DRIVEN 2014 #7: Audi A3 Sedan 1.8T quattro vs Mercedes-Benz CLA 200 vs BMW 316i

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 14 дек 2024

Комментарии • 241

  • @drpain526
    @drpain526 9 лет назад +36

    CLA250 is hands down the sexiest vehicle I have seen in a long time
    In a world of uninspired, mundane, stale cars hitting the market...the CLA250 just shines like a diamond in the rough

  • @shaun8062
    @shaun8062 9 лет назад +60

    great! so this episode is about accents!

  • @MrLeonidas123
    @MrLeonidas123 9 лет назад +2

    Guys you did a great job! I purchased the a3 quattro version 2016 and its amazing.I agree that even when im driving to the variety store in my trackpants it feels like im going somewhere special in this car.The key with these cars is to load them up with features to feel luxurious.Such as power passenger seats,dual climate,interior ambient lighting, navigation,keyless ignition, etc. Without these upgrades you will feel stupid driving the 4 rings thats missing the important stuff.

  • @unintentionallyfire
    @unintentionallyfire 10 лет назад +9

    Shouldn't the 3-series be compared to the C-Class and the A4?

    • @Jeffrey202031
      @Jeffrey202031 10 лет назад

      and the Lexus IS

    • @catc296
      @catc296 10 лет назад

      328i and up the 316i is in the price range of this cars but i'm not sure it's available in every country.

    • @catc296
      @catc296 10 лет назад

      catc296 i meant 318i and up sorry

    • @kevinmayer2470
      @kevinmayer2470 10 лет назад +1

      you're right ! normaly a4 = series 3 a6 = series 5 and a8 = series 7 but be happy, the a3 is better than a serie 3... so the a4 will be absolutely better than a serie 3 ;)

    • @pradyuntiruvaloorviavoori9194
      @pradyuntiruvaloorviavoori9194 10 лет назад

      Kevin Mayer the a4 is so old and has so less power and it is really boring

  • @lingyg
    @lingyg 10 лет назад +2

    Funny and entertaining as always. But finale already? ?? I have not had enough yet. More episides plz, u guys and the story lines are awesome.

  • @jin5632
    @jin5632 8 лет назад +6

    1. Audi A3
    2. BMW 3 series
    3. merc CLA
    BMW 2 serie should have been compared instead of 3 series, but Audi A3 would still win AND the 3 series is not boring to look especially the M sport model

  • @tt6368
    @tt6368 9 лет назад +4

    I'm dont know if I should choose the BMW Tree series or the audi A Tree

    • @gvengittas
      @gvengittas 9 лет назад +3

      First u should get on your "TREE"

    • @EXHAUSTlON
      @EXHAUSTlON 8 лет назад +1

      Or the tree pointed star CLA

  • @elvinabelgeorge9378
    @elvinabelgeorge9378 9 лет назад +21

    im going for the BMW 316i.

  • @shantidewa
    @shantidewa 9 лет назад +8

    Mercedes is really good looking and I think is the best

  • @Rickusty
    @Rickusty 9 лет назад

    Shouldn't the A3 sedan be compared to the BMW 2 series and Merc B class?

  • @apollon31
    @apollon31 10 лет назад

    S60 T4? Why left out the Volvo ?

  • @dieza.z
    @dieza.z 8 лет назад +2

    love the way you guy gives review and comparison.
    KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK! VERY HELPFUL INFO!!

  • @OfficialArulSmurfz
    @OfficialArulSmurfz 8 лет назад +1

    Before this I'm more into Cla250. The way I see a Cla 300 is nothing but normal sedan, but now, I'm slowly in love with that bad boy

  • @basilfabian05
    @basilfabian05 9 лет назад

    I watch this driven episode all the time so pls don't let this be the final episode.

  • @99syafiq
    @99syafiq 9 лет назад +18

    NONSENSE. Its suppose to be BMW 3 Series Vs. Audi A4 Vs. Mercedes C-Class. Doesn't make sense at all the cars you're comparing.

