Johnny Depp trial: Judge rejects Amber Heard's demands for dismissal | LiveNOW from FOX
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 май 2022
- The judge presiding over the Johnny Depp and Amber Heard defamation trial has denied a motion from Heard's attorneys to dismiss the case against her. Depp has sued his ex-wife for $50 million dollars alleging that her claims of domestic violence have permanently damaged his acting career.
Subscribe to LiveNOW from FOX! ruclips.net/user/livenowfox?su...
Where to watch LiveNOW from FOX: www.livenowfox.com/
Follow us @LiveNOWFOX on Twitter: / livenowfox
Raw and unfiltered. Watch a non-stop stream of breaking news, live events and stories across the nation. Limited commentary. No opinion. Experience LiveNOW from FOX.
“I can tell you she’s not the abuser” also amber on recording “I wasn’t punching you I was HITTING you”
lmao
😆😆😆😆
I love how his defense rests with the widely exaggerated and frankly pathetic “reach” that he is presenting as a fact. That just because Johnny may have “fought” back, he was abusive. And just because it may have happened once, it happened all the time as a fact.
That’s some serious Lawyering stretching the truth until covers a whole rooftop
Literally if it was the only recording that she said that and she admitted to hitting him, imagine all the others times that were not recorded! i don’t believe her for a sec and I hope she really goes away off trying to be any type of image after this
-I can tell you alcohol is good for your liver
Alcohol:
Which liver?
“I can tell you she’s not the abuser.” OBJECTION, hearsay. Lmfao.
ROFL
Lmao, nice! And it's true, since the Turd's lawyer heard her say it! Though the lawyer who tried it might get held in contempt for being a smartass. 🤣
when I tell you I CHOKED-
I mean he can say it, but cannot prove it
Wtf I heard that and literally said the same thing right before I saw this comment
She literally said “I’m here because my ex husband is suing me for an op-Ed I wrote” goodness this is ridiculous she literally admitted to writing it
AND she said that the op-ed wasn't JUST ABOUT Johnny but other men as well... So that proves the op-ed WAS referring to Johnny.
@@jfregia8070 didn't she say she had never been abused prior to being with him?
@@stormswordsworld9485 I'm not sure on that BUT she said she has NEVER assaulted anyone she's been romantically linked with right after they played a recording of her taunting Johnny and admitting that she was hitting him...
@@jfregia8070 regardless, even if a little of its true, she's spun so many webs that no one would believe it
"If you can't convince, you confuse."
Amber turd and her lawyers demonstrated it well.
Haha amber turd....
I was waiting for Amber's lawyer to pull up a picture of Chewbacca.
I was waiting him to blame Gozilla
I think they only confused themselves 🤣🤣🤣
@@michaelhockenjos7208 why godzilla. Why not blame the judge
Good to see that their initial claim of "He hit her and left physical marks" has now changed to " oh it was actually verbal abuse" because of their shitty fake evidence
isn't this literally a copy pasted comment from someone else?
Right?! Her lawyer said, "non physical abuse" what the heck??!@
objection hearsay
@@jozefk.7720 this has nothing to do with Depp. Comment stealing bots have been popping up all over RUclips lately
@@rohan1864 Move to strike your argument
I honestly believe that AH didn’t think it was going to go this far. She thought that Johnny would just lay down and take her abuse. You got this Johnny. This motion is absolutely ridiculous
As we are seeing, he have never hit back as she claimed before. So I think she thinks that he would do the same with this. But he decided to hit back once, but in a different way...
They have to put in a motion for dismissal. Depp's team rested their case. On the off chance the judge decided to dismiss it it's. 50/50 chance for them. They have to do it. Even if it's rejected
That being said, Johnny has it in the bag. Judge isn't buying he story at all based on the way she worded the dismissal rejection
I read AH as asshole at first 😂
Yep. It's because the U.K. court's decision. They had NO idea how Hollywood works, gold diggers, and blackmail. So it emboldened her and she has the worst possible legal team.
Judge Penney Azcarate has done a great job of maintaining her courtroom. She speaks quietly and politely. She does not get rattled. This could have been a very difficult courtroom case to manage and she made it look easy. My hat is off to her. Great job, Judge Azcarate!! 🧑⚖️
When you say “I’m not going to waste the court’s time.” You’ve already made a fool of yourself and have lost almost instantly. Ridiculous.
Exactly what is he saying 😡
he’s just doing his job lol he’s a lawyer and he took a tough client which i respect him for, i would blame amber for making this so hard for him lmao
@@rileyjulian3214 I respect a lawyer actually trying.
But these people are jokes. Do I really need to show examples?
I'm so glad Johnny fought to get cameras into the courtroom. This is becoming such an important case for men to be taken more seriously in domestic abuse cases. We're with you Johnny!
oh i didn’t know he fought for that. thought it is a normal procedure in the USA.. but yeah good he did!
@@fly89 No not this many cameras, you need to get permission for that. There's also full press coverage.
Mmm, Roman Polanski has been charged with multiple cases of pedophilia and sexually assaulting women - he was defended by nearly all Hollywood big names. Chris Brown abused Rihanna and got her hospitalized but wasn't jailed at all, only had to do community service. But tell me more about how men aren't taken seriously when JD has received nothing but support and encouragement, while other male abusers escape punishment and let the woman suffer.
That is such a huge thing a lot of people don't realize. This might actually set a example that men CAN be abused. In general this is just laughed off by a lot of people.
*ETA* I fully agree that this is even more huge for men. Not taking away from that yall. Go ahead and sit down now 😅 I didn't mean to ruffle feathers lol
Not just men but any sex who has to deal with a partner that acts like her.
crazy how her story went from “he beat me to the level of having bruises and cuts all over my body” to “our point is actually about emotional abuse”
That's not the case here, its the means for this dismissal.
