Edward Said interview (2001)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 авг 2024
  • Author Edward Said examines democracy and the deep conflict in the Middle East.
    Join us on Patreon! / manufacturingintellect
    Donate Crypto! commerce.coinb...
    Share this video!

Комментарии • 143

  • @ManufacturingIntellect
    @ManufacturingIntellect  7 лет назад +4

    Join us on Patreon! www.patreon.com/ManufacturingIntellect
    Donate Crypto! commerce.coinbase.com/checkout/868d67d2-1628-44a8-b8dc-8f9616d62259
    Share this video!

    • @epluribusburnum3082
      @epluribusburnum3082 Год назад

      The late Edward Said passed away before Israel expulsed its people from Gaza. The late Edward Said would never live long enough to see the hundreds of thousands of rockets to be launched from Gaza once the Palestinians earned their freedom!!!!!

  • @khaliddurrani6432
    @khaliddurrani6432 2 года назад +235

    Imagine someone living at the edge of life, battling a fatal disease, suffering Chemo and its toxicity and still keeping hope at the pinnacle of willpower. Who else but Edward Said could do that ??

    • @ricardoalmeida4719
      @ricardoalmeida4719 10 месяцев назад +5

      Have you seen Hitchens debating Tony Blair, or his last interviews?

    • @John1925T
      @John1925T 10 месяцев назад +2

      Khalid great point u made.

    • @Gadot-d6r
      @Gadot-d6r 9 месяцев назад +7

      Do miss him?! I do. I got all his books, them are my solace.

    • @syy9429
      @syy9429 8 месяцев назад +4

      He’s amazing. I’m so inspired by him. Omg. May he rest in power. What a voice.

    • @mossfitz
      @mossfitz 4 месяца назад

      He's totally bogus. Only those with no critical thinking - or reading - abilities whatever could fail to see that his books are nothing but a heap of unsupported assertions, assumptions and resentments.
      He is exactly what is sick about 'soft science' academia.

  • @silviajuarez4178
    @silviajuarez4178 8 месяцев назад +16

    What an extremely intelligent and empathetic human being.

  • @enriqueprieto4189
    @enriqueprieto4189 4 месяца назад +6

    Said was an amazing human being, not only for Palestinian People as for the humanity

  • @ruchirchaturvedi7793
    @ruchirchaturvedi7793 2 года назад +124

    Reading Orientalism for the first time at the age of 35. Never felt more drawn to a mind than yours. Your contributions to enlightenment, emancipation, and humanism will live on forever.

  • @chugalongway01
    @chugalongway01 5 лет назад +191

    Edward Said was a giant among intellectuals

    • @salmanmasud918
      @salmanmasud918 4 года назад +2

      Dr. S.H. Nasr is the great living intellectual.

    • @lilypad999-i9v
      @lilypad999-i9v 6 часов назад

      of course, he's ethnically a Jew!

    • @lilypad999-i9v
      @lilypad999-i9v 6 часов назад

      obviously not that intellectual is he to not know that...

  • @maiapraiz6774
    @maiapraiz6774 10 месяцев назад +30

    Beautiful soul, so needed nowadays, I hope Noam Chomsky gets to 100 with the same clear mind, we need these souls.

  • @TerlinguaTalkeetna
    @TerlinguaTalkeetna 10 месяцев назад +28

    Wish he could have seen the arab spring and glad he didn't have to see what has just transpired in Gaza and Israel. A great mind, heart, and spirit.

  • @petrichor100
    @petrichor100 3 года назад +78

    We miss you Edward! RIP!

  • @mabroukatis
    @mabroukatis 10 месяцев назад +18

    He's the philosopher who invented the concepts of, Defining yourself vs "The Other"

  • @clairmontlodgesurvivorsclu4521
    @clairmontlodgesurvivorsclu4521 3 года назад +47

    In late May of 2021, this voice from the past echoes greater truth.

  • @tmsphere
    @tmsphere 3 года назад +34

    I miss Edward Said, he's dearly missed, he is needed in America & Palestine, we need a new Edward Said.

