"The immature artist imitates. Mature artist steal." . Love this phrase, love the video. As an artist myself i can totally relate to it. Thanks. For some reason now, i feel very inspired.
i tried explaining this to my professor. she was pissed. she said ANY idea that didn't 100% come from just my head i had to "cite my sources".. seems simple enough, right???... WRONG. Because everything i know came from something else, whether it was from a parent, grandparent, teacher, or just experience. I said "Nothing is knew under the sun." Technically NOTHING we do is original, we are just imitating. Even our own creativity is nothing more than an outflow of our Maker.
Just because it isn't original, and/or a remix - that doesn't mean siting sources isn't required. It is always a good idea to provide the inspiration of the work. Giving credit where credit is due is never a bad idea. If the source is your grandma, then the source is your grandma.
I think that the reason the word “steal” is so essential here is because to steal is to take ownership of something that previously belonged to someone else. Imitation is merely pretending to have something that belongs to someone else. Theft inherently involves transformation; what is theirs becomes yours. When something inspires you, you must *make it yours*.
Inspiring and freeing concept. Not really to "steal", but instead use others' works as a tool to get your own creativity moving along. Turn and play with other people's words and ideas to find and make something new. Thanks Mr. Kleon for some history on the concept.
I've been experimenting with this philosophy in the Navy while serving as a Commanding Officer with great results. We call it "Best Practice Convergence" and our team has been "stealing" the best ideas from other commands, making them our own, and then exporting them back to Fleet. Talk about an enjoyable path to deliberate progress and a shared legacy. Thanks to Austin for packaging a similar message so very well...
i have a writer's block for more than 10 years now and after watching this video i feel inspired for the first time in a long time and am amazed how many opportunities i suddenly see where i can draw inspiration from. And what i saw as one of my weaknesses, having no original thoughts but having a good capability to come up with my version of somebody else's work, is basically what an artist does.
Had I known this while studying architecture! I used to be so uber anxious about "plagiarism" that everything had to be original and nothing copied or transformed. But yes as an artist I've known for a long time, it's tough to get around intellectual property rights, but inspiration always comes from viewing something of personal interest, whether its in a magazine, on the street or a conglomeration of what we've seen in the real world presented in our dreams while we sleep. Thank you thank you thank you.. this is a great example of how to turn criticism into research that helps everyone else as well!
I'm an architecture student and my teacher recommended us this book in our plastic arts workshop, in my first semester. I was always so self-conscious about my work and didn't think I could be creative in any way, but this book helped me a lot. I did a lot of research and basically put pieces of things I love together with some of my own ideas and views, and it turned out great. Got my best grades in that class and my teacher loved my work. Every once in a while I read it again. One of my favorite books in the world.
We read, we look and we listen and we add our personal handwriting to our creations. If we don't we just copy. We want to create something new. We think we are original. At the beginning of this speech I was sceptic, but he has a point. This is really an eye opener.
He is absolutely right though, everyone emulates what they love (and even hate) whether it be music, drawing,painting sculpting writing. The way we speak and dress. What we eat and how we cook even. Everything is derived from something and it's up to us to use it tastefully. For someone to claim they're entirely original in any way is pretty ridiculous.
+EmperorLOL Thanks for mentioning that. I had missed the fact that he had written a book by the same title as his talk. I checked it out from the library, and found it very good.
What is original though is what truly resonates with each one of us. That is what makes us unique. That is our unstealable fingerprint. Who you are can be mimicked and you can mimic others but that does no one justice.
Thanks for sharing. There's something about this presentation that really clicked. I especially like the idea of referencing the people that inspire us. It's a great way to stay connected to our creative ancestors. So many clever people out there doing amazing things. A nice way to remind ourselves of their achievements, and also those from the dim and distant past.
The book is great too and this is a wonderful TED TALK. I love the book and refer to it every week, especially when I have creative blocks in my hobbies. Great insights, presentation, and book too!!
