I Tried 5 Stardew Valley Alternatives

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 8 сен 2024
  • Buy Stardew Valley with this link to GOG.com to support the channel for free
    adtr.co/VnGq0S
    Discord: / discord
    Twitter: / waligug_
    Farm King:
    Crop Master: Alexandra Milan, Owen, Devon L., Drake37, Bingston, Sophie Rose
    Farmer: GalaxyGhostYT, Deep Andersson, TheLoneBit, Katherine, spiritboardvalentine, llemon, Hideko Xiong, Aaron Mohl, hannah M
    Planter: Mr. Penguinpanda, Ghost_Crafting Animations, ?, Sap Is Life, Alli Sin, Def.Not.Chopsie, Jail3n
    Tiller: Wubdubles, Waligug, OneWithTheSlugs, SH Moose, All Over The Place Productions, Mathilde M, DelightfullyIdle, Megan McGeough, berosols, human, meg, lukeya01, SoullessKaj, Aldin_14 Spahic, machine dude, Declan Matthews, monke, Mgean Magette, damon bradbury, Carmen S, Night Owl, Definitely Not meH, A S H T O N, Yamaleev, CursedCheeto, Finnyssey •, Disguised Dog, Karen Leonidas, Carter Wytinck, Cassie, Jace, Nina, HopeForEscape, Warven165, Yorel, Marie Anete Nisumaa, Pearl Chan, Skye, ZergRush 222, Daphne Abernathy, tortlepanda, Brendan Vanoffern, Rowan Francois, Andy T, DwightTheIslander, Kristin Burgess, Not Lanayaru, MrKnife002, Adam Holthouse, Pixel Lucas, michael schiedemann, Alex 28712, Luna Raydue, Deresters, Seishiin

Комментарии • 257

  • @Waligug
    @Waligug  2 года назад +849

    This should go without saying but please don't send any actual hate to these developers! This video is purely for fun and I understand it's mainly one man teams working on them.

    • @Cgg_0456
      @Cgg_0456 2 года назад +30

      why would anyone hate on these people anyway?

    • @Waligug
      @Waligug  2 года назад +88

      @@Cgg_0456 not sure, internet is a wacky place!

    • @Lil-kappa
      @Lil-kappa 2 года назад +3

      Gug

    • @MonsieurWaffle
      @MonsieurWaffle 2 года назад +2

      Isn’t the second one the same game u played in the April fools video?

    • @BlackTempleGaurdian
      @BlackTempleGaurdian 2 года назад +5

      @@Cgg_0456 The copyright infringement gives them an excuse to do so, and they wanted to anyway, probably.

  • @lerryhp
    @lerryhp 2 года назад +1388

    The first game is all over the place, Portuguese on the bed, English for the tutorial, Spanish for the shop.

    • @yeryskairos
      @yeryskairos 2 года назад +260

      ir a dormir its actually spanish too lol

    • @ztarlover13
      @ztarlover13 2 года назад +4

      @@yeryskairos ikr

    • @lerryhp
      @lerryhp 2 года назад +70

      @@yeryskairos there is a reason why my Spanish grades were the lowest of all of them, now I don't know if I blame myself or the Brazilian education

    • @hatersgonnahate6150
      @hatersgonnahate6150 2 года назад +10

      @@lerryhp I don’t like how people associate Portuguese to Brazil. Portuguese is from Portugal.

    • @lerryhp
      @lerryhp 2 года назад +104

      @@hatersgonnahate6150 I didn't associated, I'm from Brazil.

  • @scrazygames2104
    @scrazygames2104 2 года назад +633

    Hello, I am the developer of the first game,@Waligug I really appreciate that you have added me in your video, it really means a lot to me and as many of the comments say, yes, I speak Spanish and for the next update I will change all those problems, thank you very much for your great comments!

    • @Waligug
      @Waligug  2 года назад +141

      Awesome dude! Nice game!

    • @jonaut5705
      @jonaut5705 2 года назад +45

      @@Waligug Yeah. In my opinion it's better than most Roblox games. The ones with tens of thousands of player are all boring "simulators" Nice job though. It's really impressive, especially for just one person.

