several Arab countries and the genetic, cultural, and linguistic differences are VAST.
I am American. My ex boyfriend was former IDF. He was absolutely insane, abusive and I barely escaped with my life. Changed the entire way I view Israel, not for the better.
Hey, I am an Israeli, I once dated elon musk and angelina jolie simultanously, they were both very toxic and now I hate the US. Do you see how stupid that sounds? 95% of Israel are ex-IDF, if you dated a toxic person it doesn't reflect on the whole Israeli society, you get me? no? that's ok.. go out, touch some grass.
@mingo2024 Every Israeli (more or less) is a "former IDF" and if your ex boyfriend was "insane" it has nothing to do with the IDF .. If i'll judge "Americans" by what I see in universities/Media etc, i'll recommend the U.S. will turn into one big Mental-house ... so ... I hope you are smart enough to understand the stupidity in your comment
I am an Israeli , i served the army. We are troumtic and post troumtic nation. I AM PEACE PERSON. We are good, smart, and not only crazy... We Are humens! Spred love that will bring love. I am sorry about what hapenned to you...
Used to be Zionsit. After becoming an athiest it was like a veil being lifted from my eyes. Really embarrassing of how much I dehumanized Palestinians and Muslims. I hope they become free.
It shows testament to your character that when presented with new information, you changed your opinion accordingly. It's not your fault that you were most probably indoctrinated from a young age, but what you do with that new information is what matters. That's your humanity prevailing over cultism through ethno-nationalism.
Being a Zist has nothing to do with your racism toward As. That’s a you problem. Zism is simply the belief that Js are deserving of a state of their own, where they are the majority and therefore safe, and where their culture is reflected - in the land to which they are indigenous. Izzz is no different than any Native American reservation, except for a 20% non-tribe member population.
Learn the history of the conflict. Israel is defending itself from people who dont want peace nor living side by side. Once you truly get it, you'll see things differently. Clearly, you have no clue what it is like that people wants to kill you just because of your belief.
Freeing the "Palestinians" requires the abolishment and genocide of Jews. "Freeing Islam" will only produce a Caliphate ruled by Sharia Law. TBH Palestine has no "right" to exist, what keeps Palestinians from surrender and joining Israel is antisemitism.
I've never felt more seen by a film. I love being Jewish and I love my community, but once I learned about Palestine I felt great shame. I will never understand how people so hurt and harmed could even think of doing this to others, especially with a religion that promotes good deeds and empathy. I hate being forcibly connected to such awful acts, I hate that my own friends and relatives believe everything Israel has told them. I first started to change my mind upon seeing videos from individual families suffering in Gaza, and couldn't believe that people I'm supposed to be on the same side with would do this to other people. So much shame for these zionists who call themselves Jewish. ❤🇵🇸
It's human inclination to self deceive when dealt with something soo uncomfortable. Instead of changing ourselves to get rid of that discomfort, we often tell ourselves lies that makes us feel comfortable. No one wants to believe that their whole life was built on lies.
a lot of my friends and family beleive that supporting the existance of the state of israel means that you have to support the terrible leaders, and the genocide they are commiting too. i will always push for the state of israel, but that doesnt mean I have to support war crimes.
Regardless of your faith, religion or culture, if your life is imparting harm, pain, dissonance or death onto others, you have failed to see yourself in them and the main message of love from our common creator.
Why is it regardless of faith if the basis og the muslim faith is to take over the world and the only religions they allow to live as second hand citizens(google dhimmi and jizyah) are jews, christians and sabeans? Same faith says that in the end days they will kill all the jews in the world. Again, how is it "regardless of faith"?
@@heliosperegrinHamas is just as bad as Israeli government, both harm innocent people . There’s no Hamas in the West Bank yet the IDF is mistreating the civilians there nonstop
Leibowitz said that the danger is, that the Israeli government learned the methods of Nazis.. Einstein called the pre party of Likud fascist as many others
You should be embarressed. I'm from middle east and the only civilized country in our region is israel. Palestine could have benefitted from this but they refuse. Simple as that. The concept of Palestine in every sense has been a colonial entity. Is it too much to ask that jews may have 22000 km2 small patch of crappy land to live in? Or you believe that this tiny patch...should be added to 13 million km2 of land that arabs claim? Btw why is nationalism bad only for the jews?
@@___Anakin.Skywalker if they wanted genocide... they can do it within a few hours.... this means they are not aiming at a genocide. Oppression? Hamas.... hahaha sure
@farsalami8605 These are kamala voters, bro. I volunteered for IDF for 4 years. This is all lies. So many young girls converting over with boys and teenagers. Vice is left wing. So of course they make some ANTI Semitic video.
An American, From Brooklyn, NY who is of European origin...claiming a land east of the Mediterranean because his ancestors lived there thousands of years ago? But a Palestinian who is from the east Mediterranean can't have "birth right/aliyah" whose father lived there 70 years ago? Sounds legit!
Mizrahi jews fro morroco can live in morroco. Iraqi jews can live in iraq. Yemeni jews can live in yemen. Being a black man in angola does not entitle you to land in Zimbabwe just because both countries are black @desireesachs3878
@desireesachs3878 even mizrahi is a wide range - it just vaguely means eastern jews. They can be georgian, yemenite, libyan etc. If anything, that furthers my point.
@ no it does not obviously you don’t know that mizrahi jews are from the middle east countries like Iran, Iraq, syria, yemen etc… look it up. the ashkenazi jews are from europe and the sephardic jews are from morocco, spain and portugal. ethiopian jews are from ethiopia. if you going to speak, speak facts not hard to find them.
For years, I supported Israel due to my father's influence, as he obtained his news from mainstream media sources. However, in 2017/18, I stumbled upon a video of Ross Kemp interviewing Hamas fighters, Palestinian civilians, Israeli citizens, and IDF members. This prompted me to delve deeper into the conflict and conduct extensive research. As I began studying the history of civilization up to the present day, I made a startling discovery that completely altered my perspective. This revelation was truly eye-opening and forever changed my views. I have since made it my mission to educate others, including my children, about the reality of Israel as an apartheid state.
It's so baffling that young people are seeing videos online of Palestinians suffering and Israel's only response is to tell them that the videos don't tell the whole story and that there is historical context that makes the images okay.
I'm a young Jewish American and former Zionist, so I think I can speak on this. The answer is, they believe all those videos are fake and Arabs are catastrophizing the plight of Palestinians. I now know that the plight is very much real
If people think there are bad cops in America, they definitely should not watch this! These kids aka soldiers violating people’s human rights is mind blowing! Classic line: Palestinian woman: you are stealing my land. Israeli dude: if I don’t someone else will. WOOOOW I’m shocked
My cousin, who is a doctor is currently volunteering in Gaza. I'm so scared for her saftey! I'm also immensely proud of her!!! I wish I could do more to help the people of Palestine
30:30 What an excuse for sin. The Lord did not favor Israel for these terrible things to happen. I believe the bible says the Lord will abandon Israel when they commit such behaviors.
You are casting aspersions onto Israel...which is fighting BACK, not first. No mention if terrorists promise to commit these attacks AGAIN AND AGAIN...no...you are only here to villify the people whose culture you attempt to appropriate...no...GIVE BACK. G-D will have His way with you 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 sucks to be you now don't it
I admire someone who knows Gods words, or Christian scripture, in some ways we were better in the times our religions were given to us and formed. Thats what i tell people who say The Bible and all of that is man made, I say...Maybe, but see, see the difference in the books they wrote back then and the books they write today? From the Torah, Bible and Quran...to 50 shades of grey and tabloids.
The Bible says ; Live as free men. But do not use your freedom as an excuse to do evil. Live as servants of God. 17 Show respect for all people. Love the brothers and sisters of God’s family. Respect God. Honor the king. - But everyone wants to play Satan and the silly bugger.
There wouldn't be checkpoints if there were no terror attacks (suicide bombings, stabbings and shootings). The checkpoints only appeared after the intifada's.
