Is a Cartier Tank Worth It? Luxury French Dress Watch Review

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 авг 2024

Комментарии • 180

  • @sholemepstein
    @sholemepstein Год назад +141

    The Cartier Tank Must is part of my collection and gives me much pleasure. This piece is extremely versatile, whether you are attending a formal dinner or an afternoon with the family the Tank is always appropriate. In my view it is well worth the price.

    • @claytonberg721
      @claytonberg721 Год назад +6

      I like the new Must extra large. In house movement, great dial, and for a luxury watch carrying a name like Cartier pretty affordable pricetag.

    • @briankenny6883
      @briankenny6883 Год назад

      @@claytonberg721 Right on!

  • @Tom-zn9cp
    @Tom-zn9cp Год назад +73

    I've had a must de Cartier for 40 years. Because of its age mine has a mechanical movement. The iconic tank is a wonderful timepiece and pairs with just about anything, anywhere, any time. Mine is especially important to me since it was a gift from my mother, a woman with not a lot of money but impeccable taste.

    • @jonathanl2748
      @jonathanl2748 Год назад +1

      I wish the new Must Tanks were not quartz. To get mechanical and a beautiful dial, one has to go to the too big Must XL.

  • @regsantotomas
    @regsantotomas Год назад +59

    In the cascade of sport watches, Cartier and models like the Tank offer a refreshing elegant and classic option that is more versatile than many would expect especially if you change the strap.

  • @dcarbs2979
    @dcarbs2979 Год назад +30

    I'm looking into my first Cartier, and the Tank was an appealing entry level. Much more elegant than Rolex.

  • @ailestriker9888
    @ailestriker9888 Год назад +18

    It's THE definitive dress watch for it's price point. Don't be afraid to buy the quartz or solar models if you're tempted. If this is your dress piece, then it might stay in your watch box most of the time while you wear your other pieces

  • @Doctorfilth42069
    @Doctorfilth42069 Год назад +11

    My grail watch is a Cartier Tank Louis in yellow gold with a guilloche dial. Elegant, understated and timeless

  • @GeorgeChar95
    @GeorgeChar95 Год назад +36

    I've been expecting this for quite some time. In my honest opinion, the classic Cartier Tank Louis is the epitome of timeless elegance.

  • @RobbMoreiraVO
    @RobbMoreiraVO Год назад +23

    I'm definitely a fan of the look of a Cartier Tank, but I would much prefer a Jaeger Le Coultre Reverso. THOUGH, if I were to get a Tank, the Must would be the one. Great video and awesome breakdown!

  • @Quanic2000
    @Quanic2000 Год назад +65

    I'm not a watch expert; but the Cartier Tank is one of the most iconic and most recognizable designs ever, in my opinion.
    Truly classic and elegant.

    • @Quanic2000
      @Quanic2000 Год назад

      @A Father To The Fatherless Muhammad Ali didn't think the Tank was "a little woman's watch".

    • @Quanic2000
      @Quanic2000 Год назад

      @@AFatherToTheFatherless so uncivilized.

    • @Quanic2000
      @Quanic2000 Год назад

      @@AFatherToTheFatherless you feel attacked? 😂

    • @Quanic2000
      @Quanic2000 Год назад

      @A Father To The Fatherless you think you're doing something, aren't you? 😂

    • @Crispy99999
      @Crispy99999 Год назад

      Agreed

  • @BollocksThreeofThem
    @BollocksThreeofThem Год назад +8

    The new Tank Must has become my daily wear. It goes with everything and with the quick change strap options, you can mix and match the look for any outfit. A timeless classic indeed.

  • @vannaeldwijk7075
    @vannaeldwijk7075 Год назад +10

    I own three, the first was a Must in silver bought with the Christmas bonus of my first real job. Still impeccable today, with its slightly domed glass so characteristic of vintage Must❤

    • @clxma
      @clxma Год назад

      lucky you! I love the tank design as well as the santos design but i'll get a tank first.

  • @josephknecht4272
    @josephknecht4272 Год назад +12

    Best brief history of the brand that I have seen on RUclips. Great work, GG!