Well, not only that but Witnesses have shown that she is the abuser in this relationship, not him. Having an argument with someone doesn’t make you an emotional abuser, which is what her lawyers are claiming. If that were the case, everyone would be an “emotional abuser”. But she severed his finger, punched him in the face on several occasions, spit on him, etc.
This motion is based on Depp’s evidence only. I think he means there’s some evidence in there that he committed emotional abuse and it makes the article true. I don’t agree but that’s the argument. Disney didn’t drop him because of statements about emotional abuse. There’re probably going to put on a lot of evidence to show he abused her physically when they present their side. It will all be her statements and circumstantial evidence.
Each word coming out from her mouth is pure lie. This fact is more than obvious, and I knew it since the beginning.
At this point even if Johnny drop kicked her through a window I would say let the man go. I know he didn't lift a finger to her but even if he did, this might be the one instance where I wouldn't blame him.
His “I want to be respectful and not waste the court’s time” is the most ingenuine thing I’ve heard out of this dude’s mouth. It’s a pity attempt to come off as the “nice guy”, but he has no true meaning behind it.
Bastards
Best part is that he then proceeds to do exactly that. He spews so much nonsense all the while claiming to not waste the court's time. That judge has the patience of a saint.
Objection Hearsay
@@gauthambb I agree
It's the same thing as when people say "No offense but..." and what is following is always 100% an offense. Or "I don't want to be disrespectful but..." and what follow is disrespectful. It's like a bad fake disclaimer that people use to try to shield them about what they're about to do or trying to downplay their following statement.
Well said Nagy....
This judge is fair, professional and compassionate. She exudes respect for all and very rarely shows any indication that she is taking a side. This shows she is a great judge! 👍
If he stopped mentioning all the time "I'm not going to take up any more of the court's time", he would really save the court's time.
really annoys me whenever he says it
He's projecting and trying to divert away from the fact that he knows he definitely wastes the court's time.
Which keeps reminding me he's wasting time all the time.
Not to mention he had the audacity to be so rude when JD tried to talk and answer questions, then says JD is the one wasting the court's time, when they don't even have their stuff together. So unorganized, spending so much time looking for pages and etc.
Meanwhile he wants to rush a man's livelihood out the door for the jurors and courts sake. Heard's lawyer is a PoS.
Jury: "Motion to strike is denied"
Rotternborn: "Objection, hearsay"
😂😂😂 good one.
I was waiting for it!
Objection, muffins
😂😂😂
i was 100% sure the video was gonna end with this exact statement😂
Win or lose, JD is bringing awareness to abuse on men. Whoever advised him on having cameras in the courtroom, thank you!!
He won in the eyes of the public
Exactly. It’s going to be different when a woman falsely accuse men now
I literally lost some brain cells listening to this lawyer. He makes me realize I could definitely be a lawyer if the bar is that low.
😂 the realest thing I’ve heard all day. I literally dose off, woke up and saw your comment.
He just kept repeating the same words quickly, his job can easily be replaced by a house bird
watching this makes me realize that chimps could make better lawyers than these schmucks
Just popping in here to appreciate the wonderful "bar" pun in reference to a legal case. I think we can all agree that the Bar is pretty low :D
😂😂😂
She claimed physical abuse... destroyed his career and now claims something completely differrent.
Today was a joke.. plus a "doctor" who has to constantly read from her notes while testifying? (this is going to be fun for cross). Makes the excuse that reading facilitates her remembering it more clearly?? Dr. Curry had no problems with that lol. Dr. Dawn before admits to have much experience in court but still interrupts the judge and tries to "help" with decisions? Makes faces to the jury while the judge calls the lawyers to the bench and... continues while they're all talking! WOW she is as credible as an expert haha
@@marianavvitoria I guess college students should try the "reading facilitates remembering more clearly" on their professors at exam time, seeing as how this joke of a psychologist can't retain knowledge for a COURT CASE SHES A WITNESS IN.
now she's saying sexual abuse too. like he r*ped her with a broken bottle suddenly. wtf.
Ridiculous. Her only goal is to destroy him.
The headline was “sexual ab”. The accusation was “physical ab”. Now it’s “verbal ab”. Which one is it? I feel like they’re grasping now. It’s sad. Victims of DV are many and this type of stuff makes it even harder for them.
It seems that "hearsay" and "I’m not gonna waste the court's time" is all you need to learn to be a lawyer.
Objection hearsay.
That and "did i read that right"
And to say “currrect?” (Correct) after reading tabloids in court as fact. 🤦
Thank you Mr rottenborn
@@alexfarman4580 "You read that very well"
They knew from the get-go they're going to lose. 😆
I was there Johnny six years ago supporting you when everyone was judging you and I know that you might have lost 6 years of your life and career due to Amber's mess, but in the end you are becoming something bigger than you could ever imagine. You bring hope to millions of men who have been abused and were not taken seriously or were scared to talk.
Yes, you are so right. I hope justice will win
These young people don't know about 21 jump street Johnny Depp! And Glen in The First Nightmare on Elm street! The person who was unfortunately the witness of his very best friend RIP River Phoenix who passed away in front of the Viper room, and he always taken care of Joaquin Phoenix and especially in his own addiction and Johnny Depp isn't perfect but he admits his own fault! The Johnny Depp that followed Winona Ryder and still has a tattoo saying "Wino Forever" she was on the "me too" business and what she did was garbage.
There is undisputed evidence that SHE is the abuser! Of course she wants it thrown out because she is losing this hard. Justice for Johnny Depp!!!
Indeed
am glad the judge said no.. AH GIRL you best pick out you best outfit tomorrow..
100%!
@@diesellove she's gonna dress like the judge now.