Yes I'd like to know also please your story. Also who are the people that implemented the apartheid system in South africa and also were the South African government complicit.
In gaza jews can enter only as hostages. Otherwise in israel, 20% of population is arab Palestinian. Where do you see crazy levels of ethno nationalism?
"never seen before" I am curious if you are insane or if you have ignored pretty much all of history. Borders are and have never been constant. Borders always change, and the locals have to defend their lands from invaders. The so called "Palestinians" failed to defend themselves and they face the consequences of being a dominated people. There is no reason to think that borders should not change. The Nazis had much more ethno-nationalism than the Jews, so did the USSR. The Chinese currently also have significantly more ethno-nationalism than the Jews. The Native Americans also have a high amount of ethno-nationalism.
@@Bdbtg28691 Have you ever taken a look at the constitution of a Native American reservation? Would you deny any of them the right to say their nation is for them alone? Among tribal nations, Izzzrael has the largest minority population on the planet. Wake up. Btw, it won’t be long before Europeans demand their countries be for them. Those that don’t, will soon be Islic.
seems like you aren't aware that both Israel, the west bank and gaza all run by different enteties, there is no possible way this falls under the definition of apartheid unless you alter the definition first.. oh wait.
This comment section really shows how some are sheepish and blind if Israel is so nice and good just do a small research on black jews and how they are treated in Israel if their own people get kinda treatment what treatment will the Palestinian get just think about it and if you are still supporting the Israel narrative without any doubts you are truly lost
lol are you insane, Israel sent it's special forces to *rescue* black jews and bring them into Israel. Is there another country in the world who have airlifted Africans into a country instead of kicking them out? Is there some racism? yes, there;s racism in canada and the US even, but in israel it's far better than anywhere else in the middle east. Stop believing everything you see on Al Jazeera. And google what the Arab governments do to blacks.
As a Palestinian living in Occupied Jerusalem,we see and come across lots of foreigner jews (especially Americans) who are on birthright trips or any other trip with similar goals.What the Palestinian guy from Bethlehem said was true,they have more rights than any Palestinian(wether living in the west bank,jerusalem,gaza,or the in areas occuppied in 1948),and get treated and act like they're natives and owners of this land. i Always wondered when i saw them or came across them,have those people ever heard about,talked,or got exposed to Palestinians,what if I talk to them?what if i tell them a couple of the stories that either happened to me or to someone i know?would those people actually realize they're being deceived and lied to?would they empathise with Palestinians?or are we really less than humans in their eyes? Great report,lots of love and respect to those who woke up and saw the truth,and fight back against Opression,and i would be more than happy to one day have the oppurtunity to talk to one,show them around my beloved Jerusalem,and how the occupation makes our life harder each and everyday in it.
As a jew living in jerusalem I'm allways for dialog I wish I could take the birthright kids to eat hummus and see the whole of this land. Again terrorism is never justified by my book. It's never okay to fire a rocket or run into some ones home and kill a father in front of his kids on video cause that's what happened on Oct 7. I'm for freedom just don't give hamas anything I encouraged israelies to give money to hamas and now I feel that this was a huge mistake did the millions we gave them help gaza be free? Did hamas do a genocide or is this what you call resistance? Is kidnapping people and holding them hostage infornt of the world ever justified? It happend. Now what. I'm still in jerusalem and I still have Muslim friends and I believe that we can all be safe and free if we focus on being good to ourselves and our families. I'm proud to say I support my arab brothers by encouraging education and by doing things that will help their own community life community gardens and cleaning up the streets if your from east jerusalem you will understand that jerusalem is cleaner then halil or hebron and that not because of terrorist but because there are people who work all day to make it clean those people are both arab and Jewish and that's who I respect hard working good people that don't work in politics. If someone else is the blame for everything is terror justified or even celebrated? Your garden looks like a mess and your not cleaning it is this my fault?! Do you know how meny tones of trash i took out of silwan so that people wouldnt burn it and kill their own children from deadly smoke inhalation?! Yes israel has issues but it's still better then letting all the tribes here kill each other for honor or cause one of their daughters may date someone from the wrong tribe so let's go honor kill them all right? Is that the kind of Islam that you believe in? I mean there is good and bad people on both sides just try to be good. Sorry for the long reply but I'd love to actually meet in person and talk cause you might be surprised. Ma'a salama
We are fully aware of whats happening in Gaza and the West Bank. It’s not ideal but this is the situation “Palestinians” forced us into. If you guys would accept that the state of Israel is going to exist forever and if you guys were committed to peaceful relations with us, “Palestinians” wouldnt have the problems they have. And yes we are natives to this land. There has only been one country in this region in all of history, and thats Israel. When it wasnt a jewish country, it was a colony under a foreign empire. We have a right to have a country here.
@@tag6502 What I don't understand is that Jews believe God exiled them until the Messiah comes and frees them from their exile! Where is the Messiah? Netanyahu thinks he has to pave the way for the Messiah, but the Messiah has to come before not after the establishment of Israel, which is a view shared by some ultra-orthodox jews themselves! I think they are scared shitless of God as of currently!
It’s so funny how Zi0n!s+s constantly want to a++ack & disrespect Is|am & Chr!s+ianity. Everyone needs to read the Ta|mud & you will see what they think of our beloved Jesus who is a prophet in Is|am not just Chr!s+ianity. They mock our faiths & try to pin us against eachother. They make our American men fight their w@rs. Too bad for them it’s not 2001 & their Is|amph0bia & propaganda & l!es just don’t work anymore!!!
For the (bot) comment claim this video is one-sided. Yes, you're right. Just like the ICC, the UN, the UNRWA, the Red Cross, the Oxfam, the Human Right Watch, the Amnesty International, the 146 countries in General Assembly is one-sided. The only two side-honest-true story is by Netanyahu 😂😂😂.
Does lying help you sleep better at night? IsraHe|| wins at gen0c!de, aparthe!d, & ethn!c cleansing. You want to peddle the H@sbara lie that it’s the only democracy in the Middle East, yet it’s laughable.
@@idojakoby1794 Israel and Arab countries,Turkey,Iran and Egypt including Palestine are racist,xenophobia,bigotry and prejudice countries it is unbelievable and sad.
This was so well done and hopefully eye-opening to the American Jews that choose to join the IDF or become settlers. I hope this is the start of a new movement that sees the Palestinians as people of the land that have more rights than an American born Jewish person.
I’m not trying to be offensive but this seems cultish. And I’m not talking about the religion aspects because anyone can make a cult argument for any religion. But just because of your religion they want to make u go to Israel to see it, then when ur there they drill into your head that you need to learn military commands in the middle of the night, you learn to shoot guns for the 1st time, they teach you the talking points to fight against “lies”, then it’s seen as a community get together to do lobbying on behalf of AIPAC which isn’t even for the betterment of Jewish Americans but for the benefit of the country of Israel. I sympathize with why Jews want a country but the modern Zionism movement seems suspicious.
Its more than just them wanting country. They are very much capable of buying empty lands and built country there. In fact Russia has given them plot of lands before.
Suspicious is understatement. They are literally act like Nazis! Good Israelis have been talking about it if you look for it. Former IDF soldiers who got themselves free from the indoctrination have been talking about it for a long time!
@@AL-lh2htZionist like to redefine words to obfuscate their meaning. And Zionism as a word is one of those. Where no one is allowed to know its history or meaning. Use of the word is supposedly been rebranded as “antisemitic” when technically Zionism and Israel as a concept is the most antisemitic current regime. Since the Palestinians are also - a Semitic people… And the concept of Zionism is ethnic cleansing a core minimum.
The Muslims ejected all the Jews from their lands. The Deletion of Palestine is the result of the actions of Muslim regimes of the past. The change of borders is a constant, there is no reason to think that new states cannot be born and other cannot die.