    • @gigachad9316
      @gigachad9316 2 года назад +2

      Fake account

    • @gigachad9316
      @gigachad9316 2 года назад +2

      New account created from 6 days ago

    • @khanhnguyenbao5962
      @khanhnguyenbao5962 2 года назад +20

      @@gigachad9316 he may created a new account after watching the vid

  • @roedagardet
    @roedagardet 2 года назад +272

    Being able to see Ginger Island in that 2nd one was actually really cool

  • @sneakyraptor1469
    @sneakyraptor1469 2 года назад +284

    I would say Horse Valley is an entirely different game. As the Original one (You played Horse Valley 2) Didn't even have farms or anything, it was just training stations and horses. The entire aim of both games is just to get money and raise horses. To clarify even though the game he played is called "Horse Valley" It is still the second game, the original is called "Horse Valley Legacy" and is the game the second is based off of

    • @ryukisamazing
      @ryukisamazing 2 года назад +2

      @@GarnetSpace No, they were talking about the original one.

    • @sneakyraptor1469
      @sneakyraptor1469 Год назад +2

      @@ryukisamazing Putting a better explanation. Horse Valley (The name of the game he played) is not the original even tho its only called Horse Valley. The Orginal game is called Horse Valley Legacy, which had no farming, no house or anything. The only way you got money in the game was by playing, doing quests and killing wolves. The primary focus was just to train and race horses.

  • @lilywest9552
    @lilywest9552 2 года назад +90

    Waligug: yk, it’s one guy he can’t build it all
    ConcernedApe: •_•

    • @fellownoobie
      @fellownoobie 2 года назад +17

      roblox as a development platform itself sucks in my opinion , and it was probably a 12-16 year old with some spare time

    • @xavi_
      @xavi_ 2 года назад +3

      @@fellownoobie idk man makes alot of cash

    • @fellownoobie
      @fellownoobie 2 года назад +1

      @@xavi_ i mean the stardew valley alternatives , stardew itself is great

    • @xavi_
      @xavi_ 2 года назад +2

      @@fellownoobie roblox in general makes alot of cash from developing if you're lucky and somehow the roblox algorithm blesses your game with the front page

    • @fellownoobie
      @fellownoobie 2 года назад +3

      @@xavi_ Oh you meant it like that , yeah , roblox makes a ton of money , i was talking about the developers side , roblox profits , devs work and get like a fraction of what they would earn in reality ( and get limited a lot ) tho all stories have 2 sides , roblox can than cry about how they provide the platform and the service / servers ( which usually isnt even that great )

  • @paranoidpumpkin98
    @paranoidpumpkin98 2 года назад +82

    That ain't a shipping bin , that's a whole coffin

  • @gabbsmiff3510
    @gabbsmiff3510 2 года назад +103

    The riding through fences (12:45) is technically semi-accurate to stardew lol

  • @chroniclesoflaura
    @chroniclesoflaura 2 года назад +63

    I like how accurate the second one was trying to be 👍🏻 Stardew in 3D would be a pretty awesome game!

  • @mega289
    @mega289 Год назад +18

    As someone who's used a lot of scratch that last game is actually pretty amazing. Props to the creator

  • @ponikonnb
    @ponikonnb 2 года назад +24

    the first game is primarily Spanish, as someone who's taken it for 2 years now. it still means go to sleep, but in spanish

  • @CanadianPerseus
    @CanadianPerseus 2 года назад +313

    Hey I’ve played horse valley due to having horse girl friends and at one point in time there was a Npc that looked exactly like robin and was in a house that was very close to Robins house but it got removed

    • @chrysiewright4292
      @chrysiewright4292 2 года назад +13

      Horse valley was supposed to be a stardew reference? i think it just had something to do with the valley thing

    • @wolfkitty42
      @wolfkitty42 2 года назад +9

      It also had Pierre's shop. I haven't played in a while so idk if it was removed but I know it existed at one point.

    • @noriii
      @noriii 2 года назад +3

      i like horse valley lol

    • @i_am_Plague
      @i_am_Plague Год назад

      @@chrysiewright4292 it wasnt.

    • @i_am_Plague
      @i_am_Plague Год назад

      @@wolfkitty42 it has a shop with seeds, because you need seeds to farm. it wasnt removed, but anyway, it isnt a stardew game.

  • @melixrism
    @melixrism 2 года назад +11

    the second game is honestly astonishing , i really REALLY love roblox games that correctly use the terrain option to make a good surrounding, really just chill games with a great landscape.

  • @imthevevo
    @imthevevo 2 года назад +13

    I saw horse valley in the thumbnail and my jaw DROPPED. I'm a tester for the game and as a frequent viewer I never imagined I'd see you playing it, lol. I do have to agree the graphics do *not* live up to the legacy 2016 version of the game, but a developers gotta do what a developers gotta to rake in that sweet sweet horse revenue.

