Edward Said interview (1994)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 июн 2016
- Edward Said surveys the situation in the Middle East, heavily criticizes Yasser Arafat's decision-making, advocates for a new generation of Palestinian leaders, and defines Israel's role as an occupying power within the conflict.
Join us on Patreon! / manufacturingintellect
Donate Crypto! commerce.coinbase.com/checkou...
Share this video! 
Развлечения
![Edward Said & Salman Rushdie [1986]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Sf0J9KlHank/mqdefault.jpg)
Join us on Patreon! www.patreon.com/ManufacturingIntellect
Donate Crypto! commerce.coinbase.com/checkout/868d67d2-1628-44a8-b8dc-8f9616d62259
Share this video!
Listening to Dr. Edward at the current terrible time is great for reasoning with many conflicting ideas
it's just incredible how the things remain the same he was right at 100% ; nevertheless, nothing is eternal and LA GHALIB ILA ALLAH
Arafat didn't trust you... nor some of your crowd....!
said was a jealous man why was he in usa ?
Read his life story,
Why was he in the USA
Because to creat a state for the Jews, the Palestinians had to become the refugees of the world
Rest in peace. Never be forgotten. You gave an oppressed people a voice and your sacrifices and effort gave hope. You will forever be remembered and missed in our hearts
what hope? when you're Created people. it was never a palestinian people. you're invented in 1946. till than you were Arabs, gypsies and others
@@inagordan4589
Perhaps you're a godless zionist. Apologies for the assumption. I wouldn't expect you to understand 'hope'. A created people? Is there another kind. God's created people. The guardians of alAqsa. The most oppressed. Victims of a god damn conspiracy. A colonial project the Divine is about to end. The meek will inherit that sacred land from the worlds financiers and colonial Lords of war.
That’s true, they were the natives of that part of the world regardless of the labels we now give them.
Noah Chomsky
@inagordan4589
Seems you are still oblivious to the fact that the propaganda you spew is now acknowledged worldwide as being such. Same with the "but the holocaust" "but Hamas" and "but Jewish people lived here over a thousand years ago" and such. It just sounds silly
If you want to continue to enjoy the oppression of a people under made-up pretexts, you're free to - but do yourself and others a favour and keep it on the down-low.
Rest in peace
You are most needed now
Thank you, Edward. I wish you could have become the Palestinian leader, with all your wisdom and insights. If only you would have been given the time of life. Thank you for all your wise words.
I love Edward Said ❤️🩹❤️🩹❤️🩹 what a visionary and champion for the Palestinian cause.
One of the top-notch academic thinkers of 20th century. I devoured his "Culture and imperialism " and " Orientalism" heavy books which are so enlightening.
This guy was a sad, loser. His so-called "philosophy" was a bad joke and his argumentation was false and fake.
*Criticism is easy, art is difficult*
Edward Said did not engage in art. he engaged in lies.
prove it
*you play Minecraft why you jump to philosophy*
*Orientalism is the opposite of what you say. Orientalism criticizes Arabs and exaggerates/distorts differences of Arab peoples and cultures as compared to that of Europe*
Talking about Europeans they needed immigrants for labor to buid the countries and use them at the frontline in wars but once those immigrants grew in numbers they are now unwanted. *If Europe is not old and has good fertility rate why since the beginning they opened the gate begging for immigrants to come to work ?* let alone centuries of conquering nations to steal their resources and knowledge.
Meeting with a most remarkable man.
🙏🏻🙏🏽🙏
I miss civilized, rational discussions like this. Social media and radical left and right-ring podcasters make this type of analysis impossible.
Another issue is that we don’t have a lot of great thinkers like this left. And the way academia is looking we won’t have a lot of them in the future.
@@rai2423 Very true.
@@rai2423 I don't agree with that at all. There are as many if not more great thinkers than ever before. The only difference being that now they are harder to find in the fog. Use Google scholar to search for whatever topic you can imagine and you'll find a wealth of academic papers with renowned modern thinkers/scholars at the helm. You just won't find it by chance with anything run by an algorithm, as the algorithms are geared towards entertainment, as the majority of media has been for the longest time. And the majority won't be actively listening to academics. As it has always been.