العرب هم من بدا هذا التلاعب بالكلمات وعندنا شعر يقراء عموديا وافقيا وعندنا ابيات تقراء من اليمن إلى اليسار وتعطي معنا وعندما تقراها من اليسار إلى اليمين تعطي معنا آخر وكل هذه الأشعار بدأت قبل كل هؤلاء حقيقة
Exactly! Love it. And whenever and where ever possible, give credit to the artist/person from whom you got your idea, inspiration, or tutelage. Cuz we would want the same. :) Then it truly is a win-win (etc -win).
For all those let me tell you there was a time in the beginning when there was something created out of nothing. Just the thing now is that we don't have enough time to explore world and get ideas which will take upto 40-50 years.
to be clear, ak didn't steal anything, except newsprint. i mean, he used redaction creatively, without knowledge of similar 'art' that might already exist. originality is relative to the creator. newspaper blackout was an original idea to AK, but only a variant on the larger scale. it doesn't invalidate the art or the artist to invent something that isn't entirely new. and it isn't all simply outright stealing. the expectation that whatever one thinks up is fresh and new and never seen before is the illusion, not the originality or creativity of one's thoughts. the expression is what matters to the creator, and that is always valid. he's right tho. creation is often inspired and propelled and channeled by what has gone before, and thievery is a legitimate part of the trade, in proper contexts. As Bono said, 'every artist is a cannibal, every poet is a thief. All kill their inspiration and sing about the grief.' See also the South Park episode, "The SImpsons already did it." Maybe the best guideline is if you the creator know that your ideas were inspired by others, you should label them as such. If it was your idea without prior knowledge, tell critics to stfu. also, it's invalid to say that you're following in the footsteps of someone you never heard of, whose work never even brushed your life, tho it isn't wrong per se to place yourself in the company of similar creators. (lineage is a different issue.) Credit where credit is due, but don't lie or lie down. And face it: no matter what you the creator do or say, the haters gonna hatehatehatehatehate.
The important detail is not the act of theft. As Austin says "take something.. combine it with your own ideas and thoughts, transform it into something completely new". I would only add that giving credit for your inspirations is also important, its the only way we could trace that lineage of the "cut-up" idea.
I read his other book, Show Your Work in my friend's villa in Bali. It's a good handy book that I think we've used it to promote agriculture product from our garden. Like it. I hope to read this Steal Book too.
Thoughtful presentation - and one that blends easily into the new ideas of multi-media mashup. Having just written a mash-up of martial arts philosophy I'm reassured that its a more global and chronologically consistent approach than some of the more contemporary conversations would have us believe
Someone from an ad agency saw a great idea when they were online and decided to adapt and change it to fit a campaign, but didn't credit the original artist that made it. An organization awarded agency for the creative execution of the idea. Somehow, it got out that the work wasn't an original work, but derived, and many people scorned the agency which let this slip past their notice. They also complained to the organization that they shouldn't be awarded for plagiarism. When I looked at that case, I had thought it was another case of tired artist spots something in that idea which could be used in a different light, but gets punished for using the material in a way which isn't different enough to be judged as a different idea. Not many would've noticed it was the same work if the ad itself didn't win the award. And even if they did, they wouldn't bother to report it. Perhaps in a world without internet, works like theirs would've passed by various scrutiny and win awards. If you plan to use something that isn't yours, give credit where it's due - and not use materials by others similarly, even if it is in a different perspective. Unless if you're paying the original creator off, or had their permission to use it. Thanks for the interesting talk. It's confirmation of what I've always thought was true. If you're still new at something, you'll have to learn from your betters till you grow out of their shadows.
Keith Richards and Mick Jagger cut up newspapers to come up with the lyrics for Casino Boogie when they were recording Exile on Main Street in France. I think Richards wrote that they had simply run out of ideas after doing so much recording, so they used the newspaper method.
I think it has to do with our perception of loss, so we think it's ok to do it unless is being done unto us. Look for the TED talk by Kirby Ferguson and his documentary series "Everything is a Remix". This talk by itself feels like a 'remix' of that, much informative one.