What’s becoming so obvious to people now is that colonialism has never ended just rebranded with different terms. From Natives indigenous people being called “savages” in the old days to now being called “terrorist” by neocolonialists who are neoliberals, neoconservatives, and zionist. 1) Savages is now “terrorist” 2) Civilizing them is now “bringing them democracy” 3) Colonies is now “territories” We can all see Israel is a colonial project being supported by former and current colonials such as U.S, UK, and others who also control territories of indigenous natives in Caribbean Islands, Pacific Islands, Hawaii, and many more. The liberation of Palestine will definitely give RISE to many indigenous natives around the world to free themselves from western domination. This is the underlying ripple effect that the U.S government and its puppet allies don’t want to happen
Hats off to young beautiful Jewish queen simmon Zimmerman for making this Incredible film. I purchased this movie on Amazon. Suggest everyone to purchase in order to support this film
@@andyhodchild8 Yes just google it, there is an official website, this Documentary was released only via purchase, i watched it Pirated as soon as it was released, because its so important and needs to be seen, more than profit needs to be made, hence them shopping it out initially to Al Jazeera English and as of this week Vice picked it up because they want to throw their 5 cents in so history can say they may have cared, because the posted this documentary...i must admit they are late to the party but maybe some vice viewers dont watch Al Jazeera so i appreciate the spread ad it being on different channels. For awareness sake.
Sad stuff. Throughout my life, I’ve known many Jewish individuals who, while often conservative in their personal lifestyles, have generally leaned left politically due to their strong principles regarding human rights and justice. However, the topic of Israel/Palestine seems to reveal a more troubling side of many of their views.
@@duo315hes right tho. Jews love human rights unless they’re Palestinian or arab. It reveals a more cynical mentality that makes ppl feel like jews are deceiving others of their true intent.
theyre taught so young that this is so integral to their identity so once anyone makes any criticism of the state they think their identity is being attacked. luckily many more people are waking up to the truth
Imagine if people of that region actually practiced what's in their holy books and SHARED the "Holy Land". Instead theres a spirit of greed and selfishness.
"people", maybe read the quran and the hadiths to see the reason for all of it? if you can't put the blame where it's really at, talk about something you DO know instead.
@@whitebird357 there's no self defense in r@- pe and SA. you could say very valid point, but the way that the PA resistance is actings is just another chapter of ISIS and Al Qaida. There's most be a way for the Palestinian movement to Resist Israeli Zionism, without playing into their hands.
The very thing that happened to them during WW2 they are now (and have been for decades) doing to the Palestinian people. Yes they have suffered from some terrible acts of violence but that doesnt mean they can do the same or worse in retaliation. If someone rocked up in your country and told you this wasnt your country but belonged to them and forcibly removed you how would you feel. Tell me you wouldnt fight back. The whole problem is the British and the wider world allowed Israel to claim a land that didnt belong to them in the first place
Sexual abuse victims are more likely to abuse others. Perhaps the same is true for genocide victims. The Israelis/Jews are definitely seem to try to make that point.
What's unproductive for the conversation is to say that concentration camps are even comparable to an apartheid system, bad as it may be. What that people went through in those hellish 40s is unique in scale and depth of depravity which needs to be respected. Respected means not reducing the weight of the event by comparing it to events which have literally happened, i.e. apartheid. If pro Palestine camp cannot make at least this empathetic concession ,(something I've at least found rare), then why would jews concede the occupation is bad? I think most sane people just check out when people say Jews are doing what's been done to them. Would you honestly take your chances at a concentration camp rather than live through the nakba, or even the current siege? Generally I think Germans and generally Europe screwed the pooch yet again, by displacing Jews and not giving them safe haven even after the atrocities, and now Palestinians pay the price.
The students just reciting arguments that have zero foundation and was clearly given by the PR dude is shocking. No room for doubt, no reflection, no compassion whatsoever 42:49
They sold propaganda but what they are doing to Palestinians Lebanese etc is unreal unacceptable and barbaric. I do think the population makeup changed over the years as well as an influx of people causing them to become more aggressive as they need more land.
hasbara means explanation. if jews are the only people that are nor allowed to explain why and how and what is happening, it might just be because yiu are an antisemite. and you prolly are one. fyi antisemitism means hatred of jews in case you want to twist the meaning of the word and it is a trait that most modern antisemites inherited.
1:24:15 you don’t even understand how much better our world would be if these were the movies shown when we educate the kids. Powerful truths being said here. Seems like solid journalism as well to my basic understanding. Thanks vice team. Merry Christmas, and a Happy new Year.
As a Nigerian, I salute the young Jews who stood their grounds for justice, and I also want to draw our attention to supporting these Jews kids, as the fight isn't theirs alone, it's the fight for humanity. Thought, it's gonna be a huge top fight as the humanity will face the wealthiest organizations who controls the world militarily financially. But humanity will win at last.
It's interesting how, in the 1960s, 95% of Jews were not born in Israel. This could be compared to Spain claiming that all Latin Americans originate from there. While it's true that many of us have European ancestors, that doesn't mean our cultural, national, or personal identities are entirely tied to one single place. The stories of migration and diaspora are complex and cannot be reduced to a single connection with one country or region.
Vice....👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾 welcome back, these are the type of documentaries I have missed, the level of editing and sound design and storytelling was perfect, keep it up 💯
@@Ashantia35 without arguing with a complete stranger on the internet, I'm just going to agree with you and say yes.... Despite mentioning nothing remotely about politics/race/religion whatsoever in my comment,
Thank you Vice, this video is a must watch. I've been heavily criticized for not supporting Israel as a Jew. I do not agree with what Israel is doing with our brothers and sisters in Palestine. I pray our Jewish brothers and sisters realized they have been brainwashed and to truly stand for peace. The usual Keywords kept coming up, the same ones Ethan from H3 keeps using against Hasan. Ethan another lost brother who is spiraling.
Talking about teenagers joining the military, joining an army as "amazing" and "the best" is so weird and concerning. That also shows to me that these 18 year olds dying is not a concern to them. It shows how its is not a war with even somewhat equal sides. One side has all the power and being in tge army is just fun to them and something partiotic, with no risk to their lives.
And obviously not all see it as fun, but you see the videos from tons of IDF soldiers online. Also by "them" I mean the pro-Israelis and people indoctrinated into that mindset.
It is not the Jews that are the problem it is not the Palestinians that is the issue the conflict of interest is political/Psychological peservation of Zionism..
90% of Jews believe that Jews should have a country that is designed to protect them. That is the definition of Zionism and by your logic that would be 90% of Jews are the problem.
And who caused the Nakba ? Oh yes the Arab nation invading Israel … again expecting Israelis to sit and do nothing 🤦 but play victim because they retaliate
(Jewish/Christian) Judea & Samaria = (Muslim) West Bank ......just like.....(Russian) Kiev = (Ukranian) Kyiv 22:20 The Palestinian Tour Guide grew up in "Bethlehem" in the "West Bank". The choice to call the region "West Bank" instead of its historic name "Bethlehem in Judea" is a deliberate choice to support "that" side. I'm just saying, there aren't any neutral parties. There are no "objective" points of view.
Live as free men. But do not use your freedom as an excuse to do evil. Live as servants of God. Show respect for all people. Love the brothers and sisters of God’s family. Respect God. Honor the king.
Thank you, this was so insightful. I've been seeing pro Palestinian protests, and I was told they were about supporting Hamas, hating and getting rid of Jews. This explains and shows that it's about people with humanity, who want dignity and freedom for Palestinians and Jews to live in peace and stop hurting each other. I feel so brainwashed by governments and media who manipulate us to maintain power for themselves. Regular common people everywhere just want to live in peace, safety and dignity.
Imagine someone coming to your home and claiming it by saying, “god gave it to them” would you accept it or resist like the Palestinians are doing? The world stands with Palestine 🇵🇸!
What the young man in the army was explaining what they did to the Palestinians sounds like they were treating the Palestinians as the Germanys treated the Jews before sending them to the death camps. It doesn’t sound like the Palestinian people are the same as Hamas but what the Jews do to them is horrible harassment. Does that create the terrorists?