    • @SHADOW-lp2lc
      @SHADOW-lp2lc 4 года назад +1

      According to the price it was mate

  • @Aillman3
    @Aillman3 9 лет назад

    Kereta apa paling problem antara 3 brand ni?

  • @mi051225
    @mi051225 9 лет назад +1

    Are you guys drunk. The BMW 3 series does not belong in this comparison. There is a car called the 1 series, in case you are not aware of it in Malaysia.

  • @ilhamanuar
    @ilhamanuar 4 года назад

    Please review bmw 320i G20

  • @jordanmarcxavier6757
    @jordanmarcxavier6757 10 лет назад +2

    That was awesome. Harve....isnt that your license plate from your 320d?

  • @lohendran11
    @lohendran11 9 лет назад

    Will there be any driven episodes in 2015 ??
    I miss driven so much !!

  • @avaxis
    @avaxis 9 лет назад +2

    Based on the episode, I'd summarise the 3 series as the most practical car of the 3. Boring to look at, yes, but I don't find the Audi any better than the BMW. The CLA 200 is really beautiful to look at, what a shame.

  • @duolampaz
    @duolampaz 10 лет назад

    no more new episode? I wonder if paul tan u can make a review comparison for MPV that under 100k also, bcuz currently my father still in dilemma of changing our old naza citra...

  • @KelvinOon90
    @KelvinOon90 10 лет назад

    May I know will the BMW 316i underpower when it drive to Genting? Because after bought the Nissan Almera, I have been scare for those underpower car. But if it can easily climb up Genting without underpower issue then it should b a good choice. ^^

  • @wong888888881
    @wong888888881 10 лет назад

    Final episode? Noooo

  • @dannyfoo3404
    @dannyfoo3404 10 лет назад +49

    Good review. Despite the fact the Merc is the worse one here, I will take the Merc over the other 2 make. It is down right damn gorgeous. Like a beautiful woman that doesn't know how to cook. I would rather wake up to that!

  • @andrevr4229
    @andrevr4229 10 лет назад +7

    Nice vs guys, the a3 is a clear winner, such a good car.

  • @kakiigamee
    @kakiigamee 8 лет назад

    i have a question....
    in many car that you all review, which is the best car in the price range of 90k to 200k??
    please suggest..kalau boleh yang harga biar kena dgn kualiti

  • @whatdayano0000
    @whatdayano0000 10 лет назад +1

    They do realise that the boot test is a bit unfair because the bmw is a not really the same type of car as the other 2. Both CLA and A3 are a hatchback first before sedan.

  • @shobin05
    @shobin05 10 лет назад +1

    THANK YOU FOR NOT MAKING SILLY JOKE!! I loved this episode the MOST!

  • @RenegadeHOU
    @RenegadeHOU 8 лет назад +1

    perfect cars to compare they were the exact 3 I was looking at. enjoyed the show

  • @Backhandlawz
    @Backhandlawz 2 года назад

    Not sure why 316i gets looked down a lot..

