I was at the Aftershock Festival where Band'Maid and The Warning met. It didn't really suprise me that they were fans of each other. Both are awesome bands!
Two words.....Battle Scar. This was a collaboration song between two of Canada's best bands in 1980. Max Webster & Rush. It was written by Max Webster (Kim Mitchel-music, Pye Dubois-lyrics [who co-wrote Tom Sawyer with Neil Peart]) and performed by all 7 musicians. 2 guitars, 2 bass, 2 drums & 1 keyboard. All musicians have such a unique playing style/sound that it's easy to pick out who is playing what. It was recorded live in the studio with all of them present, which is why it rocks so hard. I would prefer Band-Maid & The Warning do something similar, be all together if/when recording the song. Not have one record their part in a studio and have the other do it in another studio, then mix the two together. Ideas work better when your face to face. As far as writing the music is concerned, that's a tough one (I'm on the Kanami side only because of how she thinks outside the box musically). Lyrics will depend on which audience you are trying to reach. All English lyrics would reach a wider audience (especially for Band-Maid). And we all have to remember, this wouldn't be a competition, it would be a collaboration. Just my two sense. Thanks for listening.
ruclips.net/video/PMM6Bhwpy0M/видео.html Epic, thunderous, test your woofer with this one, Still get chills listening to it. This shows how two talented bands can make it work (as mentioned in the o.p.)
I trust Kanami's mastery of complexity through the way she works with a score like a classical composer. There is no reason whatsoever why they should not all play at once. How many violins, violas and cellos do you have in a chamber orchestra? The Warning know that Kanami's arrangement skills are next level, these are pros. Also obviously Pau is very well placed to do English lyrics. These are both friends and professionals. There will be no clashing egos, among the stans obviously but they're immune to that. The Warning work closely with a producer, but if the legendary Tony Visconti defers to Kanami's production skill he can step aside and maybe help with the final master where they always defer to an independent specialist. I think the fact they're women will smooth the process too. Bandmaid have been together for a decade and run like a well oiled machine, I expect The Warning are the same, this is a skillset too. There are so many great lineups with a lot of percussion. The original Santana for starters. Likewise both bands work with multiple voices in unison and harmony. This is all just technique. There again both drummers compose carefully and thus using a score and drum machine they can craft what they want. I'd like to see achi on the Timbales given her tom skills.
@@user-ix5yj9ip9v no I'm referring to a project where he helped just with the vocal mix because, on receiving Kanami's demo he said he couldn't improve on her mix.
I don't know why yall expect more than what is probably gonna happen. You go right to them doing an album together. They're probably only doing a concert on the same ticket. You'll probably see one or two on stage during each other's show but, I'll bet that's all that will happen.
Fair point there. Although I can't speak for all the commentors, myself I am mainly addressing this because I think it is the most interesting possible outcome, and not one that would even be that hard to imagine happening. Collaboration songs are a big thing these days and are great for the profile of both artists, so I would have to imagine the record companies would be very much behind something like that which would provide a more long term benefit from a meeting that is already going to happen. So I think it is absolutely worth considering, if not only for the pure interest of it, but also as it has to be an option they would be encouraged towards.
@@ApexRadius The Warning have several features in their contract that allow them creative freedom. IDK about BM's contract, but based on their music selection, I wouldn't be surprised if they also have creative freedom. Getting both recording companies to agree to a collab is a complex arrangement in a business sense, but I'm sure all that would be worked out well in advance. I also think they might compose a song together and record it as a live performance, creating a music video in the process. The Warning tour with a videographer/producer who is one of their team and it's easy enough to assemble a group of professionals for the camera work anywhere in the world. The equipment isn't different between Mexico and Japan, after all. The Warning's collab with Aslessia Cara on the reimagined Enter Sandman was accomplished, soup to nuts, in a week. So doing a song together with two bands, though more complex for writing all the parts, is something I'm sure both bands have the creative chops to accomplish in 12 days.
@@elgonwilliams7624 Of course, anything's possible. Live collaboration actually seems most likely to me. B-M has had multi-camera crews at four of their last five shows, so, whoever does the video production, it's easily covered. B-M seems to have total creative control with Pony Canyon. But, as you mentioned, there's always business that has to happen between labels/management teams. When people start talking about them being on each other's albums they're getting further into wild speculation (I get it, it's fun). It's simply more complicated to make that happen. Pau mentioned it took a long time and a lot of effort just to make this show happen. Could she be playing possum and they've been planning to spring something all along? Sure. But folks are assuming something big as if it's inevitable. They might be disappointed. We'll just have to see what they've been up to when the time comes. It'll be soon.
If they do perform a joint song, which I think is likely (though no guarantees it'll be a new song), I don't think it'd be too difficult to make the numbers work. Kanami has already written a lot of songs, including the entire Band-Maiko EP, that would need >>5 musicians to perform live without a click-track. Gacharic Spin and Wagakki Band have shown that two drummers can improve a song. The trickiest part would normally be the bass, but the two bands have such different approaches to the instrument that it would be natural for Ale to do the traditional bassist's role and set Misa completely free to add the colour that she often does anyway. If necessary, I'm sure Miku would be delighted to put down her guitar for a song and they could have a lot of to and fro with the vocals.
Well Paulina and The Warning have recorded over 50 originals all three sisters are classically trained on piano and can sing lead ! There’s no time to collaborate as the Keep me fed album will be release at the same time their in Japan!
I'm glad you've been listening to The Warning's music. You're right, they really know how to smash out an arena thumping track. I do still take issue with your issue, though. I feel the "bass and guitar playing the same riff at the same time" is only true on some tracks and I think the reason so many bands (especially 3-piece bands) do it, is it fills out the sound more and keeps things going when the guitarist switches riffing for soloing. Speaking of solos.... YES! YES!! YES!!! Give me many solos!!! One thing I think you missed though, is that Pau, like Miku does a LOT of vocals. Not just backing, but lead also. You have 4 vocalists in this collaboration. Giving Pau some vocals and not just drums would solve one potential problem.
Thank you! Yeah, I was thinking of your previous comments as I listened lol! I feel pretty safe still in my comments about the arrangements, but that is a loooooooong chat for Discord perhaps ;) As for solos, I wasn't aware you were such a solo man!!! You continue to surprise me! Also, yes, I saw the Pau comments coming up and you are totally right. I think though that I was thinking of that in a similar light to how Miku is a vocalist, and I would love to see her sing in the song, but given that we already have two lead vocalists at work, I would more see that as a pleasant addition rather than her core role in any collaboration. Keys keys keys ;) Thanks Loon!
You may get some push back for some of the stuff you say here, but I appreciate you having an opinion other than "everything is equally great", standing by it, and daring to say so. I think they should do two songs with Saiki/Miku on a Warning-written/performed song and The Warning on a Band-Maid-written/performed song.
As always you are right indeed, and I know, that you know me well enough, to know I'm already prepped for all those dislikes lol! But hey, I was always more the opinion columnist that the news journalist ;) ;) Actually, your idea for two songs would certainly be the ideal outcome, but I think we may not be that lucky. If we are though, I am happy to scrap my plan in order to get two songs instead! Thanks for the comment!!
Imagine a dual lead featuring Dani and Kaname. Imagine a dual bass with Misa and Ale. Imagine a dual duel lead versus bass! The possibilities are endless. Having 2 drummers on the same stage has been done more times than I can mention, and with the combined talent of Kaname and Pau, I don't see a problem.
I honestly don't even care if there's a common song or not. I just hope they'll have a good time with each other and some great moments. And maybe, share some of them with us 🙂 This concert is a dream line up for me, but unfortunately I'm not gonna make it to Japan this year. At least I'm seeing The Warning in 3 weeks live in Munich 🤘🏻🙂
Love that they're doing a gig together. Shows the respect and appreciation that each band has for the others' sound. It's the songwriting for me that sets these two bands apart from their peers; they can really bring out the feels for me.
I respect BandMaid, they seem to be great and down to earth persons. I dont really see competition between them, they really are very different bands, and fans that like each band loves them for a reason. In my case I cant connect with Band Maid, no reason in particular, even If I know they are very skilled and talented musicians. I just hope both bands find good chemistry there and have a great time along with the audience.
Thanks for the comment! I think I am perhaps viewing this from the other side of the aisle, in that I have a respect for the Warning which has never quite converted in to me really getting their music, still I can see how The Warning could bring something to a potential collaboration that would give me a chance to appreciate them in a whole new light... and if not, I'll just be glad to see the 8 ladies having fun :) ! Thanks for the comment though, always great to hear from both sides of the fandoms!!
Im not a fan of band maid’s music, despite trying to get into it a few times, but I can still recognize good musicianship, so I’m very curious about the result (if there’s ever one), since their styles of music couldn’t be more different from one another. I hope they do a video of them performing together.
I would love to see something that starts out. Acoustic and builds into a heavy harder song with a great warning hook. With Saiki Singing the emotional. Parts and danny singing the harsh harder section .Miku is excellent with harmonizing and backup vocals. As far as drumming goes I have no idea how that would work. Akane is Very technical , Pau Is very hard-hitting Rock style. Whatever they do together it's a dream come true
I’m excited for a potential song no matter how it turns out. I trust both outfits to produce something amazing. The fact that they are playing a show together is in itself extremely epic.
@@BakaBroadcast the new Endless Story live video is very moving. Having seen them twice now here in the states, I am always rooting for them. Btw, my band Paint and Copter is releasing a new video tomorrow called Another Dimension with Japanese bassist Ichinose, our third collaboration with her. There is a bit of a Band-Maid meets techno influence to the song. She came pretty close to being Lovebites new bassist. But Fami has done an awesome job. Thank you.
@@BakaBroadcastI think that the Warning will just open for BM and that will be it. They are in a new market and not well known there plus the majority there will be BM fans. But I could be wrong. Good video, very interesting. 👍
I dunno, I love the music of both band's, but as far as a recording with all members playing, they are so vastly different, do I just dunno, guess we'll all have to wait and see.
Good points! 7 ladies just feeding the Gorilla her drum power bananas would also be a good usage or manpower, but since I was reminded in many comments, as you said, that Pau is an accomplished singer, it does raise an interesting question about how she could step forwards that i totally agree with. However, whatever happens, I hope we all get to at least see the show on streaming and video afterwards! 🍌🥁
Gonna predict no musical collab, at least not for a long time. It will be The Warning on stage first, then Band-Maid. They might get together after for a song or two, but I think that will be as far as it goes. It will be interesting either way, but not earth shaking.