  • @nickwyatt9498
    @nickwyatt9498 3 года назад +58

    Wonderful listening to Said, so calm, so wise and so lucid even while battling with cancer. Charlie, on the other hand, had obviously had tee many martoonis beforehand 😅

  • @Anonymous1dskjoadi93
    @Anonymous1dskjoadi93 8 месяцев назад +6

    Edward said deserved a noble peace prize

  • @enriqueprieto4189
    @enriqueprieto4189 4 месяца назад +4

    Thank you Mr. Said

  • @supersarah5157
    @supersarah5157 4 месяца назад +3

    What a gift he was to the world. He is greatly missed. Beautiful highly intelligent incredible person proudly Palestinian

    • @lilypad999-i9v
      @lilypad999-i9v 6 часов назад

      he looks like a Jew because he is ethnically one. not that smart is he...

  • @seancourtney9021
    @seancourtney9021 10 месяцев назад +18

    I had forgotten about him, alas and didn't know he died back then. So depressing to hear him talk about reconciliation between Palestinians and Jews and the need fr a Jewish leader to acknowledge the pain of the 1948 dispossession of the Arabs, depressing in the light of what is going on right now, in October 2023, some 20 years after this interview, when the Hope for Peace has significantly dimmer.

    • @rafia_khan
      @rafia_khan 10 месяцев назад +2

      Revisited this myself....saner voices have no place in the rabid politicism of today

    • @literatious308
      @literatious308 2 месяца назад

      My takeaway is politics drives geopolitical policy & it takes many more decades of pain to change the course of the supertanker called US hegemony than optimists ever imagine. Nevertheless I choose to believe a more just system can & will emerge. Remember Bush speech “kinder & gentler nation”? We’re still watching & waiting for the tide to turn toward cooperation.

  • @Abs222-
    @Abs222- 7 месяцев назад +5

    Best Arabic professor ❤

  • @MB-dp1rj
    @MB-dp1rj 3 года назад +31

    Ah, so greatly missed. An intellectual of rare nobility and humility. Its a privilege to listen to his ideas and perspective on the great peoples of the Middle East.

  • @rawanalamayreh6040
    @rawanalamayreh6040 9 месяцев назад +9

    I wonder what he would think of the recent atrocities committed against Palestinians, he said he's optimistic, that made me truly and deeply sad.

  • @kausamsalam8543
    @kausamsalam8543 Год назад +19

    May Allah give the great Christian a great place in Jannah for his honesty, tough scholarship, and deep caring for all people, including Muslims. Wasn’t a book that he wrote that is not relevant today-each one is a gem, though tough for some who believe provincially.❤️❤️🤲🏿🤲🏿🌻🌴🌴🌴
    Charlie Rose: A great journalist too-much remembered.❤️

  • @khaliddurrani6432
    @khaliddurrani6432 3 года назад +35

    An exceptionally larger than life person a Christian himself who finally got recognition, his voice heard though not heeded in a society tainted by Judo-Christian prejudice for Muslims in general and Palestinians in particular , speaks itself for his status.

    • @botas5254
      @botas5254 5 месяцев назад

      Wadie was agnostic

  • @cyrus-shanghai2283
    @cyrus-shanghai2283 10 месяцев назад +15

    I am Jew, but I feel the pain of this man… he is another victim of Human nature… domination and power upon each other… time to time the role changes from one band to another band…

  • @rational-public-discourse
    @rational-public-discourse 10 месяцев назад +18

    I guess you have to be dying of cancer for Charlie to behave himself and not to continually interrupt the person. This is one of the better interviews conducted by Charlie Rose, and the humanity of Edward Said should take the credit for that.

  • @majedabuthaher3765
    @majedabuthaher3765 5 лет назад +74

    As a Palestinian I wish that he was the leader of PLO .

    • @mugsi66
      @mugsi66 5 лет назад +16

      and unfortunately, would be eaten up by the gods of power and war...as a fellow Palestinian...

    • @moatazmattar4714
      @moatazmattar4714 3 года назад +7

      He was an intellectual. I don't think it would fit

    • @elaovi
      @elaovi 3 года назад +3

      @@moatazmattar4714 Literally anyone would’ve been better than Arafat

    • @moatazmattar4714
      @moatazmattar4714 3 года назад +1

      @@elaovi why though? I thought he was a hero?

    • @GuyShōtō
      @GuyShōtō 2 года назад +4

      @@moatazmattar4714 Arafat had a bad habit of pocketing money meant to furbish the Palestinian Authority and would hand positions to allies as opposed to genuinely skilled administrators.