  • @chanlman
    @chanlman 10 лет назад

    after sometime people might forget what's RV comparison is

  • @grayisagirl
    @grayisagirl 9 лет назад

    So pity that no Manual transmission for these cars in M'sia

  • @sccleong
    @sccleong 10 лет назад

    do a comparison of A-segment cars next pls

  • @outalingamcrap9366
    @outalingamcrap9366 10 лет назад +3

    Blessed 2015, dear fellow fans! In my honest opinion (talking about compact executive or shorter D-segment cars), and now, with the arrival of the NEW and REAL-deal W205 Merc C-Class, I think you guys should pitch that new C-class together with Beemer 320 (at least) and Audi A4 (no more A3 please - A3 quattro or not, and that Merc CLA should best be coined as sport sedans instead of anything else, IMHO), Lexus IS and the Infiniti Q50. As for sub-RM200k D-segmenters, how about pitching the likes of the ALTERNATIVE choices such as Chevy Malibu, Hyundai Sonata LF, with the facelifted Peugeot 508, VW Passat as well as the upcoming new Ford Mondeo for this year? And how about pitching an episode which you can name as "THE BUDGET HATCH Dilemma: How worthy can they be for less than 6-digit Malaysian pricing" showcasing the likes of Ford Fiesta to pitch with the likes of Kia Rio, Mazda 2, Honda Jazz 2014 as well as Malaysia's own all-new Proton Iriz 1.6 Executive which are powered up by engines of 100 bhp and more? Alternatively, the Perodua MyVi 1.3 can also be pitched with the Kia Picanto, Mitsubishi Mirage AND the Iriz 1.3 for the less than 100 bhp or 1.2L/1.3L category as well. As for C-segmenters, how about a pitch between alternatives such as VW Jetta and Nissan Sylphy with the Peugeot 408 and Renault Fluence (in a C-segment battle of East versus West)? Cheers!

  • @yohanestriatmanto2977
    @yohanestriatmanto2977 9 лет назад

    Where's Driven 2015!!!!!!

  • @zazoubakou3860
    @zazoubakou3860 10 лет назад

    du yu spik inglis?

  • @onewha90
    @onewha90 9 лет назад +1

    thats pretty funny , you are comparing 3 series with A3 , and CLA , did you ever know about car segments ???

  • @mariogonzalezlang4551
    @mariogonzalezlang4551 5 лет назад +1

    Great! I love the review!!! So excited of your work

  • @TricksterThe5th
    @TricksterThe5th 10 лет назад

    They really have to compare fwd hot hatches, the fun car to drive! GTI, ST, RS, Speed3 etc....

  • @afdhalsoft
    @afdhalsoft 10 лет назад +1

    Lol, always looking forward to watch episodes with Sam Loo in it. Never fails to chuckle me. Sadly, it also means the end of the season. New season, please come fast!

  • @JennyPenny707
    @JennyPenny707 10 лет назад +11

    A3 is fast but it over-priced. It's the same price as the a4 and that car is fully loaded
    CLA is drop dead gorgeous, maybe it's flaws of space can be overlooked. But the gearbox is terrible and ride is crap
    316i is boring. Exterior and interior are boring. But at this price point, probably the best value. But it doesn't handle well. That's the M sport.

    • @wong888888881
      @wong888888881 10 лет назад +1

      No it's not , it's probably some fans go and imitate his name

    • @rezzmenow
      @rezzmenow 10 лет назад

      The one used in the review is obviously the non M-sport model, and the reviewer still said it handled better than the other two cars.

    • @JL-ef7bh
      @JL-ef7bh 10 лет назад +4

      The A3 is still the best performer though, add an extra 40k for all wheel drive, great gearbox and good 0-100 time, worth the money if you ask me. But the CLA unfortunately picks up more chicks.

    • @newbornnewborn5309
      @newbornnewborn5309 10 лет назад +3

      Here in Germany, they call audi drivers either a pro or a show off. That's because you get the most hp for the least price. So either you're a young guy wanting the most hp, or a pro that can handle high hp. However the handling is not as good as the BMW.
      I'll take the BMW home anytime if I have the money! Top handling, good AT and good looks (at least for me).

    • @rezzmenow
      @rezzmenow 10 лет назад

      Newborn Newborn Then what do they called VW drivers there?

  • @chimyshark
    @chimyshark 10 лет назад +1

    Love the series guys! Hope you guys come back! =')

  • @eternalenvy2670
    @eternalenvy2670 8 лет назад +1

    nice review! i do really enjoyed when i watch this haha
    greetings from indonesia!

  • @goonerook
    @goonerook 10 лет назад

    merc c class?