Yes, I'm leaning that way, too, although a song is certainly possible. B-M never explicitly stated that they were doing recording collaborations with anyone. To read that is to make an inference. And, remember, the bands are signed to two different labels. It's complicated. "Collaboration" can mean a whole host of things, like simply playing a show together. But, I understand that it's fun to speculate about what they might do. We'll have to wait and see.
Agree, and if they do play together on stage for a couple of songs, they will most likely play covers of some other band or artist that both groups are familiar with.
This is a concert/get to know each other event. What will happen is hoped, but unknown. I just love the female power vibe. Chill out and enjoy what comes.
The Allman Brothers made two drummers work.......for years! I feel there would need to be a huge coordination of time off for the bands to practice a song collaboration. More power to them if they can pull it off, which I don't doubt given their non-stop, can do, will do attitude/energy. They are ALL Troopers!
Nice example! I think that, a lot like other bands, one drummer was more in the percussion area whilst the other played the main kit, if I am correct. I actually really like this style of percussion when used, but I think that whichever band didn't have their drummer on the traditional kit may feel slighted. However, I do agree this would be the most fun way to approach it :)
I think if there is a collaboration it will less likely be a new song, but more likely just playing together on stage for a song or two, most likely covers of other bands/artists (like TW has done with Eruca Sativa in the past), with Pau perhaps out front singing and channeling her inner Jagger.
It seems possible you are right, I just hope this is part of what Band-Maid's announcement was discussing, as it seems like such a great opportunity, but I will take what we can get ;)
I clearly see you have put a lot of thought into this. Imagine the disappointment when all that happens is each band just plays their own set. End of story.
Did you ever consider that what Band-Maid meant by "collaborations" was simply just playing shows with other bands and not literally songwriting together? Their understanding and use of the word might be different than what we usually interpret it to mean; especially in the context of music. I think that's what might be happening here. It IS logical to see it that way, correct?
All 3 of the sisters Villarreal can play the piano. Pau is the main songwriter but each sister contributes. All 3 can sing but Ale shies away from lead. Pau and Dany both can front a band with 0 effort, with or without their instrument. I would like to see part Japanese, part Spanish and part English in the lyrics. That would be epic.
The two bands have been together for several days now. Whether they're collaborating or just hanging out doing touristy stuff, they've not said. It would be silly if they didn't (Witness Babymetal and Electric Callboy's recent collab!)
Your giddiness is contagious! The solution, of course, is a blues song. The chord structure is already worked out; there's nothing to decide except the key and the turn-around, write some couplets, and decide who takes the next solo (and in true blues fashion, no one knows until they look at each other). But neither band really does blues so ignore that. The Warning is a power trio where they fill up the room with simplicity and Band-Maid fills the room with density. It will be interesting to see what they do. No shade intended to anyone (like, in the history of music), Kanami Tōno is a rare bird when it comes to composition. Give her a couple of ideas and she'll figure it out. An aside. The video from the media area at Aftershock makes Ale look like a giant compared to everyone else! It may be the camera lens and angle, but still ... what a striking woman. Between her and MISA, they will have the best-looking bass section in the history of rock music; Paul McCartney, Jack Bruce, and John Paul Jones included. We'll leave Dusty Hill out of the discussion, LOL.
Thank you! Yes indeed as well, anyone who offers the possibility of a collaboration leading to something neither fanbase expected, is very much speaking my language lol! Louder rock music can somewhat limit the sonic space available, and as much as we all want to see them rock out for the energy, and the appropriateness of that to their established sounds, I would certainly be first in line if things took on a blues tinge. The Warning nailing a core, whilst Band-Maid paint colour between the notes, this would be an interesting listen for sure! Thanks for the lovely comment!
Those are two VERY DIFFERENT bands. The Warning is three, very talented, but rather ordinary sisters that write good music, plays and sing well and are very good at stage presence. They rock catchy and powerful songs. They are also very beautiful. Some of their songs is a bit more pop. Personally I listen to The Warning when I want straight rock with power. They are brilliant, one of the best thing that has happened for many years. BAND-MAID is a group of goofy girls that has made one of the best rock bands on the planet. They write very different songs. Complex and good. Not so much catchy and powerful. Rather just interesting and good rock, on the border of prog rock, mixed with some pop singing. They also play around on the scena and do guitar and bass battles and other stuff. They have long concerts with diverse things around, like Miku doing her crazy stuff with the audience, while the rest is chilling. They also have some killer instrumentals where they show their skills. Even though The Warning has more power, BAND-MAID has more chops. Now, if they like each other and the chemistry is right and they got the time, this might be magic. Both BAND-MAID and The Warning have shown that they are capable of writing killer songs in no time at all. It is Kanami that i the super composer in BAND-MAID, I think it might be Pau in The Warning, but I am not sure. Lyrics might be tough though 😁
You tried to make that comment seem fair. Some key words used gave it away. In my opinion BAND-MAID writes songs to show off their "chops". And again in my opinion is why their songs are very good.
@@scottlafleur4148 Yes, BAND-MAID has technical excellence as a goal. You can see that in the text to Domination. It says again and again that they work hard to get better and better. And yes, this is a part of their charm. I saw an interview made by Herman Lee from Dragonforce of Kanami and Miku. Kanami asked how fast the fastest Dragonforce song was, and Herman said 220 BPM. Then we shall aim for 225 said Kanami with a straight face. And ... I think that the totally wild song "Black Hole" has 225 BPM.
It seems,at some point, before June 12th, the commentary will denigrate to a classically primitive level. If true...what a shame. These eight great ladies should be treated as they treat us. With the utmost professionalism and respect. Whether I like the finished product or not is immaterial. They have brought so much joy to their fans that I can only take the high road concerning them...👍🏻🔥
Good point, and this is always a great concern. Obviously, I enter this conversation myself very much on one side of things, but I would feel pretty dissapointed if anyone purely hated on the collaboration for happening, or the other side for just being there. Of course no one has to like something just because their favourite band or fandom likes it, but anyone who starts to treat it like a tribal conflict clearly doesn't understand music. This is why in my graphic I took time to put both bands on the same team 😂👍 As you so well said, their is joy to be had here. Joy is what they want to spread, and joy is all anyone needs to take from it, discussion is a nice way to understand it, and anything else probably just isn't worth bothering with . Thanks!
Yes!! "Warning!" by The Warning and ...... do The Warning have a song about Maids for Band-Maid..... oh this is the most confusing sentence I have ever written 😂
The fact that they share the stage already seems extraordinary and wonderful to me. I hope this to be broadcast on streaming because I suspect on that day I´ll still be 22 hours from Tokyo... damn... Regarding the 8 fantastic musicians on stage at a time, I would like to remember here the collaboration between U2 and Green Day, The Saints are Coming. Everything is possible in rock music on stage. And... YES!, I expect at least a song.
I love your positive energy! I imagine it will go out on some streaming service as The Warning will have so many fans back home wanting to watch! I think 8 folks on a stage is not too many, but I certainly want them all to shine, and no one to just be left playing the same thing as someone else. Perhaps just the song arranger side of my brain pushing for that as it is my personal ideal in any collaboration. That being said, I'll just be happy to see whatever happens! Thanks as always for commenting :) !!
I don’t really know why people are unsure about it, i just can remember George Harrison’s gigs with a lot of legends on stage and the sound was incredible
Respectfully, I hope none of what you speculate happens. No need for Bandmaid to do any of that. It would be way cooler, less complicated logistically and also provide more prestige to BM if they were to bring Mike Einziger from Incubus as guest for a tune on the new record and even more exiciting if they get Mike on stage to play such song with them at their upcoming show together.
Since it was said, I've always had the feeling that the word collaboration has be miss interpreted and only means together for a show, like the one that has been announced. Mixing two complete bands musically does not make sense. I've seen similar in the past which sometimes ends in a messy chaos. So, I'm hoping that it only means sharing a show. So no recordings.
I come from a completely different backround, not really familiar with Bandmaid, perhaps the point is just to get new fans by appearing with a group whose music they admire. I know that The Warning have very diverse interests in the music they listen to and I would suppose that Bandmaid does as well.
In this case, Band-Maid is helping The Warning get a bump in Japan. TW is not well known there. And even B-M is more of a growing niche band but with a very dedicated fanbase. The show will almost certainly sell out. It's very possible that TW returns the favor in a market where they're very strong and B-M is not as well known.
As a fan of both bands, I'm excited to hear what they come up with. - I think it'll be good for both to appeal to one another's fans also. - As to what they produce, it could be anything. - I think a collaboration in writing would be the foundation. How they arrange it will be the most interesting aspect. There is a lot of talent there.... Maybe a Warning-ish song, with a Japanese verse, and all three vocalists sparring, back and forth, or just all three vocalists singing in harmony, then add in some little solos by each remaining member would be the final outcome.
Thanks for popping in a comment fella, and yeah I think you probably hit the nail on the head as to what I suspect a lot of people are perhaps expecting. I certainly would be interested to see a lot of vocal work though yeah. If you have Miku, Saiki, Pau and Dany all singing, that would be incredibly fun! 🤘😊
@@BakaBroadcastIn a way, that'd possibly be the clincher, to have two strong leads and two very good backing singers is what is going to sell it the most. To mix English, Japanese and maybe Spanish in the lyrics would be a challenge, however, not insurmountable, since I feel that their long experience ( both bands are around 10-years old) will help a lot in the process. Whatever happens I think both acts will be much enriched by working the other, whatever the outcome. - and let's not forget that bands have a team of people on the other side of the glass to bounce ideas off. It won't be just 8 ladies in a studio, a bunch of microphones and a blank notebook each.
@@triquivijate I agree, for my preferences at least. If that showed through in the recording as well it would be amazing. Honestly I can imagine both bands learning enough lines in the other's language just to sing together. That sounds fun :)
So, April 1st is less than two weeks from now. Wouldn't it be amazing if Band Maid dropped a colab track with a video? I think it's a very long shot but jeeze that would be amazing. Not sure it would beat Band Maiko but still.
I’m here for both, because music is the universal language among tribes, nations or just among simple people. I’m a Warning fan because they started their journey in a hard way being just a three persons band. The Band Made have more than five members and of course they sound more full than the Warning, or they just were? The new album of the Warning proves that they learned their lessons from producers and sound Engineers and sound awsom. I’m not worried about loosing their own style during collaborating with others, actually those few new songs will lift them to the stratosphere in rock which they deserve it for 100%.