Nailed it! Been an artist since I was a kid and even I can admit this lol. I express my art through music, sketching, comics, and photography. All of my ideas I get for my art are from other things/people. For example, when I used to make beats, I would get inspiration from other beats. I'd essentially combine multiple beats together to make an entirely "new" beat. OR, I'd hear a song and then I'd edit the song based on specific melodies in the song to make an entirely "new" song. OR, i'd hear a melody from some random song I came across and use that to make a beat. The same case applies to my other art forms lol.
That's how we learn and grow.... From everyone and everything around us! Hahahaha! I absolutely love this!!! So basic to human existence! Sooo INSPIRING!!!
There was a great artist that pieced together a living picture that could show us how bodies would move under an influence ... His name was Isaac Newton, and he also stole lot's of ideas. He phrased his theft on a very elegant way: “If I have seen further, it is because i have stood on the shoulders of giants.”
I love this. Frederic Chopin 'stole' the idea for his famous Fantasie Impromptu--a Romantic piece used by those who audition for university-level piano courses--adding his own tone, style, and harmonies, from a piece both rhythmically and technically complex, a piece that acts as a third movement for the "Sonanta quasi una Fantasia;" the third movement of Beethoven's "Moonlight Sonata."
![[#2024MAMA] G-DRAGON - 무제(Untitled, 2014)+POWER+HOME SWEET HOME+뱅뱅뱅+FANTASTIC BABY | Mnet 241123 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Ox29z5Nf1Uk/mqdefault.jpg)
My ten-year artist's block ended after reading Austin books. Awsome.
Absolutely beautiful. I will steal this as best I can.
"The immature artist imitates. Mature artist steal." . Love this phrase, love the video. As an artist myself i can totally relate to it. Thanks. For some reason now, i feel very inspired.
It’s a shared language. We didn’t invent letters, but we all speak some sort of language we were taught. Love this video.
i tried explaining this to my professor. she was pissed. she said ANY idea that didn't 100% come from just my head i had to "cite my sources".. seems simple enough, right???... WRONG. Because everything i know came from something else, whether it was from a parent, grandparent, teacher, or just experience. I said "Nothing is knew under the sun." Technically NOTHING we do is original, we are just imitating. Even our own creativity is nothing more than an outflow of our Maker.
Think of a kaleidoscope!
Hint: Don't ask a teacher. Why? Because the quality of the answer is equally important as the quality of the source.
BRAL Studios
My sentiments exactly.
Just because it isn't original, and/or a remix - that doesn't mean siting sources isn't required. It is always a good idea to provide the inspiration of the work. Giving credit where credit is due is never a bad idea. If the source is your grandma, then the source is your grandma.
The biggest problem is that all the data we've collected throughout our lives isn't sourced. I have ideas, but no idea where they came from.
I think that the reason the word “steal” is so essential here is because to steal is to take ownership of something that previously belonged to someone else. Imitation is merely pretending to have something that belongs to someone else. Theft inherently involves transformation; what is theirs becomes yours. When something inspires you, you must *make it yours*.
Inspiring and freeing concept. Not really to "steal", but instead use others' works as a tool to get your own creativity moving along. Turn and play with other people's words and ideas to find and make something new. Thanks Mr. Kleon for some history on the concept.
I've been experimenting with this philosophy in the Navy while serving as a Commanding Officer with great results. We call it "Best Practice Convergence" and our team has been "stealing" the best ideas from other commands, making them our own, and then exporting them back to Fleet. Talk about an enjoyable path to deliberate progress and a shared legacy. Thanks to Austin for packaging a similar message so very well...
i have a writer's block for more than 10 years now and after watching this video i feel inspired for the first time in a long time and am amazed how many opportunities i suddenly see where i can draw inspiration from. And what i saw as one of my weaknesses, having no original thoughts but having a good capability to come up with my version of somebody else's work, is basically what an artist does.