If u condemned ongoing genocide in gaza committed by Israeli occupation terrorists forces then your comment is censored or deleted by social media platforms. This level of support for genocidal regime by silencing people is very dangerous for whole humanity
Dive into some of the most outstanding feature films available, for free, on VICE: shorturl.at/yEJZ0
This piece is gross. Super anti semetic. Answer the question? Why is Israel limiting Palestinian movement? ... your answer is that Israel is cruel?
Ireland stands proudly with Palestine
Where else in the world can Jews openly express their Jewish identity without being subjected to verbal, physical or online abuse ? No where else but Israel.🔯 🇮🇱
100 years ago, most Arab countries had large Jewish communities. Now there are very few Jewish communities living in Arab countries due to anti Jewish racism. Only 3 Jews live in Syria in 2024. Very few Pro Palestine supporters dare to mention it, let alone discuss this openly.
Imagine what has been done to the Palestinians off camera.
They played pocker and had a beer
palestinians who named themselves a false indentidy palestinians (means "invaders" originated from philistine) claimed to be indegenous but erase the aboriginous jws from Dome of rock. funny. why dont we create Meccaians who built a country on top of Mecca and be rocognized by the muslim countries?
Palestine isnt a real thing, that was invented in the last century.
@@RifndjsklljuwhdnchAfacnxla so are they instead Greek? 😂
@@RifndjsklljuwhdnchAfacnxla do you know how many foreign names there are in the Levant and North Africa? Does it mean the citizens of Alexandria of Egypt are Macedonians?
An American born kid, growing up in America, claiming land and rights in a country across the world is peak colonialism. I get connecting to your roots, but saying a place you have never been to owes you anything is incredibly fucked up.
Yes - it is like a kid born in America of French parents, who claims France as his homeland - its colonialism NOT !
Silly Boy !
@@bluestar6879 well, the settlers arrived on ships to a land with a people.
@@bluestar6879 I understand you believe that all Jews are from Israel, but when you look into the history of the area the reason why so many “Arab” peasant farmers in Palestine held Jewish traditions from the Old Testament is because many Israelites chose other religions over time. Hellenistic religions, Christianity, Islam. That’s why when you take samples of genetic DNA from Israelite sites the closest living relatives are Samaritans and Palestinians. Levantine Arabs are not from Arabia. They’re not real Arabs. Neither are Moroccans or Sudanese or Egyptians by the way. So having a group of people come from outside and claim the entire land of Israel for themselves is a bit threatening in that context, no?
@@shannonweatherly3940 precisely, just how Native Americans predominantly speak English now, doesn't mean they are not sons of the soil. Palestinians are pretty much the same people who were there thousands of years ago, they just adopted the language of those who came to rule over them (Umayyads, etc).
@@gangstanongrataI agree! The way I explain it to people is Mexicans speak Spanish language, have a Spanish culture, and adopted a Spanish religion aka Christianity. They identify as Hispanic aka from Spain. But they’re native because the majority of their ancestors are from Mexico going back thousands of years. I think a lot of people don’t realize Arab and Arabian are different. Once you see “Arabs” stand together and you see white skin, brown skin, black skin, red hair, brown hair, black hair, blue eyes, brown eyes, green eyes, then it starts to click they’re not homogenous for a reason. I’ve visited several Arab countries and the genetic, cultural, and linguistic differences are VAST.
I am American. My ex boyfriend was former IDF. He was absolutely insane, abusive and I barely escaped with my life. Changed the entire way I view Israel, not for the better.
Hey, I am an Israeli, I once dated elon musk and angelina jolie simultanously, they were both very toxic and now I hate the US.
Do you see how stupid that sounds?
95% of Israel are ex-IDF, if you dated a toxic person it doesn't reflect on the whole Israeli society, you get me? no? that's ok.. go out, touch some grass.
@mingo2024 Every Israeli (more or less) is a "former IDF" and if your ex boyfriend was "insane" it has nothing to do with the IDF ..
If i'll judge "Americans" by what I see in universities/Media etc, i'll recommend the U.S. will turn into one big Mental-house ... so ... I hope you are smart enough to understand the stupidity in your comment
You saw the truth, so believe me it was for the better.
I am an Israeli , i served the army. We are troumtic and post troumtic nation. I AM PEACE PERSON. We are good, smart, and not only crazy... We Are humens! Spred love that will bring love. I am sorry about what hapenned to you...
what about the palestinians who you treat worse than animals? are they not humans?
Used to be Zionsit. After becoming an athiest it was like a veil being lifted from my eyes.
Really embarrassing of how much I dehumanized Palestinians and Muslims. I hope they become free.
It shows testament to your character that when presented with new information, you changed your opinion accordingly. It's not your fault that you were most probably indoctrinated from a young age, but what you do with that new information is what matters. That's your humanity prevailing over cultism through ethno-nationalism.
Being a Zist has nothing to do with your racism toward As. That’s a you problem. Zism is simply the belief that Js are deserving of a state of their own, where they are the majority and therefore safe, and where their culture is reflected - in the land to which they are indigenous. Izzz is no different than any Native American reservation, except for a 20% non-tribe member population.
@@joge2468 hey so this is insane. Zionism is a form of ethno-nationalism. It’s inherently racist in its nature. But stay delusional I suppose lol
Learn the history of the conflict. Israel is defending itself from people who dont want peace nor living side by side. Once you truly get it, you'll see things differently. Clearly, you have no clue what it is like that people wants to kill you just because of your belief.
Freeing the "Palestinians" requires the abolishment and genocide of Jews. "Freeing Islam" will only produce a Caliphate ruled by Sharia Law. TBH Palestine has no "right" to exist, what keeps Palestinians from surrender and joining Israel is antisemitism.
I've never felt more seen by a film. I love being Jewish and I love my community, but once I learned about Palestine I felt great shame. I will never understand how people so hurt and harmed could even think of doing this to others, especially with a religion that promotes good deeds and empathy. I hate being forcibly connected to such awful acts, I hate that my own friends and relatives believe everything Israel has told them. I first started to change my mind upon seeing videos from individual families suffering in Gaza, and couldn't believe that people I'm supposed to be on the same side with would do this to other people. So much shame for these zionists who call themselves Jewish. ❤🇵🇸
Same. There’s a lot of us “self-hating” Jews out here, and we’re growing by the day as people start to educate themselves.
It's human inclination to self deceive when dealt with something soo uncomfortable.
Instead of changing ourselves to get rid of that discomfort, we often tell ourselves lies that makes us feel comfortable.
No one wants to believe that their whole life was built on lies.
I’m very proud of all of you 🥺 you’re powerful
Don't think your self loathing will spare you - they'll just come after you once they're done with the rest of us.
a lot of my friends and family beleive that supporting the existance of the state of israel means that you have to support the terrible leaders, and the genocide they are commiting too. i will always push for the state of israel, but that doesnt mean I have to support war crimes.
Israel doing what happened to them to others is wild
You still believe the official world war two narrative after all this?
Still believe the official narrative that we have been told for 80 years?
Lol that's bullshit. 40,000 deaths is not even slightly comparable.
@@scoon2117 youre saying since october 7 2023 or 1948?
It’s literally one of the lowest causality counts for civilians in urban combat in history. If this is gnocide then they are pretty bad at it/
Regardless of your faith, religion or culture, if your life is imparting harm, pain, dissonance or death onto others, you have failed to see yourself in them and the main message of love from our common creator.
You're talking about Hamas right?
Why is it regardless of faith if the basis og the muslim faith is to take over the world and the only religions they allow to live as second hand citizens(google dhimmi and jizyah) are jews, christians and sabeans?
Same faith says that in the end days they will kill all the jews in the world.
Again, how is it "regardless of faith"?
@@heliosperegrinHamas is just as bad as Israeli government, both harm innocent people . There’s no Hamas in the West Bank yet the IDF is mistreating the civilians there nonstop
@@panchitz13 if its a fictional god then they don't need Isisrahell do they?
@@heliosperegrin I guess you are they guy the original comment was referring to, that you failed to see yourself in other people. Shame on you buddy.