Actually, this is normal as halftime in a football game. You make this motion to preserve rights to appeal and/or new trial. Standard stuff. JD will make the same motion. Judge will deny both and the jury will decide. Nothing to see here.
Ironic that she wants the case to be dismissed before she has the chance to testify.
Surely if all these abuse claims were true she would want to explain her side?
JUSTICE FOR JOHNNY DEPP!
Genau !!!
J.D. 🌷💜🌷
That tells you everything. She doesn't want to be questioned as to why there's no proof he ever abused her.
If she was really the victim, then she would have nothing to lose by sticking it out. How scared her lawyers must be to think the case could get worse by having her testify
I don't think she wants the case to be dismissed?
@@junesnow4760 that’s what this motion was for though, to dismiss the case
If she wasn't GUILTY and had ALL this evidence of abuse why would she try to get the case dismissed🤔
Actually she testified that she wrote that. She admitted under oath that she wrote the article.
“He physically hit me” to “oh it was verbal abuse”. Amber is moving the goal post. There is absolutely 0 reason to believe anything she says now. 0 credibility.
Yeah but that's moving the goal post closer. xD
you forgot sexual abuse
"He physically hit me with his words"? 🤣🤣
@@ChimmyxChang I've known people with that mentality. People I don't associate with anymore lol.
"He didn't exactly use any abusive words... he raised his voice and that was traumatic to me. Well he didn't actually raise his voice... he changed his tone and that was just too much for my fragile sensibilities."
The evidence presented in court by Johnny and his team, is too overwhelmingly detailed to be ignored.
Hes going to bankrupt her over this.
@@christopherniceley8848 They implied Amber would be the one going bankrupt not Johnny 🤦♀
@@StarScythe7 Jhonny will never get work again hollywood will blacklist him for winning this case
when he was accused he was doomed. IF he didnt figght back he would have been assumed guilty and blacklisted. Now hes hurt a a birthing person objectively by suing her.
But both will lose, maybe?
And then Amber steps up to the stand and states plainly she wrote it! 🤦♀️😂 Isn’t there some repercussion if a lawyer is found to be lying on behalf of their client??
He's thinking woman I just covered for u, we are going with this story, oh crap u just exposed us.....how the hell do I fix this now. It must have been very hard to defend someone like that. Putting Thier foot init was the only thing they did, and looked stupid
The Judge was no nonsense type of person.. Super fair .. this is how a judge should be .. Very polite yet stern, speak very elegantly yet very direct. No means no, yes means yes ..Kudos Judge
The fact that Johnny has to go this far and this hard just to prove his innocence is absolutely unfair. Heard had put little effort to defame him because she knows how the social world works is genuinely disgusting.
💯💯💯‼️
Truth 100% !!!
I don't know who would take her lawyers after this, sometimes I wonder if they don't troll us, if it's not some live reality show or movie, I'm joking a little, I know it's not, but I've never seen such crazy lawyers, I'm really interested in the verdict, I loved i would see her in jail because she deserves it !!!
Fair point
remember when innocent till proven guilty was a thing? i miss those days
good thing hes not an average man, they couldn't afford to fight
“I can tell you she’s not the abuser” yeah, you can say it, but you CANNOT prove it. 😂 Justice for Johnny Depp!
Someone should’ve shouted out objection hearsay 🤣
@@natassjasworld 😂
There is evidence for that, therefore she is in fact abuser. So could that be lie under the oath?
For real. Like okay, so if you’re so confident then stick to your guns, if that’s really the case, then you should have nothing to fear 🤨 her team is passionate about contradicting themselves lol
It seems like their evidence on abuse is just a "dude, trust me". Which, in a defamation trial, has no weight at all
What ?!!! Did he really say that ?! She admitted herself that she abused him by “hitting him” ! Good call judge ! Much respect !
"hey judge, we have all this evidence that will 100% clear our clients name after being slandered for 2 weeks straight. Please dismiss this case so we don't have to show it" Makes absolutely no sense.
The amount of times I've shaken my head in utter disbelief at Amber's lawyers is insane. They have absolutely nothing.
Do you agree they have hearsay?
lol I agree. But it must be tricky to be the defense when you know your client is a lying douche.
@@henrikj3372 lots of hearsay
@@henrikj3372 OBJECTION!
@@henrikj3372 When you say they have hearsay, are you saying they can reasonably claim that Depp's case is hearsay or that AHs defense is hearsay? If the former, the testimony has not been about what she said, but what she did. So it does not qualify as hearsay. If the latter, AHs attorneys have not had a chance to present a proper defense yet. Though if this IS them doing that then she's toast. These trial don't matter as much as the court of public opinion. So ultimately the victor won't be whoever wins this trial. But whoever can have their hollywood career after this mess is over.
Amber not only destroys the careers of Johnny but also her own lawyers. I mean... Noone will want to hire them lol
Especially that woman. Ugh.
Not defending Amber’s case in the slightest, but to be fair though, her lawyers are fighting a battle that is borderline impossible to win. They’re just doing their jobs. Yes, they’re condescending and clumsy in some aspects but it’s hard to blame lawyers for doing the job they were hired to do.
That's a good one 😅😅😅
😂😂😂fact!
🤣🤣🤣🤣
How much of the courts time did you take up with side bars and objections.
What I have examined is the behavior of DV being exhibited by Johnny. I have seen reports that say "he won't look at her he is guilty" as a victim of physical abuse I will say you could not pay me (for lack of a better analogy) to sit me by or around the person who abused me, yet alone give them eye attention. He seems sad and hurt, and she seems unbothered and happy at times she glows when she speaks of "the good times". I would have no kind words to say about my abuser or recollect in a way that seems to almost miss the relationship. It's hurtful and embarrassing to recount things an abuser did to you. I don't see that from her. I see it more from him. Even when you asked him what he lost he says, "everything" even if he wins the case. I just hope that the God of justice would reveal the truth. I was not there, but I hope justice wins and the truth comes to the light.