  • @NadeemKhanNUML
    @NadeemKhanNUML Год назад +22

    Edward Said was a a university in himself.

  • @anuradhainamdar8967
    @anuradhainamdar8967 4 года назад +42

    Though I have read none of his books ,it is his humbleness that has lead him to just a echelon of position among the Universities .Like Noam Chomsky he is a visionary and well spoken fellow, the day we lost such a gaint to Luekemia was sad for intellectual faculties of the world. May what he has left behind be read with interest and awards" like the International Mahatma Gandhi prize for peace" be instituted in his name.He is a proud symbol of Palestinian identity.

    • @literatious308
      @literatious308 2 месяца назад

      Neither Gandhi nor Mother Teresa are the saints they are portrayed as. A deep dive into history from various voices always gives greater insight & clarity.

    • @literatious308
      @literatious308 2 месяца назад

      Narratives are rarely factual & certainty lack nuance. Enjoy your exploration of what really happened.

  • @SKD1947
    @SKD1947 Год назад +12

    Intellectual personality of 20th century.

  • @prettypurple7175
    @prettypurple7175 10 месяцев назад +11

    THE GREAT EDWARD SAID

  • @francoisedandre3644
    @francoisedandre3644 Год назад +8

    Vaincre la mort en son corps donne de solides convictions sur les droits de la vie ! Admiration !

  • @howardleekilby7390
    @howardleekilby7390 3 месяца назад +1

    ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
    If the olive trees could remember the hands that planted them, instead of giving oil they would give tears. - Edward Said
    ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

  • @abomarsyr103
    @abomarsyr103 10 месяцев назад +5

    what a great man
    RIP

  • @BillyBob-xw8kf
    @BillyBob-xw8kf 10 месяцев назад +64

    Brilliant, courageous, compassionate, empathetic, Intelligent, poignant and most of all: sorely missed.

  • @xds900
    @xds900 6 месяцев назад +1

    Rose’s challenge to Said’s despondence for the Palestinians’ suffering is chilling (16:45).

  • @rachelcorrie8928
    @rachelcorrie8928 Год назад +11

    Amnesty International, Human Rights watch, J-Street, B'TSelem and Neturei Karta have all condemned lsraeI as an Apartheid state.

    • @fafolaw
      @fafolaw 9 месяцев назад

      "Neturei Karta " lol

    • @literatious308
      @literatious308 2 месяца назад

      As Israel would say, obvious proof these organizations are antisemitic, genocidal & deny the right for a Jewish Nation to defend itself. “Settlers” in West Bank are armed & continually usurping land & destroying home, armed with US weapons freely distributed by Israeli govt. PA helps IDF. They’re incarcerating native residents without charges or legal representation by huge escalation since 10/07/23, now doubled uncharged detention since.

  • @TravisRiver
    @TravisRiver Год назад +7

    This conversation clearly took place before September

  • @lujainjabar5552
    @lujainjabar5552 3 года назад +24

    I wonder what if he still alive ? What would his opinions be about the current events that took place ! What would he think about Arab countries who declared peace with Israel!?

    • @migrationethistoire
      @migrationethistoire 3 года назад +4

      He have prefered to commit suicide than To see somthing like That

  • @xds900
    @xds900 6 месяцев назад +3

    Rose’s questioning about Palestinian denial of Israel’s right to exist is so one-sided. Zionism denies Palestine’s right to exist.

  • @TBD3.0
    @TBD3.0 8 месяцев назад +3

    And here we are 2023 nothing has changed, Edward is gone and the oppressor is still playing victim.

  • @literatious308
    @literatious308 2 месяца назад +1

    It’s so sad how little has changed, if anything it’s just gotten 10x worse.

  • @Cindy-yx1ip3rd2j
    @Cindy-yx1ip3rd2j 3 года назад +16

    Hello,I'm glad to meet you.
    I am Japanese.I can't hear
    English.
    But I want to know
    Edward Said Interview 2001.
    Please attach Japanese subtitles.
    Yes,please.
    こんにちは。
    はじめまして、私は日本人です。
    エドワード・サイードについて学んでいます。
    私は英語が聞き取れません。
    しかし『エドワード・サイード・インタビュー(2001)』で、サイードが何を語っているか知りたいです。
    日本語字幕を付けてください。
    どうかお願いします。

    • @johnericsonmatela5114
      @johnericsonmatela5114 3 года назад +2

      helo do u still need japanese subtitles?