The parallels between this and Germany in the '30s is scary. Hard to watch this knowing what's going on.
EXACTLY. The Israeli government is to Palestinians as the German government was to the Jewish population.
@ yea man, what do we do about it with peace and love to all man
@@katrabbit Ahkmeeds are to non ahkmeeds what the german government was to jews.
Leibowitz said that the danger is, that the Israeli government learned the methods of Nazis.. Einstein called the pre party of Likud fascist as many others
How they celebrate their fascism openly. Even in children books and all these youth organisations and trips.
Yea….thats a cult.
Definitely a cult
Definitely how do Jewish kids not see this. You’re Israeli government gives you talking points and you think you’re thinking for yourselves.
its actually nationalism which you could call a cult to some degree any way.
The cult of nationalism at the intersection of religious fundamentalism. Weaponized trauma 😢
100%. Not representing even 0.1%.
I'm Jewish and this is so embarrasing. Nationalism and colonialism are not good.
You should be embarressed. I'm from middle east and the only civilized country in our region is israel. Palestine could have benefitted from this but they refuse. Simple as that. The concept of Palestine in every sense has been a colonial entity. Is it too much to ask that jews may have 22000 km2 small patch of crappy land to live in? Or you believe that this tiny patch...should be added to 13 million km2 of land that arabs claim? Btw why is nationalism bad only for the jews?
You didn't mention genocide, brutalization and oppression
@@___Anakin.Skywalker if they wanted genocide... they can do it within a few hours.... this means they are not aiming at a genocide. Oppression? Hamas.... hahaha sure
Yes it is. And there is no colonization in Israel
@farsalami8605 These are kamala voters, bro. I volunteered for IDF for 4 years. This is all lies. So many young girls converting over with boys and teenagers. Vice is left wing. So of course they make some ANTI Semitic video.
Another example of just how true it is that hurt people hurt people.
I keep saying this. 💯 It's what it's like trying to reason with some of my distant family about this
An American, From Brooklyn, NY who is of European origin...claiming a land east of the Mediterranean because his ancestors lived there thousands of years ago? But a Palestinian who is from the east Mediterranean can't have "birth right/aliyah" whose father lived there 70 years ago? Sounds legit!
what about the mizrahi jews😳😳
Mizrahi jews fro morroco can live in morroco. Iraqi jews can live in iraq. Yemeni jews can live in yemen. Being a black man in angola does not entitle you to land in Zimbabwe just because both countries are black @desireesachs3878
@desireesachs3878 even mizrahi is a wide range - it just vaguely means eastern jews. They can be georgian, yemenite, libyan etc.
If anything, that furthers my point.
@ no it does not obviously you don’t know that mizrahi jews are from the middle east countries like Iran, Iraq, syria, yemen etc… look it up. the ashkenazi jews are from europe and the sephardic jews are from morocco, spain and portugal. ethiopian jews are from ethiopia. if you going to speak, speak facts not hard to find them.
@ georgian is in europe… not the middle east and it is not vague… Mitzrahi jews are arabs that are jewish
I rented this film like 5 times. I'm glad it is spreading worldwide. It deserves to go viral.
For years, I supported Israel due to my father's influence, as he obtained his news from mainstream media sources. However, in 2017/18, I stumbled upon a video of Ross Kemp interviewing Hamas fighters, Palestinian civilians, Israeli citizens, and IDF members. This prompted me to delve deeper into the conflict and conduct extensive research. As I began studying the history of civilization up to the present day, I made a startling discovery that completely altered my perspective. This revelation was truly eye-opening and forever changed my views. I have since made it my mission to educate others, including my children, about the reality of Israel as an apartheid state.
But Israel isn't an Apartheid State. You might want to restart your research.
My goodness, you lost your mind...
israel is the single country in our region where the " rule of law" regns. Get over your hate... breath
you have been misguided and should study history not propaganda and fake news stories
@@shardanette1 what the hell is the so called "Hafrada" policy then?
It's so baffling that young people are seeing videos online of Palestinians suffering and Israel's only response is to tell them that the videos don't tell the whole story and that there is historical context that makes the images okay.
I'm a young Jewish American and former Zionist, so I think I can speak on this. The answer is, they believe all those videos are fake and Arabs are catastrophizing the plight of Palestinians. I now know that the plight is very much real
"Israelism"
That's just zionism
@@gogetyourgun1490 pasestine thats just hamas terrorism
The film is literally critiquing Zionism.
@wtpaige so why don't use it?
synonyms just like antisemitism and judophobia are
cry about it
If people think there are bad cops in America, they definitely should not watch this! These kids aka soldiers violating people’s human rights is mind blowing!
Classic line:
Palestinian woman: you are stealing my land.
Israeli dude: if I don’t someone else will.
WOOOOW I’m shocked
Yeah I know Jacob from new york
Its hillariously dark .....
My cousin, who is a doctor is currently volunteering in Gaza. I'm so scared for her saftey! I'm also immensely proud of her!!! I wish I could do more to help the people of Palestine
The way he talks about millennials like we are children and not middle-aged.
i am.... middle aged? 😐
I mean you guys kind of are like middle aged children
kinda Infantiles
you are children
I’m not middle aged…yet 😂
30:30 What an excuse for sin. The Lord did not favor Israel for these terrible things to happen. I believe the bible says the Lord will abandon Israel when they commit such behaviors.
It does, but they love to ignore those pesky parts that don't justify their bloodlust
You are casting aspersions onto Israel...which is fighting BACK, not first. No mention if terrorists promise to commit these attacks AGAIN AND AGAIN...no...you are only here to villify the people whose culture you attempt to appropriate...no...GIVE BACK.
G-D will have His way with you 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 sucks to be you now don't it
He literally did in the past
I admire someone who knows Gods words, or Christian scripture, in some ways we were better in the times our religions were given to us and formed. Thats what i tell people who say The Bible and all of that is man made, I say...Maybe, but see, see the difference in the books they wrote back then and the books they write today? From the Torah, Bible and Quran...to 50 shades of grey and tabloids.
The Bible says ; Live as free men. But do not use your freedom as an excuse to do evil. Live as servants of God. 17 Show respect for all people. Love the brothers and sisters of God’s family. Respect God. Honor the king. - But everyone wants to play Satan and the silly bugger.
20:32 when he spoke about the Check points, it took me back to our Apartheid days in South Africa. 😢
damn tell me your story please
There wouldn't be checkpoints if there were no terror attacks (suicide bombings, stabbings and shootings). The checkpoints only appeared after the intifada's.
Yes I'd like to know also please your story.
Also who are the people that implemented the apartheid system in South africa and also were the South African government complicit.
womp womp welcome to earth
@@sentrrss womp womp go away from earth
Crazy levels of ethno-nationalism that I have never seen before. Horrifying.
You need to do that to maintain an expansionist settler colony
In gaza jews can enter only as hostages. Otherwise in israel, 20% of population is arab Palestinian. Where do you see crazy levels of ethno nationalism?
"never seen before" I am curious if you are insane or if you have ignored pretty much all of history.
Borders are and have never been constant. Borders always change, and the locals have to defend their lands from invaders. The so called "Palestinians" failed to defend themselves and they face the consequences of being a dominated people.
There is no reason to think that borders should not change.
The Nazis had much more ethno-nationalism than the Jews, so did the USSR. The Chinese currently also have significantly more ethno-nationalism than the Jews. The Native Americans also have a high amount of ethno-nationalism.
@@Bdbtg28691 Have you ever taken a look at the constitution of a Native American reservation? Would you deny any of them the right to say their nation is for them alone? Among tribal nations, Izzzrael has the largest minority population on the planet. Wake up. Btw, it won’t be long before Europeans demand their countries be for them. Those that don’t, will soon be Islic.
@ericcartmann i think they mean in modern times. Like something they can actually see and experience happening in their lifetime
Growing up during Apartheid South Africa, some of these images bring up all the bad memories.
It's no coincidence that Iss was an ally of SA's apartheid government.