“We can tell you she is not the abuser”
Dude the woman straight up admitted “just” hitting him. Hitting is still physical abuse like it or not. The fact she used the word “just” makes it sound like she sees no wrong, which i think is sick
It's called gaslighting.
That comment make the most sense
I think what AH meant when she said that was “well at least you’re not dead!”
Finally, a use of the term gaslighting that is actually appropriate. Although it would have been more apt if she said something like "I didn't hit him, I was just teasing him"
It looks like a horrible relationship very confusing but one thing is true she is a horrid person not saying that makes her guilty especially in woke America but man she has dark evil eyes like a shark
She really thought this would blow over and she would just get all the money . She never thought she’d actually get held accountable for her slimy actions bc she’s never had to until now. So amazing to watch
She thought this was the uk where she got an easy ride from the judge
She's scared now you can see it in her face! She knows she messed up and is now she's gonna pay for her actions, the law holds people accountable. She just wants his money and also to ruin his reputation. Fellas wake up pick your females or males wisely!
What woman lies and think she won't get away
She did? Is there a quote I can read somewhere?
@@heelercs people like you are sad always need someone else to think for you.. just pay attention it's obvious to everyone except you I guess.
She testified under oath, twice that she wrote it. And I quote “that is why I wrote the op Ed”
“I cAn teLl U tHAt sHeS nOtT tHe aBusEr“🤡
A prestigious lawyer who graduated from Walmart law school👏👏👏
He said “I’m not gonna waste the courts time with that” then proceeded to waste the courts time.
That’s all Rottenborn has done.
Thats lawyers for you
And he keeps wasting everyone's time with the bs they're putting out there 😂😂
I don’t understand why he keeps saying that. As if the judge and the jury are going to thank him for rushing through the case and coming to a conclusion without taking everything into account?
@@moeez1211 he sounds so unprofessional too. Like EVERYONE knows a case in trial can take a veryyy long time and no one is complaining except for MR ROTTEBORN
She's literally on tape admitting she assaulted him. How is she not under criminal investigation?
statute of limitation
How is she not in jail for lying repeatedly to the police in her depo alone???
Cause she is woman...If she was a man she would have lost everything by now,Disney fired Johny just in case he was guilty,Amber still has her job even after all those proofs of her being abusive,and thats equality ladies and gentlemen
Because that case is over; and gender equality is a folk tale.
this is probably your 100th time you have copy pasted this comment. And no I won't subscribe to your channel.
All I’ve seen is AH, her lawyers, her witnesses, etc., proven about JD’s substances abuse which he has confirmed, has never denied about him abusing them. I’m still waiting to see AH’s proof about JD abusing her. I thought that AH’s defense is to prove JD abused her, AH, not about his substance abuse. Maybe she uses “substance abuse and DV abuse” the same as “pledging and donating”..?
Johnny Depp pledged assault against Amber Turd. He has not been able to fulfill that obligation, but he pledged it.
Yes, he pledged it.
He pledged it.
@@dsandoval9396 I know right?! 😜😂🤣😆Because to AH, it’s the same thing, 😂
Johnny showed enormous patience with heard. Dailey physical and verbal abuse would push any human to the edge, but yet he maintained his composure
“I’m not going to waste the courts time with implications of defamation”
Wastes courts time by talking
Basically amber legal team in a nutshell. The irony.
🤣
"Did I read that right?"
objection hearsay
And then repeats that line 3-4 more times
I love how her attorney goes on and on about not wasting the courts time, as he spends 5 minutes talking in circles, effectively wasting the courts time lol😂🤦🏻♀️
Literally lol
That 🤡 wasted more time than anyone else in that room.
Yes, Yes I was just thinking that
What can he say more.? There is no more to say in AH case...
muffins are important, as is objecting to your own questions!
“There was no proof”
“ respect the courts time”
says the man who spent 10 minutes looking for document that didn’t even have the correct information.
Justice for Johnny depp
I believe he subconsciously fell for a woman that was just as abusive as his mother ! And he literally got torn to pieces He didn’t realize she had a toxic personality
It’s funny how her lawyer always states he doesn’t want to waste the courts time…yet ALL he does is WASTE THE COURTS TIME. If anything has to be dismissed, it’s Ms.Turd for her lies under oath.
He's waysting my time and I chose to watch the video.
@@sherpajones I think they were making a point. You chose to watch it. So did I. Now I’m choosing to point out, your comment, made no sense, really. Just saying.
Miss Trud. That's brilliant. Laughed for ever.
@@sarahbark7967 I came to say this!!! It's too perfect! From this day forth, I will now only refer to her as Ms. Turd.
Mrs. Turd🤣🤣
She files this dismissal motion for ONE REASON ONLY! She is scared to DEATH of taking the stand and being even FURTHER shown to be a FRAUD!!
You are exactly right. It’s her lawyers who wanted to get this case thrown out before it was her turn to testify because they know they can lose the case because Johnny Depp lawyers are going to tear her apart. I honestly think her lawyers were banking on the case getting thrown out now they are crapping their pants lol.
Exactly. She will not know exacrly what to say at all. She'll be trembling like a weak new born chicken.
This dismissal motion is required by the state of Virginia to be requested.
Edit - it is only "required" Heards lawyers are doing their job.
Facts amber is fraud hiring pyscho just to read script amber written and she has to read it bec she dont memorize her script 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Dennis I have never seen a comment upvoted so fast. Congratulations, genuinely. 160 in an hour. But to your point, you are absolutely correct.