  • @jessjameson285
    @jessjameson285 Год назад +5

    I saw an “Art Deco” inspired watch with a square face a few months ago at Walmart’s jewelry counter. I fell in love with that design. (I didn't buy it, as that particular watch looked very cheap.) I thought square-faced watches were a rare thing. Thank you for giving me something to save up for!
    Jess
    P.S. I'm a 21-year-old girl and I love your videos! I've learned a lot about belts, wallets, watches, etc. from you guys.
    Thank you so much!

  • @didamnesia3575
    @didamnesia3575 Год назад +15

    I have Cartier tastes but a Seiko budget. I do accept donations of Cartier watches however 😆 🤣

    • @gentlemansgazette
      @gentlemansgazette  Год назад +4

      🤣 We get you!

    • @didamnesia3575
      @didamnesia3575 Год назад +1

      @@gentlemansgazette I even accept seiko donations. Lol.
      To me the appreciation of fine goods is more important than the desire to own them. I'd rather have 10 pairs of allen edmonds instead of one pair of crocodile shoes

    • @anonanon7497
      @anonanon7497 Год назад +1

      Fairly sure Seiko do a tank equivalent.

    • @didamnesia3575
      @didamnesia3575 Год назад

      @@anonanon7497 yep they do

  • @alexp3752
    @alexp3752 Год назад +2

    Great video and highly informative. As a watch enthusiast for over 50 years, I agree, the Cartier Tank is an iconic timepiece and it is one of the rare models that can be worn almost everywhere, whether it be formal, informal, sport or simply daily all around wear. Fantastic choice! My favorite watch is a Piaget Protocole, which is very similar to the Cartier Tank, thin, simple, plain, gold, Roman numerals with a black leather strap. I've worn the same watch for 35 years. However, the secret to the watch's longevity is the manner an owner takes care of his/her watch. As a mechanical person, I keep my watch in a small leather pouch in my bag, when it is not on my wrist. That way I can work on cars, get rough, etc. without worrying if the watch can be damaged.
    Just a suggestion for any fine watch owner who wants to take care of his timepiece so it will last a lifetime.

  • @SkywhiteChannel
    @SkywhiteChannel Год назад +6

    I own 4 Cartier watches, and while I don’t agree with your conclusion that buying a new Tank Louis is a bad decision, your video is surprisingly in depth and better with the detail of the Cartier history than almost any other RUclips video. All talk about the influence of the tank from ww1 or the Santos story but you went deeper, well done!

    • @gentlemansgazette
      @gentlemansgazette  Год назад +1

      Thank you! Glad to hear you enjoyed the video and hey - it's okay that we all have different opinions 🙂

    • @abdouelshazly5495
      @abdouelshazly5495 Год назад

      Hi

  • @nickgee7291
    @nickgee7291 Год назад +2

    its been my dream watch since I was 16. My wife got it for me as a wedding gift last year! Its the only watch I wanna wear!

  • @isabellareid9609
    @isabellareid9609 Год назад +13

    I love this watch so much. So classic and timeless. ♥ (also the fact Cartier are sparkly and do cat based jewellery are a win for me!) 🐈

    • @gentlemansgazette
      @gentlemansgazette  Год назад +1

      Cartier is pretty puuurrrfect when it comes to jewelry, too! 😺

  • @TheTerryE
    @TheTerryE Год назад +7

    The answer is YES. Don't need an entire video to answer that question!

  • @danielvalentino9776
    @danielvalentino9776 Год назад +2

    I purchased my Tank XL auto last september - $3750 new - well worth it, goes with everything, finishing is fabulous.

  • @tanachip
    @tanachip Год назад +3

    Bought mine Tank Louis in rose gold new, and I think it’s absolutely worth it. I think it just depends on how you value things. I like watches more than clothing, so I spend more on watches and less on clothing.

  • @randolph1917
    @randolph1917 Год назад +4

    It's low profile, sleek, and elegant. I like it

  • @Crispy99999
    @Crispy99999 Год назад +3

    It is an icon that transcends the watch world; it crosses over as a general dressing style icon. It is emblematic, ingrained in the mind of many people; it is immortal. As for buying it new…well, the second-hand market only exists because people originally bought them new; someone has to make the investment. Since the case is polished, even slight scratches on a gold version show very easily. Buying retail is, therefore, definitely worth it in my view.