I would agree, I think the fans of either band would feel sad if their drummer was off the kit, but I do agree. They should just have fun adding novel percussive ideas 😊👍
The Warning... The Best!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Take a look at Snarky Puppy's live recording of their album "Empire Central" (on their Groundup Music NYC YT channel) done at a club in Dallas, Tx. USA, Sep. 2022. They had 3 drummers (Larnell Lewis, JT Thomas, and Jamison Ross) seamlessly taking turns during every song. They won a Grammy for that album in 2023, 5 in total. I think Band Maid and The Warning will surprise us all, Po! The MV will be super delicious, a little wasabi with salsa, Po! 🦍🍌Yes, Wasabi salsa is a thing, Po! 🥵 Wasabi Salsa should be the song title and theme, Po!
I had no idea Wasabi Salsa was a thing, but now I do I totally endorse this song name! If not, I can use it to coat my delicious hat 🤯. How about Tequila-Hi 😉? I agree though, although I am throwing out my thoughts, I am sure the ladies will have many good surprises of their own up their sleeves 😊
This comment section is hilarious. It's a Japanese rock channel so I thought I'd take a look. Other than a few comments I don't think BAND-MAID fans understand the appeal of The Warning. If you listen to The Warning and can't figure out their appeal. The Warning isn't for you and that's fine. Put the insults.......😳
Yeah, for sure, but take it with a grain of salt. There's been an uptick in silly sniping and across several bands' fan bases recently---and a few professional trolls intentionally whipping up trouble between them. There have been a few from TW's base going after B-M for some odd reason. It's as if they can't deal with any other band getting attention. (There's another fanbase who's growing notorious for that kind of behavior.) And there have been a few B-M fans who are also getting silly, which is a little unusual. But there's always a few. It's perfectly fine for someone to say he/she prefers a particular band but, jeez, keep it civil. And sometimes it's better not to say anything at all. Most of these people are more than old enough to know better.
@@ApexRadius The thing is that there isn't a Mexican rock thing. The Japanese Metal scene is a thing with many bands. The Warning is a rock band from Mexico but they are not Mexican rock.
@@scottlafleur4148 I'm sorry, I'm not sure I follow your point. Correct me if I'm on the wrong track. Online it doesn't really matter where the bands are from. People get tribal. B-M actually has quite a substantial international fanbase. They actually first gained traction in N.America and Europe, not Japan. They're built steadily and incrementally in Japan and are only relatively recently playing bigger shows there. And although there's a very active Japanese rock and metal scene, it's still very niche. Pop rules, just like everywhere else. B-M is one of a few rock/metal artists from there who've actually established a presence overseas. So I suppose the primary overlap between them and TW is that they're young women playing some brand of hard rock. It seems that a minority of too-invested fans imagine them being in some fierce competition, especially since both have fan bases in N. America and Europe (some of which is shared, obviously). I understand there's a lot of TW fans who have followed them since they were kids, so I get it to a degree. And there are a number of B-M fans who have been following them since they were playing to half-empty basement clubs. Both of them are somewhat unlikely successes, so some people are rooting just a little too hard for their team. The thing is, I'm pretty sure all the members of each band don't see it that way at all. They're clearly trying to help each other. (Sorry for the length.)
Line-up issue for drums can be solved through Pau taking the place of Dany in vocals, then we can have a 3 guitar showdown. Easier than 2 drums I guess. Honestly however they do this, it will be epic, so please can this be happening? 🤞
Love this idea! I guess I would just worry that 3 guitarists could lead to too many guitar solos 😉. Maybe I would prefer 3 vocalists and some big harmonies 🎤🎤🎤 I am sure whatever happens though, they will have a ton of fun, and creative genius will lead the way! 😊🤘🤘🤘
or maybe as a set of muscians they will figure it out we let them figure it out. and you forget that many of the collaborations these days usually have one side doing the writing then the other doing the playing so it could go that way. pretty sure kanami would either put her foot down and say she's doing the musical writing side of it or go with the flow and do what is good for the collaboration
Thanks for the comment on this, and I certainly am not suggesting we prescribe how it should be done, this is more just my interested contemplations on how I can imagine them maximizing their potential. As mentioned, I would not be surprised if they came up with something incredible that had nothing to do with my pondered possibility at all 😊! I certainly was aware of your afore mentioned point about the writing often being headed by one side of a collaboration, but the deeper the collaboration goes, the potentially more interesting it could be, and they seem like such a lovely bunch, I can imagine the communication and collaboration running deep. Even with the language difference. Fingers crossed either way, as I certainly hope for a song, and I am sure they will have fun 😊!
Among the discussions the community have had was the suggestion that they would do a cover version of a song by some other band. It makes sense. But if indeed they have time to get together record an original song and shoot a video then we have to start out with heavy bass and drums. Then leap into twin guitars and follow up by twin vocals with the emotional backing vocal from Miku. It will be heavy, loud and quick with no time to breathe and finishing with a crescendo of sound with twin bass and drums.Statues will at last be built in every major city of the World depicting the time they first met. There will be World Peace and money will cease as a form of slavery.......I feel I may be setting myself up for disappointment. But let there be hope.
haha, no no, I think you are simply predicting the most likely outcome 🌏😂. You make a very good point though, it is extremely common at least in Japan, for bands at a two-man live to cover one of each other's songs. I would therefore be very interested to hear that, especially given the language barrier. A translated version each perhaps? 😮
@@josephbel7532 The Pigeon is the rhythm guitar player and backup singer Miku in BAND-MAID. She is the founder and the manager of BAND-MAID. She is brilliant and has some weird stories around her. One is that she believes she is a pigeon. The lore says that she is 810 years old. She also falls a lot and have several bruises. As you can see. She is the borne leader.
I don’t think Miku, or anyone in either band, would take a “boss” attitude. They all work collaboratively in their respective bands and I sense that none of them would have a primadonna attitude if these bands do a joint project.
Your idea is fantastic! I really wish they do collaborate with an original song, but man... with both of their schedules... is that really possible? If yes, the only change I would make to your line up is that you get Saiki, Danny and Pau on lead vocals. 3 way harmonies would be fantastic!!! but in reality if a new song is not possible, a cover wour most likely be the outcome. if that is the case... any ideas what cover they could do together?
Thanks so much, I think you're the first person who actually agreed with my suggestion 😂! I do hope for an original, however, if they do a cover than I would hope they covered a mutual band they both liked. Ultimately, really, I want to be surprised. Both bands are so capable within their own spaces, that any collaboration has me hoping for something that neither could do on their own, so maybe a song that encourages the 3 way harmonies you mentioned. A rock version of a famous girlband song even 😉. Ultimately, I will always prefer something risky to something safe, especially with two bands so well established in their own field. That is my feeling at least 😁. Thanks again!
Hey so sorry I missed this! So yes, it isn't what I expected as much, but I am wondering what it will sound like when the studio version comes out. I know The Warning tend to bring a lot of production playfulness in to the studio and Band-Maid do too, so I wonder it the live version was more straight shooting, but we will hear more layering on the do-as-you-please studio version? My hopes remain high! 😂😂
i checked out thrill and liked what i saw , so i looked for more band maid and it was all just thrill light, so im not a maid fan but i do go back and click on thrill now and then.
Most of their music is nothing like Thrill. It's a straightforward classic rock song from their very early days and they have become much more innovative since then. But it probably is a good gateway to Band-Maid for fans of The Warning because it's closer to their style.
Try "Reincarnation" (AKA "Rinne"), "Shambles," "Warning," "I Cant Live Without You," "I Still Seek Revenge," "Hate?," "Puzzle," "Clang," "The Non-fiction Days," "Black Hole" and dozens of others. Sounds like you've only scratched the surface of a few singles. "Thrill" isn't nearly the heaviest or most interesting of their songs. That's basically the very early days. What they do now is quite different.
I can understand that feeling when a band just isn't hitting the points that gives songs individuality and character for you as a listener. There are some genres where I am really surprised that people tell me there is so much variation, and I can't really see it except in points that aren't as interesting to me. So I can imagine how this must have felt for you. As a Band-Maid fan, I don't want to bombard you with my opinions. I would perhaps recommend Memorable for being an acoustic number, and Bubble as another rock song but with a focus on building up from start to crescendo, but absolutely you don't have to like something just because other people do, and as I am assuming you are a WARNING fan, I hope that any potential collaboration at least gives you something fun to checkout :)
Why have 2 drummers. Pau can do vocals, leaving the gorilla in her natural element. Don't forget kanami is great at arranging complex things without cluttering it up. Even though there is no way I could be there for this concert, the amount of energy these 2 bands give off would be magical.
BAND-MAD has a song called Black Hole were all 5 members do solos through the whole song. Even the two singers. So - it is actually 6 continues solos for 6 minutes. It is not an easy song to listen to. But it gets better and better each time when you find more and more cool stuff. I am not sure if it scales to 8 persons.
So.....*big angry inhale*.... it had to be you huh? ........... the nemesis...... the man with over 15x as many subscribers who comes here to my tiny little channel to attack me with your screaming guitar solos ................. when you do eventually get what you want lol........... and I am crying in the corner with my complex song arrangement graphs lol......................... I want you to know that you are a BIG MEANIE 😂😂😂
My thoughts on BAND-MAID & THE WARNING is focused on their performance together this June 12th. I think each band should offer an original and have both bands perform those two songs together. It would present some cool possibilities in arrangements and, most likely, have a fuller sound. Which songs? I trust the eight musicians' choices better than my own. Nice job, Baka. Thank you.
Thank you too! I actually think that would be a nice idea, and with both bands working on material this year (to the best of my knowledge), what a lovely way to share the moment 😊
So i am totally in TWA, DPA forever. I have yet to warm to BandMaid (was gonna go BM, but that's just wrong). TW Songs are usually sonically complete, which is why they adhere to the mind; not just a hook but as a whole. The whole song is a hook, if you will. And, they understand that leaving space in between sounds is just as important as the notes themselves. DPA all can kill instrumental work. But, leaving room for tasty, memorable fiils makes you await them and appreciate them more. That said the one part if the admittedly limited B-M music i have listened to that i really have liked, is the bass work. REALLY liked. Like Asterism, like Lovebites.. Musr be the old bassist in me. Or the Geddy lover. So, i don't see much of a meaningful collab. But these folks are uber talented, so...who knows? BTW do i remember one of DPA sayng they would love to work Willow? THAF would be cool.