    • @Cindy-yx1ip3rd2j
      @Cindy-yx1ip3rd2j Год назад +3

      ​​​To ​@@johnericsonmatela5114
      ✨😃❗
      I still require to translate words of Mr.Edward Said into Japanese.
      Two years have already passed since I ordered it from you.
      I'm sorry. I apologize.
      And please translate words of Mr.Edward Said into Japanese. Yes, please
      こんにちは。
      私は、サイード氏の言葉を日本語に訳すことを、まだ必要としています。
      私はそれをあなたがたに頼んだ時から、すでに2年も経過してしまいました。謝ります。ごめんなさい。
      そして、サイード氏の言葉を今度こそ日本語に訳してください。どうかお願いします。
      From Cindy.

  • @judysteadman799
    @judysteadman799 10 месяцев назад +6

    Huge loss when he passed in 2003.

  • @markkeeper7771
    @markkeeper7771 9 месяцев назад +2

    🎯 Key Takeaways for quick navigation:
    00:00 📚 Overview of Edward Said's background and recent book
    - Edward Said's diverse career and his advocacy for Palestinian nationhood.
    - Introduction to Said's book "Power, Politics, and Culture," a compilation of interviews.
    - Mention of Said's health and ongoing treatment for leukemia.
    02:03 🩺 Facing a life-threatening illness and the importance of a good doctor
    - Said discusses living with a life-threatening illness.
    - Emphasis on the importance of having a good doctor, especially one with an understanding of the patient's work and intellectual pursuits.
    - Said's approach to treatments and the impact on his life.
    05:19 🌍 The deep-seated conflict in the Middle East and the gap between cultures
    - Said addresses the historical conflict in the Middle East and the perception of the Arab world as a threat.
    - Discussion on the cultural, political, and communication gaps between different parts of the world.
    - Emphasis on the need for individuals familiar with both cultures to bridge the gap.
    07:50 🇵🇸 The Palestinian issue and the lack of acknowledgment from Israel
    - Said expresses the emotional and political significance of the Palestinian issue.
    - Advocacy for an acknowledgment from the Israeli government of responsibility for the Palestinian situation.
    - Reflection on the impact of the lack of acknowledgment on the prospects for peace.
    13:00 🇺🇸 Colin Powell's speech and the potential for change
    - Analysis of Colin Powell's speech and its significance, breaking taboo by using the word "Palestine."
    - Powell's mention of a viable Palestinian state with acknowledged borders as a crucial point.
    - The importance of Powell addressing the need for the end of occupation, sparking hope for a new climate.
    16:57 💔 Desperation in the Palestinian situation and the impact of violence
    - Discussion on the desperate situation of Palestinians, particularly in the face of brutal occupation.
    - Said's perspective on the violence and the cycle it perpetuates.
    - The urgency for optimism and change in the current Palestinian situation.
    Made with HARPA AI

  • @rishabhaniket1952
    @rishabhaniket1952 Год назад +17

    Charlie Rose was definitely a clown when he spoke but he was perhaps he was the only one conducting long form interviews with the most interesting people of their time. There is no ease about his demeanour, always too excited to interject and babble.

  • @chelvamano4741
    @chelvamano4741 7 лет назад +5

    mam good to hear your thoughts..

  • @cliffgaither
    @cliffgaither 3 года назад +5

    ( Hamas )
    Said :: "Their [ Hamas ] attractiveness to young people".
    If Israel has a Right to exist ... the Palestinians have a Right to Self-Defense.

  • @OlafsonN
    @OlafsonN 9 месяцев назад +1

    Interviewer, Charlie, kept interrupting so you could never hear the last few words of every sentence Edward spoke.

  • @rashlion
    @rashlion 3 месяца назад +1

    I noticed how the interviewer tried to control the narrative

  • @javimarinas9347
    @javimarinas9347 3 года назад +7

    hey can somebody tell me the official source for this video? i need it for my thesis please

  • @syy9429
    @syy9429 8 месяцев назад

    Wow his words are still true today.

  • @Miranda9162
    @Miranda9162 9 месяцев назад +1

    I wonder what he would say about what is happening now in Israel/Gazza. Nothing has changed. It’s all only got worse.