  • @bigcat618
    @bigcat618 Год назад +4

    I bought a Mus de Cartier in the 80s for $700. The alligator band broke after about a month and I replaced it with a leather band.
    What a chick magnet! Women look at your watch, my friends. It's a great investment.
    I have a fond memory of the salesman at CD Peacock in Chicago where I bought it. I tried it on and said, "I'll take it." To which he replied, "Let me get you a fresh one."

    • @Salmahandnafisah
      @Salmahandnafisah Год назад

      Can you share the website you bought it from ?

    • @bigcat618
      @bigcat618 Год назад

      @@Salmahandnafisah I bought it at CD Peacock in Chicago about 40 years ago. I have no idea what they retail for today.

    • @anonanon7497
      @anonanon7497 Год назад

      Alligator is a type of leather. I presume you replaced it with a calf leather?

  • @Iamsamchampagne
    @Iamsamchampagne Год назад +2

    Tip: a navy blue alligator strap to match the cabochon and the hands really makes it look incredible!

  • @davidhalldurham
    @davidhalldurham Год назад +4

    That jacket looks GREAT on Nathan! Bravo, dude.

  • @SuperGwah
    @SuperGwah Год назад +1

    The Cartier Tank is my favourite watch. Elegant, classic, and timeless. It is the only serious watch I’ve ever had. I’m saving up to buy a new one after my last one was stolen in a break-in.

  • @janerkenbrack3373
    @janerkenbrack3373 Год назад +4

    In modern practice hand-winding is really nice. It is easy enough to change watches from day to day according to outfits, and wind whatever watch you want to wear. It will run until the next day, when you'll probably be winding a different one. But unless you're buying quartz watches, automatics will run down and need to be reset anyway, unless you wear the same watch every day.

    • @gentlemansgazette
      @gentlemansgazette  Год назад +2

      Great way to think about manual wind watches - thanks for sharing, Jan!

    • @anonanon7497
      @anonanon7497 Год назад

      You don't want to be letting your watches run out, as the oils in the mechanisms start to seize up over time.

  • @jetsons101
    @jetsons101 Год назад +1

    My mom had a Cartier Lincoln Continental in the early 80's. It really was a nice riding car, wish it was still in the family. Never knew the name Cartier had such a long and interesting history...

  • @JoleneLin78
    @JoleneLin78 11 месяцев назад

    I am not a gentleman but have just gotten my Cartier Tank Must extra-large with black leather strap today! Such clean lines and the automatic movement, date, ease of wearing and how lightweight the watch was really got me! Cannot wait to wear it everyday. 😄⌚️

  • @phantom-nn7yv
    @phantom-nn7yv 10 месяцев назад +1

    My first “real” watch is a Cartier Tank Solo XL. I don’t have a tone of money for watches, but my watch was well worth the investment,

  • @PhenomenalBomb
    @PhenomenalBomb Год назад +3

    On my way to France as we speak so this is awesome to watch

  • @landryblake7846
    @landryblake7846 Год назад +6

    I was just thinking of purchasing a Cartier, this video is super helpful!

    • @gentlemansgazette
      @gentlemansgazette  Год назад +1

      Glad to be of service! Which Cartier is on your list?

    • @landryblake7846
      @landryblake7846 Год назад +1

      @@gentlemansgazette Right Now I believe a large Tank Americaine with a silver case and a black/blue leather band is right for me. I'm trying to expand my classic Men's wear collection, so I've been going on a GG marathon to get lots of inspiration.

  • @lisag.6599
    @lisag.6599 Год назад +4

    The Americaine is my favorite - the slim, long shape. :)

  • @marvyeap
    @marvyeap Год назад +2

    Wow…I just noticed that (7:23) there is a variant where the Cartier word is at the X instead of the VII….

  • @tempestandacomputer6951
    @tempestandacomputer6951 Год назад +4

    I believe this kind of video has room for an alternatives section. Seiko Tanks are competitive options under $200 while providing quality and reliability.

    • @Marroca1n
      @Marroca1n Год назад +1

      longines dolce vita

    • @timothygreeley9673
      @timothygreeley9673 Год назад

      I have one and it looks great. You can definitely tell it isnt a cartier and as nice but the styling Is great

    • @gentlemansgazette
      @gentlemansgazette  Год назад +1

      We've got you covered in this video! www.gentlemansgazette.com/luxury-watch-alternatives/?