These are 8 very talented and creative musicians. They do different things and do them extremely well. I don’t see any hint of egoism in any of them, so I’m betting they can, if they collaborate, get those musical differences to be complimentary, and not clash.
Well said! I agree that on a personality level, they don't give off the signs of being people who would bulldoze in to a collaboration and make a mess, but it will be interesting how each of them finds their voice and who takes control of what. Certainly though, they seem like a very pleasant bunch of talented creatives to share a room, and I hope they have a blast in the process 😊!
I can totally see that haha!!! Personally, I'd just love to see Dany and Saiki freely bouncing around the stage, and I think there will be enough instrumental awesomeness already to allow it give the amount of talent on offer :)
I love seeing Dany singing without the guitar to keep her strapped to a place on stage, she loves taking over the satage the few times she hasn’t had to pay the guitar
I respect your feelings but they will without a doubt do that eventually, I fact Dany has already when the 3 day grace tour song she did with them, and Pau with that colab she did years ago with a Mexican ensemble of musicians. Was a foo fighters song can't remember exactly, but yeah
Some may claim there is a complete absence of ego in these ladies. Well... someone has to defer to someone or nothing will get done. Perhaps in Japan (and I expect it) Band Maid will roll out the humble carpet for a band wanting to make a big splash. The Warning will never be made to feel sleighted by their 'elder sisters '. The Warning will return the favor in a substantial way when the two reunite in Mexico !
Dany taking solos? She doesn't do solos normally. What seems like a solo today turns up again note for note the same the next day. I'm not saying she can't compose an original solo on the fly, but that that's not her habit. Also, understand that they have a different fan base and TW fans don't go to their concerts hoping to bask in their instrumental prowess. They go there to hear the songs they love played just like they were on RUclips or the album or wherever it is they go to replay them.
Sorry if I misunderstood, but actually I was saying for Dany not to play guitar at all in my proposed lineup. Sorry if I misunderstood your comment, but I'm a little unsure what you mean. Let me know :)
@@BakaBroadcast I'm not talking about your lineup. I'm explaining another reason why we may not hear Dany playing a solo. The Warning is not a flash band. All of the members of Band Maid are monsters on their instruments. Heck, Akane is more than just a pretender to Neil Peart's throne. That's their forte, TW's is songwriting. TW writes one song after another you can sing in the shower. I wouldn't even try that with 99% of Band Maid's songs. I'm interested to see how well they blend. I'm sure it'll be great because both bands want it to happen.
@@thsc9119Band Maids songs are great compositions too. Also very catchy, IMO, although I can’t sing them very well because of the language barrier. I get what you’re saying, though. The Warning occupy a different rock space, and their songs are so easy to love. Also, for me, if QOTMS was the only album they’d ever made, I’d still love them forever. An awesome concept album from an all-female trio as young as they were? That’s just right up my alley!
@@interstellardave Even if you spoke Japanese, I'm not sure you'd find anything like the hooks TW puts in every single song. It's their superpower. TW is best viewed as more a parallel to Lennon/McCartney than to The Beatles. They are songwriters first, musicians second, and they are very good musicians.
@@thsc9119Well Band Maid songs stick in my head all the time. The rhythms and melodies are often contagious. At least as contagious as they can be with the complex dense arrangements they are now producing. A lot of people say the same so it’s in the ear of the beholder. As a fan of both bands I think both are very complete in every area. I think anything either band may “lack” is simply because they haven’t done it, not because they can’t.
Just in case I went online looking for edible hats.Sorry looks like you're on your own..I would love to see The Warning on a messy stage saying to one" we need a maid" then a another says " like a band maid" then MIKU pops her head in and says " did you say BAND-MAID PO!" I know silly...
Haha, I don't know why, but I want to see your stage play intro now ;) ! Sounds quite cute actually lol. I must check to see is hats are improved with shoyu , hmmmm...
Or maybe a very early Fleetwood Mac song, from when the Mac included Peter Green, Danny Kirwan and Jeremy Spencer, any one of those in a band would be a fine lead guitarist on their own, that all 3 were in the same band... wow!
Both drummers are top notch, but both drummers are also eccentric, they do not play ordinary stuff. I love them both because they are so hard to predict. Its not simple chugga chugga chugga. It is big arm movements and surprising bass drum fills and delicious syncopations and stick fills. It is just pure entertainment. And the are both in contact with the audience, a rare treat among drummers.
If you believe that arranging is The Warning's so-called "weak point", then you're either not aware of their 2018 concept album, "Queen Of The Murder Scene", haven't heard any of its tracks or both. There are some VERY complex song arrangements on the album. Seriously, listen to its title track, "Queen Of The Murder Scene", and "The One" and "The Sacrifice". Those three songs are the best examples of The Warning's high-level, complex-arrangement abilities. Educate yourself. Then, you will hopefully completely change your mind about the girls' complete lack of ANY songwriting weaknesses whatsoever. You're welcome in advance!
Thanks for the comment. I did check out the Queen Of The Murder Scene, and it was an interesting one but, as much as it rocked, left me in a rather similar place. The breakdown of the descending bass line as the guitar picked above made for an interesting moment, but it mostly reinforced how I had felt about the Warning previously. I think they do good stonking headbangers, but it did still feel rather thin on arrangement for me. That is ok though. I mean, my biggest disagreement with you is perhaps the idea that any band has no weaknesses whatsoever. Every band does, even the greatest legends of any artform, they all have their relative weaknesses within their skill set, and most of them are driven by the creative desire to improve upon them. Then again, obviously, no band or fandom is under any obligation to agree on what those weaknesses are, as art has the joy of being subjective, but for me I would consider arrangement to be the area where I would love to see more of The Warning. Thank you though for the suggestion, I did check it out and enjoyed the music! 😊🙏
In comparison and my opinion after hearing some songs of band maid the japenese girls are pretty cool, but it sounds a little bit more like playing against each other than together. Their compositions are almost overloaded and doesn't let room for each other to shine with their special skills. I have to admiit that I've been warned and since then I'm totally addicted by the (in my opinion) new gold standard of all time rock music: With band maid I have instantly several ideas how to arrange their songs differently to get more out of it. With the Villarreal sisters I'll be alway the little child again with mouth wide open that can't belief what it's witnessing - every single note, every little sequence... all of it is at its perfect place, perfectly played brillant composed It doesn't have to be less, but it also doesnt have to be more - it's just on the point- I'm into music since I was ten - that's 43 years ago now and I saw and heard alot and wrote about it for several music magazines - but I've never seen anything comparable to these three girls.
I was at the Aftershock Festival where Band'Maid and The Warning met. It didn't really suprise me that they were fans of each other. Both are awesome bands!
Two words.....Battle Scar. This was a collaboration song between two of Canada's best bands in 1980. Max Webster & Rush. It was written by Max Webster (Kim Mitchel-music, Pye Dubois-lyrics [who co-wrote Tom Sawyer with Neil Peart]) and performed by all 7 musicians. 2 guitars, 2 bass, 2 drums & 1 keyboard. All musicians have such a unique playing style/sound that it's easy to pick out who is playing what. It was recorded live in the studio with all of them present, which is why it rocks so hard.
I would prefer Band-Maid & The Warning do something similar, be all together if/when recording the song. Not have one record their part in a studio and have the other do it in another studio, then mix the two together. Ideas work better when your face to face.
As far as writing the music is concerned, that's a tough one (I'm on the Kanami side only because of how she thinks outside the box musically). Lyrics will depend on which audience you are trying to reach. All English lyrics would reach a wider audience (especially for Band-Maid).
And we all have to remember, this wouldn't be a competition, it would be a collaboration.
Just my two sense. Thanks for listening.
ruclips.net/video/PMM6Bhwpy0M/видео.html Epic, thunderous, test your woofer with this one, Still get chills listening to it. This shows how two talented bands can make it work (as mentioned in the o.p.)
I trust Kanami's mastery of complexity through the way she works with a score like a classical composer. There is no reason whatsoever why they should not all play at once.
How many violins, violas and cellos do you have in a chamber orchestra?
The Warning know that Kanami's arrangement skills are next level, these are pros. Also obviously Pau is very well placed to do English lyrics. These are both friends and professionals. There will be no clashing egos, among the stans obviously but they're immune to that.
The Warning work closely with a producer, but if the legendary Tony Visconti defers to Kanami's production skill he can step aside and maybe help with the final master where they always defer to an independent specialist.
I think the fact they're women will smooth the process too. Bandmaid have been together for a decade and run like a well oiled machine, I expect The Warning are the same, this is a skillset too. There are so many great lineups with a lot of percussion. The original Santana for starters.
Likewise both bands work with multiple voices in unison and harmony. This is all just technique.
There again both drummers compose carefully and thus using a score and drum machine they can craft what they want. I'd like to see achi on the Timbales given her tom skills.
So The Warning are not PRO?
Don't believe Tony Visconti is involved in this ? not that I'm informed of that ?
@@user-ix5yj9ip9v no I'm referring to a project where he helped just with the vocal mix because, on receiving Kanami's demo he said he couldn't improve on her mix.
@@lookiloo100 I'm referring to all of them. I thought that was apparent.
I don't know why yall
expect more than what is probably gonna happen. You go right to them doing an album together. They're probably only doing a concert on the same ticket. You'll probably see one or two on stage during each other's show but, I'll bet that's all that will happen.
Fair point there. Although I can't speak for all the commentors, myself I am mainly addressing this because I think it is the most interesting possible outcome, and not one that would even be that hard to imagine happening. Collaboration songs are a big thing these days and are great for the profile of both artists, so I would have to imagine the record companies would be very much behind something like that which would provide a more long term benefit from a meeting that is already going to happen. So I think it is absolutely worth considering, if not only for the pure interest of it, but also as it has to be an option they would be encouraged towards.
@@BakaBroadcastIs Band maid signed to a label? U.S
Or Japan label?
@@SDsailor7They're signed to Pony Canyon, a major Japanese label.
@@SDsailor7 Both are signed to independent label's !
@@ApexRadius Thank you
Given the fact both bands have new albums coming this summer, I suspect both have already contributed to each others albums.
Great point!
Maybe, but I wouldn't expect it. They're signed to two different labels and that makes it a bit more complicated.
