It would've been interesting to see her compete this season. I bet you Taylor would've been gone, or instead of Katherine in Taylor, it would've been Katherine and Carly, or Chris and Carly, or Elliot and Carly, or meh taylor and CARLY!! But she got the cooler stage in season 7, and she got the beatles!
I think Carly was the pre-show favorite in Season 5, They were talking left and right about an "Irish girl" they were really excited about. She was a lot more marketable back then. she probably would have won or made second place and it would've been her v.s. Katharine in the finale. (If she schewed to her rock tendencies, she would have easily overtaken Daughtry)
If Carly made it to the Top 12 on S5, that would've been the best season!! Daughtry, Elliot and Carly? Damn!! What more could u ask for? That's pure talent! 🔥
@paranormalrockstar They haven't played any Ev songs at any of their concerts. They've played their entire album, plus a Journey, Madonna, and Iron Maiden covers. They've covered two Ev songs that Ben wrote, one at the press conf. last summer and one at a bar when they did acoustic My Immortal. I really don't think that We Are The Fallen is "against Amy Lee." I saw them live, and they're were so energetic and really loved what they were doing. There's so much talent. Shame not everyone agrees.
@paranormalrockstar Lol, her looks? big freakin woop, she has black hair, pale skin, and beautiful eyes. So she has a goth style, doesn't mean she's going "Amy Lee" I love Amy and Carly, just because they are both beautiful gothic rock singers and Amy came before Carly doesn't mean a thing! It's like people say Amy is copying Sharen (from Within Temptation) just because she came before Amy/...
@pete2k10 erm...for the most part, Ben wrote and arranged alot of their hits, so don't hate on We Are The Fallen, Carly isn't an Amy, and you and I both know Amy can hardly sing live, unless she works out her voice...Where as Carly is 100% actual voice.....and also Ben left Evanescence so Carly didn't have anything to do with him leaving....and also mind letting off on the ''caps lock'' key? It may make people say hey, your mature, I think I'll listen to you..
@pete2k10 Thank you. I have my opinion and you have yours. Let's leave it at that. And, you know, there's this button called the "caps lock". Try it. Maybe people would take you seriously more often.
Honestly, i like her more than Amy. We are the Fallen is a great band, and so is Evanescence. I don't think she's copying Amy at all. Their look is similar yes, but there are differences, too. If your opinion is mean, just keep it to yourself. It would save everyone on RUclips a lot of trouble.
Ah, the days when Simon Cowell was on the show... I think we can all agree, not only that Carly was AMAZING, but that American Idol is not nearly as good as it used to be.
It would've been interesting to see her compete this season. I bet you Taylor would've been gone, or instead of Katherine in Taylor, it would've been Katherine and Carly, or Chris and Carly, or Elliot and Carly, or meh taylor and CARLY!! But she got the cooler stage in season 7, and she got the beatles!
Finally! They released Carly's full audtion!
I really looking everywhere, finally i see it now 😍😍
To the person below who said that Amy couldn't do that, that would be because this isn't the type of song that suits Amy's voice range.
Simon was right, she was better in this audition lol
I was gonna say that.. if only a little.
How so?
this just made me a bigger carly fan. her voice is just amazing. :)
I think Carly was the pre-show favorite in Season 5, They were talking left and right about an "Irish girl" they were really excited about. She was a lot more marketable back then. she probably would have won or made second place and it would've been her v.s. Katharine in the finale. (If she schewed to her rock tendencies, she would have easily overtaken Daughtry)
I was right there with ya, 'til ya came for Daughtry, lol.
If Carly made it to the Top 12 on S5, that would've been the best season!! Daughtry, Elliot and Carly? Damn!! What more could u ask for? That's pure talent! 🔥
Yes, thank you! Carly is the queen, no ifs ands or buts about it :D
this audition was better than her 2nd 1
How so?
never heard a voice like that. brilliant.
@paranormalrockstar They haven't played any Ev songs at any of their concerts. They've played their entire album, plus a Journey, Madonna, and Iron Maiden covers. They've covered two Ev songs that Ben wrote, one at the press conf. last summer and one at a bar when they did acoustic My Immortal. I really don't think that We Are The Fallen is "against Amy Lee." I saw them live, and they're were so energetic and really loved what they were doing. There's so much talent. Shame not everyone agrees.
Oh shut it- AMY wrote 'Going Under', and they played that one at multiple shows in 2009 to gain a buzz in the media.
OMG she was much better back then
How so?
I really think that she would have won had her papers went through the first time.
@pete2k10 Oh, I don't know if I could help you to understand. It'd take years for someone like you to learn how to do something so difficult.
Carly is awesome.
@paranormalrockstar Lol, her looks? big freakin woop, she has black hair, pale skin, and beautiful eyes. So she has a goth style, doesn't mean she's going "Amy Lee" I love Amy and Carly, just because they are both beautiful gothic rock singers and Amy came before Carly doesn't mean a thing! It's like people say Amy is copying Sharen (from Within Temptation) just because she came before Amy/...
@pete2k10 erm...for the most part, Ben wrote and arranged alot of their hits, so don't hate on We Are The Fallen, Carly isn't an Amy, and you and I both know Amy can hardly sing live, unless she works out her voice...Where as Carly is 100% actual voice.....and also Ben left Evanescence so Carly didn't have anything to do with him leaving....and also mind letting off on the ''caps lock'' key? It may make people say hey, your mature, I think I'll listen to you..
Amy can hardly sing live?! Lmao! #Delusional
@pete2k10 Thank you. I have my opinion and you have yours. Let's leave it at that. And, you know, there's this button called the "caps lock". Try it. Maybe people would take you seriously more often.
Lol!
Honestly, i like her more than Amy. We are the Fallen is a great band, and so is Evanescence. I don't think she's copying Amy at all. Their look is similar yes, but there are differences, too. If your opinion is mean, just keep it to yourself. It would save everyone on RUclips a lot of trouble.
Says the Karen with an anti-Amy 'opinion'.
Amy could never do that.
Lmao, Amy is way better and can't even be touched by this wannabe so I agree- Amy could never FLOP like her.
Ah, the days when Simon Cowell was on the show...
I think we can all agree, not only that Carly was AMAZING, but that American Idol is not nearly as good as it used to be.