Had I known this while studying architecture! I used to be so uber anxious about "plagiarism" that everything had to be original and nothing copied or transformed. But yes as an artist I've known for a long time, it's tough to get around intellectual property rights, but inspiration always comes from viewing something of personal interest, whether its in a magazine, on the street or a conglomeration of what we've seen in the real world presented in our dreams while we sleep. Thank you thank you thank you.. this is a great example of how to turn criticism into research that helps everyone else as well!
I'm an architecture student and my teacher recommended us this book in our plastic arts workshop, in my first semester. I was always so self-conscious about my work and didn't think I could be creative in any way, but this book helped me a lot. I did a lot of research and basically put pieces of things I love together with some of my own ideas and views, and it turned out great. Got my best grades in that class and my teacher loved my work. Every once in a while I read it again. One of my favorite books in the world.
The art of art is to steal creatively - not to steal directly, steal from your subconscious.
Excellent comment. Very true! “It's not where you take things from - it's where you take them to.” - Jean-Luc Godard
Exactly.
i say just steal. all that other stuff is just a matter of perspective.
I actually bought the "Steal Like an Artist" calendar which is available for 2017. :]
@@IanFrantz Off to a bad start, you should have stolen it.
the book changed my life and i have just found this video after 3 years.. life is so unfair indeed
Love this short speech on stealing art...he explains it so well, and so truthfully.
We read, we look and we listen and we add our personal handwriting to our creations. If we don't we just copy. We want to create something new. We think we are original. At the beginning of this speech I was sceptic, but he has a point. This is really an eye opener.
Creative Stealing = Creative Recycling. Thank you!
"The secret to creativity is knowing how to hide your sources." -Albert Einstein
He is absolutely right though, everyone emulates what they love (and even hate) whether it be music, drawing,painting sculpting writing. The way we speak and dress. What we eat and how we cook even. Everything is derived from something and it's up to us to use it tastefully. For someone to claim they're entirely original in any way is pretty ridiculous.
His book is worth reading 10 times.
I own it and j think I've read it more than that haha
+EmperorLOL Thanks for mentioning that. I had missed the fact that he had written a book by the same title as his talk. I checked it out from the library, and found it very good.
his book is literally just what he said here.
His book is literally the same thing as this speech lmao
Make that ×2 lol
"Transformation is flattery"
I like this quote.
Hey this was my Speech!
"Hoarders collect everything; artists collect selectively." 👏🏽
this guy have memorised his whole book!
The best way of stealing I have ever heard.
Sweet jesus, how freeing are Kleon's words and ideas!
Read Steal Like An Artist. And i absolutely loved it. And loved this video!!
Orginality Is Unditected Plagarism.
What is original though is what truly resonates with each one of us. That is what makes us unique. That is our unstealable fingerprint. Who you are can be mimicked and you can mimic others but that does no one justice.
ohhhh man, i LOVE the idea of "creative lineage"
Thanks for sharing. There's something about this presentation that really clicked. I especially like the idea of referencing the people that inspire us. It's a great way to stay connected to our creative ancestors. So many clever people out there doing amazing things. A nice way to remind ourselves of their achievements, and also those from the dim and distant past.
The book is great too and this is a wonderful TED TALK. I love the book and refer to it every week, especially when I have creative blocks in my hobbies. Great insights, presentation, and book too!!
This is the first time I see the idea of stealing in a positive way
This is such a good, modern view on art. One of the best made arguments for appropriation. Thanks!
The beautiful concept applies to everything we do in this world.
Hats off to you. I completely agree.
What has been will be again,
what has been done will be done again;
there is nothing new under the sun.
Ecclesiastes 1:9
I definitely looveeee this man´s work and speech!! he is a total stealer genius! Thanks Austin, big hug from Guadalajara, Mexico!
I already knew of this on a basic level, but I really liked the speech as it put it into more perspective!
Love your new book and love this presentation. Informational and transformational. Can't ask for more. All the best.
Love love love the message of this
Creativity is the word. Excelente, es un banco de ideas permanente. Me encantó.