@@ApexRadius The Warning have several features in their contract that allow them creative freedom. IDK about BM's contract, but based on their music selection, I wouldn't be surprised if they also have creative freedom. Getting both recording companies to agree to a collab is a complex arrangement in a business sense, but I'm sure all that would be worked out well in advance. I also think they might compose a song together and record it as a live performance, creating a music video in the process. The Warning tour with a videographer/producer who is one of their team and it's easy enough to assemble a group of professionals for the camera work anywhere in the world. The equipment isn't different between Mexico and Japan, after all. The Warning's collab with Aslessia Cara on the reimagined Enter Sandman was accomplished, soup to nuts, in a week. So doing a song together with two bands, though more complex for writing all the parts, is something I'm sure both bands have the creative chops to accomplish in 12 days.
@@elgonwilliams7624 Of course, anything's possible. Live collaboration actually seems most likely to me. B-M has had multi-camera crews at four of their last five shows, so, whoever does the video production, it's easily covered.
B-M seems to have total creative control with Pony Canyon. But, as you mentioned, there's always business that has to happen between labels/management teams.
When people start talking about them being on each other's albums they're getting further into wild speculation (I get it, it's fun). It's simply more complicated to make that happen. Pau mentioned it took a long time and a lot of effort just to make this show happen. Could she be playing possum and they've been planning to spring something all along? Sure. But folks are assuming something big as if it's inevitable. They might be disappointed. We'll just have to see what they've been up to when the time comes. It'll be soon.
Akane on trombone. 'Nuff said. 🤣
100% 😂 ! I should have led with that, I missed a golden opportunity lol. Thank you for correcting me!
Or cajon -- Akane likes the cajon too. But trombone would be cool. Misa could play the trumpet.
If they do perform a joint song, which I think is likely (though no guarantees it'll be a new song), I don't think it'd be too difficult to make the numbers work. Kanami has already written a lot of songs, including the entire Band-Maiko EP, that would need >>5 musicians to perform live without a click-track. Gacharic Spin and Wagakki Band have shown that two drummers can improve a song. The trickiest part would normally be the bass, but the two bands have such different approaches to the instrument that it would be natural for Ale to do the traditional bassist's role and set Misa completely free to add the colour that she often does anyway. If necessary, I'm sure Miku would be delighted to put down her guitar for a song and they could have a lot of to and fro with the vocals.
Well Paulina and The Warning have recorded over 50 originals all three sisters are classically trained on piano and can sing lead ! There’s no time to collaborate as the Keep me fed album will be release at the same time their in Japan!
I'm glad you've been listening to The Warning's music. You're right, they really know how to smash out an arena thumping track. I do still take issue with your issue, though. I feel the "bass and guitar playing the same riff at the same time" is only true on some tracks and I think the reason so many bands (especially 3-piece bands) do it, is it fills out the sound more and keeps things going when the guitarist switches riffing for soloing.
Speaking of solos.... YES! YES!! YES!!! Give me many solos!!!
One thing I think you missed though, is that Pau, like Miku does a LOT of vocals. Not just backing, but lead also. You have 4 vocalists in this collaboration. Giving Pau some vocals and not just drums would solve one potential problem.
Thank you! Yeah, I was thinking of your previous comments as I listened lol!
I feel pretty safe still in my comments about the arrangements, but that is a loooooooong chat for Discord perhaps ;)
As for solos, I wasn't aware you were such a solo man!!! You continue to surprise me!
Also, yes, I saw the Pau comments coming up and you are totally right. I think though that I was thinking of that in a similar light to how Miku is a vocalist, and I would love to see her sing in the song, but given that we already have two lead vocalists at work, I would more see that as a pleasant addition rather than her core role in any collaboration.
Keys keys keys ;)
Thanks Loon!
You may get some push back for some of the stuff you say here, but I appreciate you having an opinion other than "everything is equally great", standing by it, and daring to say so.
I think they should do two songs with Saiki/Miku on a Warning-written/performed song and The Warning on a Band-Maid-written/performed song.
As always you are right indeed, and I know, that you know me well enough, to know I'm already prepped for all those dislikes lol! But hey, I was always more the opinion columnist that the news journalist ;) ;)
Actually, your idea for two songs would certainly be the ideal outcome, but I think we may not be that lucky. If we are though, I am happy to scrap my plan in order to get two songs instead!
Thanks for the comment!!
Imagine a dual lead featuring Dani and Kaname. Imagine a dual bass with Misa and Ale. Imagine a dual duel lead versus bass! The possibilities are endless. Having 2 drummers on the same stage has been done more times than I can mention, and with the combined talent of Kaname and Pau, I don't see a problem.
I honestly don't even care if there's a common song or not. I just hope they'll have a good time with each other and some great moments. And maybe, share some of them with us 🙂
This concert is a dream line up for me, but unfortunately I'm not gonna make it to Japan this year. At least I'm seeing The Warning in 3 weeks live in Munich 🤘🏻🙂
As much as I do agree, ohhhhh would we not all be sad in years to come if no song had come from this meeting of 2024's rock titans ;)
@@BakaBroadcast don't get me wrong, if it happens, I'll take it gladly.
It's just not my top priority thinking of those 2 🙂
Love that they're doing a gig together. Shows the respect and appreciation that each band has for the others' sound. It's the songwriting for me that sets these two bands apart from their peers; they can really bring out the feels for me.
That was a remarkable exegesis of how BandMaid and The Warning can create epic music together!
Thank you so much 😊🙏
I respect BandMaid, they seem to be great and down to earth persons. I dont really see competition between them, they really are very different bands, and fans that like each band loves them for a reason. In my case I cant connect with Band Maid, no reason in particular, even If I know they are very skilled and talented musicians. I just hope both bands find good chemistry there and have a great time along with the audience.
Thanks for the comment! I think I am perhaps viewing this from the other side of the aisle, in that I have a respect for the Warning which has never quite converted in to me really getting their music, still I can see how The Warning could bring something to a potential collaboration that would give me a chance to appreciate them in a whole new light... and if not, I'll just be glad to see the 8 ladies having fun :) ! Thanks for the comment though, always great to hear from both sides of the fandoms!!
Im not a fan of band maid’s music, despite trying to get into it a few times, but I can still recognize good musicianship, so I’m very curious about the result (if there’s ever one), since their styles of music couldn’t be more different from one another. I hope they do a video of them performing together.
I would love to see something that starts out. Acoustic and builds into a heavy harder song with a great warning hook. With Saiki
Singing the emotional. Parts and danny singing the harsh harder section .Miku is excellent with harmonizing and backup vocals. As far as drumming goes I have no idea how that would work. Akane is
Very technical , Pau Is very hard-hitting Rock style. Whatever they do together it's a dream come true
Love both bands! Great thought experiment. I hope it ALL comes true!
I’m excited for a potential song no matter how it turns out. I trust both outfits to produce something amazing.
The fact that they are playing a show together is in itself extremely epic.
Thanks, and indeed! Can't wait :) !!!!
@@BakaBroadcast the new Endless Story live video is very moving. Having seen them twice now here in the states, I am always rooting for them.
Btw, my band Paint and Copter is releasing a new video tomorrow called Another Dimension with Japanese bassist Ichinose, our third collaboration with her.
There is a bit of a Band-Maid meets techno influence to the song.
She came pretty close to being Lovebites new bassist. But Fami has done an awesome job.
Thank you.
@@BakaBroadcastI think that the Warning will just open for BM and that will be it. They are in a new market and not well known there plus the majority there will be BM fans. But I could be wrong.
Good video, very interesting. 👍
** PS- I am aware of the error at 2:03 lol **
I dunno, I love the music of both band's, but as far as a recording with all members playing, they are so vastly different, do I just dunno, guess we'll all have to wait and see.
Good points! 7 ladies just feeding the Gorilla her drum power bananas would also be a good usage or manpower, but since I was reminded in many comments, as you said, that Pau is an accomplished singer, it does raise an interesting question about how she could step forwards that i totally agree with. However, whatever happens, I hope we all get to at least see the show on streaming and video afterwards! 🍌🥁
@@BakaBroadcast I'm certainly looking forward to it.
As a Japanese fan, I'm interested in seeing what would happen if BAND-MAID produced a song for THE WARNING.
Gonna predict no musical collab, at least not for a long time. It will be The Warning on stage first, then Band-Maid. They might get together after for a song or two, but I think that will be as far as it goes. It will be interesting either way, but not earth shaking.
Yes, I'm leaning that way, too, although a song is certainly possible. B-M never explicitly stated that they were doing recording collaborations with anyone. To read that is to make an inference. And, remember, the bands are signed to two different labels. It's complicated.
"Collaboration" can mean a whole host of things, like simply playing a show together. But, I understand that it's fun to speculate about what they might do.
We'll have to wait and see.
Agree, and if they do play together on stage for a couple of songs, they will most likely play covers of some other band or artist that both groups are familiar with.
@@KansaSCaymanS this, yep
And the survey says.... X
Please let them make a song/video together! 🤞
This is a concert/get to know each other event. What will happen is hoped, but unknown. I just love the female power vibe. Chill out and enjoy what comes.
The Allman Brothers made two drummers work.......for years!
I feel there would need to be a huge coordination of time off for the bands to practice a song collaboration. More power to them if they can pull it off, which I don't doubt given their non-stop, can do, will do attitude/energy. They are ALL Troopers!
Nice example! I think that, a lot like other bands, one drummer was more in the percussion area whilst the other played the main kit, if I am correct. I actually really like this style of percussion when used, but I think that whichever band didn't have their drummer on the traditional kit may feel slighted. However, I do agree this would be the most fun way to approach it :)
This will be a great market for The Warning In Japan. R&R is in good hands.
I think if there is a collaboration it will less likely be a new song, but more likely just playing together on stage for a song or two, most likely covers of other bands/artists (like TW has done with Eruca Sativa in the past), with Pau perhaps out front singing and channeling her inner Jagger.
It seems possible you are right, I just hope this is part of what Band-Maid's announcement was discussing, as it seems like such a great opportunity, but I will take what we can get ;)
I clearly see you have put a lot of thought into this. Imagine the disappointment when all that happens is each band just plays their own set. End of story.
Haha 😂, the inevitable reality, I know 🙏
crow is a dish best served cold.
Whatever it is I believe it will be amazing both bands are fire and full of amazing musicians.
Awesome!!
Whatever they do I'm for it!
Viva Band Maid and The Warning!! ⚡⚡⚡
Ultimately, this is a better conclusion than my one ❤︎😊🤘
Did you ever consider that what Band-Maid meant by "collaborations" was simply just playing shows with other bands and not literally songwriting together? Their understanding and use of the word might be different than what we usually interpret it to mean; especially in the context of music. I think that's what might be happening here. It IS logical to see it that way, correct?