Oh give me a break, self proclaimed SA. I doubt you know what Apartheid is, and I doubt even more that you ever been to West Bank.
seems like you aren't aware that both Israel, the west bank and gaza all run by different enteties, there is no possible way this falls under the definition of apartheid unless you alter the definition first.. oh wait.
@Omkuskom yawn. Bad hasbara
@@Omkuskom bad hasbara
“When education is not liberating, the dream of the oppressed is to become the oppressor”
They don’t understand that the reason they are under threat is because of occupation. It is a vicious cycle, somebody needs to break this cycle.
These young Jews speaking out give me some hope
They are actors in a propaganda documentary that will only be consumed by leftiods.
This comment section really shows how some are sheepish and blind if Israel is so nice and good just do a small research on black jews and how they are treated in Israel if their own people get kinda treatment what treatment will the Palestinian get just think about it and if you are still supporting the Israel narrative without any doubts you are truly lost
Forced sterilisations if I'm not mistaken. Israel truly is a fundamentally sick society.
I feel like the comment section shows that people are waking up to being not blind.
@musicaldramaqueen I pray you're right
lol are you insane, Israel sent it's special forces to *rescue* black jews and bring them into Israel. Is there another country in the world who have airlifted Africans into a country instead of kicking them out? Is there some racism? yes, there;s racism in canada and the US even, but in israel it's far better than anywhere else in the middle east. Stop believing everything you see on Al Jazeera. And google what the Arab governments do to blacks.
Israel did nothing wrong.
This only shows an ounce of what Palestinians experience. 💔
The fakestinians do not exist.
They are as fake as the Egyptian mass murderer who invented them in the 1970s.
As a Palestinian living in Occupied Jerusalem,we see and come across lots of foreigner jews (especially Americans) who are on birthright trips or any other trip with similar goals.What the Palestinian guy from Bethlehem said was true,they have more rights than any Palestinian(wether living in the west bank,jerusalem,gaza,or the in areas occuppied in 1948),and get treated and act like they're natives and owners of this land.
i Always wondered when i saw them or came across them,have those people ever heard about,talked,or got exposed to Palestinians,what if I talk to them?what if i tell them a couple of the stories that either happened to me or to someone i know?would those people actually realize they're being deceived and lied to?would they empathise with Palestinians?or are we really less than humans in their eyes?
Great report,lots of love and respect to those who woke up and saw the truth,and fight back against Opression,and i would be more than happy to one day have the oppurtunity to talk to one,show them around my beloved Jerusalem,and how the occupation makes our life harder each and everyday in it.
As a jew living in jerusalem I'm allways for dialog I wish I could take the birthright kids to eat hummus and see the whole of this land. Again terrorism is never justified by my book. It's never okay to fire a rocket or run into some ones home and kill a father in front of his kids on video cause that's what happened on Oct 7. I'm for freedom just don't give hamas anything I encouraged israelies to give money to hamas and now I feel that this was a huge mistake did the millions we gave them help gaza be free? Did hamas do a genocide or is this what you call resistance? Is kidnapping people and holding them hostage infornt of the world ever justified? It happend. Now what. I'm still in jerusalem and I still have Muslim friends and I believe that we can all be safe and free if we focus on being good to ourselves and our families. I'm proud to say I support my arab brothers by encouraging education and by doing things that will help their own community life community gardens and cleaning up the streets if your from east jerusalem you will understand that jerusalem is cleaner then halil or hebron and that not because of terrorist but because there are people who work all day to make it clean those people are both arab and Jewish and that's who I respect hard working good people that don't work in politics.
If someone else is the blame for everything is terror justified or even celebrated? Your garden looks like a mess and your not cleaning it is this my fault?! Do you know how meny tones of trash i took out of silwan so that people wouldnt burn it and kill their own children from deadly smoke inhalation?!
Yes israel has issues but it's still better then letting all the tribes here kill each other for honor or cause one of their daughters may date someone from the wrong tribe so let's go honor kill them all right? Is that the kind of Islam that you believe in? I mean there is good and bad people on both sides just try to be good. Sorry for the long reply but I'd love to actually meet in person and talk cause you might be surprised.
Ma'a salama
We are fully aware of whats happening in Gaza and the West Bank. It’s not ideal but this is the situation “Palestinians” forced us into. If you guys would accept that the state of Israel is going to exist forever and if you guys were committed to peaceful relations with us, “Palestinians” wouldnt have the problems they have. And yes we are natives to this land. There has only been one country in this region in all of history, and thats Israel. When it wasnt a jewish country, it was a colony under a foreign empire. We have a right to have a country here.
@@tag6502 the Jews left black and came back white.
@@tag6502The moment you put " Palestinians " we knew you support genocide
amen my friend
@@tag6502 What I don't understand is that Jews believe God exiled them until the Messiah comes and frees them from their exile! Where is the Messiah? Netanyahu thinks he has to pave the way for the Messiah, but the Messiah has to come before not after the establishment of Israel, which is a view shared by some ultra-orthodox jews themselves! I think they are scared shitless of God as of currently!
I love how this documentary is on multiple platforms for free. The creators are so passionate about spreading the information! Well done Simone
A religion can’t be a geographical place. That’s doesn’t make sense!
It's the homeland of the Jewish people
that’s a cult.
Israel is a death cult built on lies and apartheid.
Yeah I know how they indoctrinate those young Jewish kids to believe that Palestinians aren’t really human is awful.
☪️☪️☪️☪️ correct
It’s so funny how Zi0n!s+s constantly want to a++ack & disrespect Is|am & Chr!s+ianity. Everyone needs to read the Ta|mud & you will see what they think of our beloved Jesus who is a prophet in Is|am not just Chr!s+ianity. They mock our faiths & try to pin us against eachother. They make our American men fight their w@rs. Too bad for them it’s not 2001 & their Is|amph0bia & propaganda & l!es just don’t work anymore!!!
(A🇮🇱N(ER of the world = 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
For the (bot) comment claim this video is one-sided. Yes, you're right. Just like the ICC, the UN, the UNRWA, the Red Cross, the Oxfam, the Human Right Watch, the Amnesty International, the 146 countries in General Assembly is one-sided. The only two side-honest-true story is by Netanyahu 😂😂😂.
I had no idea that an American citizen could join another nation's army.
See French Legionares
The fact that we get free videos on RUclips by VICE is truly a gift; keeping education and knowledge alive. 👍🙏🤷
Ethno nationalism is bad
You might want to talk to all the barA countries about that. Oh, and all the Native American tribes.
israel might be the only non
Ethno nationalism country in the middle east lol
Does lying help you sleep better at night? IsraHe|| wins at gen0c!de, aparthe!d, & ethn!c cleansing. You want to peddle the H@sbara lie that it’s the only democracy in the Middle East, yet it’s laughable.
@@idojakoby1794 Israel and Arab countries,Turkey,Iran and Egypt including Palestine are racist,xenophobia,bigotry and prejudice countries it is unbelievable and sad.
And what do you think the Palestinians want?
nice to see VICE do journalism again
they just bought the rights to the documentary, it originally aired on aljazeera
If only, they didn’t make this they’re just showing it on their channel
One-sided journalism yes
😂😂😂
Was thinking the same thing. They became awful for a while. When they used to do such hard hitting real on the ground journalism
Everyone needs to see this
This was so well done and hopefully eye-opening to the American Jews that choose to join the IDF or become settlers. I hope this is the start of a new movement that sees the Palestinians as people of the land that have more rights than an American born Jewish person.
Why should they have more rights than us? Everyone in Israel should have equal rights. We believe all Jews have a connection to Israel
@@tovahjustic556 Not the jews from eastern europe tho....DNA test prove it.
Expansionism isn't self defense.
You do realize that the armies of Islam rampaged across North Africa, Spain, the Balkans, and Central Asia right after it was founded, right?
@@andybarr6751owh youre soul still live in that era?
Hopefully you can move on to the 20th century Geezz...
Was just watching how they target killed this farmer that was interviewed trying to grow some food near his tent
wtf.... you got more details?
