Tarja, Annette, and Floor all sing very differently and direct comparison is pointless. What can be said is that all three are superb in their domains. Tarja has the most powerful voice of the three. Her voice is deeper and has a "darker" texture, and she sings the songs of her era with a level of menace. Annette can do evil - she puts in diabolical twists in Storytime and Scaretale that are truly brilliant. Her jazz voice is superb. And the lighter songs, she does without equal. Floor has the greatest range of all three and can switch styles in a fraction of a second - an achievement far beyond the capabilities of most singers. Her sustain with power is amazing - she can compete well with Rob Halford and Bruce Dickenson on that. I've seen three different claims on the dynamic range - just over three octaves (slightly more than Tarja), four, or even five. All three have limitations. Tarja does classic rock and classic opera, but that's her range. Her voice can cover three octaves (which would be damned good in any other context). Annette can do evil, yes, but struggles with fierce menace and can oy manage two and a half octaves. Floor's voice us astonishing, but she struggles with opera, the core isn't terribly strong, and although she is very good at making songs originally sung as sinister much happier (Elvenpath, Storytime), she has difficulty with menace. Anger, sure, but not diabolical tones. Really, this triad of goddesses should never be pitted against each other. They are all worthy of being loved.
они сами получают большое удовольствие - посмотрите на их руки, которыми они охватывают головы - им - это в кайф! и я рад, что слушаю их работу, вижу - и тоже обхватываю руками голову)) Они правда - молодцы! Работают честно! Виктор, из России, всем приятного прослушивания!!!
She didn't leave, she was fired for her conduct. She ignored the fans, left signings and avoided band practices. All she cared about was the money. She does not deserve your loyalty.
@@AOD_AnkGrooger But she pretty much disproved all of that shortly after the open letter was released. No other artist has spoken ill of her character since...
Rest of the world: It's only a song Marko put on eyes that devour planets and destroy civilizatons Survivors: We worship Marko Odin Forkbeard, God of Metal!
monstrueux !!! quel mise en place,et la voix !!!!
Jukka is a beast!!
True, but, Neil Peart was a beast slayer.
Tarja is the best! It was a big mistake letting her go...sry for my english
Nepravda. Floor Jansen je omnoho lepšia. Bez Floor by Nightwish nemohli existovať, čo povedal aj dám Tuomas.
Tarja, Annette, and Floor all sing very differently and direct comparison is pointless. What can be said is that all three are superb in their domains.
Tarja has the most powerful voice of the three. Her voice is deeper and has a "darker" texture, and she sings the songs of her era with a level of menace.
Annette can do evil - she puts in diabolical twists in Storytime and Scaretale that are truly brilliant. Her jazz voice is superb. And the lighter songs, she does without equal.
Floor has the greatest range of all three and can switch styles in a fraction of a second - an achievement far beyond the capabilities of most singers. Her sustain with power is amazing - she can compete well with Rob Halford and Bruce Dickenson on that. I've seen three different claims on the dynamic range - just over three octaves (slightly more than Tarja), four, or even five.
All three have limitations.
Tarja does classic rock and classic opera, but that's her range. Her voice can cover three octaves (which would be damned good in any other context).
Annette can do evil, yes, but struggles with fierce menace and can oy manage two and a half octaves.
Floor's voice us astonishing, but she struggles with opera, the core isn't terribly strong, and although she is very good at making songs originally sung as sinister much happier (Elvenpath, Storytime), she has difficulty with menace. Anger, sure, but not diabolical tones.
Really, this triad of goddesses should never be pitted against each other. They are all worthy of being loved.
@@jonathanday6692 The best freaking elaboration on the ,,tribulations'' of Nightwish. I am so sick and tired of the same old debate
Ладно я и так счастлива Вас слышать
они сами получают большое удовольствие - посмотрите на их руки, которыми они охватывают головы - им - это в кайф! и я рад, что слушаю их работу, вижу - и тоже обхватываю руками голову)) Они правда - молодцы! Работают честно!
Виктор, из России, всем приятного прослушивания!!!
MARCO IS THE BEST SINGER EVER.
From Italy :D
Tarja is the best too
@@anacarolinacb25 its been 9 years bro he is probably dead :D (just joking)
@@ardaapaydn3144 don't break my dreams kkk
The moment this woman left the band it changed sooooo much lol.
She didn't leave, she was fired for her conduct.
She ignored the fans, left signings and avoided band practices. All she cared about was the money. She does not deserve your loyalty.
@@AOD_AnkGrooger But she pretty much disproved all of that shortly after the open letter was released. No other artist has spoken ill of her character since...
Самые лучшие!
Tarja is the best!
This is a Very Good Song Planet Hell \,,/
Rest of the world: It's only a song
Marko put on eyes that devour planets and destroy civilizatons
Survivors: We worship Marko Odin Forkbeard, God of Metal!
присмотрись у Тарьи глаза не человека тоже)))
Слушайте ВСЕ!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
YEEAA NIGHTWISH
Super
kocham was .tylko tyle . KG+WR
Fuckun Great song
❤❤❤❤❤❤😊😊😊😊
Wow
JUKKAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA!
Вы как жизнь и смерть но не важно Вы прекрасны я люблю Вас❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
2019☝
Мне простой Русский женщина хочу Вас увидеть при жизни❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤😢
MARCO IS THE BEST
Garden of Terror lvl 20 choise a telent
😷
I want to tallk
Верните Дарию !!!
В смысле, Тарью? ;) )))
По нашему Дарья, просто Даша)
Подтверждаю!!!
Так как она могёт , никто не может!