  • @leosaura1993
    @leosaura1993 Год назад

    I own a classic Cartier Tank Louis model 1990 beautiful never regret buying it had it restored and clean and works fine beautiful piece of work.

  • @mattshaffer5935
    @mattshaffer5935 Год назад +2

    Agree the Tank Must in XL is🔥

  • @justingalore123
    @justingalore123 Год назад +1

    I agree with your conclusions.. I have a large tank must in steel I got from cartier direct (total bargain - the best watch I own) and a used gold tank Louis which was 50% less than retail… Anyone considering either watch should just go for it!

  • @rogernobbs6559
    @rogernobbs6559 Год назад +1

    Just a small footnote on, ironically, chronology: Edward VII died in 1910, so some time before Cartier started doing their most iconic pieces as discussed here. The insertion of his quote suggested he was around in the 1920s, which he definitely was not. Otherwise a really good video about a distinguished brand.

  • @adamcohen2632
    @adamcohen2632 Год назад +2

    Yes, its worth it. Particularly because with vintage models and even quartz alternatives with new ones, their are so many price points to choose from. Unlike other century old icons of the gentleman's world, like Burberry trench coats, everything Brooks Brothers and so many other things, quality has not suffered over the years. Contrary to modern popular sensibilities, it goes with virtually everything and is appropriate anywhere other than for rugged outdoors uses or a trip to the gym.

  • @anonanon7497
    @anonanon7497 Год назад +1

    Such a classy watch. Generally, i prefer a proper movement and the JLC Reverso is a much more elaborate mechanism but you just can't beat the class and aesthetic of the Cartier Tank collection. In this case, this is one of the few (if not only) quartz movement I'd pay luxury prices for.

    • @bax4562
      @bax4562 Год назад

      The 100th anniversary edition of the Cartier Tank has a JLC Reverso movement inside.

  • @cyankirkpatrick5194
    @cyankirkpatrick5194 Год назад +1

    Did you know that Cartier has a buy back program. Also Cartier redesign the infamous Hope diamond into a necklace we know now from a bandeau Mrs Walsh wasn't really interested in the diamond at first but being the salesman that he was suggested that she take it for a weekend try and she was hooked, and the rest is history.

  • @JohnnyTurnerMusic
    @JohnnyTurnerMusic Год назад +1

    If you like these starting buying the Vintage Must De Tanks now while they're still affordable. The Must De Tank has just re-released at £3500 so vintage pieces are about to rocket.

  • @Visqo1
    @Visqo1 Год назад +1

    The tank must XL is my fave from the line

  • @Jairseph
    @Jairseph Год назад +4

    do a video about Audemars Piguet or Patek next!

  • @kagezen
    @kagezen 3 месяца назад

    Cartier Tank Solar Must is the best value for money in my opinion. Lovely video as always!

  • @piotrek3580
    @piotrek3580 8 месяцев назад

    If I have to choose just 1 watch collection, it would be Cartier Tank or JLC Reverso The simplicity, classy look of these square masterpieces are beautifull. You can wear them with casual dress, polo, or suit. Strap color can literally change watch. They are small, dont need toprove anything.

  • @LMNRocks101
    @LMNRocks101 Год назад +1

    Please do a 'Get dressed with me WHITE TIE' video. it would be very beneficial to beginners to understand where everything should be placed and latched onto. it is also hard to find videos and info on how to dress in White Tie. Thank you!!

    • @gentlemansgazette
      @gentlemansgazette  Год назад

      We love putting on our White Tie ensembles! Perhaps this will help you out for now? www.gentlemansgazette.com/white-tie-do-dont-dress-code-met-ball/?

  • @blemonn
    @blemonn Год назад +1

    I believe that the strap on the newest iteration Cartier Must is a “Vegan Leather,” as opposed to genuine leather.

  • @Knightwingofbludhaven
    @Knightwingofbludhaven Год назад +2

    I been looking at these for weeks now

  • @LlyleHunter
    @LlyleHunter Год назад +1

    I prefer the Cartier Santos Tank but yes they are definitely worth it. There’s nothing like a good Swiss watch

  • @LargeEnsemble
    @LargeEnsemble Год назад

    I think the host has a point preferring the Tank Solo/Must.
    As of January 2023, you can for example get a Must with an automatic movement for €4‘500 in my native Germany and you get a lot for the money spent.
    I would prefer a Louis Cartier with a handwound movement, even if it means to spend €13‘100 for the large handwound Modell. Winding a watch is a great experience, the LC is very thin and easily fits under a sleeve.