العرب هم من بدا هذا التلاعب بالكلمات وعندنا شعر يقراء عموديا وافقيا وعندنا ابيات تقراء من اليمن إلى اليسار وتعطي معنا وعندما تقراها من اليسار إلى اليمين تعطي معنا آخر وكل هذه الأشعار بدأت قبل كل هؤلاء حقيقة
You have summed up creativity.
robbery?
Read his book 'SLAA' today, excellent thought provoking book. Gave me the so much to think about. Thank you
Perfect summary of his book
Fantastic, Some videos hit you at the right times of your life
This one reassured something that I was doing
I love this man
We all stand on the shoulders of giants.
Exactly! Love it. And whenever and where ever possible, give credit to the artist/person from whom you got your idea, inspiration, or tutelage. Cuz we would want the same. :) Then it truly is a win-win (etc -win).
Until you ironically get sued by an artist for stealing his/her stolen ideas.
For all those let me tell you there was a time in the beginning when there was something created out of nothing. Just the thing now is that we don't have enough time to explore world and get ideas which will take upto 40-50 years.
to be clear, ak didn't steal anything, except newsprint. i mean, he used redaction creatively, without knowledge of similar 'art' that might already exist. originality is relative to the creator. newspaper blackout was an original idea to AK, but only a variant on the larger scale. it doesn't invalidate the art or the artist to invent something that isn't entirely new. and it isn't all simply outright stealing. the expectation that whatever one thinks up is fresh and new and never seen before is the illusion, not the originality or creativity of one's thoughts. the expression is what matters to the creator, and that is always valid. he's right tho. creation is often inspired and propelled and channeled by what has gone before, and thievery is a legitimate part of the trade, in proper contexts. As Bono said, 'every artist is a cannibal, every poet is a thief. All kill their inspiration and sing about the grief.' See also the South Park episode, "The SImpsons already did it." Maybe the best guideline is if you the creator know that your ideas were inspired by others, you should label them as such. If it was your idea without prior knowledge, tell critics to stfu. also, it's invalid to say that you're following in the footsteps of someone you never heard of, whose work never even brushed your life, tho it isn't wrong per se to place yourself in the company of similar creators. (lineage is a different issue.) Credit where credit is due, but don't lie or lie down. And face it: no matter what you the creator do or say, the haters gonna hatehatehatehatehate.
The important detail is not the act of theft. As Austin says "take something.. combine it with your own ideas and thoughts, transform it into something completely new". I would only add that giving credit for your inspirations is also important, its the only way we could trace that lineage of the "cut-up" idea.
That's why I stole the book :D
uh.. yey??
Me too lol
ha haaha...
Me too
Pdf
his book and this talk is a true inspiration, it really makes me keep being an artist just to live by these tips
this is just phenomenal!!!
What an excellent video! Absolutely loved it 👍🏼
this is simply amazing. i own the book, but i much prefer the talk!
Thank you for this.
Damn I wish modern copyright law took into account things like "love" and "respect". Unfortunately large corporations are incapable of either.
I read his other book, Show Your Work in my friend's villa in Bali. It's a good handy book that I think we've used it to promote agriculture product from our garden. Like it. I hope to read this Steal Book too.
Thoughtful presentation - and one that blends easily into the new ideas of multi-media mashup. Having just written a mash-up of martial arts philosophy I'm reassured that its a more global and chronologically consistent approach than some of the more contemporary conversations would have us believe
great TED Talk. Inspired my animated summary videos.
Just read the book, now enjoying Austin's TEDx talk on the same subject - 'Steal Like an Artist'. Watch >>
I was going to buy the book then I got into this review saying that the whole book was explained here in this video.
Same
Same!
Same here
Ain’t no shame in picking up something and make it better for the greater good, starting with you
We're 12 years later and AI has entered the chat
Buy this book, buy it. Trust me
Today is 2022 and am watching,
Amenikaribisha kwenye fikra njema
um artista sempre terá artistas como inspiração e roubar sua essência sem roubar quem se é
Thank you. Gave your book to my artist teen son.
So Inspiring!