Good interview. Said was splendid. the interviewer asked hard but valid questions. Today interviewers ask look at me questions and they get standard boring responses.
and 1994 wasn't all that long ago ..... says this oldie.
A pure heart with right thinking❤❤❤❤❤. World will miss you badly.
Great respect to Dr Edward Said. That being said, I am here to pay more respect to the interviewer, because compared to Piers Morgan, this man is a gentleman who actually allows his guest to talk and express. Piers has the habit of cutting short when the guest is just about to make the most important point and does not allow an answer. Piers Morgan can and should learn from him.
I totally agree he was so respectful
I was thinking the same thing.
Comparing anyone to Piers Morgan is a really low bar.
@@xds900 I apologize for that. You are correct.
02:29 on Oslo agreement
09:17 where we went wrong “rushing too quickly” “no honesty about these are what we can get”
11:06 “disgraceful document”: settlement continues ; “limited autonomy but no self-determination”
14:49 against “Hamas has different agenda”
15:40 Arafat is the cheaper alternative to enforce settlements for 🇮🇱
19:30 the peace favors the Israelis
Are you a green anarchist?
It is unbelievable how clear-sighted he was. Everything he predicted in this 1994 interview has come true with a vengeance over these past 30 years. What a tragedy for the Palestinians!
i miss him. a true gem, allah yirahma.
I don't miss him. He was a corrupt liar with no logic to his arguments.
@@rachel36ify
You mean Arafat? Yeah I agree.
@@rachel36ifyZionist troll. You are obsessed with Palestinians you’re in several comments claiming everyone is a ‘liar’ yet present no argument or reasoning to your accusations.
@@rachel36ifySTOPPED!!!!
Can’t believe he was on corporate “public” tv
this show was on pbs (public broadcasting service), which is a publicly funded nonprofit organization
Excellent interview, thank you
we all miss this geart man - rest in peace
what a geart comment
You were right Edward SAID
Resistance is born with every Palestinian.... For every oppressed people, resistance is inevitable.....
Prognosis is bleak. Prophetic words. An intellectual hero.
An intellectual conman, academic swindler & devioys architect of the Woke Degeneracy of the 2020s.
All his prophecies came true, sadly.
What a man.
You will be forever remembered and missed in our heart
did everyone hear that he said: "... he was shaken by the INFITATA.."? 20:21
priceless
Love a good infitada and a diet coke
Why is that priceless?
he makes the same mistake in at least one other interview from around the same time
His words are very opportune to the current situation ....
charlie literally called it the infitada
Before there was the gem from Israel, Miko Peled the Israeli general's son there was Edward Said. Said was the pioneer behind the one democratic state solution with equal rights for Arabs and Jews.
You don't understand the Arabs have no chance because of Hitler the Arabs are The victims of the victims and every one wants the Jews to live there! Right or wrong that is the reality and doubt if it will change?
*Palestinians and Jews. Not ‘arabs’. We are the Palestinian people of Palestine, we speak a dialect of Arabic but our identity goes beyond our language group.
@@sidbullet1Says who. Palestine will be liberated and both Palestinians and Jews will live with EQUAL rights and freedoms in a secular state. It is inevitable. Zionism is losing support and people are becoming more educated on the past 75 years of injustice, cruelty, apartheid, and land-theft.
@@nadasuleman1725 your identity didn’t even exist before the 1960’s though…before the creation of Israel Palestinians were just known as “Arabs”. Your entire identity is reactionary and manufactured
You are Arab before you consider yourself Palestinian. You are Muslim first before Arab@@nadasuleman1725
it is now 2023 after oct 7th and everything starts to make sense
1:42 haunting prediction
Who knows where one can find the link of the memory and dreams part of interview?
This hits home harder today with the genocide going on in Gaza
The irony of the Charlie Rose saying "let me finish" twice when he can't stop cutting off Said 😆
unbeleivable intellect ! He'd be sad the this time and age..
MARAVILLOSA E INOLVIDABLE PERSONA. SIEMPRE UNA LUZ
Visionary.
Charlie Rose is so bad and clueless it's not funny. Said knew about fifteen times of information about the Middle East than Charlie did. Let your guest speak. You invite the person on your show to interrupt the person? Charlie is insane in this interview. Absolutely awful. Said needed a much better interviewer.
More relevant than never
What an intelligent, well spoken and driven man. Rest in peace.