  • @mikelob6707
    @mikelob6707 Год назад

    Just bought a vintage blue faced tank, can't wait to wear with a nice suit granted I don't plan to take it off once I get it

  • @femiakinyemi7168
    @femiakinyemi7168 Год назад +1

    Cartier tank are iconic watches thanks for info

  • @teenoso4069
    @teenoso4069 Год назад +1

    Depends on your style and the feeling it gives you

  • @linkinparkfan239
    @linkinparkfan239 Год назад +2

    Hey Nathan, have you guys ever noticed that a lot of watches that have Roman numerals have the Roman 4 as “IIII” rather than “IV” is this a sign of bad attention to detail or is there a particular reason for this.

    • @ebdaniels8774
      @ebdaniels8774 Год назад +5

      While "IV" is technically the more correct figure, most watches and clocks, including historical examples, feature "IIII" instead of "IV." Many stories and explanations have popped up as to why, but I think that most likely explanation is simple aesthetics. The "IIII" needs to "balance" the "VIII" that is opposite it on the radial face, and "IIII" has a more pleasing, comparable bulk than "IV" does.
      So, if anything, one could argue that is shows good attention to detail (if not to proper Roman numerology!)

  • @luisramonrivera-lopez6187
    @luisramonrivera-lopez6187 4 месяца назад

    El Must que poseo lo compré en la tienda de París en el año 2000, tiene números arábigos y máquina de cuarzo. Buenas presentaciones en su página, gracias.

  • @Leby69
    @Leby69 Год назад +2

    Short answer, yes, of course it is. I mean come on

  • @zaco-km3su
    @zaco-km3su Год назад

    The Cartier Tank is a classic. That being said you don't wear a watch with black tie or white tie or at an event.

  • @sukanjaruyothin5125
    @sukanjaruyothin5125 Год назад

    Thank you for the video. Loved it. With Tank Must, can I simply say, it’s Tank louis without precious metal?

  • @johnrobinson2228
    @johnrobinson2228 5 месяцев назад

    Really enjoyed the history here thanks 😊

  • @MisterKnightly
    @MisterKnightly Год назад +3

    Nothing better than a tank.

  • @jamesmoore391
    @jamesmoore391 Год назад +1

    Yes

  • @serena_davis
    @serena_davis Год назад

    New here. Thanks for your video! What's a good website to buy pre-owned Cartier watches?

  • @dayoowoyemi9576
    @dayoowoyemi9576 Год назад +1

    What was the site in that "is it worth it" segment?

  • @paulcornwell5581
    @paulcornwell5581 Год назад

    Would the Tank Must Quartz large look silly on a 7.6 inch wrist?

  • @derlachendevagabund7942
    @derlachendevagabund7942 Год назад +2

    Of course it is

  • @specialforces101
    @specialforces101 Год назад

    Hardly more than advertising for Cartier. We need more detail on movements, faces, hands, date-marker and bracelet quality.

  • @lukasp6406
    @lukasp6406 Год назад

    Thanks a lot for this awesome Series!
    Could you maybe do a video in the „Is it worth it“ Series about the legendary Chateau Petrus Pomerol?
    Kind Regards and thanks again for your Videos!

  • @a-complished4406
    @a-complished4406 Год назад +1

    My dream watch.. one day.. who knows 😢

  • @electrobabe
    @electrobabe 10 месяцев назад

    Hi where do you shop for your vintage pieces?

  • @daniell2217
    @daniell2217 Год назад +4

    If you like watches as jewelry, there are few better than Cartier. If you like watches as watches (but still want that Tank look), I agree with the commenter below - go get a JLC Reverso.

    • @bax4562
      @bax4562 Год назад +1

      The 100th anniversary edition of the Tank Louis has a JLC Reverso movement inside.

    • @hectthorno584
      @hectthorno584 10 месяцев назад

      Except that for a gentleman looking for a true and elegant dress watch, the Reverso cannot be really an option. Like the Cartier Santos, the Reverso is a chic and fancy watch but nevertheless it is a sport watch.