  • @CrxzyYT
    @CrxzyYT 2 года назад +22

    as a former scratch developer, the scratch version by "csXXXXXXXXXX" game is decently made, Although still pretty lazy. I bet i could make a decently accurate and enjoyable version of stardew valley for Scratch. btw you had to run the game in "Turbo Mode" which speeds up the game to account for browser lag when running it.

    • @a-10warthog23
      @a-10warthog23 2 года назад

      Do it, then, fellow Nexpo enjoyer.

  • @zerotwo8819
    @zerotwo8819 2 года назад +40

    first two were actually really good.surprised it didn't have any players

  • @potato.pancake
    @potato.pancake 2 года назад +7

    within ten seconds and im already hit w nostalgia just from seeing the scratch cat oh my GOD that shit was my childhood

  • @ilikeminecraftepic3849
    @ilikeminecraftepic3849 2 года назад +30

    horse valley is a game with horses and valley in the name, doesn't mean its a Stardew Valley clone

  • @hkayakh
    @hkayakh 2 года назад +46

    Hey wali, I remember playing that scratch stardew valley. Apparently there are secrets in it.

  • @yourbestfriend9574
    @yourbestfriend9574 2 года назад +7

    1:08 that image hurt my soul

  • @akuro_the_time_traveler4200
    @akuro_the_time_traveler4200 2 года назад +33

    Isn't horse valley like entirely a just a different game?

  • @tayk.t.523
    @tayk.t.523 2 года назад +11

    The first two were awesome. I hope the "developers" become successful later in life.

  • @1ndiebird
    @1ndiebird 2 года назад +40

    I would applaud you for playing other games on the channel, but....

  • @aYtto
    @aYtto 2 года назад +4

    Minor correction, the first game was in spanish but the english words were just sort of poorly translated, we can see that because of the ¡exclamations!.

  • @Icommittedarson
    @Icommittedarson 2 года назад +8

    The reason the second one has missing assets I think is because it would get WAY more copyrighted

  • @BlackTempleGaurdian
    @BlackTempleGaurdian 2 года назад +3

    I read one of them as "Stardew Vallet", and now I really want to see that.

  • @souci1295
    @souci1295 2 года назад +4

    All of these made me think about the stardew valley esque horror game I thought up in a dream one time

  • @UtopiaClipzzz
    @UtopiaClipzzz 2 года назад +17

    Absolutely amazing idea. You should switch to horse valley and become a joja store owner

  • @ikirutv
    @ikirutv 2 года назад +43

    Cool to see different varieties of content every once in awhile

  • @toaf3402
    @toaf3402 2 года назад +4

    aww you missed the zip line in horse valley. best feature.

  • @sallyryan2909
    @sallyryan2909 2 года назад +2

    shows me a cat at the beginning.... SCRATCH???? IS THAT YOU????? i love scratch i basically grew up using that app making small games haha

  • @lizzie.exe.7522
    @lizzie.exe.7522 2 года назад +2

    NO NOT SCRATCH THAT GAVE ME FLASHBACKS

  • @Nils_61
    @Nils_61 2 года назад +20

    The best part is that the first one wasnt even in portuguese

  • @apo11ocat
    @apo11ocat 2 года назад +1

    14:29 the reason the name has so many numbers is because the accounts are automatically made for a computer science class. so there are that many accounts. crazyy

  • @acefrostplayz5612
    @acefrostplayz5612 Год назад +1

    8:40 good for her/him he said he did this alone and it was hard props

  • @fakerina
    @fakerina 2 года назад +3

    "Ir a dormir" is spanish, all was in spanish since the begining, unless the tutorial xd

  • @taMeska
    @taMeska 2 года назад +2

    8:30 that bowl lookin a little
    *_sus_*

  • @penguinswithpencils2333
    @penguinswithpencils2333 Год назад +1

    His google tabs open, lmao... a document called "Nostlogic" and a youtube video titled "i'm coming on your..." A man of class.

  • @klepto_mania_
    @klepto_mania_ 2 года назад +2

    I play horse valley a lot and personally this is more of a horse game with a slight feel of Stardew but I don’t this is an exact copy of the game.

  • @RyanDxxx0
    @RyanDxxx0 2 года назад +1

    That's it, gonna relearn scratch after 7 years and make a Stardew Valley.

  • @wolfkitty42
    @wolfkitty42 2 года назад +2

    Horse valley is like... A very good horse training game with nice designs and animation (at least for like, roblox standards it's pretty polished) but I played it a while ago and laughed a ton at how Pierre's shop and Robin's DESIGN and shop got dumped into the game. (You literally missed the ENTIRE town with them). Also, the scratch one was fairly good. For scratch, that game was fantastic. I do think it'd be possible to recreate some of Stardew in scratch (someone made 2d minecraft) and honestly that platformer wasn't half bad.