2:15 What were these "great" alternatives that Arafat turned down in the 70s? Did Israel really offer an end to the occupation and a fully independent Palestine state with the 1967 borders or close to it?
No they never did. People give Arafat a lot of shit but he was dealing with an opponent that was arm twisting him to no end. People expected him to do the impossible. Although he made a lot of mistakes.
Any Israeli or Palestinian who sees Edward Said's interviews will immediately understand that he was another pro-Palestinian American who had no idea what the political moods are in the Middle East. It's so noticeable and jarring. The man literally lived two years in Palestine, from birth to the age of two.
RIP
He was the biggest loss of the century
Bleu Star: Get educated or stay ignorant by listening to our Western Media, our corrupt politicians and religious leaders who are controlled by some corporations that are leading us to the destruction of the whole world.
He was a great man, but I wouldn't go that far. MLK, nelson Mandela, Oscar Romero, gusmao etc. . .
Very interesting.....
♥️🇵🇸✌️✌️✌️✌️✌️
Mr said is so sick in this interview but as smart n quick to defend palestine as nobody has since with such a flair ❤
20:19 One of the greatest minds, and hearts to ever put this struggle into words is being interviewed by a man who thinks it's pronounced "infatada"
Het got It all right.
Postponement of the conflict… to death… may you RIP Edward
Saied is always alive for world for dispossesed humanity..but my red salute to him for telling the truth after 1948 world
Not even dictatorships, no country would be insane enough to accept disarming itself to the extent that the Syrians are being asked for the Golan.....and considering what is happening recently they'd be insane to disarm now
And he was right.
I wonder if the host knows how wrong he was now
18:06 What's wrong with that? It says everything !
💚💚
The host has no insights and the bias is obvious. Prof. Said was right on every point
He was no prophet but every thing he said was true and happening
Said would 83 today
forgot charlie rose had a twang
Legend
most, like 90% of what he says feels immemorial.... his assessment of Hamas popularity and how.... unpopular Abu Mazen will become, for Hamas to win outright in an election ...... is however unfortunate
Said and Chomsky knew very well by Oslo that the Empire would take thugs and put them in police uniform for maintaining open prisons (like the Warsaw Ghetto) and call it Palestine.
Ir Isrrael comanders with ar ms and medicinas disease ir palestina murders...and Roman no rigths the 2 mad people
Edward Said at his very best. So annoying Charlie Rose, didn’t let him finish
Interesting that Hamas was considered a protest movement at this point in time.
Intersting that hamas was supported financially by isreal. For keeping Political division between the Palestinian movement, so they can avoid the establishment of palestine a state. ( Benjamin told that in a government meeting in 2019)
That’s all they wanted them to be. It seems very obvious. Israel funded them to weaken Fatah and they didn’t expect Hamas to organise themselves to this extent.
21:06
This is 30 years ago
What a remarkable man
He should have been the Palestinian leader
What a change in history that would have meant
The Palestinians would be in a worse place if he were the leader. He is not even ready to give up the absurd principle of the right of return.
Edward Said What?
My goodness, was he so wrong about everything concerning the Middle East. This discussion did not age well. May he rest in peace.
Makee people new generation start refusing slavery sinsce now
Israeli security would have been safeguarded for life if a just two state solution could have been agreed.
Read Ilan Pappe and watch Chomsky’s interview with Peter Bienart: Even before the 1967 war, Israel had plans for settling the West Bank and limiting Palestinians to only major populations centers. There was never a chance to allow anything more than a “Bantustan”.
Israel never intended for a two state solution. Knesset members have stated this time and again. Israel doesn’t even admit to it being an oppressive power. You can’t deny the major sticking point and then agree to two states.
Israel never wanted a two state solution. They always wanted all the land.
Unfortunately that is not possible with Zionism. To build an ‘ethno state’ on a land that has historically been home for numerous religions and ethnicities, is never feasible. It will never be safe because it’s creation was made possible by displacing and massacring a native population off their land. The Palestinians will never stop resisting their occupation, the injustices and oppression being inflicted upon them will only breed more resistance fighters and create more bloodshed. Zionism needs to be dismantled, the apartheid regime must take accountability for its crimes, and international law needs to be respected and upheld. The right of return, as affirmed by the UN, needs to be granted to the millions of displaced Palestinians. Only then, will one secular state be possible. A state with equal rights and freedoms for all. That is how you create co-existence.