  • @NabilLanang
    @NabilLanang 9 лет назад

    very casual yet superb comparison review.thumbs up

  • @armaandhami207
    @armaandhami207 6 лет назад +1

    My ranking:
    Audi A3
    BMW
    Merc cla

  • @actrostan5259
    @actrostan5259 10 лет назад

    To the hosts of Driven: Why don't you guys do a group test on cars like the MyVi, Axia, i10, the upcoming Proton Iriz etc to see where should P licencees put their money on. That would be better.

  • @amykiamfook6371
    @amykiamfook6371 10 лет назад +2

    I prefer the BMW 316i..

    • @Amg3677
      @Amg3677 9 лет назад +1

      Amy Kiamfook bmw is the sensative engine out there

  • @SquiinTv
    @SquiinTv 10 лет назад +1

    how can you compare passenger space of two different SEDANS to a CLA250 COUPE … its a coupe… a 4 door COUPE!!!

  • @SelvamSelvam-si7xm
    @SelvamSelvam-si7xm 6 лет назад +2

    cla is my favorite

  • @RoliMchau
    @RoliMchau 8 лет назад

    this review was actually Entertaining .... just awesome!

  • @syameer95
    @syameer95 10 лет назад +1

    It's such a shame that I've to admit that although the 3-series is too mainstream, but it still offers the best package on overall for that price. *sigh* I guess that's why it's too mainstream!

  • @Vanguardkl
    @Vanguardkl 8 лет назад +1

    biased as a3 was what i thought would be best. cla is better than hafidz puts it, just yes it's a bit style over substance. 316-what you'd buy to say i can't afford a BMW.. but i want one anyway

  • @waijun08
    @waijun08 10 лет назад

    Sad, malaysian version doesnt stand out, i will still go back to top gear.

  • @Vanguardkl
    @Vanguardkl 8 лет назад +1

    nice job guys. good video.

  • @michaporeda6149
    @michaporeda6149 6 лет назад

    So You take premium car in base equipment and tell, they don't have different stuff... You don't buy that kind of car to drive it with basic option...

  • @kobenoyashi3394
    @kobenoyashi3394 10 лет назад +1

    very entertaining! Even though these models aren't available in this trim in America, I liked the skit style presentation!

  • @zda0682
    @zda0682 3 года назад

    6 years later and the BMW 316i is priced around 63k in mudah.

  • @bluehunter6854
    @bluehunter6854 7 лет назад +2

    mercedes benz cla is best coupe car

  • @maxcomrade8184
    @maxcomrade8184 10 лет назад +2

    CLA 200 :)

  • @sonujosemathew
    @sonujosemathew 9 лет назад +4

    Audi3 has the premium looking dashboard? ohh really?

    • @kbabdullahi3096
      @kbabdullahi3096 6 лет назад

      Sonu Mathew I said the same thing, they were just talking about the low res screen

  • @IzuanOthmanIZO1980
    @IzuanOthmanIZO1980 3 месяца назад

    My car is f30 316i 2015 converted to msport body kit...and i am pretty sure 100% that my brand is most powerful than 2 brands

  • @JL-ef7bh
    @JL-ef7bh 10 лет назад +5

    I really hope Mercedes in Malaysia would provide the CLA250 with a better gearbox in the future, perhaps that may attract more buyers to get them. And I'd recommend people to watch the video at the end, typical Toyota fanboy was hilarious.

    • @iambryan1234
      @iambryan1234 10 лет назад +1

      Toyota doesn't make nice cars like they used to. I remenber laughing my ass off when a vios owner told me she was averaging around rm10 on an approximately 14km trip back and forth while i was averaging rm5 in an e90 corolla on the same trip

    • @JL-ef7bh
      @JL-ef7bh 10 лет назад

      iambryan1234 I personally think Toyota's reason for using old engines in their cars for reliability is a pathetic excuse.