All 3 of the sisters Villarreal can play the piano. Pau is the main songwriter but each sister contributes. All 3 can sing but Ale shies away from lead. Pau and Dany both can front a band with 0 effort, with or without their instrument. I would like to see part Japanese, part Spanish and part English in the lyrics. That would be epic.
The two bands have been together for several days now. Whether they're collaborating or just hanging out doing touristy stuff, they've not said. It would be silly if they didn't (Witness Babymetal and Electric Callboy's recent collab!)
Your giddiness is contagious! The solution, of course, is a blues song. The chord structure is already worked out; there's nothing to decide except the key and the turn-around, write some couplets, and decide who takes the next solo (and in true blues fashion, no one knows until they look at each other). But neither band really does blues so ignore that. The Warning is a power trio where they fill up the room with simplicity and Band-Maid fills the room with density. It will be interesting to see what they do. No shade intended to anyone (like, in the history of music), Kanami Tōno is a rare bird when it comes to composition. Give her a couple of ideas and she'll figure it out.
An aside. The video from the media area at Aftershock makes Ale look like a giant compared to everyone else! It may be the camera lens and angle, but still ... what a striking woman. Between her and MISA, they will have the best-looking bass section in the history of rock music; Paul McCartney, Jack Bruce, and John Paul Jones included. We'll leave Dusty Hill out of the discussion, LOL.
Thank you! Yes indeed as well, anyone who offers the possibility of a collaboration leading to something neither fanbase expected, is very much speaking my language lol!
Louder rock music can somewhat limit the sonic space available, and as much as we all want to see them rock out for the energy, and the appropriateness of that to their established sounds, I would certainly be first in line if things took on a blues tinge. The Warning nailing a core, whilst Band-Maid paint colour between the notes, this would be an interesting listen for sure! Thanks for the lovely comment!
Those are two VERY DIFFERENT bands.
The Warning is three, very talented, but rather ordinary sisters that write good music, plays and sing well and are very good at stage presence. They rock catchy and powerful songs. They are also very beautiful. Some of their songs is a bit more pop. Personally I listen to The Warning when I want straight rock with power. They are brilliant, one of the best thing that has happened for many years.
BAND-MAID is a group of goofy girls that has made one of the best rock bands on the planet. They write very different songs. Complex and good. Not so much catchy and powerful. Rather just interesting and good rock, on the border of prog rock, mixed with some pop singing. They also play around on the scena and do guitar and bass battles and other stuff. They have long concerts with diverse things around, like Miku doing her crazy stuff with the audience, while the rest is chilling. They also have some killer instrumentals where they show their skills. Even though The Warning has more power, BAND-MAID has more chops.
Now, if they like each other and the chemistry is right and they got the time, this might be magic. Both BAND-MAID and The Warning have shown that they are capable of writing killer songs in no time at all. It is Kanami that i the super composer in BAND-MAID, I think it might be Pau in The Warning, but I am not sure. Lyrics might be tough though 😁
You tried to make that comment seem fair. Some key words used gave it away. In my opinion BAND-MAID writes songs to show off their "chops". And again in my opinion is why their songs are very good.
@@scottlafleur4148 Yes, BAND-MAID has technical excellence as a goal. You can see that in the text to Domination. It says again and again that they work hard to get better and better. And yes, this is a part of their charm. I saw an interview made by Herman Lee from Dragonforce of Kanami and Miku. Kanami asked how fast the fastest Dragonforce song was, and Herman said 220 BPM. Then we shall aim for 225 said Kanami with a straight face. And ... I think that the totally wild song "Black Hole" has 225 BPM.
You should be a music critic. You describe these two bands perfectly as far as I can see.
Both great rock bands but they are very different.
Years ago Joe Bonamassa toured for a year with two drummers and it worked out great.
The Tedeschi Trucks band have 2 full time drummers.
Joe is playing in Maryland very soon .
It seems,at some point, before June 12th, the commentary will denigrate to a classically primitive level. If true...what a shame. These eight great ladies should be treated as they treat us. With the utmost professionalism and respect.
Whether I like the finished product or not is immaterial. They have brought so much joy to their fans that I can only take the high road concerning them...👍🏻🔥
Good point, and this is always a great concern.
Obviously, I enter this conversation myself very much on one side of things, but I would feel pretty dissapointed if anyone purely hated on the collaboration for happening, or the other side for just being there. Of course no one has to like something just because their favourite band or fandom likes it, but anyone who starts to treat it like a tribal conflict clearly doesn't understand music. This is why in my graphic I took time to put both bands on the same team 😂👍
As you so well said, their is joy to be had here. Joy is what they want to spread, and joy is all anyone needs to take from it, discussion is a nice way to understand it, and anything else probably just isn't worth bothering with .
Thanks!
I would love to see NEMOPHILA & The Warning collaborate.😊
the warnings new album drops a few days after this show, I dont think they would add a new song to compete with the new album
The collaboration would be on BAND-MAID's album when it's released. It's not going to compete with The Warning's album release
Good point. Their music labels will probably only allow them to rock out to a classic song from bands like KISS or G&R.
A live joint version of Warning! by Band-Maid and... The Warning!!
Yes!! "Warning!" by The Warning and ...... do The Warning have a song about Maids for Band-Maid..... oh this is the most confusing sentence I have ever written 😂
The fact that they share the stage already seems extraordinary and wonderful to me. I hope this to be broadcast on streaming because I suspect on that day I´ll still be 22 hours from Tokyo... damn...
Regarding the 8 fantastic musicians on stage at a time, I would like to remember here the collaboration between U2 and Green Day, The Saints are Coming. Everything is possible in rock music on stage. And... YES!, I expect at least a song.
I love your positive energy! I imagine it will go out on some streaming service as The Warning will have so many fans back home wanting to watch!
I think 8 folks on a stage is not too many, but I certainly want them all to shine, and no one to just be left playing the same thing as someone else. Perhaps just the song arranger side of my brain pushing for that as it is my personal ideal in any collaboration.
That being said, I'll just be happy to see whatever happens!
Thanks as always for commenting :) !!
I don’t really know why people are unsure about it, i just can remember George Harrison’s gigs with a lot of legends on stage and the sound was incredible
My world's are colliding!
MY TWO FAVORITE BANDS
Respectfully, I hope none of what you speculate happens. No need for Bandmaid to do any of that.
It would be way cooler, less complicated logistically and also provide more prestige to BM if they were to bring Mike Einziger from Incubus as guest for a tune on the new record and even more exiciting if they get Mike on stage to play such song with them at their upcoming show together.
Anyone see the announcement on a upcoming co-written song called "Bestie" with Mike from Incubus?
Told ya! 🙃
Since it was said, I've always had the feeling that the word collaboration has be miss interpreted and only means together for a show, like the one that has been announced. Mixing two complete bands musically does not make sense. I've seen similar in the past which sometimes ends in a messy chaos. So, I'm hoping that it only means sharing a show. So no recordings.
I come from a completely different backround, not really familiar with Bandmaid, perhaps the point is just to get new fans by appearing with a group whose music they admire. I know that The Warning have very diverse interests in the music they listen to and I would suppose that Bandmaid does as well.
In this case, Band-Maid is helping The Warning get a bump in Japan. TW is not well known there. And even B-M is more of a growing niche band but with a very dedicated fanbase. The show will almost certainly sell out.
It's very possible that TW returns the favor in a market where they're very strong and B-M is not as well known.
As a fan of both bands, I'm excited to hear what they come up with. - I think it'll be good for both to appeal to one another's fans also. - As to what they produce, it could be anything. - I think a collaboration in writing would be the foundation. How they arrange it will be the most interesting aspect. There is a lot of talent there.... Maybe a Warning-ish song, with a Japanese verse, and all three vocalists sparring, back and forth, or just all three vocalists singing in harmony, then add in some little solos by each remaining member would be the final outcome.
Thanks for popping in a comment fella, and yeah I think you probably hit the nail on the head as to what I suspect a lot of people are perhaps expecting. I certainly would be interested to see a lot of vocal work though yeah. If you have Miku, Saiki, Pau and Dany all singing, that would be incredibly fun! 🤘😊
@@BakaBroadcastIn a way, that'd possibly be the clincher, to have two strong leads and two very good backing singers is what is going to sell it the most. To mix English, Japanese and maybe Spanish in the lyrics would be a challenge, however, not insurmountable, since I feel that their long experience ( both bands are around 10-years old) will help a lot in the process. Whatever happens I think both acts will be much enriched by working the other, whatever the outcome. - and let's not forget that bands have a team of people on the other side of the glass to bounce ideas off. It won't be just 8 ladies in a studio, a bunch of microphones and a blank notebook each.
@@triquivijate I agree, for my preferences at least. If that showed through in the recording as well it would be amazing. Honestly I can imagine both bands learning enough lines in the other's language just to sing together. That sounds fun :)
So, April 1st is less than two weeks from now. Wouldn't it be amazing if Band Maid dropped a colab track with a video? I think it's a very long shot but jeeze that would be amazing. Not sure it would beat Band Maiko but still.
Whatever they do im for it
I hope the warning girls enjoy some time at Japan
⚡⚡⚡!
🔥🔥🔥!
💀💀💀!
🌀🌀🌀! + Band-Maid ❤❤❤❤❤ = 🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶🎶🌞
Here for The Warning. 😎🤟⚡️
I’m here for both, because music is the universal language among tribes, nations or just among simple people. I’m a Warning fan because they started their journey in a hard way being just a three persons band. The Band Made have more than five members and of course they sound more full than the Warning, or they just were? The new album of the Warning proves that they learned their lessons from producers and sound Engineers and sound awsom. I’m not worried about loosing their own style during collaborating with others, actually those few new songs will lift them to the stratosphere in rock which they deserve it for 100%.
About the drumming issue: Something like the Waggaki with Akane playing taiko drums. Pau does also sing...