  • @FCristian92
    @FCristian92 9 месяцев назад

    hero

  • @elizabethjgall8054
    @elizabethjgall8054 3 месяца назад

    I wish the interviewer would stop interrupting him

  • @itssanti
    @itssanti 10 месяцев назад +3

    I think Dr Said was an outstanding speaker. Yet I can't recall any state apologizing to the people they oppressed, killed or dispossessed. The only exception to my knowledge would be Germany, and I think they did so because they lost the war. I can't imagine any possible scenario in which an undefeated Germany would have apologized for its crimes.

    • @lmarsh5407
      @lmarsh5407 9 месяцев назад

      Canada is one example, or south Africa, as well as potentially the UK to Ireland but im not sure about that last one

  • @lilypad999-i9v
    @lilypad999-i9v 6 часов назад

    For the last time, this man is not an Arab.

  • @fariedbadjeber-ds6zv
    @fariedbadjeber-ds6zv 7 месяцев назад

    💚💚💚

  • @literatious308
    @literatious308 2 месяца назад +1

    I’d rather listen to a Charlie Rose than a Piers Morgan rage fest

  • @seanabbas7053
    @seanabbas7053 3 года назад +2

    9:35

  • @georgka74
    @georgka74 10 месяцев назад

    what would he say today , after the 10.07.23?

  • @crisalvarez6515
    @crisalvarez6515 4 месяца назад

    While palestinian children were being murdered the interviewer seemed to be more concerned about the "perception" the israelis had of the fearful people they were killing

  • @sammitkhandeparkara
    @sammitkhandeparkara 9 месяцев назад +2

    Who is the interviewer? too much of an annoying presence.

    • @Ssalamanderr
      @Ssalamanderr Месяц назад

      Charlie Rose. Yeah he’s a prick and a western chauvinist

  • @mubashrasattar4260
    @mubashrasattar4260 Год назад

    9/14/2022

  • @jamiazad4750
    @jamiazad4750 9 месяцев назад

    What a loss ;( for Palestine also

  • @Edward-zw9ld
    @Edward-zw9ld 6 месяцев назад

    So bad, so sad

  • @nass5964
    @nass5964 9 месяцев назад

    Palestinians are the victims yet they have to show there worthy of emancipation from the occupation

  • @armin8370
    @armin8370 2 месяца назад

    this interviewer is so frustrating.

  • @bartversteege6270
    @bartversteege6270 7 лет назад +5

    look at...Yemen, Irak,Syrie,Lybie,Somalie, Soedan,Nigeria,Mali,Chetnia.....only one thing in commen...ISLAM !
    but its only about Israel..way ?

    • @moh-ajami
      @moh-ajami 6 лет назад +50

      totally irrelative and crap

    • @sadshitpoorpoop
      @sadshitpoorpoop 4 года назад +11

      I think you mispelled the name 'Palestine'.

    • @beckaldo8741
      @beckaldo8741 3 года назад +5

      When you learn to speak in full sentences, I will answer your question. Until then, you should recognize that nothing is so clear cut. People are complex, cultures are complex and we must be open minded in our perceptions of them. Otherwise we end up becoming arrogant, and lack any form of growth.
      I know this is late, and I know it is unnecessary. But if you have a genuine question, I would be happy to try and answer it.

    • @wesam8444
      @wesam8444 3 года назад +1

      You are right anyone who doesn't see that is blind , where ever there is islam there is war , conflict poverty and hatred toward others i lived their and anybody who denies that is deep in denial , time to wake up

    • @SA41959
      @SA41959 3 года назад +3

      @@wesam8444 BS! It has nothing to do with religion and everything to do with Western politic gain and greed. The rapacious West just cannot stop interfering and imposing itself in Islamic lands, that’s what the real issue is! If they would just eff off and leave Muslim countries alone there wouldn’t be such destruction and chaos in the Middle East. Stop using Islam as a scapegoat for Western crimes.

  • @moosehak
    @moosehak 8 месяцев назад

    God, this man was incredible. He must be turning in his grave watching the genocide of his people.

  • @mg7798
    @mg7798 3 года назад +6

    RIP Arabic man :)

    • @Boymanjusri
      @Boymanjusri 10 месяцев назад

      He is not Arabic. More British and American; not even a Muslim.

    • @sparent8
      @sparent8 10 месяцев назад +3

      You know you can be arab and non-muslim, right?@@Boymanjusri