    • @monkecsaba8735
      @monkecsaba8735 2 года назад

      Horse valley is a star stable cop, lol

    • @wolfkitty42
      @wolfkitty42 2 года назад

      ​@@monkecsaba8735lol at this point any horse game is kind of a clone

    • @wolfkitty42
      @wolfkitty42 2 года назад

      @@monkecsaba8735 i just find it so funny that they put in 3d stardew valley stuff

  • @Eterna.l-x
    @Eterna.l-x 2 года назад +1

    10:19 most were from the tool menu on the building thing if yk what i mean. so most of thoses were already made by other ppl

  • @IwillloveY4ever
    @IwillloveY4ever 2 года назад +1

    CDS could also be Crop Distribution Service since they sell you crops
    Obviously, I made up the word definition for CDS in this context, but it makes the most logical sense.

  • @vaporeon1606
    @vaporeon1606 2 года назад +1

    You know a game is going to be good when it has a cat named oreo you can pet

  • @trailsofstars
    @trailsofstars 2 года назад +2

    So happy my favorite horse valley player has discovered my favorite game, Stardew Valley, and tried to play that too!!

  • @daisythefoxx6872
    @daisythefoxx6872 2 года назад +1

    Oh yeah btw a good Stardew Valley based game on Roblox is called Farm Life

  • @iBugOne
    @iBugOne 2 года назад +4

    I guess ConcernedApe has got his idea for the next game: A nice-looking Roblox-like 3D platformer on horse back, with AAA-level shaders and lighting effects, as well as English guides and Spanish tooltips :)

  • @yourlocalpossum4744
    @yourlocalpossum4744 Год назад +1

    new stardew valley lore, morris steals the farm

  • @Iambender0811
    @Iambender0811 2 года назад +1

    Actually in the second one it shouldn't be a Geneva convention violation because it's a red cross but that was a pink cross.

  • @GodzillaFreak
    @GodzillaFreak 2 года назад +3

    Now this is the content we've been wanting

  • @FungusUnited
    @FungusUnited 2 года назад +1

    Funny thing is I played all of these games before just was curious

  • @sethstersbench
    @sethstersbench 2 года назад +1

    Would you believe me if I told you I got a stardew valley like game as an ad before this video

  • @kinglybingly8827
    @kinglybingly8827 2 года назад +2

    the second one was missing elliotts house TT_TT

  • @enderfire3379
    @enderfire3379 2 года назад +1

    the moment i saw that silouette i said oh no

  • @Lilly31913
    @Lilly31913 2 года назад +2

    Horse valley isnt a stardew valley clone. its a good game it just has valley in the name so it came up

  • @chloepenrod9207
    @chloepenrod9207 2 года назад +3

    Horse valley is actually pretty good compared to the other clones plus it’s not pose to be like standee valley it’s pose to be about horses and horse camps with friends

  • @Cat99838
    @Cat99838 2 года назад +1

    Unfortunatly I recognize the scratch cat.

  • @egg4666
    @egg4666 2 года назад +2

    Honestly horse valley looks quite in depth

  • @pun1200
    @pun1200 2 года назад +3

    Great video I am a alpha tester for the 1st game!

    • @sarah6775
      @sarah6775 2 года назад

      It’s really good!! Idk why more people don’t play it

  • @Korrin69
    @Korrin69 2 года назад +2

    Your jokes you made are really funny!

  • @oranplan1630
    @oranplan1630 2 года назад +2

    Holy shit i was NOT expecting that last one. Where does it go on the rating?

  • @NanaIsMyNickname
    @NanaIsMyNickname 2 года назад +1

    Not the first one being actually kinda legit

  • @0Milena_aneliM0
    @0Milena_aneliM0 2 года назад +1

    The first even harvest moon was fire, you should play it if you manage to get an emulator

  • @katkazam5246
    @katkazam5246 2 года назад +1

    did a little bit of gaming on the roblox stardew valley game that was made by one guy and was basically the whole map and got my way over to the ginger island and it was just a small island with a empty volcano

  • @ROBZOMBIEENJOYER
    @ROBZOMBIEENJOYER 2 года назад +1

    I died when he said “Roblox in Portuguese”

  • @wumbus6045
    @wumbus6045 2 года назад +13

    Why are some of these games actually playable 🤣

  • @aiste8099
    @aiste8099 2 года назад +1

    although i wouldn’t call it a clone, harvest town is really fun

    • @ashleypetrini4627
      @ashleypetrini4627 2 года назад

      The mobile game? Have they made Chris marriable yet?