Thank you for teaching me to steal from people 🤯❤❤
Someone from an ad agency saw a great idea when they were online and decided to adapt and change it to fit a campaign, but didn't credit the original artist that made it. An organization awarded agency for the creative execution of the idea. Somehow, it got out that the work wasn't an original work, but derived, and many people scorned the agency which let this slip past their notice. They also complained to the organization that they shouldn't be awarded for plagiarism. When I looked at that case, I had thought it was another case of tired artist spots something in that idea which could be used in a different light, but gets punished for using the material in a way which isn't different enough to be judged as a different idea. Not many would've noticed it was the same work if the ad itself didn't win the award. And even if they did, they wouldn't bother to report it.
Perhaps in a world without internet, works like theirs would've passed by various scrutiny and win awards.
If you plan to use something that isn't yours, give credit where it's due - and not use materials by others similarly, even if it is in a different perspective. Unless if you're paying the original creator off, or had their permission to use it.
Thanks for the interesting talk. It's confirmation of what I've always thought was true. If you're still new at something, you'll have to learn from your betters till you grow out of their shadows.
Keith Richards and Mick Jagger cut up newspapers to come up with the lyrics for Casino Boogie when they were recording Exile on Main Street in France. I think Richards wrote that they had simply run out of ideas after doing so much recording, so they used the newspaper method.
his ideas are now in my swipe file, well saved.
Awesome lecture 👏👏👏
true originality comes from The Universal mind.After that nothing is original.
Brilliant, genius, bravo!
exactly what i needed to hear
Maravilloso, Austin! Totalmente de acuerdo contigo 😜 Muchas gracias*************
I have your books ! Thanks for them. My friend just bought your journal. Love your work
I think it has to do with our perception of loss, so we think it's ok to do it unless is being done unto us. Look for the TED talk by Kirby Ferguson and his documentary series "Everything is a Remix". This talk by itself feels like a 'remix' of that, much informative one.
If you always do what you always did, you will always get what you always got - Al Einstein
Time is the only true avenger
I love his book!!!!
Nailed it! Been an artist since I was a kid and even I can admit this lol. I express my art through music, sketching, comics, and photography. All of my ideas I get for my art are from other things/people. For example, when I used to make beats, I would get inspiration from other beats. I'd essentially combine multiple beats together to make an entirely "new" beat. OR, I'd hear a song and then I'd edit the song based on specific melodies in the song to make an entirely "new" song. OR, i'd hear a melody from some random song I came across and use that to make a beat. The same case applies to my other art forms lol.
Fantástica palestra! 👏👏👏👏👏
He’s absolutely right! I think live in this era there’s no original idea 😂
That's how we learn and grow.... From everyone and everything around us! Hahahaha! I absolutely love this!!! So basic to human existence!
Sooo INSPIRING!!!
I think you will find the answer in the way it is described in this talk, "Imitation is not flattery. Transformation is flattery."
Wow! Incredible 🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽
watch it at 1.75x. And you are welcome! :)
lol thanks
Belated thank you :)
Thanks for sharing that quote.
that is why art is an imitation of life. we just need to make a new innovation of the existing piece of art. :-?
sampling in music. namely hip-hop/rap. thats pretty much this whole video right there
You are brilliant love your way of thinking and speaking
I wish more professors understood this
So what I found on Tumblr came from this? This is why I love bloggers.
There was a great artist that pieced together a living picture that could show us how bodies would move under an influence ... His name was Isaac Newton, and he also stole lot's of ideas. He phrased his theft on a very elegant way: “If I have seen further, it is because i have stood on the shoulders of giants.”
My favorite author
I love this. Frederic Chopin 'stole' the idea for his famous Fantasie Impromptu--a Romantic piece used by those who audition for university-level piano courses--adding his own tone, style, and harmonies, from a piece both rhythmically and technically complex, a piece that acts as a third movement for the "Sonanta quasi una Fantasia;" the third movement of Beethoven's "Moonlight Sonata."
POV: You're in year 11 English and your teacher linked this video for an assignment