This is the type leadership....those Arab need in Palestine
From the late Yasin until today!
We have been crying for many years over the massacre of Diriasin and Kafrqasem. 100 to 200 Palestinians were massacred in Diriyasin and 48 in Kafr Qasim. Compared to today's war, these numbers are not huge! Is humanity moving forward or backward in terms of cruelty and violence?
Weapons are becoming more destructive day by day and human lives are losing more and more value. Is this the result of Nietzsche's famous statement about God? Or is the debate still about what kind of worship of God is, contrary to Nietzsche's view, life? Or that selfish people have hidden God in the basement of their minds and, by claiming God for themselves, are taking the human race to the slaughterhouse? Or does the story have nothing to do with God?
Murder and brutality have always challenged optimism about the nature of humanity. A new type of pessimism is emerging with regard to human nature. In my opinion, pessimism towards human nature can make the world more tolerable, because it lowers the level of expectations towards it! Expecting mercy, compassion, fairness, justice and morality from him over all his fellow human beings apparently seems more like stupidity and how stupid God has made me!
Charlie is such a rude host. I've never seen him act so without manners. HE'S interrupting his guest. HE'S talking over his guest. HE'S constantly contradicting his guest. He very seldom allows Mr Said to make a point and to acknowledge that he has made a point. Is it because Charlie is a Jew?
It is because he is a ZIONIST. We need to make a clear distinction between Jewish people and Zionists. Jewish people who practice their religion know that Zionism is a contradiction to their beliefs and a horrific, extremist ideology that was born and bred in Europe by an atheist man and propped up by anti-Semitic Christians.
Interesting… Every time a Palestinian has to discuss political issue of their land western media demands they talk to someone who is Jewish or is very loyal/protective towards Israel. And it’s still like that today.
And why should the right of return be a problem
Unless you accept that what you are building is an ethno nationalist state.
How can a man living in Brookline- America, the land of the free. Have to occupy and steal and live on someone else’s occupied stolen house/ land
But the man who point to his house and show you the documents for it , can not even visit that house.
Unless we are all human
But some are more human than others
After the establishment of the state of Palestine, will you promise me that it will not be an ethnocentric state? Will Hamas agree that millions of Jews will also live there? I doubt it. Welcome to the Middle East.
One of the comments in here is saying,
That Edward sawed would have been a terrible leader
Because he believed in the right of return.
But if you accept that the Jewish of this world
Should have the right to return to a land that they lived in 7 thousands years ago.
You blame the Palestinians for wanting to return to a land they lived in 70 years ago
By the way, Edward sawed family home, the actual house that they lived in. Was stolen from his family and and became the centre for the most Zionist Christian American organisation
What would any want if they were terrorised and had their house occupied by an entity that they did not do anything against
You have to really put yourself in another human place to understand that
You have to accept the idea that the Palestinians are human. Who needs rights and freedoms and an apology from the whole wide world
For all of us being complicit in what they have suffered for the last 70 odd years
If the Palestinians win the war against Israel as Israel defeated 6 colonial Arab forces - they are allowed to expel all the Jews from the land and establish the right of return.
Cut their propaganda
He sure misunderstood Hamas "they don't mobilize people" (15:34). They mobilized plenty on October 7th...
Arafat is a war criminal, fighting against an occupied force. Land stolen from 1947 onwards, this land was not Zionist land.
What is wrong with demillitarization .....this anchorman is living in a parallel universe....and so annoying and interruptive
23 years later .... they got it all wrong..funny
Edward got it all right .
Whatever you say fart…
The timing took longer
What do you mean? Everything Edward has said has come to fruition.
born in Egypt so what he is saying? suddenly he is Palestinian? you're an Arab
fyi he was born in west Jerusalem.
@@Sima-mo9qz he was born in Jerusalem Israel. nothing to do with Palestine
@@Sima-mo9qz Israel was a thing 3750 years ago to your information.
@@inagordan4589 hhhhhh.aucun pays au n'a 3000 ans de vécu.stop au mensonge
@@inagordan4589 European mongrels are not the people of the book 🥴
The decreased Charlie Rose had a privilege to interview man like Edward Said shame