    • @iambryan1234
      @iambryan1234 10 лет назад

      The power of cost cutting does wonders

    • @jamiljam1291
      @jamiljam1291 10 лет назад

      Mister fining berapi

    • @MrAriffeffendi
      @MrAriffeffendi 10 лет назад

      mercedes has a bad history in gearbox. almost all models from 1980s has slow response on the gear

  • @younghans2328
    @younghans2328 10 лет назад +2

    Even the blind wud get this right...with a liltle extra, peeps u wud DEFINITELY wud want to go for CLA..Mercedes Benz FTW!! Period!

  • @GameTimeGTX
    @GameTimeGTX 6 лет назад +3

    "That's coz You're a hobbit..."😂

  • @davisdesigns1153
    @davisdesigns1153 8 лет назад +17

    These videos are so annoying ...but I still keep watching😂

  • @mohdfairuz1011
    @mohdfairuz1011 10 лет назад

    the best car review to watch, well done guys

  • @boljoke
    @boljoke 10 лет назад

    Well done. Love DRIVEN.

  • @LESHEWIN
    @LESHEWIN 10 лет назад

    Hey guys, good video loved it! but do try to make an intro before your video starts and try using better terms to describe the vehicle! besides that, the video was great oh ya try better sound quality when talking. loved it thank you.

  • @ridzuan786
    @ridzuan786 10 лет назад

    best video i expected for, well suited for young adults to get these cars.

  • @Bio2cool
    @Bio2cool 5 лет назад

    Good review guys, like the humours, just reduce the music when talking, hard to hear with that loud music.

  • @wanbee3635
    @wanbee3635 3 года назад

    Among those 3:
    Audi is no. 1, followed by BMW and Merc 👍😊

  • @Greatkappy
    @Greatkappy 9 лет назад +2

    Front wheel is best

    • @maumauhun
      @maumauhun 9 лет назад +1

      Nedim Mehh Nah

    • @Greatkappy
      @Greatkappy 9 лет назад

      maumauhun it's the safest

    • @villepusa3830
      @villepusa3830 9 лет назад +1

      +Nedim Mehh Really? Are you idiot or just stupid??

  • @petur4eto
    @petur4eto 10 лет назад

    Nice review guys! Fun too! :)

  • @metrindojaya6064
    @metrindojaya6064 8 лет назад +1

    except Mercedez ..other car like bmw 3 and audi, is not on formula one race...so mercedez won..by brand, luxury, value, decent speed..

  • @FerchOfficial
    @FerchOfficial 7 лет назад +1

    I put a e s t h e t i c s over performance any time, where i live the streets suck major balls. I'd go for the Merc CLA 250. Audi as a brand needs a major redesign, and I've never liked the looks of the BMW

  • @arbak89
    @arbak89 10 лет назад

    What, final episode already? What a sad day, bring more Samloo in next season. Lol..

  • @noel3466
    @noel3466 6 лет назад

    Good review

  • @jeremymichael7095
    @jeremymichael7095 8 лет назад +2

    This is like a low budget top get

  • @kraezygees7711
    @kraezygees7711 10 лет назад

    ohhh my BM got scratch. . 8:04

  • @madan4312
    @madan4312 8 лет назад

    good job folks.... liked the review.... it's a different take

  • @nrnccrdn
    @nrnccrdn 10 лет назад +3

    3 Series doesn't even compete with the other two, so it is a bit unfair.
    3 Series goes against A4 and C Class, so luggage test fails miserably.

  • @XiaoComicDevil
    @XiaoComicDevil 6 лет назад

    Nice car review, good job! Malaysia

  • @lsksupporter
    @lsksupporter 8 лет назад

    I love my 316i < 3

  • @oliverkhoo
    @oliverkhoo 9 лет назад

    All three are awesome

  • @nething94
    @nething94 6 лет назад +1

    CLA

  • @dalphinusdal5135
    @dalphinusdal5135 10 лет назад

    Haha... I wonder why Toyota alwiz kena at the end? But it's funny.