My partner hired a lawyer to serve me divorce paper. That lawyer look exactly like Amber's lawyer. The hair style, the face, the talk, ect. She came to my house and said: " you are going to jail for abusing woman". I showed her my injuries on the face, the legs, and the head. She ran away. Lol. Great judge.
Her wanting the trial dismissed just proves even more that she is guilty and won't win this case
Yup... she started this whole circus... Johnny is just finishing it👍👏👌
For a lawyer who has wasted more time in a courtroom asking “DID I READ THAT RIGHT?” a hundred times and being very repetitive on things he reads than any lawyer I have ever seen, he sure loves to throw out “I don’t want to waste the court’s time” a lot trying to get brownie points from the jury. Lol
Ikr this guy is a joke
He's just out of touch. I'm sure the jury sees through his thin veil whenever he makes that not wasting time statement.
Typically for stuff like this, the jury isn’t present.
Rightttt!!! The irony in that statement is crazy lol "I stand up and go over the same points day after day and focus on totally irrelevant things 80% of the time and rifle off gossip rag headlines that are pretty much (insert hollywood celebrity here), but I don't wanna waste the courts time like they have"
BAAAAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!! c'mon bro
the joke in this case is that he's now actually denied all the evidence as shown in the case as false, demands dismissal because he knows his client has no case to stand on and their team just botched everything up because of the fact that AH is their client and has not given any correct evidence for them to even build a case on. In short, this is the straw that broke the camel's back.
She’s getting so destroyed in this case her reputation is completely ruined and she deserves it all she’s a terrible person for what she did to Johnny and everyone else she’s abused
Guarantee nothing will happen to her though and we’ll still see her in movies
@@unclebensrice4702 I'm glad that there are at least some people who see her as the liar she is
Don’t let that distract you from the fact that she took a dump on his bed
@@apapz3245 You heard? Amber Heard dropped the turd...
@@unclebensrice4702 who's we? Cause I can guarantee most people won't be seeing them even if she's in new movies lmao
Its crazy how people comes together..I wish we can also come together like this for other stuff too.
People get together for other stuff too :)
AH's Team: (says anything). Me: "OBJECTION HEARSAY!"
How did we go from “this exact makeup palette” to “verbal abuse, not physical”? 😂😂😂
cause of the damn muffins.
because the company that made that palette went on record it wasnt even in stores at the time she claimed to be using it to conceal bruises and marks
All because of a megapint
@@Inkdisc Fantastic response from them. If I was a woman I'd start buying their stuff.
🤣
I like that the Judge is being accountable for all evidence. She's doing a great job.
You got that right, this can’t be overstated
I don't think you understand the definition of 'accountable'.
Agree, she seems super reasonable and respectful to everyone involved.
Unfortunately not all judges are like her. Huge respect too her.
Pretty sure the word you’re looking for is “accounting for all the evidence” she’s no accountable for it, the lawyers are
"I'm not gonna argue with that" and then ends his statement with "that's our argument on that"
To Johnny Depp: you got this, man! You can do it! Justice for Johnny Depp.
The fact that they all see how bad this is getting for Amber and her lawyers still tried it. This is comical at this point.
On the other hand, it could be that the Judge is biased, as many people are speculating that (based upon the comments i read on last 2-3 videos, im assuming this), so it could be that they tried to throw in such pathetic plea attempt and the judge denying it would prove her unbiased nature and in the end of she rolls in favour of Amber then it would be because of "evidence and facts" and not any kind of biased nature. But I sure hope it doesn't happen and Depp wins.
I heard that this motion to strike was expected and is pretty standard to do. Don’t quote me on that though bc I’m not a law expert. Just heard a few mention it. But I hope I’m wrong and you’re right actually haha
@@_birdie you are right, birdie; this is standard and happens in everyone of them
even Amber's laywers knew she would reject it, there's too much evidence in favor of johnny, to have the case striked.
Actually, this is normal as halftime in a football game. You make this motion to preserve rights to appeal and/or new trial. Standard stuff. JD will make the same motion. Judge will deny both and the jury will decide. Nothing to see here.
It opens up the possibility of appeal afterwards (when) if she loses. They're covering the bases, going through the motions so this thing can never end...
My blood's boiling listening to her lawyers. Lies after lies, it's so amazing to watch her finally get exposed and accountable.
Don't get it twisted buddy. All lawyers are like that including depps because they get paid a lot and have a job to do. The only difference is amber turds case is very hard to prove so it will always make lawyers look like this. You're just watching a high profile case is why you think that. It happens more than you think 👍
That's a defence lawyer's job: throw muck, muddy those waters so much you cannot determine fact from fiction. Not guilty, because there's far too much muck! Justice!
Agree 100%
to be fair, thats the point of a lawyer.
He's not gonna say, "yeah shes guilty lmao", his job is to put aside personal feelings and defend his client in a non bias manner.
That's why everyone says, "DONT BE YOUR OWN LAWYER", because while you can you simply can't do it in a non bias manner, and bias has no place in the court room and will be stricken immediately.
Now, he's not a GOOD lawyer, but he's trying with everything he has which is basically nothing lmao
This corrupt gold digger verbally abuses all of us who follow this shameful trial, the goose is ashamed, JD is one hundred percent innocent, STOP VIOLENCE AGAINST WOMEN, WEAKERS AND MEN !!!
You know you have a good judge when there are very few videos about something the judge said or did that was goody, out of the norms, or otherwise wrong. The best refereed cases take place here when you really don’t notice the judge.
Great job so far judge!
Lawyer: "not gonna waste court's time"
Also him: wastes court's time for 3 minutes
Her lawyers knows she can't stand and testify her allegations, so their best choice is the motion for strike or dismiss the case. They were overwhelmed by all the testimonies which truth came out. Really difficult for her Lawyers because it's lies after lies after lies.