I would agree, I think the fans of either band would feel sad if their drummer was off the kit, but I do agree. They should just have fun adding novel percussive ideas 😊👍
@@BakaBroadcastWhen Waggaki do it is very impressive
@@BakaBroadcastAnd Misa plays samisen as well (secret Maiko lips)
@@BakaBroadcast I don't think any The Warning fan would object Pau singing lead without her drums. It is really unheard of :D
The Warning... The Best!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I love this energy! Looking forward to seeing the Warning fans in Japan too 😃🙏🎸
I'm very excited for them and for us
100% 😊🤘
Take a look at Snarky Puppy's live recording of their album "Empire Central" (on their Groundup Music NYC YT channel) done at a club in Dallas, Tx. USA, Sep. 2022. They had 3 drummers (Larnell Lewis, JT Thomas, and Jamison Ross) seamlessly taking turns during every song. They won a Grammy for that album in 2023, 5 in total. I think Band Maid and The Warning will surprise us all, Po! The MV will be super delicious, a little wasabi with salsa, Po! 🦍🍌Yes, Wasabi salsa is a thing, Po! 🥵 Wasabi Salsa should be the song title and theme, Po!
I had no idea Wasabi Salsa was a thing, but now I do I totally endorse this song name! If not, I can use it to coat my delicious hat 🤯. How about Tequila-Hi 😉?
I agree though, although I am throwing out my thoughts, I am sure the ladies will have many good surprises of their own up their sleeves 😊
I hope you go to their joint concert!
Thank you! May be difficult, but I would love to, and hope to! At worst I will report from outside 😄
This comment section is hilarious. It's a Japanese rock channel so I thought I'd take a look. Other than a few comments I don't think BAND-MAID fans understand the appeal of The Warning. If you listen to The Warning and can't figure out their appeal. The Warning isn't for you and that's fine. Put the insults.......😳
Yeah, for sure, but take it with a grain of salt. There's been an uptick in silly sniping and across several bands' fan bases recently---and a few professional trolls intentionally whipping up trouble between them.
There have been a few from TW's base going after B-M for some odd reason. It's as if they can't deal with any other band getting attention. (There's another fanbase who's growing notorious for that kind of behavior.) And there have been a few B-M fans who are also getting silly, which is a little unusual. But there's always a few.
It's perfectly fine for someone to say he/she prefers a particular band but, jeez, keep it civil. And sometimes it's better not to say anything at all. Most of these people are more than old enough to know better.
@@ApexRadius The thing is that there isn't a Mexican rock thing. The Japanese Metal scene is a thing with many bands. The Warning is a rock band from Mexico but they are not Mexican rock.
@@scottlafleur4148 I'm sorry, I'm not sure I follow your point. Correct me if I'm on the wrong track.
Online it doesn't really matter where the bands are from. People get tribal. B-M actually has quite a substantial international fanbase. They actually first gained traction in N.America and Europe, not Japan. They're built steadily and incrementally in Japan and are only relatively recently playing bigger shows there.
And although there's a very active Japanese rock and metal scene, it's still very niche. Pop rules, just like everywhere else. B-M is one of a few rock/metal artists from there who've actually established a presence overseas.
So I suppose the primary overlap between them and TW is that they're young women playing some brand of hard rock. It seems that a minority of too-invested fans imagine them being in some fierce competition, especially since both have fan bases in N. America and Europe (some of which is shared, obviously).
I understand there's a lot of TW fans who have followed them since they were kids, so I get it to a degree. And there are a number of B-M fans who have been following them since they were playing to half-empty basement clubs. Both of them are somewhat unlikely successes, so some people are rooting just a little too hard for their team.
The thing is, I'm pretty sure all the members of each band don't see it that way at all. They're clearly trying to help each other.
(Sorry for the length.)
As long as I live, I'll never understand the appeal of Band-Maid.
Line-up issue for drums can be solved through Pau taking the place of Dany in vocals, then we can have a 3 guitar showdown. Easier than 2 drums I guess. Honestly however they do this, it will be epic, so please can this be happening? 🤞
If they do a ballad Pau would fit but if they are rocking out it has to be 100% Dany.
Love this idea! I guess I would just worry that 3 guitarists could lead to too many guitar solos 😉. Maybe I would prefer 3 vocalists and some big harmonies 🎤🎤🎤
I am sure whatever happens though, they will have a ton of fun, and creative genius will lead the way! 😊🤘🤘🤘
All 3 ladies of The Warning can do vocals. Could you imagine a 5 part vocal harmony?
Ya esperaba algo así con las 2 bandas 🦾
The Greatful Dead recorded and toured with 2 Drumers for decades.
or maybe as a set of muscians they will figure it out we let them figure it out. and you forget that many of the collaborations these days usually have one side doing the writing then the other doing the playing so it could go that way. pretty sure kanami would either put her foot down and say she's doing the musical writing side of it or go with the flow and do what is good for the collaboration
Thanks for the comment on this, and I certainly am not suggesting we prescribe how it should be done, this is more just my interested contemplations on how I can imagine them maximizing their potential. As mentioned, I would not be surprised if they came up with something incredible that had nothing to do with my pondered possibility at all 😊! I certainly was aware of your afore mentioned point about the writing often being headed by one side of a collaboration, but the deeper the collaboration goes, the potentially more interesting it could be, and they seem like such a lovely bunch, I can imagine the communication and collaboration running deep. Even with the language difference. Fingers crossed either way, as I certainly hope for a song, and I am sure they will have fun 😊!
Annisokay and Any Given Day recently did a song together and it totally works!
Among the discussions the community have had was the suggestion that they would do a cover version of a song by some other band. It makes sense. But if indeed they have time to get together record an original song and shoot a video then we have to start out with heavy bass and drums. Then leap into twin guitars and follow up by twin vocals with the emotional backing vocal from Miku. It will be heavy, loud and quick with no time to breathe and finishing with a crescendo of sound with twin bass and drums.Statues will at last be built in every major city of the World depicting the time they first met. There will be World Peace and money will cease as a form of slavery.......I feel I may be setting myself up for disappointment. But let there be hope.
haha, no no, I think you are simply predicting the most likely outcome 🌏😂. You make a very good point though, it is extremely common at least in Japan, for bands at a two-man live to cover one of each other's songs. I would therefore be very interested to hear that, especially given the language barrier. A translated version each perhaps? 😮
Poco a Poco The Warning es reconocido su rock en el mundo ,hasta los Japoneses conocen sus temas y los cantan
Whatever they do, can they sell online tickets for overseas viewers, please. I missed not being able to view the recent acoustic concert online.
Two of my favourite female drummers together?? Whoa!! I'm just sorry I can't be there.. Bummer..
What would be nice if a world tour with Band-Aids warning and vob calling the women of Rock Tour🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Locura!!!
¡Hola! Estoy tratando de traducir si esta es una palabra positiva. 😂 Debo aprender español antes de que ocurra la colaboración. 😉
@@BakaBroadcastIt was the word that Paulina used to describe what it was like to open for Foo Fighters at Foro Sol CDMX
Nice! I learnt something today 😊! Thank you!
"Band-Maid is not an Arena band"...oh, okay, I'll tell Sai-chan that you said it. She will be very disappointed😥
😂😁😏
I think everything will be fine and amazing as long as everyone understands the Pigeon is boss.
Pigeons will save the world!
Who is pigeon?
Anyone?
@@josephbel7532 The Pigeon is the rhythm guitar player and backup singer Miku in BAND-MAID. She is the founder and the manager of BAND-MAID. She is brilliant and has some weird stories around her. One is that she believes she is a pigeon. The lore says that she is 810 years old. She also falls a lot and have several bruises. As you can see. She is the borne leader.
I don’t think Miku, or anyone in either band, would take a “boss” attitude. They all work collaboratively in their respective bands and I sense that none of them would have a primadonna attitude if these bands do a joint project.
結果、想像以上のパーフェクトコラボレーションになったね。
スタジオ録音を聴くのが楽しみです！ライブバージョンはティーザーのようでした。期待しています :)
Pau can sing while Akane is drumming. Maybe The Warning sing the song Warning from Band Maid hahahah
Your idea is fantastic! I really wish they do collaborate with an original song, but man... with both of their schedules... is that really possible? If yes, the only change I would make to your line up is that you get Saiki, Danny and Pau on lead vocals. 3 way harmonies would be fantastic!!! but in reality if a new song is not possible, a cover wour most likely be the outcome. if that is the case... any ideas what cover they could do together?
Thanks so much, I think you're the first person who actually agreed with my suggestion 😂! I do hope for an original, however, if they do a cover than I would hope they covered a mutual band they both liked. Ultimately, really, I want to be surprised. Both bands are so capable within their own spaces, that any collaboration has me hoping for something that neither could do on their own, so maybe a song that encourages the 3 way harmonies you mentioned. A rock version of a famous girlband song even 😉. Ultimately, I will always prefer something risky to something safe, especially with two bands so well established in their own field. That is my feeling at least 😁. Thanks again!
@@BakaBroadcast we’ll have to come back to this post and comment on the outcome! I guess we are dreamers!
@@BakaBroadcast so we were both wrong. Have you seen the new song yet?
Hey so sorry I missed this! So yes, it isn't what I expected as much, but I am wondering what it will sound like when the studio version comes out. I know The Warning tend to bring a lot of production playfulness in to the studio and Band-Maid do too, so I wonder it the live version was more straight shooting, but we will hear more layering on the do-as-you-please studio version? My hopes remain high! 😂😂
I think Kanami has allready did something in her lab 😅
I kinda predicted something similar actually. I think them setting the date, some work must have been done in advance 😉😉😉🤞🤞🤞
I wish that I could see this concert. It's going to be epic 🤘🤘🤘
I hope Band Maid plays 'Warning'.
During my image search, 90% was Kanami on top of a car 😂, I feel this comment lol 👍
I hope The Warning can be able to make a videoclip in Japan just as The Killers and Manic Street Preachers that would be amazing
100% 🤘😊
i checked out thrill and liked what i saw , so i looked for more band maid and it was all just thrill light, so im not a maid fan but i do go back and click on thrill now and then.
Most of their music is nothing like Thrill. It's a straightforward classic rock song from their very early days and they have become much more innovative since then. But it probably is a good gateway to Band-Maid for fans of The Warning because it's closer to their style.
Try "Reincarnation" (AKA "Rinne"), "Shambles," "Warning," "I Cant Live Without You," "I Still Seek Revenge," "Hate?," "Puzzle," "Clang," "The Non-fiction Days," "Black Hole" and dozens of others.
Sounds like you've only scratched the surface of a few singles. "Thrill" isn't nearly the heaviest or most interesting of their songs. That's basically the very early days. What they do now is quite different.
I can understand that feeling when a band just isn't hitting the points that gives songs individuality and character for you as a listener. There are some genres where I am really surprised that people tell me there is so much variation, and I can't really see it except in points that aren't as interesting to me. So I can imagine how this must have felt for you.