  • @olioshop
    @olioshop 6 месяцев назад

    Dive into this comprehensive review of the luxury French dress watch, weighing its design, craftsmanship, heritage, and overall value

  • @truper232424
    @truper232424 Год назад +1

    Cartier is top. Period.

  • @Neftali_RR
    @Neftali_RR Год назад

    El canal en español necesita este video 👍🏻

  • @spade2you
    @spade2you 10 месяцев назад

    It's not a mainstay or grail watch for me. Something like Longines is more practical.

  • @cyankirkpatrick5194
    @cyankirkpatrick5194 Год назад

    Clark Gable is responsible for men wearing the wrist watch he wore one in a movie and then again is in history. I have a vintage lighter from Japan.

  • @roadtrekralph311
    @roadtrekralph311 Год назад +1

    Did you mention JFK wore this watch more often than any other he owned?

  • @alaamgdad9236
    @alaamgdad9236 Год назад

    برنامج راءع عن الساعات القديمة والجديدة والتعرف الداءم ما شاء الله

  • @isaackyaga2007
    @isaackyaga2007 Год назад

    Can you do a video about the Breton shirt?

  • @tf5331
    @tf5331 Год назад

    Sir, when will wallets be available in the store?

  • @noegarcia5246
    @noegarcia5246 Год назад

    My concern with the tank is that its a quartz movement. For 3000k, it seems they could have included a mechanical movement...even a basic one.

    • @spade2you
      @spade2you 10 месяцев назад

      Other companies offer that, although they tend to be XL in size compared to Cartier.

  • @cyankirkpatrick5194
    @cyankirkpatrick5194 Год назад

    Yes for a vintage one.

  • @Pensivelyexpensive
    @Pensivelyexpensive Год назад

    Please keep posting good sir!

  • @acalero2308
    @acalero2308 25 дней назад

    It is.

  • @nealfry2230
    @nealfry2230 Год назад +1

    " Cartier has Charisma "

  • @hellfire510
    @hellfire510 Год назад

    Can Gentleman's Gazette do a video on belted cardigans?

  • @attjy6458
    @attjy6458 Год назад

    Could you perhaps give a review on the vintage reproduction brand Simon James Cathcart?

  • @wongjefx980
    @wongjefx980 Год назад

    Is anything luxury worth it? If you are going to monetarily justify a luxury purchase, is it based on resale value? The Tank is such a classic, and for dress watch I’d be hard pressed to find something so stylish and iconic.

    • @anonanon7497
      @anonanon7497 Год назад

      I don't think luxury items need justifying, as such. People buy these items because they have the desire of owning something luxury and not because of any utilitarian reason.

  • @honestbrute9216
    @honestbrute9216 Год назад

    All I’ve ever wanted was the Roadster…

  • @menwithven2717
    @menwithven2717 14 дней назад

    Wait, where’s the OG guy?

  • @themoderndandy713
    @themoderndandy713 Год назад

    I have a perhaps controversial watch opinion. Watches should have two functions: to look good and accurately tell time. You can generally get that in the hundred dollar price range. Anything more is fluff. Similar to a Tom Ford suit, you're paying for all these expensive extra little details that really serve no obvious purpose and overpaying for said expensive details at that. However, if that's what makes you happy, then go for it. It's better to use excess money than hoard it.

    • @anonanon7497
      @anonanon7497 Год назад

      You're paying for the status of having a luxury item.

  • @yutthasakkomjornkijborworn5119
    @yutthasakkomjornkijborworn5119 Год назад +1

    Worth every pennys.

  • @Dranreb865
    @Dranreb865 Год назад

    Funny posting prices based on ebay. I doubt there's someone willing to pay 20k usd and up for a cartier watch.

  • @pedrojose9135
    @pedrojose9135 Год назад

    Today I learned mant of these were qwartz movement watches.

  • @jesperqvistberg5711
    @jesperqvistberg5711 Год назад

    why dont ya make a dresshirt video reviewing Swedish brand Stenströms ?

  • @trisov
    @trisov Год назад +3

    first time being so early! hii GG!!

  • @GrumpyYank26
    @GrumpyYank26 Год назад

    Very interesting. Thank you!
    Maybe use the word ‘iconic’ less often. It is overused everywhere and is losing its meaning

  • @Nile8765
    @Nile8765 5 месяцев назад

    Wait so having diamonds on a watch is girly?