@@redrumreverse964Bruh! Watch other news channels other than corporate media
They also burn olive trees.
I’m not trying to be offensive but this seems cultish. And I’m not talking about the religion aspects because anyone can make a cult argument for any religion. But just because of your religion they want to make u go to Israel to see it, then when ur there they drill into your head that you need to learn military commands in the middle of the night, you learn to shoot guns for the 1st time, they teach you the talking points to fight against “lies”, then it’s seen as a community get together to do lobbying on behalf of AIPAC which isn’t even for the betterment of Jewish Americans but for the benefit of the country of Israel. I sympathize with why Jews want a country but the modern Zionism movement seems suspicious.
Its more than just them wanting country. They are very much capable of buying empty lands and built country there. In fact Russia has given them plot of lands before.
Suspicious is understatement. They are literally act like Nazis!
Good Israelis have been talking about it if you look for it. Former IDF soldiers who got themselves free from the indoctrination have been talking about it for a long time!
Russia also had pogroms
"israelism"? Oh, you're you mean rebranded zionism, why not just say that?
No they just made up a term out of nowhere. But I guess it makes sense you think the concept of Israel being allowed to exist is a slur
@@AL-lh2ht you're funny
@@AL-lh2htZionist like to redefine words to obfuscate their meaning. And Zionism as a word is one of those. Where no one is allowed to know its history or meaning. Use of the word is supposedly been rebranded as “antisemitic” when technically Zionism and Israel as a concept is the most antisemitic current regime. Since the Palestinians are also - a Semitic people… And the concept of Zionism is ethnic cleansing a core minimum.
The film is critiquing Zionism.
everyone agrees zionism is bad for you you but the thing is they want to Kill everyone!
as they say is TIME to make the enemy PAY the price!
Being Jews is cool but being IDF is a no no
I am a moslem, I have a different POV of jews and IDF.
Jews, Moslem, Christian live there in peace before 1948 said an ortodox rabbi in an interview.
Thank you to my all my true jews brothers & sisters for speaking the truth & support. Also, heath felt thanks to Vice being wise as always. 🇵🇸 🕊️
Seek peace and you'll find it
Stop the genocide
Hell yeah! My grandparents are Jews that fled from Afghanistan, I'd love to go back but they genocided us across the Arab and Muslim world.
@@idansim1you can’t commit genocide against Muslims and not expect a blowback, come on, don’t play dumb
The Muslims ejected all the Jews from their lands.
The Deletion of Palestine is the result of the actions of Muslim regimes of the past. The change of borders is a constant, there is no reason to think that new states cannot be born and other cannot die.
Free the hostages
Just because they are losing a war does not make it a genocide.
What’s becoming so obvious to people now is that colonialism has never ended just rebranded with different terms. From Natives indigenous people being called “savages” in the old days to now being called “terrorist” by neocolonialists who are neoliberals, neoconservatives, and zionist.
1) Savages is now “terrorist”
2) Civilizing them is now “bringing them democracy”
3) Colonies is now “territories”
We can all see Israel is a colonial project being supported by former and current colonials such as U.S, UK, and others who also control territories of indigenous natives in Caribbean Islands, Pacific Islands, Hawaii, and many more.
The liberation of Palestine will definitely give RISE to many indigenous natives around the world to free themselves from western domination. This is the underlying ripple effect that the U.S government and its puppet allies don’t want to happen
I'm so proud of these Jewish people who are standing up for the Palestinians against the ZIONIST MONSTERS!
Same way, I'm so proud of Palestinians who standing against the ISLAMIST INFIDELS aka Hamaas.
Hats off to young beautiful Jewish queen simmon Zimmerman for making this Incredible film. I purchased this movie on Amazon. Suggest everyone to purchase in order to support this film
Not Amazon because that's to Boycott. Must be available elsewhere?
@@andyhodchild8 Yes just google it, there is an official website, this Documentary was released only via purchase, i watched it Pirated as soon as it was released, because its so important and needs to be seen, more than profit needs to be made, hence them shopping it out initially to Al Jazeera English and as of this week Vice picked it up because they want to throw their 5 cents in so history can say they may have cared, because the posted this documentary...i must admit they are late to the party but maybe some vice viewers dont watch Al Jazeera so i appreciate the spread ad it being on different channels. For awareness sake.
I am a Muslim Arab professor, and I stand for Jews for Peace and against Zionism.
As a professor, you know the actual dictionary definition of Zionism, don't you? If so, are you against the existence of Israel?
You aren't a professor but kinda rookie learn material better
@@AntonAdelsonhere's a professor
ruclips.net/video/LX5jHbfnzXA/видео.htmlsi=fH5fk3J4l1cpHcFu
@@volumeone2812here's another professor
ruclips.net/video/LX5jHbfnzXA/видео.htmlsi=fH5fk3J4l1cpHcFu
@@AntonAdelson Judaism isn't Zionism.
Thank you to these Jewish people who are speaking out you are some of the strongest and loudest advocates out there
Sad stuff. Throughout my life, I’ve known many Jewish individuals who, while often conservative in their personal lifestyles, have generally leaned left politically due to their strong principles regarding human rights and justice. However, the topic of Israel/Palestine seems to reveal a more troubling side of many of their views.
and a more troubling side of many of your views. that you would single out Jews and the Jewish State for criticism is utterly abhorrent
@ it’s the topic of the video?
@@broilergivenquirkily I'm referring to you, not the video
@@duo315 Am I supposed to mention Saudi Arabia’s mistreatment of women in a video about Zionists demonizing dissenting Jews? K.
@@duo315hes right tho. Jews love human rights unless they’re Palestinian or arab. It reveals a more cynical mentality that makes ppl feel like jews are deceiving others of their true intent.
These young Jews speaking for Palestinians are so brave! That is the generation that will change the world! It saddens me I won’t get to see it
theyre taught so young that this is so integral to their identity so once anyone makes any criticism of the state they think their identity is being attacked. luckily many more people are waking up to the truth
Imagine if people of that region actually practiced what's in their holy books and SHARED the "Holy Land". Instead theres a spirit of greed and selfishness.
It's not greed and selfishness as much as it is fear and self-defense.
@@whitebird357 Israel doesnt deserve to exist is the bottom line
"people", maybe read the quran and the hadiths to see the reason for all of it?
if you can't put the blame where it's really at, talk about something you DO know instead.
Sharing Israel with mire than 2 million arabs
@@whitebird357 there's no self defense in r@- pe and SA. you could say very valid point, but the way that the PA resistance is actings is just another chapter of ISIS and Al Qaida. There's most be a way for the Palestinian movement to Resist Israeli Zionism, without playing into their hands.
The very thing that happened to them during WW2 they are now (and have been for decades) doing to the Palestinian people. Yes they have suffered from some terrible acts of violence but that doesnt mean they can do the same or worse in retaliation. If someone rocked up in your country and told you this wasnt your country but belonged to them and forcibly removed you how would you feel. Tell me you wouldnt fight back. The whole problem is the British and the wider world allowed Israel to claim a land that didnt belong to them in the first place
Sexual abuse victims are more likely to abuse others. Perhaps the same is true for genocide victims. The Israelis/Jews are definitely seem to try to make that point.
What's unproductive for the conversation is to say that concentration camps are even comparable to an apartheid system, bad as it may be. What that people went through in those hellish 40s is unique in scale and depth of depravity which needs to be respected. Respected means not reducing the weight of the event by comparing it to events which have literally happened, i.e. apartheid.
If pro Palestine camp cannot make at least this empathetic concession ,(something I've at least found rare), then why would jews concede the occupation is bad?
I think most sane people just check out when people say Jews are doing what's been done to them. Would you honestly take your chances at a concentration camp rather than live through the nakba, or even the current siege?
Generally I think Germans and generally Europe screwed the pooch yet again, by displacing Jews and not giving them safe haven even after the atrocities, and now Palestinians pay the price.
Comparing WW2 to Gaza is naive at best.