The case will go on, people wanne know the truth,and amber will liegh, we know her like that, she is scared
Actually, this is normal as halftime in a football game. You make this motion to preserve rights to appeal and/or new trial. Standard stuff. JD will make the same motion. Judge will deny both and the jury will decide. Nothing to see here.
I feel like if they actually had more on him, they'd have pulled it out by now.. But we shall see.
There is no way they could dismiss the case there is lack of evidence and to much evidence all at the same time. I can't believe they tried to strike the day before amber goes up to testify. They know she won't be able to handle it.
@@rbu2136 JD wasnt gonna try to dismiss his own case. Unless i misunderstood you.
The fact that the legal team is asking for dismissal of evidence just because they can’t do their jobs is appalling
It's a rubbish job to have to do
I'm sure they're a decent lawyer, but they have no way of defending Amber with all the evidence stacked against them
Bad take. It’s not they can’t do their job it’s the at they can’t lie on the job and to succeed in this case they would have to. Basically it’s an insanely hard case to win when your person is clearly guilty
@@A_itsar Much respect to the man because I couldn’t get in the stand and lie to try and defend her but in all honesty I think he is buying time and theatrics because he knows he can’t win. This is more of an interesting case to watch the legality in the court of then have morals because everybody knows who is clearly in the wrong
They can do their jobs. They just don’t have enough evidence. Standing up there questioning all these people trying to make something out of it and accuse someone of something when there’s a lot of evidence against it is extremely hard. They can’t just exactly say “yeah you win” they have to fight everything being thrown at them. They look like fools but it’s part of their job. They are just on the losing side.
Great judge. Cool, calm, educated and well spoken. 👏👏👏
A such nice judge!
While having no judicial knowledge nevertheless I was immensely enjoying watching this court process - mostly because of the professionalism, modesty and humanness of this wonderful judge, Penney Azcarate.
The fact that Rottenborn has the audacity to continue invoking “the court’s time” is laughable. This guy spent 95% of his time during examination in a spiral of trial and error, offering loaded and leading statements and asking witnesses to agree or disagree, then trying again when they disagreed. I have to imagine she is furious with her team.
Objection, asked and answered.
I'll sustain, next question
Objection. Lack of foundation
"did I read that right?"
He also spent hours going through 6000 text messages, NONE of which proved that Johnny actually physically abused her as she claims.. This man is a joke. The only person wasting the court's time is Rotternborn.
However, she doesn't "look" furious. I've wondered why she doesn't fire them. Does she not see the lack of professionalism?
Doesn't it actually makes Amber look even more guilty that she tries bailing out without speaking up or presenting witnesses?
@ xxlCortez....100%.....If i knew I was not guilty..I would want to see this to the very end...plain and simple
it really is the end of the world it is since 2000 years when jesus first came now is just at its peak, for god 1 thousand years is a second and a second is 1 thousand years! the sign 666 will be keeping sunday as day of worship! you heared me right! the 4th comandement in the ten laws is keep my sabats ,that shall be a sign between me and you, it was refering to the jews, but the bible has 100 precent actuality and 100 precent do as god said no matter the times! the godgiven day of worship the sabath is saturday not sunday! sunday was the first day of the weak, vatican and the popes changed it , claiming they have is autorityn as the pope is god on earth, ruler of heavens earth and hell! now this is the bigest blasphemy somone claiming hes god! the pope already met with all worlds leaders, political-religious-and the 1precent wealthiest people on earth the illuminatis A class luciferian puppets! they met saying they discuss the climate change problem! what happened when jesus was crucified , saying that is better for one man to die than the whole people to be in disagreement, this is text book what will happen these days, youl hear this soon enough,! as inflation and economy, the famens the climate calamities , wile keep growing in intensity, whatever they do it by harpp projects or some ar really god let to happen, as its all predicted in Daniel prophet and apocalypse! the fear the teror the need for a solution will expend, ! all this problems will be blaimed on those who refuse to worship sunday , the sign of the pope, and everything will be blamed on this few people who refuse to bow in front of vatican (sunday)! text book what happened with jesus will happen to those who refuse popes autority who claims he is god, and all this wrath is beacouse this public enemys refuse to listen to him! but lucifer was defeated in heavens, was defeated at the cruce, and will be defeated in the end! for those who understand jesuses died for all sins , and all sinners, no man is reedemed by his deeds but by gods grace, and the holy spirit who strenghtens those who care only about what the bible says , and refuse to worship a man given day! evrything is mad for people to be blind to this: "ego" "music" "brandi love", its all made to sell you a false sense of utopia and comfort, meanwille you neglect this most precious times ever on earth! i cant reply back to anything as youtube deletes my replys most of the times, even if i respond from another acount, pray and have faith , jesus is right next to you, have faith!
In a court of law, maybe.
In the court of public opinion, absolutely.
I think so! If u were a victim then why not take your chance on the stand to speak up against your supposed abuser?? I would have and I was a victim twice! By my step father growing up and my ex husband! And I would never have done any of the shenanigans she pulled throughout her relationship or this trial. Recording him in the kitchen slamming cabinets, if I saw my abuser pissed off like that I would get away from him so I didn't become their next target! She was amused by it, she is no victim.
Amber is innocent
"She, and her witnesses, will put on even *MORE* evidence of the physical abuse . . . ". Then why wasn't that evidence produced? You would think that physical abuse being a key element in the case that the lawyers would already have that "evidence" on record.
That's like saying you've been planning to shoot someone but left your gun at home at the last minute.
This judge is so clear and concise. I love it!
This is just proof that Amber is looking for a way to back out of this without having to testify. Not doing herself a favor 😅
And lying under oath
@@divineordergovernsmylife808 JAIL TIME. 😁🔥🔥🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲🧂🧂🧂🧂🧂🧂🧂
She’s terrified to get up there & face Johnny head on & lie
She prolly will plead the 5th. If it's allowed in this case.