  • @chrysiewright4292
    @chrysiewright4292 2 года назад +1

    Horse valley isn't supposed to be a stardew it just happens to have the word valley which is rare

  • @whitetrash6510
    @whitetrash6510 2 года назад +1

    No way someone did Stardew on Scratch! I hope it’s good

  • @jebediahkerman9426
    @jebediahkerman9426 2 года назад

    AAAAAAAAAAAAA "ir a dormir" is spanish as a native spanish speaker that hurt

  • @spookysteel
    @spookysteel 2 года назад +1

    NOTE:
    Horse valley was made BEFORE stardew valley existed.
    Thus its not a COPY!

  • @-Maximo
    @-Maximo 2 года назад +1

    Cds probably means “cartel del sur”

  • @ilyrana
    @ilyrana 2 года назад +1

    the cross was pink. not red. not sure if that makes it a violation xD

  • @Keshlynne
    @Keshlynne 2 года назад +2

    Check out Staxel and Sun Haven. Both are very similar to Stardew Valley. They're not free, however.

  • @lloydbrand2
    @lloydbrand2 2 года назад +1

    I miss waligug streams

  • @Skyrunner-nu8dp
    @Skyrunner-nu8dp 2 года назад +2

    The npc had CD's on him so that he could
    CEE DEEZ NUTS
    (I'm sorry)

  • @Grayscale14
    @Grayscale14 2 года назад +1

    scratch is superior

  • @canadianjaken5889
    @canadianjaken5889 2 года назад +2

    What Achievements are you missing with 1.4k hours?

  • @warrenpeace5150
    @warrenpeace5150 2 года назад +1

    I knew that silhouette

  • @sagethegreat4680
    @sagethegreat4680 Год назад +1

    If stardew was junimo carts

  • @johnleaf8918
    @johnleaf8918 2 года назад +1

    My sister was named after Leah form stardew (not joking)

  • @kokonafriedchicken9031
    @kokonafriedchicken9031 2 года назад +1

    I love horse valley💀💀

  • @GHOSTLETTERS.
    @GHOSTLETTERS. 2 года назад

    Did you know that Farm Life on roblox is also basically a stardew valley clone? it's actually pretty alright though

  • @cagierspore5159
    @cagierspore5159 Год назад

    You said that is amassing that someone that a Roblox map when consernape made stardew valley alone

  • @sianblack3042
    @sianblack3042 2 года назад

    hey the horse at 12:18 had my name in it

  • @yo_its_ash2012
    @yo_its_ash2012 2 года назад +1

    THE FIRST ONE WAS JUST SPANISH 😭😭

  • @hatersgonnahate6150
    @hatersgonnahate6150 2 года назад +6

    The first game is not in Portuguese, it’s in Spanish

  • @RANPA_RANMARE
    @RANPA_RANMARE 2 года назад +1

    I thought harvest town was gonna be here

  • @arachne4070
    @arachne4070 2 года назад +5

    What even is the first game lmao

  • @katwalker8070
    @katwalker8070 2 года назад

    I'm only on like year 2 and I'm still in spring How would I get a frozen tear fast And a Sweet pea?😅

  • @notabot567
    @notabot567 2 года назад

    How roblox water looks is based on what your in hame settings (graphics quality)

  • @wilkoczkowa64
    @wilkoczkowa64 2 года назад

    you should plaing welcome to farmtown i think its pretty similiar to stardew valley

  • @Eris250
    @Eris250 7 месяцев назад

    Honestly the lore of the last game is ironically better than Stardew Valley lore. But it ain't all that bad either.

  • @pepsidog1101
    @pepsidog1101 2 года назад

    there was a really cool game on roblox too
    it was like a farmer simulator

  • @AndroidHarris
    @AndroidHarris 2 года назад +1

    You forgot Disney dreamlight valley.

  • @Lupinta
    @Lupinta 2 года назад +1

    Hey there is a pretty good, but no longer updated game on Roblox that’s more like SV
    My farm I think it’s called.

  • @galaxye3432
    @galaxye3432 2 года назад +2

    the first one is in beta

  • @nom1489
    @nom1489 2 года назад +1

    Hey Gug, wanna explain that RUclips tab at 17:08?

  • @Just_Poncho
    @Just_Poncho 2 года назад +1

    The first prompt was spanish by the way not portuguese

  • @jasonjahn6634
    @jasonjahn6634 2 года назад +1

    Farm Life is the best "roblox" stardew valley