    • @Amg3677
      @Amg3677 9 лет назад

      DalphinuS DaL because toyota is the no 1 top selling in asia

  • @benanglersgear3324
    @benanglersgear3324 9 лет назад

    Clear winner definitely goes to Audi !!

  • @Amg3677
    @Amg3677 9 лет назад +2

    wauuu the back mercedes so sexy , akhirnya mercedes da ubah bentokk , kalau x mcm org tuaaa !!! , tp enjin tahan lasak , banyak org kaya kata bmw xthn sensatif selalu meragam terok dari proton

  • @jayho4775
    @jayho4775 6 лет назад

    Going to get a Audi A3 sedan soon~~

  • @Disinf3ctant
    @Disinf3ctant 9 лет назад +1

    Replace the 3 series with a 2 series. You get a similarly styled car but with a more exciting engine and rear wheel drive.
    CLA 200: gorgeous but sluggish.
    228i: great handling. But pretty basic without the options and too expensive with them.
    A3: a shit version of the golf GTI. You pay more and you trade performance for the badge, I'd honestly just disregard this car.
    So pick. Looks or performance?

  • @WiAndroid
    @WiAndroid 9 лет назад +1

    U got a new subcriber ☺☺

  • @xtechxtips
    @xtechxtips 10 лет назад +5

    I'll give a constructive criticism to the episodes of car reviews so far, it has been great to see Malaysians finally did some of these reviews, but sometimes the reviews caught of topic, maybe too much jokes or other funny concepts they try to put into it.
    I hope these cars can be reviewed professionally because they are many serious watchers out there would take it seriously based on the things said in the video, so i hope you guys will have more passion to bring out more of the car itself instead of funny jokes.
    Thank you.

    • @sallea.1165
      @sallea.1165 10 лет назад

      I agree. The faux rivalry and the jokes that usually comes with it are starting to bore me. It's starting to look more like an act, rather than reviewing the cars objectively. I prefer honest reviews, minus the acting and scripted rivalry. However, I'd like to congratulate the team for creating the best Malaysian video car review so far. Hope the show will be better next season.

    • @artificialharmonix
      @artificialharmonix 10 лет назад

      Salle A. yes to this. its really awkward to watch. borderline cringeworthy

    • @Jeffrey202031
      @Jeffrey202031 10 лет назад

      they want to be like topgear uk eventually

  • @koyuki4848
    @koyuki4848 10 лет назад +2

    A3 vs 316 vs CLA? LOL!
    A4 vs 320 vs C200 would be more or less equal

    • @Urzu3
      @Urzu3 10 лет назад +3

      they r comparing an entry level for the same class..

    • @Clove_Parma
      @Clove_Parma 9 лет назад

      koyuki4848 More like CLA 250

    • @koyuki4848
      @koyuki4848 9 лет назад

      Dan Ghys A4/3-series natural competitor is the C-class not CLA-class

    • @Clove_Parma
      @Clove_Parma 9 лет назад

      koyuki4848 actually yeah, maybe 2 series 118I? vs lower range a3 vs cla 250?

    • @koyuki4848
      @koyuki4848 9 лет назад

      iinm
      A2 (hatch) vs A200 vs 1-series
      A3 (sedan) vs CLA vs N/A
      A4 vs C-Class vs 3-series
      A2 and A3 are probably from the same platform, while price wise the 316 does fight with the A3 and CLA but segment wise it isn't.

  • @tinbjj
    @tinbjj 6 лет назад

    nice video guys :D

  • @shobin05
    @shobin05 10 лет назад

    Guess i spoke too soon, well, at least its at the end.

  • @Avatargeek23
    @Avatargeek23 6 лет назад +1

    Went purchase a CLA walked out with a 18 C300 4matic lol. The CLA is definitely the cheap Benz and it shows when compared to its bigger brothers

  • @magoo308
    @magoo308 10 лет назад +8

    beli bmw 316 then cabut the 316 lettering.hehehe

  • @DriveSpot
    @DriveSpot 9 лет назад

    Very good test ;)