A have a question, im from europe and following the case, but i don't know a lot of the law in the us.
But what is this motion? And what is the goal of this motion?
They're afraid that once she's on the stand, she'll make herself look awful with extra lies. People will see that how she's so sick in doing these kind of things.
it really is the end of the world it is since 2000 years when jesus first came now is just at its peak, for god 1 thousand years is a second and a second is 1 thousand years! the sign 666 will be keeping sunday as day of worship! you heared me right! the 4th comandement in the ten laws is keep my sabats ,that shall be a sign between me and you, it was refering to the jews, but the bible has 100 precent actuality and 100 precent do as god said no matter the times! the godgiven day of worship the sabath is saturday not sunday! sunday was the first day of the weak, vatican and the popes changed it , claiming they have is autorityn as the pope is god on earth, ruler of heavens earth and hell! now this is the bigest blasphemy somone claiming hes god! the pope already met with all worlds leaders, political-religious-and the 1precent wealthiest people on earth the illuminatis A class luciferian puppets! they met saying they discuss the climate change problem! what happened when jesus was crucified , saying that is better for one man to die than the whole people to be in disagreement, this is text book what will happen these days, youl hear this soon enough,! as inflation and economy, the famens the climate calamities , wile keep growing in intensity, whatever they do it by harpp projects or some ar really god let to happen, as its all predicted in Daniel prophet and apocalypse! the fear the teror the need for a solution will expend, ! all this problems will be blaimed on those who refuse to worship sunday , the sign of the pope, and everything will be blamed on this few people who refuse to bow in front of vatican (sunday)! text book what happened with jesus will happen to those who refuse popes autority who claims he is god, and all this wrath is beacouse this public enemys refuse to listen to him! but lucifer was defeated in heavens, was defeated at the cruce, and will be defeated in the end! for those who understand jesuses died for all sins , and all sinners, no man is reedemed by his deeds but by gods grace, and the holy spirit who strenghtens those who care only about what the bible says , and refuse to worship a man given day! evrything is mad for people to be blind to this: "ego" "music" "brandi love", its all made to sell you a false sense of utopia and comfort, meanwille you neglect this most precious times ever on earth! i cant reply back to anything as youtube deletes my replys most of the times, even if i respond from another acount, pray and have faith , jesus is right next to you, have faith!
I can't wait to see her on the stand 😂. Liars and cheaters always get found out in the end. Go JD ✊️✊️
@@mrhman when will she stand? I canf wait for the shitshow to go down 😂
She's innocent
@@walkingtree2486 you're living in a lie if you think she's innocent especially considering the fact she already has been abusive in the past while Depp hasn't.
"Am not going to waste the court time with that"
Yet you waste 5 minutes of court time finding a document
the rectitude of this judge is absolutely exemplary!! thank God for a judge who knows the stuff, responsive and plays fair.
Victims of abuse should always be listened to and helped. People who falsify and lie to pretend to be victims of abuse to intentionally spite and destroy anyone else's livelihood should be held accountable.
Objection, lack of foundation
On Point 👌🏼👍🏼🙏
Not to mention put in doubt the testimony of people who’ve actually been abused
Exactly.
Unfortunately, the bar is set to such a high standard that you basically need a woman to say I did lie to have any chance of prosecution in a criminal case. The courts in the uk favour women so much assuming that why would a woman lie?
"Tell the world, Johnny, tell them, 'Johnny Depp, I, a man, I'm a victim too of domestic violence'. And see how many people believe or side with you"
talk about words coming back to haunt you…
she is a horrendous human being. hell, i am not even sure she is human.
And that's how she proved her head is filled with only useless poop!!!!
We side with you Johnny! The majority does!
@Parmesan Cheese Addict and kudos to the people in his life that took those pictures and encouraged him to document everything. His bodyguards are amazing in all this
And guess what. People believed in him !!
She looks the lawyer and smiled like yeah yeah.... because you better do you're work
Thank you Judge Penny for applying the law thoughtfully and carefully.
Let's just take a moment to appreciate the judge's patience regarding this case...
Oh she loves it. And her pay checks. Rofl. Silly sheeples.
Wdym it's her job🤷
its ...her...job....🤡
Why does this stupid comment have so many likes?
If you are getting paid in high amounts to watch live comedy show, how is that a bad thing?
Didn’t she admit on tape to hitting Johnny? I’m surprised that he could say she isn’t the abuser with a straight face.
But, but.. you're missing the point... she said she didn't "punch" him, she was only "hitting" him... 🤣
@@Mr_Weather860 It's a valid distinction if hitting him involves her boobs. Sadly, she only has A-cups so she was certainly punching him.
That’s what narcissist do though they provoke you to the point of hitting them and then play the victim
Bingo.
@@victoriaarcturus203 You sound like an abuser. "She was asking for it."
Judge knew what she was doing.
Her lawyer literally said nothing the whole video just used big words to distract the judge😂
Objection hearsay
@@livyett9251 leave jesus out of it
U could even say he wasted the courts time
Yea and it didn’t work 🤣🤣 they are only fooling themselves.
It honestly made no sense.
“We have evidence proving she wasn’t the abuser”. Then shouldn’t you want to show such evidence to defend amber?
Exactly, some tactics they got there.
Ikr
Exactly she got 100 million reasons to keep case going so idk someone or anyone who don't want 100 million
Well, yeah, given they said they would be offering up their own witnesses next.
@@calastyphon2510 I mean, they already back paddled from Johnny having "physically" abused her to just "verbal" abuse. They themself have already admitted that amber lied. That alone is enough for most people to not give two cents about amber heard. If she is the one abusing physically and verbally, which is proven, then anything Johnny might say is "defending himself" and reactionary and not "verbal abuse" as they try to prove.