As a Band-Maid fan, I don't want to bombard you with my opinions. I would perhaps recommend Memorable for being an acoustic number, and Bubble as another rock song but with a focus on building up from start to crescendo, but absolutely you don't have to like something just because other people do, and as I am assuming you are a WARNING fan, I hope that any potential collaboration at least gives you something fun to checkout :)
@@kicorseI agree I love "Thrill". BAND-MAID went in a different direction that I really don't like.
@@kicorseI agree I love "Thrill". BAND-MAID went in a different direction that I really don't like.
I🖤TW🤘
This could also spin off into an April Fools Day release for 2025.
Why have 2 drummers. Pau can do vocals, leaving the gorilla in her natural element. Don't forget kanami is great at arranging complex things without cluttering it up. Even though there is no way I could be there for this concert, the amount of energy these 2 bands give off would be magical.
Or you could get Pau on keys and vocals. All 3 The Warning play keys AND sing!
LET THEM ALL PLAY A SOLO!!
BAND-MAD has a song called Black Hole were all 5 members do solos through the whole song. Even the two singers. So - it is actually 6 continues solos for 6 minutes. It is not an easy song to listen to. But it gets better and better each time when you find more and more cool stuff. I am not sure if it scales to 8 persons.
@@rolandkarlsson7072 And The Warning has a song named Black Holes. 😉
So.....*big angry inhale*.... it had to be you huh? ........... the nemesis...... the man with over 15x as many subscribers who comes here to my tiny little channel to attack me with your screaming guitar solos ................. when you do eventually get what you want lol........... and I am crying in the corner with my complex song arrangement graphs lol......................... I want you to know that you are a BIG MEANIE 😂😂😂
My thoughts on BAND-MAID & THE WARNING is focused on their performance together this June 12th. I think each band should offer an original and have both bands perform those two songs together. It would present some cool possibilities in arrangements and, most likely, have a fuller sound. Which songs? I trust the eight musicians' choices better than my own. Nice job, Baka. Thank you.
Thank you too! I actually think that would be a nice idea, and with both bands working on material this year (to the best of my knowledge), what a lovely way to share the moment 😊
So i am totally in TWA, DPA forever. I have yet to warm to BandMaid (was gonna go BM, but that's just wrong). TW Songs are usually sonically complete, which is why they adhere to the mind; not just a hook but as a whole. The whole song is a hook, if you will. And, they understand that leaving space in between sounds is just as important as the notes themselves. DPA all can kill instrumental work. But, leaving room for tasty, memorable fiils makes you await them and appreciate them more.
That said the one part if the admittedly limited B-M music i have listened to that i really have liked, is the bass work. REALLY liked. Like Asterism, like Lovebites..
Musr be the old bassist in me. Or the Geddy lover.
So, i don't see much of a meaningful collab. But these folks are uber talented, so...who knows?
BTW do i remember one of DPA sayng they would love to work Willow? THAF would be cool.
These are 8 very talented and creative musicians. They do different things and do them extremely well. I don’t see any hint of egoism in any of them, so I’m betting they can, if they collaborate, get those musical differences to be complimentary, and not clash.
Well said! I agree that on a personality level, they don't give off the signs of being people who would bulldoze in to a collaboration and make a mess, but it will be interesting how each of them finds their voice and who takes control of what. Certainly though, they seem like a very pleasant bunch of talented creatives to share a room, and I hope they have a blast in the process 😊!
I have zero interest in any member of The Warning putting down their instruments.
I can totally see that haha!!! Personally, I'd just love to see Dany and Saiki freely bouncing around the stage, and I think there will be enough instrumental awesomeness already to allow it give the amount of talent on offer :)
I love seeing Dany singing without the guitar to keep her strapped to a place on stage, she loves taking over the satage the few times she hasn’t had to pay the guitar
I respect your feelings but they will without a doubt do that eventually, I fact Dany has already when the 3 day grace tour song she did with them, and Pau with that colab she did years ago with a Mexican ensemble of musicians. Was a foo fighters song can't remember exactly, but yeah
@@eduardoescobar1906 I was not interested in any of those performances either. 🙂
@@roywall8169 than why are you here? Trashing bands or having an orgasm by thinking that you are a big boy now?
Some may claim there is a complete absence of ego in these ladies. Well... someone has to defer to someone or nothing will get done. Perhaps in Japan (and I expect it) Band Maid will roll out the humble carpet for a band wanting to make a big splash. The Warning will never be made to feel sleighted by their 'elder sisters '. The Warning will return the favor in a substantial way when the two reunite in Mexico !
Would love to see a Mexican sequel for sure! 😇
I'm also thinking that's how this will probably go.
Let Akane and Paulina create a drum combo like Godsmack’s Batalla de los Tambores before the main song to get the crowd hyped.
I ❤ the Warning and so like me Band Maid ....epic show
😊🤘
Dany taking solos? She doesn't do solos normally. What seems like a solo today turns up again note for note the same the next day. I'm not saying she can't compose an original solo on the fly, but that that's not her habit. Also, understand that they have a different fan base and TW fans don't go to their concerts hoping to bask in their instrumental prowess. They go there to hear the songs they love played just like they were on RUclips or the album or wherever it is they go to replay them.
Sorry if I misunderstood, but actually I was saying for Dany not to play guitar at all in my proposed lineup. Sorry if I misunderstood your comment, but I'm a little unsure what you mean. Let me know :)
@@BakaBroadcast I'm not talking about your lineup. I'm explaining another reason why we may not hear Dany playing a solo. The Warning is not a flash band. All of the members of Band Maid are monsters on their instruments. Heck, Akane is more than just a pretender to Neil Peart's throne. That's their forte, TW's is songwriting. TW writes one song after another you can sing in the shower. I wouldn't even try that with 99% of Band Maid's songs. I'm interested to see how well they blend. I'm sure it'll be great because both bands want it to happen.
@@thsc9119Band Maids songs are great compositions too. Also very catchy, IMO, although I can’t sing them very well because of the language barrier. I get what you’re saying, though. The Warning occupy a different rock space, and their songs are so easy to love. Also, for me, if QOTMS was the only album they’d ever made, I’d still love them forever. An awesome concept album from an all-female trio as young as they were? That’s just right up my alley!
@@interstellardave Even if you spoke Japanese, I'm not sure you'd find anything like the hooks TW puts in every single song. It's their superpower. TW is best viewed as more a parallel to Lennon/McCartney than to The Beatles. They are songwriters first, musicians second, and they are very good musicians.
@@thsc9119Well Band Maid songs stick in my head all the time. The rhythms and melodies are often contagious. At least as contagious as they can be with the complex dense arrangements they are now producing. A lot of people say the same so it’s in the ear of the beholder. As a fan of both bands I think both are very complete in every area. I think anything either band may “lack” is simply because they haven’t done it, not because they can’t.
😳😳 We will finally see what the rare, misunderstood effects of dividing by zero is!!!🤘🏼❤️🔥🤘🏼🇲🇽🇯🇵🌀SUBBED.
😊🙏÷0 🤘
Just in case I went online looking for edible hats.Sorry looks like you're on your own..I would love to see The Warning on a messy stage saying to one" we need a maid" then a another says " like a band maid" then MIKU pops her head in and says " did you say BAND-MAID PO!" I know silly...
Haha, I don't know why, but I want to see your stage play intro now ;) ! Sounds quite cute actually lol.
I must check to see is hats are improved with shoyu , hmmmm...
It’s just a concert …
I reckon it will be a cover.....maybe a Santana cover......🎉
Or maybe a very early Fleetwood Mac song, from when the Mac included Peter Green, Danny Kirwan and Jeremy Spencer, any one of those in a band would be a fine lead guitarist on their own, that all 3 were in the same band... wow!
... or Akane could play her trombone again finally? 😁
Both drummers are top notch, but both drummers are also eccentric, they do not play ordinary stuff. I love them both because they are so hard to predict. Its not simple chugga chugga chugga. It is big arm movements and surprising bass drum fills and delicious syncopations and stick fills. It is just pure entertainment. And the are both in contact with the audience, a rare treat among drummers.
Ah, I forgot my point 😁
As they are so unconventional, it might be hard to make them cooperate.
Haha 100%, I didn't even consider this 😂 !!!!! 🎺📯 Why is there no trombone emoji lol?
If you believe that arranging is The Warning's so-called "weak point", then you're either not aware of their 2018 concept album, "Queen Of The Murder Scene", haven't heard any of its tracks or both.
There are some VERY complex song arrangements on the album. Seriously, listen to its title track, "Queen Of The Murder Scene", and "The One" and "The Sacrifice". Those three songs are the best examples of The Warning's high-level, complex-arrangement abilities.
Educate yourself. Then, you will hopefully completely change your mind about the girls' complete lack of ANY songwriting weaknesses whatsoever. You're welcome in advance!
Thanks for the comment. I did check out the Queen Of The Murder Scene, and it was an interesting one but, as much as it rocked, left me in a rather similar place. The breakdown of the descending bass line as the guitar picked above made for an interesting moment, but it mostly reinforced how I had felt about the Warning previously. I think they do good stonking headbangers, but it did still feel rather thin on arrangement for me.
That is ok though. I mean, my biggest disagreement with you is perhaps the idea that any band has no weaknesses whatsoever. Every band does, even the greatest legends of any artform, they all have their relative weaknesses within their skill set, and most of them are driven by the creative desire to improve upon them. Then again, obviously, no band or fandom is under any obligation to agree on what those weaknesses are, as art has the joy of being subjective, but for me I would consider arrangement to be the area where I would love to see more of The Warning.
Thank you though for the suggestion, I did check it out and enjoyed the music! 😊🙏
Hai! Hai! Hai! Si! Si! Si!
Miku is already 5 steps ahead of you.
In comparison and my opinion after hearing some songs of band maid the japenese girls are pretty cool, but it sounds a little bit more like playing against each other than together. Their compositions are almost overloaded and doesn't let room for each other to shine with their special skills.
I have to admiit that I've been warned and since then I'm totally addicted by the (in my opinion) new gold standard of all time rock music: With band maid I have instantly several ideas how to arrange their songs differently to get more out of it. With the Villarreal sisters I'll be alway the little child again with mouth wide open that can't belief what it's witnessing - every single note, every little sequence... all of it is at its perfect place, perfectly played brillant composed It doesn't have to be less, but it also doesnt have to be more - it's just on the point- I'm into music since I was ten - that's 43 years ago now and I saw and heard alot and wrote about it for several music magazines - but I've never seen anything comparable to these three girls.