I don’t remember them gassing and incinerating millions of Palestinians
Except the arabs where the ones who supported Shitler !
Read about Haj Amin Al Husseini.
Whoops.
I’m Palestinian and cannot bring myself to watch this in its entirety, the imagery…
The students just reciting arguments that have zero foundation and was clearly given by the PR dude is shocking. No room for doubt, no reflection, no compassion whatsoever 42:49
They sold propaganda but what they are doing to Palestinians Lebanese etc is unreal unacceptable and barbaric. I do think the population makeup changed over the years as well as an influx of people causing them to become more aggressive as they need more land.
FREE PALESTINE !!! 🇵🇸
sounds and feels like a cult.
Hasbara bots going to be busy tonight
hasbara means explanation.
if jews are the only people that are nor allowed to explain why and how and what is happening, it might just be because yiu are an antisemite.
and you prolly are one.
fyi antisemitism means hatred of jews in case you want to twist the meaning of the word
and it is a trait that most modern antisemites inherited.
Said Iranian bot lol
Do you even know what "Hasbara" means?
@Cloudbuster1987 isn't it covering up thaapatheid, ethnic cleansing and genocide Gainst the Palestinians with state sanctioned bullshit?
@@dwai963 eww don’t call
Me Iranian
Not sure where this is going but cant even bear to watch more than 3 minutes of this...
1:24:15 you don’t even understand how much better our world would be if these were the movies shown when we educate the kids. Powerful truths being said here. Seems like solid journalism as well to my basic understanding. Thanks vice team. Merry Christmas, and a Happy new Year.
The amount of times I had to skip an ad while watching this 84 minute video was insane!!!
I'm so happy my eyes have been opened to this issue. It took a lot of de-programing.
I'm glad you are awake brother,
Peace and blessings to you and your family.
Try to spread the message ❤
It is a cult that happen to have a piece of land as their base
As a Nigerian, I salute the young Jews who stood their grounds for justice, and I also want to draw our attention to supporting these Jews kids, as the fight isn't theirs alone, it's the fight for humanity. Thought, it's gonna be a huge top fight as the humanity will face the wealthiest organizations who controls the world militarily financially. But humanity will win at last.
Israel is a complete embarrassment and disappointment!! I stand with Palestine!!
of course you do you are irish that supported IRA terrorism 😳
0:12 my god the cringe!😬
Lalalaaalaallaa
It's a cult
I'm jealous of their unity
1000000 observations skills 😂😂😂 I believe no one noticed until you pointed out
So glad to see VICE always uncovering real undisclosed public information
lol kids when it’s them and 18-19 year olds are full grown adults when it’s Palestinians. Even 15 year olds they don’t see as kids. 17:35
Not all Jews are sionists.
And vice versa.
We are all humans first and foremost 😢
It's interesting how, in the 1960s, 95% of Jews were not born in Israel. This could be compared to Spain claiming that all Latin Americans originate from there. While it's true that many of us have European ancestors, that doesn't mean our cultural, national, or personal identities are entirely tied to one single place. The stories of migration and diaspora are complex and cannot be reduced to a single connection with one country or region.
:( .. they are doing this again in Syria now
It's heartbreaking 😭💔
Vice doing journalism again! 👏👏
They stopped being journalists in favor of a propaganda machine long ago
The truth comes out when the Zionist stop talking.
Defund Israel.
Vice....👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾 welcome back, these are the type of documentaries I have missed, the level of editing and sound design and storytelling was perfect, keep it up 💯
One sided narrative is what you like huh
@@Ashantia35 without arguing with a complete stranger on the internet, I'm just going to agree with you and say yes.... Despite mentioning nothing remotely about politics/race/religion whatsoever in my comment,
thanks for showing this docu. important.
This is absolutely terrifying and sad
Thank you Vice, this video is a must watch. I've been heavily criticized for not supporting Israel as a Jew. I do not agree with what Israel is doing with our brothers and sisters in Palestine. I pray our Jewish brothers and sisters realized they have been brainwashed and to truly stand for peace. The usual Keywords kept coming up, the same ones Ethan from H3 keeps using against Hasan. Ethan another lost brother who is spiraling.
33:33 Another act of thievery. What kind of guest is this? How does one act as host to such disgraceful behavior?
“I learned a long time ago, there’s no way you can say ‘no’ to Abe.”
Right there, is the crux of the problem…
Talking about teenagers joining the military, joining an army as "amazing" and "the best" is so weird and concerning. That also shows to me that these 18 year olds dying is not a concern to them. It shows how its is not a war with even somewhat equal sides. One side has all the power and being in tge army is just fun to them and something partiotic, with no risk to their lives.
And obviously not all see it as fun, but you see the videos from tons of IDF soldiers online. Also by "them" I mean the pro-Israelis and people indoctrinated into that mindset.
This is brain washing on an other level
It is not the Jews that are the problem it is not the Palestinians that is the issue the conflict of interest is political/Psychological peservation of Zionism..
Average view of an Islamist supporter living in a tunnel.
90% of Jews believe that Jews should have a country that is designed to protect them. That is the definition of Zionism and by your logic that would be 90% of Jews are the problem.
Nakba 1948. It started there. Zionism is the issue, not Jews
And who caused the Nakba ? Oh yes the Arab nation invading Israel … again expecting Israelis to sit and do nothing 🤦 but play victim because they retaliate
Not at all. It’s a religious war
You should change the thumbnail photo to an Israeli flag or something. This will get you more views.
It doesn’t have to attract views anyone that wants to see the truth will find it on his own
(Jewish/Christian) Judea & Samaria = (Muslim) West Bank ......just like.....(Russian) Kiev = (Ukranian) Kyiv
22:20 The Palestinian Tour Guide grew up in "Bethlehem" in the "West Bank". The choice to call the region "West Bank" instead of its historic name "Bethlehem in Judea" is a deliberate choice to support "that" side. I'm just saying, there aren't any neutral parties. There are no "objective" points of view.
Live as free men. But do not use your freedom as an excuse to do evil. Live as servants of God. Show respect for all people. Love the brothers and sisters of God’s family. Respect God. Honor the king.
1:09:40 they are literally doing the Nazi salute lmaooo
Wait why are these American citizens joining a foreign military?
you should ask why the pro Ps are joining the march of ji had ists, a foreign enemy movement
For the same reason that Ukrainian living abroad joined the Ukrainian army when the war started
@@RifndjsklljuwhdnchAfacnxlaPalestinians are fighting dirty colonizers who stole their homes. Did you even watch the video hasbara shill?
Wow, Vice shared this documentary, this is a very nice sign!
Thank you, this was so insightful. I've been seeing pro Palestinian protests, and I was told they were about supporting Hamas, hating and getting rid of Jews. This explains and shows that it's about people with humanity, who want dignity and freedom for Palestinians and Jews to live in peace and stop hurting each other. I feel so brainwashed by governments and media who manipulate us to maintain power for themselves. Regular common people everywhere just want to live in peace, safety and dignity.
Thank you for sharing this documentary! I’ve been wanting to watch it for so long
Imagine someone coming to your home and claiming it by saying, “god gave it to them” would you accept it or resist like the Palestinians are doing? The world stands with Palestine 🇵🇸!
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Israel will always be here
@@user-es7en3mo1bthen you shouldn’t have to say that now would you? It shows how insecure you people really are
free them from hamas.
@@user-es7en3mo1bgo back to europe
I remember purchasing this doc on prime video. I loved it. Glad other people get to enjoy it now too.
What the young man in the army was explaining what they did to the Palestinians sounds like they were treating the Palestinians as the Germanys treated the Jews before sending them to the death camps. It doesn’t sound like the Palestinian people are the same as Hamas but what the Jews do to them is horrible harassment. Does that create the terrorists?
Extreme oppression gives rise to extreme resistance. You’ll find those situations throughout history.
If u condemned ongoing genocide in gaza committed by Israeli occupation terrorists forces then your comment is censored or deleted by social media platforms.
This level of support for genocidal regime by silencing people is very dangerous for whole humanity