There is a big difference whether johnny calls her names after she starts slapping and cursing him, or HE is the one constantly starting verbal fights. Which he obviously isn't, just to clarify.
She said more in ten seconds than the lawyer did in 3 minutes.
Cliff Notes:
*Lawyer:* Nuh-uh!
*Judge:* Yes-huh!
Breaks for lunch...
“I would like to have this case dismissed.” “On what grounds?” “We are losing and look like idiots.” “Request denied.”
injection, hearsay
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Thank you for the translation
"On what grounds?" "We are clearly winning but we don't want to waste your time with that."
Exactly Right! I would too if I was them! Haha! They need to switch teams! Seriously!!!
Her attorneys are so into “the courts time” but never have evidence fully ready, are always flipping through papers while asking questions, reasking the same questions over and over again and even after the witness says that is incorrect they keep going with the same line of questioning. They are a laughing stock at this point, they do not look good and it makes sense the judge dismissed their motion to strike.
And telling “objection heresay” every 2 seconds
Or objecting to everything and anything… even when there’s no grounds to object. Objecting so much that they’re even objecting their own questions! Lol. There idiots.
And the Judge let Hurds Team do it. She never stopped them once. To me she is Biased. MO.
@@micheletorimaru9348 You know that the Judge can't stop it unless Depp's team objects to the questioning, right?
Ikr so hypocritical and kinda same like Amber accusing others of doing the very thing they did/do. I can't stand that kind of people.
Me compadezco de los abogados de la mentirosa esta, la gente se ríe de ellos, pero su trabajo es más duro que el de los abogados de Johnny, por el dice la verdad y ella no para de mentir, por eso querían desestimar el juicio porque sabían que si ella declaraba lo tenían todo perdido.
Also why do her lawyers stumble over their words so much? She probably should have hired an actual legal team
This is brilliant, she knows she’s caught for falsifying domestic abuse and has no way to dodge what’s coming. Hope she gets a prison sentence. 👏
sorry to break it to you but it's a defamation case, which is a whole lot less "dangerous" than crime investigation. Also she is a woman, so getting her to prison is several times more difficult.
She won't get a prison sentence, this is a civil suit. If she loses, she can only pay damages (up to 50 million, as that is the amount Depp has sued for). Defamation is not a criminal violation in the US, so prison time can't be the punishment for losing this case.
this is a civil case...
@@shivampatil6897 she has counter sued for 100 million
Amen 🙏
Being a victim of DV myself, I am disgusted by this woman. She does not serve us in any way. The contrary is the case: The more she does, the more people tend to dismiss actual DV reports as "some fake story".
Yeah it's just disgusting how people lie about such horrible things.. Making it so much harder for actual victims to find justice. The selfishness and greed in some people is just ridiculous.
please excuse my ignorance, what is DV?
@@maxownzor2thelawnmower776
It’s DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
@@jannatulsara8986 no it’s domestic violence
@@xiaohuli96 I mean Amber isn't mentally sane to be fair, she lives in her own world of delusions and doesnt give any fucks about people in general, a person like that needs to be isolated from world, especially since she's making a whole show in front of the entire world making, as you said, things even worse for people with actual problems and struggling cause of domestic violence.
They really need to get this lunatic off the public and not let her be a celebrity of any sorts.
Johnny made a mistake, once, and after all this, i doubt he'll ever make it again.
love that the judge doesn't care what both parties are trying to prove. she's there to apply the law.
i think her lawyers did just great . imagine having to defend a vile narcissist and the stress of dealing with her everyday .
Lawyer: “I’m not gonna waste the courts time”
Also Lawyer: *tries to dismiss the trial after ALLLL the evidence against her, that Depp and his team has shown*
@LaEdibleChicken true, and to OP's point, a waste of time
Repent to Jesus Christ
““Honor your father and mother”-which is the first commandment with a promise- “so that it may go well with you and that you may enjoy long life on the earth.””
Ephesians 6:2-3 NIV
M
@@getonthecrossanddontlookba5004 🤮
@@liandre9035 so childish, good job! 👍 (ps. I'm talking about you)
@@bluewolf2708 so you support cultists who rape children?
Her lawyer just committed career suicide. He just put on display how TERRIBLE a lawyer he is.
Hardly.
It says nothing of the lawyer, it speaks of the sheer undefendability of Amber.
@@idiotbuster8662 you’re right, he does have a hard job defending the indefensible but that doesn’t take away from how much he sucks 🤣
You can't make a good case out of thin air. Amber has nothing, so the lawyers are trying desperately to make a good job somehow. Not really succeeding.
He just had a really bad argument as to the motion to strike. We all know she was going to the stand no matter what he was about to say
Tbh, given how ferociously and, at times, unprofessionally they have argued this case - there will be plenty of guilty people lining up to retain them.
How can you win a case when all you do is quote newspaper articles?? I have a theory, do your damn job!!
The judge knew her ruling WAAAYYY before both lawyers presented their arguments 😅. She read thru her ruling IMMEDIATELY and before Rottenborn could even breath seconds after his last words to her 🤣.
Johnny lost 40M because of her allegations of abuse, but she still has a job after actual EVIDENCE of her abusing him.
This is disgusting and repulsive.
Yes !! One good thing is that her career is now toast. Hallmark and Lifetime wouldn't even hire her at this point.
Plz people...boycott her films. If there are any. I read producer? would not cave to the millions who signed a petition. Yeah. If that was about getting Johnny dismissed from a film. He'd be out. It's b.s double standard..
the ME movement will get everyman UN-truth or N0T ..... theses lying hos are NO g00d...- the fastest way to take a man dn.- say me movent
@@jhanes3791 Don't forget Mc Donalds
He lost $100 million to be clear